-
A Critique of a Variety of "Memory-Based'' Process Monitoring Methods
Authors:
Sven Knoth,
Nesma A. Saleh,
Mahmoud A. Mahmoud,
William H. Woodall,
Victor G. Tercero-Gomez
Abstract:
Many extensions and modifications have been made to standard process monitoring methods such as the exponentially weighted moving average (EWMA) chart and the cumulative sum (CUSUM) chart. In addition, new schemes have been proposed based on alternative weighting of past data, usually to put greater emphasis on past data and less weight on current and recent data. In other cases, the output of one…
▽ More
Many extensions and modifications have been made to standard process monitoring methods such as the exponentially weighted moving average (EWMA) chart and the cumulative sum (CUSUM) chart. In addition, new schemes have been proposed based on alternative weighting of past data, usually to put greater emphasis on past data and less weight on current and recent data. In other cases, the output of one process monitoring method, such as the EWMA statistic, is used as the input to another method, such as the CUSUM chart. Often the recursive formula for a control chart statistic is itself used recursively to form a new control chart statistic. We find the use of these ad hoc methods to be unjustified. Statistical performance comparisons justifying the use of these methods have been either flawed by focusing only on zero-state run length metrics or by making comparisons to an unnecessarily weak competitor.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
The Case against Generally Weighted Moving Average (GWMA) Control Charts
Authors:
Sven Knoth,
William H. Woodall,
Víctor G. Tercero-Gómez
Abstract:
We argue against the use of generally weighted moving average (GWMA) control charts. Our primary reasons are the following: 1) There is no recursive formula for the GWMA control chart statistic, so all previous data must be stored and used in the calculation of each chart statistic. 2) The Markovian property does not apply to the GWMA statistics, so computer simulation must be used to determine co…
▽ More
We argue against the use of generally weighted moving average (GWMA) control charts. Our primary reasons are the following: 1) There is no recursive formula for the GWMA control chart statistic, so all previous data must be stored and used in the calculation of each chart statistic. 2) The Markovian property does not apply to the GWMA statistics, so computer simulation must be used to determine control limits and the statistical performance. 3) An appropriately designed, and much simpler, exponentially weighted moving average (EWMA) chart provides as good or better statistical performance. 4) In some cases the GWMA chart gives more weight to past data values than to current values.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
A Quantile Estimate Based on Local Curve Fitting
Authors:
María I. Salazar-Alvarez,
Víctor G. Tercero-Gómez,
Alvaro E. Cordero-Franco,
William J. Conover,
Mario G. Beruvides
Abstract:
Quantile estimation is a problem presented in fields such as quality control, hydrology, and economics. There are different techniques to estimate such quantiles. Nevertheless, these techniques use an overall fit of the sample when the quantiles of interest are usually located in the tails of the distribution. Regression Approach for Quantile Estimation (RAQE) is a method based on regression techn…
▽ More
Quantile estimation is a problem presented in fields such as quality control, hydrology, and economics. There are different techniques to estimate such quantiles. Nevertheless, these techniques use an overall fit of the sample when the quantiles of interest are usually located in the tails of the distribution. Regression Approach for Quantile Estimation (RAQE) is a method based on regression techniques and the properties of the empirical distribution to address this problem. The method was first presented for the problem of capability analysis. In this paper, a generalization of the method is presented, extended to the multiple sample scenario, and data from real examples is used to illustrate the proposed approaches. In addition, theoretical framework is presented to support the extension for multiple homogeneous samples and the use of the uncertainty of the estimated probabilities as a weighting factor in the analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
