-
Semi-classical imprints on quasinormal mode spectra
Authors:
Fil Simovic,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We compute quasinormal mode frequencies for static limits of physical black holes - semi-classical black hole solutions to Einstein-Hilbert gravity characterized by the finite formation time of an apparent horizon and its weak regularity. These assumptions lead to a highly constrained yet non-trivial form of the metric and components of the energy-momentum tensor near the horizon, which contain as…
▽ More
We compute quasinormal mode frequencies for static limits of physical black holes - semi-classical black hole solutions to Einstein-Hilbert gravity characterized by the finite formation time of an apparent horizon and its weak regularity. These assumptions lead to a highly constrained yet non-trivial form of the metric and components of the energy-momentum tensor near the horizon, which contain as a special case many known models of black holes. Using a two-point M-fraction approximation to construct an interpolating metric which captures the essential near-horizon and asymptotic properties of black holes, we explore a large part of the parameter space that characterizes the near-horizon geometry. We cast the perturbation problem as a discretized homogeneous eigensystem and compute the low-lying quasinormal mode frequencies for perturbations of a massless scalar field. Working in spherical symmetry, we provide rough constraints on leading and subleading deviations from the Schwarzschild solution which arise in a semi-classical setting, and demonstrate the potential for mimicking signatures of axially-symmetric geometries from a spherically-symmetric source.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2024; v1 submitted 28 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Unification of energy concepts in generalised phase space theories
Authors:
Libo Jiang,
Daniel R. Terno,
Oscar Dahlsten
Abstract:
We consider how to describe Hamiltonian mechanics in generalised probabilistic theories with the states represented as quasi-probability distributions. We give general operational definitions of energy-related concepts. We define generalised energy eigenstates as the purest stationary states. Planck's constant plays two different roles in the framework: the phase space volume taken up by a pure st…
▽ More
We consider how to describe Hamiltonian mechanics in generalised probabilistic theories with the states represented as quasi-probability distributions. We give general operational definitions of energy-related concepts. We define generalised energy eigenstates as the purest stationary states. Planck's constant plays two different roles in the framework: the phase space volume taken up by a pure state and a dynamical factor. The Hamiltonian is a linear combination of generalised energy eigenstates. This allows for a generalised Liouville time-evolution equation that applies to quantum and classical Hamiltonian mechanics and more. The approach enables a unification of quantum and classical energy concepts and a route to discussing energy in a wider set of theories.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
From reasonable postulates to generalised Hamiltonian systems
Authors:
Libo Jiang,
Daniel R. Terno,
Oscar Dahlsten
Abstract:
Hamiltonian mechanics describes the evolution of a system through its Hamiltonian. The Hamiltonian typically also represents the energy observable, a Noether-conserved quantity associated with the time-invariance of the law of evolution. In both quantum and classical mechanics, Hamiltonian mechanics demands a precise relationship between time evolution and observable energy, albeit using slightly…
▽ More
Hamiltonian mechanics describes the evolution of a system through its Hamiltonian. The Hamiltonian typically also represents the energy observable, a Noether-conserved quantity associated with the time-invariance of the law of evolution. In both quantum and classical mechanics, Hamiltonian mechanics demands a precise relationship between time evolution and observable energy, albeit using slightly different terminology. We distil basic conditions satisfied in both quantum and classical mechanics, including canonical coordinate symmetries and inner product invariance. We express these conditions in the framework of generalised probabilistic theories, which includes generalizing the definition of energy eigenstates in terms of time-invariant properties of the Hamiltonian system. By postulating these conditions to hold, we derive a unified Hamiltonian system model. This unified framework describes quantum and classical mechanics in a consistent language, facilitating their comparison. We moreover discuss alternative theories: an equation of motion given by a mixture of commutation relations, an information-restricted version of quantum theory, and Spekken's toy theory. The findings give a deeper understanding of the Hamiltonian in quantum and classical theories and point to several potential research topics.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Models of cosmological black holes
Authors:
Pravin K. Dahal,
Swayamsiddha Maharana,
Fil Simovic,
Ioannis Soranidis,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We study various aspects of modeling astrophysical black holes using the recently introduced semiclassical formalism of physical black holes (PBHs). This approach is based on the minimal requirements of observability and regularity of the horizons. We demonstrate that PBHs do not directly couple to the cosmological background in the current epoch, and their equation of state renders them unsuitabl…
▽ More
We study various aspects of modeling astrophysical black holes using the recently introduced semiclassical formalism of physical black holes (PBHs). This approach is based on the minimal requirements of observability and regularity of the horizons. We demonstrate that PBHs do not directly couple to the cosmological background in the current epoch, and their equation of state renders them unsuitable for describing dark energy. Utilizing their properties for analysis of more exotic models, we present a consistent semiclassical scenario for a black-to-white hole bounce and identify obstacles to the transformation from a black hole horizon to a wormhole mouth.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Horizon-bound objects: Kerr-Vaidya solutions
Authors:
Pravin K. Dahal,
Swayamsiddha Maharana,
Fil Simovic,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
The formation of horizons in finite time according to distant observers results in a number of remarkable properties of the objects they bound. Subject to this requirement, spherically-symmetric black holes can only decrease in mass, while white holes can only expand. We provide a detailed analysis of the latter scenario, focussing on the energy-momentum tensor near the horizon and the experiences…
▽ More
The formation of horizons in finite time according to distant observers results in a number of remarkable properties of the objects they bound. Subject to this requirement, spherically-symmetric black holes can only decrease in mass, while white holes can only expand. We provide a detailed analysis of the latter scenario, focussing on the energy-momentum tensor near the horizon and the experiences of various observers. Kerr-Vaidya metrics are the simplest dynamical axially-symmetric solutions, all of which violate the null energy condition and thus are not excluded by the criterion of finite formation time. Of the four classes of Kerr-Vaidya metrics, two correspond to the allowed spherically-symmetric solutions: evaporating black holes and expanding white holes. We demonstrate a consistent description of accreting black holes based on the ingoing Kerr-Vaidya metric with increasing mass, and show that the model can be extended to cases where the angular momentum to mass ratio varies. Their apparent horizon is shown to be weakly singular. Pathologies are also identified in the evaporating white hole geometry which reinforce controversies arising from the classical and quantum instabilities of their static counterparts. We also describe a generalization of the equivalence between Rindler and Schwarzschild horizons to Kerr-Vaidya black holes, and describe the relevant geometric constructions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2024; v1 submitted 6 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Classical-Quantum Hybrid Models
Authors:
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Hybrid classical-quantum models are computational schemes that investigate the time evolution of systems, where some degrees of freedom are treated classically, while others are described quantum-mechanically. First, we present the motivation for such models, outline the requirements they must satisfy, and provide explanations for their development. Then we review various popular non-relativistic…
▽ More
Hybrid classical-quantum models are computational schemes that investigate the time evolution of systems, where some degrees of freedom are treated classically, while others are described quantum-mechanically. First, we present the motivation for such models, outline the requirements they must satisfy, and provide explanations for their development. Then we review various popular non-relativistic schemes and their associated limitations, with a particular emphasis on reversible dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2024; v1 submitted 10 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Black holes as spherically-symmetric horizon-bound objects
Authors:
Pravin K. Dahal,
Fil Simovic,
Ioannis Soranidis,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Working in a semi-classical setting, we consider solutions of the Einstein equations that exhibit light trap** in finite time according to distant observers. In spherical symmetry, we construct near-horizon quantities from the assumption of regularity of the renormalized expectation value of the energy-momentum tensor, and derive explicit coordinate transformations in the near-horizon region. We…
▽ More
Working in a semi-classical setting, we consider solutions of the Einstein equations that exhibit light trap** in finite time according to distant observers. In spherical symmetry, we construct near-horizon quantities from the assumption of regularity of the renormalized expectation value of the energy-momentum tensor, and derive explicit coordinate transformations in the near-horizon region. We examine the boundary conditions appropriate for embedding the model into a cosmological background, describe their evaporation in the linear regime and highlight the observational consequences, while also discussing the implications for the laws of black hole mechanics.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2023; v1 submitted 28 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Matter and forces near physical black holes
Authors:
Pravin Kumar Dahal,
Ioannis Soranidis,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We describe general features of formation and disappearance of regular spherically symmetric black holes in semiclassical gravity. The allowed models are critically dependent on the requirement that the resulting objects evolve in finite time according to a distant observer. Violation of the null energy condition (NEC) is mandatory for this to happen, and we study the properties of the necessary e…
▽ More
We describe general features of formation and disappearance of regular spherically symmetric black holes in semiclassical gravity. The allowed models are critically dependent on the requirement that the resulting objects evolve in finite time according to a distant observer. Violation of the null energy condition (NEC) is mandatory for this to happen, and we study the properties of the necessary energy-momentum tensor in the vicinity of the apparent horizon. In studies of the kinematics of massive test particles, it is found that the escape from a black hole is possible only on the ingoing trajectories when the particles are overtaken by the contracting outer apparent horizon. Tidal forces experienced by geodesic observers, infalling or esca**, are shown to be finite at the apparent horizon, although this is not true for nongeodesic trajectories.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2022; v1 submitted 21 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Inaccessibility of traversable wormholes
Authors:
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Wormhole solutions to the equations of general relativity have some spectacular local and global properties. As these unusual features are not explicitly forbidden by known physics, wormholes are considered in various astrophysical and cosmological scenarios. The paradigmatic traversable wormhole models are described by static spherically-symmetric Ellis--Morris--Thorne and Simpson--Visser metrics…
▽ More
Wormhole solutions to the equations of general relativity have some spectacular local and global properties. As these unusual features are not explicitly forbidden by known physics, wormholes are considered in various astrophysical and cosmological scenarios. The paradigmatic traversable wormhole models are described by static spherically-symmetric Ellis--Morris--Thorne and Simpson--Visser metrics. We show that no dynamical solution of the semiclassical Einstein equations can have these metrics as their static limit. On the other hand, possible static limits of the dynamical solutions are not traversable. Moreover, they lead to violation of a quantum energy inequality that bounds violations of the null energy condition by quantum fields. This conclusion does not depend on specific properties of fields that may be proposed for wormhole construction. As a result, spherically-symmetric wormholes cannot exist in semiclassical gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2022; v1 submitted 7 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Controlling wave-particle duality with quantum entanglement
Authors:
Kai Wang,
Daniel R. Terno,
Caslav Brukner,
Shining Zhu,
Xiao-Song Ma
Abstract:
Wave-particle duality and entanglement are two fundamental characteristics of quantum mechanics. All previous works on experimental investigations in wave{particle properties of single photons (or single particles in general) show that a well-defined interferometer setting determines a well-defined property of single photons. Here we take a conceptual step forward and control the wave-particle pro…
▽ More
Wave-particle duality and entanglement are two fundamental characteristics of quantum mechanics. All previous works on experimental investigations in wave{particle properties of single photons (or single particles in general) show that a well-defined interferometer setting determines a well-defined property of single photons. Here we take a conceptual step forward and control the wave-particle property of single photons with quantum entanglement. By doing so, we experimentally test the complementarity principle in a scenario, in which the setting of the interferometer is not defined at any instance of the experiment, not even in principle. To achieve this goal, we send the photon of interest (S) into a quantum Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI), in which the output beam splitter of the MZI is controlled by the quantum state of the second photon (C), who is entangled with a third photon (A). Therefore, the individual quantum state of photon C is undefined, which implements the undefined settings of the MZI for photon S. This is realized by using three cascaded phase-stable interferometers for three photons. There is typically no well-defined setting of the MZI, and thus the very formulation of the wave-particle properties becomes internally inconsistent.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Black holes and their horizons in semiclassical and modified theories of gravity
Authors:
Robert B. Mann,
Sebastian Murk,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
For distant observers black holes are trapped spacetime domains bounded by apparent horizons. We review properties of the near-horizon geometry emphasizing the consequences of two common implicit assumptions of semiclassical physics. The first is a consequence of the cosmic censorship conjecture, namely that curvature scalars are finite at apparent horizons. The second is that horizons form in fin…
▽ More
For distant observers black holes are trapped spacetime domains bounded by apparent horizons. We review properties of the near-horizon geometry emphasizing the consequences of two common implicit assumptions of semiclassical physics. The first is a consequence of the cosmic censorship conjecture, namely that curvature scalars are finite at apparent horizons. The second is that horizons form in finite asymptotic time (i.e. according to distant observers), a property implicitly assumed in conventional descriptions of black hole formation and evaporation. Taking these as the only requirements within the semiclassical framework, we find that in spherical symmetry only two classes of dynamic solutions are admissible, both describing evaporating black holes and expanding white holes. We review their properties and present the implications. The null energy condition is violated in the vicinity of the outer horizon and satisfied in the vicinity of the inner apparent/anti-trap** horizon. Apparent and anti-trap** horizons are timelike surfaces of intermediately singular behavior, which manifests itself in negative energy density firewalls. These and other properties are also present in axially symmetric solutions. Different generalizations of surface gravity to dynamic spacetimes are discordant and do not match the semiclassical results. We conclude by discussing signatures of these models and implications for the identification of observed ultra-compact objects.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2022; v1 submitted 13 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Light rays in the Solar system experiments: phases and displacements
Authors:
Pravin Kumar Dahal,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Geometric optics approximation is sufficient to describe the effects in the near-Earth environment. In this framework Faraday rotation is purely a reference frame (gauge) effect. However, it cannot be simply dismissed. Establishing local reference frame with respect to some distant stars leads to the Faraday phase error between the ground station and the spacecraft of the order of $10^{-10}$ in th…
▽ More
Geometric optics approximation is sufficient to describe the effects in the near-Earth environment. In this framework Faraday rotation is purely a reference frame (gauge) effect. However, it cannot be simply dismissed. Establishing local reference frame with respect to some distant stars leads to the Faraday phase error between the ground station and the spacecraft of the order of $10^{-10}$ in the leading post-Newtonian expansion of the Earth's gravitational field. While the Wigner phase of special relativity is of the order $10^{-4}$--$10^{-5}$. Both types of errors can be simultaneously mitigated by simple encoding procedures. We also present briefly the covariant formulation of geometric optic correction up to the subleading order approximation, which is necessary for the propagation of electromagnetic/ gravitational waves of large but finite frequencies. We use this formalism to obtain a closed form of the polarization dependent correction of the light ray trajectory in the leading order in a weak spherically symmetric gravitational field.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Physical black holes in semiclassical gravity
Authors:
Sebastian Murk,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We derive and critically examine the consequences that follow from the formation of a regular black or white hole horizon in finite time of a distant observer. In spherical symmetry, only two distinct classes of solutions to the semiclassical Einstein equations are self-consistent. Both are required to describe the formation of physical black holes and violate the null energy condition in the vici…
▽ More
We derive and critically examine the consequences that follow from the formation of a regular black or white hole horizon in finite time of a distant observer. In spherical symmetry, only two distinct classes of solutions to the semiclassical Einstein equations are self-consistent. Both are required to describe the formation of physical black holes and violate the null energy condition in the vicinity of the outer apparent horizon. The near-horizon geometry differs considerably from that of classical solutions. If semiclassical physics is valid, accretion into a black hole is no longer possible after the horizon has formed. In addition, the two principal generalizations of surface gravity to dynamical spacetimes are irreconcilable, and neither can describe the emission of nearly-thermal radiation. Comparison of the required energy and timescales with established semiclassical results suggests that if the observed astrophysical black holes indeed have horizons, their formation is associated with new physics.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2022; v1 submitted 25 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Semiclassical black holes and horizon singularities
Authors:
Pravin K. Dahal,
Sebastian Murk,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
In spherical symmetry, solutions of the semiclassical Einstein equations belong to one of two possible classes. Both classes contain solutions that -- depending on the dynamic behavior of the horizon -- describe evaporating physical black holes or expanding white holes (trapped/anti-trapped regions that form in finite time of a distant observer). These solutions are real-valued only if the null en…
▽ More
In spherical symmetry, solutions of the semiclassical Einstein equations belong to one of two possible classes. Both classes contain solutions that -- depending on the dynamic behavior of the horizon -- describe evaporating physical black holes or expanding white holes (trapped/anti-trapped regions that form in finite time of a distant observer). These solutions are real-valued only if the null energy condition (NEC) is violated in the vicinity of the Schwarzschild sphere. We review their properties and describe the only consistent black hole formation scenario. While the curvature scalars are finite on the outer apparent/anti-trap** horizon, it is still a weakly singular surface. This singularity manifests itself in a mild firewall. Near the inner apparent horizon, the NEC is satisfied. Models of static regular black holes are known to be unstable, but since dynamic models of regular black holes are severely constrained by self-consistency requirements, their stability requires further investigation.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022; v1 submitted 2 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Paradoxes before the paradox: surface gravity and the information loss problem
Authors:
Robert B. Mann,
Sebastian Murk,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
The information loss paradox is widely regarded as one of the biggest open problems in theoretical physics. Several classical and quantum features must be present to enable its formulation. First, an event horizon is needed to justify the objective status of tracing out degrees of freedom inside the black hole. Second, evaporation must be completed (or nearly completed) in finite time according to…
▽ More
The information loss paradox is widely regarded as one of the biggest open problems in theoretical physics. Several classical and quantum features must be present to enable its formulation. First, an event horizon is needed to justify the objective status of tracing out degrees of freedom inside the black hole. Second, evaporation must be completed (or nearly completed) in finite time according to a distant observer, and thus the formation of the black hole should also occur in finite time. In spherical symmetry these requirements constrain the possible metrics strongly enough to obtain a unique black hole formation scenario and match their parameters with the semiclassical results. However, the two principal generalizations of surface gravity, the quantity that determines the Hawking temperature, do not agree with each other on the dynamical background. Neither can correspond to the emission of nearly-thermal radiation. We infer from this that the information loss problem cannot be consistently posed in its standard form.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2023; v1 submitted 28 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Polarization rotation and near-Earth quantum communications
Authors:
Pravin Kumar Dahal,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We revisit polarization rotation due to gravity, known as the gravitational Faraday effect, with a view on its role in quantum communications with Earth-orbiting satellites. In a static spherically symmetric gravitational field Faraday rotation is purely a reference frame (gauge) effect. This is so also in the leading post-Newtonian expansion of the Earth's gravitational field. However, establishi…
▽ More
We revisit polarization rotation due to gravity, known as the gravitational Faraday effect, with a view on its role in quantum communications with Earth-orbiting satellites. In a static spherically symmetric gravitational field Faraday rotation is purely a reference frame (gauge) effect. This is so also in the leading post-Newtonian expansion of the Earth's gravitational field. However, establishing the local reference frame with respect to distant stars leads to the nonzero Faraday phase. In communications between a ground station and an Earth-orbiting spacecraft this phase is of the order of 10^-10. Under the same conditions the Wigner phase of special relativity is typically of the order 10^-4--10^-5. These phases lead to the physical lower bound on communication errors. However, both types of errors can be simultaneously mitigated. Moreover, they are countered by a fully reference frame independent scheme that also handles arbitrary misalignment between the reference frames of sender and receiver.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2021; v1 submitted 25 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Spherically symmetric black holes in metric gravity
Authors:
Sebastian Murk,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
The existence of black holes is one of the key predictions of general relativity (GR) and therefore a basic consistency test for modified theories of gravity. In the case of spherical symmetry in GR the existence of an apparent horizon and its regularity is consistent with only two distinct classes of physical black holes. Here we derive constraints that any self-consistent modified theory of grav…
▽ More
The existence of black holes is one of the key predictions of general relativity (GR) and therefore a basic consistency test for modified theories of gravity. In the case of spherical symmetry in GR the existence of an apparent horizon and its regularity is consistent with only two distinct classes of physical black holes. Here we derive constraints that any self-consistent modified theory of gravity must satisfy to be compatible with their existence. We analyze their properties and illustrate characteristic features using the Starobinsky model. Both of the GR solutions can be regarded as zeroth-order terms in perturbative solutions of this model. We also show how to construct nonperturbative solutions without a well-defined GR limit.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2021; v1 submitted 21 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Universal properties of the near-horizon geometry
Authors:
Sebastian Murk,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We derive universal properties of the near-horizon geometry of spherically symmetric black holes that follow from the observability of a regular apparent horizon. Only two types of solutions are admissible. After reviewing their properties we show that only a special form of the solutions of the second type is consistent. We describe how these results extend to modified theories of gravity, includ…
▽ More
We derive universal properties of the near-horizon geometry of spherically symmetric black holes that follow from the observability of a regular apparent horizon. Only two types of solutions are admissible. After reviewing their properties we show that only a special form of the solutions of the second type is consistent. We describe how these results extend to modified theories of gravity, including Einstein--Cartan theories. Then we describe the unique black hole formation scenario that necessarily involves both types of solutions. The generalized surface gravity is infinite at the apparent horizon. This feature and comparison of the required energy and timescales with the known semiclassical results suggest that the observed astrophysical black holes are horizonless ultra-compact objects, and the presence of a horizon is associated with currently unknown physics.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2021; v1 submitted 8 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Kerr-Vaidya black holes
Authors:
Pravin Kumar Dahal,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Kerr-Vaidya metrics are the simplest nonstationary extensions of the Kerr metric. We explore their properties and compare them with the near-horizon limits of the spherically symmetric self-consistent solutions (the ingoing Vaidya metric with decreasing mass and the outgoing Vaidya metric with increasing mass) for the evaporating and accreting physical black holes. The Newman-Janis transformation…
▽ More
Kerr-Vaidya metrics are the simplest nonstationary extensions of the Kerr metric. We explore their properties and compare them with the near-horizon limits of the spherically symmetric self-consistent solutions (the ingoing Vaidya metric with decreasing mass and the outgoing Vaidya metric with increasing mass) for the evaporating and accreting physical black holes. The Newman-Janis transformation relates the corresponding Vaidya and Kerr-Vaidya metrics. For nonzero angular momentum, the energy-momentum tensor violates the null energy condition (NEC). However, we show that its structure differs from the standard form of the NEC-violating tensors. The apparent horizon in the outgoing Kerr-Vaidya metric coincides with that of the Kerr black hole. For the ingoing metric, its location is different. We derive the ordinary differential equation for this surface and locate it numerically. A spherically symmetric accreting black hole leads to a firewall -- a divergent energy density, pressure, and flux as perceived by an infalling observer. We show that this is also true for the outgoing Kerr-Vaidya metric
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2020; v1 submitted 31 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Pandora's box lid: geometry near the apparent horizon
Authors:
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Trapped regions bounded by horizons are the defining features of black holes. However, formation of a singularity-free apparent horizon in finite time of a distant observer is consistent only with special states of geometry and matter in its vicinity. In spherical symmetry such horizons exist only in two classes of solutions of the Einstein equations. Both violate the null energy condition (NEC) a…
▽ More
Trapped regions bounded by horizons are the defining features of black holes. However, formation of a singularity-free apparent horizon in finite time of a distant observer is consistent only with special states of geometry and matter in its vicinity. In spherical symmetry such horizons exist only in two classes of solutions of the Einstein equations. Both violate the null energy condition (NEC) and allow for expanding and contracting trapped regions. However, an expanding trapped region leads to a firewall. The weighted time average of the energy density for an observer crossing this firewall is negative and exceeds the maximal NEC violation that quantum fields can produce. As a result, either black holes only can evaporate or the semiclassical physics breaks down already at the horizons. Geometry of a contracting trapped region approaches the ingoing Vaidya metric with decreasing mass. Only one class of solutions allows for a test particle to cross the apparent horizon, and for a thin shell to collapse into a black hole. These results significantly constrain the regular black hole models. Models with regular matter properties at the horizon can be realized only if significant departures from the semiclassical physics occur already at the horizon scale. The Hayward-Frolov model may describe only evaporation, but not formation of a regular black hole.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2020; v1 submitted 27 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Weak-value magnetometry for precision tests of fundamental physics
Authors:
Sounok Ghosh,
Leong-Chuan Kwek,
Daniel R. Terno,
Sai Vinjanampathy
Abstract:
Progress in testing fundamental physics relies on our ability to measure exceedingly small physical quantities. Using a $^{40}$Ca$^{+}$ trapped ion system as an example we show that an exceedingly weak synthetic magnetic field (at the scale of $10^{-19}$ T) can be measured with current technology. This improved sensitivity can be used to test the effects of spin coupling that affect the equivalenc…
▽ More
Progress in testing fundamental physics relies on our ability to measure exceedingly small physical quantities. Using a $^{40}$Ca$^{+}$ trapped ion system as an example we show that an exceedingly weak synthetic magnetic field (at the scale of $10^{-19}$ T) can be measured with current technology. This improved sensitivity can be used to test the effects of spin coupling that affect the equivalence principle and, if present, may impact the performance of the proposed entangled optical clocks arrays.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Large-scale optical interferometry in general spacetimes
Authors:
Daniel R. Terno,
Giuseppe Vallone,
Francesco Vedovato,
Paolo Villoresi
Abstract:
We introduce a convenient formalism to evaluate the frequency-shift affecting a light signal propagating on a general curved background. Our formulation, which is based on the laws of geometric optics in a general relativistic setting, allows to obtain a transparent generalization of the Doppler frequency-shift without requiring to perform Local Lorentz transformations. It is easily applicable to…
▽ More
We introduce a convenient formalism to evaluate the frequency-shift affecting a light signal propagating on a general curved background. Our formulation, which is based on the laws of geometric optics in a general relativistic setting, allows to obtain a transparent generalization of the Doppler frequency-shift without requiring to perform Local Lorentz transformations. It is easily applicable to stationary spacetimes, and in particular to the near-Earth experiments where geometry is described in the parametrized post-Newtonian approximation. We apply our recipe to evaluate the phase-shift arising in large-scale optical interferometric experiments, as the optical version of the Colella-Overhauser-Werner experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2020; v1 submitted 12 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Quantum satellites and tests of relativity
Authors:
Piergiovanni Magnani,
Matteo Schiavon,
Alexander R. H. Smith,
Daniel R. Terno,
Giuseppe Vallone,
Francesco Vedovato,
Paolo Villoresi,
Sai Vinjanampathy
Abstract:
Deployment of quantum technology in space provides opportunities for new types of precision tests of gravity. On the other hand, the operational demands of such technology can make previously unimportant effects practically relevant. We describe a novel optical interferometric red-shift measurement and a measurement scheme designed to witness possible spin-gravity coupling effects.
Deployment of quantum technology in space provides opportunities for new types of precision tests of gravity. On the other hand, the operational demands of such technology can make previously unimportant effects practically relevant. We describe a novel optical interferometric red-shift measurement and a measurement scheme designed to witness possible spin-gravity coupling effects.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Trapped surfaces, energy conditions, and horizon avoidance in spherically-symmetric collapse
Authors:
Valentina Baccetti,
Robert B. Mann,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We consider spherically-symmetric black holes in semiclassical gravity. For a collapsing radiating thin shell we derive a sufficient condition on the exterior geometry that ensures that a black hole is not formed. This is also a sufficient condition for an infalling test particle to avoid the apparent horizon of an existing black hole and approach it only within a certain minimal distance. Taking…
▽ More
We consider spherically-symmetric black holes in semiclassical gravity. For a collapsing radiating thin shell we derive a sufficient condition on the exterior geometry that ensures that a black hole is not formed. This is also a sufficient condition for an infalling test particle to avoid the apparent horizon of an existing black hole and approach it only within a certain minimal distance. Taking the presence of a trapped region and its outer boundary --- the apparent horizon--- as the defining feature of black holes, we explore the consequences of their finite time of formation according to a distant observer. Assuming regularity of the apparent horizon we obtain the limiting form of the metric and the energy-momentum tensor in its vicinity that violates the null energy condition (NEC). The metric does not satisfy the sufficient condition for horizon avoidance: a thin shell collapses to form a black hole and test particles (unless too slow) cross into it in finite time. However, there may be difficulty in maintaining the expected range of the NEC violation, and stability against perturbations is not assured.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2019; v1 submitted 31 March, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Black hole evaporation and semiclassical thin shell collapse
Authors:
Valentina Baccetti,
Sebastian Murk,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
In case of spherical symmetry, the assumptions of finite-time formation of a trapped region and regularity of its boundary --- the apparent horizon --- are sufficient to identify the form of the metric and energy-momentum tensor in its vicinity. By comparison with the known results for quasistatic evaporation of black holes, we complete the identification of their parameters. Consistency of the Ei…
▽ More
In case of spherical symmetry, the assumptions of finite-time formation of a trapped region and regularity of its boundary --- the apparent horizon --- are sufficient to identify the form of the metric and energy-momentum tensor in its vicinity. By comparison with the known results for quasistatic evaporation of black holes, we complete the identification of their parameters. Consistency of the Einstein equations allows only two possible types of higher-order terms in the energy-momentum tensor. By using its local conservation, we provide a method of calculation of the higher-order terms, explicitly determining the leading-order regular corrections. Contraction of a spherically symmetric thin dust shell is the simplest model of gravitational collapse. Nevertheless, the inclusion of a collapse-triggered radiation in different extensions of this model leads to apparent contradictions. Using our results, we resolve these contradictions and show how gravitational collapse may be completed in finite time according to a distant observer.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2020; v1 submitted 18 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Proposal for an optical interferometric measurement of the gravitational red-shift with satellite systems
Authors:
Daniel R. Terno,
Francesco Vedovato,
Matteo Schiavon,
Alexander R. H. Smith,
Piergiovanni Magnani,
Giuseppe Vallone,
Paolo Villoresi
Abstract:
The Einstein Equivalence Principle (EEP) underpins all metric theories of gravity. One of its key aspects is the local position invariance (LPI) of non-gravitational experiments, which is captured by the gravitational red-shift. The iconic gravitational red-shift experiment places two fermionic systems, used as clocks, in different gravitational potentials and compares them using the electromagnet…
▽ More
The Einstein Equivalence Principle (EEP) underpins all metric theories of gravity. One of its key aspects is the local position invariance (LPI) of non-gravitational experiments, which is captured by the gravitational red-shift. The iconic gravitational red-shift experiment places two fermionic systems, used as clocks, in different gravitational potentials and compares them using the electromagnetic field. However, the electromagnetic field itself can be used as a clock, by comparing the phases acquired by two optical pulses propagating through different gravitational potentials. A fundamental point in the implementation of a satellite large-distance optical interferometric experiment is the suppression of the first-order Doppler effect, which dominates the weak gravitational signal necessary to test the EEP. Here, we propose a novel scheme to suppress it, by subtracting the phase-shifts measured in the one-way and in the two-way configuration between a ground station and a satellite. We present a detailed analysis of this technique within the post-Newtonian framework and perform some simulations of its performance using realistic satellite orbits and the state-of-the-art fiber technology at the telecom wavelength of 1550 nm.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2023; v1 submitted 12 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Energy-momentum tensor and metric near the Schwarzschild sphere
Authors:
Valentina Baccetti,
Robert B. Mann,
Sebastian Murk,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Regularity of the horizon radius $r_g$ of a collapsing body constrains a limiting form of a spherically-symmetric energy-momentum tensor near it. Its non-zero limit belongs to one of four classes that are distinguished only by two signs. As a result, close to $r_g$ the geometry can always be described by either an ingoing or outgoing Vaidya metric with increasing or decreasing mass. If according t…
▽ More
Regularity of the horizon radius $r_g$ of a collapsing body constrains a limiting form of a spherically-symmetric energy-momentum tensor near it. Its non-zero limit belongs to one of four classes that are distinguished only by two signs. As a result, close to $r_g$ the geometry can always be described by either an ingoing or outgoing Vaidya metric with increasing or decreasing mass. If according to a distant outside observer the trapped regions form in finite time, then the Einstein equations imply violation of the null energy condition. In this case the horizon radius and its rate of change determine the metric in its vicinity, and the hypersurface $r = r_g(t)$ is timelike during both the expansion and contraction of the trapped region. We present the implications of these results for the firewall paradox and discuss arguments that the required violation of the null energy condition is incompatible with the standard analysis of black hole evaporation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2019; v1 submitted 11 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Transition to light-like trajectories in thin shell dynamics
Authors:
Robert B. Mann,
Ian Nagle,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
It was recently shown that a massive thin shell that is sandwiched between a flat interior and an exterior geometry given by the outgoing Vaidya metric becomes null in a finite proper time. We investigate this transition for a general spherically-symmetric metric outside the shell and find that it occurs generically. Once the shell is null its persistence on a null trajectory can be ensured by sev…
▽ More
It was recently shown that a massive thin shell that is sandwiched between a flat interior and an exterior geometry given by the outgoing Vaidya metric becomes null in a finite proper time. We investigate this transition for a general spherically-symmetric metric outside the shell and find that it occurs generically. Once the shell is null its persistence on a null trajectory can be ensured by several mechanisms that we describe. Using the outgoing Vaidya metric as an example we show that if a dust shell acquires surface pressure on its transition to a null trajectory it can evade the Schwarzschild radius through its collapse. Alternatively, the pressureless collapse may continue if the exterior geometry acquires a more general form.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Do event horizons exist?
Authors:
Valentina Baccetti,
Robert B. Mann,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Event horizons are the defining feature of classical black holes. They are the key ingredient of the information loss paradox which, as paradoxes in quantum foundations, is built on a combination of predictions of quantum theory and counterfactual classical features: neither horizon formation nor its crossing by a test body is observable. Furthermore, horizons are unnecessary for the production of…
▽ More
Event horizons are the defining feature of classical black holes. They are the key ingredient of the information loss paradox which, as paradoxes in quantum foundations, is built on a combination of predictions of quantum theory and counterfactual classical features: neither horizon formation nor its crossing by a test body is observable. Furthermore, horizons are unnecessary for the production of Hawking-like radiation. We demonstrate that when this radiation is taken into account it prevents horizon crossing/formation in a large class of models. We conjecture that horizon avoidance is a general feature of collapse. The non-existence of event horizons dispels the paradox, but opens up important questions about thermodynamic properties of the resulting objects and correlations between different degrees of freedom.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2017; v1 submitted 4 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Horizon avoidance in spherically-symmetric collapse
Authors:
Valentina Baccetti,
Robert B. Mann,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We study collapse of evaporating spherically-symmetric thin dust shells and dust balls assuming that quantum effects are encapsulated in a spherically-symmetric metric that satisfied mild regularity conditions. The evaporation may accelerate collapse, but for a generic metric the Schwarzschild radius is not crossed. Instead the shell (or the layer in the ball of dust) is always at a certain sub-Pl…
▽ More
We study collapse of evaporating spherically-symmetric thin dust shells and dust balls assuming that quantum effects are encapsulated in a spherically-symmetric metric that satisfied mild regularity conditions. The evaporation may accelerate collapse, but for a generic metric the Schwarzschild radius is not crossed. Instead the shell (or the layer in the ball of dust) is always at a certain sub-Planckian distance from it.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
The information recovery problem
Authors:
Valentina Baccetti,
Viqar Husain,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
The issue of unitary evolution during creation and evaporation of a black hole remains controversial. We~argue that some prominent cures are more troubling than the disease, demonstrate that their central element---forming of the event horizon before the evaporation begins---is not necessarily true, and describe a fully coupled matter-gravity system which is manifestly unitary.
The issue of unitary evolution during creation and evaporation of a black hole remains controversial. We~argue that some prominent cures are more troubling than the disease, demonstrate that their central element---forming of the event horizon before the evaporation begins---is not necessarily true, and describe a fully coupled matter-gravity system which is manifestly unitary.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2017; v1 submitted 31 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Role of evaporation in gravitational collapse
Authors:
Valentina Baccetti,
Robert B. Mann,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We investigate the possibility that quantum effects responsible for black hole radiation do not allow for hori- zon crossing of gravitationally collapsing matter in a finite time as seen by distant observers. We consider this in the context of the collapse of evaporating massive thin dust shells using two families of metrics to describe the exterior geometry: the outgoing Vaidya metric and the ret…
▽ More
We investigate the possibility that quantum effects responsible for black hole radiation do not allow for hori- zon crossing of gravitationally collapsing matter in a finite time as seen by distant observers. We consider this in the context of the collapse of evaporating massive thin dust shells using two families of metrics to describe the exterior geometry: the outgoing Vaidya metric and the retarded Schwarzschild metric. We describe how this hypothesis results in a modified equation of motion for the shell. In each case the collapse is accelerated due to evaporation, but the Schwarzschild radius is not crossed. Instead the shell is always at a certain sub-Planckian distance from this would-be horizon that depends only on the mass and evaporation rate, while a comoving observer encounters firewall-like energy density and flux with a natural cutoff.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2017; v1 submitted 25 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Why should we care about quantum discord?
Authors:
Aharon Brodutch,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Entanglement is a central feature of quantum theory. Mathematical properties and physical applications of pure state entanglement make it a template to study quantum correlations. However, an extension of entanglement measures to mixed states in terms of separability does not always correspond to all the operational aspects. Quantum discord measures allow an alternative way to extend the idea of q…
▽ More
Entanglement is a central feature of quantum theory. Mathematical properties and physical applications of pure state entanglement make it a template to study quantum correlations. However, an extension of entanglement measures to mixed states in terms of separability does not always correspond to all the operational aspects. Quantum discord measures allow an alternative way to extend the idea of quantum correlations to mixed states. In many cases these extensions are motivated by physical scenarios and quantum information protocols. In this chapter we discuss several settings involving correlated quantum systems, ranging from distributed gates to detectors testing quantum fields. In each setting we show how entanglement fails to capture the relevant features of the correlated system, and discuss the role of discord as a possible alternative.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Spin and localization of relativistic fermions and uncertainty relations
Authors:
Lucas C. Céleri,
Vasilis Kiosses,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We discuss relations between several relativistic spin observables and derive a Lorentz-invariant characteristic of a reduced spin density matrix.A relativistic position operator that satisfies all the properties of its nonrelativistic analog does not exist. Instead we propose two causality-preserving positive operator-valued measures (POVMs) that are based on projections onto one-particle and ant…
▽ More
We discuss relations between several relativistic spin observables and derive a Lorentz-invariant characteristic of a reduced spin density matrix.A relativistic position operator that satisfies all the properties of its nonrelativistic analog does not exist. Instead we propose two causality-preserving positive operator-valued measures (POVMs) that are based on projections onto one-particle and antiparticle spaces, and on the normalized energy density. They predict identical expectation values for position. The variances differ by less than a quarter of the squared de Broglie wavelength and coincide in the nonrelativistic limit. Since the resulting statistical moment operators are not canonical conjugates of momentum, the Heisenberg uncertainty relations need not hold. Indeed, the energy density POVM leads to a lower uncertainty. We reformulate the standard equations of the spin dynamics by explicitly considering the charge-independent acceleration, allowing a consistent treatment of backreaction and inclusion of a weak gravitational field.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2016; v1 submitted 1 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Classicality of a quantum oscillator
Authors:
Aida Ahmadzadegan,
Robert B. Mann,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Gaussian quantum systems exhibit many explicitly quantum effects but can be simulated classically. Using both the Hilbert space (Koopman) and the phase-space (Moyal) formalisms we investigate how robust this classicality is. We find failures of consistency of the dynamics of a hybrid classical-quantum systems from both perspectives. By demanding that no unobservable operators couple to the quantum…
▽ More
Gaussian quantum systems exhibit many explicitly quantum effects but can be simulated classically. Using both the Hilbert space (Koopman) and the phase-space (Moyal) formalisms we investigate how robust this classicality is. We find failures of consistency of the dynamics of a hybrid classical-quantum systems from both perspectives. By demanding that no unobservable operators couple to the quantum sector in the Koopmanian formalism, we show that the classical equations of motion act on their quantum counterparts without experiencing any back-reaction, resulting in non-conservation of energy in the quantum system. Using the phase-space formalism we study the short time evolution of the moment equations of a hybrid classical-Gaussian quantum system and observe violations of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Relation in the quantum sector for a broad range of initial conditions. We estimate the time scale for these violations, which is generically rather short. This inconsistency indicates that while many explicitly quantum effects can be represented classically, quantum aspects of the system cannot be fully masked. We comment on the implications of our results for quantum gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2017; v1 submitted 14 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Spacetime structure and vacuum entanglement
Authors:
Eduardo Martin-Martinez,
Alexander R. H. Smith,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We study the role that both vacuum fluctuations and vacuum entanglement of a scalar field play in identifying the spacetime topology, which is not prescribed from first principles---neither in general relativity or quantum gravity. We analyze how the entanglement and observable correlations acquired between two particle detectors are sensitive to the spatial topology of spacetime. We examine the d…
▽ More
We study the role that both vacuum fluctuations and vacuum entanglement of a scalar field play in identifying the spacetime topology, which is not prescribed from first principles---neither in general relativity or quantum gravity. We analyze how the entanglement and observable correlations acquired between two particle detectors are sensitive to the spatial topology of spacetime. We examine the detector's time evolution to all orders in perturbation theory and then study the phenomenon of vacuum entanglement harvesting in Minkowski spacetime and two flat topologically distinct spacetimes constructed from identifications of the Minkowski space. We show that, for instance, if the spatial topology induces a preferred direction, this direction may be inferred from the dependence of correlations between the two detectors on their orientation. We therefore show that vacuum fluctuations and vacuum entanglement harvesting makes it, in principle, possible to distinguish spacetimes with identical local geometry that differ only in their topology.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Post-Newtonian gravitational effects in quantum interferometry
Authors:
Aharon Brodutch,
Alexei Gilchrist,
Thomas Guff,
Alexander R. H. Smith,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We investigate general properties of optical interferometry in stationary spacetimes and apply the obtained results focusing on quantum-optical experiments in near-Earth environments. We provide a rigorous expression for the {gravitationally induced} phase difference and adapt the parametrized post-Newtonian formalism for calculations of polarization rotation. We investigate two optical versions o…
▽ More
We investigate general properties of optical interferometry in stationary spacetimes and apply the obtained results focusing on quantum-optical experiments in near-Earth environments. We provide a rigorous expression for the {gravitationally induced} phase difference and adapt the parametrized post-Newtonian formalism for calculations of polarization rotation. We investigate two optical versions of the Colella-Overhauser-Werner experiment and show that the phase difference is independent of the post-Newtonian parameter $γ$, making it a possible candidate for an optical test of the Einstein equivalence principle. Polarization rotation provides an example of the quantum clock variable, and while related to the optical Lense-Thirring effects, shows a qualitatively different behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Determinism, independence and objectivity are incompatible
Authors:
Radu Ionicioiu,
Robert B. Mann,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Hidden-variable models aim to reproduce the results of quantum theory and to satisfy our classical intuition. Their refutation is usually based on deriving predictions that are different from those of quantum mechanics. Here instead we study the mutual compatibility of apparently reasonable classical assumptions. We analyze a version of the delayed-choice experiment which ostensibly combines deter…
▽ More
Hidden-variable models aim to reproduce the results of quantum theory and to satisfy our classical intuition. Their refutation is usually based on deriving predictions that are different from those of quantum mechanics. Here instead we study the mutual compatibility of apparently reasonable classical assumptions. We analyze a version of the delayed-choice experiment which ostensibly combines determinism, independence of hidden variables on the conducted experiments, and wave-particle objectivity (the assertion that quantum systems are, at any moment, either particles or waves, but not both). These three ideas are incompatible with any theory, not only with quantum mechanics.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2015; v1 submitted 16 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Towards Quantifying Complexity with Quantum Mechanics
Authors:
Ryan Tan,
Daniel R. Terno,
Jayne Thompson,
Vlatko Vedral,
Mile Gu
Abstract:
While we have intuitive notions of structure and complexity, the formalization of this intuition is non-trivial. The statistical complexity is a popular candidate. It is based on the idea that the complexity of a process can be quantified by the complexity of its simplest mathematical model - the model that requires the least past information for optimal future prediction. Here we review how such…
▽ More
While we have intuitive notions of structure and complexity, the formalization of this intuition is non-trivial. The statistical complexity is a popular candidate. It is based on the idea that the complexity of a process can be quantified by the complexity of its simplest mathematical model - the model that requires the least past information for optimal future prediction. Here we review how such models, known as $ε$-machines can be further simplified through quantum logic, and explore the resulting consequences for understanding complexity. In particular, we propose a new measure of complexity based on quantum $ε$-machines. We apply this to a simple system undergoing constant thermalization. The resulting quantum measure of complexity aligns more closely with our intuition of how complexity should behave.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2014; v1 submitted 24 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Localization of relativistic particles and uncertainty relations
Authors:
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Localization of relativistic particles and their position-momentum uncertainty relations are not yet fully understood. We discuss two schemes of photon localization that are based on the energy density. One scheme produces a positive operator-valued measure for localization. It coincides with the number density operator and reproduces the effective 3x3 polarization density matrix. Another scheme r…
▽ More
Localization of relativistic particles and their position-momentum uncertainty relations are not yet fully understood. We discuss two schemes of photon localization that are based on the energy density. One scheme produces a positive operator-valued measure for localization. It coincides with the number density operator and reproduces the effective 3x3 polarization density matrix. Another scheme results in a probability distribution that is conditioned on the detection. In both schemes the uncertainty relations for transversal position and momentum approach the Heisenberg bound $Δp Δz= \hbar/2$
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2014; v1 submitted 2 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Quantum control in foundational experiments
Authors:
Lucas C. Celeri,
Rafael M. Gomes,
Radu Ionicioiu,
Thomas Jennewein,
Robert B. Mann,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We describe a new class of experiments designed to probe the foundations of quantum mechanics. Using quantum controlling devices, we show how to attain a freedom in temporal ordering of the control and detection of various phenomena. We consider wave-particle duality in the context of quantum-controlled and the entanglement-assisted delayed-choice experiments. Then we discuss a quantum-controlled…
▽ More
We describe a new class of experiments designed to probe the foundations of quantum mechanics. Using quantum controlling devices, we show how to attain a freedom in temporal ordering of the control and detection of various phenomena. We consider wave-particle duality in the context of quantum-controlled and the entanglement-assisted delayed-choice experiments. Then we discuss a quantum-controlled CHSH experiment and measurement of photon's transversal position and momentum in a single set-up.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2014; v1 submitted 29 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Is wave-particle objectivity compatible with determinism and locality?
Authors:
Radu Ionicioiu,
Thomas Jennewein,
Robert B. Mann,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Wave-particle duality, superposition and entanglement are among the most counterintuitive features of quantum theory. Their clash with our classical expectations motivated hidden-variable (HV) theories. With the emergence of quantum technologies we can test experimentally the predictions of quantum theory {\em versus} HV theories and put strong restrictions on their key assumptions. Here we study…
▽ More
Wave-particle duality, superposition and entanglement are among the most counterintuitive features of quantum theory. Their clash with our classical expectations motivated hidden-variable (HV) theories. With the emergence of quantum technologies we can test experimentally the predictions of quantum theory {\em versus} HV theories and put strong restrictions on their key assumptions. Here we study an entanglement-assisted version of the quantum delayed-choice experiment and show that the extension of HV to the controlling devices only exacerbates the contradiction. We compare HV theories that satisfy the conditions of objectivity (a property of photons being either particles or waves, but not both), determinism, and local independence of hidden variables with quantum mechanics. Any two of the above conditions are compatible with it. The conflict becomes manifest when all three conditions are imposed and persists for any non-zero value of entanglement. We propose an experiment to test our conclusions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2015; v1 submitted 5 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Entropy and entanglement in polymer quantization
Authors:
Tommaso F. Demarie,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Polymer quantization is as a useful toy model for the mathematical aspects of loop quantum gravity and is interesting in its own right. Analyzing entropies of physically equivalent states in the standard Hilbert space and the polymer Hilbert space we show that they converge in the limit of vanishing polymer scale. We derive a general bound that relates entropies of physically equivalent states in…
▽ More
Polymer quantization is as a useful toy model for the mathematical aspects of loop quantum gravity and is interesting in its own right. Analyzing entropies of physically equivalent states in the standard Hilbert space and the polymer Hilbert space we show that they converge in the limit of vanishing polymer scale. We derive a general bound that relates entropies of physically equivalent states in unitarily inequivalent representations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2013; v1 submitted 13 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Fundamental quantum optics experiments conceivable with satellites -- reaching relativistic distances and velocities
Authors:
David Rideout,
Thomas Jennewein,
Giovanni Amelino-Camelia,
Tommaso F. Demarie,
Brendon L. Higgins,
Achim Kempf,
Adrian Kent,
Raymond Laflamme,
Xian Ma,
Robert B. Mann,
Eduardo Martin-Martinez,
Nicolas C. Menicucci,
John Moffat,
Christoph Simon,
Rafael Sorkin,
Lee Smolin,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Physical theories are developed to describe phenomena in particular regimes, and generally are valid only within a limited range of scales. For example, general relativity provides an effective description of the Universe at large length scales, and has been tested from the cosmic scale down to distances as small as 10 meters. In contrast, quantum theory provides an effective description of physic…
▽ More
Physical theories are developed to describe phenomena in particular regimes, and generally are valid only within a limited range of scales. For example, general relativity provides an effective description of the Universe at large length scales, and has been tested from the cosmic scale down to distances as small as 10 meters. In contrast, quantum theory provides an effective description of physics at small length scales. Direct tests of quantum theory have been performed at the smallest probeable scales at the Large Hadron Collider, ${\sim} 10^{-20}$ meters, up to that of hundreds of kilometers. Yet, such tests fall short of the scales required to investigate potentially significant physics that arises at the intersection of quantum and relativistic regimes. We propose to push direct tests of quantum theory to larger and larger length scales, approaching that of the radius of curvature of spacetime, where we begin to probe the interaction between gravity and quantum phenomena. In particular, we review a wide variety of potential tests of fundamental physics that are conceivable with artificial satellites in Earth orbit and elsewhere in the solar system, and attempt to sketch the magnitudes of potentially observable effects. The tests have the potential to determine the applicability of quantum theory at larger length scales, eliminate various alternative physical theories, and place bounds on phenomenological models motivated by ideas about spacetime microstructure from quantum gravity. From a more pragmatic perspective, as quantum communication technologies such as quantum key distribution advance into Space towards large distances, some of the fundamental physical effects discussed here may need to be taken into account to make such schemes viable.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2012; v1 submitted 21 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Entropy in the Classical and Quantum Polymer Black Hole Models
Authors:
Etera R. Livine,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We investigate the entropy counting for black hole horizons in loop quantum gravity (LQG). We argue that the space of 3d closed polyhedra is the classical counterpart of the space of SU(2) intertwiners at the quantum level. Then computing the entropy for the boundary horizon amounts to calculating the density of polyhedra or the number of intertwiners at fixed total area. Following the previous wo…
▽ More
We investigate the entropy counting for black hole horizons in loop quantum gravity (LQG). We argue that the space of 3d closed polyhedra is the classical counterpart of the space of SU(2) intertwiners at the quantum level. Then computing the entropy for the boundary horizon amounts to calculating the density of polyhedra or the number of intertwiners at fixed total area. Following the previous work arXiv:1011.5628, we dub these the classical and quantum polymer models for isolated horizons in LQG. We provide exact micro-canonical calculations for both models and we show that the classical counting of polyhedra accounts for most of the features of the intertwiner counting (leading order entropy and log-correction), thus providing us with a simpler model to further investigate correlations and dynamics. To illustrate this, we also produce an exact formula for the dimension of the intertwiner space as a density of "almost-closed polyhedra".
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Photon polarization and geometric phase in general relativity
Authors:
Aharon Brodutch,
Tommaso F. Demarie,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Rotation of polarization in an external gravitational field is one of the effects of general relativity that can serve as a basis for its precision tests. A careful analysis of reference frames is crucial for a proper evaluation of this effect. We introduce an operationally-motivated local reference frame that allows for a particularly simple description. We present a solution of null geodesics in…
▽ More
Rotation of polarization in an external gravitational field is one of the effects of general relativity that can serve as a basis for its precision tests. A careful analysis of reference frames is crucial for a proper evaluation of this effect. We introduce an operationally-motivated local reference frame that allows for a particularly simple description. We present a solution of null geodesics in Kerr space-time that is organized around a new expansion parameter, allowing a better control of the series, and use it to calculate the resulting polarization rotation. While this rotation depends on the reference-frame convention, we demonstrate a gauge-independent geometric phase for closed paths in general space-times.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2011; v1 submitted 3 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Polarization rotation, reference frames and Mach's principle
Authors:
Aharon Brodutch,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Polarization of light rotates in a gravitational field. The accrued phase is operationally meaningful only with respect to a local polarization basis. In stationary space-times, we construct local reference frames that allow us to isolate the Machian gravimagnetic effect from the geodetic (mass) contribution to the rotation. The Machian effect is supplemented by the geometric term that arises from…
▽ More
Polarization of light rotates in a gravitational field. The accrued phase is operationally meaningful only with respect to a local polarization basis. In stationary space-times, we construct local reference frames that allow us to isolate the Machian gravimagnetic effect from the geodetic (mass) contribution to the rotation. The Machian effect is supplemented by the geometric term that arises from the choice of standard polarizations. The phase accrued along a close trajectory is gauge-independent and is zero in the Schwarzschild space-time. The geometric term may give a dominant contribution to the phase. We calculate polarization rotation for several trajectories and find it to be more significant than is usually believed, pointing to its possible role as a future gravity probe.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2011; v1 submitted 6 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
Proposal for a quantum delayed-choice experiment
Authors:
Radu Ionicioiu,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
Gedanken experiments are important conceptual tools in the quest to reconcile our classical intuition with quantum mechanics and nowadays are routinely performed in the laboratory. An important open question is the quantum behaviour of the controlling devices in such experiments. We propose a framework to analyse quantum-controlled experiments and illustrate the implications by discussing a quantu…
▽ More
Gedanken experiments are important conceptual tools in the quest to reconcile our classical intuition with quantum mechanics and nowadays are routinely performed in the laboratory. An important open question is the quantum behaviour of the controlling devices in such experiments. We propose a framework to analyse quantum-controlled experiments and illustrate the implications by discussing a quantum version of Wheeler's delayed-choice experiment. The introduction of a quantum-controlled device (i.e., quantum beamsplitter) has several consequences. First, it implies that we can measure complementary phenomena with a single experimental setup, thus pointing to a redefinition of complementarity principle. Second, a quantum control allows us to prove there are no consistent hidden-variable theories in which "particle" and "wave" are realistic properties. Finally, it shows that a photon can have a morphing behaviour between "particle" and "wave"; this further supports the conclusion that "particle" and "wave" are not realistic properties but merely reflect how we 'look' at the photon. The framework developed here can be extended to other experiments, particularly to Bell-inequality tests.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2011; v1 submitted 1 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Quantum discord in quantum computation
Authors:
Aharon Brodutch,
Alexei Gilchrist,
Daniel R. Terno,
Christopher J. Wood
Abstract:
Quantum discord is a measure of the quantumness of correlations. After reviewing its different versions and properties, we apply it to the questions of quantum information processing. First we show that changes in discord in the processed unentangled states indicate the need for entanglement in the distributed implementation of quantum gates. On the other hand, it was shown that zero system-enviro…
▽ More
Quantum discord is a measure of the quantumness of correlations. After reviewing its different versions and properties, we apply it to the questions of quantum information processing. First we show that changes in discord in the processed unentangled states indicate the need for entanglement in the distributed implementation of quantum gates. On the other hand, it was shown that zero system-environment discord is a necessary and sufficient condition for applicability of the standard completely positive description of the system's evolution. We demonstrate that this result does not translate into useful quantum process tomography. Depending on the details of the preparation procedure only absence of any initial correlations may guarantees consistency of the process tomography.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2011; v1 submitted 7 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Entanglement, discord and the power of quantum computation
Authors:
Aharon Brodutch,
Daniel R. Terno
Abstract:
We show that the ability to create entanglement is necessary for execution of bipartite quantum gates even when they are applied to unentangled states and create no entanglement. Starting with a simple example we demonstrate that to execute such a gate bi-locally the local operations and classical communications (LOCC) should be supplemented by shared entanglement. Our results point to the changes…
▽ More
We show that the ability to create entanglement is necessary for execution of bipartite quantum gates even when they are applied to unentangled states and create no entanglement. Starting with a simple example we demonstrate that to execute such a gate bi-locally the local operations and classical communications (LOCC) should be supplemented by shared entanglement. Our results point to the changes in quantum discord, which is a measure of quantumness of correlations even in the absence of entanglement, as the indicator of failure of a LOCC implementation of the gates.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2011; v1 submitted 14 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
