-
Robust Optimization for Spot Scanning Proton Therapy based on Dose-Linear Energy Transfer (LET) Volume Constraints
Authors:
**gyuan Chen,
Yunze Yang,
Hongying Feng,
Lian Zhang,
Carlos E. Vargas,
Nathan Y. Yu,
Jean-Claude M. Rwigema,
Sameer R. Keole,
Sujay A. Vora,
Jiajian Shen,
Wei Liu
Abstract:
Purpose: Historically, spot scanning proton therapy (SSPT) treatment planning utilizes dose volume constraints and linear-energy-transfer (LET) volume constraints separately to balance tumor control and organs-at-risk (OARs) protection. We propose a novel dose-LET volume constraint (DLVC)-based robust optimization (DLVCRO) method for SSPT in treating prostate cancer to obtain a desirable joint dos…
▽ More
Purpose: Historically, spot scanning proton therapy (SSPT) treatment planning utilizes dose volume constraints and linear-energy-transfer (LET) volume constraints separately to balance tumor control and organs-at-risk (OARs) protection. We propose a novel dose-LET volume constraint (DLVC)-based robust optimization (DLVCRO) method for SSPT in treating prostate cancer to obtain a desirable joint dose and LET distribution to minimize adverse events (AEs).
Methods: DLVCRO treats DLVC as soft constraints controlling the joint distribution of dose and LET. Ten prostate cancer patients were included with rectum and bladder as OARs. DLVCRO was compared with the conventional robust optimization (RO) method using the worst-case analysis method. Besides the dose-volume histogram (DVH) indices, the analogous LETVH and extra-biological-dose (xBD)-volume histogram indices were also used. The Wilcoxon signed rank test was used to measure statistical significance.
Results: In nominal scenario, DLVCRO significantly improved dose, LET and xBD distributions to protect OARs (rectum: V70Gy: 3.07\% vs. 2.90\%, p = .0063, RO vs. DLVCRO; $\text{LET}_{\max}$ (keV/um): 11.53 vs. 9.44, p = .0101; $\text{xBD}_{\max}$ (Gy$\cdot$keV/um): 420.55 vs. 398.79, p = .0086; bladder: V65Gy: 4.82\% vs. 4.61\%, p = .0032; $\text{LET}_{\max}$ 8.97 vs. 7.51, p = .0047; $\text{xBD}_{\max}$ 490.11 vs. 476.71, p = .0641). The physical dose distributions in targets are comparable (D2%: 98.57\% vs. 98.39\%; p = .0805; CTV D2% - D98%: 7.10\% vs. 7.75\%, p = .4624). In the worst-case scenario, DLVCRO robustly enhanced OAR while maintaining the similar plan robustness in target dose coverage and homogeneity.
Conclusion: DLVCRO upgrades 2D DVH-based to 3D DLVH-based treatment planning to adjust dose/LET distributions simultaneously and robustly. DLVCRO is potentially a powerful tool to improve patient outcomes in SSPT.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
The status and challenges for prostate SBRT treatments in United States proton therapy centers: An NRG Oncology practice survey
Authors:
Jiajian Shen,
Paige A. Taylor,
Carlos E. Vargas,
Minglei Kang,
Jatinder Saini,
Jun Zhou,
Peilong Wang,
Wei Liu,
Charles B. Simone II,
Ying Xiao,
Liyong Lin
Abstract:
A survey was designed to inquire about the practice of proton SBRT treatment for prostate cancer. The survey was distributed to all 30 proton therapy centers in the United States that participate in the National Clinical Trial Network in Feb. 2023. The survey focused on usage, patient selection criteria, prescriptions, target contours, dose constraints, treatment plan optimization and evaluation m…
▽ More
A survey was designed to inquire about the practice of proton SBRT treatment for prostate cancer. The survey was distributed to all 30 proton therapy centers in the United States that participate in the National Clinical Trial Network in Feb. 2023. The survey focused on usage, patient selection criteria, prescriptions, target contours, dose constraints, treatment plan optimization and evaluation methods, patient-specific QA, and IGRT methods. Results: We received responses from 25 centers (83% participation). Only 8 respondent proton centers (32%) reported performing SBRT of the prostate. The remaining 17 centers cited three primary reasons for not offering this treatment: no clinical need, lack of volumetric imaging, and/or lack of clinical evidence. Only 1 center cited the reduction in overall reimbursement as a concern for not offering prostate SBRT. Several common practices among the 8 centers offering SBRT for the prostate were noted, such as using Hydrogel spacers, fiducial markers, and MRI for target delineation. Most proton centers (87.5%) utilized pencil beam scanning (PBS) delivery and completed Imaging and Radiation Oncology Core (IROC) phantom credentialing. Treatment planning typically used parallel opposed lateral beams, and consistent parameters for setup and range uncertainties were used for plan optimization and robustness evaluation. Measurements-based patient-specific QA, beam delivery every other day, fiducial contours for IGRT, and total doses of 35-40 GyRBE were consistent across all centers. However, there was no consensus on the risk levels for patient selection. Conclusion: Prostate SBRT is used in about 1/3 of proton centers in the US. There was a significant consistency in practices among proton centers treating with proton SBRT. It is possible that the adoption of proton SBRT may become more common if proton SBRT is more commonly offered in clinical trials.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Noisy probing dose facilitated dose prediction for pencil beam scanning proton therapy: physics enhances generalizability
Authors:
Lian Zhang,
Jason M. Holmes,
Zhengliang Liu,
Hongying Feng,
Terence T. Sio,
Carlos E. Vargas,
Sameer R. Keole,
Kristin Stützer,
Sheng Li,
Tianming Liu,
Jiajian Shen,
William W. Wong,
Sujay A. Vora,
Wei Liu
Abstract:
Purpose: Prior AI-based dose prediction studies in photon and proton therapy often neglect underlying physics, limiting their generalizability to handle outlier clinical cases, especially for pencil beam scanning proton therapy (PBSPT). Our aim is to design a physics-aware and generalizable AI-based PBSPT dose prediction method that has the underlying physics considered to achieve high generalizab…
▽ More
Purpose: Prior AI-based dose prediction studies in photon and proton therapy often neglect underlying physics, limiting their generalizability to handle outlier clinical cases, especially for pencil beam scanning proton therapy (PBSPT). Our aim is to design a physics-aware and generalizable AI-based PBSPT dose prediction method that has the underlying physics considered to achieve high generalizability to properly handle the outlier clinical cases. Methods and Materials: This study analyzed PBSPT plans of 103 prostate and 78 lung cancer patients from our institution,with each case comprising CT images, structure sets, and plan doses from our Monte-Carlo dose engine (serving as the ground truth). Three methods were evaluated in the ablation study: the ROI-based method, the beam mask and sliding window method, and the noisy probing dose method. Twelve cases with uncommon beam angles or prescription doses tested the methods' generalizability to rare treatment planning scenarios. Performance evaluation used DVH indices, 3D Gamma passing rates (3%/2mm/10%), and dice coefficients for dose agreement. Results: The noisy probing dose method showed improved agreement of DVH indices, 3D Gamma passing rates, and dice coefficients compared to the conventional methods for the testing cases. The noisy probing dose method showed better generalizability in the 6 outlier cases than the ROI-based and beam mask-based methods with 3D Gamma passing rates (for prostate cancer, targets: 89.32%$\pm$1.45% vs. 93.48%$\pm$1.51% vs. 96.79%$\pm$0.83%, OARs: 85.87%$\pm$1.73% vs. 91.15%$\pm$1.13% vs. 94.29%$\pm$1.01%). The dose predictions were completed within 0.3 seconds. Conclusions: We've devised a novel noisy probing dose method for PBSPT dose prediction in prostate and lung cancer patients. With more physics included, it enhances the generalizability of dose prediction in handling outlier clinical cases.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Artificial Intelligence-Facilitated Online Adaptive Proton Therapy Using Pencil Beam Scanning Proton Therapy
Authors:
Hongying Feng,
Jie Shan,
Carlos E. Vargas,
Sameer R. Keole,
Jean-Claude M. Rwigema,
Nathan Y. Yu,
Yuzhen Ding,
Lian Zhang,
Steven E. Schild,
William W. Wong,
Sujay A. Vora,
JiaJian Shen,
Wei Liu
Abstract:
We propose an oAPT workflow that incorporates all these functionalities and validate its clinical implementation feasibility with prostate patients. AI-based auto-segmentation tool AccuContourTM (Manteia, Xiamen, China) was seamlessly integrated into oAPT. Initial spot arrangement tool on the vCT for re-optimization was implemented using raytracing. An LET-based biological effect evaluation tool w…
▽ More
We propose an oAPT workflow that incorporates all these functionalities and validate its clinical implementation feasibility with prostate patients. AI-based auto-segmentation tool AccuContourTM (Manteia, Xiamen, China) was seamlessly integrated into oAPT. Initial spot arrangement tool on the vCT for re-optimization was implemented using raytracing. An LET-based biological effect evaluation tool was developed to assess the overlap region of high dose and high LET in selected OARs. Eleven prostate cancer patients were retrospectively selected to verify the efficacy and efficiency of the proposed oAPT workflow. The time cost of each component in the workflow was recorded for analysis. The verification plan showed significant degradation of the CTV coverage and rectum and bladder sparing due to the interfractional anatomical changes. Re-optimization on the vCT resulted in great improvement of the plan quality. No overlap regions of high dose and high LET distributions were observed in bladder or rectum in re-plans. 3D Gamma analyses in PSQA confirmed the accuracy of the re-plan doses before delivery (Gamma passing rate = 99.57%), and after delivery (98.59%). The robustness of the re-plans passed all clinical requirements. The average time for the complete execution of the workflow was 9.12minutes, excluding manual intervention time. The AI-facilitated oAPT workflow was demonstrated to be both efficient and effective by generating a re-plan that significantly improved the plan quality in prostate cancer treated with PBSPT.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Beam mask and sliding window-facilitated deep learning-based accurate and efficient dose prediction for pencil beam scanning proton therapy
Authors:
Lian Zhang,
Jason M. Holmes,
Zhengliang Liu,
Sujay A. Vora,
Terence T. Sio,
Carlos E. Vargas,
Nathan Y. Yu,
Sameer R. Keole,
Steven E. Schild,
Martin Bues,
Sheng Li,
Tianming Liu,
Jiajian Shen,
William W. Wong,
Wei Liu
Abstract:
Purpose: To develop a DL-based PBSPT dose prediction workflow with high accuracy and balanced complexity to support on-line adaptive proton therapy clinical decision and subsequent replanning.
Methods: PBSPT plans of 103 prostate cancer patients and 83 lung cancer patients previously treated at our institution were included in the study, each with CTs, structure sets, and plan doses calculated b…
▽ More
Purpose: To develop a DL-based PBSPT dose prediction workflow with high accuracy and balanced complexity to support on-line adaptive proton therapy clinical decision and subsequent replanning.
Methods: PBSPT plans of 103 prostate cancer patients and 83 lung cancer patients previously treated at our institution were included in the study, each with CTs, structure sets, and plan doses calculated by the in-house developed Monte-Carlo dose engine. For the ablation study, we designed three experiments corresponding to the following three methods: 1) Experiment 1, the conventional region of interest (ROI) method. 2) Experiment 2, the beam mask (generated by raytracing of proton beams) method to improve proton dose prediction. 3) Experiment 3, the sliding window method for the model to focus on local details to further improve proton dose prediction. A fully connected 3D-Unet was adopted as the backbone. Dose volume histogram (DVH) indices, 3D Gamma passing rates, and dice coefficients for the structures enclosed by the iso-dose lines between the predicted and the ground truth doses were used as the evaluation metrics. The calculation time for each proton dose prediction was recorded to evaluate the method's efficiency.
Results: Compared to the conventional ROI method, the beam mask method improved the agreement of DVH indices for both targets and OARs and the sliding window method further improved the agreement of the DVH indices. For the 3D Gamma passing rates in the target, OARs, and BODY (outside target and OARs), the beam mask method can improve the passing rates in these regions and the sliding window method further improved them. A similar trend was also observed for the dice coefficients. In fact, this trend was especially remarkable for relatively low prescription isodose lines. The dose predictions for all the testing cases were completed within 0.25s.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Microscopic study of neutron-rich Dysprosium isotopes
Authors:
Carlos E. Vargas,
Victor Velazquez,
Sergio Lerma
Abstract:
Microscopic studies in heavy nuclei are very scarce due to large valence spaces involved. This computational problem can be avoided by means of the use of symmetry based models. Ground-state, gamma and beta-bands, and their B(E2) transition strengths in 160-168Dy isotopes, are studied in the framework of the pseudo-SU(3) model which includes the preserving symmetry Q.Q term and the symmetry-breaki…
▽ More
Microscopic studies in heavy nuclei are very scarce due to large valence spaces involved. This computational problem can be avoided by means of the use of symmetry based models. Ground-state, gamma and beta-bands, and their B(E2) transition strengths in 160-168Dy isotopes, are studied in the framework of the pseudo-SU(3) model which includes the preserving symmetry Q.Q term and the symmetry-breaking Nilsson and pairing terms, systematically parametrized. Additionally, three rotor-like terms are considered whose free parameters, fixed for all members of the chain are used to fine tune the moment of inertia of rotational bands and the band-head of gamma and beta-bands. The model succesfully describes in a systematic way rotational features in these nuclei and allows to extrapolate toward the midshell nucleus 170Dy. The results presented show that it is possible to study full chain of isotopes or isotones in the region with the present model.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Low energy 0+ excitations in 158Gd
Authors:
Jorge G. Hirsch,
Gabriela Popa,
Shelly R. Lesher,
Ani Aprahamian,
Carlos E. Vargas,
Jerry P. Draayer
Abstract:
High precision (p,t) studies of the deformed nucleus 158Gd allowed the observation of 13 excited 0+ states below an excitation energy of 3.1 MeV. This high density of low energy states, and particularly their measured B(E2) transition strengths to the first excited 2+ state challenge nuclear models. The pseudo SU(3) model, which successfully describes many excited bands in Dy isotopes, is used t…
▽ More
High precision (p,t) studies of the deformed nucleus 158Gd allowed the observation of 13 excited 0+ states below an excitation energy of 3.1 MeV. This high density of low energy states, and particularly their measured B(E2) transition strengths to the first excited 2+ state challenge nuclear models. The pseudo SU(3) model, which successfully describes many excited bands in Dy isotopes, is used to analyze this nuclei. We have fairly good reproduction of most of the states but the absence of actively including nucleons occupying intruders orbits may be the reason for the observed limitations of the model.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2005;
originally announced May 2005.
-
Pseudo + quasi SU(3): Towards a shell-model description of heavy deformed nuclei
Authors:
Jorge G. Hirsch,
Carlos E. Vargas,
Gabriela Popa,
Jerry P. Draayer
Abstract:
The pseudo-SU(3) model has been extensively used to study normal parity bands in even-even and odd-mass heavy deformed nuclei. The use of a realistic Hamiltonian that mixes many SU(3) irreps has allowed for a successful description of energy spectra and electromagnetic transition strengths. While this model is powerful, there are situations in which the intruder states must be taken into account…
▽ More
The pseudo-SU(3) model has been extensively used to study normal parity bands in even-even and odd-mass heavy deformed nuclei. The use of a realistic Hamiltonian that mixes many SU(3) irreps has allowed for a successful description of energy spectra and electromagnetic transition strengths. While this model is powerful, there are situations in which the intruder states must be taken into account explicitly. The quasi-SU(3) symmetry is expected to complement the model, allowing for a description of nucleons occupying normal and intruder parity orbitals using a unified formalism.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2003;
originally announced April 2003.
-
Microscopic description of the scissors mode in odd-mass heavy deformed nuclei
Authors:
Carlos E. Vargas,
Jorge G. Hirsch,
Jerry P. Draayer
Abstract:
Pseudo-SU(3) shell-model results are reported for M1 excitation strengths in 157-Gd, 163-Dy and 169-Tm in the energy range between 2 and 4 MeV. Non-zero pseudo-spin couplings between the configurations play a very important role in determining the M1 strength distribution, especially its rapidly changing fragmentation pattern which differs significantly from what has been found in neighboring ev…
▽ More
Pseudo-SU(3) shell-model results are reported for M1 excitation strengths in 157-Gd, 163-Dy and 169-Tm in the energy range between 2 and 4 MeV. Non-zero pseudo-spin couplings between the configurations play a very important role in determining the M1 strength distribution, especially its rapidly changing fragmentation pattern which differs significantly from what has been found in neighboring even-even systems. The results suggest one should examine contributions from intruder levels.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2002;
originally announced November 2002.
-
Excited bands in odd-mass rare-earth nuclei
Authors:
C. E. Vargas,
J. G. Hirsch,
J. P. Draayer
Abstract:
Normal parity bands are studied in 157Gd, 163Dy and 169Tm using the pseudo SU(3) shell model. Energies and B(E2) transition strengths of states belonging to six low-lying rotational bands with the same parity in each nuclei are presented. The pseudo SU(3) basis includes states with pseudo-spin 0 and 1, and 1/2 and 3/2, for even and odd number of nucleons, respectively. States with pseudo-spin 1…
▽ More
Normal parity bands are studied in 157Gd, 163Dy and 169Tm using the pseudo SU(3) shell model. Energies and B(E2) transition strengths of states belonging to six low-lying rotational bands with the same parity in each nuclei are presented. The pseudo SU(3) basis includes states with pseudo-spin 0 and 1, and 1/2 and 3/2, for even and odd number of nucleons, respectively. States with pseudo-spin 1 and 3/2 must be included for a proper description of some excited bands.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2002;
originally announced August 2002.
-
Inter-band B(E2) transition strengths in odd-mass heavy deformed nuclei
Authors:
C. E. Vargas,
J. G. Hirsch,
J. P. Draayer
Abstract:
Inter-band B(E2) transition strengths between different normal parity bands in 163Dy and 165Er are described using the pseudo-SU(3) model. The Hamiltonian includes Nilsson single-particle energies, quadrupole-quadrupole and pairing interactions with fixed, parametrized strengths, and three extra rotor terms used to fine tune the energy spectra. In addition to inter-band transitions, the energy s…
▽ More
Inter-band B(E2) transition strengths between different normal parity bands in 163Dy and 165Er are described using the pseudo-SU(3) model. The Hamiltonian includes Nilsson single-particle energies, quadrupole-quadrupole and pairing interactions with fixed, parametrized strengths, and three extra rotor terms used to fine tune the energy spectra. In addition to inter-band transitions, the energy spectra and the ground state intra-band B(E2) strengths are reported. The results show the pseudo-SU(3) shell model to be a powerful microscopic theory for a description of the normal parity sector in heavy deformed odd-A nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2001;
originally announced September 2001.
-
Quasi-SU(3) truncation scheme for odd-even sd-shell nuclei
Authors:
C. E. Vargas,
J. G. Hirsch,
J. P. Draayer
Abstract:
The quasi-SU(3) symmetry, as found in shell model calculations, refers to the dominance of the single particle plus quadrupole-quadrupole terms in the Hamiltonian used to describe well deformed nuclei, and to the subspace relevant in its diagonalization. It provides a very efficient basis truncation scheme. It is shown that a small number of SU(3) coupled irreps, those with the largest C_2 value…
▽ More
The quasi-SU(3) symmetry, as found in shell model calculations, refers to the dominance of the single particle plus quadrupole-quadrupole terms in the Hamiltonian used to describe well deformed nuclei, and to the subspace relevant in its diagonalization. It provides a very efficient basis truncation scheme. It is shown that a small number of SU(3) coupled irreps, those with the largest C_2 values within the direct product of the proton and neutron SU(3) irreps with spin 0 and 1 (for even number of particles), and spin 1/2 and 3/2 for (for odd number of nucleons), are enough to describe the low energy spectra and B(E2) transition strengths of 21Ne, 23Na and 25Mg. A simple but realistic Hamiltonian is employed. Results compare favorably both with experimental data and with full shell model calculations. Limitations and possible improvements of the schematic Hamiltonian are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2000;
originally announced December 2000.
-
Pseudo SU(3) shell model: Normal parity bands in odd-mass nuclei
Authors:
C. E. Vargas,
J. G. Hirsch,
J. P. Draayer
Abstract:
A pseudo shell SU(3) model description of normal parity bands in 159-Tb is presented. The Hamiltonian includes spherical Nilsson single-particle energies, the quadrupole-quadrupole and pairing interactions, as well as three rotor terms. A systematic parametrization is introduced, accompained by a detailed discussion of the effect each term in the Hamiltonian has on the energy spectrum. Yrast and…
▽ More
A pseudo shell SU(3) model description of normal parity bands in 159-Tb is presented. The Hamiltonian includes spherical Nilsson single-particle energies, the quadrupole-quadrupole and pairing interactions, as well as three rotor terms. A systematic parametrization is introduced, accompained by a detailed discussion of the effect each term in the Hamiltonian has on the energy spectrum. Yrast and excited band wavefunctions are analyzed together with their B(E2) values.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2000;
originally announced September 2000.
-
Quasi-SU(3) truncation scheme for even-even sd-shell nuclei
Authors:
C. E. Vargas,
J. G. Hirsch,
J. P. Draayer
Abstract:
The Quasi-SU(3) symmetry was uncovered in full pf and sdg shell-model calculations for both even-even and odd-even nuclei. It manifests itself through a dominance of single-particle and quadrupole-quadrupole terms in the Hamiltonian used to describe well-deformed nuclei. A practical consequence of the quasi-SU(3) symmetry is an efficient basis truncation scheme. In a recent work was shown that w…
▽ More
The Quasi-SU(3) symmetry was uncovered in full pf and sdg shell-model calculations for both even-even and odd-even nuclei. It manifests itself through a dominance of single-particle and quadrupole-quadrupole terms in the Hamiltonian used to describe well-deformed nuclei. A practical consequence of the quasi-SU(3) symmetry is an efficient basis truncation scheme. In a recent work was shown that when this type of Hamiltonian is diagonalized in an SU(3) basis, only a few irreducible represntations (irreps) of SU(3) are needed to describe the Yrast band, the leading S = 0 irrep augmented with the leading S = 1 irreps in the proton and neutron subspaces. In the present article the quasi-SU(3) truncation scheme is used, in conjunction with a "realistic but schematic" Hamiltonian that includes the most important multipole terms, to describe the energy spectra and B(E2) transition strengths of 20-Ne, 22-Ne, 24-Mg and 28-Si. The effect of the size of the Hilbert space on both sets of observables is discussed, as well as the structure of the Yrast band and the importance of the various terms in the Hamiltonian.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2000;
originally announced September 2000.
-
Shell model description of normal parity bands in odd-mass heavy deformed nuclei
Authors:
C. E. Vargas,
J. G. Hirsch,
T. Beuschel,
J. P. Draayer
Abstract:
The low-energy spectra and B(E2) electromagnetic transition strengths of 159Eu, 159Tb and 159Dy are described using the pseudo SU(3) model. Normal parity bands are built as linear combinations of SU(3) states, which are the direct product of SU(3) proton and neutron states with pseudo spin zero (for even number of nucleons) and pseudo spin 1/2 (for odd number of nucleons). Each of the many-parti…
▽ More
The low-energy spectra and B(E2) electromagnetic transition strengths of 159Eu, 159Tb and 159Dy are described using the pseudo SU(3) model. Normal parity bands are built as linear combinations of SU(3) states, which are the direct product of SU(3) proton and neutron states with pseudo spin zero (for even number of nucleons) and pseudo spin 1/2 (for odd number of nucleons). Each of the many-particle states have a well-defined particle number and total angular momentum. The Hamiltonian includes spherical Nilsson single-particle energies, the quadrupole-quadrupole and pairing interactions, as well as three rotor terms which are diagonal in the SU(3) basis. The pseudo SU(3) model is shown to be a powerful tool to describe odd-mass heavy deformed nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2000;
originally announced January 2000.