-
Diversity of What? On the Different Conceptualizations of Diversity in Recommender Systems
Authors:
Sanne Vrijenhoek,
Savvina Daniil,
Jorden Sandel,
Laura Hollink
Abstract:
Diversity is a commonly known principle in the design of recommender systems, but also ambiguous in its conceptualization. Through semi-structured interviews we explore how practitioners at three different public service media organizations in the Netherlands conceptualize diversity within the scope of their recommender systems. We provide an overview of the goals that they have with diversity in…
▽ More
Diversity is a commonly known principle in the design of recommender systems, but also ambiguous in its conceptualization. Through semi-structured interviews we explore how practitioners at three different public service media organizations in the Netherlands conceptualize diversity within the scope of their recommender systems. We provide an overview of the goals that they have with diversity in their systems, which aspects are relevant, and how recommendations should be diversified. We show that even within this limited domain, conceptualization of diversity greatly varies, and argue that it is unlikely that a standardized conceptualization will be achieved. Instead, we should focus on effective communication of what diversity in this particular system means, thus allowing for operationalizations of diversity that are capable of expressing the nuances and requirements of that particular domain.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Improving and Evaluating the Detection of Fragmentation in News Recommendations with the Clustering of News Story Chains
Authors:
Alessandra Polimeno,
Myrthe Reuver,
Sanne Vrijenhoek,
Antske Fokkens
Abstract:
News recommender systems play an increasingly influential role in sha** information access within democratic societies. However, tailoring recommendations to users' specific interests can result in the divergence of information streams. Fragmented access to information poses challenges to the integrity of the public sphere, thereby influencing democracy and public discourse. The Fragmentation me…
▽ More
News recommender systems play an increasingly influential role in sha** information access within democratic societies. However, tailoring recommendations to users' specific interests can result in the divergence of information streams. Fragmented access to information poses challenges to the integrity of the public sphere, thereby influencing democracy and public discourse. The Fragmentation metric quantifies the degree of fragmentation of information streams in news recommendations. Accurate measurement of this metric requires the application of Natural Language Processing (NLP) to identify distinct news events, stories, or timelines. This paper presents an extensive investigation of various approaches for quantifying Fragmentation in news recommendations. These approaches are evaluated both intrinsically, by measuring performance on news story clustering, and extrinsically, by assessing the Fragmentation scores of different simulated news recommender scenarios. Our findings demonstrate that agglomerative hierarchical clustering coupled with SentenceBERT text representation is substantially better at detecting Fragmentation than earlier implementations. Additionally, the analysis of simulated scenarios yields valuable insights and recommendations for stakeholders concerning the measurement and interpretation of Fragmentation.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2023; v1 submitted 12 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Do you MIND? Reflections on the MIND dataset for research on diversity in news recommendations
Authors:
Sanne Vrijenhoek
Abstract:
The MIND dataset is at the moment of writing the most extensive dataset available for the research and development of news recommender systems. This work analyzes the suitability of the dataset for research on diverse news recommendations. On the one hand we analyze the effect the different steps in the recommendation pipeline have on the distribution of article categories, and on the other hand w…
▽ More
The MIND dataset is at the moment of writing the most extensive dataset available for the research and development of news recommender systems. This work analyzes the suitability of the dataset for research on diverse news recommendations. On the one hand we analyze the effect the different steps in the recommendation pipeline have on the distribution of article categories, and on the other hand we check whether the supplied data would be sufficient for more sophisticated diversity analysis. We conclude that while MIND is a great step forward, there is still a lot of room for improvement.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2023; v1 submitted 17 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
RADio -- Rank-Aware Divergence Metrics to Measure Normative Diversity in News Recommendations
Authors:
Sanne Vrijenhoek,
Gabriel Bénédict,
Mateo Gutierrez Granada,
Daan Odijk,
Maarten de Rijke
Abstract:
In traditional recommender system literature, diversity is often seen as the opposite of similarity, and typically defined as the distance between identified topics, categories or word models. However, this is not expressive of the social science's interpretation of diversity, which accounts for a news organization's norms and values and which we here refer to as normative diversity. We introduce…
▽ More
In traditional recommender system literature, diversity is often seen as the opposite of similarity, and typically defined as the distance between identified topics, categories or word models. However, this is not expressive of the social science's interpretation of diversity, which accounts for a news organization's norms and values and which we here refer to as normative diversity. We introduce RADio, a versatile metrics framework to evaluate recommendations according to these normative goals. RADio introduces a rank-aware Jensen Shannon (JS) divergence. This combination accounts for (i) a user's decreasing propensity to observe items further down a list and (ii) full distributional shifts as opposed to point estimates. We evaluate RADio's ability to reflect five normative concepts in news recommendations on the Microsoft News Dataset and six (neural) recommendation algorithms, with the help of our metadata enrichment pipeline. We find that RADio provides insightful estimates that can potentially be used to inform news recommender system design.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2022; v1 submitted 17 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Building Human Values into Recommender Systems: An Interdisciplinary Synthesis
Authors:
Jonathan Stray,
Alon Halevy,
Parisa Assar,
Dylan Hadfield-Menell,
Craig Boutilier,
Amar Ashar,
Lex Beattie,
Michael Ekstrand,
Claire Leibowicz,
Connie Moon Sehat,
Sara Johansen,
Lianne Kerlin,
David Vickrey,
Spandana Singh,
Sanne Vrijenhoek,
Amy Zhang,
McKane Andrus,
Natali Helberger,
Polina Proutskova,
Tanushree Mitra,
Nina Vasan
Abstract:
Recommender systems are the algorithms which select, filter, and personalize content across many of the worlds largest platforms and apps. As such, their positive and negative effects on individuals and on societies have been extensively theorized and studied. Our overarching question is how to ensure that recommender systems enact the values of the individuals and societies that they serve. Addre…
▽ More
Recommender systems are the algorithms which select, filter, and personalize content across many of the worlds largest platforms and apps. As such, their positive and negative effects on individuals and on societies have been extensively theorized and studied. Our overarching question is how to ensure that recommender systems enact the values of the individuals and societies that they serve. Addressing this question in a principled fashion requires technical knowledge of recommender design and operation, and also critically depends on insights from diverse fields including social science, ethics, economics, psychology, policy and law. This paper is a multidisciplinary effort to synthesize theory and practice from different perspectives, with the goal of providing a shared language, articulating current design approaches, and identifying open problems. It is not a comprehensive survey of this large space, but a set of highlights identified by our diverse author cohort. We collect a set of values that seem most relevant to recommender systems operating across different domains, then examine them from the perspectives of current industry practice, measurement, product design, and policy approaches. Important open problems include multi-stakeholder processes for defining values and resolving trade-offs, better values-driven measurements, recommender controls that people use, non-behavioral algorithmic feedback, optimization for long-term outcomes, causal inference of recommender effects, academic-industry research collaborations, and interdisciplinary policy-making.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Recommenders with a mission: assessing diversity in newsrecommendations
Authors:
Sanne Vrijenhoek,
Mesut Kaya,
Nadia Metoui,
Judith Möller,
Daan Odijk,
Natali Helberger
Abstract:
News recommenders help users to find relevant online content and have the potential to fulfill a crucial role in a democratic society, directing the scarce attention of citizens towards the information that is most important to them. Simultaneously, recent concerns about so-called filter bubbles, misinformation and selective exposure are symptomatic of the disruptive potential of these digital new…
▽ More
News recommenders help users to find relevant online content and have the potential to fulfill a crucial role in a democratic society, directing the scarce attention of citizens towards the information that is most important to them. Simultaneously, recent concerns about so-called filter bubbles, misinformation and selective exposure are symptomatic of the disruptive potential of these digital news recommenders. Recommender systems can make or break filter bubbles, and as such can be instrumental in creating either a more closed or a more open internet. Current approaches to evaluating recommender systems are often focused on measuring an increase in user clicks and short-term engagement, rather than measuring the user's longer term interest in diverse and important information.
This paper aims to bridge the gap between normative notions of diversity, rooted in democratic theory, and quantitative metrics necessary for evaluating the recommender system. We propose a set of metrics grounded in social science interpretations of diversity and suggest ways for practical implementations.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Diversity in News Recommendations
Authors:
Abraham Bernstein,
Claes de Vreese,
Natali Helberger,
Wolfgang Schulz,
Katharina Zweig,
Christian Baden,
Michael A. Beam,
Marc P. Hauer,
Lucien Heitz,
Pascal Jürgens,
Christian Katzenbach,
Benjamin Kille,
Beate Klimkiewicz,
Wiebke Loosen,
Judith Moeller,
Goran Radanovic,
Guy Shani,
Nava Tintarev,
Suzanne Tolmeijer,
Wouter van Atteveldt,
Sanne Vrijenhoek,
Theresa Zueger
Abstract:
News diversity in the media has for a long time been a foundational and uncontested basis for ensuring that the communicative needs of individuals and society at large are met. Today, people increasingly rely on online content and recommender systems to consume information challenging the traditional concept of news diversity. In addition, the very concept of diversity, which differs between disci…
▽ More
News diversity in the media has for a long time been a foundational and uncontested basis for ensuring that the communicative needs of individuals and society at large are met. Today, people increasingly rely on online content and recommender systems to consume information challenging the traditional concept of news diversity. In addition, the very concept of diversity, which differs between disciplines, will need to be re-evaluated requiring a interdisciplinary investigation, which requires a new level of mutual cooperation between computer scientists, social scientists, and legal scholars. Based on the outcome of a multidisciplinary workshop, we have the following recommendations, directed at researchers, funders, legislators, regulators, and the media industry: 1. Do more research on news recommenders and diversity. 2. Create a safe harbor for academic research with industry data. 3. Optimize the role of public values in news recommenders. 4. Create a meaningful governance framework. 5. Fund a joint lab to spearhead the needed interdisciplinary research, boost practical innovation, develop. reference solutions, and transfer insights into practice.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2021; v1 submitted 19 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
