-
Flat Maps that improve on the Winkel Tripel
Authors:
J. Richard Gott III,
David M. Goldberg,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Goldberg & Gott (2008) developed six error measures to rate flat map projections on their verisimilitude to the sphere: Isotropy, Area, Flexion, Skewness, Distances, and Boundary Cuts. The first two depend on the metric of the projection, the next two on its first derivatives. By these criteria, the Winkel Tripel (used by National Geographic for world maps) was the best scoring of all the known pr…
▽ More
Goldberg & Gott (2008) developed six error measures to rate flat map projections on their verisimilitude to the sphere: Isotropy, Area, Flexion, Skewness, Distances, and Boundary Cuts. The first two depend on the metric of the projection, the next two on its first derivatives. By these criteria, the Winkel Tripel (used by National Geographic for world maps) was the best scoring of all the known projections with a sum of squares of the six errors of 4.563, normalized relative to the Equirectangular in each error term. We present here a useful Gott-Wagner variant with a slightly better error score of only 4.497. We also present a radically new class of flat double-sided maps (like phonograph records) which have correct topology and vastly improved error scores: 0.881 for the azimuthal equidistant version. We believe it is the most accurate flat map of Earth yet. We also show maps of other solar system objects and sky maps.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
A Simple 3D Isometric Embedding of the Flat Square Torus
Authors:
J. Richard Gott III,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Start with Gott (2019)'s envelope polyhedron (Squares-4 around a point): a unit cube missing its top and bottom faces. Stretch by a factor of 2 in the vertical direction so its sides become (2x1 unit) rectangles. This has 8 faces (4 exterior, 4 interior), 8 vertices, and 16 edges. F-E+V = 0, implying a (toroidal) genus = 1. It is isometric to a flat square torus. Like any polyhedron it has zero in…
▽ More
Start with Gott (2019)'s envelope polyhedron (Squares-4 around a point): a unit cube missing its top and bottom faces. Stretch by a factor of 2 in the vertical direction so its sides become (2x1 unit) rectangles. This has 8 faces (4 exterior, 4 interior), 8 vertices, and 16 edges. F-E+V = 0, implying a (toroidal) genus = 1. It is isometric to a flat square torus. Like any polyhedron it has zero intrinsic Gaussian curvature on its faces and edges. Since 4 right angled rectangles meet at each vertex, there is no angle deficit and zero Gaussian curvature there as well. All meridian and latitudinal circumferences are equal (4 units long).
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A Framework for Telescope Schedulers: With Applications to the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope
Authors:
Elahesadat Naghib,
Peter Yoachim,
Robert J. Vanderbei,
Andrew J. Connolly,
R. Lynne Jones
Abstract:
How ground-based telescopes schedule their observations in response to competing science priorities and constraints, variations in the weather, and the visibility of a particular part of the sky can significantly impact their efficiency. In this paper we introduce the Feature-Based telescope scheduler that is an automated, proposal-free decision making algorithm that offers \textit{controllability…
▽ More
How ground-based telescopes schedule their observations in response to competing science priorities and constraints, variations in the weather, and the visibility of a particular part of the sky can significantly impact their efficiency. In this paper we introduce the Feature-Based telescope scheduler that is an automated, proposal-free decision making algorithm that offers \textit{controllability} of the behavior, \textit{adjustability} of the mission, and quick \textit{recoverability} from interruptions for large ground-based telescopes. By framing this scheduler in the context of a coherent mathematical model the functionality and performance of the algorithm is simple to interpret and adapt to a broad range of astronomical applications. This paper presents a generic version of the Feature-Based scheduler, with minimal manual tailoring, to demonstrate its potential and flexibility as a foundation for large ground-based telescope schedulers which can later be adjusted for other instruments. In addition, a modified version of the Feature-Based scheduler for the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) is introduced and compared to previous LSST scheduler simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Shaped Pupil Lyot Coronagraphs: High-Contrast Solutions for Restricted Focal Planes
Authors:
Neil T. Zimmerman,
A J Eldorado Riggs,
N. Jeremy Kasdin,
Alexis Carlotti,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Coronagraphs of the apodized pupil and shaped pupil varieties use the Fraunhofer diffraction properties of amplitude masks to create regions of high contrast in the vicinity of a target star. Here we present a hybrid coronagraph architecture in which a binary, hard-edged shaped pupil mask replaces the gray, smooth apodizer of the apodized pupil Lyot coronagraph (APLC). For any contrast and bandwid…
▽ More
Coronagraphs of the apodized pupil and shaped pupil varieties use the Fraunhofer diffraction properties of amplitude masks to create regions of high contrast in the vicinity of a target star. Here we present a hybrid coronagraph architecture in which a binary, hard-edged shaped pupil mask replaces the gray, smooth apodizer of the apodized pupil Lyot coronagraph (APLC). For any contrast and bandwidth goal in this configuration, as long as the prescribed region of contrast is restricted to a finite area in the image, a shaped pupil is the apodizer with the highest transmission. We relate the starlight cancellation mechanism to that of the conventional APLC. We introduce a new class of solutions in which the amplitude profile of the Lyot stop, instead of being fixed as a padded replica of the telescope aperture, is jointly optimized with the apodizer. Finally, we describe shaped pupil Lyot coronagraph (SPLC) designs for the baseline architecture of the Wide-Field Infrared Survey Telescope-Astrophysics Focused Telescope Assets (WFIRST-AFTA) coronagraph. These SPLCs help to enable two scientific objectives of the WFIRST-AFTA mission: (1) broadband spectroscopy to characterize exoplanet atmospheres in reflected starlight and (2) debris disk imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
The Complex Roots of Random Sums
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
This paper extends earlier work on the distribution in the complex plane of the roots of random polynomials. In this paper, the random polynomials are generalized to random finite sums of given "basis" functions. The basis functions are assumed to be entire functions that are real-valued on the real line. The coefficients are assumed to be independent identically distributed Normal $(0,1)$ random…
▽ More
This paper extends earlier work on the distribution in the complex plane of the roots of random polynomials. In this paper, the random polynomials are generalized to random finite sums of given "basis" functions. The basis functions are assumed to be entire functions that are real-valued on the real line. The coefficients are assumed to be independent identically distributed Normal $(0,1)$ random variables. An explicit formula for the density function is given in terms of the set of basis functions. We also consider some practical examples including Fourier series. In some cases, we derive an explicit formula for the limiting density as the number of terms in the sum tends to infinity.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2016; v1 submitted 20 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Constructing Strong Markov Processes
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
The construction presented in this paper can be briefly described as follows: starting from any "finite-dimensional" Markov transition function p_t, on a measurable state space (E,B), we construct a strong Markov process on a certain "intrinsic" state space that is, in fact, a closed subset of a finite dimensional Euclidean space R^d. Of course we must explain the meaning of finite-dimensionality…
▽ More
The construction presented in this paper can be briefly described as follows: starting from any "finite-dimensional" Markov transition function p_t, on a measurable state space (E,B), we construct a strong Markov process on a certain "intrinsic" state space that is, in fact, a closed subset of a finite dimensional Euclidean space R^d. Of course we must explain the meaning of finite-dimensionality and intrinsity. Starting with p_t, we consider the range of the nonnegative bounded measurable functions under the action of the resolvent. This class of functions induces a uniform structure on E. We say that E is finite-dimensional if this uniformity is finitely generated. In such cases we then map E into R^d. The intrinsic state space is the closure of the range of this map**. On this enlarged state space we construct a strong Markov process, which corresponds quite naturally to p_t. We give several examples including the usual examples of nonstrong Markov process.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
A Regression Approach to Fairer Grading
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei,
Gordon Scharf,
Daniel Marlow
Abstract:
In this paper we describe a statistical procedure to account for differences in grading practices from one course to another. The goal is to define a course "inflatedness" and a student "aptitude" that best captures one's intuitive notions of these concepts.
In this paper we describe a statistical procedure to account for differences in grading practices from one course to another. The goal is to define a course "inflatedness" and a student "aptitude" that best captures one's intuitive notions of these concepts.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Local Warming
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Using 55 years of daily average temperatures from a local weather station, I made a least-absolute-deviations (LAD) regression model that accounts for three effects: seasonal variations, the 11-year solar cycle, and a linear trend. The model was formulated as a linear programming problem and solved using widely available optimization software. The solution indicates that temperatures have gone up…
▽ More
Using 55 years of daily average temperatures from a local weather station, I made a least-absolute-deviations (LAD) regression model that accounts for three effects: seasonal variations, the 11-year solar cycle, and a linear trend. The model was formulated as a linear programming problem and solved using widely available optimization software. The solution indicates that temperatures have gone up by about 2 degrees Fahrenheit over the 55 years covered by the data. It also correctly identifies the known phase of the solar cycle; i.e., the date of the last solar minimum. It turns out that the maximum slope of the solar cycle sinusoid in the regression model is about the same size as the slope produced by the linear trend. The fact that the solar cycle was correctly extracted by the model is a strong indicator that effects of this size, in particular the slope of the linear trend, can be accurately determined from the 55 years of data analyzed.
The main purpose for doing this analysis is to demonstrate that it is easy to find and analyze archived temperature data for oneself. In particular, this problem makes a good class project for upper-level undergraduate courses in optimization or in statistics.
It is worth noting that a similar least-squares model failed to characterize the solar cycle correctly and hence even though it too indicates that temperatures have been rising locally, one can be less confident in this result.
The paper ends with a section presenting similar results from a few thousand sites distributed world-wide, some results from a modification of the model that includes both temperature and humidity, as well as a number of suggestions for future work and/or ideas for enhancements that could be used as classroom projects.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Fast Fourier Optimization: Sparsity Matters
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Many interesting and fundamentally practical optimization problems, ranging from optics, to signal processing, to radar and acoustics, involve constraints on the Fourier transform of a function. It is well-known that the {\em fast Fourier transform} (fft) is a recursive algorithm that can dramatically improve the efficiency for computing the discrete Fourier transform. However, because it is recur…
▽ More
Many interesting and fundamentally practical optimization problems, ranging from optics, to signal processing, to radar and acoustics, involve constraints on the Fourier transform of a function. It is well-known that the {\em fast Fourier transform} (fft) is a recursive algorithm that can dramatically improve the efficiency for computing the discrete Fourier transform. However, because it is recursive, it is difficult to embed into a linear optimization problem. In this paper, we explain the main idea behind the fast Fourier transform and show how to adapt it in such a manner as to make it encodable as constraints in an optimization problem. We demonstrate a real-world problem from the field of high-contrast imaging. On this problem, dramatic improvements are translated to an ability to solve problems with a much finer grid of discretized points. As we shall show, in general, the "fast Fourier" version of the optimization constraints produces a larger but sparser constraint matrix and therefore one can think of the fast Fourier transform as a method of sparsifying the constraints in an optimization problem, which is usually a good thing.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Scientific Design of a High Contrast Integral Field Spectrograph for the Subaru Telescope
Authors:
Michael W. McElwain,
Timothy D. Brandt,
Markus Janson,
Gillian R. Knapp,
Mary Anne Peters,
Adam Burrows,
Alexis Carlotti,
Michael A. Carr,
Tyler Groff,
James E. Gunn,
Olivier Guyon,
Masahiko Hayashi,
N. Jeremy Kasdin,
Masayuki Kuzuhara,
Robert H. Lupton,
Frantz Martinache,
David Spiegel,
Naruhisa Takato,
Motohide Tamura,
Edwin L. Turner,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Ground-based telescopes equipped with adaptive-optics (AO) systems and specialized science cameras are now capable of directly detecting extrasolar planets. We present the expected scientific capabilities of CHARIS, the Coronagraphic High Angular Resolution Imaging Spectrograph, which is being built for the Subaru 8.2 m telescope of the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan. CHARIS will be im…
▽ More
Ground-based telescopes equipped with adaptive-optics (AO) systems and specialized science cameras are now capable of directly detecting extrasolar planets. We present the expected scientific capabilities of CHARIS, the Coronagraphic High Angular Resolution Imaging Spectrograph, which is being built for the Subaru 8.2 m telescope of the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan. CHARIS will be implemented behind the new extreme adaptive optics system at Subaru, SCExAO, and the existing 188-actuator system AO188. CHARIS will offer three observing modes over near-infrared wavelengths from 0.9 to 2.4 microns (the y-, J-, H-, and K-bands), including a low-spectral-resolution mode covering this entire wavelength range and a high-resolution mode within a single band. With these capabilities, CHARIS will offer exceptional sensitivity for discovering giant exoplanets, and will enable detailed characterization of their atmospheres. CHARIS, the only planned high-contrast integral field spectrograph on an 8m-class telescope in the Northern Hemisphere, will complement the similar instruments such as Project 1640 at Palomar, and GPI and SPHERE in Chile.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
The Transit Ingress and the Tilted Orbit of the Extraordinarily Eccentric Exoplanet HD 80606b
Authors:
Joshua N. Winn,
Andrew W. Howard,
John Asher Johnson,
Geoffrey W. Marcy,
J. Zachary Gazak,
Donn Starkey,
Eric B. Ford,
Knicole D. Colon,
Francisco Reyes,
Lisa Nortmann,
Stefan Dreizler,
Stephen Odewahn,
William F. Welsh,
Shimonee Kadakia,
Robert J. Vanderbei,
Elisabeth R. Adams,
Matthew Lockhart,
Ian J. Crossfield,
Jeff A. Valenti,
Ronald Dantowitz,
Joshua A. Carter
Abstract:
We present the results of a transcontinental campaign to observe the 2009 June 5 transit of the exoplanet HD 80606b. We report the first detection of the transit ingress, revealing the transit duration to be 11.64 +/- 0.25 hr and allowing more robust determinations of the system parameters. Keck spectra obtained at midtransit exhibit an anomalous blueshift, giving definitive evidence that the st…
▽ More
We present the results of a transcontinental campaign to observe the 2009 June 5 transit of the exoplanet HD 80606b. We report the first detection of the transit ingress, revealing the transit duration to be 11.64 +/- 0.25 hr and allowing more robust determinations of the system parameters. Keck spectra obtained at midtransit exhibit an anomalous blueshift, giving definitive evidence that the stellar spin axis and planetary orbital axis are misaligned. The Keck data show that the projected spin-orbit angle is between 32-87 deg with 68.3% confidence and between 14-142 deg with 99.73% confidence. Thus the orbit of this planet is not only highly eccentric (e=0.93), but is also tilted away from the equatorial plane of its parent star. A large tilt had been predicted, based on the idea that the planet's eccentric orbit was caused by the Kozai mechanism. Independently of the theory, it is noteworthy that all 3 exoplanetary systems with known spin-orbit misalignments have massive planets on eccentric orbits, suggesting that those systems migrate differently than lower-mass planets on circular orbits.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2009; v1 submitted 29 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
-
Externally Occulted Terrestrial Planet Finder Coronagraph: Simulations and Sensitivities
Authors:
Richard G. Lyon,
Sally Heap,
Amy Lo,
Webster Cash,
Glenn D. Starkman,
Robert J. Vanderbei,
N. Jeremy Kasdin,
Craig J. Copi
Abstract:
A multitude of coronagraphic techniques for the space-based direct detection and characterization of exo-solar terrestrial planets are actively being pursued by the astronomical community. Typical coronagraphs have internal shaped focal plane and/or pupil plane occulting masks which block and/or diffract starlight thereby increasing the planet's contrast with respect to its parent star. Past stu…
▽ More
A multitude of coronagraphic techniques for the space-based direct detection and characterization of exo-solar terrestrial planets are actively being pursued by the astronomical community. Typical coronagraphs have internal shaped focal plane and/or pupil plane occulting masks which block and/or diffract starlight thereby increasing the planet's contrast with respect to its parent star. Past studies have shown that any internal technique is limited by the ability to sense and control amplitude, phase (wavefront) and polarization to exquisite levels - necessitating stressing optical requirements. An alternative and promising technique is to place a starshade, i.e. external occulter, at some distance in front of the telescope. This starshade suppresses most of the starlight before entering the telescope - relaxing optical requirements to that of a more conventional telescope. While an old technique it has been recently been advanced by the recognition that circularly symmetric graded apodizers can be well approximated by shaped binary occulting masks. Indeed optimal shapes have been designed that can achieve smaller inner working angles than conventional coronagraphs and yet have high effective throughput allowing smaller aperture telescopes to achieve the same coronagraphic resolution and similar sensitivity as larger ones.
Herein we report on our ongoing modeling, simulation and optimization of external occulters and show sensitivity results with respect to number and shape errors of petals, spectral passband, accuracy of Fresnel propagation, and show results for both filled and segmented aperture telescopes and discuss acquisition and sensing of the occulter's location relative to the telescope.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
-
Fast computation of Lyot-style coronagraph propagation
Authors:
Remi Soummer,
Laurent Pueyo,
Anand Sivaramakrishnan,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
We present a new method for numerical propagation through Lyot-style coronagraphs using finite occulting masks. Standard methods for coronagraphic simulations involve Fast Fourier Transforms (FFT) of very large arrays, and computing power is an issue for the design and tolerancing of coronagraphs on segmented Extremely Large Telescopes (ELT) in order to handle both the speed and memory requireme…
▽ More
We present a new method for numerical propagation through Lyot-style coronagraphs using finite occulting masks. Standard methods for coronagraphic simulations involve Fast Fourier Transforms (FFT) of very large arrays, and computing power is an issue for the design and tolerancing of coronagraphs on segmented Extremely Large Telescopes (ELT) in order to handle both the speed and memory requirements. Our method combines a semi-analytical approach with non-FFT based Fourier transform algorithms. It enables both fast and memory-efficient computations without introducing any additional approximations. Typical speed improvements based on computation costs are of about ten to fifty for propagations from pupil to Lyot plane, with thirty to sixty times less memory needed. Our method makes it possible to perform numerical coronagraphic studies even in the case of ELTs using a contemporary commercial laptop computer, or any standard commercial workstation computer.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Optimal Occulter Design for Finding Extrasolar Planets
Authors:
R. J. Vanderbei,
N. J. Kasdin,
E. Cady
Abstract:
One proposed method for finding terrestrial planets around nearby stars is to use two spacecraft--a telescope and a specially shaped occulter that is specifically designed to prevent all but a tiny fraction of the starlight from diffracting into the telescope. As the cost and observing cadence for such a mission will be driven largely by the separation between the two spacecraft, it is criticall…
▽ More
One proposed method for finding terrestrial planets around nearby stars is to use two spacecraft--a telescope and a specially shaped occulter that is specifically designed to prevent all but a tiny fraction of the starlight from diffracting into the telescope. As the cost and observing cadence for such a mission will be driven largely by the separation between the two spacecraft, it is critically important to design an occulter that can meet the observing goals while flying as close to the telescope as possible. In this paper, we explore this tradeoff between separation and occulter diameter. More specifically, we present a method for designing the shape of the outer edge of an occulter that is as small as possible and gives a shadow that is deep enough and large enough for a 4m telescope to survey the habitable zones of many stars for Earth-like planets. In particular, we show that in order for a 4m telescope to detect in broadband visible light a planet 0.06 arcseconds from a star shining $10^{10}$ times brighter than the planet requires a specially-shaped occulter 50m in diameter positioned about $72,000$ km in front of the telescope.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2007;
originally announced April 2007.
-
Linear Stability of Ring Systems
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei,
Egemen Kolemen
Abstract:
We give a self-contained modern linear stability analysis of a system of n equal mass bodies in circular orbit about a single more massive body. Starting with the mathematical description of the dynamics of the system, we form the linear approximation, compute all of the eigenvalues of the linear stability matrix, and finally derive inequalities that guarantee that none of these eigenvalues have…
▽ More
We give a self-contained modern linear stability analysis of a system of n equal mass bodies in circular orbit about a single more massive body. Starting with the mathematical description of the dynamics of the system, we form the linear approximation, compute all of the eigenvalues of the linear stability matrix, and finally derive inequalities that guarantee that none of these eigenvalues have positive real part. In the end, we rederive the result that J.C. Maxwell found for large n in his seminal paper on the nature and stability of Saturn's rings, which was published 150 years ago. In addition, we identify the exact matrix that defines the linearized system even when n is not large. This matrix is then investigated numerically (by computer) to find stability inequalities. Furthermore, using properties of circulant matrices, the eigenvalues of the large 4nx4n matrix can be computed by solving n quartic equations, which further facilitates the investigation of stability. Finally, we have implemented an n-body simulator and we verify that the threshold mass ratios that we derived mathematically or numerically do indeed identify the threshold between stability and instability. Throughout the paper we consider only the planar n-body problem so that the analysis can be carried out purely in complex notation, which makes the equations and derivations more compact, more elegant and therefore, we hope, more transparent. The result is a fresh analysis that shows that these systems are always unstable for 2<=n<=6 and for n > 6 they are stable provided that the central mass is massive enough. We give an explicit formula for this mass-ratio threshold.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2006; v1 submitted 21 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
Diffraction-Based Sensitivity Analysis of Apodized Pupil Map** Systems
Authors:
Ruslan Belikov,
N. Jeremy Kasdin,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Pupil map** is a promising and unconventional new method for high contrast imaging being considered for terrestrial exoplanet searches. It employs two (or more) specially designed aspheric mirrors to create a high-contrast amplitude profile across the telescope pupil that does not appreciably attenuate amplitude. As such, it reaps significant benefits in light collecting efficiency and inner w…
▽ More
Pupil map** is a promising and unconventional new method for high contrast imaging being considered for terrestrial exoplanet searches. It employs two (or more) specially designed aspheric mirrors to create a high-contrast amplitude profile across the telescope pupil that does not appreciably attenuate amplitude. As such, it reaps significant benefits in light collecting efficiency and inner working angle, both critical parameters for terrestrial planet detection. While much has been published on various aspects of pupil map** systems, the problem of sensitivity to wavefront aberrations remains an open question. In this paper, we present an efficient method for computing the sensitivity of a pupil mapped system to Zernike aberrations. We then use this method to study the sensitivity of a particular pupil map** system and compare it to the concentric-ring shaped pupil coronagraph. In particular, we quantify how contrast and inner working angle degrade with increasing Zernike order and rms amplitude. These results have obvious ramifications for the stability requirements and overall design of a planet-finding observatory.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2006; v1 submitted 25 May, 2006;
originally announced May 2006.
-
Diffraction of Apodized Pupil Map** Systems with Aberrations
Authors:
Ruslan Belikov,
N. Jeremy Kasdin,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Pupil map** is a promising and unconventional new method for high contrast imaging being considered for terrestrial exoplanet searches. It employs two (or more) specially designed aspheric mirrors to create a high-contrast amplitude profile across the telescope pupil that does not appreciably attenuate amplitude. As such, it reaps significant benefits in light collecting efficiency and inner w…
▽ More
Pupil map** is a promising and unconventional new method for high contrast imaging being considered for terrestrial exoplanet searches. It employs two (or more) specially designed aspheric mirrors to create a high-contrast amplitude profile across the telescope pupil that does not appreciably attenuate amplitude. As such, it reaps significant benefits in light collecting efficiency and inner working angle, both critical parameters for terrestrial planet detection. While much has been published on various aspects of pupil map** systems, the problem of sensitivity to wavefront aberrations remains an open question. In this paper, we present an efficient method for computing the sensitivity of a pupil mapped system to Zernike aberrations. We then use this method to study the sensitivity of a particular pupil map** system and compare it to the concentric-ring shaped pupil coronagraph. In particular, we show how contrast and inner working angle degrade with increasing Zernike order and rms amplitude, which has obvious ramifications for the stability requirements and overall design of a planet-finding observatory.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2006;
originally announced March 2006.
-
Diffraction Analysis of 2-D Pupil Map** for High-Contrast Imaging
Authors:
R. J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Pupil-map** is a technique whereby a uniformly-illuminated input pupil, such as from starlight, can be mapped into a non-uniformly illuminated exit pupil, such that the image formed from this pupil will have suppressed sidelobes, many orders of magnitude weaker than classical Airy ring intensities. Pupil map** is therefore a candidate technique for coronagraphic imaging of extrasolar planets…
▽ More
Pupil-map** is a technique whereby a uniformly-illuminated input pupil, such as from starlight, can be mapped into a non-uniformly illuminated exit pupil, such that the image formed from this pupil will have suppressed sidelobes, many orders of magnitude weaker than classical Airy ring intensities. Pupil map** is therefore a candidate technique for coronagraphic imaging of extrasolar planets around nearby stars. Unlike most other high-contrast imaging techniques, pupil map** is lossless and preserves the full angular resolution of the collecting telescope. So, it could possibly give the highest signal-to-noise ratio of any proposed single-telescope system for detecting extrasolar planets. Prior analyses based on pupil-to-pupil ray-tracing indicate that a planet fainter than 10^{-10} times its parent star, and as close as about 2 lambda/D, should be detectable. In this paper, we describe the results of careful diffraction analysis of pupil map** systems. These results reveal a serious unresolved issue. Namely, high-contrast pupil map**s distribute light from very near the edge of the first pupil to a broad area of the second pupil and this dramatically amplifies diffraction-based edge effects resulting in a limiting attainable contrast of about 10^{-5}. We hope that by identifying this problem others will provide a solution.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
Pupil Map** in 2-D for High-Contrast Imaging
Authors:
R. J. Vanderbei,
W. A. Traub
Abstract:
Pupil-map** is a technique whereby a uniformly-illuminated input pupil, such as from starlight, can be mapped into a non-uniformly illuminated exit pupil, such that the image formed from this pupil will have suppressed sidelobes, many orders of magnitude weaker than classical Airy ring intensities. Pupil map** is therefore a candidate technique for coronagraphic imaging of extrasolar planets…
▽ More
Pupil-map** is a technique whereby a uniformly-illuminated input pupil, such as from starlight, can be mapped into a non-uniformly illuminated exit pupil, such that the image formed from this pupil will have suppressed sidelobes, many orders of magnitude weaker than classical Airy ring intensities. Pupil map** is therefore a candidate technique for coronagraphic imaging of extrasolar planets around nearby stars. The pupil map** technique is lossless, and preserves the full angular resolution of the collecting telescope, so it could possibly give the highest signal-to-noise ratio of any proposed single-telescope system for detecting extrasolar planets. A planet fainter than $10^{-10}$ times its parent star, and as close as about $2 λ/D$ should be detectable. We derive the 2-dimensional equations of pupil map** for both 2-mirror and 2-lens systems. We give examples for both cases. We derive analytical estimates of aberration in a 2-mirror system, and show that the aberrations are essentially corrected with an added reversed set of mirrors.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2004;
originally announced December 2004.
-
Optimal Asymmetric Apodizations and Shaped Pupils for Planet Finding Coronagraphy
Authors:
N. Jeremy Kasdin,
Robert J. Vanderbei,
Michael G. Littman,
David N. Spergel
Abstract:
The realization that direct imaging of extrasolar planets could be technologically feasible within the next decade or so has inspired a great deal of recent research into high-contrast imaging. We ourselves have contributed several design ideas, all of which can be described as shaped pupil coronagraphs. In this paper, we offer a complete and unified survey of asymmetric shaped pupils designs, s…
▽ More
The realization that direct imaging of extrasolar planets could be technologically feasible within the next decade or so has inspired a great deal of recent research into high-contrast imaging. We ourselves have contributed several design ideas, all of which can be described as shaped pupil coronagraphs. In this paper, we offer a complete and unified survey of asymmetric shaped pupils designs, some of which have been published in our previous papers. We also introduce a promising new design, which we call barcode masks. These masks achieve the required contrast with a fairly large discovery zone and throughput but most importantly they are perhaps the easiest to manufacture and might therefore stand up best to a refined analysis based on vector propogation techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
Rectangular-Mask Coronagraphs for High-Contrast Imaging
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei,
N. Jeremy Kasdin,
David N. Spergel
Abstract:
We present yet another new family of masks for high-contrast imaging as required for the to-be-built terrestrial planet finder space telescope. The ``best'' design involves a square entrance pupil having a 4-vane spider, a square image-plane mask containing a plus-sign shaped occulter to block the starlight inside 0.6 lambda/D, and a Lyot-plane mask consisting of a rectangular array of rectangul…
▽ More
We present yet another new family of masks for high-contrast imaging as required for the to-be-built terrestrial planet finder space telescope. The ``best'' design involves a square entrance pupil having a 4-vane spider, a square image-plane mask containing a plus-sign shaped occulter to block the starlight inside 0.6 lambda/D, and a Lyot-plane mask consisting of a rectangular array of rectangular opennings. Using Fraunhofer analysis, we show that the optical system can image a planet 10^{-10} times as bright as an on-axis star in four rectangular regions given by {(xi,zeta): 1.4 < | xi | < 20, 1.4 < | zeta | < 20}.
Since the design involves an image plane mask, pointing error is an issue. We show that the design can tolerate pointing errors of about 0.05 lambda/D.
The inclusion of a 4-vane spider in the entrance pupil provides the possibility to build a mirror-only on-axis system thereby greatly reducing the negative effects of polarization.
Each of the masks can be realized as two masks consisting of stripes of opaque material with the stripes oriented at right angles to each other. We call these striped masks barcode masks. We show that it is sufficient for the barcode masks by themselves to provide 10^{-5} contrast. This then guarantees that the full system will provide the required 10^{-10} contrast.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2004;
originally announced January 2004.
-
Two-Mirror Apodization for High-Contrast Imaging
Authors:
Wesley A. Traub,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
Direct detection of extrasolar planets will require imaging systems capable of unprecedented contrast. Apodized pupils provide an attractive way to achieve such contrast but they are difficult, perhaps impossible, to manufacture to the required tolerance and they absorb about 90% of the light in order to create the apodization, which of course lengthens the exposure times needed for planet detec…
▽ More
Direct detection of extrasolar planets will require imaging systems capable of unprecedented contrast. Apodized pupils provide an attractive way to achieve such contrast but they are difficult, perhaps impossible, to manufacture to the required tolerance and they absorb about 90% of the light in order to create the apodization, which of course lengthens the exposure times needed for planet detection. A recently proposed alternative is to use two mirrors to accomplish the apodization. With such a system, no light is lost. In this paper, we provide a careful mathematical analysis, using one dimensional mirrors, of the on-axis and off-axis performance of such a two-mirror apodization system. There appear to be advantages and disadvantages to this approach. In addition to not losing any light, we show that the nonuniformity of the apodization implies an extra magnification of off-axis sources and thereby makes it possible to build a real system with about half the aperture that one would otherwise require or, equivalently, resolve planets at about half the angular separation as one can achieve with standard apodization. More specifically, ignoring pointing error and stellar disk size, a planet at $1.7 λ/D$ ought to be at the edge of detectability. However, we show that the non-zero size of a stellar disk pushes the threshold for high-contrast so that a planet must be at least $2.5 λ/D$ from its star to be detectable. The off-axis analysis of two-dimensional mirrors is left for future study.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2003; v1 submitted 26 June, 2003;
originally announced June 2003.
-
Circularly Symmetric Apodization via Starshaped Masks
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei,
David N. Spergel,
N. Jeremy Kasdin
Abstract:
Recently, we introduced a class of shaped pupil masks, called spiderweb masks, that produce point spread functions having annular dark zones. With such masks, a single image can be used to probe a star for extrasolar planets. In this paper, we introduce a new class of shaped pupil masks that also provide annular dark zones. We call these masks starshaped masks. Given any circularly symmetric apo…
▽ More
Recently, we introduced a class of shaped pupil masks, called spiderweb masks, that produce point spread functions having annular dark zones. With such masks, a single image can be used to probe a star for extrasolar planets. In this paper, we introduce a new class of shaped pupil masks that also provide annular dark zones. We call these masks starshaped masks. Given any circularly symmetric apodization function, we show how to construct a corresponding starshaped mask that has the same point-spread function (out to any given outer working distance) as obtained by the apodization.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2003; v1 submitted 3 May, 2003;
originally announced May 2003.
-
New Orbits for the n-Body Problem
Authors:
R. J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider minimizing the action functional as a method for numerically discovering periodic solutions to the $n$-body problem. With this method, we can find a large number of choreographies and other more general solutions. We show that most of the solutions found, including all but one of the choreographies, are unstable. It appears to be much easier to find unstable solutions…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider minimizing the action functional as a method for numerically discovering periodic solutions to the $n$-body problem. With this method, we can find a large number of choreographies and other more general solutions. We show that most of the solutions found, including all but one of the choreographies, are unstable. It appears to be much easier to find unstable solutions to the $n$-body problem than stable ones. Simpler solutions are more likely to be stable than exotic ones.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2003;
originally announced March 2003.
-
Spiderweb Masks for High-Contrast Imaging
Authors:
Robert J. Vanderbei,
David N. Spergel,
N. Jeremy Kasdin
Abstract:
Motivated by the desire to image exosolar planets, recent work by us and others has shown that high-contrast imaging can be achieved using specially shaped pupil masks. To date, the masks we have designed have been symmetric with respect to a cartesian coordinate system but were not rotationally invariant, thus requiring that one take multiple images at different angles of rotation about the cen…
▽ More
Motivated by the desire to image exosolar planets, recent work by us and others has shown that high-contrast imaging can be achieved using specially shaped pupil masks. To date, the masks we have designed have been symmetric with respect to a cartesian coordinate system but were not rotationally invariant, thus requiring that one take multiple images at different angles of rotation about the central point in order to obtain high-contrast in all directions. In this paper, we present a new class of masks that have rotational symmetry and provide high-contrast in all directions with just one image. These masks provide the required 10^{-10} level of contrast to within 4 lambda/D, and in some cases 3 lambda/D, of the central point, which is deemed necessary for exosolar planet finding/imaging. They are also well-suited for use on ground-based telescopes, and perhaps NGST too, since they can accommodate central obstructions and associated support spiders.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2003;
originally announced March 2003.
-
The Kruskal Count
Authors:
Jeffrey C. Lagarias,
Eric Rains,
Robert J. Vanderbei
Abstract:
The Kruskal Count is a card trick invented by Martin J. Kruskal in which a magician "guesses" a card selected by a subject according to a certain counting procedure. With high probability the magician can correctly "guess" the card. The success of the trick is based on a mathematical principle related to coupling methods for Markov chains. This paper analyzes in detail two simplified variants of…
▽ More
The Kruskal Count is a card trick invented by Martin J. Kruskal in which a magician "guesses" a card selected by a subject according to a certain counting procedure. With high probability the magician can correctly "guess" the card. The success of the trick is based on a mathematical principle related to coupling methods for Markov chains. This paper analyzes in detail two simplified variants of the trick and estimates the probability of success. The model predictions are compared with simulation data for several variants of the actual trick.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2001;
originally announced October 2001.
