-
Learning Environment Models with Continuous Stochastic Dynamics
Authors:
Martin Tappler,
Edi Muškardin,
Bernhard K. Aichernig,
Bettina Könighofer
Abstract:
Solving control tasks in complex environments automatically through learning offers great potential. While contemporary techniques from deep reinforcement learning (DRL) provide effective solutions, their decision-making is not transparent. We aim to provide insights into the decisions faced by the agent by learning an automaton model of environmental behavior under the control of an agent. Howeve…
▽ More
Solving control tasks in complex environments automatically through learning offers great potential. While contemporary techniques from deep reinforcement learning (DRL) provide effective solutions, their decision-making is not transparent. We aim to provide insights into the decisions faced by the agent by learning an automaton model of environmental behavior under the control of an agent. However, for most control problems, automata learning is not scalable enough to learn a useful model. In this work, we raise the capabilities of automata learning such that it is possible to learn models for environments that have complex and continuous dynamics.
The core of the scalability of our method lies in the computation of an abstract state-space representation, by applying dimensionality reduction and clustering on the observed environmental state space. The stochastic transitions are learned via passive automata learning from observed interactions of the agent and the environment. In an iterative model-based RL process, we sample additional trajectories to learn an accurate environment model in the form of a discrete-state Markov decision process (MDP). We apply our automata learning framework on popular RL benchmarking environments in the OpenAI Gym, including LunarLander, CartPole, Mountain Car, and Acrobot. Our results show that the learned models are so precise that they enable the computation of policies solving the respective control tasks. Yet the models are more concise and more general than neural-network-based policies and by using MDPs we benefit from a wealth of tools available for analyzing them. When solving the task of LunarLander, the learned model even achieved similar or higher rewards than deep RL policies learned with stable-baselines3.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
On the Relationship Between RNN Hidden State Vectors and Semantic Ground Truth
Authors:
Edi Muškardin,
Martin Tappler,
Ingo Pill,
Bernhard K. Aichernig,
Thomas Pock
Abstract:
We examine the assumption that the hidden-state vectors of recurrent neural networks (RNNs) tend to form clusters of semantically similar vectors, which we dub the clustering hypothesis. While this hypothesis has been assumed in the analysis of RNNs in recent years, its validity has not been studied thoroughly on modern neural network architectures. We examine the clustering hypothesis in the cont…
▽ More
We examine the assumption that the hidden-state vectors of recurrent neural networks (RNNs) tend to form clusters of semantically similar vectors, which we dub the clustering hypothesis. While this hypothesis has been assumed in the analysis of RNNs in recent years, its validity has not been studied thoroughly on modern neural network architectures. We examine the clustering hypothesis in the context of RNNs that were trained to recognize regular languages. This enables us to draw on perfect ground-truth automata in our evaluation, against which we can compare the RNN's accuracy and the distribution of the hidden-state vectors.
We start with examining the (piecewise linear) separability of an RNN's hidden-state vectors into semantically different classes. We continue the analysis by computing clusters over the hidden-state vector space with multiple state-of-the-art unsupervised clustering approaches. We formally analyze the accuracy of computed clustering functions and the validity of the clustering hypothesis by determining whether clusters group semantically similar vectors to the same state in the ground-truth model.
Our evaluation supports the validity of the clustering hypothesis in the majority of examined cases. We observed that the hidden-state vectors of well-trained RNNs are separable, and that the unsupervised clustering techniques succeed in finding clusters of similar state vectors.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Online Shielding for Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Bettina Könighofer,
Julian Rudolf,
Alexander Palmisano,
Martin Tappler,
Roderick Bloem
Abstract:
Besides the recent impressive results on reinforcement learning (RL), safety is still one of the major research challenges in RL. RL is a machine-learning approach to determine near-optimal policies in Markov decision processes (MDPs). In this paper, we consider the setting where the safety-relevant fragment of the MDP together with a temporal logic safety specification is given and many safety vi…
▽ More
Besides the recent impressive results on reinforcement learning (RL), safety is still one of the major research challenges in RL. RL is a machine-learning approach to determine near-optimal policies in Markov decision processes (MDPs). In this paper, we consider the setting where the safety-relevant fragment of the MDP together with a temporal logic safety specification is given and many safety violations can be avoided by planning ahead a short time into the future. We propose an approach for online safety shielding of RL agents. During runtime, the shield analyses the safety of each available action. For any action, the shield computes the maximal probability to not violate the safety specification within the next $k$ steps when executing this action. Based on this probability and a given threshold, the shield decides whether to block an action from the agent. Existing offline shielding approaches compute exhaustively the safety of all state-action combinations ahead of time, resulting in huge computation times and large memory consumption. The intuition behind online shielding is to compute at runtime the set of all states that could be reached in the near future. For each of these states, the safety of all available actions is analysed and used for shielding as soon as one of the considered states is reached. Our approach is well suited for high-level planning problems where the time between decisions can be used for safety computations and it is sustainable for the agent to wait until these computations are finished. For our evaluation, we selected a 2-player version of the classical computer game SNAKE. The game represents a high-level planning problem that requires fast decisions and the multiplayer setting induces a large state space, which is computationally expensive to analyse exhaustively.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Automata Learning meets Shielding
Authors:
Martin Tappler,
Stefan Pranger,
Bettina Könighofer,
Edi Muškardin,
Roderick Bloem,
Kim Larsen
Abstract:
Safety is still one of the major research challenges in reinforcement learning (RL). In this paper, we address the problem of how to avoid safety violations of RL agents during exploration in probabilistic and partially unknown environments. Our approach combines automata learning for Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) and shield synthesis in an iterative approach. Initially, the MDP representing th…
▽ More
Safety is still one of the major research challenges in reinforcement learning (RL). In this paper, we address the problem of how to avoid safety violations of RL agents during exploration in probabilistic and partially unknown environments. Our approach combines automata learning for Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) and shield synthesis in an iterative approach. Initially, the MDP representing the environment is unknown. The agent starts exploring the environment and collects traces. From the collected traces, we passively learn MDPs that abstractly represent the safety-relevant aspects of the environment. Given a learned MDP and a safety specification, we construct a shield. For each state-action pair within a learned MDP, the shield computes exact probabilities on how likely it is that executing the action results in violating the specification from the current state within the next $k$ steps. After the shield is constructed, the shield is used during runtime and blocks any actions that induce a too large risk from the agent. The shielded agent continues to explore the environment and collects new data on the environment. Iteratively, we use the collected data to learn new MDPs with higher accuracy, resulting in turn in shields able to prevent more safety violations. We implemented our approach and present a detailed case study of a Q-learning agent exploring slippery Gridworlds. In our experiments, we show that as the agent explores more and more of the environment during training, the improved learned models lead to shields that are able to prevent many safety violations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Reinforcement Learning under Partial Observability Guided by Learned Environment Models
Authors:
Edi Muskardin,
Martin Tappler,
Bernhard K. Aichernig,
Ingo Pill
Abstract:
In practical applications, we can rarely assume full observability of a system's environment, despite such knowledge being important for determining a reactive control system's precise interaction with its environment. Therefore, we propose an approach for reinforcement learning (RL) in partially observable environments. While assuming that the environment behaves like a partially observable Marko…
▽ More
In practical applications, we can rarely assume full observability of a system's environment, despite such knowledge being important for determining a reactive control system's precise interaction with its environment. Therefore, we propose an approach for reinforcement learning (RL) in partially observable environments. While assuming that the environment behaves like a partially observable Markov decision process with known discrete actions, we assume no knowledge about its structure or transition probabilities.
Our approach combines Q-learning with IoAlergia, a method for learning Markov decision processes (MDP). By learning MDP models of the environment from episodes of the RL agent, we enable RL in partially observable domains without explicit, additional memory to track previous interactions for dealing with ambiguities stemming from partial observability. We instead provide RL with additional observations in the form of abstract environment states by simulating new experiences on learned environment models to track the explored states. In our evaluation, we report on the validity of our approach and its promising performance in comparison to six state-of-the-art deep RL techniques with recurrent neural networks and fixed memory.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Search-Based Testing of Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Martin Tappler,
Filip Cano Córdoba,
Bernhard K. Aichernig,
Bettina Könighofer
Abstract:
Evaluation of deep reinforcement learning (RL) is inherently challenging. Especially the opaqueness of learned policies and the stochastic nature of both agents and environments make testing the behavior of deep RL agents difficult. We present a search-based testing framework that enables a wide range of novel analysis capabilities for evaluating the safety and performance of deep RL agents. For s…
▽ More
Evaluation of deep reinforcement learning (RL) is inherently challenging. Especially the opaqueness of learned policies and the stochastic nature of both agents and environments make testing the behavior of deep RL agents difficult. We present a search-based testing framework that enables a wide range of novel analysis capabilities for evaluating the safety and performance of deep RL agents. For safety testing, our framework utilizes a search algorithm that searches for a reference trace that solves the RL task. The backtracking states of the search, called boundary states, pose safety-critical situations. We create safety test-suites that evaluate how well the RL agent escapes safety-critical situations near these boundary states. For robust performance testing, we create a diverse set of traces via fuzz testing. These fuzz traces are used to bring the agent into a wide variety of potentially unknown states from which the average performance of the agent is compared to the average performance of the fuzz traces. We apply our search-based testing approach on RL for Nintendo's Super Mario Bros.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2022; v1 submitted 7 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Online Shielding for Stochastic Systems
Authors:
Bettina Könighofer,
Julian Rudolf,
Alexander Palmisano,
Martin Tappler,
Roderick Bloem
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a method to develop trustworthy reinforcement learning systems. To ensure safety especially during exploration, we automatically synthesize a correct-by-construction runtime enforcer, called a shield, that blocks all actions that are unsafe with respect to a temporal logic specification from the agent. Our main contribution is a new synthesis algorithm for computing the s…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a method to develop trustworthy reinforcement learning systems. To ensure safety especially during exploration, we automatically synthesize a correct-by-construction runtime enforcer, called a shield, that blocks all actions that are unsafe with respect to a temporal logic specification from the agent. Our main contribution is a new synthesis algorithm for computing the shield online. Existing offline shielding approaches compute exhaustively the safety of all states-action combinations ahead-of-time, resulting in huge offline computation times, large memory consumption, and significant delays at run-time due to the look-ups in a huge database. The intuition behind online shielding is to compute during run-time the set of all states that could be reached in the near future. For each of these states, the safety of all available actions is analysed and used for shielding as soon as one of the considered states is reached. Our proposed method is general and can be applied to a wide range of planning problems with stochastic behavior. For our evaluation, we selected a 2-player version of the classical computer game SNAKE. The game requires fast decisions and the multiplayer setting induces a large state space, computationally expensive to analyze exhaustively. The safety objective of collision avoidance is easily transferable to a variety of planning tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Adaptive Shielding under Uncertainty
Authors:
Stefan Pranger,
Bettina Könighofer,
Martin Tappler,
Martin Deixelberger,
Nils Jansen,
Roderick Bloem
Abstract:
This paper targets control problems that exhibit specific safety and performance requirements. In particular, the aim is to ensure that an agent, operating under uncertainty, will at runtime strictly adhere to such requirements. Previous works create so-called shields that correct an existing controller for the agent if it is about to take unbearable safety risks. However, so far, shields do not c…
▽ More
This paper targets control problems that exhibit specific safety and performance requirements. In particular, the aim is to ensure that an agent, operating under uncertainty, will at runtime strictly adhere to such requirements. Previous works create so-called shields that correct an existing controller for the agent if it is about to take unbearable safety risks. However, so far, shields do not consider that an environment may not be fully known in advance and may evolve for complex control and learning tasks. We propose a new method for the efficient computation of a shield that is adaptive to a changing environment. In particular, we base our method on problems that are sufficiently captured by potentially infinite Markov decision processes (MDP) and quantitative specifications such as mean payoff objectives. The shield is independent of the controller, which may, for instance, take the form of a high-performing reinforcement learning agent. At runtime, our method builds an internal abstract representation of the MDP and constantly adapts this abstraction and the shield based on observations from the environment. We showcase the applicability of our method via an urban traffic control problem.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Learning a Behavior Model of Hybrid Systems Through Combining Model-Based Testing and Machine Learning (Full Version)
Authors:
Bernhard K. Aichernig,
Roderick Bloem,
Masoud Ebrahimi,
Martin Horn,
Franz Pernkopf,
Wolfgang Roth,
Astrid Rupp,
Martin Tappler,
Markus Tranninger
Abstract:
Models play an essential role in the design process of cyber-physical systems. They form the basis for simulation and analysis and help in identifying design problems as early as possible. However, the construction of models that comprise physical and digital behavior is challenging. Therefore, there is considerable interest in learning such hybrid behavior by means of machine learning which requi…
▽ More
Models play an essential role in the design process of cyber-physical systems. They form the basis for simulation and analysis and help in identifying design problems as early as possible. However, the construction of models that comprise physical and digital behavior is challenging. Therefore, there is considerable interest in learning such hybrid behavior by means of machine learning which requires sufficient and representative training data covering the behavior of the physical system adequately. In this work, we exploit a combination of automata learning and model-based testing to generate sufficient training data fully automatically.
Experimental results on a platooning scenario show that recurrent neural networks learned with this data achieved significantly better results compared to models learned from randomly generated data. In particular, the classification error for crash detection is reduced by a factor of five and a similar F1-score is obtained with up to three orders of magnitude fewer training samples.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
L*-Based Learning of Markov Decision Processes (Extended Version)
Authors:
Martin Tappler,
Bernhard K. Aichernig,
Giovanni Bacci,
Maria Eichlseder,
Kim G. Larsen
Abstract:
Automata learning techniques automatically generate system models from test observations. These techniques usually fall into two categories: passive and active. Passive learning uses a predetermined data set, e.g., system logs. In contrast, active learning actively queries the system under learning, which is considered more efficient.
An influential active learning technique is Angluin's L* algo…
▽ More
Automata learning techniques automatically generate system models from test observations. These techniques usually fall into two categories: passive and active. Passive learning uses a predetermined data set, e.g., system logs. In contrast, active learning actively queries the system under learning, which is considered more efficient.
An influential active learning technique is Angluin's L* algorithm for regular languages which inspired several generalisations from DFAs to other automata-based modelling formalisms. In this work, we study L*-based learning of deterministic Markov decision processes, first assuming an ideal setting with perfect information. Then, we relax this assumption and present a novel learning algorithm that collects information by sampling system traces via testing. Experiments with the implementation of our sampling-based algorithm suggest that it achieves better accuracy than state-of-the-art passive learning techniques with the same amount of test data. Unlike existing learning algorithms with predefined states, our algorithm learns the complete model structure including the states.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Model-Based Testing IoT Communication via Active Automata Learning
Authors:
Martin Tappler,
Bernhard K. Aichernig,
Roderick Bloem
Abstract:
This paper presents a learning-based approach to detecting failures in reactive systems. The technique is based on inferring models of multiple implementations of a common specification which are pair-wise cross-checked for equivalence. Any counterexample to equivalence is flagged as suspicious and has to be analysed manually. Hence, it is possible to find possible failures in a semi-automatic way…
▽ More
This paper presents a learning-based approach to detecting failures in reactive systems. The technique is based on inferring models of multiple implementations of a common specification which are pair-wise cross-checked for equivalence. Any counterexample to equivalence is flagged as suspicious and has to be analysed manually. Hence, it is possible to find possible failures in a semi-automatic way without prior modelling.
We show that the approach is effective by means of a case study. For this case study, we carried out experiments in which we learned models of five implementations of MQTT brokers/servers, a protocol used in the Internet of Things. Examining these models, we found several violations of the MQTT specification. All but one of the considered implementations showed faulty behaviour. In the analysis, we discuss effectiveness and also issues we faced.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Learning Timed Automata via Genetic Programming
Authors:
Martin Tappler,
Bernhard K. Aichernig,
Kim Guldstrand Larsen,
Florian Lorber
Abstract:
Model learning has gained increasing interest in recent years. It derives behavioural models from test data of black-box systems. The main advantage offered by such techniques is that they enable model-based analysis without access to the internals of a system. Applications range from fully automated testing over model checking to system understanding. Current work focuses on learning variations o…
▽ More
Model learning has gained increasing interest in recent years. It derives behavioural models from test data of black-box systems. The main advantage offered by such techniques is that they enable model-based analysis without access to the internals of a system. Applications range from fully automated testing over model checking to system understanding. Current work focuses on learning variations of finite state machines. However, most techniques consider discrete time. In this paper, we present a method for learning timed automata, finite state machines extended with real-valued clocks. The learning method generates a model consistent with a set of timed traces collected by testing. This generation is based on genetic programming, a search-based technique for automatic program creation. We evaluate our approach on 44 timed systems, comprising four systems from the literature and 40 randomly generated examples.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2019; v1 submitted 23 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.