-
JWST meets Chandra: a large population of Compton thick, feedback-free, and X-ray weak AGN, with a sprinkle of SNe
Authors:
Roberto Maiolino,
Guido Risaliti,
Matilde Signorini,
Bartolomeo Trefoloni,
Ignas Juodzbalis,
Jan Scholtz,
Hannah Uebler,
Francesco D'Eugenio,
Stefano Carniani,
Andy Fabian,
Xihan Ji,
Giovanni Mazzolari,
Elena Bertola,
Marcella Brusa,
Andrew J. Bunker,
Stephane Charlot,
Andrea Comastri,
Giovanni Cresci,
Christa Noel DeCoursey,
Eiichi Egami,
Fabrizio Fiore,
Roberto Gilli,
Michele Perna,
Sandro Tacchella,
Giacomo Venturi
Abstract:
We investigate the X-ray properties of a large sample of 71 broad line and narrow line AGN at 2<z<11 discovered by JWST in the GOODS fields, which have the deepest Chandra observations ever obtained. Despite the widespread presence of AGN signatures in their rest-optical and -UV spectra, the vast majority of them is X-ray undetected. The stacked X-ray data of the non-detected sources also results…
▽ More
We investigate the X-ray properties of a large sample of 71 broad line and narrow line AGN at 2<z<11 discovered by JWST in the GOODS fields, which have the deepest Chandra observations ever obtained. Despite the widespread presence of AGN signatures in their rest-optical and -UV spectra, the vast majority of them is X-ray undetected. The stacked X-ray data of the non-detected sources also results in a non-detection. The upper limit on the X-ray emission for many of these AGN is one or even two orders of magnitude lower than expected from a standard AGN SED. Heavy X-ray absorption by clouds with large (Compton thick) column density and low dust content, such as the Broad Line Region (BLR) clouds, can explain the X-ray weakness. In this scenario the BLR covering factor should be much larger than in low-z AGN or luminous quasar; this is supported by the larger equivalent width of the broad component of Halpha in JWST-selected AGN. We also find that the JWST-discovered AGN lack the prominent, fast outflows characterizing low-z AGN and luminous quasars, suggesting that, in JWST-selected AGN, dense gas lingers in the nuclear region, resulting in large covering factors. We also note that a large fraction of JWST-selected AGN match the definition of NLSy1, typically characterized by a steep X-ray spectrum, and this can further contribute to their observed weakness at high-z. Finally, we discuss that the broad Balmer lines used to identify type 1 AGN cannot be ascribed to Very Massive Stars, Tidal Disruption Events, or Supernovae, although we show that a minority of the faintest broad lines could potentially be associated with the echo of superluminous SNe or TDE. Scenarios in which the broad lines are ascribed to galactic outflows are also untenable. We emphasize that confirming any of the scenarios discussed above will require X-ray missions more sensitive than Chandra. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Quasars as standard candles VI: spectroscopic validation of the cosmological sample
Authors:
Bartolomeo Trefoloni,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Guido Risaliti,
Alessandro Marconi,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Andrea Sacchi,
Matilde Signorini
Abstract:
A sample of quasars has been recently assembled to investigate the non-linear relation between their monochromatic luminosities at 2500Å, and 2 keV and to exploit quasars as a new class of standardized candles. The use of this technique for cosmological purposes relies on the non-evolution with redshift of the UV-optical spectral properties of quasars, as well as on the absence of possible contami…
▽ More
A sample of quasars has been recently assembled to investigate the non-linear relation between their monochromatic luminosities at 2500Å, and 2 keV and to exploit quasars as a new class of standardized candles. The use of this technique for cosmological purposes relies on the non-evolution with redshift of the UV-optical spectral properties of quasars, as well as on the absence of possible contaminants such as dust extinction and host-galaxy contribution. We address these possible issues by analysing the spectral properties of our cosmological quasar sample. We produced composite spectra in different bins of redshift and accretion parameters (black hole mass, bolometric luminosity), to investigate any possible evolution of the spectral properties of the continuum of the composites with these parameters. We found a remarkable similarity amongst the various stacked spectra. The overall shape of the continuum does not show any statistically significant trend with the accretion parameters nor with the redshift. The composite spectrum of our quasar sample is consistent with negligible levels of both intrinsic reddening (with a colour excess E(B-V)< 0.01) and host-galaxy emission (less than 10%) in the optical. We tested whether unaccounted dust extinction could explain the discrepancy between our cosmographic fit of the Hubble-Lemaitre diagram and the concordance ΛCDM model. The average colour excess required to solve the tension should increase with redshift up to unphysically high values (E(B-V)=0.1 at z>3) that would imply that the intrinsic emission of quasars is much bluer and more luminous than ever reported in observed spectra. The similarity of quasar spectra across the parameter space excludes a significant evolution of the average continuum properties with any of the explored parameters, confirming the reliability of our sample for cosmological applications.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Quasars as Standard Candles V. Evaluation of a $\leq$ 0.06 dex intrinsic dispersion in the LX-LUV relation
Authors:
Matilde Signorini,
Guido Risaliti,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Andrea Sacchi,
Bartolomeo Trefoloni
Abstract:
A characteristic feature of quasars is the observed non-linear relationship between their monochromatic luminosities at rest-frame 2500 Å and 2 keV. This relationship is evident across all redshifts and luminosities and, due to its non-linearity, can be implemented to estimate quasar distances and construct a Hubble Diagram for quasars. Historically, a significant challenge in the cosmological app…
▽ More
A characteristic feature of quasars is the observed non-linear relationship between their monochromatic luminosities at rest-frame 2500 Å and 2 keV. This relationship is evident across all redshifts and luminosities and, due to its non-linearity, can be implemented to estimate quasar distances and construct a Hubble Diagram for quasars. Historically, a significant challenge in the cosmological application of this relation has been its high observed dispersion. Recent studies have demonstrated that this dispersion can be reduced by excluding biased objects from the sample. Nevertheless, the dispersion remains considerable ($δ\sim 0.20$ dex), especially when compared to the Phillips relation for supernovae Ia. Given the absence of a comprehensive physical model for the relation, it remains unclear how much of the remaining dispersion is intrinsically tied to the relation itself and how much can be attributed to observational factors not addressed by the sample selection and by the choice of X-ray and UV indicators. Potential contributing factors include (i) the scatter produced by using X-ray photometric results instead of spectroscopic ones, (ii) the intrinsic variability of quasars, and (iii) the inclination of the accretion disc relative to our line of sight. In this study, we thoroughly examine these three factors and quantify their individual contributions to the observed dispersion. Based on our findings, we argue that the intrinsic dispersion of the X-ray/UV luminosity relation is likely below 0.06 dex. We also discuss why high-redshift subsamples can show a significantly lower dispersion than the average one.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Searching for outflows in X-ray weak quasars
Authors:
Bartolomeo Trefoloni
Abstract:
The connection between X-ray weakness and powerful X-ray outflows is both expected in a scenario where outflows are connected with radiation-driven winds, and observed in several sources, both in the local Universe and at high redshift. Here I present the first results of a new study of this possible connection based on a search for SDSS quasars with weak X-ray emission in serendipitous XMM-Newton…
▽ More
The connection between X-ray weakness and powerful X-ray outflows is both expected in a scenario where outflows are connected with radiation-driven winds, and observed in several sources, both in the local Universe and at high redshift. Here I present the first results of a new study of this possible connection based on a search for SDSS quasars with weak X-ray emission in serendipitous XMM-Newton observations. The selected objects have a "normal" optical/UV blue continuum, but a flat and extraordinarily weak X-ray spectrum. The availability of rest-frame optical/UV spectra allows to check for the signature of outflows in the absorption lines and/or in the profiles of the emission lines. This method could reveal the presence of a population of so-far overlooked outflowing quasars and confirm the connection between winds and X-ray weakness in quasars.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Quasars as Standard Candles IV. Analysis of the X-ray and UV indicators of the disc-corona relation
Authors:
Matilde Signorini,
Guido Risaliti,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Andrea Sacchi,
Bartolomeo Trefoloni
Abstract:
Context: A non-linear relation between quasar monochromatic luminosities at 2500A and 2 keV holds at all observed redshifts and luminosities, and it has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble Diagram of quasars. The choice of the X-ray and UV indicators has so far been somewhat arbitrary, and has typically relied on photometric data. Aims: We want to determine the X-ray and UV…
▽ More
Context: A non-linear relation between quasar monochromatic luminosities at 2500A and 2 keV holds at all observed redshifts and luminosities, and it has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble Diagram of quasars. The choice of the X-ray and UV indicators has so far been somewhat arbitrary, and has typically relied on photometric data. Aims: We want to determine the X-ray and UV proxies that provide the smallest dispersion of the relation, in order to obtain more precise distance estimates, and to confirm the reliability of the X-ray to UV relation as a distance indicator. Methods: We performed a complete UV spectroscopic analysis of a sample of $\sim$1800 quasars with SDSS optical spectra and XMM- Newton X-ray serendipitous observations. In the X-rays, we analysed the spectra of all the sample objects at redshift z $>$1.9, while we relied on photometric measurements at lower redshifts. As done in previous studies, we analysed the relation in small redshift bins, using fluxes instead of luminosities. Results: We show that the monochromatic fluxes at 1 keV and 2500A are, respectively, the best X-ray and UV continuum indicators among those that are typically available. We also find a tight relation between soft X-ray and Mg ii2800A line fluxes, and a marginal dependence of the X-ray to UV relation on the width of the Mg ii line. Conclusions: Our analysis suggests that the physical quantities that are more tightly linked to one another are the soft X-ray flux at $\sim$1 keV and the ionizing UV flux blueward of the Lyman limit. However, the "usual" monochromatic fluxes at 2 keV and 2500A estimated from photometric data provide an almost as-tight X-ray to UV relation, and can be used to derive quasar distances. The Hubble diagram obtained using spectroscopic indicators is fully consistent with the one presented in previous papers, based on photometric data.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The most luminous blue quasars at 3.0<z<3.3 -- III. LBT spectra and accretion parameters
Authors:
Bartolomeo Trefoloni,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Guido Risaliti,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Susanna Bisogni,
Francesca M. Civano,
Martin Elvis,
Giuseppina Fabbiano,
Roberto Gilli,
Alessandro Marconi,
Gordon T. Richards,
Andrea Sacchi,
Francesco Salvestrini,
Matilde Signorini,
Cristian Vignali
Abstract:
We present the analysis of the rest frame ultraviolet and optical spectra of 30 bright blue quasars at $z\sim3$, selected to examine the suitability of AGN as cosmological probes. In our previous works, we found an unexpectedly high fraction ($\approx 25 \%$) of X-ray weak quasars in the sample. The latter sources also display a flatter UV continuum and a broader and fainter CIV profile in the arc…
▽ More
We present the analysis of the rest frame ultraviolet and optical spectra of 30 bright blue quasars at $z\sim3$, selected to examine the suitability of AGN as cosmological probes. In our previous works, we found an unexpectedly high fraction ($\approx 25 \%$) of X-ray weak quasars in the sample. The latter sources also display a flatter UV continuum and a broader and fainter CIV profile in the archival UV data with respect to their X-ray normal counterparts. Here we present new observations with the LBT in both the $zJ$ (rest-frame $\simeq$2300-3100 $\rm \mathring{A}$) and the $K_S$ ($\simeq$4750-5350 $\rm \mathring{A}$) bands. We estimated black hole masses ($M_{\rm BH}$) and Eddington ratios ($λ_{\rm Edd}$) from the from the H$β$ and MgII emission lines, finding that our $z\sim3$ quasars are on average highly accreting ($\langle λ_{\rm Edd} \rangle\simeq 1.2$ and $\langle M_{\rm BH} \rangle\simeq 10^{9.7}M_\odot$), with no difference in $λ_{\rm Edd}$ or $M_{\rm BH}$ between X-ray weak and X-ray normal quasars. From the $zJ$ spectra, we derive flux and equivalent width of MgII and FeII, finding that X-ray weak quasars display higher FeII/MgII ratios with respect to typical quasars. FeII/MgII ratios of X-ray normal quasars are instead consistent with other estimates up to $z\simeq6.5$, corroborating the idea of already chemically mature BLRs at early cosmic time. From the $K_S$ spectra, we find that all the X-ray weak quasars present generally weaker [OIII] emission (EW<10 $\rm \mathring{A}$) than the normal ones. The sample as a whole, however, abides by the known X-ray/[OIII] luminosity correlation, hence the different [OIII] properties are likely due to an intrinsically weaker [OIII] emission in X-ray weak objects, associated to the shape of the spectral energy distribution. We interpret these results in the framework of accretion-disc winds.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Quasars as high-redshift standard candles
Authors:
Guido Risaliti,
Elisabeta Lusso,
Emanuele Nardini,
Giada Bargiacchi,
Susanna Bisogni,
Andrea Sacchi,
Matilde Signorini,
Bartolomeo Trefoloni
Abstract:
In the past few years, we built a Hubble diagram of quasars up to redshift z$\sim$7, based on the nonlinear relation between quasars' x-ray and UV luminosities. Such a Hubble diagram shows a >4$σ$ deviation from the standard flat $Λ$CDM model at z>1.5. Given the important consequences of this result, it is fundamental to rule out any systematic effect in the selection of the sample and/or in the f…
▽ More
In the past few years, we built a Hubble diagram of quasars up to redshift z$\sim$7, based on the nonlinear relation between quasars' x-ray and UV luminosities. Such a Hubble diagram shows a >4$σ$ deviation from the standard flat $Λ$CDM model at z>1.5. Given the important consequences of this result, it is fundamental to rule out any systematic effect in the selection of the sample and/or in the flux measurements, and to investigate possible redshift dependences of the relation, that would invalidate the use of quasars as standard candles. Here we review all the observational results supporting our method: the match of the Hubble diagram of quasars with that of supernovae in the common redshift range, the constant slope of the relation at all redshifts, the redshift non-evolution of the spectral properties of our sources both in the x-rays and in the UV. An independent test of our results requires the observation of other standard candles at high redshift. In particular, we expect that future observations of supernovas at z>2 will confirm the deviation from the concordance model found with the Hubble diagram of quasars.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Quasars as high-redshift standard candles
Authors:
A. Sacchi,
G. Risaliti,
M. Signorini,
E. Lusso,
E. Nardini,
G. Bargiacchi,
S. Bisogni,
F. Civano,
M. Elvis,
G. Fabbiano,
R. Gilli,
B. Trefoloni,
C. Vignali
Abstract:
The non-linear relation between the X-ray and ultraviolet (UV) luminosity in quasars has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble diagram at redshifts up to $z\sim$ 7. This cosmological application is based on the assumption of independence of the relation on redshift and luminosity. We want to test the reliability of this hypothesis by studying the spectroscopic properties of hi…
▽ More
The non-linear relation between the X-ray and ultraviolet (UV) luminosity in quasars has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble diagram at redshifts up to $z\sim$ 7. This cosmological application is based on the assumption of independence of the relation on redshift and luminosity. We want to test the reliability of this hypothesis by studying the spectroscopic properties of high-redshift quasars in the X-ray and UV bands. We performed a one-by-one analysis of a sample of 130 quasars at $z>$ 2.5 with high-quality X-ray and UV spectroscopic observations. We found that not only the X-ray to UV correlation still holds at these redshifts, but its intrinsic dispersion is as low as 0.12 dex (previous works reached 0.20$-$0.22 dex). For a sample of quasars at $z\sim$ 3 with particularly high-quality observations the dispersion further drops to 0.09 dex, a value entirely accountable for by intrinsic variability and source geometry effects. The composite spectra of these quasars, in both the X-rays and the UV, do not show any difference with respect to the average spectra of quasars at lower redshifts. The absence of any spectral difference between high- and low-$z$ quasars and the tightness of the X-ray to UV relation suggests that no evolutionary effects are present in the relation. Therefore, it can be safely employed to derive quasar distances. Under this assumption, we obtain a measurement of the luminosity distance at $z\sim$ 3 with 15 % uncertainty, and in a 4$σ$ tension with the concordance model.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
