Showing 1–50 of 67 results for author: Tobias, S

Run-away transition to turbulent strong-field dynamo

Authors: Anna Guseva, Ludovic Petitdemange, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Planets and stars are able to generate coherent large-scale magnetic fields by helical convective motions in their interiors. This process, known as hydromagnetic dynamo, involves nonlinear interaction between the flow and magnetic field. Nonlinearity facilitates existence of bi-stable dynamo branches: a weak field branch where the magnetic field is not strong enough to enter into the leading orde… ▽ More Planets and stars are able to generate coherent large-scale magnetic fields by helical convective motions in their interiors. This process, known as hydromagnetic dynamo, involves nonlinear interaction between the flow and magnetic field. Nonlinearity facilitates existence of bi-stable dynamo branches: a weak field branch where the magnetic field is not strong enough to enter into the leading order force balance in the momentum equation at large flow scales, and a strong field branch where the field enters into this balance. The transition between the two with enhancement of convection can be either subcritical or supercritical, depending on the strength of magnetic induction. In both cases, it is accompanied by topological changes in velocity field across the system; however, it is yet unclear how these changes are produced. In this work, we analyse transitions between the weak and strong dynamo regimes using a data-driven approach, separating different physical effects induced by dynamically active flow scales. Using Dynamic Mode Decomposition, we decompose the dynamo data from direct numerical simulations into different components (modes), identify the ones relevant for transition, and estimate relative magnitudes of their contributions Lorentz force and induction term. Our results suggest that subcritical transition to a strong dynamo is facilitated by a subharmonic instability, allowing for a more efficient mode of convection, and provide a modal basis for reduced-order models of this transition. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Ordering of timescales predicts applicability of quasi-linear theory in unstable flows

Authors: Curtis J. Saxton, Brad Marston, Jeffrey S. Oishi, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: We discuss the applicability of quasilinear-type approximations for a turbulent system with a large range of spatial and temporal scales. We consider a paradigm fluid system of rotating convection with a vertical and horizontal temperature gradients. In particular, the interaction of rotating with the horizontal temperature gradient drives a ``thermal wind'' shear flow whose strength is controlled… ▽ More We discuss the applicability of quasilinear-type approximations for a turbulent system with a large range of spatial and temporal scales. We consider a paradigm fluid system of rotating convection with a vertical and horizontal temperature gradients. In particular, the interaction of rotating with the horizontal temperature gradient drives a ``thermal wind'' shear flow whose strength is controlled by a horizontal temperature gradient. Varying the parameters systematically alters the ordering of the shearing timescale, the convective timescale, and the correlation timescale. We demonstrate that quasilinear-type approximations work well when the shearing timescale or the correlation timescale is sufficiently short. In all cases, the Generalised Quasilinear approximation (GQL) systematically outperforms the Quasilinear approximation (QL). We discuss the consequences for statistical theories of turbulence interacting with mean gradients. We conclude with comments about the general applicability of these ideas across a wide variety of non-linear physical systems. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures

Linear and nonlinear properties of the Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke instability in stellar interiors with arbitrary local radial and latitudinal differential rotation

Authors: Robert W. Dymott, Adrian J. Barker, Chris A. Jones, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: We investigate the linear and nonlinear properties of the Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability in stellar radiative zones with arbitrary local (radial and latitudinal) differential rotation. This instability may lead to turbulence that contributes to redistribution of angular momentum and chemical composition in stars. In our local Boussinesq model, we investigate varying the orientation of… ▽ More We investigate the linear and nonlinear properties of the Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability in stellar radiative zones with arbitrary local (radial and latitudinal) differential rotation. This instability may lead to turbulence that contributes to redistribution of angular momentum and chemical composition in stars. In our local Boussinesq model, we investigate varying the orientation of the shear with respect to the 'effective gravity', which we describe using the angle $φ$. We first perform an axisymmetric linear analysis to explore the effects of varying $φ$ on the local stability of arbitrary differential rotations. We then explore the nonlinear hydrodynamical evolution in three dimensions using a modified shearing box. The model exhibits both the diffusive GSF instability, and a non-diffusive instability that occurs when the Solberg-H\{o}iland criteria are violated. We observe the nonlinear development of strong zonal jets ("layering" in the angular momentum) with a preferred orientation in both cases, which can considerably enhance turbulent transport. By varying $φ$ we find the instability with mixed radial and latitudinal shears transports angular momentum more efficiently (particularly if adiabatically unstable) than cases with purely radial shear $(φ= 0)$. By exploring the dependence on box size, we find the transport properties of the GSF instability to be largely insensitive to this, implying we can meaningfully extrapolate our results to stars. However, there is no preferred length-scale for adiabatic instability, which therefore exhibits strong box-size dependence. These instabilities may contribute to the missing angular momentum transport required in red giant and subgiant stars and drive turbulence in the solar tachocline. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 26 pages, 17 figures, 4 tables, accepted for publication in MNRAS (28th June 2023)

Jupiter's cloud-level variability triggered by torsional oscillations in the interior

Authors: Kumiko Hori, Chris A. Jones, Arrate Antuñano, Leigh N. Fletcher, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Jupiter's weather layer exhibits long-term and quasi-periodic cycles of meteorological activity that can completely change the appearance of its belts and zones. There are cycles with intervals from 4 to 9 years, dependent on the latitude, which were detected in 5$μ$m radiation, which provides a window into the cloud-forming regions of the troposphere; however, the origin of these cycles has been… ▽ More Jupiter's weather layer exhibits long-term and quasi-periodic cycles of meteorological activity that can completely change the appearance of its belts and zones. There are cycles with intervals from 4 to 9 years, dependent on the latitude, which were detected in 5$μ$m radiation, which provides a window into the cloud-forming regions of the troposphere; however, the origin of these cycles has been a mystery. Here we propose that magnetic torsional oscillations/waves arising from the dynamo region could modulate the heat transport and hence be ultimately responsible for the variability of the tropospheric banding. These axisymmetric waves are magnetohydrodynamic waves influenced by the rapid rotation, which have been detected in Earth's core, and have been recently suggested to exist in Jupiter by the observation of magnetic secular variations by Juno. Using the magnetic field model JRM33, together with the density distribution model, we compute the expected speed of these waves. For the waves excited by variations in the zonal jet flows, their wavelength can be estimated from the width of the alternating jets, yielding waves with a half period of 3.2-4.7 years in 14-23$^\circ$N, consistent with the intervals with the cycles of variability of Jupiter's North Equatorial Belt and North Temperate Belt identified in the visible and infrared observations. The nature of these waves, including the wave speed and the wavelength, is revealed by a data-driven technique, dynamic mode decomposition, applied to the spatio-temporal data for 5$μ$m emission. Our results imply that exploration of these magnetohydrodynamic waves may provide a new window to the origins of quasi-periodic patterns in Jupiter's tropospheric clouds and to the internal dynamics and the dynamo of Jupiter. △ Less

Submitted 19 May, 2023; v1 submitted 10 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Journal ref: Nature Astronomy, 2023

Direct Statistical Simulation Using Generalised Cumulant Expansions

Authors: G. V. Nivarti, J. B. Marston, S. M. Tobias

Abstract: In recent years, the Generalised Quasilinear (GQL) approximation has been developed and its efficacy tested against purely quasilinear (QL) approximations. GQL systematically interpolates between QL and fully non-linear dynamics by employing a generalised Reynolds decomposition. Here, we examine an exact statistical closure for the GQL equations on the doubly periodic $β$-plane. Closure is achieve… ▽ More In recent years, the Generalised Quasilinear (GQL) approximation has been developed and its efficacy tested against purely quasilinear (QL) approximations. GQL systematically interpolates between QL and fully non-linear dynamics by employing a generalised Reynolds decomposition. Here, we examine an exact statistical closure for the GQL equations on the doubly periodic $β$-plane. Closure is achieved at second order using a generalised cumulant approach which we term GCE2. GCE2 is shown to yield improved performance over statistical representations of purely QL dynamics (CE2) and thus enables Direct Statistical Simulation (DSS) of complex mean flows that do not entirely fall within the remit of pure QL theory. Despite the existence of an exact closure, GCE2 like CE2 admits the possibility of a rank instability that leads to differences with statistics obtained from GQL. Recognition of this instability is a necessary step before further progress can be made with the GCE2 statistical closure. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2024; v1 submitted 13 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 19 pages, 10 figures. Version to appear in JFM

Direct statistical simulation of Lorenz96 system in model reduction approaches

Authors: Kuan Li, J. B. Marston, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Direct statistical simulation (DSS) of nonlinear dynamical systems bypasses the traditional route of accumulating statistics by lengthy direct numerical simulations (DNS) by solving the equations that govern the statistics themselves. DSS suffers, however, from the curse of dimensionality as the statistics (such as correlations) generally have higher dimension than the underlying dynamical variabl… ▽ More Direct statistical simulation (DSS) of nonlinear dynamical systems bypasses the traditional route of accumulating statistics by lengthy direct numerical simulations (DNS) by solving the equations that govern the statistics themselves. DSS suffers, however, from the curse of dimensionality as the statistics (such as correlations) generally have higher dimension than the underlying dynamical variables. Here we investigate two approaches to reduce the dimensionality of DSS, illustrating each method with numerical experiments with the Lorenz-96 dynamical system. The forms of DSS chosen here involve approximate closures at second and third order in the equal time cumulants. We demonstrate significant reduction in computational effort that can be achieved without sacrificing the accuracy of DSS. The methods developed here can be applied to turbulent fluid and magnetohydrodynamical systems. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 16 pages, 13 figures and 6 tables

Transition to chaos and modal structure of magnetized Taylor-Couette flow

Authors: Anna Guseva, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Taylor-Couette flow is often used as a simplified model for complex rotating flows in the interior of stars and accretion disks. The flow dynamics in these objects is influenced by magnetic fields. For example, quasi-Keplerian flows in Taylor-Couette geometry become unstable to a travelling or standing wave in an external magnetic field if the fluid is conducting; there is an instability even when… ▽ More Taylor-Couette flow is often used as a simplified model for complex rotating flows in the interior of stars and accretion disks. The flow dynamics in these objects is influenced by magnetic fields. For example, quasi-Keplerian flows in Taylor-Couette geometry become unstable to a travelling or standing wave in an external magnetic field if the fluid is conducting; there is an instability even when the flow is hydrodynamically stable. This magnetorotational instability leads to the development of chaotic states and, eventually, turbulence, when the cylinder rotation is sufficiently fast. The transition to turbulence in this flow can be complex, with the coexistence of parameter regions with spatio-temporal chaos and regions with quasi-periodic behaviour, involving one or two additional modulating frequencies. Although the unstable modes of a periodic flow can be identified with Floquet analysis, here we adopt a more flexible equation-free data-driven approach. We analyse the data from the transition to chaos in the magnetized Taylor-Couette flow and identify the flow structures related to the modulating frequencies with Dynamic Mode Decomposition; this method is based on approximating nonlinear dynamics with a linear infinite-dimensional Koopman operator. With the use of these structures, one can construct a nonlinear reduced model for the transition. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Waves in planetary dynamos

Authors: K. Hori, A. Nilsson, S. M. Tobias

Abstract: This Special Topic focuses on magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) processes in deep interiors of planets, in which their fluid dynamos are in operation. The dynamo-generated, global, magnetic fields provide a background for our solar-terrestrial environment. Probing the processes within the dynamos is a significant theoretical and computational challenge and any window into interior dynamics greatly increas… ▽ More This Special Topic focuses on magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) processes in deep interiors of planets, in which their fluid dynamos are in operation. The dynamo-generated, global, magnetic fields provide a background for our solar-terrestrial environment. Probing the processes within the dynamos is a significant theoretical and computational challenge and any window into interior dynamics greatly increases our understanding. Such a window is provided by exploring rapid dynamics, particularly MHD waves about the dynamo-defined basic state. This field is the subject of current attention as geophysical observations and numerical modellings advance. We give here particular attention to torsional Alfvén waves/oscillations and magnetic Rossby waves, which may be regarded as typical axisymmetric and nonaxisymmetric modes, respectively, amongst a wide variety of wave classes of the rapidly-rotating MHD fluids. The excitation of those waves is being evidenced for the geodynamo, whilst also being suggested for Jupiter. We shall overview their dynamics, summarise our current understanding, and give open questions for future perspectives. △ Less

Submitted 9 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 26 pages, 12 figures, accepted for publication in Reviews of Modern Plasma Physics

Magnetoclinicity Instability

Authors: Nobumitsu Yokoi, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: In strongly compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence, obliqueness between the large-scale density gradient and magnetic field gives an electromotive force mediated by density variance (intensity of density fluctuation). This effect is named ``magnetoclinicity'', and is expected to play an important role in large-scale magnetic-field generation in astrophysical compressible turbulent flows. Anal… ▽ More In strongly compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence, obliqueness between the large-scale density gradient and magnetic field gives an electromotive force mediated by density variance (intensity of density fluctuation). This effect is named ``magnetoclinicity'', and is expected to play an important role in large-scale magnetic-field generation in astrophysical compressible turbulent flows. Analysis of large-scale instability due to the magnetoclinicity effect shows that the mean magnetic-field perturbation is destabilised at large scales in the vicinity of strong mean density gradient in the presence of density variance. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures, iTi (interdisciplinary Turbulence initiative) 2021

Journal ref: R. Örlü et al. (eds.), Progress in Turbulence IX (2021), Springer Proceedings in Physics 267

Recent Developments in Theories of Inhomogeneous and Anisotropic Turbulence

Authors: J. B. Marston, S. M. Tobias

Abstract: Understanding inhomogeneous and anisotropic fluid flows require mathematical and computational tools that are tailored to such flows and distinct from methods used to understand the canonical problem of homogeneous and isotropic turbulence. We review some recent developments in the theory of inhomogeneous and anisotropic turbulence, placing special emphasis on several kinds of quasilinear approxim… ▽ More Understanding inhomogeneous and anisotropic fluid flows require mathematical and computational tools that are tailored to such flows and distinct from methods used to understand the canonical problem of homogeneous and isotropic turbulence. We review some recent developments in the theory of inhomogeneous and anisotropic turbulence, placing special emphasis on several kinds of quasilinear approximations and their corresponding statistical formulations. Aspects of quasilinear theory that have received insufficient attention in the literature are discussed, and open questions are framed. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2022; v1 submitted 11 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: Some added material and references and corrected typos. To appear in Annual Reviews of Fluid Mechanics. 29 pages, 7 figures. When citing this paper, please use the following: J. B. Marston and S. M. Tobias. 2022. "Recent Developments in Theories of Inhomogeneous and Anisotropic Turbulence," Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. Vol. 55. Accepted. http://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-fluid-120720-031006

Journal ref: Annual Reviews of Fluid Mechanics 55, 351 -- 375 (2023)

Direct Statistical Simulation of the Busse Annulus

Authors: Jeffrey S. Oishi, Keaton J. Burns, J. B. Marston, S. M. Tobias

Abstract: We consider direct statistical simulation (DSS) of a paradigm system of convection interacting with mean flows. In the Busse Annulus model zonal jets are generated through the interaction of convectively driven turbulence and rotation; non-trivial dynamics including the emergence of multiple jets and bursting `predator-prey' type dynamics can be found. We formulate the DSS by expanding around the… ▽ More We consider direct statistical simulation (DSS) of a paradigm system of convection interacting with mean flows. In the Busse Annulus model zonal jets are generated through the interaction of convectively driven turbulence and rotation; non-trivial dynamics including the emergence of multiple jets and bursting `predator-prey' type dynamics can be found. We formulate the DSS by expanding around the mean flow in terms of equal-time cumulants and arrive at a closed set of equations of motion for the cumulants. Here, we present results using an expansion terminated at the second cumulant (CE2); it is fundamentally a quasi-linear theory. We focus on particular cases including bursting and bistable multiple jets and demonstrate that CE2 can reproduce the results of direct numerical simulation if particular attention is given to symmetry considerations. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 11 pages, 6 figures

Non-equivalence of quasilinear dynamical systems and their statistical closures

Authors: G. V. Nivarti, R. R. Kerswell, J. B. Marston, S. M. Tobias

Abstract: It is widely believed that statistical closure theories for dynamical systems provide statistics equivalent to those of the governing dynamical equations from which the former are derived. Here, we demonstrate counterexamples in the context of the widely used mean-field quasilinear (QL) approximation applied to 2D fluid dynamical systems. We compare statistics of QL numerical simulations with thos… ▽ More It is widely believed that statistical closure theories for dynamical systems provide statistics equivalent to those of the governing dynamical equations from which the former are derived. Here, we demonstrate counterexamples in the context of the widely used mean-field quasilinear (QL) approximation applied to 2D fluid dynamical systems. We compare statistics of QL numerical simulations with those obtained by direct statistical simulation via a cumulant expansion closed at second order (CE2). We observe that, though CE2 is an exact statistical closure for QL dynamics, its predictions disagree with the statistics of the QL solution for identical parameter values. These disagreements are attributed to instabilities, which we term rank instabilities, of the second cumulant dynamics within CE2 that are unavailable in the QL equations. △ Less

Submitted 18 May, 2024; v1 submitted 8 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 12 pages, 6 figures

Can neural networks predict dynamics they have never seen?

Authors: Anton Pershin, Cedric Beaume, Kuan Li, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Neural networks have proven to be remarkably successful for a wide range of complicated tasks, from image recognition and object detection to speech recognition and machine translation. One of their successes is the skill in prediction of future dynamics given a suitable training set of data. Previous studies have shown how Echo State Networks (ESNs), a subset of Recurrent Neural Networks, can suc… ▽ More Neural networks have proven to be remarkably successful for a wide range of complicated tasks, from image recognition and object detection to speech recognition and machine translation. One of their successes is the skill in prediction of future dynamics given a suitable training set of data. Previous studies have shown how Echo State Networks (ESNs), a subset of Recurrent Neural Networks, can successfully predict even chaotic systems for times longer than the Lyapunov time. This study shows that, remarkably, ESNs can successfully predict dynamical behavior that is qualitatively different from any behavior contained in the training set. Evidence is provided for a fluid dynamics problem where the flow can transition between laminar (ordered) and turbulent (disordered) regimes. Despite being trained on the turbulent regime only, ESNs are found to predict laminar behavior. Moreover, the statistics of turbulent-to-laminar and laminar-to-turbulent transitions are also predicted successfully, and the utility of ESNs in acting as an early-warning system for transition is discussed. These results are expected to be widely applicable to data-driven modelling of temporal behaviour in a range of physical, climate, biological, ecological and finance models characterized by the presence of tip** points and sudden transitions between several competing states. △ Less

Submitted 12 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures

New applications for the Boris Spectral Deferred Correction algorithm for plasma simulations

Authors: Kris Smedt, Daniel Ruprecht, Jitse Niesen, Steven Tobias, Joonas Nättilä

Abstract: The paper investigates two new use cases for the Boris Spectral Deferred Corrections (Boris-SDC) time integrator for plasma simulations. First, we show that using Boris-SDC as a particle pusher in an electrostatic particle-in-cell (PIC) code can, at least in the linear regime, improve simulation accuracy compared with the standard second order Boris method. In some instances, the higher order of B… ▽ More The paper investigates two new use cases for the Boris Spectral Deferred Corrections (Boris-SDC) time integrator for plasma simulations. First, we show that using Boris-SDC as a particle pusher in an electrostatic particle-in-cell (PIC) code can, at least in the linear regime, improve simulation accuracy compared with the standard second order Boris method. In some instances, the higher order of Boris-SDC even allows a much larger time step, leading to modest computational gains. Second, we propose a modification of Boris-SDC for the relativistic regime. Based on an implementation of Boris-SDC in the \textsc{runko} PIC code, we demonstrate for a relativistic Penning trap that Boris-SDC retains its high order of convergence for velocities ranging from $0.5c$ to $>0.99c$. We also show that for the force-free case where acceleration from electric and magnetic field cancel, Boris-SDC produces less numerical drift than Boris. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Journal ref: Applied Mathematics and Computation: 442, pp. 127706, 2023

Direct statistical simulation of the Lorenz63 system

Authors: Kuan Li, J. B. Marston, Saloni Saxena, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: We use direct statistical simulation (DSS) to find the low-order statistics of the well-known dynamical system, the Lorenz63 model. Instead of accumulating statistics from numerical simulation of the dynamical systems, we solve the equations of motion for the statistics themselves after closing them by making several different choices for the truncation. Fixed points of the statistics are obtained… ▽ More We use direct statistical simulation (DSS) to find the low-order statistics of the well-known dynamical system, the Lorenz63 model. Instead of accumulating statistics from numerical simulation of the dynamical systems, we solve the equations of motion for the statistics themselves after closing them by making several different choices for the truncation. Fixed points of the statistics are obtained either by time evolving, or by iterative methods. Statistics so obtained are compared to those found by the traditional approach. △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2021; v1 submitted 27 August, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:2103.12741

Journal ref: Chaos 32, 043111 (2022)

Ion Heat and Parallel Momentum Transport by Stochastic Magnetic Fields and Turbulence

Authors: Chang-Chun Chen, Patrick H. Diamond, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: The theory of turbulent transport of parallel momentum and ion heat by the interaction of stochastic magnetic fields and turbulence is presented. Attention is focused on determining the kinetic stress and the compressive energy flux. A critical parameter is identified as the ratio of the turbulent scattering rate to the rate of parallel acoustic dispersion. For the parameter large, the kinetic str… ▽ More The theory of turbulent transport of parallel momentum and ion heat by the interaction of stochastic magnetic fields and turbulence is presented. Attention is focused on determining the kinetic stress and the compressive energy flux. A critical parameter is identified as the ratio of the turbulent scattering rate to the rate of parallel acoustic dispersion. For the parameter large, the kinetic stress takes the form of a viscous stress. For the parameter small, the quasilinear residual stress is recovered. In practice, the viscous stress is the relevant form, and the quasilinear limit is not observable. This is the principal prediction of this paper. A simple physical picture is developed and shown to recover the results of the detailed analysis. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2021; v1 submitted 26 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: 16 pages, 5 figures, PPCF invited paper

MSC Class: 76F25; 76M35; 76E25; 76F10; 76W05

Optimizing the control of transition to turbulence using a Bayesian method

Authors: Anton Pershin, Cedric Beaume, Tom S. Eaves, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: The nonlinear robustness of laminar plane Couette flow is considered under the action of in-phase spanwise wall oscillations by computing properties of the edge of chaos, i.e., the boundary of its basin of attraction. Three measures are used to quantify the chosen control strategy on laminar-to-turbulent transition: the kinetic energy of edge states (local attractors on the edge of chaos), the for… ▽ More The nonlinear robustness of laminar plane Couette flow is considered under the action of in-phase spanwise wall oscillations by computing properties of the edge of chaos, i.e., the boundary of its basin of attraction. Three measures are used to quantify the chosen control strategy on laminar-to-turbulent transition: the kinetic energy of edge states (local attractors on the edge of chaos), the form of the minimal seed (least energetic perturbation on the edge of chaos), and the laminarization probability (the probability that a random perturbation from the laminar flow of given kinetic energy will laminarize). A novel Bayesian approach is introduced to enable the accurate computation of the laminarization probability at a fraction of the cost of previous methods. While the edge state and the minimal seed provide useful information about the dynamics of transition to turbulence, neither measure is particularly useful to judge the effectiveness of the control strategy since they are not representative of the global geometry of the edge. In contrast, the laminarization probability provides global information about the edge and can be used to evaluate the control effectiveness by computing a laminarization score (the expected laminarization probability) and the associated expected dissipation rate of the controlled flow. These two quantities allow for the determination of optimal control parameter values subject to desired constraints. The results discussed in the paper are expected to be applied to a wide range of transitional flows and control strategies aimed at suppressing or triggering transition to turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 17 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: 29 pages, 14 figures

Direct statistical simulation of low-order dynamo systems

Authors: Kuan Li, J. B. Marston, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: In this paper we investigate the effectiveness of direct statistical simulation (DSS) for two low-order models of dynamo action. The first model, which is a simple model of solar and stellar dynamo action, is third-order and has cubic nonlinearities whilst the second has only quadratic nonlinearities and describes the interaction of convection and an aperiodically reversing magnetic field. We show… ▽ More In this paper we investigate the effectiveness of direct statistical simulation (DSS) for two low-order models of dynamo action. The first model, which is a simple model of solar and stellar dynamo action, is third-order and has cubic nonlinearities whilst the second has only quadratic nonlinearities and describes the interaction of convection and an aperiodically reversing magnetic field. We show how DSS can be utilised to solve for the statistics of these systems of equations both in the presence and the absence of stochastic terms, by truncating the cumulant hierarchy at either second or third order. We compare two different techniques for solving for the statistics, timestep** -- which is able to locate only stable solutions of the equations for the statistics and direct detection of the fixed points. We develop a complete methodology and symbolic package in Python for deriving the statistical equations governing the Low-order dynamic systems in cumulant expansions. We demonstrate that although direct detection of the fixed points is efficient and accurate for DSS truncated at second order, the addition of higher order terms leads to the inclusion of many unstable fixed points that may be found by direct detection of the fixed point by iterative methods. In those cases timestep** is a more robust protocol for finding meaninful solutions to DSS. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Journal ref: Proc. R. Soc. A 477:20210427 (2021)

Efficiency gains of a multi-scale integration method applied to a scale-separated model for rapidly rotating dynamos

Authors: Krasymyr Tretiak, Meredith Plumley, Michael Calkins, Steven Tobias

Abstract: Numerical geodynamo simulations with parameters close to an Earth-like regime would be of great interest for understanding the dynamics of the Earth's liquid outer core and the associated geomagnetic field. Such simulations are far too computationally demanding owing to the large range in spatiotemporal scales. This paper explores the application of a multi-scale timestep** method to an asymptot… ▽ More Numerical geodynamo simulations with parameters close to an Earth-like regime would be of great interest for understanding the dynamics of the Earth's liquid outer core and the associated geomagnetic field. Such simulations are far too computationally demanding owing to the large range in spatiotemporal scales. This paper explores the application of a multi-scale timestep** method to an asymptotic model for the generation of magnetic field in the fluid outer core of the Earth. The method is based on the heterogeneous multiscale modelling (HMM) strategy, which incorporates scale separation and utilizes several integrating models for the fast and slow fields. Quantitative comparisons between the multi-scale simulations and direct solution of the asymptotic model in the limit of rapid rotation and low Ekman number are performed. The multi-scale method accurately captures the varying temporal and spatial dynamics of the mean magnetic field at lower computational costs compared to the direct solution of the asymptotic model. △ Less

Submitted 28 November, 2021; v1 submitted 5 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Journal ref: Computer Physics Communications, Volume 273, 2022, 108253

Potential Vorticity Transport in Weakly and Strongly Magnetized Plasmas

Authors: Chang-Chun Chen, Patrick H. Diamond, Rameswar Singh, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Tangled magnetic fields, often coexisting with an ordered mean field, have a major impact on turbulence and momentum transport in many plasmas, including those found in the solar tachocline and magnetic confinement devices. We present a novel mean field theory of potential vorticity mixing in $β$-plane magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) and drift wave turbulence. Our results show that mean-square stochasti… ▽ More Tangled magnetic fields, often coexisting with an ordered mean field, have a major impact on turbulence and momentum transport in many plasmas, including those found in the solar tachocline and magnetic confinement devices. We present a novel mean field theory of potential vorticity mixing in $β$-plane magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) and drift wave turbulence. Our results show that mean-square stochastic fields strongly reduce Reynolds stress coherence. This decoherence of potential vorticity flux due to stochastic field scattering leads to suppression of momentum transport and zonal flow formation. A simple calculation suggests that the breaking of the shear-eddy tilting feedback loop by stochastic fields is the key underlying physics mechanism. A dimensionless parameter that quantifies the increment in power threshold is identified and used to assess the impact of stochastic field on the L-H transition. We discuss a model of stochastic fields as a resisto-elastic network. △ Less

Submitted 19 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 11 pages, 10 figures

MSC Class: 76F25; 76E25; 76M35; 76F10

Exoplanets and the Sun

Authors: J. Y-K. Cho, H. Th. Thrastarson, T. T. Koskinen, P. L. Read, S. M. Tobias, W. Moon, J. W. Skinner

Abstract: We review the recent progress in understanding the jet structures on exoplanets as well as on and inside the Sun. The emphasis is on the more robust aspects of observation and numerical modeling that relate directly to jets. For the exoplanets, the primary focus is on hot-Jupiters since many more observations are available for them presently than other types of exoplanets. Because not much is know… ▽ More We review the recent progress in understanding the jet structures on exoplanets as well as on and inside the Sun. The emphasis is on the more robust aspects of observation and numerical modeling that relate directly to jets. For the exoplanets, the primary focus is on hot-Jupiters since many more observations are available for them presently than other types of exoplanets. Because not much is known about the morphology and strength of the jets on exoplanets, there is currently not much agreement. In contrast, the picture is very different for the Sun. In fact, the jet structure of the Sun is arguably one of the best known jet structures of all the planets and stars, due to the fact that Sun's disk is resolved and its interior can be probed with helioseismology. A discussion of several critical issues pertaining to the modeling of jets on exoplanets and the Sun is presented, along with a brief outlook on the subject. △ Less

Submitted 19 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Dynamic mode decomposition to retrieve torsional Alfvén waves

Authors: Kumiko Hori, Steven M. Tobias, Robert J. Teed

Abstract: Dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) is utilised to identify the intrinsic signals arising from planetary interiors. Focusing on an axisymmetric quasi-geostrophic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) wave -called torsional Alfvén waves (TW) - we examine the utility of DMD in two types of MHD direct numerical simulations: Boussinesq magnetoconvection and anelastic convection-driven dynamos in rapidly rotating sph… ▽ More Dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) is utilised to identify the intrinsic signals arising from planetary interiors. Focusing on an axisymmetric quasi-geostrophic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) wave -called torsional Alfvén waves (TW) - we examine the utility of DMD in two types of MHD direct numerical simulations: Boussinesq magnetoconvection and anelastic convection-driven dynamos in rapidly rotating spherical shells, which model the dynamics in Earth's core and in Jupiter, respectively. We demonstrate that DMD is capable of distinguishing internal modes and boundary/interface-related modes from the timeseries of the internal velocity. Those internal modes may be realised as free TW, in terms of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of their normal mode solutions. Meanwhile it turns out that, in order to account for the details, the global TW eigenvalue problems in spherical shells need to be further addressed. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 7 pages, 11 figures, Proceedings of the Japan Society of Fluid Mechanics Annual Meeting 2020, Virtual, 18-20 September 2020

Report number: 104

Characterising the shape, size and orientation of cloud-feeding coherent boundary layer structures

Authors: Leif Denby, Steven J. Böing, Douglas J. Parker, Andrew N. Ross, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: This paper presents two techniques for characterisation of cloud-feeding coherent boundary layer structures through analysis of large-eddy simulations of shallow cumulus clouds, contrasting conditions with and without ambient shear. The first technique is a generalisation of the two-point correlation function where the correlation length-scale as well as orientation can be extracted. The second te… ▽ More This paper presents two techniques for characterisation of cloud-feeding coherent boundary layer structures through analysis of large-eddy simulations of shallow cumulus clouds, contrasting conditions with and without ambient shear. The first technique is a generalisation of the two-point correlation function where the correlation length-scale as well as orientation can be extracted. The second technique decomposes the vertical transport by coherent structures by the shape, size and orientation of these structures. It is found that the structures dominating the vertical flux are plume-like in character (extending from the surface into cloud), show small width/thickness asymmetry and rise near-vertically in the absence of ambient wind. The planar stretching and tilting of boundary layer structures caused by the introduction of ambient shear is also quantified, demonstrating the general applicability of the techniques for future study of other boundary layer patterns. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2021; v1 submitted 17 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 26 pages, 14 figures, submitted to QJRMS

Solitary magnetostrophic Rossby waves in spherical shells

Authors: K. Hori, S. M. Tobias, C. A. Jones

Abstract: Finite-amplitude hydromagnetic Rossby waves in the magnetostrophic regime are studied. We consider the slow mode, which travels in the opposite direction to the hydrodynamic or fast mode, in the presence of a toroidal magnetic field and zonal flow by means of quasi-geostrophic models for thick spherical shells. The weakly-nonlinear, long waves are derived asymptotically using a reductive perturbat… ▽ More Finite-amplitude hydromagnetic Rossby waves in the magnetostrophic regime are studied. We consider the slow mode, which travels in the opposite direction to the hydrodynamic or fast mode, in the presence of a toroidal magnetic field and zonal flow by means of quasi-geostrophic models for thick spherical shells. The weakly-nonlinear, long waves are derived asymptotically using a reductive perturbation method. The problem at the first order is found to obey a second-order ODE, leading to a hypergeometric equation for a Malkus field and a confluent Heun equation for an electrical-wire field, and is nonsingular when the wave speed approaches the mean flow. Investigating its neutral, nonsingular eigensolutions for different basic states, we find the evolution is described by the Korteweg-de Vries equation. This implies that the nonlinear slow wave forms solitons and solitary waves. These may take the form of a coherent eddy, such as a single anticyclone. We speculate on the relation of the anti-cyclone to the asymmetric gyre seen in Earth's fluid core, and in state-of-the-art dynamo DNS. △ Less

Submitted 21 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: 12 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 904 (2020) R3

Angular momentum transport, layering, and zonal jet formation by the GSF instability: nonlinear simulations at a general latitude

Authors: Adrian J. Barker, Chris A. Jones, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: We continue our investigation into the nonlinear evolution of the Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability in differentially rotating radiation zones. This instability may be a key player in transporting angular momentum in stars and giant planets, but its nonlinear evolution remains mostly unexplored. In a previous paper we considered the equatorial instability, whereas here we simulate the in… ▽ More We continue our investigation into the nonlinear evolution of the Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability in differentially rotating radiation zones. This instability may be a key player in transporting angular momentum in stars and giant planets, but its nonlinear evolution remains mostly unexplored. In a previous paper we considered the equatorial instability, whereas here we simulate the instability at a general latitude for the first time. We adopt a local Cartesian Boussinesq model in a modified shearing box for most of our simulations, but we also perform some simulations with stress-free, impenetrable, radial boundaries. We first revisit the linear instability and derive some new results, before studying its nonlinear evolution. The instability is found to behave very differently compared with its behaviour at the equator. In particular, here we observe the development of strong zonal jets ("layering" in the angular momentum), which can considerably enhance angular momentum transport, particularly in axisymmetric simulations. The jets are, in general, tilted with respect to the local gravity by an angle that corresponds initially with that of the linear modes, but which evolves with time and depends on the strength of the flow. The instability transports angular momentum much more efficiently (by several orders of magnitude) than it does at the equator, and we estimate that the GSF instability could contribute to the missing angular momentum transport required in both red giant and subgiant stars. It could also play a role in the long-term evolution of the solar tachocline and the atmospheric dynamics of hot Jupiters. △ Less

Submitted 11 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS on 8th May 2020

Generation of shear flows and vortices in rotating anelastic convection

Authors: Laura K. Currie, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: We consider the effect of stratification on systematic, large-scale flows generated in anelastic convection. We present results from three-dimensional numerical simulations of convection in a rotating plane layer in which the angle between the axis of rotation and gravity is allowed to vary. This model is representative of different latitudes of a spherical body. We consider two distinct parameter… ▽ More We consider the effect of stratification on systematic, large-scale flows generated in anelastic convection. We present results from three-dimensional numerical simulations of convection in a rotating plane layer in which the angle between the axis of rotation and gravity is allowed to vary. This model is representative of different latitudes of a spherical body. We consider two distinct parameter regimes: (i) weakly rotating and (ii) rapidly rotating. In each case, we examine the effect of stratification on the flow structure and heat transport properties focussing on the difference between Boussinesq and anelastic convection. Furthermore, we show that regimes (i) and (ii) generate very different large-scale flows and we investigate the role stratification has in modifying these flows. The stratified flows possess a net helicity not present in the Boussinesq cases which we suggest, when combined with the self-generated shear flows, could be important for dynamo action. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2020; v1 submitted 22 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: 18 pages, 12 figures. Accepted for publication in Physical Review Fluids

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 5, 073501 (2020)

Performance of parallel-in-time integration for Rayleigh Bénard Convection

Authors: Andrew Clarke, Chris Davies, Daniel Ruprecht, Steven Tobias, Jeffrey S. Oishi

Abstract: Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RBC) is a fundamental problem of fluid dynamics, with many applications to geophysical, astrophysical, and industrial flows. Understanding RBC at parameter regimes of interest requires complex physical or numerical experiments. Numerical simulations require large amounts of computational resources; in order to more efficiently use the large numbers of processors now ava… ▽ More Rayleigh-Bénard convection (RBC) is a fundamental problem of fluid dynamics, with many applications to geophysical, astrophysical, and industrial flows. Understanding RBC at parameter regimes of interest requires complex physical or numerical experiments. Numerical simulations require large amounts of computational resources; in order to more efficiently use the large numbers of processors now available in large high performance computing clusters, novel parallelisation strategies are required. To this end, we investigate the performance of the parallel-in-time algorithm Parareal when used in numerical simulations of RBC. We present the first parallel-in-time speedups for RBC simulations at finite Prandtl number. We also investigate the problem of convergence of Parareal with respect to to statistical numerical quantities, such as the Nusselt number, and discuss the importance of reliable online stop** criteria in these cases. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Journal ref: Computing and Visualization in Science 23(10), 2020

Topological Gaseous Plasmon Polariton in Realistic Plasma

Authors: Jeffrey B. Parker, J. B. Marston, Steven M. Tobias, Ziyan Zhu

Abstract: Nontrivial topology in bulk matter has been linked with the existence of topologically protected interfacial states. We show that a gaseous plasmon polariton (GPP), an electromagnetic surface wave existing at the boundary of magnetized plasma and vacuum, has a topological origin that arises from the nontrivial topology of magnetized plasma. Because a gaseous plasma cannot sustain a sharp interface… ▽ More Nontrivial topology in bulk matter has been linked with the existence of topologically protected interfacial states. We show that a gaseous plasmon polariton (GPP), an electromagnetic surface wave existing at the boundary of magnetized plasma and vacuum, has a topological origin that arises from the nontrivial topology of magnetized plasma. Because a gaseous plasma cannot sustain a sharp interface with discontinuous density, one must consider a gradual density falloff with scale length comparable or longer than the wavelength of the wave. We show that the GPP may be found within a gapped spectrum in present-day laboratory devices, suggesting that platforms are currently available for experimental investigation of topological wave physics in plasmas. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2020; v1 submitted 4 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: Supplementary Material is included

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 195001 (2020)

Nontrivial topology in the continuous spectrum of a magnetized plasma

Authors: Jeffrey B. Parker, J. W. Burby, J. B. Marston, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Classification of matter through topological phases and topological edge states between distinct materials has been a subject of great interest recently. While lattices have been the main setting for these studies, a relatively unexplored realm for this physics is that of continuum fluids. In the typical case of a fluid model with a point spectrum, nontrivial topology and associated edge modes hav… ▽ More Classification of matter through topological phases and topological edge states between distinct materials has been a subject of great interest recently. While lattices have been the main setting for these studies, a relatively unexplored realm for this physics is that of continuum fluids. In the typical case of a fluid model with a point spectrum, nontrivial topology and associated edge modes have been observed previously. However, another possibility is that a continuous spectrum can coexist with the point spectrum. Here we demonstrate that a fluid plasma model can harbor nontrivial topology within its continuous spectrum, and that there are boundary modes at the interface between topologically distinct regions. We consider the ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) model. In the presence of magnetic shear, we find nontrivial topology in the Alfvén continuum. For strong shear, the Chern number is $\pm 1$, depending on the sign of the shear. If the magnetic shear changes sign within the plasma, a topological phase transition occurs, and bulk-boundary correspondence then suggests a mode localized to the layer of zero magnetic shear. We confirm the existence of this mode numerically. Moreover, this reversed-shear Alfvén eigenmode (RSAE) is well known within magnetic fusion as it has been observed in several tokamaks. In examining how the MHD model might be regularized at small scales, we also consider the electron limit of Hall MHD. We show that the whistler band, which plays an important role in planetary ionospheres, has nontrivial topology. More broadly, this work raises the possibility that fusion devices could be carefully tailored to produce other topological states with potentially useful behavior. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2020; v1 submitted 17 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 18 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 2, 033425 (2020)

A probabilistic protocol for the assessment of transition and control

Authors: Anton Pershin, Cedric Beaume, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Transition to turbulence dramatically alters the properties of fluid flows. In most canonical shear flows, the laminar flow is linearly stable and a finite-amplitude perturbation is necessary to trigger transition. Controlling transition to turbulence is achieved via the broadening or narrowing of the basin of attraction of the laminar flow. In this paper, a novel methodology to assess the robustn… ▽ More Transition to turbulence dramatically alters the properties of fluid flows. In most canonical shear flows, the laminar flow is linearly stable and a finite-amplitude perturbation is necessary to trigger transition. Controlling transition to turbulence is achieved via the broadening or narrowing of the basin of attraction of the laminar flow. In this paper, a novel methodology to assess the robustness of the laminar flow and the efficiency of control strategies is introduced. It relies on the statistical sampling of the phase space neighborhood around the laminar flow in order to assess the transition probability of perturbations as a function of their energy. This approach is applied to a canonical flow (plane Couette flow) and provides invaluable insight: in the presence of the chosen control, transition is significantly suppressed whereas plausible scalar indicators of the nonlinear stability of the flow, such as the edge state energy, do not provide conclusive predictions. The methodology presented here in the context of transition to turbulence is applicable to any nonlinear system displaying finite-amplitude instability. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2020; v1 submitted 8 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 895 (2020) A16

The Turbulent Dynamo

Authors: Steven Tobias

Abstract: The generation of magnetic field in an electrically conducting fluid generally involves the complicated nonlinear interaction of flow turbulence, rotation and field. This dynamo process is of great importance in geophysics, planetary science and astrophysics, since magnetic fields are known to play a key role in the dynamics of these systems. This paper gives an introduction to dynamo theory for t… ▽ More The generation of magnetic field in an electrically conducting fluid generally involves the complicated nonlinear interaction of flow turbulence, rotation and field. This dynamo process is of great importance in geophysics, planetary science and astrophysics, since magnetic fields are known to play a key role in the dynamics of these systems. This paper gives an introduction to dynamo theory for the fluid dynamicist. It proceeds by laying the groundwork, introducing the equations and techniques that are at the heart of dynamo theory, before presenting some simple dynamo solutions. The problems currently exercising dynamo theorists are then introduced, along with the attempts to make progress. The paper concludes with the argument that progress in dynamo theory will be made in the future by utilising and advancing some of the current breakthroughs in neutral fluid turbulence such as those in transition, self-sustaining processes, turbulence/mean-flow interaction, statistical methods and maintenance and loss of balance. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Heat transfer and flow regimes in quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field

Authors: Ming Yan, Michael A. Calkins, Stefano Maffei, Keith Julien, Steven M. Tobias, Philippe Marti

Abstract: Numerical simulations of quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field are carried out up to a Chandrasekhar number of $Q=10^8$ over a broad range of Rayleigh numbers $Ra$. Three magnetoconvection regimes are identified: two of the regimes are magnetically-constrained in the sense that a leading-order balance exists between the Lorentz and buoyancy forces, whereas the third regime… ▽ More Numerical simulations of quasi-static magnetoconvection with a vertical magnetic field are carried out up to a Chandrasekhar number of $Q=10^8$ over a broad range of Rayleigh numbers $Ra$. Three magnetoconvection regimes are identified: two of the regimes are magnetically-constrained in the sense that a leading-order balance exists between the Lorentz and buoyancy forces, whereas the third regime is characterized by unbalanced dynamics that is similar to non-magnetic convection. Each regime is distinguished by flow morphology, momentum and heat equation balances, and heat transport behavior. One of the magnetically-constrained regimes appears to represent an `ultimate' magnetoconvection regime in the dual limit of asymptotically-large buoyancy forcing and magnetic field strength; this regime is characterized by an interconnected network of anisotropic, spatially-localized fluid columns aligned with the direction of the imposed magnetic field that remain quasi-laminar despite having large flow speeds. As for non-magnetic convection, heat transport is controlled primarily by the thermal boundary layer. Empirically, the scaling of the heat transport and flow speeds with $Ra$ appear to be independent of the thermal Prandtl number within the magnetically-constrained, high-$Q$ regimes. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2019; v1 submitted 31 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 24 pages, 11 figures

Angular momentum transport by the GSF instability: nonlinear simulations at the equator

Authors: Adrian J. Barker, Chris A. Jones, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: We present an investigation into the nonlinear evolution of the Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability using axisymmetric and three-dimensional simulations near the equator of a differentially rotating radiation zone. This instability may provide an important contribution to angular momentum transport in stars and planets. We adopt a local Boussinesq Cartesian shearing box model, which repres… ▽ More We present an investigation into the nonlinear evolution of the Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability using axisymmetric and three-dimensional simulations near the equator of a differentially rotating radiation zone. This instability may provide an important contribution to angular momentum transport in stars and planets. We adopt a local Boussinesq Cartesian shearing box model, which represents a small patch of a differentially rotating stellar radiation zone. Complementary simulations are also performed with stress-free, impenetrable boundaries in the local radial direction. The linear and nonlinear evolution of the equatorial axisymmetric instability is formally equivalent to the salt fingering instability. This is no longer the case in 3D, but we find that the instability behaves nonlinearly in a similar way to salt fingering. Axisymmetric simulations -- and those in 3D with short dimensions along the local azimuthal direction -- quickly develop strong jets along the rotation axis, which inhibit the instability and lead to predator-prey-like temporal dynamics. In 3D, the instability initially produces homogeneous turbulence and enhanced momentum transport, though in some cases jets form on a much longer timescale. We propose and validate numerically a simple theory for nonlinear saturation of the GSF instability and its resulting angular momentum transport. This theory is straightforward to implement in stellar evolution codes incorporating rotation. We estimate that the GSF instability could contribute towards explaining the missing angular momentum transport required in red giant stars, and play a role in the long-term evolution of the solar tachocline. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 19 pages, 15 figures, 1 table, accepted for publication in MNRAS on 16th May 2019

Parallel-in-time integration of Kinematic Dynamos

Authors: Andrew T. Clarke, Christopher J. Davies, Daniel Ruprecht, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: The precise mechanisms responsible for the natural dynamos in the Earth and Sun are still not fully understood. Numerical simulations of natural dynamos are extremely computationally intensive, and are carried out in parameter regimes many orders of magnitude away from real conditions. Parallelization in space is a common strategy to speed up simulations on high performance computers, but eventual… ▽ More The precise mechanisms responsible for the natural dynamos in the Earth and Sun are still not fully understood. Numerical simulations of natural dynamos are extremely computationally intensive, and are carried out in parameter regimes many orders of magnitude away from real conditions. Parallelization in space is a common strategy to speed up simulations on high performance computers, but eventually hits a scaling limit. Additional directions of parallelization are desirable to utilise the high number of processor cores now available. Parallel-in-time methods can deliver speed up in addition to that offered by spatial partitioning but have not yet been applied to dynamo simulations. This paper investigates the feasibility of using the parallel-in-time algorithm Parareal to speed up initial value problem simulations of the kinematic dynamo, using the open source Dedalus spectral solver. Both the time independent Roberts and time dependent Galloway-Proctor 2.5D dynamos are investigated over a range of magnetic Reynolds numbers. Speed ups beyond those possible from spatial parallelization are found in both cases. Results for the Galloway-Proctor flow are promising, with Parareal efficiency found to be close to 0.3. Roberts flow results are less efficient, but Parareal still shows some speed up over spatial parallelization alone. Parallel in space and time speed ups of $\sim300$ were found for 1600 cores for the Galloway-Proctor flow, with total parallel efficiency of $\sim0.16$. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Journal ref: Journal of Computational Physics X: 7, pp. 100057, 2020

Convection-driven kinematic dynamos with a self-consistent shear flow

Authors: Laura K. Currie, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: It is widely accepted that astrophysical magnetic fields are generated by dynamo action. In many cases these fields exhibit organisation on a scale larger than that of the underlying turbulent flow (e.g., the eleven-year solar cycle). The mechanism for the generation of so-called large scale fields remains an open problem. In cases where the magnetic Reynolds number ($Rm$) is small, dynamo-generat… ▽ More It is widely accepted that astrophysical magnetic fields are generated by dynamo action. In many cases these fields exhibit organisation on a scale larger than that of the underlying turbulent flow (e.g., the eleven-year solar cycle). The mechanism for the generation of so-called large scale fields remains an open problem. In cases where the magnetic Reynolds number ($Rm$) is small, dynamo-generated fields are coherent but at (the astrophysically relevant) high $Rm$, the fields are overwhelmed by small scale fluctuating field. Recently Tobias and Cattaneo (2013) have shown that an imposed large scale shear flow can suppress the small scale fluctuations and allow the large scale temporal behaviour to emerge. Shear is also believed to modify the electromotive force by introducing correlations between the flow and the field. However in previous models at high $Rm$ the shear is often artificially imposed or driven by an arbitrary body force. Here we consider a simple kinematic model of a convective dynamo in which shear is self consistently driven by the presence of a horizontal temperature gradient (resulting in a thermal wind) and a rotation vector that is oblique to gravity. By considering a $2.5$-dimensional system, we are able to reach high $Rm$ so that the dynamo approaches the asymptotic regime where the growth rate becomes approximately independent of $Rm$. We find the flows studied here to be excellent small-scale dynamos, but with very little systematic behaviour evident at large $Rm$. We attribute this to being unable to self-consistently generate flows with both large (net) helicity and strong shear in this setup. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 17 pages, 11 figures. Available open access from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03091929.2018.1517210

Journal ref: Geophysical & Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics (2018)

A Simple System for Moist Convection: the Rainy-Benard Model

Authors: Geoffrey K. Vallis, Douglas J. Parker, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Raylaigh-Benard convection is one of the most well-studied models in fluid mechanics. Atmospheric convection, one of the most important components of the climate system, is by comparison complicated and poorly understood. A key attribute of atmospheric convection is the buoyancy source provided by the condensation of water vapour, but the presence of radiation, compressibility, liquid water and ic… ▽ More Raylaigh-Benard convection is one of the most well-studied models in fluid mechanics. Atmospheric convection, one of the most important components of the climate system, is by comparison complicated and poorly understood. A key attribute of atmospheric convection is the buoyancy source provided by the condensation of water vapour, but the presence of radiation, compressibility, liquid water and ice further complicate the system and our understanding of it. In this paper we present an idealized model of moist convection by taking the Boussinesq limit of the ideal gas equations and adding a condensate that obeys a simplified Clausius--Clapeyron relation. The system allows moist convection to be explored at a fundamental level and reduces to the classical Rayleigh-Benard model if the latent heat of condensation is taken to be zero. The model has an exact, Rayleigh-number independent `drizzle' solution in which the diffusion of water vapour from a saturated lower surface is balanced by condensation, with the temperature field (and so the saturation value of the moisture) determined self-consistently by the heat released in the condensation. This state is the moist analogue of the conductive solution in the classical problem. We numerically determine the linear stability properties of this solution as a function of Rayleigh number and a nondimensional latent-heat parameter. We also present a number of turbulent solutions. △ Less

Submitted 19 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 35 pages, J. Fluid Mech (in press)

Generalised Quasilinear Approximation of the Interaction of Convection and Mean Flows in a Thermal Annulus

Authors: S. M. Tobias, J. Oishi, J. B. Marston

Abstract: In this paper we examine the interaction of convection, rotation and mean flows in a thermal annulus. In this system mean flows are driven by correlations induced by rotation leading to non-trivial Reynolds stresses. The mean flows act back on the convective turbulence acting as a barrier to transport. For this system we demonstrate that the Generalised Quasilinear Approximation (GQL) (Marston et… ▽ More In this paper we examine the interaction of convection, rotation and mean flows in a thermal annulus. In this system mean flows are driven by correlations induced by rotation leading to non-trivial Reynolds stresses. The mean flows act back on the convective turbulence acting as a barrier to transport. For this system we demonstrate that the Generalised Quasilinear Approximation (GQL) (Marston et al 2016) may provide a much better approximation to the complicated full nonlinear dynamics than the widely used Quasilinear Approximation (QL). This result will enable the construction of more accurate statistical theories for the description of geophysical and astrophysical flows. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Journal ref: Proc. R. Soc. A 474, 20180422 (2018)

Joint Instability and Abrupt Nonlinear Transitions in a Differentially Rotating Plasma

Authors: Abigail Plummer, J. B. Marston, S. M. Tobias

Abstract: Global magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) instabilities are investigated in a computationally tractable two-dimensional model of the solar tachocline. The model's differential rotation yields stability in the absence of a magnetic field, but if a magnetic field is present, a joint instability is observed. We analyze the nonlinear development of the instability via fully nonlinear direct numerical simulatio… ▽ More Global magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) instabilities are investigated in a computationally tractable two-dimensional model of the solar tachocline. The model's differential rotation yields stability in the absence of a magnetic field, but if a magnetic field is present, a joint instability is observed. We analyze the nonlinear development of the instability via fully nonlinear direct numerical simulation, the generalized quasilinear approximation (GQL), and direct statistical simulation (DSS) based upon low-order expansion in equal-time cumulants. As the magnetic diffusivity is decreased, the nonlinear development of the instability becomes more complicated until eventually a set of parameters are identified that produce a previously unidentified long-term cycle in which energy is transformed from kinetic energy to magnetic energy and back. We find that the periodic transitions, which mimic some aspects of solar variability -- for example, the quasiperiodic seasonal exchange of energy between toroidal field and waves or eddies -- are unable to be reproduced when eddy-scattering processes are excluded from the model. △ Less

Submitted 7 January, 2019; v1 submitted 4 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: 21 pages with 17 figure. Version accepted for publication in the Journal of Plasma Physics

Journal ref: Journal of Plasma Physics 85, 193-21 (2019)

Dynamics of spatially localized states in transitional plane Couette flow

Authors: Anton Pershin, Cedric Beaume, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Unsteady spatially localized states such as puffs, slugs or spots play an important role in transition to turbulence. In plane Couette flow, steady versions of these states are found on two intertwined solution branches describing homoclinic snaking (Schneider $\textit{et al.}$ 2010a). These branches can be used to generate a number of spatially localized initial conditions whose transition can be… ▽ More Unsteady spatially localized states such as puffs, slugs or spots play an important role in transition to turbulence. In plane Couette flow, steady versions of these states are found on two intertwined solution branches describing homoclinic snaking (Schneider $\textit{et al.}$ 2010a). These branches can be used to generate a number of spatially localized initial conditions whose transition can be investigated. From the low Reynolds numbers where homoclinic snaking is first observed ($Re < 175$) to transitional ones ($Re \approx 325$), these spatially localized states traverse various regimes where their relaminarisation time and dynamics are affected by the dynamical structure of phase space. These regimes are reported and characterised in this paper for a $4π$ periodic domain in the streamwise direction as a function of the two remaining variables: the Reynolds number and the width of the localized pattern. Close to the snaking, localized states are attracted by spatially localized periodic orbits before relaminarising. At larger values of the Reynolds number, the flow enters a chaotic transient of variable duration before relaminarising. Very long chaotic transients ($t > 10^4$) can be observed without difficulty for relatively low values of the Reynolds number ($Re \approx 250$). △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2019; v1 submitted 26 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Breaking Kelvin: Circulation conservation and vortex breakup in MHD at low Magnetic Prandtl Number

Authors: D. G. Dritschel, P. H. Diamond, S. M. Tobias

Abstract: In this paper we examine the role of weak magnetic fields in breaking Kelvin's circulation theorem and in vortex breakup in two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics for the physically important case of a low magnetic Prandtl number (low $Pm$) fluid. We consider three canonical inviscid solutions for the purely hydrodynamical problem, namely a Gaussian vortex, a circular vortex patch and an elliptical… ▽ More In this paper we examine the role of weak magnetic fields in breaking Kelvin's circulation theorem and in vortex breakup in two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics for the physically important case of a low magnetic Prandtl number (low $Pm$) fluid. We consider three canonical inviscid solutions for the purely hydrodynamical problem, namely a Gaussian vortex, a circular vortex patch and an elliptical vortex patch. We examine how magnetic fields lead to an initial loss of circulation $Γ$ and attempt to derive scaling laws for the loss of circulation as a function of field strength and diffusion as measured by two non-dimensional parameters. We show that for all cases the loss of circulation depends on the integrated effects of the Lorentz force, with the patch cases leading to significantly greater circulation loss. For the case of the elliptical vortex the loss of circulation depends on the total area swept out by the rotating vortex and so this leads to more efficient circulation loss than for a circular vortex. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 21 pages, 12 figures

Rotationally induced coherence in turbulent kinematic dynamos

Authors: Vassilios Dallas, Steve Tobias

Abstract: We consider rotating, kinematic dynamos at low magnetic Prandtl number $Pm$. We show that the inclusion of rotation leads to an increase in spatio-temporal coherence and a modification of the turbulent spectrum. These effects make the flow more efficient in driving the dynamo, in the sense that the energy injection rate required to reach the critical value of the magnetic Reynolds number $Rm_c$ is… ▽ More We consider rotating, kinematic dynamos at low magnetic Prandtl number $Pm$. We show that the inclusion of rotation leads to an increase in spatio-temporal coherence and a modification of the turbulent spectrum. These effects make the flow more efficient in driving the dynamo, in the sense that the energy injection rate required to reach the critical value of the magnetic Reynolds number $Rm_c$ is reduced in comparison with a non-rotating dynamo (Seshasayanan et al. 2017). For random dynamos it is known that the growth-rate would largely be determined by the spectral index of the flow at the resistive scale. Here, however, we demonstrate that the dynamo growth-rate in rotating flows is increased by the rotationally induced long-lived large scale eddies with a coherence time greater than the local turnover time. These eddies play the major role in determining the dynamo growth-rate. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2018; v1 submitted 6 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 12 pages, 8 figures

Scale Selection in the Stratified Convection of the Solar Photosphere

Authors: M. Kessar, D. W. Hughes, E. Kersale, K. A. Mizerski, S. M. Tobias

Abstract: We examine the role of stratification in determining the scale for turbulent anelastic convection. Motivated by the range of scales observed in convection at the solar photosphere, we perform local numerical simulations of convection for a range of density contrasts in large domains. We analyse both the Eulerian and Lagrangian statistics of the convection and demonstrate that increasing the strati… ▽ More We examine the role of stratification in determining the scale for turbulent anelastic convection. Motivated by the range of scales observed in convection at the solar photosphere, we perform local numerical simulations of convection for a range of density contrasts in large domains. We analyse both the Eulerian and Lagrangian statistics of the convection and demonstrate that increasing the stratification shifts the scale of the most energetic structures in the flow to smaller scales; furthermore, the relative amplitude of vertical to horizontal flows in the convection decreases with increasing stratification. We discuss the implications of our results to the issue of solar mesogranulation. △ Less

Submitted 4 March, 2018; v1 submitted 5 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: Submitted to ApJ

Direct Statistical Simulation of Jets and Vortices in 2D Flows

Authors: Steven Tobias, Brad Marston

Abstract: In this paper we perform Direct Statistical Simulations of a model of two-dimensional flow that exhibits a transition from jets to vortices. The model employs two-scale Kolmogorov forcing, with energy injected directly into the zonal mean of the flow. We compare these results with those from Direct Numerical Simulations. For square domains the solution takes the form of jets, but as the aspect rat… ▽ More In this paper we perform Direct Statistical Simulations of a model of two-dimensional flow that exhibits a transition from jets to vortices. The model employs two-scale Kolmogorov forcing, with energy injected directly into the zonal mean of the flow. We compare these results with those from Direct Numerical Simulations. For square domains the solution takes the form of jets, but as the aspect ratio is increased a transition to isolated coherent vortices is found. We find that a truncation at second order in the equal-time but nonlocal cumulants that employs zonal averaging (zonal CE2) is capable of capturing the form of the jets for a range of Reynolds numbers as well as the transition to the vortex state, but, unsurprisingly, is unable to reproduce the correlations found for the fully nonlinear (non-zonally symmetric) vortex state. This result continues the program of promising advances in statistical theories of turbulence championed by Kraichnan. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Journal ref: Physics of Fluids 29, 111111 (2017)

Dimensional Reduction of Direct Statistical Simulation

Authors: Altan Allawala, S. M. Tobias, J. B. Marston

Abstract: Direct Statistical Simulation (DSS) solves the equations of motion for the statistics of turbulent flows in place of the traditional route of accumulating statistics by Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS). That low-order statistics usually evolve slowly compared with instantaneous dynamics is one important advantage of DSS. Depending on the symmetry of the problem and the choice of averaging operati… ▽ More Direct Statistical Simulation (DSS) solves the equations of motion for the statistics of turbulent flows in place of the traditional route of accumulating statistics by Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS). That low-order statistics usually evolve slowly compared with instantaneous dynamics is one important advantage of DSS. Depending on the symmetry of the problem and the choice of averaging operation, however, DSS is usually more expensive computationally than DNS because even low order statistics typically have higher dimension than the underlying fields. Here we show that it is possible to go much further by using Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) to address the "curse of dimensionality." We apply POD directly to DSS in the form of expansions in the equal-time cumulants to second order (CE2). We explore two averaging operations (zonal and ensemble) and test the approach on two idealized barotropic models on a rotating sphere (a jet that relaxes deterministically towards an unstable profile, and a stochastically-driven flow that spontaneously organizes into jets). Order-of-magnitude savings in computational cost are obtained in the reduced basis, potentially enabling access to parameter regimes beyond the reach of DNS. △ Less

Submitted 13 February, 2020; v1 submitted 25 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 17 pages and 11 figures. Corrections, improved figures, and new section on "Continuation in Parameter Space."

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 898 (2020) A21

Inertia-less convectively-driven dynamo models in the limit of low Rossby number and large Prandtl number

Authors: Michael A. Calkins, Keith Julien, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Compositional convection is thought to be an important energy source for magnetic field generation within planetary interiors. The Prandtl number, $Pr$, characterizing compositional convection is significantly larger than unity, suggesting that the inertial force may not be important on the small scales of convection as long as the buoyancy force is not too strong. We develop asymptotic dynamo mod… ▽ More Compositional convection is thought to be an important energy source for magnetic field generation within planetary interiors. The Prandtl number, $Pr$, characterizing compositional convection is significantly larger than unity, suggesting that the inertial force may not be important on the small scales of convection as long as the buoyancy force is not too strong. We develop asymptotic dynamo models for the case of small Rossby number and large Prandtl number in which inertia is absent on the convective scale. The relevant diffusivity parameter for this limit is the compositional Roberts number, $q = D/η$, which is the ratio of compositional and magnetic diffusivities. Dynamo models are developed for both order one $q$ and the more geophysically relevant low $q$ limit. For both cases the ratio of magnetic to kinetic energy densities, $M$, is asymptotically large and reflects the fact that Alfvén waves have been filtered from the dynamics. Along with previous investigations of asymptotic dynamo models for $Pr=O(1)$, our results show that the ratio $M$ is not a useful indicator of dominant force balances in the momentum equation since many different asymptotic limits of $M$ can be obtained without changing the leading order geostrophic balance. Furthermore, the present models show that inertia is not a requirement for driving low $q$, large-scale dynamos. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2017; v1 submitted 13 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 22 pages, fixed typos, added references to discussion

Convection-driven kinematic dynamos at low Rossby and magnetic Prandtl numbers

Authors: Michael A. Calkins, Louie Long, David Nieves, Keith Julien, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: Most large-scale planetary magnetic fields are thought to be driven by low Rossby number convection of a low magnetic Prandtl number fluid. Here kinematic dynamo action is investigated with an asymptotic, rapidly rotating dynamo model for the plane layer geometry that is intrinsically low magnetic Prandtl number. The thermal Prandtl number and Rayleigh number are varied to illustrate fundamental c… ▽ More Most large-scale planetary magnetic fields are thought to be driven by low Rossby number convection of a low magnetic Prandtl number fluid. Here kinematic dynamo action is investigated with an asymptotic, rapidly rotating dynamo model for the plane layer geometry that is intrinsically low magnetic Prandtl number. The thermal Prandtl number and Rayleigh number are varied to illustrate fundamental changes in flow regime, ranging from laminar cellular convection to geostrophic turbulence in which an inverse energy cascade is present. A decrease in the efficiency of the convection to generate a dynamo, as determined by an increase in the critical magnetic Reynolds number, is observed as the buoyancy forcing is increased. This decreased efficiency may result from both the loss of correlations associated with the increasingly disordered states of flow that are generated, and boundary layer behavior that enhances magnetic diffusion locally. We find that the spatial characteristics of $α$, and thus the large-scale magnetic field, is dependent only weakly on changes in flow behavior. However, our results are limited to the linear, kinematic dynamo regime, and future simulations including the Lorentz force are therefore necessary to assess the robustness of this result. In contrast to the large-scale magnetic field, the behavior of the small-scale magnetic field is directly dependent on, and therefore shows significant variations with, the small-scale convective flow field. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 28 pages, 12 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 1, 083701 (2016)

Convective dynamo action in a spherical shell: symmetries and modulation

Authors: Raphaël Raynaud, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: We consider dynamo action driven by three-dimensional rotating anelastic convection in a spherical shell. Motivated by the behaviour of the solar dynamo, we examine the interaction of hydromagnetic modes with different symmetries and demonstrate how complicated interactions between convection, differential rotation and magnetic fields may lead to modulation of the basic cycle. For some parameters,… ▽ More We consider dynamo action driven by three-dimensional rotating anelastic convection in a spherical shell. Motivated by the behaviour of the solar dynamo, we examine the interaction of hydromagnetic modes with different symmetries and demonstrate how complicated interactions between convection, differential rotation and magnetic fields may lead to modulation of the basic cycle. For some parameters, Type 1 modulation occurs by the transfer of energy between modes of different symmetries with little change in the overall amplitude, for other parameters, the modulation is of Type 2, where the amplitude is significantly affected (leading to grand minima in activity) without significant changes in symmetry. Most importantly, we identify the presence of "supermodulation" in the solutions, where the activity switches chaotically between Type 1 and Type 2 modulation, this is believed to be an important process in solar activity. △ Less

Submitted 4 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 12 pages

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. (2016), vol. 799, R6

Three-Dimensional Rotating Couette Flow Via The Generalised Quasilinear Approximation

Authors: Steven Tobias, Brad Marston

Abstract: We examine the effectiveness of the Generalised Quasilinear (GQL) Approximation introduced by Marston et al (2016). This approximation splits the variables into large and small scales in directions where there is a translational symmetry and removes nonlinear interactions involving only small scales. We utilise as a paradigm problem three-dimensional, turbulent, rotating Couette flow. We compare t… ▽ More We examine the effectiveness of the Generalised Quasilinear (GQL) Approximation introduced by Marston et al (2016). This approximation splits the variables into large and small scales in directions where there is a translational symmetry and removes nonlinear interactions involving only small scales. We utilise as a paradigm problem three-dimensional, turbulent, rotating Couette flow. We compare the results obtained from Direct Numerical Solution of the equations with those from Quasilinear (QL) and GQL calculations. In this three-dimensional setting, there is a choice of cut-off wavenumber for the GQL approximation both in the streamwise and in the spanwise directions. We demonstrate that the GQL approximation significantly improves the accuracy of mean flows, spectra and two-point correlation functions over models that are quasilinear in any of the translationally invariant directions, even if only a few streamwise and spanwise modes are included. We argue that this provides significant support for a programme of Direct Statistical Simulation utilising the GQL approximation. △ Less

Submitted 12 October, 2016; v1 submitted 24 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 810, 412-428 (2017)

Mean flow generation in rotating anelastic two-dimensional convection

Authors: Laura K. Currie, Steven M. Tobias

Abstract: We investigate the processes that lead to the generation of mean flows in two-dimensional anelastic convection. The simple model consists of a plane layer that is rotating about an axis inclined to gravity. The results are two-fold: firstly we numerically investigate the onset of convection in three-dimensions, paying particular attention to the role of stratification and highlight a curious symme… ▽ More We investigate the processes that lead to the generation of mean flows in two-dimensional anelastic convection. The simple model consists of a plane layer that is rotating about an axis inclined to gravity. The results are two-fold: firstly we numerically investigate the onset of convection in three-dimensions, paying particular attention to the role of stratification and highlight a curious symmetry. Secondly, we investigate the mechanisms that drive both zonal and meridional flows in two dimensions. We find that, in general, non-trivial Reynolds stresses can lead to systematic flows and, using statistical measures, we quantify the role of stratification in modifying the coherence of these flows. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 28 pages, 9 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Fluids 28, 017101 (2016)

Generalised quasi-linear approximation of the HMRI

Authors: Adam Child, Rainer Hollerbach, Brad Marston, Steven Tobias

Abstract: Motivated by recent advances in Direct Statistical Simulation (DSS) of astrophysical phenomena such as out of equilibrium jets, we perform a Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) of the helical magnetorotational instability (HMRI) under the generalised quasilinear approximation (GQL). This approximation generalises the quasilinear approximation (QL) to include the self-consistent interaction of large-… ▽ More Motivated by recent advances in Direct Statistical Simulation (DSS) of astrophysical phenomena such as out of equilibrium jets, we perform a Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) of the helical magnetorotational instability (HMRI) under the generalised quasilinear approximation (GQL). This approximation generalises the quasilinear approximation (QL) to include the self-consistent interaction of large-scale modes, interpolating between fully nonlinear DNS and QL DNS whilst still remaining formally linear in the small scales. In this paper we address whether GQL can more accurately describe low-order statistics of axisymmetric HMRI when compared with QL by performing DNS under various degrees of GQL approximation. We utilise various diagnostics, such as energy spectra in addition to first and second cumulants, for calculations performed for a range of Reynolds and Hartmann numbers (describing rotation and imposed magnetic field strength respectively). We find that GQL performs significantly better than QL in describing the statistics of the HMRI even when relatively few large-scale modes are kept in the formalism. We conclude that DSS based on GQL (GCE2) will be significantly more accurate than that based on QL (CE2). △ Less

Submitted 19 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 17 pages, 8 figures