Showing 1–22 of 22 results for author: Stepney, S

A methodology for comparing and benchmarking quantum devices

Authors: Jessica Park, Susan Stepney, Irene D'Amico

Abstract: Quantum Computing (QC) is undergoing a high rate of development, investment and research devoted to its improvement.However, there is little consensus in the industry and wider literature as to what improvement might consist of beyond ambiguous statements of "more qubits" and "fewer errors". Before one can decide how to improve something, it is first necessary to define the criteria for success: w… ▽ More Quantum Computing (QC) is undergoing a high rate of development, investment and research devoted to its improvement.However, there is little consensus in the industry and wider literature as to what improvement might consist of beyond ambiguous statements of "more qubits" and "fewer errors". Before one can decide how to improve something, it is first necessary to define the criteria for success: what are the metrics or statistics that are relevant to the problem? The lack of clarity surrounding this question has led to a rapidly develo** capability with little consistency or standards present across the board. This paper lays out a framework by which any user, developer or researcher can define, articulate and justify the success criteria and associated benchmarks that have been used to solve their problem or make their claim. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Unconventional Computing and Natural Computing 2024

An analysis of the relative effects of connectivity and coupling interactions on spin networks emulating the D-Wave 2000Q quantum annealer

Authors: Jessica Park, Susan Stepney, Irene D'Amico

Abstract: From available data, we show strong positive spatial correlations in the qubits of a D-Wave 2000Q quantum annealing chip that are connected to qubits outside their own unit cell. Then, by simulating the dynamics of three different spin networks and two different initial conditions, we then show that correlation between nodes is affected by a number of factors. The different connectivity of qubits… ▽ More From available data, we show strong positive spatial correlations in the qubits of a D-Wave 2000Q quantum annealing chip that are connected to qubits outside their own unit cell. Then, by simulating the dynamics of three different spin networks and two different initial conditions, we then show that correlation between nodes is affected by a number of factors. The different connectivity of qubits within the network means that information transfer is not straightforward even when all the qubit-qubit couplings have equal weighting. Connected nodes behave even more dissimilarly when the couplings' strength is scaled according to the physical length of the connections (here to simulate dipole-dipole interactions). This highlights the importance of understanding the architectural features and potentially unprogrammed interactions/connections that can divert the performance of a quantum system away from the idealised model of identical qubits and couplings across the chip. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: Extension to arXiv:2305.07385 To be published in Springer Natural Computing

Reservoir Computing Benchmarks: a review, a taxonomy, some best practices

Authors: Chester Wringe, Martin Trefzer, Susan Stepney

Abstract: Reservoir Computing is an Unconventional Computation model to perform computation on various different substrates, such as RNNs or physical materials. The method takes a "black-box" approach, training only the outputs of the system it is built on. As such, evaluating the computational capacity of these systems can be challenging. We review and critique the evaluation methods used in the field of R… ▽ More Reservoir Computing is an Unconventional Computation model to perform computation on various different substrates, such as RNNs or physical materials. The method takes a "black-box" approach, training only the outputs of the system it is built on. As such, evaluating the computational capacity of these systems can be challenging. We review and critique the evaluation methods used in the field of Reservoir Computing. We introduce a categorisation of benchmark tasks. We review multiple examples of benchmarks from the literature as applied to reservoir computing, and note their strengths and shortcomings. We suggest ways in which benchmarks and their uses may be improved to the benefit of the reservoir computing community △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 36pp, 15figs, review article

Unsupervised self-organising map of prostate cell Raman spectra shows disease-state subclustering

Authors: Daniel West, Susan Stepney, Y. Hancock

Abstract: Prostate cancer is a disease which poses an interesting clinical question: should it be treated? A small subset of prostate cancers are aggressive and require removal and treatment to prevent metastatic spread. However, conventional diagnostics remain challenged to risk-stratify such patients, hence, new methods of approach to biomolecularly subclassify the disease are needed. Here we use an unsup… ▽ More Prostate cancer is a disease which poses an interesting clinical question: should it be treated? A small subset of prostate cancers are aggressive and require removal and treatment to prevent metastatic spread. However, conventional diagnostics remain challenged to risk-stratify such patients, hence, new methods of approach to biomolecularly subclassify the disease are needed. Here we use an unsupervised, self-organising map approach to analyse live-cell Raman spectroscopy data obtained from prostate cell-lines; our aim is to test the feasibility of this method to differentiate, at the single-cell-level, cancer from normal using high-dimensional datasets with minimal preprocessing. The results demonstrate not only successful separation of normal prostate and cancer cells, but also a new subclustering of the prostate cancer cell-line into two groups. Initial analysis of the spectra from each of the cancer subclusters demonstrates a differential expression of lipids, which, against the normal control, may be linked to disease-related changes in cellular signalling. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 14 pages, 6 figures

Optimising network interactions through device agnostic models

Authors: Luca Manneschi, Ian T. Vidamour, Kilian D. Stenning, Jack C. Gartside, Charles Swindells, Guru Venkat, David Griffin, Susan Stepney, Will R. Branford, Thomas Hayward, Matt O Ellis, Eleni Vasilaki

Abstract: Physically implemented neural networks hold the potential to achieve the performance of deep learning models by exploiting the innate physical properties of devices as computational tools. This exploration of physical processes for computation requires to also consider their intrinsic dynamics, which can serve as valuable resources to process information. However, existing computational methods ar… ▽ More Physically implemented neural networks hold the potential to achieve the performance of deep learning models by exploiting the innate physical properties of devices as computational tools. This exploration of physical processes for computation requires to also consider their intrinsic dynamics, which can serve as valuable resources to process information. However, existing computational methods are unable to extend the success of deep learning techniques to parameters influencing device dynamics, which often lack a precise mathematical description. In this work, we formulate a universal framework to optimise interactions with dynamic physical systems in a fully data-driven fashion. The framework adopts neural stochastic differential equations as differentiable digital twins, effectively capturing both deterministic and stochastic behaviours of devices. Employing differentiation through the trained models provides the essential mathematical estimates for optimizing a physical neural network, harnessing the intrinsic temporal computation abilities of its physical nodes. To accurately model real devices' behaviours, we formulated neural-SDE variants that can operate under a variety of experimental settings. Our work demonstrates the framework's applicability through simulations and physical implementations of interacting dynamic devices, while highlighting the importance of accurately capturing system stochasticity for the successful deployment of a physically defined neural network. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Spatial correlations in the qubit properties of D-Wave 2000Q measured and simulated qubit networks

Authors: Jessica Park, Susan Stepney, Irene D'Amico

Abstract: We show strong positive spatial correlations in the qubits of a D-Wave 2000Q quantum annealing chip that are connected to qubits outside their own unit cell. By simulating the dynamics of spin networks, we then show that correlation between nodes is affected by a number of factors. The different connectivity of qubits within the network means that information transfer is not straightforward even w… ▽ More We show strong positive spatial correlations in the qubits of a D-Wave 2000Q quantum annealing chip that are connected to qubits outside their own unit cell. By simulating the dynamics of spin networks, we then show that correlation between nodes is affected by a number of factors. The different connectivity of qubits within the network means that information transfer is not straightforward even when all the qubit-qubit couplings have equal weighting. The similarity between connected nodes is further changed when the couplings' strength is scaled according to the physical length of the connections (here to simulate dipole-dipole interactions). This highlights the importance of understanding the architectural features and potentially unprogrammed interactions/connections that can divert the performance of a quantum system away from the idealised model of identical qubits and couplings across the chip. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: To be included in conference proceedings for Unconventional Computation and Natural Computation 2023

A perspective on physical reservoir computing with nanomagnetic devices

Authors: Dan A Allwood, Matthew O A Ellis, David Griffin, Thomas J Hayward, Luca Manneschi, Mohammad F KH Musameh, Simon O'Keefe, Susan Stepney, Charles Swindells, Martin A Trefzer, Eleni Vasilaki, Guru Venkat, Ian Vidamour, Chester Wringe

Abstract: Neural networks have revolutionized the area of artificial intelligence and introduced transformative applications to almost every scientific field and industry. However, this success comes at a great price; the energy requirements for training advanced models are unsustainable. One promising way to address this pressing issue is by develo** low-energy neuromorphic hardware that directly support… ▽ More Neural networks have revolutionized the area of artificial intelligence and introduced transformative applications to almost every scientific field and industry. However, this success comes at a great price; the energy requirements for training advanced models are unsustainable. One promising way to address this pressing issue is by develo** low-energy neuromorphic hardware that directly supports the algorithm's requirements. The intrinsic non-volatility, non-linearity, and memory of spintronic devices make them appealing candidates for neuromorphic devices. Here we focus on the reservoir computing paradigm, a recurrent network with a simple training algorithm suitable for computation with spintronic devices since they can provide the properties of non-linearity and memory. We review technologies and methods for develo** neuromorphic spintronic devices and conclude with critical open issues to address before such devices become widely used. △ Less

Submitted 9 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Quantifying the Computational Capability of a Nanomagnetic Reservoir Computing Platform with Emergent Magnetization Dynamics

Authors: Ian T Vidamour, Matthew O A Ellis, David Griffin, Guru Venkat, Charles Swindells, Richard W S Dawidek, Thomas J Broomhall, Nina-Juliane Steinke, Joshaniel F K Cooper, Francisco Maccherozzi, Sarnjeet S Dhesi, Susan Stepney, Eleni Vasilaki, Dan A Allwood, Thomas J Hayward

Abstract: Devices based on arrays of interconnected magnetic nano-rings with emergent magnetization dynamics have recently been proposed for use in reservoir computing applications, but for them to be computationally useful it must be possible to optimise their dynamical responses. Here, we use a phenomenological model to demonstrate that such reservoirs can be optimised for classification tasks by tuning h… ▽ More Devices based on arrays of interconnected magnetic nano-rings with emergent magnetization dynamics have recently been proposed for use in reservoir computing applications, but for them to be computationally useful it must be possible to optimise their dynamical responses. Here, we use a phenomenological model to demonstrate that such reservoirs can be optimised for classification tasks by tuning hyperparameters that control the scaling and input rate of data into the system using rotating magnetic fields. We use task-independent metrics to assess the rings' computational capabilities at each set of these hyperparameters and show how these metrics correlate directly to performance in spoken and written digit recognition tasks. We then show that these metrics, and performance in tasks, can be further improved by expanding the reservoir's output to include multiple, concurrent measures of the ring arrays magnetic states. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2022; v1 submitted 29 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Reservoir Computing with Magnetic Thin Films

Authors: Matthew Dale, David Griffin, Richard F. L. Evans, Sarah Jenkins, Simon O'Keefe, Angelika Sebald, Susan Stepney, Fernando Torre, Martin Trefzer

Abstract: Advances in artificial intelligence are driven by technologies inspired by the brain, but these technologies are orders of magnitude less powerful and energy efficient than biological systems. Inspired by the nonlinear dynamics of neural networks, new unconventional computing hardware has emerged with the potential to exploit natural phenomena and gain efficiency, in a similar manner to biological… ▽ More Advances in artificial intelligence are driven by technologies inspired by the brain, but these technologies are orders of magnitude less powerful and energy efficient than biological systems. Inspired by the nonlinear dynamics of neural networks, new unconventional computing hardware has emerged with the potential to exploit natural phenomena and gain efficiency, in a similar manner to biological systems. Physical reservoir computing demonstrates this with a variety of unconventional systems, from optical-based to memristive systems. Reservoir computers provide a nonlinear projection of the task input into a high-dimensional feature space by exploiting the system's internal dynamics. A trained readout layer then combines features to perform tasks, such as pattern recognition and time-series analysis. Despite progress, achieving state-of-the-art performance without external signal processing to the reservoir remains challenging. Here we perform an initial exploration of three magnetic materials in thin-film geometries via microscale simulation. Our results reveal that basic spin properties of magnetic films generate the required nonlinear dynamics and memory to solve machine learning tasks (although there would be practical challenges in exploiting these particular materials in physical implementations). The method of exploration can be applied to other materials, so this work opens up the possibility of testing different materials, from relatively simple (alloys) to significantly complex (antiferromagnetic reservoirs). △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2023; v1 submitted 29 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 30 pages, 10 figures, updated and clarified

Journal ref: International Journal of Unconventional Computing, 19(1):63-92, 2024

MetaChem: An Algebraic Framework for Artificial Chemistries

Authors: Penelope Faulkner Rainford, Angelika Sebald, Susan Stepney

Abstract: We introduce MetaChem, a language for representing and implementing Artificial Chemistries. We motivate the need for modularisation and standardisation in representation of artificial chemistries. We describe a mathematical formalism for Static Graph MetaChem, a static graph based system. MetaChem supports different levels of description, and has a formal description; we illustrate these using Str… ▽ More We introduce MetaChem, a language for representing and implementing Artificial Chemistries. We motivate the need for modularisation and standardisation in representation of artificial chemistries. We describe a mathematical formalism for Static Graph MetaChem, a static graph based system. MetaChem supports different levels of description, and has a formal description; we illustrate these using StringCatChem, a toy artificial chemistry. We describe two existing Artificial Chemistries -- Jordan Algebra AChem and Swarm Chemistries -- in MetaChem, and demonstrate how they can be combined in several different configurations by using a MetaChem environmental link. MetaChem provides a route to standardisation, reuse, and composition of Artificial Chemistries and their tools. △ Less

Submitted 14 June, 2020; v1 submitted 29 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 39 pages, 19 figures; minor typos corrected

Journal ref: Artificial Life 26(2):153-195 2020

Visualising high-dimensional state spaces with "Tuple Plots"

Authors: Susan Stepney

Abstract: Complex systems are described with high-dimensional data that is hard to visualise. Inselberg's parallel coordinates are one representation technique for visualising high-dimensional data. Here we generalise Inselberg's approach, and use it for visualising trajectories through high dimensional state spaces. We introduce two geometric projections of parallel coordinate representations -- 'plan tupl… ▽ More Complex systems are described with high-dimensional data that is hard to visualise. Inselberg's parallel coordinates are one representation technique for visualising high-dimensional data. Here we generalise Inselberg's approach, and use it for visualising trajectories through high dimensional state spaces. We introduce two geometric projections of parallel coordinate representations -- 'plan tuple plots' and 'side tuple plots' -- and demonstrate a link between state space and ordinary space representations. We provide examples from many domains to illustrate use of the approach, including Cellular Automata, Random Boolean Networks, coupled logistic maps, reservoir computing, search algorithms, Turing Machines, and flocking. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 40 pages, 47 colour figures

Evolving Graphs with Semantic Neutral Drift

Authors: Timothy Atkinson, Detlef Plump, Susan Stepney

Abstract: We introduce the concept of Semantic Neutral Drift (SND) for genetic programming (GP), where we exploit equivalence laws to design semantics preserving mutations guaranteed to preserve individuals' fitness scores. A number of digital circuit benchmark problems have been implemented with rule-based graph programs and empirically evaluated, demonstrating quantitative improvements in evolutionary per… ▽ More We introduce the concept of Semantic Neutral Drift (SND) for genetic programming (GP), where we exploit equivalence laws to design semantics preserving mutations guaranteed to preserve individuals' fitness scores. A number of digital circuit benchmark problems have been implemented with rule-based graph programs and empirically evaluated, demonstrating quantitative improvements in evolutionary performance. Analysis reveals that the benefits of the designed SND reside in more complex processes than simple growth of individuals, and that there are circumstances where it is beneficial to choose otherwise detrimental parameters for a GP system if that facilitates the inclusion of SND. △ Less

Submitted 3 February, 2020; v1 submitted 24 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

A Substrate-Independent Framework to Characterise Reservoir Computers

Authors: Matthew Dale, Julian F. Miller, Susan Stepney, Martin A. Trefzer

Abstract: The Reservoir Computing (RC) framework states that any non-linear, input-driven dynamical system (the reservoir) exhibiting properties such as a fading memory and input separability can be trained to perform computational tasks. This broad inclusion of systems has led to many new physical substrates for RC. Properties essential for reservoirs to compute are tuned through reconfiguration of the sub… ▽ More The Reservoir Computing (RC) framework states that any non-linear, input-driven dynamical system (the reservoir) exhibiting properties such as a fading memory and input separability can be trained to perform computational tasks. This broad inclusion of systems has led to many new physical substrates for RC. Properties essential for reservoirs to compute are tuned through reconfiguration of the substrate, such as change in virtual topology or physical morphology. As a result, each substrate possesses a unique `quality' -- obtained through reconfiguration -- to realise different reservoirs for different tasks. Here we describe an experimental framework to characterise the quality of potentially any substrate for RC. Our framework reveals that a definition of quality is not only useful to compare substrates, but can help map the non-trivial relationship between properties and task performance. In the wider context, the framework offers a greater understanding as to what makes a dynamical system compute, hel** improve the design of future substrates for RC. △ Less

Submitted 20 May, 2019; v1 submitted 16 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: addition of a further substrate: a simulated delay-based reservoir

Journal ref: Proc.Roy.Soc.A 475(2226), 2019

Computability and Complexity of Unconventional Computing Devices

Authors: Hajo Broersma, Susan Stepney, Goran Wendin

Abstract: We discuss some claims that certain UCOMP devices can perform hypercomputation (compute Turing-uncomputable functions) or perform super-Turing computation (solve NP-complete problems in polynomial time). We discover that all these claims rely on the provision of one or more unphysical resources. We discuss some claims that certain UCOMP devices can perform hypercomputation (compute Turing-uncomputable functions) or perform super-Turing computation (solve NP-complete problems in polynomial time). We discover that all these claims rely on the provision of one or more unphysical resources. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2017; v1 submitted 9 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: to appear in "Computational Matter". Stepney, Rasmussen, Amos, eds. Springer 2017

The Geometry of Speed Limiting Resources in Physical Models of Computation

Authors: Benjamin Russell, Susan Stepney

Abstract: We study the maximum speed of quantum computation and how it is affected by limitations on physical resources. We show how the resulting concepts generalize to a broader class of physical models of computation within dynamical systems and introduce a specific algebraic structure representing these speed limits. We derive a family of quantum speed limit results in resource-constrained quantum syste… ▽ More We study the maximum speed of quantum computation and how it is affected by limitations on physical resources. We show how the resulting concepts generalize to a broader class of physical models of computation within dynamical systems and introduce a specific algebraic structure representing these speed limits. We derive a family of quantum speed limit results in resource-constrained quantum systems with pure states and a finite dimensional state space, by using a geometric method based on right invariant action functionals on $SU(N)$. We show that when the action functional is bi-invariant, the minimum time for implementing any quantum gate using a potentially time-dependent Hamiltonian is equal to the minimum time when using a constant Hamiltonian, thus constant Hamiltonians are time optimal for these constraints. We give an explicit formula for the time in these cases, in terms of the resource constraint. We show how our method produces a rich family of speed limit results, of which the generalized Margolus--Levitin theorem and the Mandelstam--Tamm inequality are special cases. We discuss the broader context of geometric approaches to speed limits in physical computation, including the way geometric approaches to quantum speed limits are a model for physical speed limits to computation arising from a limited resource. △ Less

Submitted 28 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: 1 figure

Report number: IJFCS-D-16-00021

A Geometrical Derivation of a Family of Quantum Speed Limit Results

Authors: Benjamin Russell, Susan Stepney

Abstract: We derive a family of quantum speed limit results in time independent systems with pure states and a finite dimensional state space, by using a geometric method based on right invariant action functionals on SU(N). The method relates speed limits for implementing quantum gates to bounds on orthogonality times. We reproduce the known result of the Margolus-Levitin theorem, and a known generalisatio… ▽ More We derive a family of quantum speed limit results in time independent systems with pure states and a finite dimensional state space, by using a geometric method based on right invariant action functionals on SU(N). The method relates speed limits for implementing quantum gates to bounds on orthogonality times. We reproduce the known result of the Margolus-Levitin theorem, and a known generalisation of the Margolis-Levitin theorem, as special cases of our method, which produces a rich family of other similar speed limit formulas corresponding to positive homogeneous functions on su(n). We discuss the general relationship between speed limits for controlling a quantum state and a system's time evolution operator. △ Less

Submitted 13 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: 12 pages

Zermelo Navigation in the Quantum Brachistochrone

Authors: Benjamin Russell, Susan Stepney

Abstract: We analyse the optimal times for implementing unitary quantum gates in a constrained finite dimensional controlled quantum system. The family of constraints studied is that the permitted set of (time dependent) Hamiltonians is the unit ball of a norm induced by an inner product on su(n). We also consider a generalisation of this to arbitrary norms. We construct a Randers metric, by applying a theo… ▽ More We analyse the optimal times for implementing unitary quantum gates in a constrained finite dimensional controlled quantum system. The family of constraints studied is that the permitted set of (time dependent) Hamiltonians is the unit ball of a norm induced by an inner product on su(n). We also consider a generalisation of this to arbitrary norms. We construct a Randers metric, by applying a theorem of Shen on Zermelo navigation, the geodesics of which are the time optimal trajectories compatible with the prescribed constraint. We determine all geodesics and the corresponding time optimal Hamiltonian for a specific constraint on the control i.e. k (Tr(Hc(t)^2) = 1 for any given value of k > 0. Some of the results of Carlini et. al. are re-derived using alternative methods. A first order system of differential equations for the optimal Hamiltonian is obtained and shown to be of the form of the Euler Poincare equations. We illustrate that this method can form a methodology for determining which physical substrates are effective at supporting the implementation of fast quantum computation. △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2015; v1 submitted 6 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: 27 pages, 3 figures, final published version in Journal of Physics A, March 2015

Journal ref: Journal of Physics A, 48:115303, 2015

Zermelo Navigation and a Speed Limit to Quantum Information Processing

Authors: Benjamin Russell, Susan Stepney

Abstract: We use a specific geometric method to determine speed limits to the implementation of quantum gates in controlled quantum systems that have a specific class of constrained control functions. We achieve this by applying a recent theorem of Shen, which provides a connection between time optimal navigation on Riemannian manifolds and the geodesics of a certain Finsler metric of Randers type. We use t… ▽ More We use a specific geometric method to determine speed limits to the implementation of quantum gates in controlled quantum systems that have a specific class of constrained control functions. We achieve this by applying a recent theorem of Shen, which provides a connection between time optimal navigation on Riemannian manifolds and the geodesics of a certain Finsler metric of Randers type. We use the lengths of these geodesics to derive the optimal implementation times (under the assumption of constant control fields) for an arbitrary quantum operation (on a finite dimensional Hilbert space), and explicitly calculate the result for the case of a controlled single spin system in a magnetic field, and a swap gate in a Heisenberg spin chain. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2014; v1 submitted 24 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: 7 pages, accepted by Phys.Rev.A

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 90, 012303 (2014)

When does a physical system compute?

Authors: Dominic Horsman, Susan Stepney, Rob C. Wagner, Viv Kendon

Abstract: Computing is a high-level process of a physical system. Recent interest in non-standard computing systems, including quantum and biological computers, has brought this physical basis of computing to the forefront. There has been, however, no consensus on how to tell if a given physical system is acting as a computer or not; leading to confusion over novel computational devices, and even claims tha… ▽ More Computing is a high-level process of a physical system. Recent interest in non-standard computing systems, including quantum and biological computers, has brought this physical basis of computing to the forefront. There has been, however, no consensus on how to tell if a given physical system is acting as a computer or not; leading to confusion over novel computational devices, and even claims that every physical event is a computation. In this paper we introduce a formal framework that can be used to determine whether or not a physical system is performing a computation. We demonstrate how the abstract computational level interacts with the physical device level, drawing the comparison with the use of mathematical models to represent physical objects in experimental science. This powerful formulation allows a precise description of the similarities between experiments, computation, simulation, and technology, leading to our central conclusion: physical computing is the use of a physical system to predict the outcome of an abstract evolution. We give conditions that must be satisfied in order for computation to be occurring, and illustrate these with a range of non-standard computing scenarios. The framework also covers broader computing contexts, where there is no obvious human computer user. We define the critical notion of a 'computational entity', and show the role this plays in defining when computing is taking place in physical systems. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2014; v1 submitted 30 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 22 pages, 10 figures. v3 as accepted by Proc.Roy.Soc.A

Journal ref: Proc. R. Soc. A 2014 470, 20140182

A Framework for Heterotic Computing

Authors: Susan Stepney, Viv Kendon, Peter Hines, Angelika Sebald

Abstract: Computational devices combining two or more different parts, one controlling the operation of the other, for example, derive their power from the interaction, in addition to the capabilities of the parts. Non-classical computation has tended to consider only single computational models: neural, analog, quantum, chemical, biological, neglecting to account for the contribution from the experimental… ▽ More Computational devices combining two or more different parts, one controlling the operation of the other, for example, derive their power from the interaction, in addition to the capabilities of the parts. Non-classical computation has tended to consider only single computational models: neural, analog, quantum, chemical, biological, neglecting to account for the contribution from the experimental controls. In this position paper, we propose a framework suitable for analysing combined computational models, from abstract theory to practical programming tools. Focusing on the simplest example of one system controlled by another through a sequence of operations in which only one system is active at a time, the output from one system becomes the input to the other for the next step, and vice versa. We outline the categorical machinery required for handling diverse computational systems in such combinations, with their interactions explicitly accounted for. Drawing on prior work in refinement and retrenchment, we suggest an appropriate framework for develo** programming tools from the categorical framework. We place this work in the context of two contrasting concepts of "efficiency": theoretical comparisons to determine the relative computational power do not always reflect the practical comparison of real resources for a finite-sized computational task, especially when the inputs include (approximations of) real numbers. Finally we outline the limitations of our simple model, and identify some of the extensions that will be required to treat more complex interacting computational systems. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: In Proceedings QPL 2011, arXiv:1210.0298

Journal ref: EPTCS 95, 2012, pp. 263-273

Boolean logic gate design principles in unconventional computers: an NMR case study

Authors: Matthias Bechmann, Angelika Sebald, Susan Stepney

Abstract: We present a general method for analysing novel computational substrates to determine which of their parameters can be manipulated to exhibit the complete set of 2-input boolean logical operations. We demonstrate this approach with an NMR-based case study, showing which NMR parameters can be used to perform boolean logic. We present a general method for analysing novel computational substrates to determine which of their parameters can be manipulated to exhibit the complete set of 2-input boolean logical operations. We demonstrate this approach with an NMR-based case study, showing which NMR parameters can be used to perform boolean logic. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2011; originally announced September 2011.

Journal ref: International Journal of Unconventional Computing, 2012, 8, 139-159

Highly entangled multi-qubit states with simple algebraic structure

Authors: Juan E. Tapiador, Julio C. Hernandez-Castro, John A. Clark, Susan Stepney

Abstract: Recent works by Brown et al and Borras et al have explored numerical optimisation procedures to search for highly entangled multi-qubit states according to some computationally tractable entanglement measure. We present an alternative scheme based upon the idea of searching for states having not only high entanglement but also simple algebraic structure. We report results for 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 qu… ▽ More Recent works by Brown et al and Borras et al have explored numerical optimisation procedures to search for highly entangled multi-qubit states according to some computationally tractable entanglement measure. We present an alternative scheme based upon the idea of searching for states having not only high entanglement but also simple algebraic structure. We report results for 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 qubits discovered by this approach, showing that many of such states do exist. In particular, we find a maximally entangled 6-qubit state with an algebraic structure simpler than the best results known so far. For the case of 7, we discover states with high, but not maximum, entanglement and simple structure, as well as other desirable properties. Some preliminary results are shown for the case of 8 qubits. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2009; v1 submitted 24 April, 2009; originally announced April 2009.

Comments: 15 pages, 1 figure