Showing 251–294 of 294 results for author: Tegmark, M

Removing real-world foregrounds from CMB maps

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: Most work on foreground removal has treated the case where the frequency dependence of all components is perfectly known and independent of position. In contrast, real-world foregrounds are generally not perfectly correlated between frequencies, with the spectral index varying slightly with position and (in the case of some radio sources) with time. A method incorporating this complication in pr… ▽ More Most work on foreground removal has treated the case where the frequency dependence of all components is perfectly known and independent of position. In contrast, real-world foregrounds are generally not perfectly correlated between frequencies, with the spectral index varying slightly with position and (in the case of some radio sources) with time. A method incorporating this complication in presented, and illustrated with an application to the upcoming satellite missions MAP and Planck. We find that even spectral index variations as small as 0.1 can have a substantial impact on how channels should be combined and on attainable accuracy. △ Less

Submitted 19 February, 1998; v1 submitted 2 December, 1997; originally announced December 1997.

Comments: Expanded with wavelet discussion. Matches accepted ApJ version. 6 pages, with 3 figs included. Color figures and links at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/foregrounds.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/foregrounds.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: ApJ, 502, 1-6 (1998)

Cosmic microwave background maps from the HACME experiment

Authors: Max Tegmark, Angelica de Oliveira-Costa, John Staren, Peter Meinhold, Philip Lubin, Jeffrey Childers, Newton Figueiredo, Todd Gaier, Mark Lim, Michael Seiffert, Thyrso Villela, C. Alexandre Wuensche

Abstract: We present Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) maps from the Santa Barbara HACME balloon experiment (Staren etal 2000), covering about 1150 square degrees split between two regions in the northern sky, near the stars gamma Ursae Minoris and alpha Leonis, respectively. The FWHM of the beam is about 0.77 degrees in three frequency bands centered on 39, 41 and 43 GHz. The results demonstrate that the… ▽ More We present Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) maps from the Santa Barbara HACME balloon experiment (Staren etal 2000), covering about 1150 square degrees split between two regions in the northern sky, near the stars gamma Ursae Minoris and alpha Leonis, respectively. The FWHM of the beam is about 0.77 degrees in three frequency bands centered on 39, 41 and 43 GHz. The results demonstrate that the thoroughly interconnected scan strategy employed allows efficient removal of 1/f-noise and slightly variable scan-synchronous offsets. The maps display no stri**, and the noise correlations are found to be virtually isotropic, decaying on an angular scale around one degree. The noise performance of the experiment resulted in an upper limit on CMB anisotropy. However, our results demonstrate that atmospheric contamination and other systematics resulting from the circular scanning strategy can be accurately controlled, and bodes well for the planned follow-up experiments BEAST and ACE, since they show that even with the overly cautious assumption that 1/f-noise and offsets will be as dominant as for HACME, the problems they pose can be readily overcome with the mapmaking algorithm discussed. Our prewhitened notch-filter algorithm for destri** and offset removal should be useful also for other balloon- and ground-based experiments whose scan strategies involve substantial interleaving. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2000; v1 submitted 10 November, 1997; originally announced November 1997.

Comments: Greatly expanded version accepted to ApJ, including a fully worked and illustrated signal-to-noise analysis that is hopefully of pedagogical use. 7 ApJ pages. Color figs and links at http://www.physics.upenn.edu/~max/hacmemaps_frames.html or from [email protected]

The Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics: Many Worlds or Many Words?

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: As cutting-edge experiments display ever more extreme forms of non-classical behavior, the prevailing view on the interpretation of quantum mechanics appears to be gradually changing. A (highly unscientific) poll taken at the 1997 UMBC quantum mechanics workshop gave the once all-dominant Copenhagen interpretation less than half of the votes. The Many Worlds interpretation (MWI) scored second, c… ▽ More As cutting-edge experiments display ever more extreme forms of non-classical behavior, the prevailing view on the interpretation of quantum mechanics appears to be gradually changing. A (highly unscientific) poll taken at the 1997 UMBC quantum mechanics workshop gave the once all-dominant Copenhagen interpretation less than half of the votes. The Many Worlds interpretation (MWI) scored second, comfortably ahead of the Consistent Histories and Bohm interpretations. It is argued that since all the above-mentioned approaches to nonrelativistic quantum mechanics give identical cookbook prescriptions for how to calculate things in practice, practical-minded experimentalists, who have traditionally adopted the ``shut-up-and-calculate interpretation'', typically show little interest in whether cozy classical concepts are in fact real in some untestable metaphysical sense or merely the way we subjectively perceive a mathematically simpler world where the Schrodinger equation describes everything - and that they are therefore becoming less bothered by a profusion of worlds than by a profusion of words. Common objections to the MWI are discussed. It is argued that when environment-induced decoherence is taken into account, the experimental predictions of the MWI are identical to those of the Copenhagen interpretation except for an experiment involving a Byzantine form of ``quantum suicide''. This makes the choice between them purely a matter of taste, roughly equivalent to whether one believes mathematical language or human language to be more fundamental. △ Less

Submitted 15 September, 1997; originally announced September 1997.

Comments: 6 pages. More details and links at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/everett.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/everett.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Fortsch.Phys.46:855-862,1998

Why is the CMB fluctuation level 10^{-5}?

Authors: Max Tegmark, Martin Rees

Abstract: We explore the qualitative changes that would occur if the amplitude Q ~ 10^{-5} of cosmological density fluctuations were different. If is less than about 10^{-6}, the cosmological objects that form would have so low virial temperatures that they may be unable to cool and form stars, and would be so loosely bound that even if they could produce a supernova explosion, they might be unable to ret… ▽ More We explore the qualitative changes that would occur if the amplitude Q ~ 10^{-5} of cosmological density fluctuations were different. If is less than about 10^{-6}, the cosmological objects that form would have so low virial temperatures that they may be unable to cool and form stars, and would be so loosely bound that even if they could produce a supernova explosion, they might be unable to retain the heavy elements necessary for planetary life. If Q is greater than about 10^{-4}, dense supermassive galaxies would form, and biological evolution could be marred by short disruption timescales for planetary orbits. If Q were still larger, most bound systems would collapse directly to supermassive black holes. These constraints on Q can be expressed in terms of fundamental constants alone, and depend only on the electromagnetic and gravitational coupling constants, the electron-proton mass ratio and the matter-to-photon ratio. We discuss the implications for inflation and defect models, and note that the recent anthropic upper bounds on the cosmological constant Lambda would be invalid if both Q and Lambda could vary and there were no anthropic constraints on Q. The same applies to anthropic bounds on the curvature parameter Omega. △ Less

Submitted 12 December, 1997; v1 submitted 8 September, 1997; originally announced September 1997.

Comments: Revised to match accepted version. 8 pages, with 1 figure included. Color figure and related links at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/Q.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/Q.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]. ApJ, in press

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.499:526-532,1998

Analyzing redshift surveys to measure the power spectrum on large scales

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: Upcoming large redshift surveys potentially allow precision measurements of the galaxy power spectrum. To accurately measure P(k) on the largest scales, comparable to the depth of the survey, it is crucial that finite volume effects are accurately corrected for in the data analysis. Here we derive analytic expressions for the one such effect that has not previously been worked out exactly: that… ▽ More Upcoming large redshift surveys potentially allow precision measurements of the galaxy power spectrum. To accurately measure P(k) on the largest scales, comparable to the depth of the survey, it is crucial that finite volume effects are accurately corrected for in the data analysis. Here we derive analytic expressions for the one such effect that has not previously been worked out exactly: that of the so-called integral constraint. We also show that for data analysis methods based on counts in cells, multiple constraints can be included via simple matrix operations, thereby rendering the results less sensitive to galactic extinction and misestimates of the shape of the radial selection function. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 1997; originally announced August 1997.

Comments: Mostly superseded by astro-ph/9708020; from 5/5-97. 10 pages, with 1 figure included. More detailed treatment at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/galpower.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/galpower.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Ringberg LSS Workshop, ed. D. Hamilton (Kluwer, Amsterdam, 1997)

Measuring the galaxy power spectrum with future redshift surveys

Authors: Max Tegmark, Andrew Hamilton, Michael Strauss, Michael Vogeley, Alexander Szalay

Abstract: Precision measurements of the galaxy power spectrum P(k) require a data analysis pipeline that is both fast enough to be computationally feasible and accurate enough to take full advantage of high-quality data. We present a rigorous discussion of different methods of power spectrum estimation, with emphasis on the traditional Fourier method, the linear (Karhunen-Loeve; KL), and quadratic data co… ▽ More Precision measurements of the galaxy power spectrum P(k) require a data analysis pipeline that is both fast enough to be computationally feasible and accurate enough to take full advantage of high-quality data. We present a rigorous discussion of different methods of power spectrum estimation, with emphasis on the traditional Fourier method, the linear (Karhunen-Loeve; KL), and quadratic data compression schemes, showing in what approximations they give the same result. To improve speed, we show how many of the advantages of KL data compression and power spectrum estimation may be achieved with a computationally faster quadratic method. To improve accuracy, we derive analytic expressions for handling the integral constraint, since it is crucial that finite volume effects are accurately corrected for on scales comparable to the depth of the survey. We also show that for the KL and quadratic techniques, multiple constraints can be included via simple matrix operations, thereby rendering the results less sensitive to galactic extinction and mis-estimates of the radial selection function. We present a data analysis pipeline that we argue does justice to the increases in both quality and quantity of data that upcoming redshift surveys will provide. It uses three analysis techniques in conjunction: a traditional Fourier approach on small scales, a pixelized quadratic matrix method on large scales and a pixelized KL eigenmode analysis to probe anisotropic effects such as redshift-space distortions. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 1998; v1 submitted 4 August, 1997; originally announced August 1997.

Comments: Major revisions for clarity. Matches accepted ApJ version. 23 pages, with 2 figs included. Color figure and links at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/galpower.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/galpower.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.499:555-576,1998

Cosmological Parameter Estimation from the CMB

Authors: Andy Taylor, Alan Heavens, Bill Ballinger, Max Tegmark

Abstract: We discuss the problems of applying Maximum Likelihood methods to the CMB and how one can make it both efficient and optimal. The solution is a generalised eigenvalue problem that allows virtually no loss of information about the parameter being estimated, but can allow a substantial compression of the data set. We discuss the more difficult question of simultaneous estimation of many parameters… ▽ More We discuss the problems of applying Maximum Likelihood methods to the CMB and how one can make it both efficient and optimal. The solution is a generalised eigenvalue problem that allows virtually no loss of information about the parameter being estimated, but can allow a substantial compression of the data set. We discuss the more difficult question of simultaneous estimation of many parameters, and propose solutions. A much fuller account of most of this work is available (Tegmark, Taylor & Heavens 1997) △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 1997; originally announced July 1997.

Comments: 5 pages (Latex), 6 postscript figures included, Published in Proceedings of the Particle Physics and Early Universe Conference (PPEUC), University of Cambridge, 7-11 April 1997

Measuring cosmological parameters with galaxy surveys

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: We assess the accuracy with which future galaxy surveys can measure cosmological parameters by deriving a handy approximation that we validate numerically. We find that galaxy surveys are quite complementary to future Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) experiments. By breaking parameter degeneracies of the Planck CMB satellite in a cold dark matter cosmology, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey might be… ▽ More We assess the accuracy with which future galaxy surveys can measure cosmological parameters by deriving a handy approximation that we validate numerically. We find that galaxy surveys are quite complementary to future Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) experiments. By breaking parameter degeneracies of the Planck CMB satellite in a cold dark matter cosmology, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey might be able to reduce the Planck error bars by about an order of magnitude on the large-scale power normalization and the reionization optical depth, down to percent levels. However, pinpointing attainable accuracies to within better than a factor of a few depends crucially on whether it will be possible to extract useful information from the mildly nonlinear regime. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 1997; v1 submitted 19 June, 1997; originally announced June 1997.

Comments: Minor changes in published version. 6 pages with 2 figs included. Color figure and links at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/galfisher.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/galfisher.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett.79:3806-3809,1997

CMB map** experiments: a designer's guide

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: We apply state-of-the art data analysis methods to a number of fictitious CMB map** experiments, including 1/f noise, distilling the cosmological information from time-ordered data to maps to power spectrum estimates, and find that in all cases, the resulting error bars can we well approximated by simple and intuitive analytic expressions. Using these approximations, we discuss how to maximize… ▽ More We apply state-of-the art data analysis methods to a number of fictitious CMB map** experiments, including 1/f noise, distilling the cosmological information from time-ordered data to maps to power spectrum estimates, and find that in all cases, the resulting error bars can we well approximated by simple and intuitive analytic expressions. Using these approximations, we discuss how to maximize the scientific return of CMB map** experiments given the practical constraints at hand, and our main conclusions are as follows. (1) For a given resolution and sensitivity, it is best to cover a sky area such that the signal-to-noise ratio per resolution element (pixel) is of order unity. (2) It is best to avoid excessively skinny observing regions, narrower than a few degrees. (3) The minimum-variance mapmaking method can reduce the effects of 1/f noise by a substantial factor, but only if the scan pattern is thoroughly interconnected. (4) 1/f noise produces a 1/l contribution to the angular power spectrum for well connected single-beam scanning, as compared to virtually white noise for a two-beam scan pattern such as that of the MAP satellite. △ Less

Submitted 29 July, 1997; v1 submitted 24 May, 1997; originally announced May 1997.

Comments: 28 pages, with 13 figures included. Minor revisions to match accepted version. Color figures and links at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/strategy.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/strategy.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D56:4514-4529,1997

Is "the theory of everything'' merely the ultimate ensemble theory?

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: We discuss some physical consequences of what might be called ``the ultimate ensemble theory'', where not only worlds corresponding to say different sets of initial data or different physical constants are considered equally real, but also worlds ruled by altogether different equations. The only postulate in this theory is that all structures that exist mathematically exist also physically, by w… ▽ More We discuss some physical consequences of what might be called ``the ultimate ensemble theory'', where not only worlds corresponding to say different sets of initial data or different physical constants are considered equally real, but also worlds ruled by altogether different equations. The only postulate in this theory is that all structures that exist mathematically exist also physically, by which we mean that in those complex enough to contain self-aware substructures (SASs), these SASs will subjectively perceive themselves as existing in a physically ``real'' world. We find that it is far from clear that this simple theory, which has no free parameters whatsoever, is observationally ruled out. The predictions of the theory take the form of probability distributions for the outcome of experiments, which makes it testable. In addition, it may be possible to rule it out by comparing its a priori predictions for the observable attributes of nature (the particle masses, the dimensionality of spacetime, etc) with what is observed. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 1998; v1 submitted 3 April, 1997; originally announced April 1997.

Comments: 29 pages, revised to match version published in Annals of Physics. The New Scientist article and color figures are available at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/toe_frames.html or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Annals Phys.270:1-51,1998

Studies of CMB structure at Dec=40. II: Analysis and cosmological interpretation

Authors: S. Hancock, C. M. Gutierrez, R. D. Davies, A. N. Lasenby, G. Rocha, R. Rebolo, R. A. Watson, M. Tegmark

Abstract: We present a detailed analysis of the cosmic microwave background structure in the Tenerife Dec=+40 degrees data. The effect of local atmospheric contributions on the derived fluctuation amplitude is considered, resulting in an improved separation of the intrinsic CMB signal from noise. Our analysis demonstrates the existence of common structure in independent data scans at 15 and 33 GHz. For th… ▽ More We present a detailed analysis of the cosmic microwave background structure in the Tenerife Dec=+40 degrees data. The effect of local atmospheric contributions on the derived fluctuation amplitude is considered, resulting in an improved separation of the intrinsic CMB signal from noise. Our analysis demonstrates the existence of common structure in independent data scans at 15 and 33 GHz. For the case of fluctuations described by a Gaussian auto-correlation function, a likelihood analysis of our combined results at 15 and 33 GHz implies an intrinsic rms fluctuation level of 48^{+21}_{-15} uK on a coherence scale of 4 degrees; the equivalent analysis for a Harrison-Zel'dovitch model gives a power spectrum normalisation of Q_{rms-ps} = 22^{+10}_{-6} uK. The fluctuation amplitude is seen to be consistent at the 68% confidence level with that reported for the COBE two-year data for primordial fluctuations described by a power law model with a spectral index in the range 1.0 \le n \le 1.6. This limit favours the large scale CMB anisotropy being dominated by scalar fluctuations rather than tensor modes from a gravitational wave background. The large scale Tenerife and COBE results are considered in conjunction with observational results from medium scale experiments in order to place improved limits on the fluctuation spectral index; we find n=1.10 +/- 0.10 assuming standard CDM with H_{0}=50 kms^{-1}Mpc^{-1}. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 1997; originally announced March 1997.

Comments: 10 pages LaTeX, including 8 PostScript figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

On the dimensionality of spacetime

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: Some superstring theories have more than one effective low-energy limit, corresponding to classical spacetimes with different dimensionalities. We argue that all but the 3+1-dimensional one might correspond to ``dead worlds'', devoid of observers, in which case all such ensemble theories would actually predict that we should find ourselves inhabiting a 3+1-dimensional spacetime. With more or les… ▽ More Some superstring theories have more than one effective low-energy limit, corresponding to classical spacetimes with different dimensionalities. We argue that all but the 3+1-dimensional one might correspond to ``dead worlds'', devoid of observers, in which case all such ensemble theories would actually predict that we should find ourselves inhabiting a 3+1-dimensional spacetime. With more or less than one time-dimension, the partial differential equations of nature would lack the hyperbolicity property that enables observers to make predictions. In a space with more than three dimensions, there can be no traditional atoms and perhaps no stable structures. A space with less than three dimensions allows no gravitational force and may be too simple and barren to contain observers. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 1997; v1 submitted 25 February, 1997; originally announced February 1997.

Comments: Minor modifications to match published version. 5 pages. Color figures and related links at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/dimensions.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/dimensions.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Class.Quant.Grav.14:L69-L75,1997

Forecasting Cosmic Parameter Errors from Microwave Background Anisotropy Experiments

Authors: J. Richard Bond, George Efstathiou, Max Tegmark

Abstract: Accurate measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies with an angular resolution of a few arcminutes can be used to determine fundamental cosmological parameters such as the densities of baryons, cold and hot dark matter, and certain combinations of the cosmological constant and the curvature of the Universe to percent-level precision. Assuming the true theory is a variant… ▽ More Accurate measurements of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies with an angular resolution of a few arcminutes can be used to determine fundamental cosmological parameters such as the densities of baryons, cold and hot dark matter, and certain combinations of the cosmological constant and the curvature of the Universe to percent-level precision. Assuming the true theory is a variant of inflationary cold dark matter cosmologies, we calculate the accuracy with which cosmological parameters can be determined by the next generation of CMB satellites, MAP and Planck. We pay special attention to: (a) the accuracy of the computed derivatives of the CMB power spectrum C_L; (b) the number and choices of parameters; (c) the inclusion of prior knowledge of the values of various parameters. △ Less

Submitted 27 August, 1997; v1 submitted 11 February, 1997; originally announced February 1997.

Comments: 10 pages, LaTeX, with 1 figure included. Revised version to appear in MNRAS with updated text, tables and figure. Text and colour figures also available at ftp://ftp.cita.utoronto.ca/bond/bet97 http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/parameters.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/parameters.html (faster from Europe)

Journal ref: Mon.Not.Roy.Astron.Soc.291:L33-L41,1997

Uncorrelated measurements of the CMB power spectrum

Authors: Max Tegmark, Andrew Hamilton

Abstract: We describe how to compute estimates of the power spectrum C_l from Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) maps that not only retain all the cosmological information, but also have uncorrelated error bars and well-behaved window functions. We apply this technique to the 4-year COBE/DMR data, and tabulate eight uncorrelated band-powers. We describe how to compute estimates of the power spectrum C_l from Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) maps that not only retain all the cosmological information, but also have uncorrelated error bars and well-behaved window functions. We apply this technique to the 4-year COBE/DMR data, and tabulate eight uncorrelated band-powers. △ Less

Submitted 3 February, 1997; originally announced February 1997.

Comments: 3 pages, with 3 figures included. Color figures and cut-and-paste band powers available at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/cl.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/cl.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

How to measure CMB power spectra without losing information

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: A new method for estimating the angular power spectrum C_l from cosmic microwave background (CMB) maps is presented, which has the following desirable properties: (1) It is unbeatable in the sense that no other method can measure C_l with smaller error bars. (2) It is quadratic, which makes the statistical properties of the measurements easy to compute and use for estimation of cosmological… ▽ More A new method for estimating the angular power spectrum C_l from cosmic microwave background (CMB) maps is presented, which has the following desirable properties: (1) It is unbeatable in the sense that no other method can measure C_l with smaller error bars. (2) It is quadratic, which makes the statistical properties of the measurements easy to compute and use for estimation of cosmological parameters. (3) It is computationally faster than rival high-precision methods such as the nonlinear maximum-likelihood technique, with the crucial steps scaling as n^2 rather than n^3, where n is the number of map pixels. (4) It is applicable to any survey geometry whatsoever, with arbitraty regions masked out and arbitrary noise behaviour. (5) It is not a "black-box" method, but quite simple to understand intuitively: it corresponds to a high-pass filtering and edge softening of the original map followed by a straight expansion in truncated spherical-harmonics. It is argued that this method is computationally feasible even for futute high-resolution CMB experiments with n=10^6-10^7. It is also shown that C_l computed with this method is useful not merely for graphical presentation purposes, but also as an intermediate (and arguably necessary) step in the data analysis pipeline, reducing the data set to a more manageable size before the final step of constraining Gaussian cosmological models and parameters - while retaining all the cosmological information that was present in the original map. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 1997; v1 submitted 21 November, 1996; originally announced November 1996.

Comments: 22 pages, with 8 figures included. Minor revisions to match accepted version. Color figures and data at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/cl.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/cl.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D55:5895-5907,1997

How to make maps from CMB data without losing information

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: The next generation of CMB experiments can measure cosmological parameters with unprecedented accuracy - in principle. To achieve this in practice when faced with such gigantic data sets, elaborate data analysis methods are needed to make it computationally feasible. An important step in the data pipeline is to make a map, which typically reduces the size of the data set my orders of magnitude.… ▽ More The next generation of CMB experiments can measure cosmological parameters with unprecedented accuracy - in principle. To achieve this in practice when faced with such gigantic data sets, elaborate data analysis methods are needed to make it computationally feasible. An important step in the data pipeline is to make a map, which typically reduces the size of the data set my orders of magnitude. We compare ten map-making methods, and find that for the Gaussian case, both the method used by the COBE DMR team and various variants of Wiener filtering are optimal in the sense that the map retains all cosmological information that was present in the time-ordered data (TOD). Specifically, one obtains just as small error bars on cosmological parameters when estimating them from the map as one could have obtained by estimating them directly from the TOD. The method of simply averaging the observations of each pixel (for total-power detectors), on the contrary, is found to generally destroy information, as does the maximum entropy method and most other non-linear map-making techniques. Since it is also numerically feasible, the COBE method is the natural choice for large data sets. Other lossless (e.g. Wiener-filtered) maps can then be computed directly from the COBE method map. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 1997; v1 submitted 18 November, 1996; originally announced November 1996.

Comments: Minor revisions to match published version. 12 pages, with 1 figure included. Color figure and links at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/mapmaking.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/mapmaking.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.480:L87-L90,1997

An icosahedron-based method for pixelizing the celestial sphere

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: For power spectrum estimation it's important that the pixelization of a CMB sky map be smooth and regular to high degree. With this criterion in mind the ``COBE sky cube" was defined. This paper has as central theme to further improve on this elegant scheme which uses a cube as projective base -- here an icosahedron is used in its place. Although the sky cube is excellent,… ▽ More For power spectrum estimation it's important that the pixelization of a CMB sky map be smooth and regular to high degree. With this criterion in mind the ``COBE sky cube" was defined. This paper has as central theme to further improve on this elegant scheme which uses a cube as projective base -- here an icosahedron is used in its place. Although the sky cube is excellent, a further reduction of 20 percent of the number of pixels can be obtained while the pixel distance is maintained, and without any degradation of accuracy for integration. The pixels are rounder in this scheme, where they are hexagonal rather than square, and the faces are small in this implementation which simplifies area-equalization. The reason distortion is lessened is that the faces are smaller and therefore more flat. To use the method, you can get a FORTRAN code from the Internet. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 1996; originally announced October 1996.

Comments: 13 pages, with 3 figures included. Source code and color figures at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/icosahedron.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/icosahedron.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: ApJ Letters, 470, L81-84 (1996)

Is lensing of point sources a problem for future CMB experiments?

Authors: Max Tegmark, Jens Villumsen

Abstract: Weak gravitational lensing from large-scale structure enhances and reduces the fluxes from extragalactic point sources with an rms amplitude of order 15%. In cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiments, sources exceeding some flux threshold are removed, which means that lensing will modulate the brightness map of the remaining unresolved sources. Since this mean brightness is of order 100 micr… ▽ More Weak gravitational lensing from large-scale structure enhances and reduces the fluxes from extragalactic point sources with an rms amplitude of order 15%. In cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiments, sources exceeding some flux threshold are removed, which means that lensing will modulate the brightness map of the remaining unresolved sources. Since this mean brightness is of order 100 micro-Kelvin at 30 GHz for a reasonable flux cut, one might be concerned that this modulation could cause substantial problems for future CMB experiments. We present a detailed calculation of this effect and, fortunately, find that its power spectrum is always smaller than the normal point source power spectrum. Thus although this effect should be taken into account when analysing future high-precision CMB measurements, it will not substantially reduce the accuracy with which cosmological parameters can be measured. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 1997; v1 submitted 27 August, 1996; originally announced August 1996.

Comments: Expanded to match published version. 14 pages, with 3 figures included. Color figures at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/lensing.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/lensing.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Mon.Not.Roy.Astron.Soc.289:169-174,1997

A high-resolution map of the cosmic microwave background around the north celestial pole

Authors: Max Tegmark, Angelica de Oliveira-Costa, Marc Devlin, Barth Netterfield, Lyman Page, Ed Wollack

Abstract: We present a Wiener filtered map of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) fluctuations in a disk with 15 degree diameter, centered at the North Celestial Pole. The map is based on the 1993-1995 data from the Saskatoon (SK) experiment, with an angular resolution around 1 degree in the frequency range 27.6-44.1 GHz. The signal-to-noise ratio in the map is of order two, and some individual hot and… ▽ More We present a Wiener filtered map of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) fluctuations in a disk with 15 degree diameter, centered at the North Celestial Pole. The map is based on the 1993-1995 data from the Saskatoon (SK) experiment, with an angular resolution around 1 degree in the frequency range 27.6-44.1 GHz. The signal-to-noise ratio in the map is of order two, and some individual hot and cold spots are significant at the 5 sigma level. The spatial features are found to be consistent from year to year, reenforcing the conclusion that the SK results are not dominated by residual atmospheric contamination or other non-celestial signals. △ Less

Submitted 20 November, 1996; v1 submitted 5 August, 1996; originally announced August 1996.

Comments: Minor modifications to match published version. 12 pages, with 3 figures included. Extra color figures at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/saskmap.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/saskmap.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: ApJ Letters, 474, L77-80 (1997)

Measuring quantum states: an experimental setup for measuring the spatial density matrix

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: To quantify the effect of decoherence in quantum measurements, it is desirable to measure not merely the square modulus of the spatial wavefunction, but the entire density matrix, whose phases carry information about momentum and how pure the state is. An experimental setup is presented which can measure the density matrix (or equivalently, the Wigner function) of a beam of identically prepared… ▽ More To quantify the effect of decoherence in quantum measurements, it is desirable to measure not merely the square modulus of the spatial wavefunction, but the entire density matrix, whose phases carry information about momentum and how pure the state is. An experimental setup is presented which can measure the density matrix (or equivalently, the Wigner function) of a beam of identically prepared charged particles to an arbitrary accuracy, limited only by count statistics and detector resolution. The particles enter into an electric field causing simple harmonic oscillation in the transverse direction. This corresponds to rotating the Wigner function in phase space. With a slidable detector, the marginal distribution of the Wigner function can be measured from all angles. Thus the phase-space tomography formalism can be used to recover the Wigner function by the standard inversion of the Radon transform. By applying this technique to for instance double-slit experiments with various degrees of environment-induced decoherence, it should be possible to make our understanding of decoherence and apparent wave-function collapse less qualitative and more quantitative. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 1996; originally announced July 1996.

Comments: Final accepted version, with 2 figures included. Latest version at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/radon.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/radon.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]. To appear in Phys Rev A.

Journal ref: Phys Rev A, 54, 2703 (1996)

Does the universe in fact contain almost no information?

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: At first sight, an accurate description of the state of the universe appears to require a mind-bogglingly large and perhaps even infinite amount of information, even if we restrict our attention to a small subsystem such as a rabbit. In this paper, it is suggested that most of this information is merely apparent, as seen from our subjective viewpoints, and that the algorithmic information conten… ▽ More At first sight, an accurate description of the state of the universe appears to require a mind-bogglingly large and perhaps even infinite amount of information, even if we restrict our attention to a small subsystem such as a rabbit. In this paper, it is suggested that most of this information is merely apparent, as seen from our subjective viewpoints, and that the algorithmic information content of the universe as a whole is close to zero. It is argued that if the Schrödinger equation is universally valid, then decoherence together with the standard chaotic behavior of certain non-linear systems will make the universe appear extremely complex to any self-aware subsets that happen to inhabit it now, even if it was in a quite simple state shortly after the big bang. For instance, gravitational instability would amplify the microscopic primordial density fluctuations that are required by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle into quite macroscopic inhomogeneities, forcing the current wavefunction of the universe to contain such Byzantine superpositions as our planet being in many macroscopically different places at once. Since decoherence bars us from experiencing more than one macroscopic reality, we would see seemingly complex constellations of stars etc, even if the initial wavefunction of the universe was perfectly homogeneous and isotropic. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 1996; originally announced March 1996.

Comments: 17 pages, LATeX, no figures. Online with refs at http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/nihilo.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/nihilo.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Found. Phys. Lett, 9, 25-42 (1996)

Karhunen-Loeve eigenvalue problems in cosmology: how should we tackle large data sets?

Authors: Max Tegmark, Andy Taylor, Alan Heavens

Abstract: Since cosmology is no longer "the data-starved science", the problem of how to best analyze large data sets has recently received considerable attention, and Karhunen-Loeve eigenvalue methods have been applied to both galaxy redshift surveys and Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) maps. We present a comprehensive discussion of methods for estimating cosmological parameters from large data sets, wh… ▽ More Since cosmology is no longer "the data-starved science", the problem of how to best analyze large data sets has recently received considerable attention, and Karhunen-Loeve eigenvalue methods have been applied to both galaxy redshift surveys and Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) maps. We present a comprehensive discussion of methods for estimating cosmological parameters from large data sets, which includes the previously published techniques as special cases. We show that both the problem of estimating several parameters jointly and the problem of not knowing the parameters a priori can be readily solved by adding an extra singular value decomposition step. It has recently been argued that the information content in a sky map from a next generation CMB satellite is sufficient to measure key cosmological parameters (h, Omega, Lambda, etc) to an accuracy of a few percent or better - in principle. In practice, the data set is so large that both a brute force likelihood analysis and a direct expansion in signal-to-noise eigenmodes will be computationally unfeasible. We argue that it is likely that a Karhunen-Loeve approach can nonetheless measure the parameters with close to maximal accuracy, if preceded by an appropriate form of quadratic "pre-compression". We also discuss practical issues regarding parameter estimation from present and future galaxy redshift surveys, and illustrate this with a generalized eigenmode analysis of the IRAS 1.2 Jy survey optimized for measuring beta=Omega^{0.6}/b using redshift space distortions. △ Less

Submitted 19 November, 1996; v1 submitted 6 March, 1996; originally announced March 1996.

Comments: 15 pages, with 5 figures included. Substantially expanded with worked COBE examples for e.g. the multiparameter case. Available from http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/karhunen.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/karhunen.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.480:22,1997

How small were the first cosmological objects?

Authors: Max Tegmark, Joseph Silk, Martin Rees, Alain Blanchard, Tom Abel, Francesco Palla

Abstract: The minimum mass that a virialized gas cloud must have in order to be able to cool in a Hubble time is computed, using a detailed treatment of the chemistry of molecular hydrogen. With a simple model for halo profiles, we reduce the problem to that of numerically integrating a system of chemical equations. The results agree well with numerically expensive 3D simulations, and our approach has the… ▽ More The minimum mass that a virialized gas cloud must have in order to be able to cool in a Hubble time is computed, using a detailed treatment of the chemistry of molecular hydrogen. With a simple model for halo profiles, we reduce the problem to that of numerically integrating a system of chemical equations. The results agree well with numerically expensive 3D simulations, and our approach has the advantage of rapidly being able to explore large regions of parameter space. The minimum baryonic mass M_b is found to be strongly redshift dependent, drop** from 10^6 solar masses at z=15 to 5000 solar masses at z=100 as molecular cooling becomes effective. For z>>100, M_b rises again, as CMB photons inhibit H_2-formation through the H^- channel. Finally, for z>>200, the H_2^+ channel for H_2-formation becomes effective, driving M_b down towards 10^3 solar masses. With a standard CDM power spectrum with sigma_8=0.7, this implies that a fraction 10^{-3} of all baryons may have formed luminous objects by z=30, which could be sufficient to reheat the universe. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 1997; v1 submitted 4 March, 1996; originally announced March 1996.

Comments: Minor modifications to match published version. Molecular cooling rates improved. 29 pages, with 6 figures included. Color figures and related work at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/minmass.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/minmass.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.474:1-12,1997

Spherical Harmonic Analysis of the Angular Distribution of Gamma-Ray Bursts

Authors: Max Tegmark, Dieter Hartmann, Michael Briggs, Charles Meegan

Abstract: We compute the angular power spectrum C_l of the BATSE 3B catalog, and find no evidence for clustering on any scale. These constraints bridge the entire range from small scales, probing source clustering and repetition, to large scales constraining possible Galactic anisotropies, or those from nearby cosmological large scale structures. We compute the angular power spectrum C_l of the BATSE 3B catalog, and find no evidence for clustering on any scale. These constraints bridge the entire range from small scales, probing source clustering and repetition, to large scales constraining possible Galactic anisotropies, or those from nearby cosmological large scale structures. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 1996; originally announced February 1996.

Comments: 5 page conf. proceedings, with one figure included. Postscript. More detailed version at http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/bursts.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/bursts.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Report number: MPI-PhT/95-138

Journal ref: Proc. 3rd Huntsville Workshop on Gamma Ray Bursts, eds. C. Kouveliotou, M. S. Briggs & G. J. Fishman

The angular power spectrum of the 4 year COBE data

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: The angular power spectrum C_l is extracted from the 4 year COBE DMR data with a 20 degree galactic cut, using the narrowest window functions possible. The average power in eight multipole bands is also computed, and plotted together with a compilation of power spectrum measurements from other experiments. The COBE results are found to be consistent with an n=1 power spectrum with the normalizat… ▽ More The angular power spectrum C_l is extracted from the 4 year COBE DMR data with a 20 degree galactic cut, using the narrowest window functions possible. The average power in eight multipole bands is also computed, and plotted together with a compilation of power spectrum measurements from other experiments. The COBE results are found to be consistent with an n=1 power spectrum with the normalization Qrmsps=18 microkelvin reported by the COBE DMR team. Certain non-standard cosmologies, such as "small universe" models with nontrivial spatial topology, predict power spectra which are not smooth functions. Rather, they contain bumps and wiggles that may not have been detected by other data analysis techniques such as the Hauser-Peebles method (Wright etal 1996), the band-power method (Hinshaw etal 1996) and orthogonalized spherical harmonics (Gorski etal 1996), since these methods all give broader window functions that can smear such features out beyond recognition. On the large angular scales probed by COBE, the Universe thus appears to be kind to us, presenting a power spectrum that is a simple smooth function. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 1996; v1 submitted 14 January, 1996; originally announced January 1996.

Comments: Final accepted version, incl. plots with new Saskatoon data. 14 pages, with 4 figures included. Postscript. Latest version at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/cobepow.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/cobepow.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: ApJ Letters, 464, L35 (1996)

Doppler peaks and all that: CMB anisotropies and what they can tell us

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: The power spectrum of fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) depends on most of the key cosmological parameters. Accurate future measurements of this power spectrum might therefore allow us to determine h, Omega, Omega_b, Lambda, n, T/S, etc, with hitherto unprecedented accuracy. In these lecture notes, which are intended to be readable without much prior CMB knowledge, I review t… ▽ More The power spectrum of fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) depends on most of the key cosmological parameters. Accurate future measurements of this power spectrum might therefore allow us to determine h, Omega, Omega_b, Lambda, n, T/S, etc, with hitherto unprecedented accuracy. In these lecture notes, which are intended to be readable without much prior CMB knowledge, I review the various physical processes that generate CMB fluctuations, focusing on how changes in the parameters alters the shape of the power spectrum. I also discuss foregrounds and real-world data analysis issues and how these affect the accuracy with which the parameters can be measured. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 1995; originally announced November 1995.

Comments: 40 pages, including 12 figures. Postscript. Latest version available from http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/power.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/power.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Report number: MPI-PhT/95-126

Journal ref: Proc. Enrico Fermi, Course CXXXII, Varenna, 1995

Improved limits on gamma ray burst repetition

Authors: Max Tegmark, Dieter Hartmann, Michael Briggs, Jon Hakkila, Charles Meegan

Abstract: We tighten previous upper limits on gamma ray burst repetition by analyzing the angular power spectrum of the BATSE 3B catalog of 1122 bursts. At 95% confidence, we find that no more than 2% of all observed bursts can be labeled as repeaters, even if no sources are observed to repeat more than once. If a fraction f of all observed bursts can be labeled as repeaters that are observed to burst v t… ▽ More We tighten previous upper limits on gamma ray burst repetition by analyzing the angular power spectrum of the BATSE 3B catalog of 1122 bursts. At 95% confidence, we find that no more than 2% of all observed bursts can be labeled as repeaters, even if no sources are observed to repeat more than once. If a fraction f of all observed bursts can be labeled as repeaters that are observed to burst v times each, then all models with (v-1)f>0.05 are ruled out at 99% confidence, as compared to the best previous 99% limit (v-1)f>0.27. At 95% confidence, our new limit is (v-1)f>0.02. Thus even a cluster of 6 events from a single source would have caused excess power above that present in the 3B catalog. We conclude that the current BATSE data are consistent with no repetition of classical gamma ray bursts, and that any repeater model is severely constrained by the near perfect isotropy of their angular distribution. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 1995; originally announced November 1995.

Comments: 18 pages, with 2 figures included. Postscript. Submitted to ApJL. Latest version at http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/repeaters.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/repeaters.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Report number: MPI-PhT/95-116, NSF-ITP-95-145

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.466:757-763,1996

The Angular Power Spectrum of BATSE 3B Gamma-Ray Burst

Authors: Max Tegmark, Dieter Hartmann, Michael Briggs, Charles Meegan

Abstract: We compute the angular power spectrum C_l from the BATSE 3B catalog of 1122 gamma-ray bursts, and find no evidence for clustering on any scale. These constraints bridge the entire range from small scales (which probe source clustering and burst repetition) to the largest scales (which constrain possible anisotropies from the Galactic halo or from nearby cosmological large scale structures). We d… ▽ More We compute the angular power spectrum C_l from the BATSE 3B catalog of 1122 gamma-ray bursts, and find no evidence for clustering on any scale. These constraints bridge the entire range from small scales (which probe source clustering and burst repetition) to the largest scales (which constrain possible anisotropies from the Galactic halo or from nearby cosmological large scale structures). We develop an analysis technique that takes the angular position errors into account, which enables us to place tight upper limits on the clustering down to scales l\approx 60, corresponding to a few degrees on the sky. The minimum-variance burst weighting that we employ is graphically visualized as an all-sky map where each burst is smeared out by an amount corresponding to its position uncertainty. We also present separate band-pass filtered sky maps for the quadrupole term and for the multipole-ranges l=3-10 and l=11-30, so that the fluctuations on different angular scales can be separately inspected for visual features such as localized ``hot spots" or structures aligned with the Galactic plane. These filtered maps reveal no apparent deviations from isotropy. △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 1995; originally announced October 1995.

Comments: 31 pages, with 10 figures included. Postscript. Submitted to ApJ. Latest version (and color figures) at http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/bursts.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/bursts.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Report number: MPI-PhT/95-95

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.468:214,1996

Using the kinematic Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect to determine the peculiar velocities of clusters of galaxies

Authors: Martin G. Haehnelt, Max Tegmark

Abstract: We have investigated the possibility of inferring peculiar velocities for clusters of galaxies from the Doppler shift of scattered cosmic microwave background (CMB) photons. We find that if the core radius of the gas distribution or the beam size of the instrument is larger than 3-7 arcminutes, then the maximum attainable signal-to-noise ratio is determined by confusion with primary fluctuations… ▽ More We have investigated the possibility of inferring peculiar velocities for clusters of galaxies from the Doppler shift of scattered cosmic microwave background (CMB) photons. We find that if the core radius of the gas distribution or the beam size of the instrument is larger than 3-7 arcminutes, then the maximum attainable signal-to-noise ratio is determined by confusion with primary fluctuations. For smaller angular scales, ``cosmic confusion'' is less important and instrumental noise and/or foreground emission will be the limiting factor. For a cluster with the optical depth of the Coma cluster and for an optimal filtering technique, typical one-sigma errors span the wide range from 400 to 1600 km/s, depending on the cosmological model, the resolution of the instrument and the core radius of the cluster. The results have important implications for the design of future high-resolution surveys of the CMB. Individual peculiar velocities will be measurable only for a few fast moving clusters at intermediate redshift unless cosmic fluctuations are smaller than most standard cosmological scenarios predict. However, a reliable measurement of bulk velocities of ensembles of X-ray bright clusters will be possible on very large scales (100-500 Mpc/h). △ Less

Submitted 20 July, 1995; originally announced July 1995.

Comments: 34 pages, with 11 figures included. Postscript. Submitted to MNRAS. Latest version (recommended) at http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/sz.html or from [email protected]

Report number: MPA 883

Journal ref: Mon.Not.Roy.Astron.Soc.279:545-556,1996

A method for subtracting foregrounds from multi-frequency CMB sky maps

Authors: Max Tegmark, George Efstathiou

Abstract: An improved method for subtracting contaminants from Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) sky maps is presented, and used to estimate how well future experiments will be able to recover the primordial CMB fluctuations. We find that the naive method of subtracting foregrounds (such as dust emission, synchrotron radiation, free-free-emission, unresolved point sources, etc) on a pixel by pixel basis c… ▽ More An improved method for subtracting contaminants from Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) sky maps is presented, and used to estimate how well future experiments will be able to recover the primordial CMB fluctuations. We find that the naive method of subtracting foregrounds (such as dust emission, synchrotron radiation, free-free-emission, unresolved point sources, etc) on a pixel by pixel basis can be improved by more than an order of magnitude by taking advantage of the correlation of the emission in neighboring pixels. The optimal multi-frequency subtraction method improves on simple pixel-by-pixel subtraction both by taking noise-levels into account, and by exploiting the fact that most contaminants have angular power spectra that differ substantially from that of the CMB. The results are natural to visualize in the two-dimensional plane with axes defined by multipole l and frequency v. We present a brief overview of the geography of this plane, showing the regions probed by various experiments and where we expect contaminants to dominate. We illustrate the method by estimating how well the proposed ESA COBRAS/SAMBA mission will be able to recover the CMB fluctuations against contaminating foregrounds. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 1996; v1 submitted 4 July, 1995; originally announced July 1995.

Comments: Final accepted version, substantially revised. 51 pages, with 14 figures included. Latest version & color figures at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/wiener.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/wiener.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: MNRAS, 281, 1297-1314

ESTIMATING MICROWAVE POWER SPECTRA

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: A new method for estimating the power spectrum $C_l$ from cosmic microwave background (CMB) maps was recently presented by the author and applied to the 2 year COBE data. It was found that the spectral resolution $Δl$ for COBE could be more than doubled at $l=15$, thereby revealing previously unresolved features in the power spectrum. Whereas that paper was rather technical, the present paper show… ▽ More A new method for estimating the power spectrum $C_l$ from cosmic microwave background (CMB) maps was recently presented by the author and applied to the 2 year COBE data. It was found that the spectral resolution $Δl$ for COBE could be more than doubled at $l=15$, thereby revealing previously unresolved features in the power spectrum. Whereas that paper was rather technical, the present paper shows that all qualitative features of this method can be understood from a simple analogy with quantum mechanics. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 1995; originally announced February 1995.

Comments: 4 pages, incl one figure. Postscript. For proceedings of 17th Texas Symposium. Latest version at http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/texas.html or from [email protected]

Report number: MPI-PhT/95-9

Journal ref: Annals N.Y.Acad.Sci.759:684-687,1995

A method for extracting maximum resolution power spectra from galaxy surveys

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: The power spectrum estimated from a galaxy redshift survey is the real spectrum convolved with a window function, so when estimating the power on very large scales (for small k), it is important that this window function be as narrow as possible. A method that achieves this is presented. The optimal estimate of P(k) is found to be the Fourier transform of the number density fluctuations (n/nbar… ▽ More The power spectrum estimated from a galaxy redshift survey is the real spectrum convolved with a window function, so when estimating the power on very large scales (for small k), it is important that this window function be as narrow as possible. A method that achieves this is presented. The optimal estimate of P(k) is found to be the Fourier transform of the number density fluctuations (n/nbar - 1) weighted by a function psi_0, and the optimal psi_0 is found to be the ground-state solution of the Schoedinger equation, with the inverse selection function as the potential. This quantum mechanics analogy occurs basically because we want the weight function to be narrow both in Fourier space (to give a narrow window) and in real space (to minimize the variance from shot noise). An optimal method for averaging the estimates at different k-vectors is also presented, generalizing the standard procedure of averaging over shells in k-space. Finally, a discrete version of the method is presented, dividing space into ``fuzzy pixels", which has the advantage of being able to handle redshift distortions in a straightforward way. △ Less

Submitted 27 November, 1995; v1 submitted 2 February, 1995; originally announced February 1995.

Comments: 25 pages, including two figures. Postscript. Slightly revised to match published version. Also available from http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/power.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/power.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Report number: MPI-PhT/95-7

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.455:429-438,1995

A method for extracting maximum resolution power spectra from microwave sky maps

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: A method for extracting maximal resolution power spectra from microwave sky maps is presented and applied to the 2 year COBE data, yielding a power spectrum that is consistent with a standard n=1, Q=20 micro-Kelvin model. By using weight functions that fall off smoothly near the galactic cut, it is found that the spectral resolution Δl can be more than doubled at l=15 and more than tripled at l=… ▽ More A method for extracting maximal resolution power spectra from microwave sky maps is presented and applied to the 2 year COBE data, yielding a power spectrum that is consistent with a standard n=1, Q=20 micro-Kelvin model. By using weight functions that fall off smoothly near the galactic cut, it is found that the spectral resolution Δl can be more than doubled at l=15 and more than tripled at l=20 compared to simply using galaxy-cut spherical harmonics. For a future high-resolution experiment with reasonable sky coverage, the resolution around the CDM Doppler peaks would be enhanced by a factor of about 100, down to Δl\approx 1, thus allowing spectral features such as the locations of the peaks to be determined with great accuracy. The reason that the improvement is so large is basically that functions with a sharp edge at the galaxy cut exhibit considerable "ringing" in the Fourier domain, whereas smooth functions do not. The method presented here is applicable to any survey geometry, chop** strategy and exposure pattern whatsoever. The so called signal-to-noise eigenfunction technique is found to be a special case, corresponding to ignoring the width of the window functions. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 1996; v1 submitted 17 December, 1994; originally announced December 1994.

Comments: 25 pages, including 4 figures. Postscript. Substantially revised, more than twice original length, matches accepted version. Latest version available from http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/window.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/window.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Mon.Not.Roy.Astron.Soc.280:299-308,1996

Probes of the Early Universe

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: One of the main challenges in cosmology is to quantify how small density fluctuations at the recombination epoch z around 1000 evolved into the galaxies and the large-scale structure we observe in the universe today. This thesis discusses ways of probing the intermediate epoch, focusing on the thermal history. The main emphasis is on the role played by non-linear feedback, where a small fraction… ▽ More One of the main challenges in cosmology is to quantify how small density fluctuations at the recombination epoch z around 1000 evolved into the galaxies and the large-scale structure we observe in the universe today. This thesis discusses ways of probing the intermediate epoch, focusing on the thermal history. The main emphasis is on the role played by non-linear feedback, where a small fraction of matter forming luminous objects can inject enough energy into the inter-galactic medium to radically alter subsequent events. Chapter 2, "A Cosmology Primer", provides a 60-page introduction to cosmology that may be useful for the reader with a general physics background. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2006; v1 submitted 17 December, 1994; originally announced December 1994.

Comments: UC Berkeley PhD thesis, April 1994. 195 pages, incl. 39 figs. Replaced by the complete document now that 650kb is no longer a large file

A brute force analysis of the COBE DMR data

Authors: Max Tegmark, Emory Bunn

Abstract: More than a dozen papers analyzing the COBE data have now appeared. We review the different techniques and compare them to a ``brute force" likelihood analysis where we invert the full 4038 x 4038 Galaxy-cut pixel covariance matrix. This method is optimal in the sense of producing minimal error bars, and is a useful reference point for comparing other analysis techniques. Our maximum-likelihood… ▽ More More than a dozen papers analyzing the COBE data have now appeared. We review the different techniques and compare them to a ``brute force" likelihood analysis where we invert the full 4038 x 4038 Galaxy-cut pixel covariance matrix. This method is optimal in the sense of producing minimal error bars, and is a useful reference point for comparing other analysis techniques. Our maximum-likelihood estimate of the spectral index and normalization are n=1.15 (0.95) and Q=18.2 (21.3) micro-Kelvin including (excluding) the quadrupole. Marginalizing over the normalization C_9, we obtain n=1.10 +/- 0.29 (n=0.90 +/- 0.32). When we compare these results with those of the various techniques that involve a linear ``compression'' of the data, we find that the latter are all consistent with the brute-force analysis and have error bars that are nearly as small as the minimal error bars. We therefore conclude that the data compressions involved in these techniques do indeed retain most of the useful cosmological information. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 1996; v1 submitted 1 December, 1994; originally announced December 1994.

Comments: 16 pages, incl 3 figures. Stone-age postscript replaced by LATeX. Latest version at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/brute.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/brute.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.455:1-6,1995

Real-space cosmic fields from redshift-space distributions: a Green function approach

Authors: Max Tegmark, Benjamin Bromley

Abstract: We present a new method for reconstructing the cosmological density, peculiar velocity and peculiar gravitational potential on large scales from redshift data. We remove the distorting effects of line-of-sight peculiar motions by using the linear theory of gravitational instability, in which the potential is the solution to a linear partial differential equation first derived by Kaiser. We solve… ▽ More We present a new method for reconstructing the cosmological density, peculiar velocity and peculiar gravitational potential on large scales from redshift data. We remove the distorting effects of line-of-sight peculiar motions by using the linear theory of gravitational instability, in which the potential is the solution to a linear partial differential equation first derived by Kaiser. We solve this equation by deriving its Green function; the Green functions for the peculiar velocity and the real-space density follow directly. Reconstruction of the cosmic fields is thus reduced to integration over redshift space with the appropriate Green function kernel. Our algorithm has a single input parameter, beta=Omega^0.6/b, where b is the linear bias factor and Omega is the cosmological density parameter. We discuss the virtues of this method for error control, for estimating beta, and for constraining the bias mechanism. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 1996; v1 submitted 14 September, 1994; originally announced September 1994.

Comments: 22 pages, incl 3 figures. Stone-age postscript replaced by LATeX. Latest version at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/zspace.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/zspace.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.453:533,1995

Reionization in an open cdm universe: implications for cosmic microwave background fluctuations

Authors: Max Tegmark, Joseph Silk

Abstract: We generalize previous work on early photoionization to CDM models with Omega<1. Such models have received recent interest because the excess power in the large-scale galaxy distribution is phenomenologically fit if the ``shape parameter" Gamma=h Omega_0 is about 0.25. It has been argued that such models may require early reionization to suppress small-scale anisotropies in order to be consisten… ▽ More We generalize previous work on early photoionization to CDM models with Omega<1. Such models have received recent interest because the excess power in the large-scale galaxy distribution is phenomenologically fit if the ``shape parameter" Gamma=h Omega_0 is about 0.25. It has been argued that such models may require early reionization to suppress small-scale anisotropies in order to be consistent with experimental data. We find that if the cosmological constant lambda=0, the extent of this suppression is quite insensitive to Omega_0. Given a sigma_8-normalization today, the loss of small-scale power associated with a lower Omega_0 is partially canceled by higher optical depth from longer lookback times and by structures forming at higher redshifts before the universe becomes curvature-dominated. The maximum angular scale on which fluctuations are suppressed decreases when Omega_0 is lowered, but this effect is also rather weak and unlikely to be measurable in the near future. For flat models, on the other hand, where lambda_0 = 1-Omega_0, the negative effects of lowering Omega_0 dominate, and early reionization is not likely to play a significant role if Omega_0<<1. The same applies to CDM models where the effective Gamma is lowered by increasing the number of relativistic particle species. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 1996; v1 submitted 17 May, 1994; originally announced May 1994.

Comments: 17 pages, incl 7 figures. Stone-age postscript replaced by LATeX. Latest version at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/openreion.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/openreion.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.441:458-464,1995

Decoherence produces coherent states: an explicit proof for harmonic chains

Authors: Max Tegmark, Harold S. Shapiro

Abstract: We study the behavior of infinite systems of coupled harmonic oscillators as t->infinity, and generalize the Central Limit Theorem (CLT) to show that their reduced Wigner distributions become Gaussian under quite general conditions. This shows that generalized coherent states tend to be produced naturally. A sufficient condition for this to happen is shown to be that the spectral function is ana… ▽ More We study the behavior of infinite systems of coupled harmonic oscillators as t->infinity, and generalize the Central Limit Theorem (CLT) to show that their reduced Wigner distributions become Gaussian under quite general conditions. This shows that generalized coherent states tend to be produced naturally. A sufficient condition for this to happen is shown to be that the spectral function is analytic and nonlinear. For a rectangular lattice of coupled oscillators, the nonlinearity requirement means that waves must be dispersive, so that localized wave-packets become suppressed. Virtually all harmonic heat-bath models in the literature satisfy this constraint, and we have good reason to believe that coherent states and their generalizations are not merely a useful analytical tool, but that nature is indeed full of them. Standard proofs of the CLT rely heavily on the fact that probability densities are non-negative. Although the CLT generally fails if the probability densities are allowed to take negative values, we show that a CLT does indeed hold for a special class of such functions. We find that, intriguingly, nature has arranged things so that all Wigner functions belong to this class. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 1996; v1 submitted 13 February, 1994; originally announced February 1994.

Comments: Final published version. 17 pages, Plain TeX, no figures. Online at http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/gaussians.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/gaussians.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: PRE 50, 2538-2547 (1994)

Steady states of harmonic oscillator chains and shortcomings of harmonic heat baths

Authors: Max Tegmark, Leehwa Yeh

Abstract: We study properties of steady states (states with time-independent density operators) of systems of coupled harmonic oscillators. Formulas are derived showing how adiabatic change of the Hamiltonian transforms one steady state into another. It is shown that for infinite systems, sudden change of the Hamiltonian also tends to produce steady states, after a transition period of oscillations. These… ▽ More We study properties of steady states (states with time-independent density operators) of systems of coupled harmonic oscillators. Formulas are derived showing how adiabatic change of the Hamiltonian transforms one steady state into another. It is shown that for infinite systems, sudden change of the Hamiltonian also tends to produce steady states, after a transition period of oscillations. These naturally arising steady states are compared to the maximum-entropy state (the thermal state) and are seen not to coincide in general. The approach to equilibrium of subsystems consisting of n coupled harmonic oscillators has been widely studied, but only in the simple case where n=1. The power of our results is that they can be applied to more complex subsustems, where n>1. It is shown that the use of coupled harmonic oscillators as heat baths models is fraught with some problems that do not appear in the simple n=1 case. Specifically, the thermal states that are though to be achievable through hard-sphere collisions with heat-bath particles can generally NOT be achieved with harmonic coupling to the heat-bath particles, except approximately when the coupling is weak. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 1996; v1 submitted 9 January, 1994; originally announced January 1994.

Comments: Final published version. 16 pages, Plain TeX, no figures. Online at http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/steady.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/steady.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Physica A, 202, 342-362 (1994)

Power Spectrum Independent Constraints on Cosmological Models

Authors: Max Tegmark, Emory Bunn, Wayne Hu

Abstract: A formalism is presented that allows cosmological experiments to be tested for consistency, and allows a simple frequentist interpretation of the resulting significance levels. As an example of an application, this formalism is used to place constraints on bulk flows of galaxies using the results of the microwave background anisotropy experiments COBE and SP91, and a few simplifying approximatio… ▽ More A formalism is presented that allows cosmological experiments to be tested for consistency, and allows a simple frequentist interpretation of the resulting significance levels. As an example of an application, this formalism is used to place constraints on bulk flows of galaxies using the results of the microwave background anisotropy experiments COBE and SP91, and a few simplifying approximations about the experimental window functions. It is found that if taken at face value, with the quoted errors, the recent detection by Lauer and Postman of a bulk flow of 689 km/s on scales of 150$h^{-1}$Mpc is inconsistent with SP91 at a 95\% confidence level within the framework of a Cold Dark Matter (CDM) model. The same consistency test is also used to place constraints that are completely model-independent, in the sense that they hold for any power spectrum whatsoever --- the only assumption being that the random fields are Gaussian. It is shown that the resulting infinite-dimensional optimization problem reduces to a set of coupled non-linear equations that can readily be solved numerically. Applying this technique to the above-mentioned example, we find that the Lauer and Postman result is inconsistent with SP91 even if no assumptions whatsoever are made about the power spectrum. △ Less

Submitted 19 December, 1993; v1 submitted 19 November, 1993; originally announced November 1993.

Comments: 18 pages, Plain TeX (4 figures in accompanying file). CfPA 93-th-40, submitted to Ap.J., significantly revised version

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.434:1-11,1994

Apparent wave function collapse caused by scattering

Authors: Max Tegmark

Abstract: Some experimental implications of the recent progress on wave function collapse are calculated. Exact results are derived for the center-of-mass wave function collapse caused by random scatterings and applied to a range of specific examples. The results show that recently proposed experiments to measure the GRW effect are likely to fail, since the effect of naturally occurring scatterings is of… ▽ More Some experimental implications of the recent progress on wave function collapse are calculated. Exact results are derived for the center-of-mass wave function collapse caused by random scatterings and applied to a range of specific examples. The results show that recently proposed experiments to measure the GRW effect are likely to fail, since the effect of naturally occurring scatterings is of the same form as the GRW effect but generally much stronger. The same goes for attempts to measure the collapse caused by quantum gravity as suggested by Hawking and others. The results also indicate that macroscopic systems tend to be found in states with (Delta-x)(Delta-p) = hbar/sqrt(2), but microscopic systems in highly tiltedly squeezed states with (Delta-x)(Delta-p) >> hbar. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 1996; v1 submitted 25 October, 1993; originally announced October 1993.

Comments: Final published version. 20 pages, Plain TeX, no figures. Online at http://astro.berkeley.edu/~max/collapse.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/collapse.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Found. Phys. Lett., 6, 571-590 (1993)

Did the universe recombine? New spectral constraints on reheating

Authors: Max Tegmark, Joseph Silk

Abstract: One still cannot conclusively assert that the universe underwent a neutral phase, despite the new COBE FIRAS limit y<0.000025 on Compton y-distortions of the cosmic microwave background. Although scenarios where the very early (z=1000) ionization is thermal, caused by IGM temperatures exceeding 10000K, are clearly ruled out, there is a significant loophole for cosmologies with typical CDM parame… ▽ More One still cannot conclusively assert that the universe underwent a neutral phase, despite the new COBE FIRAS limit y<0.000025 on Compton y-distortions of the cosmic microwave background. Although scenarios where the very early (z=1000) ionization is thermal, caused by IGM temperatures exceeding 10000K, are clearly ruled out, there is a significant loophole for cosmologies with typical CDM parameters if the dominant ionization mechanism is photoionization. If the ionizing radiation has a typical quasar spectrum, then the y-constraint implies roughly h^{3/2}Ω_b Omega_0^{-1/4}<0.1 for fully ionized models. This means that BDM models with Omega_0 around 0.15 and reionization at about z=1000 are strongly constrained even in this very conservative case, and can survive the y test only if most of the baryons form BDM around the reionization epoch. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 1996; v1 submitted 9 July, 1993; originally announced July 1993.

Comments: 15 pages, incl 3 figures. Stone-age postscript replaced by LATeX. Latest version at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/y.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/y.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.423:529-533,1994

On the inevitability of reionization: implications for cosmic microwave background fluctuations

Authors: Max Tegmark, Joseph Silk, Alain Blanchard

Abstract: Early photoionization of the intergalactic medium is discussed in a nearly model-independent way, in order to investigate whether early structures corresponding to rare Gaussian peaks in a CDM model can photoionize the intergalactic medium sufficiently early to appreciably smooth out the microwave background fluctuations. We conclude that this is indeed possible for a broad range of CDM normaliz… ▽ More Early photoionization of the intergalactic medium is discussed in a nearly model-independent way, in order to investigate whether early structures corresponding to rare Gaussian peaks in a CDM model can photoionize the intergalactic medium sufficiently early to appreciably smooth out the microwave background fluctuations. We conclude that this is indeed possible for a broad range of CDM normalizations and is almost inevitable for unbiased CDM, provided that the bulk of these early structures are quite small, no more massive than about 10^8 solar masses. Typical parameter values predict that reionization occurs around z=50, thereby suppressing fluctuations on degree scales while leaving the larger angular scales probed by COBE reasonably unaffected. However, for non-standard CDM, incorporating mixed dark matter, vacuum density or a tilted primordial power spectrum, early reionization plays no significant role. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 1996; v1 submitted 9 July, 1993; originally announced July 1993.

Comments: 32 pages, incl 10 figures. Stone-age postscript replaced by LATeX. Latest version at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/reion.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/reion.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.420:484-496,1994

Late reionization by supernova-driven winds

Authors: Max Tegmark, Joseph Silk, August Evrard

Abstract: A model is presented in which supernova-driven winds from early galaxies reionize the intergalactic medium by z=5. This scenario can explain the observed absence of a Gunn-Peterson trough in the spectra of high-redshift quasars providing that the bulk of these early galaxies are quite small, no more massive than about 10^8 solar masses. It also predicts that most of the IGM was enriched to at le… ▽ More A model is presented in which supernova-driven winds from early galaxies reionize the intergalactic medium by z=5. This scenario can explain the observed absence of a Gunn-Peterson trough in the spectra of high-redshift quasars providing that the bulk of these early galaxies are quite small, no more massive than about 10^8 solar masses. It also predicts that most of the IGM was enriched to at least 10% of current metal content by z=5 and perhaps as early as z=15. The existence of such early mini-galaxies violates no spectral constraints and is consistent with a pure CDM model with b<2. Since the final radius of a typical ionized bubble is only around 100 kpc, the induced modification of the galaxy autocorrelation function is negligible, as is the induced angular smoothing of the CMBR. Some of the gas swept up by shells may be observable as pressure-supported Lyman-alpha forest clouds. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 1996; v1 submitted 22 June, 1993; originally announced June 1993.

Comments: 29 pages, incl 6 figures. Stone-age postscript replaced by LATeX. Latest version at http://www.sns.ias.edu/~max/gp.html (faster from the US), from http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/~max/gp.html (faster from Europe) or from [email protected]

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.417:54,1993