-
A Continuum of Physics-Based Lithium-Ion Battery Models Reviewed
Authors:
Ferran Brosa Planella,
Weilong Ai,
Adam M. Boyce,
Abir Ghosh,
Ivan Korotkin,
Smita Sahu,
Valentin Sulzer,
Robert Timms,
Thomas G. Tranter,
Maxim Zyskin,
Samuel J. Cooper,
Jacqueline S. Edge,
Jamie M. Foster,
Monica Marinescu,
Billy Wu,
Giles Richardson
Abstract:
Physics-based electrochemical battery models derived from porous electrode theory are a very powerful tool for understanding lithium-ion batteries, as well as for improving their design and management. Different model fidelity, and thus model complexity, is needed for different applications. For example, in battery design we can afford longer computational times and the use of powerful computers,…
▽ More
Physics-based electrochemical battery models derived from porous electrode theory are a very powerful tool for understanding lithium-ion batteries, as well as for improving their design and management. Different model fidelity, and thus model complexity, is needed for different applications. For example, in battery design we can afford longer computational times and the use of powerful computers, while for real-time battery control (e.g. in electric vehicles) we need to perform very fast calculations using simple devices. For this reason, simplified models that retain most of the features at a lower computational cost are widely used. Even though in the literature we often find these simplified models posed independently, leading to inconsistencies between models, they can actually be derived from more complicated models using a unified and systematic framework. In this review, we showcase this reductive framework, starting from a high-fidelity microscale model and reducing it all the way down to the Single Particle Model (SPM), deriving in the process other common models, such as the Doyle-Fuller-Newman (DFN) model. We also provide a critical discussion on the advantages and shortcomings of each of the models, which can aid model selection for a particular application. Finally, we provide an overview of possible extensions to the models, with a special focus on thermal models. Any of these extensions could be incorporated into the microscale model and the reductive framework re-applied to lead to a new generation of simplified, multi-physics models.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Lithium-ion battery degradation: how to model it
Authors:
Simon E. J. O'Kane,
Weilong Ai,
Ganesh Madabattula,
Diego Alonso Alvarez,
Robert Timms,
Valentin Sulzer,
Jacqueline Sophie Edge,
Billy Wu,
Gregory J. Offer,
Monica Marinescu
Abstract:
Predicting lithium-ion battery degradation is worth billions to the global automotive, aviation and energy storage industries, to improve performance and safety and reduce warranty liabilities. However, very few published models of battery degradation explicitly consider the interactions between more than two degradation mechanisms, and none do so within a single electrode. In this paper, the firs…
▽ More
Predicting lithium-ion battery degradation is worth billions to the global automotive, aviation and energy storage industries, to improve performance and safety and reduce warranty liabilities. However, very few published models of battery degradation explicitly consider the interactions between more than two degradation mechanisms, and none do so within a single electrode. In this paper, the first published attempt to directly couple more than two degradation mechanisms in the negative electrode is reported. The results are used to map different pathways through the complicated path dependent and non-linear degradation space. Four degradation mechanisms are coupled in PyBaMM, an open source modelling environment uniquely developed to allow new physics to be implemented and explored quickly and easily. Crucially it is possible to see 'inside' the model and observe the consequences of the different patterns of degradation, such as loss of lithium inventory and loss of active material. For the same cell, five different pathways that can result in end-of-life have already been found, depending on how the cell is used. Such information would enable a product designer to either extend life or predict life based upon the usage pattern. However, parameterization of the degradation models remains as a major challenge, and requires the attention of the international battery community.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2022; v1 submitted 3 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Homogenisation of spirally-wound high-contrast layered materials
Authors:
Steven Psaltis,
Robert Timms,
Colin Please,
S. Jonathan Chapman
Abstract:
Asymptotic homogenisation is used to systematically derive reduced-order macroscopic models of conductive behaviour in spirally-wound layered materials in which the layers have very different conductivities. The problem is motivated by the need for simplified models of the electrical and thermal behaviour of lithium-ion cells, accounting for the highly conductive metallic current collectors and re…
▽ More
Asymptotic homogenisation is used to systematically derive reduced-order macroscopic models of conductive behaviour in spirally-wound layered materials in which the layers have very different conductivities. The problem is motivated by the need for simplified models of the electrical and thermal behaviour of lithium-ion cells, accounting for the highly conductive metallic current collectors and relatively poorly conductive electrodes. We identify and study three distinguished limits, and then describe two composite models which each provide a uniform approximation spanning two distinguished limits. We compare the results of the various reduced-order models with calculations of the full model on a detailed geometry to give a guide to the accuracy of the approximations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
A Suite of Reduced-Order Models of a Single-Layer Lithium-ion Pouch Cell
Authors:
Scott G. Marquis,
Robert Timms,
Valentin Sulzer,
Colin P. Please,
S. Jon Chapman
Abstract:
For many practical applications, fully coupled three-dimensional models describing the behaviour of lithium-ion pouch cells are too computationally expensive. However, owing to the small aspect ratio of typical pouch cell designs, such models are well approximated by splitting the problem into a model for through-cell behaviour and a model for the transverse behaviour. In this paper, we combine di…
▽ More
For many practical applications, fully coupled three-dimensional models describing the behaviour of lithium-ion pouch cells are too computationally expensive. However, owing to the small aspect ratio of typical pouch cell designs, such models are well approximated by splitting the problem into a model for through-cell behaviour and a model for the transverse behaviour. In this paper, we combine different simplifications to through-cell and transverse models to develop a hierarchy of reduced-order pouch cell models. We give a critical numerical comparison of each of these models in both isothermal and thermal settings, and also study their performance on realistic drive cycle data. Finally, we make recommendations regarding model selection, taking into account the available computational resource and the quantities of interest in a particular study.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Asymptotic Reduction of a Lithium-ion Pouch Cell Model
Authors:
Robert Timms,
Scott G. Marquis,
Valentin Sulzer,
Colin Please,
S. Jon Chapman
Abstract:
A three-dimensional model of a single-layer lithium-ion pouch cell is presented which couples conventional porous electrode theory describing cell electrochemical behaviour with an energy balance describing cell thermal behaviour. Asymptotic analysis of the model is carried out by exploiting the small aspect ratio typical of pouch cell designs. The analysis reveals the scaling that results in a di…
▽ More
A three-dimensional model of a single-layer lithium-ion pouch cell is presented which couples conventional porous electrode theory describing cell electrochemical behaviour with an energy balance describing cell thermal behaviour. Asymptotic analysis of the model is carried out by exploiting the small aspect ratio typical of pouch cell designs. The analysis reveals the scaling that results in a distinguished limit, and highlights the role played by the electrical conductivities of the current collectors. The resulting model comprises a collection of one-dimensional models for the through-cell electrochemical behaviour which are coupled via two-dimensional problems for the Ohmic and thermal behaviour in the planar current collectors. A further limit is identified which reduces the problem to a single volume-averaged through-cell model, greatly reducing the computational complexity. Numerical simulations are presented which illustrate and validate the asymptotic results.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
An asymptotic derivation of a single particle model with electrolyte
Authors:
Scott G. Marquis,
Valentin Sulzer,
Robert Timms,
Colin P. Please,
S. Jon Chapman
Abstract:
The standard continuum model of a lithium-ion battery, the Doyle-Fuller-Newman (DFN) model, is computationally expensive to solve. Typically simpler models, such as the single particle model (SPM), are used to provide insight for control purposes. Recently, there has been a move to extend the SPM to include electrolyte effects, which increase the accuracy and range of applicability. However, these…
▽ More
The standard continuum model of a lithium-ion battery, the Doyle-Fuller-Newman (DFN) model, is computationally expensive to solve. Typically simpler models, such as the single particle model (SPM), are used to provide insight for control purposes. Recently, there has been a move to extend the SPM to include electrolyte effects, which increase the accuracy and range of applicability. However, these extended models are derived in an ad-hoc manner, which leaves open the possibility that important terms may have been neglected, resulting in the model not being as accurate as possible. In this paper, we provide a systematic asymptotic derivation of both the SPM and a correction term that accounts for the behaviour in the electrolyte. Firstly, this allows us to quantify the error in the reduced model in terms of ratios of key parameters in the model, from which the range of applicable operating conditions can be determined. Secondly, in comparing our model with the ad-hoc models from the literature, we show that previous models have neglected a key set of terms. In particular, we make the crucial distinction between writing the terminal voltage in pointwise and electrode-averaged form, which allows us to gain additional accuracy whilst maintaining the same computational complexity as the existing models.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2019; v1 submitted 29 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
