-
Refined Thermodynamics of Black Holes with Proper Conserved Charges
Authors:
Aydin Tavlayan,
Bayram Tekin
Abstract:
Field equations of a classical, geometric, theory of gravity, augmented with some semiclassical considerations strongly suggest that the gravitational field representing a stationary black hole can be simply described with a few thermodynamical coordinates and their conjugates that obey the four laws of thermodynamics plus the Smarr formula and the reverse isoperimetric inequality that bounds the…
▽ More
Field equations of a classical, geometric, theory of gravity, augmented with some semiclassical considerations strongly suggest that the gravitational field representing a stationary black hole can be simply described with a few thermodynamical coordinates and their conjugates that obey the four laws of thermodynamics plus the Smarr formula and the reverse isoperimetric inequality that bounds the maximum entropy for a given effective volume of space. Thermodynamics of black holes is a promising window to the quantum nature of black holes and hence it is important to understand all the details of these laws. The identification and the meaning of these thermodynamic coordinates depend on the gravity theory under consideration. For example, the existence of dimensionful coupling constants, such as the cosmological constant, changes the scaling properties of the theory, its solutions, and the laws of thermodynamics. Here we show, using the background Killing charge method which applies to any gravity theory, how the thermodynamics of black holes such as the $D$ dimensional Kerr-AdS black holes in cosmological Einstein's theory and the spherically symmetric black holes in the Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet theory changes. We give the effective volume of black holes which are regular in every dimension even in the absence of a cosmological constant. The methods applied here can be used in any geometric theory of gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Partition Function of a Volume of Space in a Higher Curvature Theory
Authors:
Aydin Tavlayan,
Bayram Tekin
Abstract:
Recently, [Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 221501 (2023)] Jacobson and Visser calculated the quantum partition function of a fixed, finite volume of a region with the topology of a ball in the saddle point approximation within the context of Einstein's gravity with or without a cosmological constant. The result can be interpreted as the dimension of Hilbert space of the theory. Here we extend their computat…
▽ More
Recently, [Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 221501 (2023)] Jacobson and Visser calculated the quantum partition function of a fixed, finite volume of a region with the topology of a ball in the saddle point approximation within the context of Einstein's gravity with or without a cosmological constant. The result can be interpreted as the dimension of Hilbert space of the theory. Here we extend their computation to a theory defined in principle with infinitely many powers of curvature in three dimensions. We confirm their result: The partition function of a spatial region in the leading saddle point approximation is given as the exponential of the Bekenstein-Hawking or the Wald entropy of the boundary of the finite spatial region both in the case of zero and finite cosmological constant. In the latter case, the effective Newton's constant appears in the entropy formula. The calculations lend support to the holographic nature of gravity for finite regions of space with a boundary.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2023; v1 submitted 26 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Instability of a Kerr-type naked singularity due to light and matter accretion and its shadow
Authors:
Aydin Tavlayan,
Bayram Tekin
Abstract:
We study null and timelike constant radii geodesics in the environment of an over-spinning putative Kerr-type naked singularity. We are particularly interested in two topics: first, the differences of the shadows of the naked rotating singularity and the Kerr black hole; and second, the spinning down effect of the particles falling from the accretion disk. Around the naked singularity, the non-equ…
▽ More
We study null and timelike constant radii geodesics in the environment of an over-spinning putative Kerr-type naked singularity. We are particularly interested in two topics: first, the differences of the shadows of the naked rotating singularity and the Kerr black hole; and second, the spinning down effect of the particles falling from the accretion disk. Around the naked singularity, the non-equatorial prograde orbits in the Kerr black hole remain intact up to a critical rotation parameter ($α=\sqrt{6 \sqrt{3}-9}$) and cease to exist above this value [Eur. Phys. J. C 78, 879 (2018)]. This has an important consequence in the shadow of the naked singularity if the shadow is registered by an observer on the polar plane or close to it as the shadow cannot be distinguished from that of a Kerr black hole viewed from the same angle considering only the light emanating from the unstable photon orbits. We show that the timelike retrograde orbits in the equatorial plane immediately (after about an 8% increase in mass for the case of initial $α=1.5$) reduce the spin parameter of the naked singularity from larger values to $α=1$ at which an event horizon appears. This happens because the retrograde orbits have a larger capture cross-section than the prograde ones. So if a naked singularity happens to have an accretion disk, it will not remain naked for long, an event horizon forms.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2024; v1 submitted 31 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Light Rings around Five Dimensional Stationary Black Holes and Naked Singularities
Authors:
Aydin Tavlayan,
Bayram Tekin
Abstract:
The existence of light rings in a spacetime is closely related to the existence of black hole horizons and observables such as the ringdown and the shadow. Black holes, compared to nonvacuum ultracompact objects, have rather unique environments. To this aim, recently [P.V.P. Cunha and C.A.R. Herdeiro, Phys. Rev. Lett. \textbf{124}, 181101 (2020)] topological arguments, independent of the underlyin…
▽ More
The existence of light rings in a spacetime is closely related to the existence of black hole horizons and observables such as the ringdown and the shadow. Black holes, compared to nonvacuum ultracompact objects, have rather unique environments. To this aim, recently [P.V.P. Cunha and C.A.R. Herdeiro, Phys. Rev. Lett. \textbf{124}, 181101 (2020)] topological arguments, independent of the underlying gravity theory, were developed to prove the existence of unstable light rings outside the Killing horizon of {\it four} dimensional asymptotically flat, stationary, axisymmetric, nonextremal black holes. Here we extend these arguments to five-dimensional stationary black holes. Generically in five dimensions, there are two possible conserved angular momenta, hence the four-dimensional discussion does not extend verbatim to five dimensions; nevertheless, we prove that there is a light ring for each rotation sense for a stationary black hole. We give the static and the Myers-Perry rotating black holes as examples. We also show that when the horizon of the black hole disappears and the singularity becomes naked, only one of the light rings survives; a similar phenomenon also occurs in four dimensions which might allow testing the cosmic censorship hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2023; v1 submitted 29 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Spherical timelike orbits around Kerr black holes
Authors:
Aydin Tavlayan,
Bayram Tekin
Abstract:
We study the order ten polynomial equation satisfied by the radius of the spherical timelike orbits for a massive particle with a generic energy around a Kerr black hole. Even though the radii of the prograde and retrograde orbits at the equatorial or polar plane for particles with zero or unit energy have a monotonic dependence on the rotation parameter of the black hole, we show that there is a…
▽ More
We study the order ten polynomial equation satisfied by the radius of the spherical timelike orbits for a massive particle with a generic energy around a Kerr black hole. Even though the radii of the prograde and retrograde orbits at the equatorial or polar plane for particles with zero or unit energy have a monotonic dependence on the rotation parameter of the black hole, we show that there is a critical inclination angle above which the retrograde orbits have a nonmonotonic dependency on the rotation of the black hole. Thus the capture cross-section of these retrograde orbits decrease with increasing black hole spin. Hence their efficiency to reduce the black hole's spin is decreased. We also provide an equation for the critical inclination angle that shows exactly at which point the nonmonotonicity starts. In addition, we employ the Lagrange-Bürmann method to find approximate analytic solutions from the known exact solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Exact Formulas for Spherical Photon Orbits Around Kerr Black Holes
Authors:
Aydin Tavlayan,
Bayram Tekin
Abstract:
Exact formulas relating the radii of the spherical photon orbits to the black hole's rotation parameter and the effective inclination angle of the orbit have been known only for equatorial and polar orbits up to now. Here we provide exact formulas for nonequatorial orbits that lie between these extreme limits. For a given rotation parameter of the black hole, there is a critical inclination angle…
▽ More
Exact formulas relating the radii of the spherical photon orbits to the black hole's rotation parameter and the effective inclination angle of the orbit have been known only for equatorial and polar orbits up to now. Here we provide exact formulas for nonequatorial orbits that lie between these extreme limits. For a given rotation parameter of the black hole, there is a critical inclination angle below which there are four null photon orbits two of which are in the exterior region. At the critical angle, the radii of these orbits are explicitly found. We also provide approximate but very accurate formulas for any orbit. To arrive at these analytical solutions, we carefully study the sextic polynomial in the radius that arises for null spherical geodesics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2020; v1 submitted 15 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Event Horizon Detecting Invariants
Authors:
Aydin Tavlayan,
Bayram Tekin
Abstract:
Some judiciously chosen local curvature scalars can be used to invariantly characterize event horizons of black holes in $D > 3$ dimensions, but they fail for the three dimensional Bañados-Teitelboim-Zanelli (BTZ) black hole since all curvature invariants are constant. Here we provide an invariant characterization of the event horizon of the BTZ black hole using the curvature invariants of codimen…
▽ More
Some judiciously chosen local curvature scalars can be used to invariantly characterize event horizons of black holes in $D > 3$ dimensions, but they fail for the three dimensional Bañados-Teitelboim-Zanelli (BTZ) black hole since all curvature invariants are constant. Here we provide an invariant characterization of the event horizon of the BTZ black hole using the curvature invariants of codimension one hypersurfaces instead of the full spacetime. Our method is also applicable to black holes in generic dimensions but is most efficient in three, four, and five dimensions. We give four dimensional Kerr, five dimensional Myers-Perry and three dimensional warped-anti-de Sitter, and the three dimensional asymptotically flat black holes as examples.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2020; v1 submitted 4 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
