-
Quantifying the influence of bars on action-based dynamical modelling of disc galaxies
Authors:
Soumavo Ghosh,
Wilma H. Trick,
Gregory M. Green
Abstract:
Action-based dynamical modelling, using stars as dynamical tracers, is an excellent diagnostic to estimate the underlying axisymmetric matter distribution of the Milky Way. However, the Milky Way's bar causes non-axisymmetric resonance features in the stellar disc. Using Roadmap** (an action-based dynamical modelling framework to estimate the gravitational potential and the stellar distribution…
▽ More
Action-based dynamical modelling, using stars as dynamical tracers, is an excellent diagnostic to estimate the underlying axisymmetric matter distribution of the Milky Way. However, the Milky Way's bar causes non-axisymmetric resonance features in the stellar disc. Using Roadmap** (an action-based dynamical modelling framework to estimate the gravitational potential and the stellar distribution function), we systematically quantify the robustness of action-based modelling in the presence of a bar. We construct a set of test-particle simulations of barred galaxies (with varying bar properties), and apply Roadmap** to different survey volumes (with varying azimuthal position, size) drawn from these barred models. For realistic bar parameters, the global potential parameters are still recovered to within ~ 1 - 17 percent. However, with increasing bar strength, the best-fit values of the parameters progressively deviate from their true values. This happens due to a combination of radial heating, radial migration, and resonance overlap phenomena in our bar models. Furthermore, the azimuthal location and the size of the survey volumes play important roles in the successful recovery of the parameters. Survey volumes along the bar major axis produce larger (relative) errors in the best-fit parameter values. In addition, the potential parameters are better recovered for survey volumes with larger spatial coverage. As the Sun is located just ~ 28 - 33 degrees behind the bar's major axis, an estimate for the bar-induced systematic bias -- as provided by this study -- is therefore crucial for future modelling attempts of the Milky Way.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2023; v1 submitted 12 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Chemodynamical signatures of bar resonances in the Galactic disk: current data and future prospects
Authors:
Adam Wheeler,
Irene Abril-Cabezas,
Wilma H. Trick,
Francesca Fragkoudi,
Melissa Ness
Abstract:
The Galactic disk exhibits complex chemical and dynamical substructure thought to be induced by the bar, spiral arms, and satellites. Here, we explore the chemical signatures of bar resonances in action and velocity space and characterize the differences between the signatures of corotation and higher-order resonances using test particle simulations. Thanks to recent surveys, we now have large dat…
▽ More
The Galactic disk exhibits complex chemical and dynamical substructure thought to be induced by the bar, spiral arms, and satellites. Here, we explore the chemical signatures of bar resonances in action and velocity space and characterize the differences between the signatures of corotation and higher-order resonances using test particle simulations. Thanks to recent surveys, we now have large datasets containing metallicities and kinematics of stars outside the solar neighborhood. We compare the simulations to the observational data from Gaia EDR3 and LAMOST DR5 and find weak evidence for a slow bar with the "hat" moving group ($250~\text{km/s} \lesssim v_φ\lesssim 270~\text{km/s}$) associated with its outer Lindblad resonance and "Hercules" ($170~\textrm{km/s} \lesssim v_φ\lesssim 195~\text{km/s}$) with corotation. While constraints from current data are limited by their spatial footprint, stars closer in azimuth than the Sun to the bar's minor axis show much stronger signatures of the bar's outer Lindblad and corotation resonances in test particle simulations. Future datasets with greater azimuthal coverage, including the final Gaia data release, will allow reliable chemodynamical identification of bar resonances.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2022; v1 submitted 11 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Identifying resonances of the Galactic bar in Gaia DR2: II. Clues from angle space
Authors:
Wilma H. Trick
Abstract:
The Milky Way disk exhibits intricate orbit substructure of still-debated dynamical origin. The angle variables $(θ_φ,θ_R)$ -- which are conjugates to the actions $(L_z,J_R)$, and describe a star's location along its orbit -- are a powerful diagnostic to identify $l$:$m$ resonances via the orbit shape relation $Δθ_R / Δθ_φ= -m/l$. In the past, angle signatures have been hidden by survey selection…
▽ More
The Milky Way disk exhibits intricate orbit substructure of still-debated dynamical origin. The angle variables $(θ_φ,θ_R)$ -- which are conjugates to the actions $(L_z,J_R)$, and describe a star's location along its orbit -- are a powerful diagnostic to identify $l$:$m$ resonances via the orbit shape relation $Δθ_R / Δθ_φ= -m/l$. In the past, angle signatures have been hidden by survey selection effects (SEs). Using test particle simulations of a barred galaxy, we demonstrate that \emph{Gaia} should allow us to identify the Galactic bar's Outer Lindblad Resonance ($l=+1, m=2$, OLR) in angle space. We investigate strategies to overcome SEs. In the angle data of the \emph{Gaia} DR2 RVS sample, we independently identify four candidates for the OLR and therefore for the pattern speed $Ω_\text{bar}$. The strongest candidate, $Ω_\text{bar}\sim1.4Ω_0$, positions the OLR above the `Sirius' moving group, agrees with measurements from the Galactic center, and might be supported by higher-order resonances around the `Hercules/Horn'. But it misses the classic orbit orientation flip, as discussed in the companion study on actions. The candidate $Ω_\text{bar}\sim1.2Ω_0$ was also suggested by the action-based study, has the OLR at the `Hat', is consistent with \emph{slow bar} models, but still affected by SEs. Weaker candidates are $Ω_\text{bar}=1.6Ω_0$ and $1.74Ω_0$. In addition, we show that the stellar angles do not support the `Hercules/Horn' being created by the OLR of a \emph{fast bar}. We conclude that -- to resolve if `Sirius' or `Hat' is related to the bar's OLR -- more complex dynamical explanations and more extended data with well-behaved SEs are required.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2021; v1 submitted 2 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
From birth associations to field stars: map** the small-scale orbit distribution in the Galactic disc
Authors:
Johanna Coronado,
Hans-Walter Rix,
Wilma H. Trick,
Kareem El-Badry,
Jan Rybizki,
Maosheng Xiang
Abstract:
Stars born at the same time in the same place should have formed from gas of the same element composition. But most stars subsequently disperse from their birth siblings, in orbit and orbital phase, becoming 'field stars'. Here we explore and provide direct observational evidence for this process in the Milky Way disc, by quantifying the probability that orbit-similarity among stars implies indist…
▽ More
Stars born at the same time in the same place should have formed from gas of the same element composition. But most stars subsequently disperse from their birth siblings, in orbit and orbital phase, becoming 'field stars'. Here we explore and provide direct observational evidence for this process in the Milky Way disc, by quantifying the probability that orbit-similarity among stars implies indistinguishable metallicity. We define the orbit similarity among stars through their distance in action-angle space, $Δ(J,θ)$, and their abundance similarity simply by $Δ$[Fe/H]. Analyzing a sample of main sequence stars from Gaia DR2 and LAMOST, we find an excess of pairs with the same metallicity ($Δ\mathrm{[Fe/H]}<0.1$) that extends to remarkably large separations in $Δ(J,θ)$ that correspond to nearly 1 kpc distances. We assess the significance of this effect through a mock sample, drawn from a smooth and phase-mixed orbit distribution. Through grou** such star pairs into associations with a friend-of-friends algorithm linked by $Δ(J,θ)$, we find 100s of mono-abundance groups with $\ge 3$ (to $\gtrsim 20$) members; these groups -- some clusters, some spread across the sky -- are over an order-of-magnitude more abundant than expected for a smooth phase-space distribution, suggesting that we are witnessing the 'dissolution' of stellar birth associations into the field.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2020; v1 submitted 21 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Accreted Globular Clusters in External Galaxies: Why Adaptive Dynamics is not the Solution
Authors:
Sophia Lilleengen,
Wilma H. Trick,
Glenn van de Ven
Abstract:
Many astrophysical and galaxy-scale cosmological problems require a well determined gravitational potential which is often modeled by observers under strong assumptions. Globular clusters (GCs) surrounding galaxies can be used as dynamical tracers of the luminous and dark matter distribution at large (kpc) scales. A natural assumption for modeling the gravitational potential is that GCs accreted i…
▽ More
Many astrophysical and galaxy-scale cosmological problems require a well determined gravitational potential which is often modeled by observers under strong assumptions. Globular clusters (GCs) surrounding galaxies can be used as dynamical tracers of the luminous and dark matter distribution at large (kpc) scales. A natural assumption for modeling the gravitational potential is that GCs accreted in the same dwarf galaxy merger event move at the present time on similar orbits in the host galaxy and should therefore have similar actions. We investigate this idea in one realistic Milky Way like galaxy of the cosmological N-body simulation suite Auriga. We show how the actions of accreted stellar particles in the simulation evolve and that minimizing the standard deviation of GCs in action space, however, cannot constrain the true potential. This approach known as adaptive dynamics does therefore not work for accreted GCs.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The globular cluster system of the Auriga simulations
Authors:
Timo L. R. Halbesma,
Robert J. J. Grand,
Facundo A. Gómez,
Federico Marinacci,
Rüdiger Pakmor,
Wilma H. Trick,
Philipp Busch,
Simon D. M. White
Abstract:
We investigate whether the galaxy and star formation model used for the Auriga simulations can produce a realistic globular cluster (GC) population. We compare statistics of GC candidate star particles in the Auriga haloes with catalogues of the Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31) GC populations. We find that the Auriga simulations do produce sufficient stellar mass for GC candidates at radii and m…
▽ More
We investigate whether the galaxy and star formation model used for the Auriga simulations can produce a realistic globular cluster (GC) population. We compare statistics of GC candidate star particles in the Auriga haloes with catalogues of the Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31) GC populations. We find that the Auriga simulations do produce sufficient stellar mass for GC candidates at radii and metallicities that are typical for the MW GC system (GCS). We also find varying mass-ratios of the simulated GC candidates relative to the observed mass in the MW and M31 GC systems for different bins of galactocentric radius-metallicity (r$_{\text{gal}}$ -[Fe/H]). Overall, the Auriga simulations produce GC candidates with higher metallicities than the MW and M31 GCS and they are found at larger radii than observed. The Auriga simulations would require bound cluster formation efficiencies higher than ten percent for the metal-poor GC candidates, and those within the Solar radius should experience negligible destruction rates to be consistent with observations. GC candidates in the outer halo, on the other hand, should either have low formation efficiencies, or experience high mass loss for the Auriga simulations to produce a GCS that is consistent with that of the MW or M31. Finally, the scatter in the metallicity as well as in the radial distribution between different Auriga runs is considerably smaller than the differences between that of the MW and M31 GCSs. The Auriga model is unlikely to give rise to a GCS that can be consistent with both galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2020; v1 submitted 5 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Identifying resonances of the Galactic bar in Gaia DR2: I. Clues from action space
Authors:
Wilma H. Trick,
Francesca Fragkoudi,
Jason A. S. Hunt,
J. Ted Mackereth,
Simon D. M. White
Abstract:
Action space synthesizes the orbital information of stars and is well-suited to analyse the rich kinematic substructure of the disc in the \emph{Gaia} DR2 radial velocity sample (RVS). We revisit the strong perturbation induced in the Milky Way (MW) disc by an $m=2$ bar, using test particle simulations and the actions $(J_R,L_z,J_z)$ estimated in an axisymmetric potential. These make three useful…
▽ More
Action space synthesizes the orbital information of stars and is well-suited to analyse the rich kinematic substructure of the disc in the \emph{Gaia} DR2 radial velocity sample (RVS). We revisit the strong perturbation induced in the Milky Way (MW) disc by an $m=2$ bar, using test particle simulations and the actions $(J_R,L_z,J_z)$ estimated in an axisymmetric potential. These make three useful diagnostics cleanly visible. (1.) We use the well-known characteristic flip from outward to inward motion at the Outer Lindblad Resonance (OLR, $l=+1,m=2$), which occurs along the axisymmetric resonance line (ARL) in $(L_z,J_R)$, to identify in the \emph{Gaia} action data three candidates for the bar's OLR and pattern speed $Ω_\text{bar}$: $1.85Ω_0$, $1.20Ω_0$, and $1.63Ω_0$ (with $\sim0.1Ω_0$ systematic uncertainty). The \emph{Gaia} data is therefore consistent with both slow and fast bar models in the literature, but disagrees with recent measurements of $\sim1.45Ω_0$. (2.) For the first time, we demonstrate that bar resonances -- especially the OLR -- cause a gradient in vertical action $\langle J_z \rangle$ with $L_z$ around the ARL via "$J_z$-sorting" of stars. This could contribute to the observed coupling of $\langle v_R \rangle$ and $\langle | v_z | \rangle$ in the Galactic disc. (3.) We confirm prior results that the behaviour of resonant orbits is well approximated by scattering and oscillation in $(L_z,J_R)$ along a slope $ΔJ_R/ΔL_z = l/m$ centered on the $l$:$m$ ARL. Overall, we demonstrate that axisymmetrically estimated actions are a powerful diagnostic tool even in non-axisymmetric systems.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2021; v1 submitted 11 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Signatures of resonance and phase mixing in the Galactic disc
Authors:
Jason A. S. Hunt,
Mathew W. Bub,
Jo Bovy,
J. Ted Mackereth,
Wilma H. Trick,
Daisuke Kawata
Abstract:
Gaia DR2 has provided an unprecedented wealth of information about the kinematics of stars in the Solar neighbourhood, and has highlighted the degree of features in the Galactic disc. We confront the data with a range of bar and spiral models in both action-angle space, and the $R_{\mathrm{G}}-v_φ$ plane. We find that the phase mixing induced by transient spiral structure creates ridges and arches…
▽ More
Gaia DR2 has provided an unprecedented wealth of information about the kinematics of stars in the Solar neighbourhood, and has highlighted the degree of features in the Galactic disc. We confront the data with a range of bar and spiral models in both action-angle space, and the $R_{\mathrm{G}}-v_φ$ plane. We find that the phase mixing induced by transient spiral structure creates ridges and arches in the local kinematics which are consistent with the Gaia data. We are able to produce a qualitatively good match to the data when combined with a bar with a variety of pattern speeds, and show that it is non trivial to decouple the effects of the bar and the spiral structure.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Dynamical heating across the Milky Way disc using APOGEE and $\it{Gaia}$
Authors:
J. Ted Mackereth,
Jo Bovy,
Henry W. Leung,
Ricardo P. Schiavon,
Wilma H. Trick,
William J. Chaplin,
Katia Cunha,
Diane K. Feuillet,
Steven R. Majewski,
Marie Martig,
Andrea Miglio,
David Nidever,
Marc H. Pinsonneault,
Victor Silva Aguirre,
Jennifer Sobeck,
Jamie Tayar,
Gail Zasowski
Abstract:
The kinematics of the Milky Way disc as a function of age are well measured at the solar radius, but have not been studied over a wider range of Galactocentric radii. Here, we measure the kinematics of mono-age, mono-$\mathrm{[Fe/H]}$ populations in the low and high $\mathrm{[α/Fe]}$ discs between $4 \lesssim R \lesssim 13$ kpc and $|z| \lesssim 2$ kpc using 65,719 stars in common between APOGEE D…
▽ More
The kinematics of the Milky Way disc as a function of age are well measured at the solar radius, but have not been studied over a wider range of Galactocentric radii. Here, we measure the kinematics of mono-age, mono-$\mathrm{[Fe/H]}$ populations in the low and high $\mathrm{[α/Fe]}$ discs between $4 \lesssim R \lesssim 13$ kpc and $|z| \lesssim 2$ kpc using 65,719 stars in common between APOGEE DR14 and $\it{Gaia}$ DR2 for which we estimate ages using a Bayesian neural network model trained on asteroseismic ages. We determine the vertical and radial velocity dispersions, finding that the low and high $\mathrm{[α/Fe]}$ discs display markedly different age--velocity-dispersion relations (AVRs) and shapes $σ_z/σ_R$. The high $\mathrm{[α/Fe]}$ disc has roughly flat AVRs and constant $σ_z/σ_R = 0.64\pm 0.04$, whereas the low $\mathrm{[α/Fe]}$ disc has large variations in this ratio which positively correlate with the mean orbital radius of the population at fixed age. The high $\mathrm{[α/Fe]}$ disc component's flat AVRs and constant $σ_z/σ_R$ clearly indicates an entirely different heating history. Outer disc populations also have flatter radial AVRs than those in the inner disc, likely due to the waning effect of spiral arms. Our detailed measurements of AVRs and $σ_z/σ_R$ across the disc indicate that low $\mathrm{[α/Fe]}$, inner disc ($R \lesssim 10\,\mathrm{kpc}$) stellar populations are likely dynamically heated by both giant molecular clouds and spiral arms, while the observed trends for outer disc populations require a significant contribution from another heating mechanism such as satellite perturbations. We also find that outer disc populations have slightly positive mean vertical and radial velocities, likely because they are part of the warped disc.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2019; v1 submitted 14 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
The Galactic Disc in Action Space as seen by Gaia DR2
Authors:
Wilma H. Trick,
Johanna Coronado,
Hans-Walter Rix
Abstract:
The quality and quantity of 6D stellar position-velocity measurements in the second Gaia data release (DR2) allows to study small-scale structure in the orbit distribution of the Galactic disc beyond the immediate Solar neighborhood. We investigate the distribution of orbital actions $(J_R,J_φ=L_z,J_z)$ of $\sim 3.5$ million stars within $1.5~\text{kpc}$ of the Sun, for which precise actions can b…
▽ More
The quality and quantity of 6D stellar position-velocity measurements in the second Gaia data release (DR2) allows to study small-scale structure in the orbit distribution of the Galactic disc beyond the immediate Solar neighborhood. We investigate the distribution of orbital actions $(J_R,J_φ=L_z,J_z)$ of $\sim 3.5$ million stars within $1.5~\text{kpc}$ of the Sun, for which precise actions can be calculated from Gaia DR2 alone. This distribution $n(J_R,L_z)$ reveals a remarkable amount of sub-structure. The known moving groups in the $(U,V)$-plane of the Solar neighborhood correspond to overdensities in $(J_R,L_z)$, as expected. But $n(J_R,L_z)$ also exhibits a wealth of density clumps and ridges that extend towards higher $J_R$. These $n(J_R,L_z)$ features are most prominent among orbits that stay close to the Galactic plane and remain consistently visible out to $\sim1.5~\text{kpc}$, as opposed to the sub-structure in velocity space. Some of these $n(J_R,L_z)$ ridges resemble features expected from rapid orbit diffusion along particular ($J_R,L_z$)-directions in the presence of various resonances. Several of these $n(J_R,L_z)$ structures show a dramatic imbalance of stars moving in or out, suggesting that stars are not phase-mixed along orbits or on resonant orbits. Orbital action and angle space of stars in Gaia DR2 is therefore highly structured over kpc-scales, and appears to be very informative for modeling studies of non-axisymmetric structure and resonances in the Galactic disc.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2019; v1 submitted 9 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Unbiased TGAS$\times$LAMOST distances and the role of binarity
Authors:
Johanna Coronado,
Hans-Walter Rix,
Wilma H. Trick
Abstract:
Spectrophotometric distances to stars observed by large spectroscopic surveys offer a crucial complement to parallax distances that remain very important also after the future Gaia data releases. Here we present a probabilistic approach to modeling spectroscopic information for a subset of 4,000 main sequence stars with good parallaxes ($σ_\varpi/\varpi<0.1$) from the LAMOST $\times$ TGAS…
▽ More
Spectrophotometric distances to stars observed by large spectroscopic surveys offer a crucial complement to parallax distances that remain very important also after the future Gaia data releases. Here we present a probabilistic approach to modeling spectroscopic information for a subset of 4,000 main sequence stars with good parallaxes ($σ_\varpi/\varpi<0.1$) from the LAMOST $\times$ TGAS $\times$ 2MASS cross-match, yielding a precise spectroscopic distance estimator with uncertainties of $\sim$6% for single stars. Unlike previous approaches to this problem, we explicitly account for the individual parallax uncertainties in the model building and fully incorporate the fraction of near-equal binaries of main sequence stars, which would lead to biased distance estimates if neglected. Using this model, we estimate the distance for all (150,000) main sequence stars from LAMOST Data Release 5, without parallax information. As an application, we compute their orbital actions, where our more precise distances result in 5 times smaller action uncertainties. This illustrates how future studies of the Milky Way's orbital structure can benefit from using our model. For the fainter and more distant stars of most current spectroscopic surveys, an approach such as the one presented in this work will deliver better distances than Gaia Data Release 2.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2018; v1 submitted 20 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Confirming chemical clocks: asteroseismic age dissection of the Milky Way disk(s)
Authors:
V. Silva Aguirre,
M. Bojsen-Hansen,
D. Slumstrup,
L. Casagrande,
D. Kawata,
I. Ciuca,
R. Handberg,
M. N. Lund,
J. R. Mosumgaard,
D. Huber,
J. A. Johnson,
M. H. Pinsonneault,
A. M. Serenelli,
D. Stello,
J. Tayar,
J. C. Bird,
S. Cassisi,
M. Hon,
M. Martig,
P. E. Nissen,
H. W. Rix,
R. Schönrich,
C. Sahlholdt,
W. H. Trick,
J. Yu
Abstract:
Investigations of the origin and evolution of the Milky Way disk have long relied on chemical and kinematic identification of its components to reconstruct our Galactic past. Difficulties in determining precise stellar ages have restricted most studies to small samples, normally confined to the solar neighbourhood. Here we break this impasse with the help of asteroseismic inference and perform a c…
▽ More
Investigations of the origin and evolution of the Milky Way disk have long relied on chemical and kinematic identification of its components to reconstruct our Galactic past. Difficulties in determining precise stellar ages have restricted most studies to small samples, normally confined to the solar neighbourhood. Here we break this impasse with the help of asteroseismic inference and perform a chronology of the evolution of the disk throughout the age of the Galaxy. We chemically dissect the Milky Way disk population using a sample of red giant stars spanning out to 2~kpc in the solar annulus observed by the {\it Kepler} satellite, with the added dimension of asteroseismic ages. Our results reveal a clear difference in age between the low- and high-$α$ populations, which also show distinct velocity dispersions in the $V$ and $W$ components. We find no tight correlation between age and metallicity nor [$α$/Fe] for the high-$α$ disk stars. Our results indicate that this component formed over a period of more than 2~Gyr with a wide range of [M/H] and [$α$/Fe] independent of time. Our findings show that the kinematic properties of young $α$-rich stars are consistent with the rest of the high-$α$ population and different from the low-$α$ stars of similar age, rendering support to their origin being old stars that went through a mass transfer or stellar merger event, making them appear younger, instead of migration of truly young stars formed close to the Galactic bar.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2018; v1 submitted 26 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Action-based Dynamical Modeling for the Milky Way Disk: The Influence of Spiral Arms
Authors:
Wilma H. Trick,
Jo Bovy,
Elena D'Onghia,
Hans-Walter Rix
Abstract:
RoadMap** is a dynamical modeling machinery developed to constrain the Milky Way's (MW) gravitational potential by simultaneously fitting an axisymmetric parametrized potential and an action-based orbit distribution function (DF) to discrete 6D phase-space measurements of stars in the Galactic disk. In this work we demonstrate RoadMap**'s robustness in the presence of spiral arms by modeling d…
▽ More
RoadMap** is a dynamical modeling machinery developed to constrain the Milky Way's (MW) gravitational potential by simultaneously fitting an axisymmetric parametrized potential and an action-based orbit distribution function (DF) to discrete 6D phase-space measurements of stars in the Galactic disk. In this work we demonstrate RoadMap**'s robustness in the presence of spiral arms by modeling data drawn from an N-body simulation snapshot of a disk-dominated galaxy of MW mass with strong spiral arms (but no bar), exploring survey volumes with radii 500pc<=r_max<=5kpc. The potential constraints are very robust, even though we use a simple action-based DF, the quasi-isothermal DF (qDF). The best-fit RoadMap** model always recovers the correct gravitational forces where most of the stars that entered the analysis are located, even for small volumes. For data from large survey volumes, RoadMap** finds axisymmetric models that average well over the spiral arms. Unsurprisingly, the models are slightly biased by the excess of stars in the spiral arms. Gravitational potential models derived from survey volumes with at least r_max=3kpc can be reliably extrapolated to larger volumes. However, a large radial survey extent, r_max~5kpc, is needed to correctly recover the halo scale length. In general, the recovery and extrapolability of potentials inferred from data sets which were drawn from inter-arm regions appear to be better than those of data sets drawn from spiral arms. Our analysis implies that building axisymmetric models for the Galaxy with upcoming Gaia data will lead to sensible and robust approximations of the MW's potential.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
A spiral galaxy's mass distribution uncovered through lensing and dynamics
Authors:
Wilma H. Trick,
Glenn van de Ven,
Aaron A. Dutton
Abstract:
We investigate the matter distribution of a spiral galaxy with a counter-rotating stellar core, SDSS J1331+3628 (J1331), independently with gravitational lensing and stellar dynamical modelling. By fitting a gravitational potential model to a quadruplet of lensing images around J1331's bulge, we tightly constrain the mass inside the Einstein radius R_ein = (0.91 +/- 0.02)'' (~= 1.83 +/- 0.04 kpc)…
▽ More
We investigate the matter distribution of a spiral galaxy with a counter-rotating stellar core, SDSS J1331+3628 (J1331), independently with gravitational lensing and stellar dynamical modelling. By fitting a gravitational potential model to a quadruplet of lensing images around J1331's bulge, we tightly constrain the mass inside the Einstein radius R_ein = (0.91 +/- 0.02)'' (~= 1.83 +/- 0.04 kpc) to within 4%: M_ein = (7.8 +/- 0.3) x 10^10 M_Sun. We model observed long-slit major axis stellar kinematics in J1331's central regions by finding Multi-Gaussian Expansion (MGE) models for the stellar and dark matter distribution that solve the axisymmetric Jeans equations. The lens and dynamical model are independently derived, but in very good agreement with each other around ~R_ein. We find that J1331's center requires a steep total mass-to-light ratio gradient. A dynamical model including an NFW halo (with virial velocity v_200 ~= 240 +/- 40 km/s and concentration c_200 ~= 8 +/- 2) and moderate tangential velocity anisotropy (beta_z ~= -0.4 +/- 0.1) can reproduce the signatures of J1331's counter-rotating core and predict the stellar and gas rotation curve at larger radii. However, our models do not agree with the observed velocity dispersion at large radii. We speculate that the reason could be a non-trivial change in structure and kinematics due to a possible merger event in J1331's recent past.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Action-based Dynamical Modelling for the Milky Way Disk
Authors:
Wilma H. Trick,
Jo Bovy,
Hans-Walter Rix
Abstract:
We present RoadMap**, a full-likelihood dynamical modelling machinery that aims to recover the Milky Way's (MW) gravitational potential from large samples of stars in the Galactic disk. RoadMap** models the observed positions and velocities of stars with a parametrized, three-integral distribution function (DF) in a parametrized axisymmetric potential. We investigate through differential test…
▽ More
We present RoadMap**, a full-likelihood dynamical modelling machinery that aims to recover the Milky Way's (MW) gravitational potential from large samples of stars in the Galactic disk. RoadMap** models the observed positions and velocities of stars with a parametrized, three-integral distribution function (DF) in a parametrized axisymmetric potential. We investigate through differential test cases with idealized mock data how the breakdown of model assumptions and data properties affect constraints on the potential and DF. Our key results are: (i) If the MW's true potential is not included in the assumed model potential family, we can - in the axisymmetric case - still find a robust estimate for the potential, with only <~ 10% difference in surface density within |z| <= 1.1 kpc inside the observed volume. (ii) Modest systematic differences between the true and model DF are inconsequential. E.g, when binning stars to define sub-populations with simple DFs, binning errors do not affect the modelling as long as the DF parameters of neighbouring bins differ by < 20%. In addition, RoadMap** ensures unbiased potential estimates for either (iii) small misjudgements of the spatial selection function (i.e., <~ 15% at the survey volume's edge), (iv) if distances are known to within 10%, or (v) if proper motion uncertainties are known within 10% or are smaller than delta mu <~ 1 mas/yr. Challenges are the rapidly increasing computational costs for large sample sizes. Overall, RoadMap** is well suited to making precise new measurements of the MW's potential with data from the upcoming Gaia releases.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
