-
Testing for Restricted Stochastic Dominance under Survey Nonresponse with Panel Data: Theory and an Evaluation of Poverty in Australia
Authors:
Rami V. Tabri,
Mathew J. Elias
Abstract:
This paper lays the groundwork for a unifying approach to stochastic dominance testing under survey nonresponse that integrates the partial identification approach to incomplete data and design-based inference for complex survey data. We propose a novel inference procedure for restricted $s$th-order stochastic dominance, tailored to accommodate a broad spectrum of nonresponse assumptions. The meth…
▽ More
This paper lays the groundwork for a unifying approach to stochastic dominance testing under survey nonresponse that integrates the partial identification approach to incomplete data and design-based inference for complex survey data. We propose a novel inference procedure for restricted $s$th-order stochastic dominance, tailored to accommodate a broad spectrum of nonresponse assumptions. The method uses pseudo-empirical likelihood to formulate the test statistic and compares it to a critical value from the chi-squared distribution with one degree of freedom. We detail the procedure's asymptotic properties under both null and alternative hypotheses, establishing its uniform validity under the null and consistency against various alternatives. Using the Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia survey, we demonstrate the procedure's utility in a sensitivity analysis of temporal poverty comparisons among Australian households.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
The Impossibility of Testing for Dependence Using Kendall's $τ$ Under Missing Data of Unknown Form
Authors:
Oliver R. Cutbill,
Rami V. Tabri
Abstract:
This paper discusses the statistical inference problem associated with testing for dependence between two continuous random variables using Kendall's $τ$ in the context of the missing data problem. We prove the worst-case identified set for this measure of association always includes zero. The consequence of this result is that robust inference for dependence using Kendall's $τ$, where robustness…
▽ More
This paper discusses the statistical inference problem associated with testing for dependence between two continuous random variables using Kendall's $τ$ in the context of the missing data problem. We prove the worst-case identified set for this measure of association always includes zero. The consequence of this result is that robust inference for dependence using Kendall's $τ$, where robustness is with respect to the form of the missingness-generating process, is impossible.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
The Information Projection in Moment Inequality Models: Existence, Dual Representation, and Approximation
Authors:
Rami V. Tabri
Abstract:
This paper presents new existence, dual representation, and approximation results for the information projection in the infinite-dimensional setting for moment inequality models. These results are established under a general specification of the moment inequality model, nesting both conditional and unconditional models, and allowing for an infinite number of such inequalities. An essential innovat…
▽ More
This paper presents new existence, dual representation, and approximation results for the information projection in the infinite-dimensional setting for moment inequality models. These results are established under a general specification of the moment inequality model, nesting both conditional and unconditional models, and allowing for an infinite number of such inequalities. An essential innovation of the paper is the exhibition of the dual variable as a weak vector-valued integral to formulate an approximation scheme of the $I$-projection's equivalent Fenchel dual problem. In particular, it is shown under suitable assumptions that the dual problem's optimum value can be approximated by the values of finite-dimensional programs and that, in addition, every accumulation point of a sequence of optimal solutions for the approximating programs is an optimal solution for the dual problem. This paper illustrates the verification of assumptions and the construction of the approximation scheme's parameters for the cases of unconditional and conditional first-order stochastic dominance constraints and dominance conditions that characterize selectionable distributions for a random set. The paper also includes numerical experiments based on these examples that demonstrate the simplicity of the approximation scheme in practice and its straightforward implementation using off-the-shelf optimization methods.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2022; v1 submitted 15 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Inference for Moment Inequalities: A Constrained Moment Selection Procedure
Authors:
Rami V. Tabri,
Christopher D. Walker
Abstract:
Inference in models where the parameter is defined by moment inequalities is of interest in many areas of economics. This paper develops a new method for improving the performance of generalized moment selection (GMS) testing procedures in finite-samples. The method modifies GMS tests by tilting the empirical distribution in its moment selection step by an amount that maximizes the empirical likel…
▽ More
Inference in models where the parameter is defined by moment inequalities is of interest in many areas of economics. This paper develops a new method for improving the performance of generalized moment selection (GMS) testing procedures in finite-samples. The method modifies GMS tests by tilting the empirical distribution in its moment selection step by an amount that maximizes the empirical likelihood subject to the restrictions of the null hypothesis. We characterize sets of population distributions on which a modified GMS test is (i) asymptotically equivalent to its non-modified version to first-order, and (ii) superior to its non-modified version according to local power when the sample size is large enough. An important feature of the proposed modification is that it remains computationally feasible even when the number of moment inequalities is large. We report simulation results that show the modified tests control size well, and have markedly improved local power over their non-modified counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2020; v1 submitted 20 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
