-
Barium stars as tracers of s-process nucleosynthesis in AGB stars III. Systematic deviations from the AGB models
Authors:
B. Világos,
B. Cseh,
A. Yagüe López,
M. Joyce,
A. Karakas,
G. Tagliente,
M. Lugaro
Abstract:
Barium (Ba) stars help to verify asymptotic giant branch (AGB) star nucleosynthesis models since they experienced pollution from an AGB binary companion and thus their spectra carry the signatures of the slow neutron capture process (s process). For 180 Ba stars, we searched for AGB stellar models that match the observed abundance patterns. We employed three machine learning algorithms as classifi…
▽ More
Barium (Ba) stars help to verify asymptotic giant branch (AGB) star nucleosynthesis models since they experienced pollution from an AGB binary companion and thus their spectra carry the signatures of the slow neutron capture process (s process). For 180 Ba stars, we searched for AGB stellar models that match the observed abundance patterns. We employed three machine learning algorithms as classifiers: a Random Forest method, developed for this work, and the two classifiers used in our previous study. We studied the statistical behaviour of the s-process elements in the observational sample to investigate if the AGB models systematically under- or overpredict the abundances observed in the Ba stars and show the results in the form of violin plots of the residuals between spectroscopic abundances and model predictions. We find a significant trend in the residuals that implies an underproduction of the elements Nb, Mo, and Ru in the models relative to the observations. This may originate from a process (e.g. the intermediate neutron-capture process, i process) at the metallicity of the Ba stars not yet included in the AGB models. Correlations are found between the residuals of these elements, suggesting a common origin for the deviations. In addition, there is a weak metallicity dependence of their residuals. The s-process temperatures derived with the [Zr/Fe] - [Nb/Fe] thermometer have an unrealistic value for the majority of our stars. The most likely explanation is that at least a fraction of these elements are not produced in a steady-state s process, and instead may be due to processes not included in the AGB models. The mass distribution of the identified models confirms that our sample of Ba stars was polluted by low-mass AGB stars. Most of the matching AGB models require low accreted mass, but a few systems with high accreted mass are needed to explain the observations. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Barium stars as tracers of s-process nucleosynthesis in AGB stars II. Using machine learning techniques on 169 stars
Authors:
J. W. den Hartogh,
A. Yagüe López,
B. Cseh,
M. Pignatari,
B. Világos,
M. P. Roriz,
C. B. Pereira,
N. A. Drake,
S. Junqueira,
M. Lugaro
Abstract:
We aim to analyse the abundance pattern of 169 Barium (Ba) stars, using machine learning techniques and the AGB final surface abundances predicted by Fruity and Monash stellar models. We developed machine learning algorithms that use the abundance pattern of Ba stars as input to classify the initial mass and metallicity of its companion star using stellar model predictions. We use two algorithms:…
▽ More
We aim to analyse the abundance pattern of 169 Barium (Ba) stars, using machine learning techniques and the AGB final surface abundances predicted by Fruity and Monash stellar models. We developed machine learning algorithms that use the abundance pattern of Ba stars as input to classify the initial mass and metallicity of its companion star using stellar model predictions. We use two algorithms: the first exploits neural networks to recognise patterns and the second is a nearest-neighbour algorithm, which focuses on finding the AGB model that predicts final surface abundances closest to the observed Ba star values. In the second algorithm we include the error bars and observational uncertainties to find the best fit model. The classification process is based on the abundances of Fe, Rb, Sr, Zr, Ru, Nd, Ce, Sm, and Eu. We selected these elements by systematically removing s-process elements from our AGB model abundance distributions, and identifying those whose removal has the biggest positive effect on the classification. We excluded Nb, Y, Mo, and La. Our final classification combines the output of both algorithms to identify for each Ba star companion an initial mass and metallicity range. With our analysis tools we identify the main properties for 166 of the 169 Ba stars in the stellar sample. The classifications based on both stellar sets of AGB final abundances show similar distributions, with an average initial mass of M = 2.23 MSun and 2.34 MSun and an average [Fe/H] = -0.21 and -0.11, respectively. We investigated why the removal of Nb, Y, Mo, and La improves our classification and identified 43 stars for which the exclusion had the biggest effect. We show that these stars have statistically significant different abundances for these elements compared to the other Ba stars in our sample. We discuss the possible reasons for these differences in the abundance patterns.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
The RADIOSTAR Project
Authors:
Maria Lugaro,
Benoit Côté,
Marco Pignatari,
Andrés Yagüe López,
Hannah Brinkman,
Borbála Cseh,
Jacqueline Den Hartogh,
Carolyn Louise Doherty,
Amanda Irene Karakas,
Chiaki Kobayashi,
Thomas Lawson,
Mária Pető,
Benjámin Soós,
Thomas Trueman,
Blanka Világos
Abstract:
Radioactive nuclei are the key to understanding the circumstances of the birth of our Sun because meteoritic analysis has proven that many of them were present at that time. Their origin, however, has been so far elusive. The ERC-CoG-2016 RADIOSTAR project is dedicated to investigating the production of radioactive nuclei by nuclear reactions inside stars, their evolution in the Milky Way Galaxy,…
▽ More
Radioactive nuclei are the key to understanding the circumstances of the birth of our Sun because meteoritic analysis has proven that many of them were present at that time. Their origin, however, has been so far elusive. The ERC-CoG-2016 RADIOSTAR project is dedicated to investigating the production of radioactive nuclei by nuclear reactions inside stars, their evolution in the Milky Way Galaxy, and their presence in molecular clouds. So far, we have discovered that: (i) radioactive nuclei produced by slow ($^{107}$Pd and $^{182}$Hf) and rapid ($^{129}$I and $^{247}$Cm) neutron captures originated from stellar sources - asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars and compact binary mergers, respectively - within the galactic environment that predated the formation of the molecular cloud where the Sun was born; (ii) the time that elapsed from the birth of the cloud to the birth of the Sun was of the order of 10$^7$ years, and (iii) the abundances of the very short-lived nuclei $^{26}$Al, $^{36}$Cl, and $^{41}$Ca can be explained by massive star winds in single or binary systems, if these winds directly polluted the early Solar System. Our current and future work, as required to finalise the picture of the origin of radioactive nuclei in the Solar System, involves studying the possible origin of radioactive nuclei in the early Solar System from core-collapse supernovae, investigating the production of $^{107}$Pd in massive star winds, modelling the transport and mixing of radioactive nuclei in the galactic and molecular cloud medium, and calculating the galactic chemical evolution of $^{53}$Mn and $^{60}$Fe and of the p-process isotopes $^{92}$Nb and $^{146}$Sm.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Barium stars as tracers of s-process nucleosynthesis in AGB stars I. 28 stars with independently derived AGB mass
Authors:
B. Cseh,
B. Világos,
M. P. Roriz,
C. B. Pereira,
V. D'Orazi,
A. I. Karakas,
B. Soós,
N. A. Drake,
S. Junqueira,
M. Lugaro
Abstract:
Barium (Ba) stars are polluted by material enriched in the slow neutron capture (s-process) elements synthesised in the interior of their former asymptotic giant branch (AGB) companion star, which is now a white dwarf. We compare individual Ba star abundance patterns to AGB nucleosynthesis models to verify if the AGB model mass is compatible with independently derived AGB mass. We selected a sampl…
▽ More
Barium (Ba) stars are polluted by material enriched in the slow neutron capture (s-process) elements synthesised in the interior of their former asymptotic giant branch (AGB) companion star, which is now a white dwarf. We compare individual Ba star abundance patterns to AGB nucleosynthesis models to verify if the AGB model mass is compatible with independently derived AGB mass. We selected a sample of 28 Ba stars for which both self-consistent spectroscopic observation and analysis are available and stellar mass determinations, via positioning the star on the HR diagram and comparing with evolutionary tracks. For this sample stars we considered both previously and recently derived elemental abundances. Then, we performed a detailed comparison of these s-process elemental abundances to different AGB nucleosynthesis models from the Monash and the FRUITY theoretical data sets. We simplified the binary mass transfer by calculating dilution factors to match the [Ce/Fe] value of each star when using different AGB models, and we then compared the diluted model abundances to the complete Ba-star abundance pattern. Our comparison confirms that low mass, non-rotating AGB stellar models with 13C as the main neutron source are the polluters of the vast majority of the considered Ba stars. Out of the 28 stars, in 21 cases the models are in good agreement with both the determined abundances and the independently derived AGB mass, although in 16 cases higher observed abundances of Nb, Ru, Mo and/or Nd, Sm than predicted. For 3 stars we obtain a match to the abundances only by considering models with masses lower than those independently determined. Finally, 4 stars show much higher first s-process peak abundance values than the model predictions, which may represent the signature of a physical and/or nucleosynthetic process that is not represented in the set of models considered here.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Origin of large meteoritic SiC stardust grains in metal-rich AGB stars
Authors:
Maria Lugaro,
Borbála Cseh,
Blanka Világos,
Amanda I. Karakas,
Paolo Ventura,
Flavia Dell'Agli,
Reto Trappitsch,
Melanie Hampel,
Valentina D'Orazi,
Claudio B. Pereira,
Giuseppe Tagliente,
Gyula M. Szabó,
Marco Pignatari,
Umberto Battino,
Ashley Tattersall,
Mattias Ek,
Maria Schönbächler,
Josef Hron,
Larry R. Nittler
Abstract:
Stardust grains that originated in ancient stars and supernovae are recovered from meteorites and carry the detailed composition of their astronomical sites of origin. We present evidence that the majority of large ($μ$m-sized) meteoritic silicon carbide (SiC) grains formed in C-rich asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars that were more metal-rich than the Sun. In the framework of the slow neutron-ca…
▽ More
Stardust grains that originated in ancient stars and supernovae are recovered from meteorites and carry the detailed composition of their astronomical sites of origin. We present evidence that the majority of large ($μ$m-sized) meteoritic silicon carbide (SiC) grains formed in C-rich asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars that were more metal-rich than the Sun. In the framework of the slow neutron-captures (the s process) that occurs in AGB stars the lower-than-solar 88Sr/86Sr isotopic ratios measured in the large SiC grains can only be accompanied by Ce/Y elemental ratios that are also lower than solar, and predominately observed in metal-rich barium stars - the binary companions of AGB stars. Such an origin suggests that these large grains represent the material from high-metallicity AGB stars needed to explain the s-process nucleosynthesis variations observed in bulk meteorites (Ek et al. 2020). In the outflows of metal-rich, C-rich AGB stars SiC grains are predicted to be small ($\simeq$ 0.2 $μ$m-sized); large ($\simeq$ $μ$m-sized) SiC grains can grow if the number of dust seeds is two to three orders of magnitude lower than the standard value of $10^{-13}$ times the number of H atoms. We therefore predict that with increasing metallicity the number of dust seeds might decrease, resulting in the production of larger SiC grains.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
129I and 247Cm in Meteorites Constrain the Last Astrophysical Source of Solar r-process Elements
Authors:
Benoit Côté,
Marius Eichler,
Andrés Yagüe,
Nicole Vassh,
Matthew R. Mumpower,
Blanka Világos,
Benjámin Soós,
Almudena Arcones,
Trevor M. Sprouse,
Rebecca Surman,
Marco Pignatari,
Maria K. Pető,
Benjamin Wehmeyer,
Thomas Rauscher,
Maria Lugaro
Abstract:
The composition of the early Solar System can be inferred from meteorites. Many elements heavier than iron were formed by the rapid neutron-capture process (r process), but the astrophysical sources where this occurred remain poorly understood. We demonstrate that the near-identical half-lives ($\simeq$ 15.6 Myr) of the radioactive r-process nuclei 129I and 247Cm preserve their ratio, irrespective…
▽ More
The composition of the early Solar System can be inferred from meteorites. Many elements heavier than iron were formed by the rapid neutron-capture process (r process), but the astrophysical sources where this occurred remain poorly understood. We demonstrate that the near-identical half-lives ($\simeq$ 15.6 Myr) of the radioactive r-process nuclei 129I and 247Cm preserve their ratio, irrespective of the time between production and incorporation into the Solar System. We constrain the last r-process source by comparing the measured meteoritic 129I / 247Cm = 438 $\pm$ 184 to nucleosynthesis calculations based on neutron star merger and magneto-rotational supernova simulations. Moderately neutron-rich conditions, often found in merger disk ejecta simulations, are most consistent with the meteoritic value. Uncertain nuclear physics data limit our confidence in this conclusion.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2021; v1 submitted 8 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Stochastic Chemical Evolution of Radioactive Isotopes with a Monte Carlo Approach
Authors:
Benoit Côté,
Andrés Yagüe,
Blanka Világos,
Maria Lugaro
Abstract:
Short-lived radionuclides (SLRs) with mean-lives $τ$ of a few to hundreds Myr provide unique opportunities to probe recent nucleosynthesis events in the interstellar medium, and the physical conditions in which the Sun formed. Here we quantify the uncertainty in the predicted evolution of SLRs within a parcel of interstellar gas given the stochastic nature of stellar enrichment events. We assume t…
▽ More
Short-lived radionuclides (SLRs) with mean-lives $τ$ of a few to hundreds Myr provide unique opportunities to probe recent nucleosynthesis events in the interstellar medium, and the physical conditions in which the Sun formed. Here we quantify the uncertainty in the predicted evolution of SLRs within a parcel of interstellar gas given the stochastic nature of stellar enrichment events. We assume that an enrichment progenitor is formed at every time interval $γ$. For each progenitor, we randomly sample the delay time between its formation and its enrichment event, based on several delay-time distribution (DTD) functions that cover a wide range of astrophysical sites. For each set of $τ$, $γ$, and DTD function, we follow the abundances of SLRs for 15 Gyr, and repeat this process thousands of times to derive their probability distributions. For $τ/γ\gtrsim2$, the distributions depend on the DTD function and we provide tabulated values and analytical expressions to quantify the spread. The relative abundance uncertainty reaches a maximum of $\sim$ 60% for $τ/γ=1$. For $τ/γ\lesssim1$, we provide the probability for the SLR abundance to carry the signature of only one enrichment event, which is greater than 50% when $τ/γ\lesssim0.3$. For $0.3\lesssimτ/γ\lesssim 2$, a small number of events contributed to the SLR abundance. This case needs to be investigated with a separate statistical method. We find that an isolation time for the birth of the Sun of roughly $9-13$ Myr is consistent with the observed abundances of $^{60}$Fe, $^{107}$Pd, and $^{182}$Hf in the early Solar System, when assuming $τ/γ\sim3$ for these isotopes.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2019; v1 submitted 4 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Galactic Chemical Evolution of Radioactive Isotopes
Authors:
Benoit Côté,
Maria Lugaro,
Rene Reifarth,
Marco Pignatari,
Blanka Világos,
Andrés Yagüe,
Brad K. Gibson
Abstract:
The presence of short-lived ($\sim$\,Myr) radioactive isotopes in meteoritic inclusions at the time of their formation represents a unique opportunity to study the circumstances that led to the formation of the Solar System. To interpret these observations we need to calculate the evolution of radioactive-to-stable isotopic ratios in the Galaxy. We present an extension of the open-source galactic…
▽ More
The presence of short-lived ($\sim$\,Myr) radioactive isotopes in meteoritic inclusions at the time of their formation represents a unique opportunity to study the circumstances that led to the formation of the Solar System. To interpret these observations we need to calculate the evolution of radioactive-to-stable isotopic ratios in the Galaxy. We present an extension of the open-source galactic chemical evolution codes NuPyCEE and JINAPyCEE that enables to track the decay of radioactive isotopes in the interstellar medium. We show how the evolution of isotopic ratio depends on the star formation history and efficiency, star-to-gas mass ratio, and galactic outflows. Given the uncertainties in the observations used to calibrate our model, our predictions for isotopic ratios at the time of formation of the Sun are uncertain by a factor of 3.6. At that time, to recover the actual radioactive-to-stable isotopic ratios predicted by our model, one can multiply the steady-state solution (see Equation~1) by $2.3^{+3.4}_{-0.7}$. However, in the cases where the radioactive isotope has a half-life longer than $\sim$\,200\,Myr, or the target radioactive or stable isotopes have mass- and/or metallicity-depended production rates, or they originate from different sources with different delay-time distributions, or the reference isotope is radioactive, our codes should be used for more accurate solutions. Our preliminary calculations confirm the dichotomy between radioactive nuclei in the early Solar System with $r$- and $s$-process origin, and that $^{55}$Mn and $^{60}$Fe can be explained by galactic chemical evolution, while $^{26}$Al cannot.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.