-
Whistler waves in the quasi-parallel and quasi-perpendicular magnetosheath
Authors:
Ida Svenningsson,
Emiliya Yordanova,
Yuri V. Khotyaintsev,
Mats André,
Giulia Cozzani,
Konrad Steinvall
Abstract:
In the Earth's magnetosheath (MSH), several processes contribute to energy dissipation and plasma heating, one of which is wave-particle interactions between whistler waves and electrons. However, the overall impact of whistlers on electron dynamics in the MSH remains to be quantified. We analyze 18 hours of burst-mode measurements from the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission, including data f…
▽ More
In the Earth's magnetosheath (MSH), several processes contribute to energy dissipation and plasma heating, one of which is wave-particle interactions between whistler waves and electrons. However, the overall impact of whistlers on electron dynamics in the MSH remains to be quantified. We analyze 18 hours of burst-mode measurements from the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission, including data from the unbiased magnetosheath campaign during February-March 2023. We present a statistical study of 34,409 whistler waves found using automatic detection. We compare wave occurrence in the different MSH geometries and find three times higher occurrence in the quasi-perpendicular MSH compared to the quasi-parallel case. We also study the wave properties and find that the waves propagate quasi-parallel to the background magnetic field, have a median frequency of 0.2 times the electron cyclotron frequency, median amplitude of 0.03-0.06 nT (30-60 pT), and median duration of a few tens of wave periods. The whistler waves are preferentially observed in local magnetic dips and density peaks and are not associated with an increased temperature anisotropy. Also, almost no whistlers are observed in regions with parallel electron plasma beta lower than 0.1. Importantly, when estimating pitch-angle diffusion times we find that the whistler waves cause significant pitch-angle scattering of electrons in the MSH.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2024; v1 submitted 5 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
CMEs and SEPs During November-December 2020: A Challenge for Real-Time Space Weather Forecasting
Authors:
Erika Palmerio,
Christina O. Lee,
M. Leila Mays,
Janet G. Luhmann,
David Lario,
Beatriz Sánchez-Cano,
Ian G. Richardson,
Rami Vainio,
Michael L. Stevens,
Christina M. S. Cohen,
Konrad Steinvall,
Christian Möstl,
Andreas J. Weiss,
Teresa Nieves-Chinchilla,
Yan Li,
Davin E. Larson,
Daniel Heyner,
Stuart D. Bale,
Antoinette B. Galvin,
Mats Holmström,
Yuri V. Khotyaintsev,
Milan Maksimovic,
Igor G. Mitrofanov
Abstract:
Predictions of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and solar energetic particles (SEPs) are a central issue in space weather forecasting. In recent years, interest in space weather predictions has expanded to include impacts at other planets beyond Earth as well as spacecraft scattered throughout the heliosphere. In this sense, the scope of space weather science now encompasses the whole heliospheric sy…
▽ More
Predictions of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and solar energetic particles (SEPs) are a central issue in space weather forecasting. In recent years, interest in space weather predictions has expanded to include impacts at other planets beyond Earth as well as spacecraft scattered throughout the heliosphere. In this sense, the scope of space weather science now encompasses the whole heliospheric system, and multi-point measurements of solar transients can provide useful insights and validations for prediction models. In this work, we aim to analyse the whole inner heliospheric context between two eruptive flares that took place in late 2020, i.e. the M4.4 flare of November 29 and the C7.4 flare of December 7. This period is especially interesting because the STEREO-A spacecraft was located ~60° east of the Sun-Earth line, giving us the opportunity to test the capabilities of "predictions at 360°" using remote-sensing observations from the Lagrange L1 and L5 points as input. We simulate the CMEs that were ejected during our period of interest and the SEPs accelerated by their shocks using the WSA-Enlil-SEPMOD modelling chain and four sets of input parameters, forming a "mini-ensemble". We validate our results using in-situ observations at six locations, including Earth and Mars. We find that, despite some limitations arising from the models' architecture and assumptions, CMEs and shock-accelerated SEPs can be reasonably studied and forecast in real time at least out to several tens of degrees away from the eruption site using the prediction tools employed here.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2022; v1 submitted 30 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
On the applicability of single-spacecraft interferometry methods using electric field probes
Authors:
Konrad Steinvall,
Yuri V. Khotyaintsev,
Daniel B. Graham
Abstract:
When analyzing plasma waves, a key parameter to determine is the phase velocity. It enables us to, for example, compute wavelengths, wave potentials, and determine the energy of resonant particles. The phase velocity of a wave, observed by a single spacecraft equipped with electric field probes, can be determined using interferometry techniques. While several methods have been developed to do this…
▽ More
When analyzing plasma waves, a key parameter to determine is the phase velocity. It enables us to, for example, compute wavelengths, wave potentials, and determine the energy of resonant particles. The phase velocity of a wave, observed by a single spacecraft equipped with electric field probes, can be determined using interferometry techniques. While several methods have been developed to do this, they have not been documented in detail. In this study, we use an analytical model to analyze and compare three interferometry methods applied on the probe geometry of the Magnetospheric Multiscale spacecraft. One method relies on measured probe potentials, whereas the other two use different E-field measurements: one by reconstructing the E-field between two probes and the spacecraft, the other by constructing four pairwise parallel E-field components in the spacecraft spin-plane. We find that the potential method is sensitive both to how planar the wave is, and to spacecraft potential changes due to the wave. The E-field methods are less affected by the spacecraft potential, and while the reconstructed E-field method is applicable in some cases, the second E-field method is almost always preferable. We conclude that the potential based interferometry method is useful when spacecraft potential effects are negligible and the signals of the different probes are very well correlated. The method using two pairs of parallel E-fields is practically always preferable to the reconstructed E-field method and produces the correct velocity in the spin-plane, but it requires knowledge of the propagation direction to provide the full velocity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2022; v1 submitted 19 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Whistler waves observed by Solar Orbiter / RPW between 0.5 AU and 1 AU
Authors:
M. Kretzschmar,
T. Chust,
V. Krasnoselskikh,
D. Graham,
L. Colomban,
M. Maksimovic,
Yu. V. Khotyaintsev,
J. Soucek,
K. Steinvall,
O. Santolik,
G. Jannet,
J. Y. Brochot,
O. Le Contel,
A. Vecchio,
X. Bonnin,
S. D. Bale,
C. Froment,
A. Larosa,
M. Bergerard-Timofeeva,
P. Fergeau,
E. Lorfevre,
D. Plettemeier,
M. Steller,
S. Stverak,
P. Travnicek
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The goal of our study is to detect and characterize the electromagnetic waves that can modify the electron distribution functions, with a special attention to whistler waves. We analyse in details the electric and magnetic field fluctuations observed by the Solar Orbiter spacecraft during its first orbit around the Sun between 0.5 and 1 AU. Using data of the Search Coil Magnetometer and electric a…
▽ More
The goal of our study is to detect and characterize the electromagnetic waves that can modify the electron distribution functions, with a special attention to whistler waves. We analyse in details the electric and magnetic field fluctuations observed by the Solar Orbiter spacecraft during its first orbit around the Sun between 0.5 and 1 AU. Using data of the Search Coil Magnetometer and electric antenna, both parts of the Radio and Plasma Waves (RPW) instrumental suite, we detect the electromagnetic waves with frequencies above 3 Hz and determine the statistical distribution of their amplitudes, frequencies, polarization and k-vector as a function of distance. We also discuss relevant instrumental issues regarding the phase between the electric and magnetic measurements and the effective length of the electric antenna. An overwhelming majority of the observed waves are right hand circularly polarized in the solar wind frame and identified as outward propagating and quasi parallel whistler waves. Their occurrence rate increases by a least a factor two from 1 AU to 0.5 AU. These results are consistent with the regulation of the heat flux by the whistler heat flux instability. Near 0.5 AU, whistler waves are found to be more field-aligned and to have smaller normalized frequency ($f/f_{ce}$), larger amplitude, and larger bandwidth than at 1 AU.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Statistical study of electron density turbulence and ion-cyclotron waves in the inner heliosphere: Solar Orbiter observations
Authors:
F. Carbone,
L. Sorriso-Valvo,
Yu. V. Khotyaintsev,
K. Steinvall,
A. Vecchio,
D. Telloni,
E. Yordanova,
D. B. Graham,
N. J. T. Edberg,
A. I. Eriksson,
E. P. G. Johansson,
C. L. Vásconez,
M. Maksimovic,
R. Bruno,
R. D'Amicis,
S. D. Bale,
T. Chust,
V. Krasnoselskikh,
M. Kretzschmar,
E. Lorfèvre,
D. Plettemeier,
J. Soucek,
M. Steller,
Š. Štverák,
P. Trávnícek
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The recently released spacecraft potential measured by the RPW instrument on-board Solar Orbiter has been used to estimate the solar wind electron density in the inner heliosphere. Solar-wind electron density measured during June 2020 has been analysed to obtain a thorough characterization of the turbulence and intermittency properties of the fluctuations. Magnetic field data have been used to des…
▽ More
The recently released spacecraft potential measured by the RPW instrument on-board Solar Orbiter has been used to estimate the solar wind electron density in the inner heliosphere. Solar-wind electron density measured during June 2020 has been analysed to obtain a thorough characterization of the turbulence and intermittency properties of the fluctuations. Magnetic field data have been used to describe the presence of ion-scale waves. Selected intervals have been extracted to study and quantify the properties of turbulence. The Empirical Mode Decomposition has been used to obtain the generalized marginal Hilbert spectrum, equivalent to the structure functions analysis, and additionally reducing issues typical of non-stationary, short time series. The presence of waves was quantitatively determined introducing a parameter describing the time-dependent, frequency-filtered wave power. A well defined inertial range with power-law scaling has been found almost everywhere. However, the Kolmogorov scaling and the typical intermittency effects are only present in part of the samples. Other intervals have shallower spectra and more irregular intermittency, not described by models of turbulence. These are observed predominantly during intervals of enhanced ion frequency wave activity. Comparisons with compressible magnetic field intermittency (from the MAG instrument) and with an estimate of the solar wind velocity (using electric and magnetic field) are also provided to give general context and help determine the cause for the anomalous fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Signatures of coronal hole substructure in the solar wind: combined Solar Orbiter remote sensing and in situ measurements
Authors:
T. S. Horbury,
R. Laker,
L. Rodriguez,
K. Steinvall,
M. Maksimovic,
S. Livi,
D. Berghmans,
F. Auchere,
A. N. Zhukov,
Yu. V. Khotyaintsev,
L. Woodham,
L. Matteini,
J. Stawarz,
T. Woolley,
S. D. Bale,
A. Rouillard,
H. O'Brien,
V. Evans,
V. Angelini,
C. Owen,
S. K. Solanki,
B. Nicula,
D. Muller,
I. Zouganelis
Abstract:
Context. The Sun's complex corona is the source of the solar wind and interplanetary magnetic field. While the large scale morphology is well understood, the impact of variations in coronal properties on the scale of a few degrees on properties of the interplanetary medium is not known. Solar Orbiter, carrying both remote sensing and in situ instruments into the inner solar system, is intended to…
▽ More
Context. The Sun's complex corona is the source of the solar wind and interplanetary magnetic field. While the large scale morphology is well understood, the impact of variations in coronal properties on the scale of a few degrees on properties of the interplanetary medium is not known. Solar Orbiter, carrying both remote sensing and in situ instruments into the inner solar system, is intended to make these connections better than ever before. Aims. We combine remote sensing and in situ measurements from Solar Orbiter's first perihelion at 0.5 AU to study the fine scale structure of the solar wind from the equatorward edge of a polar coronal hole with the aim of identifying characteristics of the corona which can explain the in situ variations. Methods. We use in situ measurements of the magnetic field, density and solar wind speed to identify structures on scales of hours at the spacecraft. Using Potential Field Source Surface map** we estimate the source locations of the measured solar wind as a function of time and use EUI images to characterise these solar sources. Results. We identify small scale stream interactions in the solar wind with compressed magnetic field and density along with speed variations which are associated with corrugations in the edge of the coronal hole on scales of several degrees, demonstrating that fine scale coronal structure can directly influence solar wind properties and drive variations within individual streams. Conclusions. This early analysis already demonstrates the power of Solar Orbiter's combined remote sensing and in situ payload and shows that with future, closer perihelia it will be possible dramatically to improve our knowledge of the coronal sources of fine scale solar wind structure, which is important both for understanding the phenomena driving the solar wind and predicting its impacts at the Earth and elsewhere.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Solar wind current sheets and deHoffmann-Teller analysis: First results of DC electric field measurements by Solar Orbiter
Authors:
K. Steinvall,
Yu. V. Khotyaintsev,
G. Cozzani,
A. Vaivads,
E. Yordanova,
A. I. Eriksson,
N. J. T. Edberg,
M. Maksimovic,
S. D. Bale,
T. Chust,
V. Krasnoselskikh,
M. Kretzschmar,
E. Lorfèvre,
D. Plettemeier,
J. Souček,
M. Steller,
Š. Štverák,
A. Vecchio,
T. S. Horbury,
H. O'Brien,
V. Evans,
A. Fedorov,
P. Louarn,
V. Génot,
N. André
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Solar Orbiter was launched on February 10, 2020 with the purpose of investigating solar and heliospheric physics using a payload of instruments designed for both remote and in-situ sensing. Similar to the recently launched Parker Solar Probe, and unlike earlier missions, Solar Orbiter carries instruments designed to measure the low frequency DC electric fields. In this paper we assess the quality…
▽ More
Solar Orbiter was launched on February 10, 2020 with the purpose of investigating solar and heliospheric physics using a payload of instruments designed for both remote and in-situ sensing. Similar to the recently launched Parker Solar Probe, and unlike earlier missions, Solar Orbiter carries instruments designed to measure the low frequency DC electric fields. In this paper we assess the quality of the low-frequency DC electric field measured by the Radio and Plasma Waves instrument (RPW) on Solar Orbiter. In particular we investigate the possibility of using Solar Orbiter's DC electric and magnetic field data to estimate the solar wind speed. We use deHoffmann-Teller (HT) analysis based on measurements of the electric and magnetic fields to find the velocity of solar wind current sheets which minimizes a single component of the electric field. By comparing the HT velocity to proton velocity measured by the Proton and Alpha particle Sensor (PAS) we develop a simple model for the effective antenna length, $L_\text{eff}$ of the E-field probes. We then use the HT method to estimate the speed of the solar wind. Using the HT method, we find that the observed variations in $E_y$ are often in excellent agreement with the variations in the magnetic field. The magnitude of $E_y$, however, is uncertain due to the fact that the $L_\text{eff}$ depends on the plasma environment. We derive an empirical model relating $L_\text{eff}$ to the Debye length, which we can use to improve the estimate of $E_y$ and consequently the estimated solar wind speed. The low frequency electric field provided by RPW is of high quality. Using deHoffmann-Teller analysis, Solar Orbiter's magnetic and electric field measurements can be used to estimate the solar wind speed when plasma data is unavailable.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Density Fluctuations Associated with Turbulence and Waves: First Observations by Solar Orbiter
Authors:
Yu. V. Khotyaintsev,
D. B. Graham,
A. Vaivads,
K. Steinvall,
N. J. T. Edberg,
A. I. Eriksson,
E. P. G. Johansson,
L. Sorriso-Valvo,
M. Maksimovic,
S. D. Bale,
T. Chust,
V. Krasnoselskikh,
M. Kretzschmar,
E. Lorfèvre,
D. Plettemeier,
J. Souček,
M. Steller,
Š. Štverák,
P. Trávníček,
A. Vecchio,
T. S. Horbury,
H. O'Brien,
V. Evans,
V. Angelini
Abstract:
We use the plasma density based on measurements of the probe-to-spacecraft potential in combination with magnetic field measurements by MAG to study fields and density fluctuations in the solar wind observed by Solar Orbiter during the first perihelion encounter ($\sim$0.5~AU away from the Sun). In particular we use the polarization of the wave magnetic field, the phase between the compressible ma…
▽ More
We use the plasma density based on measurements of the probe-to-spacecraft potential in combination with magnetic field measurements by MAG to study fields and density fluctuations in the solar wind observed by Solar Orbiter during the first perihelion encounter ($\sim$0.5~AU away from the Sun). In particular we use the polarization of the wave magnetic field, the phase between the compressible magnetic field and density fluctuations and the compressibility ratio (the ratio of the normalized density fluctuations to the normalized compressible fluctuations of B) to characterize the observed waves and turbulence. We find that the density fluctuations are out-of-phase with the compressible component of magnetic fluctuations for intervals of turbulence, while they are in phase for the circular-polarized waves around the proton cyclotron frequency. We analyze in detail two specific events with simultaneous presence of left- and right-handed waves at different frequencies. We compare observed wave properties to a prediction of the three-fluid (electrons, protons and alphas) model. We find a limit on the observed wavenumbers, $10^{-6} < k < 7 \times 10^{-6}$~m$^{-1}$, which corresponds to wavelength $7 \times 10^6 >λ> 10^6$~m. We conclude that most likely both the left- and right-handed waves correspond to the low-wavenumber part (close to the cut-off at $Ω_{c\mathrm{He}++}$) proton-band electromagnetic ion cyclotron (left-handed wave in the plasma frame confined to the frequency range $Ω_{c\mathrm{He}++} < ω< Ω_{c\mathrm{H}+}$) waves propagating in the outwards and inwards directions respectively. The fact that both wave polarizations are observed at the same time and the identified wave mode has a low group velocity suggests that the double-banded events occur in the source regions of the waves.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2021; v1 submitted 31 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Whistler Waves in the foot of Quasi-Perpendicular Super-Critical Shocks
Authors:
Ahmad Lalti,
Yuri Khotyaintsev,
Daniel B. Graham,
Andris Vaivads,
Konrad Steinvall,
Christopher T. Russell
Abstract:
Whistler waves are thought to play an essential role in the dynamics of collisionless shocks. We use the magnetospheric multiscale (MMS) spacecraft to study whistler waves around the lower hybrid frequency, upstream of 11 quasi-perpendicular super-critical shocks. We apply the 4-spacecraft timing method to unambiguously determine the wave vector $\mathbf{k}$ of whistler waves. We find that the wav…
▽ More
Whistler waves are thought to play an essential role in the dynamics of collisionless shocks. We use the magnetospheric multiscale (MMS) spacecraft to study whistler waves around the lower hybrid frequency, upstream of 11 quasi-perpendicular super-critical shocks. We apply the 4-spacecraft timing method to unambiguously determine the wave vector $\mathbf{k}$ of whistler waves. We find that the waves are oblique to the background magnetic field with a wave-normal angle between $20^{\circ}$ and $42^{\circ}$, a wavelength around 100 km which is close to the ion inertial length. We also find that $\mathbf{k}$ is predominantly in the same plane as the magnetic field and the normal to the shock. By combining this precise knowledge of $\mathbf{k}$ with high-resolution measurements of the 3D ion velocity distribution we show that a reflected ion beam is in resonance with the waves, opening up the possibility for wave-particle interaction between the reflected ions and the observed whistlers. The linear stability analysis of a system mimicking the observed distribution, suggests that such a system can produce the observed waves.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2021; v1 submitted 20 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Observations of Electromagnetic Electron Holes and Evidence of Cherenkov Whistler Emission
Authors:
Konrad Steinvall,
Yuri V. Khotyaintsev,
Daniel B. Graham,
Andris Vaivads,
Olivier Le Contel,
Christopher T. Russell
Abstract:
We report observations of electromagnetic electron holes (EHs). We use multi-spacecraft analysis to quantify the magnetic field contributions of three mechanisms: the Lorentz transform, electron drift within the EH, and Cherenkov emission of whistler waves. The first two mechanisms account for the observed magnetic fields for slower EHs, while for EHs with speeds approaching half the electron Alfv…
▽ More
We report observations of electromagnetic electron holes (EHs). We use multi-spacecraft analysis to quantify the magnetic field contributions of three mechanisms: the Lorentz transform, electron drift within the EH, and Cherenkov emission of whistler waves. The first two mechanisms account for the observed magnetic fields for slower EHs, while for EHs with speeds approaching half the electron Alfvén speed, whistler waves excited via the Cherenkov mechanism dominate the perpendicular magnetic field. The excited whistlers are kinetically damped and typically confined within the EHs.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2020; v1 submitted 29 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Electron acceleration and thermalization at magnetotail separatrices
Authors:
C. Norgren,
M. Hesse,
P. Tenfjord,
D. B. Graham,
Yu. V. Khotyaintsev,
A. Vaivads,
K. Steinvall,
Y. Xu,
D. J. Gershman,
P. -A. Lindqvist,
J. L. Burch
Abstract:
In this study we use the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission to investigate the electron acceleration and thermalization occurring along the magnetic reconnection separatrices in the magnetotail. We find that initially cold electron lobe populations are accelerated towards the X line forming beams with energies up to a few keV's, corresponding to a substantial fraction of the electron thermal…
▽ More
In this study we use the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission to investigate the electron acceleration and thermalization occurring along the magnetic reconnection separatrices in the magnetotail. We find that initially cold electron lobe populations are accelerated towards the X line forming beams with energies up to a few keV's, corresponding to a substantial fraction of the electron thermal energy inside the exhaust. The accelerated electron populations are unstable to the formation of electrostatic waves which develop into nonlinear electrostatic solitary waves. The waves' amplitudes are large enough to interact efficiently with a large part of the electron population, including the electron beam. The wave-particle interaction gradually thermalizes the beam, transforming directed drift energy to thermal energy.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Electron Heating by Debye-Scale Turbulence in Guide-Field Reconnection
Authors:
Yu. V. Khotyaintsev,
D. B. Graham,
K. Steinvall,
L. Alm,
A. Vaivads,
A. Johlander,
C. Norgren,
W. Li,
A. Divin,
H. S. Fu,
K. -J. Hwang,
N. Ahmadi,
O. Le Contel,
D. J. Gershman,
C. T. Russell,
R. B. Torbert,
J. L. Burch
Abstract:
We report electrostatic Debye-scale turbulence develo** within the diffusion region of asymmetric magnetopause reconnection with moderate guide field using observations by the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission. We show that Buneman waves and beam modes cause efficient and fast thermalization of the reconnection electron jet by irreversible phase mixing, during which the jet kinetic energy…
▽ More
We report electrostatic Debye-scale turbulence develo** within the diffusion region of asymmetric magnetopause reconnection with moderate guide field using observations by the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission. We show that Buneman waves and beam modes cause efficient and fast thermalization of the reconnection electron jet by irreversible phase mixing, during which the jet kinetic energy is transferred into thermal energy. Our results show that the reconnection diffusion region in the presence of a moderate guide field is highly turbulent, and that electrostatic turbulence plays an important role in electron heating.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2019; v1 submitted 26 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.