-
Spectroscopic and interferometric signatures of magnetospheric accretion in young stars
Authors:
B. Tessore,
A. Soulain,
G. Pantolmos,
J. Bouvier,
C. Pinte,
K. Perraut
Abstract:
Methods. We use the code MCFOST to solve the non-LTE problem of line formation in non-axisymmetric accreting magnetospheres. We compute the Brγ line profile originating from accretion columns for models with different magnetic obliquities. We also derive monochromatic synthetic images of the Brγ line emitting region across the line profile. This spectral line is a prime diagnostics of magnetospher…
▽ More
Methods. We use the code MCFOST to solve the non-LTE problem of line formation in non-axisymmetric accreting magnetospheres. We compute the Brγ line profile originating from accretion columns for models with different magnetic obliquities. We also derive monochromatic synthetic images of the Brγ line emitting region across the line profile. This spectral line is a prime diagnostics of magnetospheric accretion in young stars and is accessible with the long baseline near-infrared interferometer GRAVITY installed at the ESO Very Large Telescope Interferometer.
Results. We derive Brγ line profiles as a function of rotational phase and compute interferometric observables, visibilities and phases, from synthetic images. The line profile shape is modulated along the rotational cycle, exhibiting inverse P Cygni profiles at the time the accretion shock faces the observer. The size of the line's emission region decreases as the magnetic obliquity increases, which is reflected in a lower line flux. We apply interferometric models to the synthetic visibilities in order to derive the size of the line-emitting region. We find the derived interferometric size to be more compact than the actual size of the magnetosphere, ranging from 50 to 90\% of the truncation radius. Additionally, we show that the rotation of the non-axisymmetric magnetosphere is recovered from the rotational modulation of the Brγ-to-continuum photo-centre shifts, as measured by the differential phase of interferometric visibilities.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
The height of convective plumes in the red supergiant $μ$ Cep
Authors:
A. López Ariste,
M. Wavasseur,
Ph. Mathias,
A. Lèbre,
B. Tessore,
S. Georgiev
Abstract:
Aims. We seek to understand convection in red supergiants and the mechanisms that trigger the mass loss from cool evolved stars. Methods. Linear spectropolarimetry of the atomic lines of the spectrum of $μ$ Cep reveals information well outside the wavelength range expected from previous models. This is interpreted as structures in expansion that are visible in the front hemisphere and sometimes al…
▽ More
Aims. We seek to understand convection in red supergiants and the mechanisms that trigger the mass loss from cool evolved stars. Methods. Linear spectropolarimetry of the atomic lines of the spectrum of $μ$ Cep reveals information well outside the wavelength range expected from previous models. This is interpreted as structures in expansion that are visible in the front hemisphere and sometimes also in the back hemisphere. We model the plasma distribution together with its associated velocities through an inversion algorithm to fit the observed linear polarization. Results. We find that supposing the existence of plasma beyond the limb rising high enough to be visible above it can explain the observed linear polarization signatures as well as their evolution in time. From this we are able to infer the geometric heights of the convective plumes and establish that this hot plasma rises to at least 1.1 R*. Conclusions. $μ$ Cep appears to be in an active phase in which plasma rises often above 1.1 R* . We generalize this result to all red supergiants in a similarly evolved stage, which at certain epochs may easily send plasma to greater heights, as $μ$ Cep appears to be doing at present. Plasma rising to such heights can easily escape the stellar gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
The GRAVITY Young Stellar Object survey -- IX. Spatially resolved kinematics of hot hydrogen gas in the star/disk interaction region of T Tauri stars
Authors:
GRAVITY Collaboration,
J. A. Wojtczak,
L. Labadie,
K. Perraut,
B. Tessore,
A. Soulain,
V. Ganci,
J. Bouvier,
C. Dougados,
E. Alécian,
H. Nowacki,
G. Cozzo,
W. Brandner,
A. Caratti o Garatti,
P. Garcia,
R. Garcia Lopez,
J. Sanchez-Bermudez,
A. Amorim,
M. Benisty,
J. -P. Berger,
G. Bourdarot,
P. Caselli,
Y. Clénet,
P. T. de Zeeuw,
R. Davies
, et al. (36 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Aims: We aim to spatially and spectrally resolve the Br-gamma hydrogen emission line with the methods of interferometry in order to examine the kinematics of the hydrogen gas emission region in the inner accretion disk of a sample of solar-like young stellar objects. The goal is to identify trends and categories among the sources of our sample and to discuss whether or not they can be tied to diff…
▽ More
Aims: We aim to spatially and spectrally resolve the Br-gamma hydrogen emission line with the methods of interferometry in order to examine the kinematics of the hydrogen gas emission region in the inner accretion disk of a sample of solar-like young stellar objects. The goal is to identify trends and categories among the sources of our sample and to discuss whether or not they can be tied to different origin mechanisms associated with Br-gamma emission in T Tauri stars, chiefly and most prominently magnetospheric accretion.
Methods: We observed a sample of seven T Tauri stars for the first time with VLTI GRAVITY, recording spectra and spectrally dispersed interferometric quantities across the Br-gamma line in the NIR K-band. We use them to extract the size of the Br-gamma emission region and the photocenter shifts. To assist in the interpretation, we also make use of radiative transfer models of magnetospheric accretion to establish a baseline of expected interferometric signatures if accretion is the primary driver of Br-gamma emission.
Results: From among our sample, we find that five of the seven T~Tauri stars show an emission region with a half-flux radius in the range broadly expected for magnetospheric truncation. Two of the five objects also show Br-gamma emission primarily originating from within the corotation radius, while two other objects exhibit extended emission on a scale beyond 10 R$_*$, one of them even beyond the K~band continuum half-flux radius of 11.3 R$_*$.
Conclusions: We find strong evidence to suggest that for the two weakest accretors in the sample, magnetospheric accretion is the primary driver of Br-gamma radiation. The results for the remaining sources imply either partial or strong contributions coming from spatially extended emission components in the form of outflows, such as stellar or disk winds.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022; v1 submitted 24 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Atomic line radiative transfer with MCFOST I. Code description and benchmarking
Authors:
B. Tessore,
C. Pinte,
J. Bouvier,
F. Ménard
Abstract:
Aims. We present MCFOST-art, a new non-local thermodynamic equilibrium radiative transfer solver for multilevel atomic systems. The code is embedded in the 3D radiative transfer code MCFOST and is compatible with most of the MCFOST modules. The code is versatile and designed to model the close environment of stars in 3D. Methods. The code solves for the statistical equilibrium and radiative transf…
▽ More
Aims. We present MCFOST-art, a new non-local thermodynamic equilibrium radiative transfer solver for multilevel atomic systems. The code is embedded in the 3D radiative transfer code MCFOST and is compatible with most of the MCFOST modules. The code is versatile and designed to model the close environment of stars in 3D. Methods. The code solves for the statistical equilibrium and radiative transfer equations using the Multilevel Accelerated Lambda Iteration (MALI) method. We tested MCFOST-art on spherically symmetric models of stellar photospheres as well as on a standard model of the solar atmosphere. We computed atomic level populations and outgoing fluxes and compared these values with the results of the TURBOspectrum and RH codes. Calculations including expansion and rotation of the atmosphere were also performed. We tested both the pure local thermodynamic equilibrium and the out-of-equilibrium problems. Results. In all cases, the results from all codes agree within a few percent at all wavelengths and reach the sub-percent level between RH and MCFOST-art. We still note a few marginal discrepancies between MCFOST-art and TURBOspectrum as a result of different treatments of background opacities at some critical wavelength ranges.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Asymmetric shocks in $χ$ Cyg observed with linear spectropolarimetry
Authors:
A. López Ariste,
B. Tessore,
E. S. Carlín,
Ph. Mathias,
A. Lèbre,
J. Morin,
P. Petit,
M. Aurière,
D. Gillet,
F. Herpin
Abstract:
Aims: From a coherent interpretation of the linear polarisation detected in the spectral lines of the Mira star $χ$ Cyg, we derive information about the dynamics of the stellar photosphere, including pulsation.
Methods: From spectropolarimetric observations of $χ$ Cyg, we perform careful analysis of the polarisation signals observed in atomic and molecular lines, both in absorption and emission,…
▽ More
Aims: From a coherent interpretation of the linear polarisation detected in the spectral lines of the Mira star $χ$ Cyg, we derive information about the dynamics of the stellar photosphere, including pulsation.
Methods: From spectropolarimetric observations of $χ$ Cyg, we perform careful analysis of the polarisation signals observed in atomic and molecular lines, both in absorption and emission, using the radiative transfer in the polarisation context, through two mechanisms: intrinsic polarisation and continuum depolarisation. We also explain the observed line doubling phenomenon in terms of an expanding shell in spherical geometry, which allows us to pinpoint the coordinates over the stellar disk with enhanced polarisation.
Results: We find that the polarised spectrum of $χ$ Cyg is dominated by intrinsic polarisation, with a negligible continuum depolarisation.
The observed polarised signals can only be explained by assuming that this polarisation is locally enhanced by velocity fields.
During the pulsation, radial velocities are not homogeneous over the disk.
We map these regions of enhanced velocities.
Conclusions: We have set an algorithm to distinguish in any stellar spectra of linear polarisation the origin of this polarisation and the way to increase signal by coherently adding many lines with an appropriated weight. Applied to the Mira star $χ$ Cyg, we reached the unexpected result that during the pulsation, velocities are radial but not homogeneous over the disk. The reason for these local velocity enhancements are probably related to the interplay between the atmospheric pulsation dynamics and the underlying stellar convection.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Convective cells in Betelgeuse: imaging through spectropolarimetry
Authors:
A. López Ariste,
P. Mathias,
B. Tessore,
A. Lèbre,
M. Aurière,
P. Petit,
N. Ikhenache,
E. Josselin,
J. Morin,
M. Montargès
Abstract:
We assess the ability to image the photosphere of red supergiants and, in particular Betelgeuse, through the modelling of the observed linear polarization in atomic spectral lines. We also aim to analyse the resulting images over time, to measure the size and dynamics of the convective structures in these stars. Rayleigh scattering polarizes the continuum and spectral lines depolarize it.This depo…
▽ More
We assess the ability to image the photosphere of red supergiants and, in particular Betelgeuse, through the modelling of the observed linear polarization in atomic spectral lines. We also aim to analyse the resulting images over time, to measure the size and dynamics of the convective structures in these stars. Rayleigh scattering polarizes the continuum and spectral lines depolarize it.This depolarization is seen as a linear polarization signal parallel to the radial direction on the stellar disk. Integrated over the disk, it would result in a null signal, except if brightness asymmetries/inhomogeneities are present. This is the basic concept behind our imaging technique. The several tests and comparisons performed prove that our technique reliably retrieves the salient brightness structures in the photosphere of Betelgeuse, and should be relevant to other red supergiants. We demonstrate that these structures are convective cells, with a characteristic size of more than 60% of the stellar radius. We also derive the characteristic upflow and downflow speeds, 22 and 10 km/s respectively. We find weak magnetic fields concentrated in the downflow lanes in between granules. We follow those convective structures in time. Changes happen on timescales of one week, but individual structures can be tracked over four years of observations.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Evolution of the magnetic field of Betelgeuse from 2009 - 2017
Authors:
P. Mathias,
M. Aurière,
A. López Ariste,
P. Petit,
B. Tessore,
E. Josselin,
A. Lèbre,
J. Morin,
G. Wade,
F. Herpin,
A. Chiavassa,
M. Montargès,
R. Konstantinova-Antova,
P. Kervella,
G. Perrin,
J. -F. Donati,
J. Grunhut
Abstract:
Betelgeuse is an M-type supergiant that presents a circularly polarized (Stokes V) signal in its line profiles, interpreted in terms of a surface magnetic field.
The weak circular polarization signal has been monitored over 7.5 years in order to follow its evolution on different timescales, and eventually to determine its physical origin. Linear polarization measurements have also been obtained…
▽ More
Betelgeuse is an M-type supergiant that presents a circularly polarized (Stokes V) signal in its line profiles, interpreted in terms of a surface magnetic field.
The weak circular polarization signal has been monitored over 7.5 years in order to follow its evolution on different timescales, and eventually to determine its physical origin. Linear polarization measurements have also been obtained regularly in the last few years.
We used both the ESPaDOnS and Narval spectropolarimeters to obtain high signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) spectra, which were processed by means of the least-squares deconvolution (LSD) method. In order to ensure the reality of the very weak circular polarization, special care has been taken to limit instrumental effects. In addition, several tests were performed on the Stokes V signal to establish its stellar and Zeeman origin.
We confirm the magnetic nature of the circular polarization, pointing to a surface magnetic field of the order of 1G. The Stokes V profiles present variations over different timescales, the most prominent one being close to the long secondary period (LSP; around 2000d for Betelgeuse) often invoked in red evolved stars. This long period is also dominant for all the other Stokes parameters. The circular polarization is tentatively modeled by means of magnetic field concentrations mimicking spots, showing in particular that the velocity associated with each "spot" also follows the long timescale, and that this signal is nearly always slightly redshifted.
From the coupled variations of both linear and circular polarization signatures in amplitude, velocity and timescale, we favour giant convection cells as the main engine at the origin of polarization signatures and variations in all the Stokes parameters. This strengthens support for the hypothesis that large convective cells are at the origin of the LSP.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
The convective photosphere of the red supergiant CE Tau. I. VLTI/PIONIER H-band interferometric imaging
Authors:
M. Montargès,
R. Norris,
A. Chiavassa,
B. Tessore,
A. Lèbre,
F. Baron
Abstract:
Context. Red supergiant stars are one of the latest stages in the evolution of massive stars. Their photospheric convection may play an important role in the launching mechanism of their mass loss; however, its characteristics and dynamics are still poorly constrained. Aims. By observing red supergiant stars with near infrared interferometry at different epochs, we expect to reveal the evolution o…
▽ More
Context. Red supergiant stars are one of the latest stages in the evolution of massive stars. Their photospheric convection may play an important role in the launching mechanism of their mass loss; however, its characteristics and dynamics are still poorly constrained. Aims. By observing red supergiant stars with near infrared interferometry at different epochs, we expect to reveal the evolution of bright convective features on their stellar surface. Methods. We observed the M2Iab-Ib red supergiant star CE Tau with the VLTI/PIONIER instrument in the H band at two different epochs separated by one month. Results. We derive the angular diameter of the star and basic stellar parameters, and reconstruct two reliable images of its H-band photosphere. The contrast of the convective pattern of the reconstructed images is $5 \pm 1 \%$ and $6 \pm 1 \%$ for our two epochs of observation. Conclusions. The stellar photosphere shows few changes between the two epochs. The contrast of the convective pattern is below the average contrast variations obtained on 30 randomly chosen snapshots of the best matching 3D radiative hydrodynamics simulation: $23 \pm 1~\%$ for the original simulation images and $16 \pm 1~\%$ for the maps degraded to the reconstruction resolution. We offer two hypotheses to explain this observation. CE Tau may be experiencing a quiet convective activity episode or it could be a consequence of its warmer effective temperature (hence its smaller radius) compared to the simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Measuring surface magnetic fields of red supergiant stars
Authors:
Benjamin Tessore,
Agnès Lèbre,
Julien Morin,
Philippe Mathias,
Eric Josselin,
Michel Aurière
Abstract:
RSG stars are very massive cool evolved stars. Recently, a weak magnetic field was measured at the surface of $α$ Ori and this is so far the only M-type supergiant for which a direct detection of a surface magnetic field has been reported. By extending the search for surface magnetic field in a sample of late-type supergiants, we want to determine whether the surface magnetic field detected on…
▽ More
RSG stars are very massive cool evolved stars. Recently, a weak magnetic field was measured at the surface of $α$ Ori and this is so far the only M-type supergiant for which a direct detection of a surface magnetic field has been reported. By extending the search for surface magnetic field in a sample of late-type supergiants, we want to determine whether the surface magnetic field detected on $α$ Ori is a common feature among the M-type supergiants. With the spectropolarimeter Narval at TBL we undertook a search for surface magnetic fields in a sample of cool supergiant stars, and we analysed circular polarisation spectra using the least-squares deconvolution technique. We detect weak Zeeman signatures of stellar origin in the targets CE Tau, $α^1$ Her and $μ$ Cep. For the latter star, we also show that cross-talk from the strong linear polarisation signals detected on this star must be taken into account. For CE Tau and $μ$ Cep, the longitudinal component of the detected surface fields is at the Gauss-level, such as in $α$~Ori. We measured a longitudinal field almost an order of magnitude stronger for $α^1$ Her. We also report variability of the longitudinal magnetic field of CE Tau and $α^1$ Her, with changes in good agreement with the typical atmospheric dynamics time-scales. We also report a non-detection of magnetic field at the surface of the yellow supergiant star $ρ$ Cas. The two RSG stars of our sample, CE Tau and $μ$ Cep, display magnetic fields very similar to that of $α$ Ori. The non-detection of a magnetic field on the post-RSG star $ρ$ Cas suggests that the magnetic field disappears, or at least becomes undetectable with present methods, at later evolutionary stages. Our analysis of $α^1$ Her supports the proposed reclassification of the star as an AGB star.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2017; v1 submitted 25 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Detection of the linearly polarised spectrum of the red supergiant star alpha Ori
Authors:
Benjamin Tessore,
Arturo Lòpez-Ariste,
Philippe Mathias,
Agnès Lèbre,
Julien Morin,
Eric Josselin
Abstract:
In the solar limb, linear polarisation is due to anisotropy of the radiation field induced by limb darkening. It is maximal when it is seen parallel to the limb and it vanishes when it is integrated over the spherically-symmetric solar disk. Therefore for distant stars, that present spherical symmetry, linear polarisation signatures are very difficult to observe. However strong linear polarisation…
▽ More
In the solar limb, linear polarisation is due to anisotropy of the radiation field induced by limb darkening. It is maximal when it is seen parallel to the limb and it vanishes when it is integrated over the spherically-symmetric solar disk. Therefore for distant stars, that present spherical symmetry, linear polarisation signatures are very difficult to observe. However strong linear polarisation features have been reported in the prototypical red supergiant star alpha Ori (Betelgeuse). With an analytical model we propose to explain them.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2017; v1 submitted 7 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Discovery of a complex linearly polarized spectrum of Betelgeuse dominated by depolarization of the continuum
Authors:
M. Aurière,
A. López Ariste,
P. Mathias,
A. Lèbre,
E. Josselin,
M. Montargès,
P. Petit,
A. Chiavassa,
F. Paletou,
N. Fabas,
R. Konstantinova-Antova,
J. -F. Donati,
J. H. Grunhut,
G. A. Wade,
F. Herpin,
P. Kervella,
G. Perrin,
B. Tessore
Abstract:
Betelgeuse is an M supergiant that harbors spots and giant granules at its surface and presents linear polarization of its continuum. We have previously discovered linear polarization signatures associated with individual lines in the spectra of cool and evolved stars. Here, we investigate whether a similar linearly polarized spectrum exists for Betelgeuse. We used the spectropolarimeter Narval, c…
▽ More
Betelgeuse is an M supergiant that harbors spots and giant granules at its surface and presents linear polarization of its continuum. We have previously discovered linear polarization signatures associated with individual lines in the spectra of cool and evolved stars. Here, we investigate whether a similar linearly polarized spectrum exists for Betelgeuse. We used the spectropolarimeter Narval, combining multiple polarimetric sequences to obtain high signal-to-noise ratio spectra of individual lines, as well as the least-squares deconvolution (LSD) approach. We have discovered the existence of a linearly polarized spectrum for Betelgeuse, detecting a rather strong signal (at a few times 10$^{-4}$ of the continuum intensity level), both in individual lines and in the LSD profiles. Studying its properties and the signal observed for the resonant \ion{Na}{i}\,D lines, we conclude that we are mainly observing depolarization of the continuum by the absorption lines. The linear polarization of the Betelgeuse continuum is due to the anisotropy of the radiation field induced by brightness spots at the surface and Rayleigh scattering in the atmosphere. We have developed a geometrical model to interpret the observed polarization, from which we infer the presence of two brightness spots and their positions on the surface of Betelgeuse. We show that applying the model to each velocity bin along the Stokes Q and U profiles allows the derivation of a map of the bright spots. We use the Narval linear polarization observations of Betelgeuse obtained over a period of 1.4 years to study the evolution of the spots. Our study of the linearly polarized spectrum of Betelgeuse provides a novel method for studying the evolution of brightness spots at its surface and complements quasi-simultaneous observations obtained with PIONIER at the VLTI.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2016; v1 submitted 16 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
