Showing 1–49 of 49 results for author: Stinson, G S

NIHAO XVI: The properties and evolution of kinematically selected discs, bulges and stellar haloes

Authors: Aura Obreja, Aaron A. Dutton, Andrea V. Macciò, Benjamin Moster, Tobias Buck, Glenn van den Ven, Liang Wang, Gregory S. Stinson, Ling Zhu

Abstract: We use 25 simulated galaxies from the NIHAO project to define and characterize a variety of kinematic stellar structures: thin and thick discs, large scale single discs, classical and pseudo bulges, spheroids, inner discs, and stellar haloes. These structures have masses, spins, shapes and rotational support in good agreement with theoretical expectations and observational data. Above a dark matte… ▽ More We use 25 simulated galaxies from the NIHAO project to define and characterize a variety of kinematic stellar structures: thin and thick discs, large scale single discs, classical and pseudo bulges, spheroids, inner discs, and stellar haloes. These structures have masses, spins, shapes and rotational support in good agreement with theoretical expectations and observational data. Above a dark matter halo mass of $2.5\times10^{\rm~11}M_{\rm\odot}$, all galaxies have a classical bulge and 70\% have a thin and thick disc. The kinematic (thin) discs follow a power-law relation between angular momentum and stellar mass $J_{\rm *}=3.4M_{\rm *}^{\rm1.26\pm0.06}$, in very good agreement with the prediction based on the empirical stellar-to-halo mass relation in the same mass range, and show a strong correlation between maximum `observed' rotation velocity and dark matter halo circular velocity $v_{\rm c}=6.4v_{\rm max}^{0.64\pm0.04}$. Tracing back in time these structures' progenitors, we find all to lose a fraction $1-f_j$ of their maximum angular momentum. Thin discs are significantly better at retaining their high-redshift spins ($f_j\sim0.70$) than thick ones ($f_j\sim0.40$). Stellar haloes have their progenitor baryons assembled the latest ($z_{\rm~1/2}\sim1.1$) and over the longest timescales ($τ\sim6.2$~Gyr), and have the smallest fraction of stars born in-situ ($f_{\rm in-situ}=0.35\pm0.14$). All other structures have $1.5\lesssim z_{\rm1/2}\lesssim3$, $τ=4\pm2$~Gyr and $f_{\rm in-situ}\gtrsim0.9$. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2019; v1 submitted 18 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: Accepted by MNRAS. First application of the methods described in arXiv:1804.05576

Introducing galactic structure finder: the multiple stellar kinematic structures of a simulated Milky Way mass galaxy

Authors: Aura Obreja, Andrea V. Macciò, Benjamin Moster, Aaron A. Dutton, Tobias Buck, Gregory S. Stinson, Liang Wang

Abstract: We present the first results of applying Gaussian Mixture Models in the stellar kinematic space of normalized angular momentum and binding energy on NIHAO high resolution galaxies to separate the stars into multiple components. We exemplify this method using a simulated Milky Way analogue, whose stellar component hosts: thin and thick discs, classical and pseudo bulges, and a stellar halo. The pro… ▽ More We present the first results of applying Gaussian Mixture Models in the stellar kinematic space of normalized angular momentum and binding energy on NIHAO high resolution galaxies to separate the stars into multiple components. We exemplify this method using a simulated Milky Way analogue, whose stellar component hosts: thin and thick discs, classical and pseudo bulges, and a stellar halo. The properties of these stellar structures are in good agreement with observational expectations in terms of sizes, shapes and rotational support. Interestingly, the two kinematic discs show surface mass density profiles more centrally concentrated than exponentials, while the bulges and the stellar halo are purely exponential. We trace back in time the Lagrangian mass of each component separately to study their formation history. Between z~3 and the end of halo virialization, z~1.3, all components lose a fraction of their angular momentum. The classical bulge loses the most (~95%) and the thin disc the least (~60%). Both bulges formed their stars in-situ at high redshift, while the thin disc formed ~98% in-situ, but with a constant SFR~1.5M$_{\rm\odot}$/yr$^{\rm-1}$ over the last ~11 Gyr. Accreted stars (6% of total stellar mass) are mainly incorporated to the thick disc or the stellar halo, which formed ex-situ 8% and 45% of their respective masses. Our analysis pipeline is freely available at https://github.com/aobr/gsf. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2018; v1 submitted 16 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: MNRAS accepted. First results described in arXiv:1804.06635

Quenching vs. Quiescence: forming realistic massive ellipticals with a simple starvation model

Authors: Thales A. Gutcke, Andrea V. Macciò, Aaron A. Dutton, Greg S. Stinson

Abstract: The decrease in star formation (SF) and the morphological change necessary to produce the $z=0$ elliptical galaxy population are commonly ascribed to a sudden quenching event, which is able to rid the central galaxy of its cold gas reservoir in a short time. Following this event, the galaxy is able to prevent further SF and stay quiescent via a maintenance mode. We test whether such a quenching ev… ▽ More The decrease in star formation (SF) and the morphological change necessary to produce the $z=0$ elliptical galaxy population are commonly ascribed to a sudden quenching event, which is able to rid the central galaxy of its cold gas reservoir in a short time. Following this event, the galaxy is able to prevent further SF and stay quiescent via a maintenance mode. We test whether such a quenching event is truly necessary using a simple model of quiescence. In this model, hot gas (all gas above a temperature threshold) in a $\sim10^{12} M_{\odot}$ halo mass galaxy at redshift $z\sim3$ is prevented from cooling. The cool gas continues to form stars at a decreasing rate and the galaxy stellar mass, morphology, velocity dispersion and position on the color magnitude diagram (CMD) proceed to evolve. By $z=0$, the halo mass has grown to $10^{13} M_{\odot}$ and the galaxy has attained characteristics typical of an observed $z=0$ elliptical galaxy. Our model is run in the framework of a cosmological, smooth particle hydrodynamic code which includes SF, early stellar feedback, supernova feedback, metal cooling and metal diffusion. Additionally, we post-process our simulations with a radiative transfer code to create a mock CMD. In contrast to previous assumptions that a pure "fade away" model evolves too slowly to account for the sparsity of galaxies in the "green valley", we demonstrate crossing times of $<$1 Gyr. We conclude that no sudden quenching event is necessary to produce such rapid colour transitions. △ Less

Submitted 4 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: 12 pages, 11 figures, accepted to be published in MNRAS

NIHAO XII: galactic uniformity in a ΛCDM universe

Authors: Aaron A. Dutton, Aura Obreja, Liang Wang, Thales A. Gutcke, Tobias Buck, Silviu M. Udrescu, Jonas Frings, Gregory S. Stinson, Xi Kang, Andrea V. Macciò

Abstract: We use a sample of 83 high-resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations and a semi-analytic model (SAM) to study the stochasticity of galaxy formation in haloes ranging from dwarf to Milky Way masses. Our simulated galaxies reproduce the observed inefficiency of galaxy formation as expressed through the stellar, gas and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations. For HI velocities in the range (70 < V < 220 k… ▽ More We use a sample of 83 high-resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations and a semi-analytic model (SAM) to study the stochasticity of galaxy formation in haloes ranging from dwarf to Milky Way masses. Our simulated galaxies reproduce the observed inefficiency of galaxy formation as expressed through the stellar, gas and baryonic Tully-Fisher relations. For HI velocities in the range (70 < V < 220 km/s), the scatter is just 0.08 to 0.14 dex, consistent with the observed intrinsic scatter at these scales. At low velocities (20 < V < 70 km/s), the simulated scatter is 0.2-0.25 dex, which could be tested with future observations. The scatter in the stellar mass versus dark halo velocity relation is constant for 30 < V < 180 km/s, and smaller (~0.17 dex) when using the maximum circular velocity of the dark matter only simulation, Vmax, compared to the virial velocity ($V_{200}$ or $V_{200}^{DMO}$). The scatter in stellar mass is correlated with halo concentration, and is minimized when using a circular velocity at a fixed fraction of the virial radius $\simeq 0.4 R_{200}$ or with $V_α=V_{200}^{DMO} (V_{max}^{DMO} / V_{200}^{DMO})^α$ with α~ 0.7, consistent with constraints from halo clustering. Using the SAM we show the correlation between halo formation time and concentration is essential in order to reproduce this result. This uniformity in galaxy formation efficiency we see in our hydrodynamical simulations and a semi-analytic model proves the simplicity and self-regulating nature of galaxy formation in a ΛCold Dark Matter universe. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2017; v1 submitted 20 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: 16 pages, 13 figures, accepted to MNRAS

NIHAO IX: the role of gas inflows and outflows in driving the contraction and expansion of cold dark matter haloes

Authors: Aaron A. Dutton, Andrea V. Macciò, Avishai Dekel, Liang Wang, Gregory S. Stinson, Aura Obreja, Arianna Di Cintio, Chris B. Brook, Tobias Buck, Xi Kang

Abstract: We use ~100 cosmological galaxy formation zoom-in simulations using the smoothed particle hydrodynamics code {\sc gasoline} to study the effect of baryonic processes on the mass profiles of cold dark matter haloes. The haloes in our study range from dwarf (M_{200}~10^{10}Msun) to Milky Way (M_{200}~10^{12}Msun) masses. Our simulations exhibit a wide range of halo responses, primarily varying with… ▽ More We use ~100 cosmological galaxy formation zoom-in simulations using the smoothed particle hydrodynamics code {\sc gasoline} to study the effect of baryonic processes on the mass profiles of cold dark matter haloes. The haloes in our study range from dwarf (M_{200}~10^{10}Msun) to Milky Way (M_{200}~10^{12}Msun) masses. Our simulations exhibit a wide range of halo responses, primarily varying with mass, from expansion to contraction, with up to factor ~10 changes in the enclosed dark matter mass at one per cent of the virial radius. Confirming previous studies, the halo response is correlated with the integrated efficiency of star formation: e_SF=(M_{star}/M_{200})/(Ω_b/Ω_m). In addition we report a new correlation with the compactness of the stellar system: e_R=r_{1/2}/R_{200}. We provide an analytic formula depending on e_SF and e_R for the response of cold dark matter haloes to baryonic processes. An observationally testable prediction is that, at fixed mass, larger galaxies experience more halo expansion, while the smaller galaxies more halo contraction. This diversity of dark halo response is captured by a toy model consisting of cycles of adiabatic inflow (causing contraction) and impulsive gas outflow (causing expansion). For net outflow, or equal inflow and outflow fractions, f, the overall effect is expansion, with more expansion with larger f. For net inflow, contraction occurs for small f (large radii), while expansion occurs for large f (small radii), recovering the phenomenology seen in our simulations. These regularities in the galaxy formation process provide a step towards a fully predictive model for the structure of cold dark matter haloes. △ Less

Submitted 5 July, 2016; v1 submitted 17 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Comments: 20 pages, 15 figures, accepted to MNRAS

NIHAO VI. The hidden discs of simulated galaxies

Authors: A. Obreja, G. S. Stinson, A. A. Dutton, A. V. Macciò, L. Wang, X. Kang

Abstract: Detailed studies of galaxy formation require clear definitions of the structural components of galaxies. Precisely defined components also enable better comparisons between observations and simulations. We use a subsample of eighteen cosmological zoom-in simulations from the NIHAO project to derive a robust method for defining stellar kinematic discs in galaxies. Our method uses Gaussian Mixture M… ▽ More Detailed studies of galaxy formation require clear definitions of the structural components of galaxies. Precisely defined components also enable better comparisons between observations and simulations. We use a subsample of eighteen cosmological zoom-in simulations from the NIHAO project to derive a robust method for defining stellar kinematic discs in galaxies. Our method uses Gaussian Mixture Models in a 3D space of dynamical variables. The NIHAO galaxies have the right stellar mass for their halo mass, and their angular momenta and Sérsic indices match observations. While the photometric disc-to-total ratios are close to 1 for all the simulated galaxies, the kinematic ratios are around ~0.5. Thus, exponential structure does not imply a cold kinematic disc. Above log(M*)~9.5, the decomposition leads to thin discs and spheroids that have clearly different properties, in terms of angular momentum, rotational support, ellipticity, [Fe/H] and [O/Fe]. At log(M*)<9.5, the decomposition selects discs and spheroids with less distinct properties. At these low masses, both the discs and spheroids have exponential profiles with high minor-to-major axes ratios, i.e. thickened discs. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS

NIHAO VIII: Circum-galactic medium and outflows - The puzzles of HI and OVI gas distributions

Authors: Thales A. Gutcke, Greg S. Stinson, Andrea V. Macciò, Liang Wang, Aaron A. Dutton

Abstract: We study the hot and cold circum-galactic medium (CGM) of 86 galaxies of the cosmological, hydrodynamical simulation suite NIHAO. NIHAO allows a study of how the $z=0$ CGM varies across 5 orders of magnitude of stellar mass using OVI and HI as proxies for hot and cold gas. The cool HI covering fraction and column density profiles match observations well, particularly in the inner CGM. OVI shows in… ▽ More We study the hot and cold circum-galactic medium (CGM) of 86 galaxies of the cosmological, hydrodynamical simulation suite NIHAO. NIHAO allows a study of how the $z=0$ CGM varies across 5 orders of magnitude of stellar mass using OVI and HI as proxies for hot and cold gas. The cool HI covering fraction and column density profiles match observations well, particularly in the inner CGM. OVI shows increasing column densities with mass, a trend seemingly echoed in the observations. As in multiple previous simulations, the OVI column densities in simulations are lower than observed and optically thick HI does not extend as far out as in observations. We take a look at the collisional ionisation fraction of OVI as a function of halo mass. We make observable predictions of the bipolarity of outflows and their effect on the general shape of the CGM. Bipolar outflows can be seen out to around 40 kpc in intermediate and low mass halos ($M_{\mathrm{halo}}<10^{11}M_{\mathrm{sun}}$), but outside that radius, the CGM is too well mixed to detect an elongated shape. Larger halos have extended gas discs beyond the stellar disc that dominate the shape of the inner CGM. The simulated CGM is remarkably spherical even in low mass simulations. The chemical enrichment of both halo and disc gas follow expected increasing trends as a function of halo mass that are well fit with power laws. These relations can be used in non-hydrodynamic models, such as semi-analytic models. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2016; v1 submitted 22 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 23 pages, 19 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

The impact of baryons on the direct detection of dark matter

Authors: Chris Kelso, Christopher Savage, Monica Valluri, Katherine Freese, Gregory S. Stinson, Jeremy Bailin

Abstract: The spatial and velocity distributions of dark matter particles in the Milky Way Halo affect the signals expected to be observed in searches for dark matter. Results from direct detection experiments are often analyzed assuming a simple isothermal distribution of dark matter, the Standard Halo Model (SHM). Yet there has been skepticism regarding the validity of this simple model due to the complic… ▽ More The spatial and velocity distributions of dark matter particles in the Milky Way Halo affect the signals expected to be observed in searches for dark matter. Results from direct detection experiments are often analyzed assuming a simple isothermal distribution of dark matter, the Standard Halo Model (SHM). Yet there has been skepticism regarding the validity of this simple model due to the complicated gravitational collapse and merger history of actual galaxies. In this paper we compare the SHM to the results of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation to investigate whether or not the SHM is a good representation of the true WIMP distribution in the analysis of direct detection data. We examine two Milky Way-like galaxies from the MaGICC cosmological simulations (a) with dark matter only and (b) with baryonic physics included. The inclusion of baryons drives the shape of the DM halo to become more spherical and makes the velocity distribution of dark matter particles less anisotropic especially at large heliocentric velocities, thereby making the SHM a better fit. We also note that we do not find a significant disk-like rotating dark matter component in either of the two galaxy halos with baryons that we examine, suggesting that dark disks are not a generic prediction of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations. We conclude that in the Solar neighborhood, the SHM is in fact a good approximation to the true dark matter distribution in these cosmological simulations (with baryons) which are reasonable representations of the Milky Way, and hence can also be used for the purpose of dark matter direct detection calculations. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2016; v1 submitted 18 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: Minor changes to match JCAP version. 21 pages, 9 figures

Report number: NORDITA-2015-15, CETUP2015-030

Journal ref: JCAP 1608 (2016) 071

NIHAO VII: Predictions for the galactic baryon budget in dwarf to Milky Way mass haloes

Authors: Liang Wang, Aaron A. Dutton, Gregory S. Stinson, Andrea V. Macciò, Thales Gutcke, Xi Kang

Abstract: We use the NIHAO galaxy formation simulations to make predictions for the baryonic budget in present day galaxies ranging from dwarf to Milky Way masses. The sample is made of 88 independent high resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations. NIHAO galaxies reproduce key properties of observed galaxies, such as the stellar mass vs halo mass and cold gas vs stellar mass relations. Thus they make plau… ▽ More We use the NIHAO galaxy formation simulations to make predictions for the baryonic budget in present day galaxies ranging from dwarf to Milky Way masses. The sample is made of 88 independent high resolution cosmological zoom-in simulations. NIHAO galaxies reproduce key properties of observed galaxies, such as the stellar mass vs halo mass and cold gas vs stellar mass relations. Thus they make plausible predictions for the baryon budget. We present the mass fractions of stars, cold gas ($T<10^4$K), cool gas ($10^4 < T < 10^5$K), warm-hot gas ($10^5 < T < 5\times10^6$K), and hot gas (T$> 5\times10^6$K) inside the virial radius, $R_{200}$. Compared to the predicted baryon mass, using the dark halo mass and the universal baryon fraction, $f_{\rm b}\equiv Ω_{\rm b}/Ω_{\rm m}=0.15$, we find that all of our haloes are missing baryons. The missing mass has been relocated past 2 virial radii, and cool gas dominates the corona at low mass (M$_{200} < 3 \times 10^{11} M_\odot$) while the warm-hot gas dominates at high mass (M$_{200} > 3 \times 10^{11} M_\odot$). Haloes of mass $\sim 10^{10} M_\odot$ are missing $\sim 90\%$ of their baryons. More massive haloes ($\sim 10^{12} M_\odot$) retain a higher fraction of their baryons, with $\sim 30\%$ missing, consistent with recent observational estimates. Moreover, these more massive haloes reproduce the observed fraction of cold, warm-hot and hot gas. The fraction of cool gas we predict ($0.11\pm0.06$) is significantly lower than the observation from COS-HALOs (0.3-0.47), but agrees with the alternative analysis of Stern et al. 2016. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2017; v1 submitted 5 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures, 1 table accepted for publication by MNRAS

Origin of the Metallicity Distribution in the Thick Disc

Authors: Maider S. Miranda, Kate Pilkington, Brad K. Gibson, Christopher B. Brook, Patricia Sánchez-Blázquez, Ivan Minchev, Christopher Gareth Few, Rory Smith, Rosa Domínguez-Tenreiro, Aura Obreja, Jeremy Bailin, Greg S. Stinson

Abstract: Aims. Using a suite of cosmological chemodynamical disc galaxy simulations, we assess how (a) radial metallicity gradients evolve with scaleheight; (b) the vertical metallicity gradients change through the thick disc; and (c) the vertical gradient of the stellar rotation velocity varies through the disc. We compare with the Milky Way to search for analogous trends. Methods. We analyse five simulat… ▽ More Aims. Using a suite of cosmological chemodynamical disc galaxy simulations, we assess how (a) radial metallicity gradients evolve with scaleheight; (b) the vertical metallicity gradients change through the thick disc; and (c) the vertical gradient of the stellar rotation velocity varies through the disc. We compare with the Milky Way to search for analogous trends. Methods. We analyse five simulated spiral galaxies with masses comparable to the Milky Way. The simulations span a range of star formation and energy feedback strengths and prescriptions, particle- and grid-based hydrodynamical implementations, as well as initial conditions/assembly history. Results. Consistently, we find that the steeper, negative, radial metallicity gradients seen in the mid-plane flatten with increasing height away from the plane. In simulations with stronger (and/or more spatially-extended) feedback, the negative radial gradients invert, becoming positive for heights in excess of 1 kpc. Such behaviour is consistent with that inferred from recent observations. Our measurements of the vertical metallicity gradients show no clear correlation with galactocentric radius, and are in good agreement with those observed in the Milky Way's thick disc (locally). Conclusions. Simulations employing stronger/more extended feedback prescriptions possess radial and vertical metallicity and kinematic gradients more in line with recent observations. The inverted, positive, radial metallicity gradients seen in the simulated thick stellar discs originate from a population of younger, more metal-rich, stars formed in-situ, superimposed upon a background population of older migrators from the inner disc; the contrast provided by the former increases radially, due to the inside-out growth of the disc. A similar behaviour may be responsible for the same flattening seen in the radial gradients with scaleheight in the Milky Way. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 15 pages, 12 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 587, A10 (2016)

NIHAO V: Too big doesn't fail -- reconciling the conflict between LCDM predictions and the circular velocities of nearby field galaxies

Authors: Aaron A. Dutton, Andrea V. Macciò, Jonas Frings, Liang Wang, Gregory S. Stinson, Camilla Penzo, Xi Kang

Abstract: We compare the half-light circular velocities, V_{1/2}, of dwarf galaxies in the Local Group to the predicted circular velocity curves of galaxies in the NIHAO suite of LCDM simulations. We use a subset of 34 simulations in which the central galaxy has a stellar luminosity in the range 0.5 x 10^5 < L_V < 2 x 10^8 L_{sun}. The NIHAO galaxy simulations reproduce the relation between stellar mass and… ▽ More We compare the half-light circular velocities, V_{1/2}, of dwarf galaxies in the Local Group to the predicted circular velocity curves of galaxies in the NIHAO suite of LCDM simulations. We use a subset of 34 simulations in which the central galaxy has a stellar luminosity in the range 0.5 x 10^5 < L_V < 2 x 10^8 L_{sun}. The NIHAO galaxy simulations reproduce the relation between stellar mass and halo mass from abundance matching, as well as the observed half-light size vs luminosity relation. The corresponding dissipationless simulations over-predict the V_{1/2}, recovering the problem known as too big to fail (TBTF). By contrast, the NIHAO simulations have expanded dark matter haloes, and provide an excellent match to the distribution of V_{1/2} for galaxies with L_V > 2 x 10^6 L_{sun}. For lower luminosities our simulations predict very little halo response, and tend to over predict the observed circular velocities. In the context of LCDM, this could signal the increased stochasticity of star formation in haloes below M_{halo} \sim 10^{10} M_{sun}, or the role of environmental effects. Thus, haloes that are "too big to fail", do not fail LCDM, but haloes that are "too small to pass" (the galaxy formation threshold) provide a future test of LCDM. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures, accepted to MNRAS letters

How to bend galaxy disc profiles II: stars surfing the bar in Type-III discs

Authors: Jakob Herpich, Gregory S. Stinson, Hans-Walter Rix, Marie Martig, Aaron A. Dutton

Abstract: The radial profiles of stars in disc galaxies are observed to be either purely exponential (Type-I), truncated (Type-II) or anti-truncated (Type-III) exponentials. Controlled formation simulations of isolated galaxies can reproduce all of these profile types by varying a single parameter, the initial halo spin. In this paper we examine these simulations in more detail in an effort to identify the… ▽ More The radial profiles of stars in disc galaxies are observed to be either purely exponential (Type-I), truncated (Type-II) or anti-truncated (Type-III) exponentials. Controlled formation simulations of isolated galaxies can reproduce all of these profile types by varying a single parameter, the initial halo spin. In this paper we examine these simulations in more detail in an effort to identify the physical mechanism that leads to the formation of Type-III profiles. The stars in the anti-truncated outskirts of such discs are now on eccentric orbits, but were born on near-circular orbits at much smaller radii. We show that, and explain how, they were driven to the outskirts via non-linear interactions with a strong and long-lived central bar, which greatly boosted their semi-major axis but also their eccentricity. While bars have been known to cause radial heating and outward migration to stellar orbits, we link this effect to the formation of Type-III profiles. This predicts that the anti-truncated parts of galaxies have unusual kinematics for disc-like stellar configurations: high radial velocity dispersions and slow net rotation. Whether such discs exist in nature, can be tested by future observations. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2017; v1 submitted 13 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 16 pages, 15 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS major changes from submitted version, central conclusion slightly modified, initial conditions code pyICs publicly available on https://github.com/jakobherpich/pyICs

NIHAO IV: Core creation and destruction in dark matter density profiles across cosmic time

Authors: Edouard Tollet, Andrea V. Macciò, Aaron A. Dutton, Greg S. Stinson, Liang Wang, Camilla Penzo, Thales A. Gutcke, Tobias Buck, Xi Kang, Chris Brook, Arianna Di Cintio, Ben W. Keller, James Wadsley

Abstract: We use the NIHAO simulations to investigate the effects of baryonic physics on the time evolution of Dark Matter central density profiles. The sample is made of $\approx 70$ independent high resolution hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation and covers a wide mass range: 1e10< Mhalo <1e12, i.e., from dwarfs to L* . We confirm previous results on the dependence of the inner dark matter densi… ▽ More We use the NIHAO simulations to investigate the effects of baryonic physics on the time evolution of Dark Matter central density profiles. The sample is made of $\approx 70$ independent high resolution hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation and covers a wide mass range: 1e10< Mhalo <1e12, i.e., from dwarfs to L* . We confirm previous results on the dependence of the inner dark matter density slope, $α$, on the ratio between stellar-to-halo mass. We show that this relation holds approximately at all redshifts (with an intrinsic scatter of ~0.18 in $α$). This implies that in practically all haloes the shape of their inner density profile changes quite substantially over cosmic time, as they grow in stellar and total mass. Thus, depending on their final stellar-to-halo mass ratio, haloes can either form and keep a substantial density core (size~1 kpc), or form and then destroy the core and re-contract the halo, going back to a cuspy profile, which is even steeper than CDM predictions for massive galaxies (~1e12 Msun). We show that results from the NIHAO suite are in good agreement with recent observational measurements of $α$ in dwarf galaxies. Overall our results suggest that the notion of a universal density profile for dark matter haloes is no longer valid in the presence of galaxy formation. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2019; v1 submitted 13 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 11 pages, 13 figures. Corrected typo in table 2 (middle row) with respect to the version published in MNRAS

NIHAO III: The constant disc gas mass conspiracy

Authors: G. S. Stinson, A. A. Dutton, L. Wang, A. V. Macciò, J. Herpich, J. D. Bradford, T. R. Quinn, J. Wadsley, B. Keller

Abstract: We show that the cool gas masses of galactic discs reach a steady state that lasts many Gyr after their last major merger in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations. The mass of disc gas, M$_{\rm gas}$, depends upon a galaxy halo's spin and virial mass, but not upon stellar feedback. Halos with low spin have high star formation efficiency and lower disc gas mass. Similarly, lower stellar feedback le… ▽ More We show that the cool gas masses of galactic discs reach a steady state that lasts many Gyr after their last major merger in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations. The mass of disc gas, M$_{\rm gas}$, depends upon a galaxy halo's spin and virial mass, but not upon stellar feedback. Halos with low spin have high star formation efficiency and lower disc gas mass. Similarly, lower stellar feedback leads to more star formation so the gas mass ends up nearly the same irregardless of stellar feedback strength. Even considering spin, the M$_{\rm gas}$ relation with halo mass, M$_{200}$ only shows a factor of 3 scatter. The M$_{\rm gas}$--M$_{200}$ relation show a break at M$_{200}$=$2\times10^{11}$ M$_\odot$ that corresponds to an observed break in the M$_{\rm gas}$--M$_\star$ relation. The constant disc mass stems from a shared halo gas density profile in all the simulated galaxies. In their outer regions, the profiles are isothermal. Where the profile rises above $n=10^{-3}$ cm$^{-3}$, the gas readily cools and the profile steepens. Inside the disc, rotation supports gas with a flatter density profile except where supernova explosions disrupt the disc. Energy injection from stellar feedback also provides pressure support to the halo gas to prevent runaway cooling flows. The resulting constant gas mass makes simpler models for galaxy formation possible, either using a "bathtub" model for star formation rates or when modeling chemical evolution. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: To be submitted to MNRAS. Comments very welcome in the meantime

The response of dark matter haloes to elliptical galaxy formation: a new test for quenching scenarios

Authors: Aaron A. Dutton, Andrea V. Macciò, Gregory S. Stinson, Thales A. Gutcke, Camilla Penzo, Tobias Buck

Abstract: We use cosmological hydrodynamical zoom-in simulations with the SPH code gasoline of four haloes of mass M_{200} \sim 10^{13}\Msun to study the response of the dark matter to elliptical galaxy formation. Our simulations include metallicity dependent gas cooling, star formation, and feedback from massive stars and supernovae, but not active galactic nuclei (AGN). At z=2 the progenitor galaxies have… ▽ More We use cosmological hydrodynamical zoom-in simulations with the SPH code gasoline of four haloes of mass M_{200} \sim 10^{13}\Msun to study the response of the dark matter to elliptical galaxy formation. Our simulations include metallicity dependent gas cooling, star formation, and feedback from massive stars and supernovae, but not active galactic nuclei (AGN). At z=2 the progenitor galaxies have stellar to halo mass ratios consistent with halo abundance matching, assuming a Salpeter initial mass function. However by z=0 the standard runs suffer from the well known overcooling problem, overpredicting the stellar masses by a factor of > 4. To mimic a suppressive halo quenching scenario, in our forced quenching (FQ) simulations, cooling and star formation are switched off at z=2. The resulting z=0 galaxies have stellar masses, sizes and circular velocities close to what is observed. Relative to the control simulations, the dark matter haloes in the FQ simulations have contracted, with central dark matter density slopes d\logρ/d\log r \sim -1.5, showing that dry merging alone is unable to fully reverse the contraction that occurs at z>2. Simulations in the literature with AGN feedback however, have found expansion or no net change in the dark matter halo. Thus the response of the dark matter halo to galaxy formation may provide a new test to distinguish between ejective and suppressive quenching mechanisms. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2015; v1 submitted 22 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: 21 pages, 18 figures, accepted to MNRAS

Galaxy Formation with Local Photoionization Feedback -II. Effect of X-Ray Emission from Binaries and Hot Gas

Authors: Rahul Kannan, Mark Vogelsberger, Greg S. Stinson, Joe F. Hennawi, Federico Marinacci, Volker Springel, Andrea V. Maccio

Abstract: We study how X-rays from stellar binary systems and the hot intracluster medium (ICM) affect the radiative cooling rates of gas in galaxies. Our study uses a novel implementation of gas cooling in the moving-mesh hydrodynamics code \textsc{arepo}. X-rays from stellar binaries do not affect cooling at all as their emission spectrum is too hard to effectively couple with galactic gas. In contrast, X… ▽ More We study how X-rays from stellar binary systems and the hot intracluster medium (ICM) affect the radiative cooling rates of gas in galaxies. Our study uses a novel implementation of gas cooling in the moving-mesh hydrodynamics code \textsc{arepo}. X-rays from stellar binaries do not affect cooling at all as their emission spectrum is too hard to effectively couple with galactic gas. In contrast, X-rays from the ICM couple well with gas in the temperature range $10^4 - 10^6$ K. Idealised simulations show that the hot halo radiation field has minimal impact on the dynamics of cooling flows in clusters because of the high virial temperature ($> 10^7$K), making the interaction between the gas and incident photons very ineffective. Satellite galaxies in cluster environments, on the other hand, experience a high radiation flux due to the emission from the host halo. Low mass satellites ($< 10^{12}\rm{M_\odot}$) in particular have virial temperatures that are exactly in the regime where the effect of the radiation field is maximal. Idealised simulations of satellite galaxies including only the effect of host halo radiation (no ram pressure strip** or tidal effects) fields show a drastic reduction in the amount of cool gas formed ($\sim 40\%$) on a short timescale of about $0.5$ Gyrs. A galaxy merger simulation including all the other environmental quenching mechanisms, shows about $20\%$ reduction in the stellar mass of the satellite and about $\sim 30\%$ reduction in star formation rate after $1$ Gyr due to the host hot halo radiation field. These results indicate that the hot halo radiation fields potentially play an important role in quenching galaxies in cluster environments. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2015; originally announced May 2015.

Comments: 14 pages, 12 figures, submitted to MNRAS

NIHAO project I: Reproducing the inefficiency of galaxy formation across cosmic time with a large sample of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations

Authors: Liang Wang, Aaron A. Dutton, Gregory S. Stinson, Andrea V. Macciò, Camilla Penzo, Xi Kang, Ben W. Keller, James Wadsley

Abstract: We introduce project NIHAO (Numerical Investigation of a Hundred Astrophysical Objects), a set of 100 cosmological zoom-in hydrodynamical simulations performed using the gasoline code, with an improved implementation of the SPH algorithm. The haloes in our study range from dwarf to Milky Way masses, and represent an unbiased sampling of merger histories, concentrations and spin parameters. The par… ▽ More We introduce project NIHAO (Numerical Investigation of a Hundred Astrophysical Objects), a set of 100 cosmological zoom-in hydrodynamical simulations performed using the gasoline code, with an improved implementation of the SPH algorithm. The haloes in our study range from dwarf to Milky Way masses, and represent an unbiased sampling of merger histories, concentrations and spin parameters. The particle masses and force softenings are chosen to resolve the mass profile to below 1% of the virial radius at all masses, ensuring that galaxy half-light radii are well resolved. Using the same treatment of star formation and stellar feedback for every object, the simulated galaxies reproduce the observed inefficiency of galaxy formation across cosmic time as expressed through the stellar mass vs halo mass relation, and the star formation rate vs stellar mass relation. We thus conclude that stellar feedback is the chief piece of physics required to limit the efficiency of star formation in galaxies less massive than the Milky Way. △ Less

Submitted 19 August, 2015; v1 submitted 16 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 14 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

NIHAO project II: Halo shape, phase-space density and velocity distribution of dark matter in galaxy formation simulations

Authors: Iryna Butsky, Andrea V. Macciò, Aaron A. Dutton, Liang Wang, Greg S. Stinson, Camilla Penzo, Xi Kang, Ben W. Keller, James Wadsley

Abstract: We use the NIHAO (Numerical Investigation of Hundred Astrophysical Objects) cosmological simulations to study the effects of galaxy formation on key properties of dark matter (DM) haloes. NIHAO consists of $\simeq 90$ high-resolution SPH simulations that include (metal-line) cooling, star formation, and feedback from massive stars and SuperNovae, and cover a wide stellar and halo mass range:… ▽ More We use the NIHAO (Numerical Investigation of Hundred Astrophysical Objects) cosmological simulations to study the effects of galaxy formation on key properties of dark matter (DM) haloes. NIHAO consists of $\simeq 90$ high-resolution SPH simulations that include (metal-line) cooling, star formation, and feedback from massive stars and SuperNovae, and cover a wide stellar and halo mass range: $10^6 < M_* / M_{\odot} < 10^{11}$ ( $10^{9.5} < M_{\rm halo} / M_{\odot} < 10^{12.5}$). When compared to DM-only simulations, the NIHAO haloes have similar shapes at the virial radius, R_{\rm vir}, but are substantially rounder inside $\simeq 0.1R_{\rm vir}$. In NIHAO simulations $c/a$ increases with halo mass and integrated star formation efficiency, reaching $\sim 0.8$ at the Milky Way mass (compared to 0.5 in DM-only), providing a plausible solution to the long-standing conflict between observations and DM-only simulations. The radial profile of the phase-space $Q$ parameter ($ρ/σ^3$) is best fit with a single power law in DM-only simulations, but shows a flattening within $\simeq 0.1R_{\rm vir}$ for NIHAO for total masses $M>10^{11} M_{\odot}$. Finally, the global velocity distribution of DM is similar in both DM-only and NIHAO simulations, but in the solar neighborhood, NIHAO galaxies deviate substantially from Maxwellian. The distribution is more symmetric, roughly Gaussian, with a peak that shifts to higher velocities for Milky Way mass haloes. We provide the distribution parameters which can be used for predictions for direct DM detection experiments. Our results underline the ability of the galaxy formation processes to modify the properties of dark matter haloes. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2016; v1 submitted 16 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 19 pages, 17 figures, analysis strongly improved, main conclusions unchanged, accepted for publication in MNRAS

How to bend galaxy disc profiles: the role of halo spin

Authors: Jakob Herpich, Gregory S. Stinson, Aaron A. Dutton, Hans-Walter Rix, Marie Martig, Rok Roškar, Andrea V. Macciò, Thomas R. Quinn, James Wadsley

Abstract: The radial density profiles of stellar galaxy discs can be well approximated as an exponential. Compared to this canonical form, however, the profiles in the majority of disc galaxies show downward or upward breaks at large radii. Currently, there is no coherent explanation in a galaxy formation context of the radial profile per se, along with the two types of profile breaks. Using a set of contro… ▽ More The radial density profiles of stellar galaxy discs can be well approximated as an exponential. Compared to this canonical form, however, the profiles in the majority of disc galaxies show downward or upward breaks at large radii. Currently, there is no coherent explanation in a galaxy formation context of the radial profile per se, along with the two types of profile breaks. Using a set of controlled hydrodynamic simulations of disc galaxy formation, we find a correlation between the host halo's initial angular momentum and the resulting radial profile of the stellar disc: galaxies that live in haloes with a low spin parameter λ <~ 0.03 show an up-bending break in their disc density profiles, while galaxies in haloes of higher angular momentum show a down-bending break. We find that the case of pure exponential profiles (λ ~ 0.035) coincides with the peak of the spin parameter distribution from cosmological simulations. Our simulations not only imply an explanation of the observed behaviours, but also suggest that the physical origin of this effect is related to the amount of radial redistribution of stellar mass, which is anti-correlated with λ. △ Less

Submitted 19 February, 2015; v1 submitted 8 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures, adapted to the published version in MNRAS-L

Journal ref: MNRASL, 448, 99 (2015)

A mass-dependent density profile for dark matter haloes including the influence of galaxy formation

Authors: Arianna Di Cintio, Chris B. Brook, Aaron A. Dutton, Andrea V. Macciò, Greg S. Stinson, Alexander Knebe

Abstract: We introduce a mass dependent density profile to describe the distribution of dark matter within galaxies, which takes into account the stellar-to-halo mass dependence of the response of dark matter to baryonic processes. The study is based on the analysis of hydrodynamically simulated galaxies from dwarf to Milky Way mass, drawn from the MaGICC project, which have been shown to match a wide range… ▽ More We introduce a mass dependent density profile to describe the distribution of dark matter within galaxies, which takes into account the stellar-to-halo mass dependence of the response of dark matter to baryonic processes. The study is based on the analysis of hydrodynamically simulated galaxies from dwarf to Milky Way mass, drawn from the MaGICC project, which have been shown to match a wide range of disk scaling relationships. We find that the best fit parameters of a generic double power-law density profile vary in a systematic manner that depends on the stellar-to-halo mass ratio of each galaxy. Thus, the quantity Mstar/Mhalo constrains the inner ($γ$) and outer ($β$) slopes of dark matter density, and the sharpness of transition between the slopes($α$), reducing the number of free parameters of the model to two. Due to the tight relation between stellar mass and halo mass, either of these quantities is sufficient to describe the dark matter halo profile including the effects of baryons. The concentration of the haloes in the hydrodynamical simulations is consistent with N-body expectations up to Milky Way mass galaxies, at which mass the haloes become twice as concentrated as compared with pure dark matter runs. This mass dependent density profile can be directly applied to rotation curve data of observed galaxies and to semi analytic galaxy formation models as a significant improvement over the commonly used NFW profile. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

The Role of Feedback in Sha** the Structure of the Interstellar Medium

Authors: A. P. Walker, B. K. Gibson, K. Pilkington, C. B. Brook, P. Dutta, S. Stanimirovic, G. S. Stinson, J. Bailin

Abstract: We present an analysis of the role of feedback in sha** the neutral hydrogen (HI) content of simulated disc galaxies. For our analysis, we have used two realisations of two separate Milky Way-like (~L*) discs - one employing a conservative feedback scheme (MUGS), the other significantly more energetic (MaGICC). To quantify the impact of these schemes, we generate zeroth moment (surface density)… ▽ More We present an analysis of the role of feedback in sha** the neutral hydrogen (HI) content of simulated disc galaxies. For our analysis, we have used two realisations of two separate Milky Way-like (~L*) discs - one employing a conservative feedback scheme (MUGS), the other significantly more energetic (MaGICC). To quantify the impact of these schemes, we generate zeroth moment (surface density) maps of the inferred HI distribution; construct power spectra associated with the underlying structure of the simulated cold ISM, in addition to their radial surface density and velocity dispersion profiles. Our results are compared with a parallel, self-consistent, analysis of empirical data from THINGS (The HI Nearby Galaxy Survey). Single power-law fits (P~k^gamma) to the power spectra of the stronger-feedback (MaGICC) runs (over spatial scales corresponding to 0.5 kpc to 20 kpc) result in slopes consistent with those seen in the THINGS sample (gamma = -2.5). The weaker-feedback (MUGS) runs exhibit shallower power law slopes (gamma = -1.2). The power spectra of the MaGICC simulations are more consistent though with a two-component fit, with a flatter distribution of power on larger scales (i.e., gamma = -1.4 for scales in excess of 2 kpc) and a steeper slope on scales below 1 kpc (gamma = -5), qualitatively consistent with empirical claims, as well as our earlier work on dwarf discs. The radial HI surface density profiles of the MaGICC discs show a clear exponential behaviour, while those of the MUGS suite are essentially flat; both behaviours are encountered in nature, although the THINGS sample is more consistent with our stronger (MaGICC) feedback runs. △ Less

Submitted 3 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS; 9 pages; 7 figures

Systematic Problems With Using Dark Matter Simulations to Model Stellar Halos

Authors: Jeremy Bailin, Eric F. Bell, Monica Valluri, Greg S. Stinson, Victor P. Debattista, H. M. P. Couchman, James Wadsley

Abstract: The limits of available computing power have forced models for the structure of stellar halos to adopt one or both of the following simplifying assumptions: (1) stellar mass can be "painted" onto dark matter particles in progenitor satellites; (2) pure dark matter simulations that do not form a luminous galaxy can be used. We estimate the magnitude of the systematic errors introduced by these assu… ▽ More The limits of available computing power have forced models for the structure of stellar halos to adopt one or both of the following simplifying assumptions: (1) stellar mass can be "painted" onto dark matter particles in progenitor satellites; (2) pure dark matter simulations that do not form a luminous galaxy can be used. We estimate the magnitude of the systematic errors introduced by these assumptions using a controlled set of stellar halo models where we independently vary whether we look at star particles or painted dark matter particles, and whether we use a simulation in which a baryonic disk galaxy forms or a matching pure dark matter simulation that does not form a baryonic disk. We find that the "painting" simplification reduces the halo concentration and internal structure, predominantly because painted dark matter particles have different kinematics than star particles even when both are buried deep in the potential well of the satellite. The simplification of using pure dark matter simulations reduces the concentration further, but increases the internal structure, and results in a more prolate stellar halo. These differences can be a factor of 1.5-7 in concentration (as measured by the half-mass radius) and 2-7 in internal density structure. Given this level of systematic uncertainty, one should be wary of overinterpreting differences between observations and the current generation of stellar halo models based on dark matter only simulations when such differences are less than an order of magnitude. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: ApJ, in press

Dark MaGICC: the effect of Dark Energy on galaxy formation. Cosmology does matter

Authors: Camilla Penzo, Andrea V. Macciò, Luciano Casarini, Greg S. Stinson, James Wadsley

Abstract: We present the Dark MaGICC project, which aims to investigate the effect of Dark Energy (DE) modeling on galaxy formation via hydrodynamical cosmological simulations. Dark MaGICC includes four dynamical Dark Energy scenarios with time varying equations of state, one with a self-interacting Ratra-Peebles model. In each scenario we simulate three galaxies with high resolution using smoothed particle… ▽ More We present the Dark MaGICC project, which aims to investigate the effect of Dark Energy (DE) modeling on galaxy formation via hydrodynamical cosmological simulations. Dark MaGICC includes four dynamical Dark Energy scenarios with time varying equations of state, one with a self-interacting Ratra-Peebles model. In each scenario we simulate three galaxies with high resolution using smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH). The baryonic physics model is the same used in the Making Galaxies in a Cosmological Context (MaGICC) project, and we varied only the background cosmology. We find that the Dark Energy parameterization has a surprisingly important impact on galaxy evolution and on structural properties of galaxies at z=0, in striking contrast with predictions from pure Nbody simulations. The different background evolutions can (depending on the behavior of the DE equation of state) either enhance or quench star formation with respect to a LCDM model, at a level similar to the variation of the stellar feedback parameterization, with strong effects on the final galaxy rotation curves. While overall stellar feedback is still the driving force in sha** galaxies, we show that the effect of the Dark Energy parameterization plays a larger role than previously thought, especially at lower redshifts. For this reason, the influence of Dark Energy parametrization on galaxy formation must be taken into account, especially in the era of precision cosmology. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 11 pages, 13 figures

Galaxy Formation with local photoionisation feedback I. Methods

Authors: R. Kannan, G. S. Stinson, A. V. Macciò, J. F. Hennawi, R. Woods, J. Wadsley, S. Shen, T. Robitaille, S. Cantalupo, T. R. Quinn, C. Christensen

Abstract: We present a first study of the effect of local photoionising radiation on gas cooling in smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of galaxy formation. We explore the combined effect of ionising radiation from young and old stellar populations. The method computes the effect of multiple radiative sources using the same tree algorithm used for gravity, so it is computationally efficient and well… ▽ More We present a first study of the effect of local photoionising radiation on gas cooling in smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of galaxy formation. We explore the combined effect of ionising radiation from young and old stellar populations. The method computes the effect of multiple radiative sources using the same tree algorithm used for gravity, so it is computationally efficient and well resolved. The method foregoes calculating absorption and scattering in favour of a constant escape fraction for young stars to keep the calculation efficient enough to simulate the entire evolution of a galaxy in a cosmological context to the present day. This allows us to quantify the effect of the local photoionisation feedback through the whole history of a galaxy`s formation. The simulation of a Milky Way like galaxy using the local photoionisation model forms ~ 40 % less stars than a simulation that only includes a standard uniform background UV field. The local photoionisation model decreases star formation by increasing the cooling time of the gas in the halo and increasing the equilibrium temperature of dense gas in the disc. Coupling the local radiation field to gas cooling from the halo provides a preventive feedback mechanism which keeps the central disc light and produces slowly rising rotation curves without resorting to extreme feedback mechanisms. These preliminary results indicate that the effect of local photoionising sources is significant and should not be ignored in models of galaxy formation. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2013; v1 submitted 24 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: Accepted for Publication in MNRAS, 13 pages, 13 figures

MaGICC-WDM: the effects of warm dark matter in hydrodynamical simulations of disc galaxy formation

Authors: Jakob Herpich, Gregory S. Stinson, Andrea V. Macciò, Chris Brook, James Wadsley, Hugh M. P. Couchman, Tom Quinn

Abstract: We study the effect of warm dark matter (WDM) on hydrodynamic simulations of galaxy formation as part of the Making Galaxies in a Cosmological Context (MaGICC) project. We simulate three different galaxies using three WDM candidates of 1, 2 and 5 keV and compare results with pure cold dark matter simulations. WDM slightly reduces star formation and produces less centrally concentrated stellar prof… ▽ More We study the effect of warm dark matter (WDM) on hydrodynamic simulations of galaxy formation as part of the Making Galaxies in a Cosmological Context (MaGICC) project. We simulate three different galaxies using three WDM candidates of 1, 2 and 5 keV and compare results with pure cold dark matter simulations. WDM slightly reduces star formation and produces less centrally concentrated stellar profiles. These effects are most evident for the 1 keV candidate but almost disappear for $m_{\mathrm{WDM}}>2$ keV. All simulations form similar stellar discs independent of WDM particle mass. In particular, the disc scale length does not change when WDM is considered. The reduced amount of star formation in the case of 1 keV particles is due to the effects of WDM on merging satellites which are on average less concentrated and less gas rich. The altered satellites cause a reduced starburst during mergers because they trigger weaker disc instabilities in the main galaxy. Nevertheless we show that disc galaxy evolution is much more sensitive to stellar feedback than it is to WDM candidate mass. Overall we find that WDM, especially when restricted to current observational constraints ($m_{\mathrm{WDM}}>2$ keV), has a minor impact on disc galaxy formation. △ Less

Submitted 27 November, 2013; v1 submitted 5 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Comments: 13 pages, 9 figures, 2 tables; minor clarifications added in results section, conclusions unchanged; accepted for publication in MNRAS

Journal ref: 2014 MNRAS, 437, 293

The Lowest Metallicity Stars in the LMC: Clues from MaGICC Simulations

Authors: Chris B. Brook, Maider S. Miranda, Brad. K. Gibson, Kate Pilkington, Greg S. Stinson

Abstract: Using a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation of a galaxy of similar mass to the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), we examine the predicted characteristics of its lowest metallicity populations. In particular, we emphasise the spatial distributions of first (Pop III) and second (polluted by only immediate Pop III ancestors) generation stars. We find that primordial composition stars form not only in… ▽ More Using a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation of a galaxy of similar mass to the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), we examine the predicted characteristics of its lowest metallicity populations. In particular, we emphasise the spatial distributions of first (Pop III) and second (polluted by only immediate Pop III ancestors) generation stars. We find that primordial composition stars form not only in the central galaxy's progenitor, but also in locally collapsed sub-halos during the early phases of galaxy formation. The lowest metallicity stars in these sub-halos end up in a relatively extended distribution around the host, with these accreted stars possessing present-day galactocentric distances as great as ~40kpc. By contrast, the earliest stars formed within the central galaxy remain in the inner region, where the vast majority of star formation occurs, for the entirety of the simulation. Consequently, the fraction of stars that are from the earliest generation increases strongly with radius. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2013; v1 submitted 15 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: accepted for publication in PASA, as part of the "The Magellanic System: In Perspective" edition

The dependence of dark matter profiles on the stellar to halo mass ratio: a prediction for cusps vs cores

Authors: Arianna Di Cintio, Chris B. Brook, Andrea V. Maccio, Greg S. Stinson, Alexander Knebe, Aaron A. Dutton, James Wadsley

Abstract: We use 31 simulated galaxies from the MaGICC project to investigate the effects of baryonic feedback on the density profiles of dark matter (DM) haloes. The sample covers a wide mass range: 9.4e9<Mhalo/Msun<7.8e11, hosting galaxies with stellar masses: 5.0e5<M*/Msun<8.3e10, i.e. from dwarf to L*. The galaxies are simulated with several baryonic prescriptions, including a range of stellar feedbacks… ▽ More We use 31 simulated galaxies from the MaGICC project to investigate the effects of baryonic feedback on the density profiles of dark matter (DM) haloes. The sample covers a wide mass range: 9.4e9<Mhalo/Msun<7.8e11, hosting galaxies with stellar masses: 5.0e5<M*/Msun<8.3e10, i.e. from dwarf to L*. The galaxies are simulated with several baryonic prescriptions, including a range of stellar feedbacks. The main result is a clear dependence of the inner slope of the DM density profile, α in ρr^α, on the ratio between stellar-to-halo mass (M*/Mhalo). This relation is independent of the stellar feedback scheme, allowing a prediction for cusp vs core formation. When M*/Mhalo is low, ~0.01%, energy from stellar feedback is insufficient to significantly alter the inner DM density and the galaxy retains a cuspy profile. At higher M*/Mhalo, feedback drives the expansion of the DM and generates cored profiles. The flattest profiles form where M*/Mhalo~0.5%. Above this ratio, stars formed in the central regions deepen the gravitational potential enough to oppose this supernova-driven expansion process, resulting in smaller cores and cuspier profiles. Combining the dependence of α on M*/Mhalo with the abundance matching relation between M* and Mhalo provides a prediction for how α varies with M*. Further, using the Tully-Fisher relation allows a prediction for the dependence of the DM inner slope on the observed rotation velocity of galaxies. The most cored galaxies are expected to have Vrot~50km/s, with α decreasing for more massive disc galaxies: spirals with Vrot~150km/s have central slopes α<-0.8, approaching the NFW profile. This novel prediction for the dependence of α on disc galaxy mass can be tested using current observational data sets, and can be applied to theoretical modeling of mass profiles and populations of disc galaxies. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2013; v1 submitted 4 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: accepted version, MNRAS in press. results unchanged,expanded discussion in sec 3.1,3.2,conclusions

Constraining Sub-Grid Physics with High-Redshift Spatially-Resolved Metallicity Distributions

Authors: B. K. Gibson, K. Pilkington, C. B. Brook, G. S. Stinson, J. Bailin

Abstract: We examine the role of energy feedback in sha** the distribution of metals within cosmological hydrodynamical simulations of L* disc galaxies. While negative abundance gradients today provide a boundary condition for galaxy evolution models, in support of inside-out disc growth, empirical evidence as to whether abundance gradients steepen or flatten with time remains highly contradictory. We mad… ▽ More We examine the role of energy feedback in sha** the distribution of metals within cosmological hydrodynamical simulations of L* disc galaxies. While negative abundance gradients today provide a boundary condition for galaxy evolution models, in support of inside-out disc growth, empirical evidence as to whether abundance gradients steepen or flatten with time remains highly contradictory. We made use of a suite of L* discs, realised with and without `enhanced' feedback. All the simulations were produced using the smoothed particle hydrodynamics code Gasoline, and their in situ gas-phase metallicity gradients traced from redshift z~2 to the present-day. Present-day age-metallicity relations and metallicity distribution functions were derived for each system. The `enhanced' feedback models, which have been shown to be in agreement with a broad range of empirical scaling relations, distribute energy and re-cycled ISM material over large scales and predict the existence of relatively `flat' and temporally invariant abundance gradients. Enhanced feedback schemes reduce significantly the scatter in the local stellar age-metallicity relation and, especially, the [O/Fe]-[Fe/H] relation. The local [O/Fe] distribution functions for our L* discs show clear bimodality, with peaks at [O/Fe]=-0.05 and +0.05 (for stars with [Fe/H]>-1), consistent with our earlier work on dwarf discs. Our results with `enhanced' feedback are inconsistent with our earlier generation of simulations realised with `conservative' feedback. We conclude that spatially-resolved metallicity distributions, particularly at high-redshift, offer a unique and under-utilised constraint on the uncertain nature of stellar feedback processes. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2013; v1 submitted 10 April, 2013; originally announced April 2013.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A; 5 pages; 3 figures; inset/legend to figure fixed (misaligned symbol fixed!)

The MaGICC volume: reproducing statistical properties of high redshift galaxies

Authors: Rahul Kannan, Greg S. Stinson, Andrea V. Macciò, Chris Brook, Simone M. Weinmann, James Wadsley, H. M. P. Couchman

Abstract: We present a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation of a representative volume of the Universe, as part of the Making Galaxies in a Cosmological Context (MaGICC) project. MaGICC uses a thermal implementation for supernova and early stellar feedback. This work tests the feedback model at lower resolution across a range of galaxy masses, morphologies and merger histories. The simulated sample compar… ▽ More We present a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation of a representative volume of the Universe, as part of the Making Galaxies in a Cosmological Context (MaGICC) project. MaGICC uses a thermal implementation for supernova and early stellar feedback. This work tests the feedback model at lower resolution across a range of galaxy masses, morphologies and merger histories. The simulated sample compares well with observations of high redshift galaxies ($z \ge 2$) including the stellar mass - halo mass ($M_\star - M_h$ ) relation, the Galaxy Stellar Mass Function (GSMF) at low masses ($M_\star \lt 5 \times 10^{10} M_\odot$ ) and the number density evolution of low mass galaxies. The poor match of $M_\star - M_h$ and the GSMF at high masses ($M_\star \ge 5 \times 10^{10} M_\odot$ ) indicates supernova feedback is insufficient to limit star formation in these haloes. At $z = 0$, our model produces too many stars in massive galaxies and slightly underpredicts the stellar mass around $L_\star$ mass galaxy. Altogether our results suggest that early stellar feedback, in conjunction with supernovae feedback, plays a major role in regulating the properties of low mass galaxies at high redshift. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2013; v1 submitted 11 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: Simulation extended to z=0, conclusions unchanged. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

MaGICC Thick Disk I: Comparing a Simulated Disk Formed with Stellar Feedback to the Milky Way

Authors: G. S. Stinson, J. Bovy, H. -W. Rix, C. Brook, R. Roškar, J. J. Dalcanton, A. V. Macciò, J. Wadsley, H. M. P. Couchman, T. R. Quinn

Abstract: We analyse the structure and chemical enrichment of a Milky Way-like galaxy with a stellar mass of 2 10^{10} M_sun, formed in a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation. It is disk-dominated with a flat rotation curve, and has a disk scale length similar to the Milky Way's, but a velocity dispersion that is ~50% higher. Examining stars in narrow [Fe/H] and [α/Fe] abundance ranges, we find remarkable… ▽ More We analyse the structure and chemical enrichment of a Milky Way-like galaxy with a stellar mass of 2 10^{10} M_sun, formed in a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation. It is disk-dominated with a flat rotation curve, and has a disk scale length similar to the Milky Way's, but a velocity dispersion that is ~50% higher. Examining stars in narrow [Fe/H] and [α/Fe] abundance ranges, we find remarkable qualitative agreement between this simulation and observations: a) The old stars lie in a thickened distribution with a short scale length, while the young stars form a thinner disk, with scale lengths decreasing, as [Fe/H] increases. b) Consequently, there is a distinct outward metallicity gradient. c) Mono-abundance populations exist with a continuous distribution of scale heights (from thin to thick). However, the simulated galaxy has a distinct and substantive very thick disk (h_z~1.5 kpc), not seen in the Milky Way. The broad agreement between simulations and observations allows us to test the validity of observational proxies used in the literature: we find in the simulation that mono-abundance populations are good proxies for single age populations (<1 Gyr) for most abundances. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2013; v1 submitted 22 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

Comments: 11 page, 10 figures, submitted. Comments welcome

Halo orbits in cosmological disk galaxies: tracers of formation history

Authors: Monica Valluri, Victor P. Debattista, Gregory S. Stinson, Jeremy Bailin, Thomas R. Quinn, H. M. P. Couchman, James Wadsley

Abstract: We analyze the orbits of stars and dark matter particles in the halo of a disk galaxy formed in a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation. The halo is oblate within the inner ~20 kpc and triaxial beyond this radius. About 43% of orbits are short axis tubes - the rest belong to orbit families that characterize triaxial potentials (boxes, long-axis tubes and chaotic orbits), but their shapes are clos… ▽ More We analyze the orbits of stars and dark matter particles in the halo of a disk galaxy formed in a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation. The halo is oblate within the inner ~20 kpc and triaxial beyond this radius. About 43% of orbits are short axis tubes - the rest belong to orbit families that characterize triaxial potentials (boxes, long-axis tubes and chaotic orbits), but their shapes are close to axisymmetric. We find no evidence that the self-consistent distribution function of the nearly oblate inner halo is comprised primarily of axisymmetric short-axis tube orbits. Orbits of all families, and both types of particles are highly eccentric with mean eccentricity >0.6. We find that randomly selected samples of halo stars show no substructure in "integrals of motion" space. However individual accretion events can be clearly identified in plots of metallicity versus formation time. Dynamically young tidal debris is found primarily on a single type of orbit. However, stars associated with older satellites become chaotically mixed during the formation process (possibly due to scattering by the central bulge and disk, and baryonic processes), and appear on all four types of orbits. We find that the tidal debris in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations experiences significantly more chaotic evolution than in collisionless simulations, making it much harder to identify individual progenitors using phase space coordinates alone. However by combining information on stellar ages and chemical abundances with the orbital properties of halo stars in the underlying self-consistent potential, the identification of progenitors is likely to be possible. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2013; v1 submitted 18 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

Comments: Revised version accepted by ApJ, Feb 28th 2013. Minor changes, not affecting conclusions

Properties of simulated Milky Way-mass galaxies in loose group and field environments

Authors: C. G. Few, B. K. Gibson, S. Courty, L. Michel-Dansac, C. B. Brook, G. S. Stinson

Abstract: We test the validity of comparing simulated field disk galaxies with the empirical properties of systems situated within environments more comparable to loose groups, including the Milky Way's Local Group. Cosmological simulations of Milky Way-mass galaxies have been realised in two different environment samples: in the field and in environments with similar properties to the Local Group. Apart fr… ▽ More We test the validity of comparing simulated field disk galaxies with the empirical properties of systems situated within environments more comparable to loose groups, including the Milky Way's Local Group. Cosmological simulations of Milky Way-mass galaxies have been realised in two different environment samples: in the field and in environments with similar properties to the Local Group. Apart from the environments of the galaxies, the samples are kept as homogeneous as possible with equivalent ranges in last major merger time, halo mass and halo spin. Comparison of these two samples allow for systematic differences in the simulations to be identified. Metallicity gradients, disk scale lengths, colours, magnitudes and age-velocity dispersion relations are studied for each galaxy in the suite and the strength of the link between these and environment of the galaxies is studied. The bulge-to-disk ratio of the galaxies show that these galaxies are less spheroid dominated than many other simulated galaxies in literature with the majority of both samples being disk dominated. We find that secular evolution and mergers dominate the spread of morphologies and metallicity gradients with no visible differences between the two environment samples. In contrast with this consistency in the two samples there is tentative evidence for a systematic difference in the velocity dispersion-age relations of galaxies in the different environments. Loose group galaxies appear to have more discrete steps in their velocity dispersion-age relations. We conclude that at the current resolution of cosmological galaxy simulations field environment galaxies are sufficiently similar to those in loose groups to be acceptable proxies for comparison with the Milky Way provided that a similar assembly history is considered. △ Less

Submitted 3 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: 16 pages, 11 figures, abstract abridged for arXiv. Accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics

Thin disc, Thick Disc and Halo in a Simulated Galaxy

Authors: C. B. Brook, G. S. Stinson, B. K. Gibson, D. Kawata, E. L. House, M. S. Miranda, A. V. Macciò, K. Pilkington, R. Roškar, J. Wadsley, T. R. Quinn

Abstract: Within a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation, we form a disc galaxy with sub- components which can be assigned to a thin stellar disc, thick disk, and a low mass stellar halo via a chemical decomposition. The thin and thick disc populations so selected are distinct in their ages, kinematics, and metallicities. Thin disc stars are young (<6.6 Gyr), possess low velocity dispersion (σU,V,W = 41, 3… ▽ More Within a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation, we form a disc galaxy with sub- components which can be assigned to a thin stellar disc, thick disk, and a low mass stellar halo via a chemical decomposition. The thin and thick disc populations so selected are distinct in their ages, kinematics, and metallicities. Thin disc stars are young (<6.6 Gyr), possess low velocity dispersion (σU,V,W = 41, 31, 25 km/s), high [Fe/H], and low [O/Fe]. The thick disc stars are old (6.6<age<9.8 Gyrs), lag the thin disc by \sim21 km/s, possess higher velocity dispersion (σU,V,W = 49, 44, 35 km/s), relatively low [Fe/H] and high [O/Fe]. The halo component comprises less than 4% of stars in the "solar annulus" of the simulation, has low metallicity, a velocity ellipsoid defined by (σU,V,W = 62, 46, 45 km/s) and is formed primarily in-situ during an early merger epoch. Gas-rich mergers during this epoch play a major role in fuelling the formation of the old disc stars (the thick disc). This is consistent with studies which show that cold accretion is the main source of a disc galaxy's baryons. Our simulation initially forms a relatively short (scalelength \sim1.7 kpc at z=1) and kinematically hot disc, primarily from gas accreted during the galaxy's merger epoch. Far from being a competing formation scenario, migration is crucial for reconciling the short, hot, discs which form at high redshift in ΛCDM, with the properties of the thick disc at z=0. The thick disc, as defined by its abundances maintains its relatively short scale-length at z = 0 (2.31 kpc) compared with the total disc scale-length of 2.73 kpc. The inside-out nature of disc growth is imprinted the evolution of abundances such that the metal poor α-young population has a larger scale-length (4.07 kpc) than the more chemically evolved metal rich α-young population (2.74 kpc). △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: Submitted to MNRAS. This version after helpful referee comments. Comments welcome to [email protected]

The Distribution of Metals in Cosmological Hydrodynamical Simulations of Dwarf Disk Galaxies

Authors: K. Pilkington, B. K. Gibson, C. B. Brook, F. Calura, G. S. Stinson, R. J. Thacker, L. Michel-Dansac, J. Bailin, H. M. P. Couchman, J. Wadsley, T. R. Quinn, A. Maccio

Abstract: We examine the chemical properties of 5 cosmological hydrodynamical simulations of an M33-like disc galaxy which have been shown to be consistent with the morphological characteristics and bulk scaling relations expected of late-type spirals. These simulations are part of the Making Galaxies In a Cosmological Context (MaGICC) Project, in which stellar feedback is tuned to match the stellar mass --… ▽ More We examine the chemical properties of 5 cosmological hydrodynamical simulations of an M33-like disc galaxy which have been shown to be consistent with the morphological characteristics and bulk scaling relations expected of late-type spirals. These simulations are part of the Making Galaxies In a Cosmological Context (MaGICC) Project, in which stellar feedback is tuned to match the stellar mass -- halo mass relationship. Each realisation employed identical initial conditions and assembly histories, but differed from one another in their underlying baryonic physics prescriptions, including (a) the efficiency with which each supernova energy couples to the ISM, (b) the impact of feedback associated with massive star radiation pressure, (c) the role of the minimum shut-off time for radiative cooling of Type II SNe remnants, (d) the treatment of metal diffusion, and (e) varying the IMF. Our analysis focusses on the resulting stellar metallicity distribution functions (MDFs) in each simulated (analogous) `solar neighbourhood' and central `bulge' region. We compare the simulated MDFs' skewness, kurtosis, and dispersion (inter-quartile, inter-decile, inter-centile, and inter-tenth-percentile regions) with that of the empirical solar neighbourhood MDF and Local Group dwarfs. We find that the MDFs of the simulated discs are more negatively skewed, with higher kurtosis, than those observed locally. We can trace this difference to the simulations' tight and correlated age-metallicity relations (compared with that of the Milky Way), suggesting that these relations within `dwarf' discs might be steeper than in L* discs and/or the degree of stellar orbital re-distribution and migration inferred locally has not been captured in their entirety, at the resolution of our simulations. The important role of metal diffusion in ameliorating the over-production of extremely metal-poor stars is highlighted. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS; 12 pages; 7 figures

The stellar metallicity distribution of disc galaxies and bulges in cosmological simulations

Authors: F. Calura, B. K. Gibson, L. Michel-Dansac, G. S. Stinson, M. Cignoni, A. Dotter, K. Pilkington, E. L. House, C. B. Brook, C. G. Few, J. Bailin, H. M. P. Couchman, J. Wadsley, .

Abstract: By means of high-resolution cosmological hydrodynamical simulations of Milky Way-like disc galaxies, we conduct an analysis of the associated stellar metallicity distribution functions (MDFs). After undertaking a kinematic decomposition of each simulation into spheroid and disc sub-components, we compare the predicted MDFs to those observed in the solar neighbourhood and the Galactic bulge. The ef… ▽ More By means of high-resolution cosmological hydrodynamical simulations of Milky Way-like disc galaxies, we conduct an analysis of the associated stellar metallicity distribution functions (MDFs). After undertaking a kinematic decomposition of each simulation into spheroid and disc sub-components, we compare the predicted MDFs to those observed in the solar neighbourhood and the Galactic bulge. The effects of the star formation density threshold are visible in the star formation histories, which show a modulation in their behaviour driven by the threshold. The derived MDFs show median metallicities lower by 0.2-0.3 dex than the MDF observed locally in the disc and in the Galactic bulge. Possible reasons for this apparent discrepancy include the use of low stellar yields and/or centrally-concentrated star formation. The dispersions are larger than the one of the observed MDF; this could be due to simulated discs being kinematically hotter relative to the Milky Way. The fraction of low metallicity stars is largely overestimated, visible from the more negatively skewed MDF with respect to the observational sample. For our fiducial Milky Way analog, we study the metallicity distribution of the stars born "in situ" relative to those formed via accretion (from disrupted satellites), and demonstrate that this low-metallicity tail to the MDF is populated primarily by accreted stars. Enhanced supernova and stellar radiation energy feedback to the surrounding interstellar media of these pre-disrupted satellites is suggested as an important regulator of the MDF skewness. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2012; v1 submitted 4 April, 2012; originally announced April 2012.

Comments: 20 pages, 14 figures, MNRAS, accepted

Metallicity Gradients in Disks: Do Galaxies Form Inside-Out?

Authors: K. Pilkington, C. G. Few, B. K. Gibson, F. Calura, L. Michel-Dansac, R. J. Thacker, M. Molla, F. Matteucci, A. Rahimi, D. Kawata, C. Kobayashi, C. B. Brook, G. S. Stinson, H. M. P. Couchman, J. Bailin, J. Wadsley

Abstract: We examine radial and vertical metallicity gradients using a suite of disk galaxy simulations, supplemented with two classic chemical evolution approaches. We determine the rate of change of gradient and reconcile differences between extant models and observations within the `inside-out' disk growth paradigm. A sample of 25 disks is used, consisting of 19 from our RaDES (Ramses Disk Environment St… ▽ More We examine radial and vertical metallicity gradients using a suite of disk galaxy simulations, supplemented with two classic chemical evolution approaches. We determine the rate of change of gradient and reconcile differences between extant models and observations within the `inside-out' disk growth paradigm. A sample of 25 disks is used, consisting of 19 from our RaDES (Ramses Disk Environment Study) sample, realised with the adaptive mesh refinement code RAMSES. Four disks are selected from the MUGS (McMaster Unbiased Galaxy Simulations) sample, generated with the smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) code GASOLINE, alongside disks from Rahimi et al. (GCD+) and Kobayashi & Nakasato (GRAPE-SPH). Two chemical evolution models of inside-out disk growth were employed to contrast the temporal evolution of their radial gradients with those of the simulations. We find that systematic differences exist between the predicted evolution of radial abundance gradients in the RaDES and chemical evolution models, compared with the MUGS sample; specifically, the MUGS simulations are systematically steeper at high-redshift, and present much more rapid evolution in their gradients. We find that the majority of the models predict radial gradients today which are consistent with those observed in late-type disks, but they evolve to this self-similarity in different fashions, despite each adhering to classical `inside-out' growth. We find that radial dependence of the efficiency with which stars form as a function of time drives the differences seen in the gradients; systematic differences in the sub-grid physics between the various codes are responsible for setting these gradients. Recent, albeit limited, data at redshift z=1.5 are consistent with the steeper gradients seen in our SPH sample, suggesting a modest revision of the classical chemical evolution models may be required. △ Less

Submitted 13 February, 2012; v1 submitted 30 January, 2012; originally announced January 2012.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A; 12 pages; 5 figures (several typos corrected and author affiliations updated)

The Aquila comparison Project: The Effects of Feedback and Numerical Methods on Simulations of Galaxy Formation

Authors: C. Scannapieco, M. Wadepuhl, O. H. Parry, J. F. Navarro, A. Jenkins, V. Springel, R. Teyssier, E. Carlson, H. M. P. Couchman, R. A. Crain, C. Dalla Vecchia, C. S. Frenk, C. Kobayashi, P. Monaco, G. Murante, T. Okamoto, T. Quinn, J. Schaye, G. S. Stinson, T. Theuns, J. Wadsley, S. D. M. White, R. Woods

Abstract: We compare the results of thirteen cosmological gasdynamical codes used to simulate the formation of a galaxy in the LCDM structure formation paradigm. The various runs differ in their hydrodynamical treatment (SPH, moving-mesh and AMR) but share the same initial conditions and adopt their latest published model of cooling, star formation and feedback. Despite the common halo assembly history, we… ▽ More We compare the results of thirteen cosmological gasdynamical codes used to simulate the formation of a galaxy in the LCDM structure formation paradigm. The various runs differ in their hydrodynamical treatment (SPH, moving-mesh and AMR) but share the same initial conditions and adopt their latest published model of cooling, star formation and feedback. Despite the common halo assembly history, we find large code-to-code variations in the stellar mass, size, morphology and gas content of the galaxy at z=0, due mainly to the different implementations of feedback. Compared with observation, most codes tend to produce an overly massive galaxy, smaller and less gas-rich than typical spirals, with a massive bulge and a declining rotation curve. A stellar disk is discernible in most simulations, though its prominence varies widely from code to code. There is a well-defined trend between the effects of feedback and the severity of the disagreement with observation. Models that are more effective at limiting the baryonic mass of the galaxy come closer to matching observed galaxy scaling laws, but often to the detriment of the disk component. Our conclusions hold at two different numerical resolutions. Some differences can also be traced to the numerical techniques: more gas seems able to cool and become available for star formation in grid-based codes than in SPH. However, this effect is small compared to the variations induced by different feedback prescriptions. We conclude that state-of-the-art simulations cannot yet uniquely predict the properties of the baryonic component of a galaxy, even when the assembly history of its host halo is fully specified. Develo** feedback algorithms that can effectively regulate the mass of a galaxy without hindering the formation of high-angular momentum stellar disks remains a challenge. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2012; v1 submitted 1 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Comments: 28 pages, 16 figures, MNRAS accepted. High resolution figures and additional images can be found at http://www.aip.de/People/cscannapieco/aquila/

Advanced Morphological Galaxy Classification: A Comparison of Real and Simulated Galaxies

Authors: K. M. Hambleton, B. K. Gibson, C. B. Brook, G. S. Stinson, C. J. Conselice, J. Bailin, H. Couchman, J. Wadsley

Abstract: Encoded within the morphological structure of galaxies are clues related to their formation and evolutionary history. Recent advances pertaining to the statistics of galaxy morphology include sophisticated measures of concentration (C), asymmetry (A), and clumpiness (S). In this study, these three parameters (CAS) have been applied to a suite of simulated galaxies and compared with observational r… ▽ More Encoded within the morphological structure of galaxies are clues related to their formation and evolutionary history. Recent advances pertaining to the statistics of galaxy morphology include sophisticated measures of concentration (C), asymmetry (A), and clumpiness (S). In this study, these three parameters (CAS) have been applied to a suite of simulated galaxies and compared with observational results inferred from a sample of nearby galaxies. The simulations span a range of late-type systems, with masses between ~1e10 Msun and ~1e12 Msun, and employ star formation density thresholds between 0.1 cm^-3 and 100 cm^-3. We have found that the simulated galaxies possess comparable concentrations to their real counterparts. However, the results of the CAS analysis revealed that the simulated galaxies are generally more asymmetric, and that the range of clumpiness values extends beyond the range of those observed. Strong correlations were obtained between the three CAS parameters and colour (B-V), consistent with observed galaxies. Furthermore, the simulated galaxies possess strong links between their CAS parameters and Hubble type, mostly in-line with their real counterparts. △ Less

Submitted 31 October, 2011; v1 submitted 29 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS; 11 pages; 12 figures; replacement includes minor amendments to match the published version

The Chemical and Dynamical Evolution of Isolated Dwarf Galaxies

Authors: K. Pilkington, B. K. Gibson, F. Calura, G. S. Stinson, C. B. Brook, A. Brooks

Abstract: Using a suite of simulations (Governato et al. 2010) which successfully produce bulgeless (dwarf) disk galaxies, we provide an analysis of their associated cold interstellar media (ISM) and stellar chemical abundance patterns. A preliminary comparison with observations is undertaken, in order to assess whether the properties of the cold gas and chemistry of the stellar components are recovered suc… ▽ More Using a suite of simulations (Governato et al. 2010) which successfully produce bulgeless (dwarf) disk galaxies, we provide an analysis of their associated cold interstellar media (ISM) and stellar chemical abundance patterns. A preliminary comparison with observations is undertaken, in order to assess whether the properties of the cold gas and chemistry of the stellar components are recovered successfully. To this end, we have extracted the radial and vertical gas density profiles, neutral hydrogen velocity dispersion, and the power spectrum of structure within the ISM. We complement this analysis of the cold gas with a brief examination of the simulations' metallicity distribution functions and the distribution of alpha-elements-to-iron. △ Less

Submitted 22 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: To appear in the proceedings of the JENAM 2010 Symposium "Dwarf Galaxies: Keys to Galaxy Formation and Evolution" (Lisbon, 9-10 September 2010), P. Papaderos, S. Recchi, G. Hensler (eds.), Springer Verlag (2011), in press

The Cold Gas Content of Bulgeless Dwarf Galaxies

Authors: K. Pilkington, B. K. Gibson, F. Calura, A. M. Brooks, L. Mayer, C. B. Brook, G. S. Stinson, R. J. Thacker, C. G. Few, D. Cunnama, J. Wadsley

Abstract: We present an analysis of the neutral hydrogen (HI) properties of a fully cosmological hydrodynamical dwarf galaxy, run with varying simulation parameters. As reported by Governato et al. (2010), the high resolution, high star formation density threshold version of this galaxy is the first simulation to result in the successful reproduction of a (dwarf) spiral galaxy without any associated stellar… ▽ More We present an analysis of the neutral hydrogen (HI) properties of a fully cosmological hydrodynamical dwarf galaxy, run with varying simulation parameters. As reported by Governato et al. (2010), the high resolution, high star formation density threshold version of this galaxy is the first simulation to result in the successful reproduction of a (dwarf) spiral galaxy without any associated stellar bulge. We have set out to compare in detail the HI distribution and kinematics of this simulated bulgeless disk with what is observed in a sample of nearby dwarfs. To do so, we extracted the radial gas density profiles, velocity dispersion (e.g., velocity ellipsoid, turbulence), and the power spectrum of structure within the cold interstellar medium from the simulations. The highest resolution dwarf, when using a high density star formation threshold comparable to densities of giant molecular clouds, possesses bulk characteristics consistent with those observed in nature, though the cold gas is not as radially extended as that observed in nearby dwarfs, resulting in somewhat excessive surface densities. The lines-of-sight velocity dispersion radial profiles have values that are in good agreement with observed dwarf galaxies, but due to the fact that only the streaming velocities of particles are tracked, a correction to include the thermal velocities can lead to profiles that are quite flat. The ISM power spectra of the simulations appear to possess more power on smaller spatial scales than that of the SMC. We conclude that unavoidable limitations remain due to the unresolved physics of star formation and feedback within pc-scale molecular clouds. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: Accepted for publication in MNRAS; 9 pages; 5 figures; Fig.4 de-graded to meet arXiv restrictions

Disc Heating: Comparing the Milky Way with Cosmological Simulations

Authors: Elisa House, Chris B. Brook, Brad K. Gibson, Patricia Sanchez-Blazquez, Stephanie Courty, Christopher G. Few, Fabio Governato, Daisuke Kawata, Rok Roskar, Matthias Steinmetz, Gregory S. Stinson, Romain Teyssier

Abstract: We present the analysis of a suite of simulations run with different particle-and grid-based cosmological hydrodynamical codes and compare them with observational data of the Milky Way. This is the first study to make comparisons of properties of galaxies simulated with particle and grid-based codes. Our analysis indicates that there is broad agreement between these different modelling techniques.… ▽ More We present the analysis of a suite of simulations run with different particle-and grid-based cosmological hydrodynamical codes and compare them with observational data of the Milky Way. This is the first study to make comparisons of properties of galaxies simulated with particle and grid-based codes. Our analysis indicates that there is broad agreement between these different modelling techniques. We study the velocity dispersion - age relation for disc stars at z=0 and find that four of the simulations are more consistent with observations by Holmberg et al. (2008) in which the stellar disc appears to undergo continual/secular heating. Two other simulations are in better agreement with the Quillen & Garnett (2001) observations that suggest a "saturation" in the heating profile for young stars in the disc. None of the simulations have thin discs as old as that of the Milky Way. We also analyse the kinematics of disc stars at the time of their birth for different epochs in the galaxies' evolution and find that in some simulations old stars are born cold within the disc and are subsequently heated, while other simulations possess old stellar populations which are born relatively hot. The models which are in better agreement with observations of the Milky Way's stellar disc undergo significantly lower minor-merger/assembly activity after the last major merger - i.e. once the disc has formed. All of the simulations are significantly "hotter" than the Milky Way disc; on top of the effects of mergers, we find a "floor" in the dispersion that is related to the underlying treatment of the heating and cooling of the interstellar medium, and the low density threshold which such codes use for star formation. This finding has important implications for all studies of disc heating that use hydrodynamical codes. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 15 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables, accepted version: MNRAS in press

The temperature of hot gas in galaxies and clusters: baryons dancing to the tune of dark matter

Authors: Steen H. Hansen, Andrea V. Macció, Emilio Romano-Diaz, Yehuda Hoffman, Marcus Brüggen, Evan Scannapieco, Greg S. Stinson

Abstract: The temperature profile of hot gas in galaxies and galaxy clusters is largely determined by the depth of the total gravitational potential and thereby by the dark matter (DM) distribution. We use high-resolution hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation to derive a surprisingly simple relation between the gas temperature and DM properties. We show that this relation holds not just for galaxy… ▽ More The temperature profile of hot gas in galaxies and galaxy clusters is largely determined by the depth of the total gravitational potential and thereby by the dark matter (DM) distribution. We use high-resolution hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation to derive a surprisingly simple relation between the gas temperature and DM properties. We show that this relation holds not just for galaxy clusters but also for equilibrated and relaxed galaxies at radii beyond the central stellar-dominated region of typically a few kpc. It is then clarified how a measurement of the temperature and density of the hot gas component can lead to an indirect measurement of the DM velocity anisotropy in galaxies. We also study the temperature relation for galaxy clusters in the presence of self-regulated, recurrent active galactic nuclei (AGN), and demonstrate that this temperature relation even holds outside the inner region of 30 kpc in clusters with an active AGN. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2010; originally announced December 2010.

Comments: 10 pages, 7 figures

High accuracy power spectra including baryonic physics in dynamical Dark Energy models

Authors: Luciano Casarini, Andrea V. Maccio', Silvio A. Bonometto, Greg S. Stinson

Abstract: The next generation mass probes will obtain information on non--linear power spectra P(k,z) and their evolution, allowing us to investigate the nature of Dark Energy. To exploit such data we need high precision simulations, extending at least up to scales of k 10 h/Mpc, where the effects of baryons can no longer be neglected. In this paper, we present a series of large scale hydrodynamical simul… ▽ More The next generation mass probes will obtain information on non--linear power spectra P(k,z) and their evolution, allowing us to investigate the nature of Dark Energy. To exploit such data we need high precision simulations, extending at least up to scales of k 10 h/Mpc, where the effects of baryons can no longer be neglected. In this paper, we present a series of large scale hydrodynamical simulations for LCDM and dynamical Dark Energy (dDE) models, in which the equation of state parameter is z-dependent. The simulations include gas cooling, star formation and Supernovae feedback. They closely approximate the observed star formation rate and the observationally derived star/Dark Matter mass ratio in collapsed systems. Baryon dynamics cause spectral shifts exceeding 1% at k > 2-3 h/Mpc compared to pure n-body simulations in the LCDM simulations. This agrees with previous studies, although we find a smaller effect (~50%) on the power spectrum amplitude at higher k's. dDE exhibits similar behavior, even though the dDE simulations produce ~20% less stars than the analogous LCDM cosmologies. Finally, we show that the technique introduced in Casarini et al. to obtain spectra for any $w(z)$ cosmology from constant-w models at any redshift still holds when gas physics is taken into account. While this relieves the need to explore the entire functional space of dark energy state equations, we illustrate a severe risk that future data analysis could lead to misinterpretation of the DE state equation. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2010; v1 submitted 25 May, 2010; originally announced May 2010.

Comments: 12 pages, 13 figures, minor changes to match the accepted version, MNRAS in press

The Evolution of Central Group Galaxies in Hydrodynamical Simulations

Authors: R. Feldmann, C. M. Carollo, L. Mayer, A. Renzini, G. Lake, T. Quinn, G. S. Stinson, G. Yepes

Abstract: We trace the evolution of central galaxies in three ~10^13 M_sun galaxy groups simulated at high resolution in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations. The evolution in the group potential leads, at z=0, to central galaxies that are massive, gas-poor early-type systems supported by stellar velocity dispersion resembling either elliptical or S0 galaxies. Their z~2-2.5 main progenitors are massive… ▽ More We trace the evolution of central galaxies in three ~10^13 M_sun galaxy groups simulated at high resolution in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations. The evolution in the group potential leads, at z=0, to central galaxies that are massive, gas-poor early-type systems supported by stellar velocity dispersion resembling either elliptical or S0 galaxies. Their z~2-2.5 main progenitors are massive M* ~ 3-10 x 10^10 M_sun, star forming (20-60 M_sun/yr) galaxies which host substantial reservoirs of cold gas (~5 x 10^9 M_sun) in extended gas disks. Our simulations thus show that star forming galaxies observed at z~2 are likely the main progenitors of central galaxies in galaxy groups at z=0. Their central stellar densities stay approximately constant from z~1.5 down to z=0. Instead, the galaxies grow inside-out, by acquiring a stellar envelope outside the innermost ~2 kpc. Consequently the density within the effective radius decreases by up to two orders of magnitude. Both major and minor mergers contribute to most of the mass accreted outside the effective radius and thus drive the evolution of the half-mass radii. In one of the three simulated groups the short central cooling time leads to a dramatic rejuvenation of the central group galaxy at z<1, affecting its morphology, kinematics and colors. This episode is eventually terminated by a group-group merger. Our simulations demonstrate that, in galaxy groups, the interplay between halo mass assembly, galaxy merging and gas accretion has a substantial influence on the star formation histories and z=0 morphologies of central galaxies.[Abridged] △ Less

Submitted 12 November, 2009; v1 submitted 16 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 28 pages, 23 figures, 9 tables, accepted to APJ (revised to match accepted version)

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.709:218-240,2010

Riding the Spiral Waves: Implications of Stellar Migration for the Properties of Galactic Disks

Authors: Rok Roškar, Victor P. Debattista, Thomas R. Quinn, Gregory S. Stinson, James Wadsley

Abstract: Stars in disks of spiral galaxies are usually assumed to remain roughly at their birth radii. This assumption is built into decades of modelling of the evolution of stellar populations in our own Galaxy and in external systems. We present results from self-consistent high-resolution $N$-body + Smooth Particle Hydrodynamics simulations of disk formation, in which stars migrate across significant… ▽ More Stars in disks of spiral galaxies are usually assumed to remain roughly at their birth radii. This assumption is built into decades of modelling of the evolution of stellar populations in our own Galaxy and in external systems. We present results from self-consistent high-resolution $N$-body + Smooth Particle Hydrodynamics simulations of disk formation, in which stars migrate across significant galactocentric distances due to resonant scattering with transient spiral arms, while preserving their circular orbits. We investigate the implications of such migrations for observed stellar populations. Radial migration provides an explanation for the observed flatness and spread in the age-metallicity relation and the relative lack of metal poor stars in the solar neighborhood. The presence of radial migration also prompts rethinking of interpretations of extra-galactic stellar population data, especially for determinations of star formation histories. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2008; originally announced August 2008.

Comments: 4 pages, 3 figures; Accepted for publication in ApJL

Journal ref: 2008, ApJL 684, L79

Clues to Radial Migration from the Properties of Outer Disks

Authors: Rok Roškar, Victor P. Debattista, Thomas R. Quinn, Gregory S. Stinson, James Wadsley, Tobias Kaufmann

Abstract: The outer disks of galaxies present a unique laboratory for studying the process of disk formation. A considerable fraction of observed disks exhibit a break in their surface brightness profiles. The ubiquity of these features points to a crucial aspect of disk formation which must be explained. Recent theoretical work suggests that such breaks are related to significant amounts of radial migrat… ▽ More The outer disks of galaxies present a unique laboratory for studying the process of disk formation. A considerable fraction of observed disks exhibit a break in their surface brightness profiles. The ubiquity of these features points to a crucial aspect of disk formation which must be explained. Recent theoretical work suggests that such breaks are related to significant amounts of radial migration. We discuss the current observational evidence which supports this picture. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2008; v1 submitted 11 July, 2008; originally announced July 2008.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures; Proceedings of IAU Symposium 254 "The Galaxy Disk in a Cosmological Context" - corrected reference to Foyle et al. 2008

Beyond Inside-Out Growth: Formation and Evolution of Disk Outskirts

Authors: Rok Roškar, Victor P. Debattista, Gregory S. Stinson, Thomas R. Quinn, Tobias Kaufmann, James Wadsley

Abstract: We have performed a high mass and force resolution simulation of an idealized galaxy forming from dissipational collapse of gas embedded in a spherical dark matter halo. The simulation includes star formation and effects of stellar feedback. In our simulation a stellar disk forms with a surface density profile consisting of an inner exponential breaking to a steeper outer exponential. The break… ▽ More We have performed a high mass and force resolution simulation of an idealized galaxy forming from dissipational collapse of gas embedded in a spherical dark matter halo. The simulation includes star formation and effects of stellar feedback. In our simulation a stellar disk forms with a surface density profile consisting of an inner exponential breaking to a steeper outer exponential. The break forms early on and persists throughout the evolution, moving outward as more gas is able to cool and add mass to the disk. The parameters of the break are in excellent agreement with observations. The break corresponds with a rapid drop in the star formation rate associated with a drop in the cooled gas surface density, but the outer exponential is populated by stars that were scattered outward on nearly circular orbits from the inner disk by spiral arms. The resulting profile and its associated break are therefore a consequence of the interplay between a radial star formation cutoff and redistribution of stellar mass by secular processes. A consequence of such evolution is a sharp change in the radial mean stellar age profile at the break radius. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2008; v1 submitted 29 October, 2007; originally announced October 2007.

Comments: 4 pages, 3 figures, includes minor changes. ApJL in press

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.675:L65-L68,2008

Breathing in Low Mass Galaxies: A Study of Episodic Star Formation

Authors: G. S. Stinson, J. J. Dalcanton, T. Quinn, T. Kaufmann, J. Wadsley

Abstract: We simulate the collapse of isolated dwarf galaxies using SPH + N-Body simulations including a physically motivated description of the effects of supernova feedback. As the gas collapses and stars form, the supernova feedback disrupts enough gas to temporarily quench star formation. The gas flows outward into a hot halo, where it cools until star formation can continue once more and the cycle re… ▽ More We simulate the collapse of isolated dwarf galaxies using SPH + N-Body simulations including a physically motivated description of the effects of supernova feedback. As the gas collapses and stars form, the supernova feedback disrupts enough gas to temporarily quench star formation. The gas flows outward into a hot halo, where it cools until star formation can continue once more and the cycle repeats. The star formation histories of isolated Local Group dwarf galaxies exhibit similar episodic bursts of star formation. We examine the mass dependence of the stellar velocity dispersions and find that they are no less than half the velocity of the halos measured at the virial radius. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2007; originally announced May 2007.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, accepted ApJ. Full resolution figures and movies available at http://hpcc.astro.washington.edu/feedback

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.667:170-175,2007

Magnetic White Dwarfs from the SDSS II. The Second and Third Data Releases

Authors: Karen M. Vanlandingham, Gary D. Schmidt, Daniel J. Eisenstein, Hugh C. Harris, Scott F. Anderson, Pat B. Hall, James Liebert, Donald P. Schneider, Nicole M. Silvestri, Gregory S. Stinson, Michael A. Wolfe

Abstract: Fifty-two magnetic white dwarfs have been identified in spectroscopic observations from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) obtained between mid-2002 and the end of 2004, including Data Releases 2 and 3. Though not as numerous nor as diverse as the discoveries from the first Data Release, the collection exhibits polar field strengths ranging from 1.5MG to ~1000MG, and includes two new unusual at… ▽ More Fifty-two magnetic white dwarfs have been identified in spectroscopic observations from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) obtained between mid-2002 and the end of 2004, including Data Releases 2 and 3. Though not as numerous nor as diverse as the discoveries from the first Data Release, the collection exhibits polar field strengths ranging from 1.5MG to ~1000MG, and includes two new unusual atomic DQA examples, a molecular DQ, and five stars that show hydrogen in fields above 500MG. The highest-field example, SDSSJ2346+3853, may be the most strongly magnetic white dwarf yet discovered. Analysis of the photometric data indicates that the magnetic sample spans the same temperature range as for nonmagnetic white dwarfs from the SDSS, and support is found for previous claims that magnetic white dwarfs tend to have larger masses than their nonmagnetic counterparts. A glaring exception to this trend is the apparently low-gravity object SDSSJ0933+1022, which may have a history involving a close binary companion. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2005; originally announced May 2005.

Comments: 20 pages, 4 figures Accepted for publication in the Astronomical Journal

Journal ref: Astron.J.130:734-741,2005