-
Health Wearables, Gamification, and Healthful Activity
Authors:
Muhammad Zia Hydari,
Idris Adjerid,
Aaron D. Striegel
Abstract:
Health wearables in combination with gamification enable interventions that have the potential to increase physical activity -- a key determinant of health. However, the extant literature does not provide conclusive evidence on the benefits of gamification, and there are persistent concerns that competition-based gamification approaches will only benefit those who are highly active at the expense…
▽ More
Health wearables in combination with gamification enable interventions that have the potential to increase physical activity -- a key determinant of health. However, the extant literature does not provide conclusive evidence on the benefits of gamification, and there are persistent concerns that competition-based gamification approaches will only benefit those who are highly active at the expense of those who are sedentary. We investigate the effect of Fitbit leaderboards on the number of steps taken by the user. Using a unique data set of Fitbit wearable users, some of whom participate in a leaderboard, we find that leaderboards lead to a 370 (3.5%) step increase in the users' daily physical activity. However, we find that the benefits of leaderboards are highly heterogeneous. Surprisingly, we find that those who were highly active prior to adoption are hurt by leaderboards and walk 630 fewer steps daily after adoption (a 5% relative decrease). In contrast, those who were sedentary prior to adoption benefited substantially from leaderboards and walked an additional 1,300 steps daily after adoption (a 15% relative increase). We find that these effects emerge because sedentary individuals benefit even when leaderboards are small and when they do not rank first on them. In contrast, highly active individuals are harmed by smaller leaderboards and only see benefit when they rank highly on large leaderboards. We posit that this unexpected divergence in effects could be due to the underappreciated potential of noncompetition dynamics (e.g., changes in expectations for exercise) to benefit sedentary users, but harm more active ones.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
A Survey of Passive Sensing in the Workplace
Authors:
Subigya Nepal,
Gonzalo J. Martinez,
Arvind Pillai,
Koustuv Saha,
Shayan Mirjafari,
Vedant Das Swain,
Xuhai Xu,
Pino G. Audia,
Munmun De Choudhury,
Anind K. Dey,
Aaron Striegel,
Andrew T. Campbell
Abstract:
As emerging technologies increasingly integrate into all facets of our lives, the workplace stands at the forefront of potential transformative changes. A notable development in this realm is the advent of passive sensing technology, designed to enhance both cognitive and physical capabilities by monitoring human behavior. This paper reviews current research on the application of passive sensing t…
▽ More
As emerging technologies increasingly integrate into all facets of our lives, the workplace stands at the forefront of potential transformative changes. A notable development in this realm is the advent of passive sensing technology, designed to enhance both cognitive and physical capabilities by monitoring human behavior. This paper reviews current research on the application of passive sensing technology in the workplace, focusing on its impact on employee wellbeing and productivity. Additionally, we explore unresolved issues and outline prospective pathways for the incorporation of passive sensing in future workplaces.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2024; v1 submitted 9 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Designing an Interactive Visualization System for Monitoring Participant Compliance in a Large-Scale, Longitudinal Study
Authors:
Poorna Talkad Sukumar,
Thomas Breideband,
Gonzalo Martinez,
Megan Caruso,
Sierra Rose,
Cooper Steputis,
Sidney D'Mello,
Gloria Mark,
Aaron Striegel
Abstract:
Frequent monitoring of participant compliance is necessary when conducting large-scale, longitudinal studies to ensure that the collected data is of sufficiently high quality. While the need for achieving high compliance has been underscored and there are discussions on incentives and factors affecting compliance, little is shared about the actual processes and tools used for monitoring compliance…
▽ More
Frequent monitoring of participant compliance is necessary when conducting large-scale, longitudinal studies to ensure that the collected data is of sufficiently high quality. While the need for achieving high compliance has been underscored and there are discussions on incentives and factors affecting compliance, little is shared about the actual processes and tools used for monitoring compliance in such studies. Monitoring participant compliance with respect to multi-modal data can be a tedious process, especially if there are only a few personnel involved. In this case study, we describe the iterative design of an interactive visualization system we developed for monitoring compliance and refined based on changing requirements in an ongoing study. We find that the visualization system, leveraging the digital medium, both facilitates the exploratory tasks of monitoring participant compliance and supports asynchronous collaboration among non-co-located researchers. Our documented requirements for checking participant compliance as well as the design of the visualization system can help inform the compliance-monitoring process in future studies.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Jointly Predicting Job Performance, Personality, Cognitive Ability, Affect, and Well-Being
Authors:
Pablo Robles-Granda,
Suwen Lin,
Xian Wu,
Sidney D'Mello,
Gonzalo J. Martinez,
Koustuv Saha,
Kari Nies,
Gloria Mark,
Andrew T. Campbell,
Munmun De Choudhury,
Anind D. Dey,
Julie Gregg,
Ted Grover,
Stephen M. Mattingly,
Shayan Mirjafari,
Edward Moskal,
Aaron Striegel,
Nitesh V. Chawla
Abstract:
Assessment of job performance, personalized health and psychometric measures are domains where data-driven and ubiquitous computing exhibits the potential of a profound impact in the future. Existing techniques use data extracted from questionnaires, sensors (wearable, computer, etc.), or other traits, to assess well-being and cognitive attributes of individuals. However, these techniques can neit…
▽ More
Assessment of job performance, personalized health and psychometric measures are domains where data-driven and ubiquitous computing exhibits the potential of a profound impact in the future. Existing techniques use data extracted from questionnaires, sensors (wearable, computer, etc.), or other traits, to assess well-being and cognitive attributes of individuals. However, these techniques can neither predict individual's well-being and psychological traits in a global manner nor consider the challenges associated to processing the data available, that is incomplete and noisy. In this paper, we create a benchmark for predictive analysis of individuals from a perspective that integrates: physical and physiological behavior, psychological states and traits, and job performance. We design data mining techniques as benchmark and uses real noisy and incomplete data derived from wearable sensors to predict 19 constructs based on 12 standardized well-validated tests. The study included 757 participants who were knowledge workers in organizations across the USA with varied work roles. We developed a data mining framework to extract the meaningful predictors for each of the 19 variables under consideration. Our model is the first benchmark that combines these various instrument-derived variables in a single framework to understand people's behavior by leveraging real uncurated data from wearable, mobile, and social media sources. We verify our approach experimentally using the data obtained from our longitudinal study. The results show that our framework is consistently reliable and capable of predicting the variables under study better than the baselines when prediction is restricted to the noisy, incomplete data.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
The power of dynamic social networks to predict individuals' mental health
Authors:
Shikang Liu,
David Hachen,
Omar Lizardo,
Christian Poellabauer,
Aaron Striegel,
Tijana Milenkovic
Abstract:
Precision medicine has received attention both in and outside the clinic. We focus on the latter, by exploiting the relationship between individuals' social interactions and their mental health to develop a predictive model of one's likelihood to be depressed or anxious from rich dynamic social network data. To our knowledge, we are the first to do this. Existing studies differ from our work in at…
▽ More
Precision medicine has received attention both in and outside the clinic. We focus on the latter, by exploiting the relationship between individuals' social interactions and their mental health to develop a predictive model of one's likelihood to be depressed or anxious from rich dynamic social network data. To our knowledge, we are the first to do this. Existing studies differ from our work in at least one aspect: they do not model social interaction data as a network; they do so but analyze static network data; they examine "correlation" between social networks and health but without develo** a predictive model; or they study other individual traits but not mental health. In a systematic and comprehensive evaluation, we show that our predictive model that uses dynamic social network data is superior to its static network as well as non-network equivalents when run on the same data.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Heterogeneous network approach to predict individuals' mental health
Authors:
Shikang Liu,
Fatemeh Vahedian,
David Hachen,
Omar Lizardo,
Christian Poellabauer,
Aaron Striegel,
Tijana Milenkovic
Abstract:
Depression and anxiety are critical public health issues affecting millions of people around the world. To identify individuals who are vulnerable to depression and anxiety, predictive models have been built that typically utilize data from one source. Unlike these traditional models, in this study, we leverage a rich heterogeneous data set from the University of Notre Dame's NetHealth study that…
▽ More
Depression and anxiety are critical public health issues affecting millions of people around the world. To identify individuals who are vulnerable to depression and anxiety, predictive models have been built that typically utilize data from one source. Unlike these traditional models, in this study, we leverage a rich heterogeneous data set from the University of Notre Dame's NetHealth study that collected individuals' (student participants') social interaction data via smartphones, health-related behavioral data via wearables (Fitbit), and trait data from surveys. To integrate the different types of information, we model the NetHealth data as a heterogeneous information network (HIN). Then, we redefine the problem of predicting individuals' mental health conditions (depression or anxiety) in a novel manner, as applying to our HIN a popular paradigm of a recommender system (RS), which is typically used to predict the preference that a person would give to an item (e.g., a movie or book). In our case, the items are the individuals' different mental health states. We evaluate four state-of-the-art RS approaches. Also, we model the prediction of individuals' mental health as another problem type - that of node classification (NC) in our HIN, evaluating in the process four node features under logistic regression as a proof-of-concept classifier. We find that our RS and NC network methods produce more accurate predictions than a logistic regression model using the same NetHealth data in the traditional non-network fashion as well as a random-approach. Also, we find that the best of the considered RS approaches outperforms all considered NC approaches. This is the first study to integrate smartphone, wearable sensor, and survey data in an HIN manner and use RS or NC on the HIN to predict individuals' mental health conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2020; v1 submitted 10 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Aggressive Economic Incentives and Physical Activity: The Role of Choice and Technology Decision Aids
Authors:
Idris Adjerid,
Rachael Purta,
Aaron Striegel,
George Loewenstein
Abstract:
Aggressive incentive schemes that allow individuals to impose economic punishment on themselves if they fail to meet health goals present a promising approach for encouraging healthier behavior. However, the element of choice inherent in these schemes introduces concerns that only non-representative sectors of the population will select aggressive incentives, leaving value on the table for those w…
▽ More
Aggressive incentive schemes that allow individuals to impose economic punishment on themselves if they fail to meet health goals present a promising approach for encouraging healthier behavior. However, the element of choice inherent in these schemes introduces concerns that only non-representative sectors of the population will select aggressive incentives, leaving value on the table for those who don't opt in. In a field experiment conducted over a 29 week period on individuals wearing Fitbit activity trackers, we find modest and short lived increases in physical activity for those provided the choice of aggressive incentives. In contrast, we find significant and persistent increases for those assigned (oftentimes against their stated preference) to the same aggressive incentives. The modest benefits for those provided a choice seems to emerge because those who benefited most from the aggressive incentives were the least likely to choose them, and it was those who did not need them who opted in. These results are confirmed in a follow up lab experiment. We also find that benefits to individuals assigned to aggressive incentives were pronounced if they also updated their step target in the Fitbit mobile application to match the new activity goal we provided them. Our findings have important implications for incentive based interventions to improve health behavior. For firms and policy makers, our results suggest that one effective strategy for encouraging sustained healthy behavior combines exposure to aggressive incentive schemes to jolt individuals out of their comfort zones with technology decision aids that help individuals sustain this behavior after incentives end.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2018; v1 submitted 15 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Long-term Compliance Habits: What Early Data Tells Us
Authors:
Louis Faust,
Priscilla Jiménez,
David Hachen,
Omar Lizardo,
Aaron Striegel,
Nitesh V. Chawla
Abstract:
The rise in popularity of physical activity trackers provides extensive opportunities for research on personal health, however, barriers such as compliance attrition can lead to substantial losses in data. As such, insights into student's compliance habits could support researcher's decisions when designing long-term studies. In this paper, we examined 392 students on a college campus currently tw…
▽ More
The rise in popularity of physical activity trackers provides extensive opportunities for research on personal health, however, barriers such as compliance attrition can lead to substantial losses in data. As such, insights into student's compliance habits could support researcher's decisions when designing long-term studies. In this paper, we examined 392 students on a college campus currently two and a half years into an ongoing study. We find that compliance data from as early as one month correlated with student's likelihood of drop** out of the study (p < .001) and compliance long-term (p < .001). The findings in this paper identify long-term compliance habits and the viability of their early detection.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
RadioHound: A Pervasive Sensing Network for Sub-6 GHz Dynamic Spectrum Monitoring
Authors:
Nikolaus Kleber,
Jonathan Chisum,
Aaron Striegel,
Bertrand Hochwald,
Abbas Termos,
J. Nicholas Laneman,
Zuohui Fu,
John Merritt
Abstract:
We design a custom spectrum sensing network, called RadioHound, capable of tuning from 25 MHz to 6 GHz, which covers nearly all widely-deployed wireless activity. We describe the system hardware and network infrastructure in detail with a view towards driving the cost, size, and power usage of the sensors as low as possible. The system estimates the spatial variation of radio-frequency power from…
▽ More
We design a custom spectrum sensing network, called RadioHound, capable of tuning from 25 MHz to 6 GHz, which covers nearly all widely-deployed wireless activity. We describe the system hardware and network infrastructure in detail with a view towards driving the cost, size, and power usage of the sensors as low as possible. The system estimates the spatial variation of radio-frequency power from an unknown random number of sources. System performance is measured by computing the mean square error against a simulated radio-frequency environment. We find that the system performance depends heavily on the deployment density of the sensors. Consequently, we derive an expression for the sensor density as a function of environmental characteristics and confidence in measurement quality.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Gender Differences in Communication Behaviors, Spatial Proximity Patterns, and Mobility Habits
Authors:
Yang Yang,
Omar Lizardo,
Dong Wang,
Yuxiao Dong,
Aaron D. Striegel,
David Hachen,
Nitesh V. Chawla
Abstract:
The existence of gender differences in the structure and composition of social networks is a well established finding in the social and behavioral sciences, but researchers continue to debate whether structural, dispositional, or life course factors are the primary driver of these differences. In this paper we extend work on gender differences in social networks to patterns of interaction, propinq…
▽ More
The existence of gender differences in the structure and composition of social networks is a well established finding in the social and behavioral sciences, but researchers continue to debate whether structural, dispositional, or life course factors are the primary driver of these differences. In this paper we extend work on gender differences in social networks to patterns of interaction, propinquity, and connectivity captured via a social sensing platform comprised of an ensemble of individuals' phone calls, text messaging, face-to-face interactions, and traces of their mobility activities. We attempt to isolate dispositional from other factors by focusing on a relatively homogeneous population on a relatively closed setting at the same stage in the life course. Analysis across three different networks along with mobility data reveals systematic gender differences in terms of communicative, distributional, mobility, and spatial proximity tendencies. Most importantly, some patterns observed in the communication network (e.g. stronger same-gender preference for women) are found to be reversed in the spatial proximity context, with men displaying a greater tendency to spend time in a narrower (and thus more predictable) range of spaces with same-gender peers than women. These findings provide robust and novel evidence for the powerful effect of gender in structuring behavior across a wide range of communication and mobility behaviors, validating and extending recent work pointing to differences of socio-cultural and evolutionary origin in the styles of sociability and interaction characteristic of men and women.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Redundancy Elimination Might Be Overrated: A Quantitative Study on Real-World Wireless Traffic
Authors:
Xueheng Hu,
Aaron Striegel
Abstract:
With significant increases in mobile device traffic slated for the foreseeable future, numerous technologies must be embraced to satisfy such demand. Notably, one of the more intriguing approaches has been blending on-device caching and device-to-device (D2D) communications. While various past research has pointed to potentially significant gains (30%+) via redundancy elimination (RE), some skepti…
▽ More
With significant increases in mobile device traffic slated for the foreseeable future, numerous technologies must be embraced to satisfy such demand. Notably, one of the more intriguing approaches has been blending on-device caching and device-to-device (D2D) communications. While various past research has pointed to potentially significant gains (30%+) via redundancy elimination (RE), some skepticism has emerged to whether or not such gains are truly harnessable in practice. The premise of this paper is to explore whether or not significant potential for redundancy elimination exists and whether the rise of video and encryption might blunt said efforts. Critically, we find that absent significant synchronized interests of mobile users, the actual redundancy falls well short of the promising values from the literature. In our paper, we investigate the roots for said shortcomings by exploring RE savings with regards to cache hit characteristics and to what extent client and domain diversity contribute to the realized redundancy savings.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
IGLOO: Integrating global and local biological network alignment
Authors:
Lei Meng,
Joseph Crawford,
Aaron Striegel,
Tijana Milenkovic
Abstract:
Analogous to genomic sequence alignment, biological network alignment (NA) aims to find regions of similarities between molecular networks (rather than sequences) of different species. NA can be either local (LNA) or global (GNA). LNA aims to identify highly conserved common subnetworks, which are typically small, while GNA aims to identify large common subnetworks, which are typically suboptimall…
▽ More
Analogous to genomic sequence alignment, biological network alignment (NA) aims to find regions of similarities between molecular networks (rather than sequences) of different species. NA can be either local (LNA) or global (GNA). LNA aims to identify highly conserved common subnetworks, which are typically small, while GNA aims to identify large common subnetworks, which are typically suboptimally conserved. We recently showed that LNA and GNA yield complementary results: LNA has high functional but low topological alignment quality, while GNA has high topological but low functional alignment quality. Thus, we propose IGLOO, a new approach that integrates GNA and LNA in hope to reconcile the two. We evaluate IGLOO against state-of-the-art LNA (NetworkBLAST, NetAligner, AlignNemo, and AlignMCL) and GNA (GHOST, NETAL, GEDEVO, MAGNA++, WAVE, and L-GRAAL) methods. We show that IGLOO allows for a trade-off between topological and functional alignment quality better than the existing LNA and GNA methods considered in our study.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2016; v1 submitted 20 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Local versus Global Biological Network Alignment
Authors:
Lei Meng,
Aaron Striegel,
Tijana Milenkovic
Abstract:
Network alignment (NA) aims to find regions of similarities between molecular networks of different species. There exist two NA categories: local (LNA) or global (GNA). LNA finds small highly conserved network regions and produces a many-to-many node map**. GNA finds large conserved regions and produces a one-to-one node map**. Given the different outputs of LNA and GNA, when a new NA method i…
▽ More
Network alignment (NA) aims to find regions of similarities between molecular networks of different species. There exist two NA categories: local (LNA) or global (GNA). LNA finds small highly conserved network regions and produces a many-to-many node map**. GNA finds large conserved regions and produces a one-to-one node map**. Given the different outputs of LNA and GNA, when a new NA method is proposed, it is compared against existing methods from the same category. However, both NA categories have the same goal: to allow for transferring functional knowledge from well- to poorly-studied species between conserved network regions. So, which one to choose, LNA or GNA? To answer this, we introduce the first systematic evaluation of the two NA categories.
We introduce new measures of alignment quality that allow for fair comparison of the different LNA and GNA outputs, as such measures do not exist. We provide user-friendly software for efficient alignment evaluation that implements the new and existing measures. We evaluate prominent LNA and GNA methods on synthetic and real-world biological networks. We study the effect on alignment quality of using different interaction types and confidence levels. We find that the superiority of one NA category over the other is context-dependent. Further, when we contrast LNA and GNA in the application of learning novel protein functional knowledge, the two produce very different predictions, indicating their complementarity. Our results and software provide guidelines for future NA method development and evaluation.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Is There WiFi Yet? How Aggressive WiFi Probe Requests Deteriorate Energy and Throughput
Authors:
Xueheng Hu,
Lixing Song,
Dirk Van Bruggen,
Aaron Striegel
Abstract:
WiFi offloading has emerged as a key component of cellular operator strategy to meet the data needs of rich, mobile devices. As such, mobile devices tend to aggressively seek out WiFi in order to provide improved user Quality of Experience (QoE) and cellular capacity relief. For home and work environments, aggressive WiFi scans can significantly improve the speed on which mobile nodes join the WiF…
▽ More
WiFi offloading has emerged as a key component of cellular operator strategy to meet the data needs of rich, mobile devices. As such, mobile devices tend to aggressively seek out WiFi in order to provide improved user Quality of Experience (QoE) and cellular capacity relief. For home and work environments, aggressive WiFi scans can significantly improve the speed on which mobile nodes join the WiFi network. Unfortunately, the same aggressive behavior that excels in the home environment incurs considerable side effects across crowded wireless environments. In this paper, we show through empirical studies at both large (stadium) and small (laboratory) scales how aggressive WiFi scans can have significant implications for energy and throughput, both for the mobile nodes scanning and other nearby mobile nodes. We close with several thoughts on the disjoint incentives for properly balancing WiFi discovery speed and ultra-dense network interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
The jigsaw puzzle of sequence phenotype inference: Piecing together Shannon entropy, importance sampling, and Empirical Bayes
Authors:
Zeina Shreif,
Deborah A. Striegel,
Vipul Periwal
Abstract:
A nucleotide sequence 35 base pairs long can take 1,180,591,620,717,411,303,424 possible values. An example of systems biology datasets, protein binding microarrays, contain activity data from about 40000 such sequences. The discrepancy between the number of possible configurations and the available activities is enormous. Thus, albeit that systems biology datasets are large in absolute terms, the…
▽ More
A nucleotide sequence 35 base pairs long can take 1,180,591,620,717,411,303,424 possible values. An example of systems biology datasets, protein binding microarrays, contain activity data from about 40000 such sequences. The discrepancy between the number of possible configurations and the available activities is enormous. Thus, albeit that systems biology datasets are large in absolute terms, they oftentimes require methods developed for rare events due to the combinatorial increase in the number of possible configurations of biological systems. A plethora of techniques for handling large datasets, such as Empirical Bayes, or rare events, such as importance sampling, have been developed in the literature, but these cannot always be simultaneously utilized. Here we introduce a principled approach to Empirical Bayes based on importance sampling, information theory, and theoretical physics in the general context of sequence phenotype model induction. We present the analytical calculations that underlie our approach. We demonstrate the computational efficiency of the approach on concrete examples, and demonstrate its efficacy by applying the theory to publicly available protein binding microarray transcription factor datasets and to data on synthetic cAMP-regulated enhancer sequences. As further demonstrations, we find transcription factor binding motifs, predict the activity of new sequences and extract the locations of transcription factor binding sites. In summary, we present a novel method that is efficient (requiring minimal computational time and reasonable amounts of memory), has high predictive power that is comparable with that of models with hundreds of parameters, and has a limited number of optimized parameters, proportional to the sequence length.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2015; v1 submitted 16 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Zen and the Science of Pattern Identification: An Inquiry into Bayesian Skepticism
Authors:
Deborah A. Striegel,
Damian Wojtowicz,
Teresa M. Przytycka,
Vipul Periwal
Abstract:
Finding patterns in data is one of the most challenging open questions in information science. The number of possible relationships scales combinatorially with the size of the dataset, overwhelming the exponential increase in availability of computational resources. Physical insights have been instrumental in develo** efficient computational heuristics. Using quantum field theory methods and ret…
▽ More
Finding patterns in data is one of the most challenging open questions in information science. The number of possible relationships scales combinatorially with the size of the dataset, overwhelming the exponential increase in availability of computational resources. Physical insights have been instrumental in develo** efficient computational heuristics. Using quantum field theory methods and rethinking three centuries of Bayesian inference, we formulated the problem in terms of finding landscapes of patterns and solved this problem exactly. The generality of our calculus is illustrated by applying it to handwritten digit images and to finding structural features in proteins from sequence alignments without any presumptions about model priors suited to specific datasets. Landscapes of patterns can be uncovered on a desktop computer in minutes.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
