-
Cluster deep loci and mirror symmetry
Authors:
Marco Castronovo,
Mikhail Gorsky,
José Simental,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Affine cluster varieties are covered up to codimension 2 by open algebraic tori. We put forth a general conjecture (based on earlier conversation between Vivek Shende and the last author) characterizing their deep locus, i.e. the complement of all cluster charts, as the locus of points with non-trivial stabilizer under the action of cluster automorphisms. We use the diagrammatics of Demazure weave…
▽ More
Affine cluster varieties are covered up to codimension 2 by open algebraic tori. We put forth a general conjecture (based on earlier conversation between Vivek Shende and the last author) characterizing their deep locus, i.e. the complement of all cluster charts, as the locus of points with non-trivial stabilizer under the action of cluster automorphisms. We use the diagrammatics of Demazure weaves to verify the conjecture for skew-symmetric cluster varieties of finite cluster type with arbitrary choice of frozens and for the top open positroid strata of Grassmannians $\mathrm{Gr}(2,n)$ and $\mathrm{Gr}(3,n)$. We illustrate how this already has applications in symplectic topology and mirror symmetry, by proving that the Fukaya category of Grassmannians $\mathrm{Gr}(2,2n+1)$ is split-generated by finitely many Lagrangian tori, and homological mirror symmetry holds with a Landau--Ginzburg model proposed by Rietsch. Finally, we study the geometry of the deep locus, and find that it can be singular and have several irreducible components of different dimensions, but they all are again cluster varieties in our examples in really full rank cases.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024; v1 submitted 26 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Affine extended weak order is a lattice
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Coxeter groups are equipped with a partial order known as the weak Bruhat order, such that $u \leq v$ if the inversions of $u$ are a subset of the inversions of $v$. In finite Coxeter groups, weak order is a complete lattice, but in infinite Coxeter groups it is only a meet semi-lattice. Motivated by questions in Kazhdan-Lusztig theory, Matthew Dyer introduced a larger poset, now known as extended…
▽ More
Coxeter groups are equipped with a partial order known as the weak Bruhat order, such that $u \leq v$ if the inversions of $u$ are a subset of the inversions of $v$. In finite Coxeter groups, weak order is a complete lattice, but in infinite Coxeter groups it is only a meet semi-lattice. Motivated by questions in Kazhdan-Lusztig theory, Matthew Dyer introduced a larger poset, now known as extended weak order, which contains the weak Bruhat order as an order ideal and coincides with it for finite Coxeter groups. The extended weak order is the containment order on certain sets of positive roots: those which satisfy a geometric condition making them "biclosed". The finite biclosed sets are precisely the inversion sets of Coxeter group elements. Generalizing the result for finite Coxeter groups, Dyer conjectured that the extended weak order is always a complete lattice, even for infinite Coxeter groups.
In this paper, we prove Dyer's conjecture for Coxeter groups of affine type. To do so, we introduce the notion of a clean arrangement, which is a hyperplane arrangement where the regions are in bijection with biclosed sets. We show that root poset order ideals in a finite or rank 3 untwisted affine root system are clean. We set up a general framework for reducing Dyer's conjecture to checking cleanliness of certain subarrangements. We conjecture this framework can be used to prove Dyer's conjecture for all Coxeter groups.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024; v1 submitted 9 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Shard modules
Authors:
Will Dana,
David E Speyer,
Hugh Thomas
Abstract:
Motivated by the goal of studying cluster algebras in infinite type, we study the stability domains of modules for the preprojective algebra in the corresponding infinite types. Specifically, we study real bricks: those modules whose endomorphism algebra is a division ring and which have no self-extensions. We define "shard modules" to be those real bricks whose stability domain is as large as pos…
▽ More
Motivated by the goal of studying cluster algebras in infinite type, we study the stability domains of modules for the preprojective algebra in the corresponding infinite types. Specifically, we study real bricks: those modules whose endomorphism algebra is a division ring and which have no self-extensions. We define "shard modules" to be those real bricks whose stability domain is as large as possible (meaning, of dimension one less than the rank of the preprojective algebra). We show that all real bricks are obtained by applying the Baumann-Kamnitzer reflection functors to simple modules, and we give a recursive formula for the stability domain of a real brick. We show that shard modules are in bijection with Nathan Reading's "shards", and that their stability domains are the shards; we also establish many foundational results about shards in infinite type which have not previously appeared in print. With an eye toward applications to cluster algebras, our paper is written to handle skew-symmetrizable as well as skew-symmetric exchange matrices, and we therefore discuss the basics of the theory of species for preprojective algebras. We also give some counterexamples to show ways in which infinite type is more subtle than the well-studied finite type cases.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Richardson varieties, projected Richardson varieties and positroid varieties
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
This is a survey article on Richardson varieties and their combinatorics. A Richardson variety is the intersection, inside the flag manifold GL_n/B_+, of a Schubert cell (B_- u B_+)/B_+ and an opposite Schubert cell (B_+ w B_+)/B_+ (or the similar intersection of Schubert varieties). In this survey, we provide an overview of what is known about (1) homogeneous coordinate rings of Richardson variet…
▽ More
This is a survey article on Richardson varieties and their combinatorics. A Richardson variety is the intersection, inside the flag manifold GL_n/B_+, of a Schubert cell (B_- u B_+)/B_+ and an opposite Schubert cell (B_+ w B_+)/B_+ (or the similar intersection of Schubert varieties). In this survey, we provide an overview of what is known about (1) homogeneous coordinate rings of Richardson varieties, their bases and degenerations (2) parametrizations of Richardson varieties using Bott-Samelson varieties (3) Deodhar's decompositions of the flag manifold and of Richardson varieties within it and (4) total positivity in the flag manifold. We also provide an overview of the combinatorics of positroid varieties, their relations to Richardson varieties, and how they are parametrized using plabic graphs. Most of this survey is an overview of other author's work over the last forty years, but there are also some minor original results: For example, that coordinate rings of open Richardson varieties are UFD's (Corollary 3.23), that the Deodhar decomposition is not a stratification in Lie type A (Section 4.3) and explicit descriptions of the Deodhar decomposition in terms of ranks of submatrices (Section 4.4).
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2024; v1 submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Combinatorial descriptions of biclosed sets in affine type
Authors:
Grant T. Barkley,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Let $W$ be a Coxeter group and let $Φ^+$ be its positive roots. A subset $B$ of $Φ^+$ is called biclosed if, whenever we have roots $α$, $β$ and $γ$ with $γ\in \mathbb{R}_{>0} α+ \mathbb{R}_{>0} β$, if $α$ and $β\in B$ then $γ\in B$ and, if $α$ and $β\not\in B$, then $γ\not\in B$. The finite biclosed sets are the inversion sets of the elements of $W$, and the containment between finite inversion s…
▽ More
Let $W$ be a Coxeter group and let $Φ^+$ be its positive roots. A subset $B$ of $Φ^+$ is called biclosed if, whenever we have roots $α$, $β$ and $γ$ with $γ\in \mathbb{R}_{>0} α+ \mathbb{R}_{>0} β$, if $α$ and $β\in B$ then $γ\in B$ and, if $α$ and $β\not\in B$, then $γ\not\in B$. The finite biclosed sets are the inversion sets of the elements of $W$, and the containment between finite inversion sets is the weak order on $W$. Matthew Dyer suggested studying the poset of all biclosed subsets of $Φ^+$, ordered by containment, and conjectured that it is a complete lattice. As progress towards Dyer's conjecture, we classify all biclosed sets in the affine root systems. We provide both a type uniform description, and concrete models in the classical types $\widetilde{A}$, $\widetilde{B}$, $\widetilde{C}$, $\widetilde{D}$. We use our models to prove that biclosed sets form a complete lattice in types $\widetilde{A}$ and $\widetilde{C}$.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024; v1 submitted 13 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Cohomology of cluster varieties. II. Acyclic case
Authors:
Thomas Lam,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
In previous work, we initiated the study of the cohomology of locally acyclic cluster varieties. In the present work, we show that the mixed Hodge structure and point counts of acyclic cluster varieties are essentially determined by the combinatorics of the independent sets of the quiver. We use this to show that the mixed Hodge numbers of acyclic cluster varieties of really full rank satisfy a st…
▽ More
In previous work, we initiated the study of the cohomology of locally acyclic cluster varieties. In the present work, we show that the mixed Hodge structure and point counts of acyclic cluster varieties are essentially determined by the combinatorics of the independent sets of the quiver. We use this to show that the mixed Hodge numbers of acyclic cluster varieties of really full rank satisfy a strong vanishing condition.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Castelnuovo-Mumford regularity of matrix Schubert varieties
Authors:
Oliver Pechenik,
David E Speyer,
Anna Weigandt
Abstract:
Matrix Schubert varieties are affine varieties arising in the Schubert calculus of the complete flag variety. We give a formula for the Castelnuovo-Mumford regularity of matrix Schubert varieties, answering a question of Jenna Rajchgot. We follow her proposed strategy of studying the highest-degree homogeneous parts of Grothendieck polynomials, which we call Castelnuovo-Mumford polynomials. In add…
▽ More
Matrix Schubert varieties are affine varieties arising in the Schubert calculus of the complete flag variety. We give a formula for the Castelnuovo-Mumford regularity of matrix Schubert varieties, answering a question of Jenna Rajchgot. We follow her proposed strategy of studying the highest-degree homogeneous parts of Grothendieck polynomials, which we call Castelnuovo-Mumford polynomials. In addition to the regularity formula, we obtain formulas for the degrees of all Castelnuovo-Mumford polynomials and for their leading terms, as well as a complete description of when two Castelnuovo-Mumford polynomials agree up to scalar multiple. The degree of the Grothendieck polynomial is a new permutation statistic which we call the Rajchgot index; we develop the properties of Rajchgot index and relate it to major index and to weak order.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Electrical networks and Lagrangian Grassmannians
Authors:
Sunita Chepuri,
Terrence George,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Cactus networks were introduced by Lam as a generalization of planar electrical networks. He defined a map from these networks to the Grassmannian Gr($n+1,2n$) and showed that the image of this map, $\mathcal X_n$ lies inside the totally nonnegative part of this Grassmannian. In this paper, we show that $\mathcal X_n$ is exactly the elements of Gr($n+1,2n$) that are both totally nonnegative and is…
▽ More
Cactus networks were introduced by Lam as a generalization of planar electrical networks. He defined a map from these networks to the Grassmannian Gr($n+1,2n$) and showed that the image of this map, $\mathcal X_n$ lies inside the totally nonnegative part of this Grassmannian. In this paper, we show that $\mathcal X_n$ is exactly the elements of Gr($n+1,2n$) that are both totally nonnegative and isotropic for a particular skew-symmetric bilinear form. For certain classes of cactus networks, we also explicitly describe how to turn response matrices and effective resistance matrices into points of Gr($n+1,2n$) given by Lam's map. Finally, we discuss how our work relates to earlier studies of total positivity for Lagrangian Grassmannians.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
The fundamental theorem of finite semidistributive lattices
Authors:
Nathan Reading,
David E Speyer,
Hugh Thomas
Abstract:
We prove a Fundamental Theorem of Finite Semidistributive Lattices (FTFSDL), modelled on Birkhoff's Fundamental Theorem of Finite Distributive Lattices. Our FTFSDL is of the form "A poset L is a finite semidistributive lattice if and only if there exists a set Sha with some additional structure, such that L is isomorphic to the admissible subsets of Sha ordered by inclusion; in this case, Sha and…
▽ More
We prove a Fundamental Theorem of Finite Semidistributive Lattices (FTFSDL), modelled on Birkhoff's Fundamental Theorem of Finite Distributive Lattices. Our FTFSDL is of the form "A poset L is a finite semidistributive lattice if and only if there exists a set Sha with some additional structure, such that L is isomorphic to the admissible subsets of Sha ordered by inclusion; in this case, Sha and its additional structure are uniquely determined by L." The additional structure on Sha is a combinatorial abstraction of the notion of torsion pairs from representation theory and has geometric meaning in the case of posets of regions of hyperplane arrangements. We show how the FTFSDL clarifies many constructions in lattice theory, such as canonical join representations and passing to quotients, and how the semidistributive property interacts with other major classes of lattices. Many of our results also apply to infinite lattices.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Matroids and their Dressians
Authors:
Madeline Brandt,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
We study Dressians of matroids using the initial matroids of Dress and Wenzel. These correspond to cells in regular matroid subdivisions of matroid polytopes. An efficient algorithm for computing Dressians is presented, and its implementation is applied to a range of interesting matroids. We give counterexamples to a few plausible statements about matroid subdivisions.
We study Dressians of matroids using the initial matroids of Dress and Wenzel. These correspond to cells in regular matroid subdivisions of matroid polytopes. An efficient algorithm for computing Dressians is presented, and its implementation is applied to a range of interesting matroids. We give counterexamples to a few plausible statements about matroid subdivisions.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2020; v1 submitted 14 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Proof of a conjecture of Stanley about Stern's array
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Stanley, building on work of Stern, defined an array of numbers by the recurrence $s(n, 2k) = s(n-1, k)$, $s(n, 2k+1) = s(n-1, k) + s(n-1, k+1)$. Stanley showed that, for each positive integer $r$, the sequence $s_n^r:= \sum_k s(n,k)^r$ obeys a homogeneous linear recurrence in $n$ of length $r/2+O(1)$. Numerical evidence, however, suggested that $s_n^r$ obeys shorter recurrences, of length…
▽ More
Stanley, building on work of Stern, defined an array of numbers by the recurrence $s(n, 2k) = s(n-1, k)$, $s(n, 2k+1) = s(n-1, k) + s(n-1, k+1)$. Stanley showed that, for each positive integer $r$, the sequence $s_n^r:= \sum_k s(n,k)^r$ obeys a homogeneous linear recurrence in $n$ of length $r/2+O(1)$. Numerical evidence, however, suggested that $s_n^r$ obeys shorter recurrences, of length $r/3+O(1)$. We prove Stanley's conjecture.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Derivatives of Schubert polynomials and proof of a determinant conjecture of Stanley
Authors:
Zachary Hamaker,
Oliver Pechenik,
David E Speyer,
Anna Weigandt
Abstract:
We study the action of a differential operator on Schubert polynomials. Using this action, we first give a short new proof of an identity of I. Macdonald (1991). We then prove a determinant conjecture of R. Stanley (2017). This conjecture implies the (strong) Sperner property for the weak order on the symmetric group, a property recently established by C. Gaetz and Y. Gao (2018).
We study the action of a differential operator on Schubert polynomials. Using this action, we first give a short new proof of an identity of I. Macdonald (1991). We then prove a determinant conjecture of R. Stanley (2017). This conjecture implies the (strong) Sperner property for the weak order on the symmetric group, a property recently established by C. Gaetz and Y. Gao (2018).
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Specht modules decompose as alternating sums of restrictions of Schur modules
Authors:
Sami H. Assaf,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
Schur modules give the irreducible polynomial representations of the general linear group $\mathrm{GL}_t$. Viewing the symmetric group $\mathfrak{S}_t$ as a subgroup of $\mathrm{GL}_t$, we may restrict Schur modules to $\mathfrak{S}_t$ and decompose the result into a direct sum of Specht modules, the irreducible representations of $\mathfrak{S}_t$. We give an equivariant Möbius inversion formula t…
▽ More
Schur modules give the irreducible polynomial representations of the general linear group $\mathrm{GL}_t$. Viewing the symmetric group $\mathfrak{S}_t$ as a subgroup of $\mathrm{GL}_t$, we may restrict Schur modules to $\mathfrak{S}_t$ and decompose the result into a direct sum of Specht modules, the irreducible representations of $\mathfrak{S}_t$. We give an equivariant Möbius inversion formula that we use to invert this expansion in the representation ring for $\mathfrak{S}_t$ for $t$ large. In addition to explicit formulas in terms of plethysms, we show the coefficients that appear alternate in sign by degree. In particular, this allows us to define a new basis of symmetric functions whose structure constants are stable Kronecker coefficients and which expand with alternating signs into the Schur basis.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
A Gröbner basis for the graph of the reciprocal plane
Authors:
Alex Fink,
David E Speyer,
Alexander Woo
Abstract:
Given the complement of a hyperplane arrangement, let $Γ$ be the closure of the graph of the map inverting each of its defining linear forms. The characteristic polynomial manifests itself in the Hilbert series of $Γ$ in two different-seeming ways, one due to Orlik and Terao and the other to Huh and Katz. We define an extension of the no broken circuit complex of a matroid and use it to give a dir…
▽ More
Given the complement of a hyperplane arrangement, let $Γ$ be the closure of the graph of the map inverting each of its defining linear forms. The characteristic polynomial manifests itself in the Hilbert series of $Γ$ in two different-seeming ways, one due to Orlik and Terao and the other to Huh and Katz. We define an extension of the no broken circuit complex of a matroid and use it to give a direct Gröbner basis argument that the polynomials extracted from the Hilbert series in these two ways agree.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Frobenius split subvarieties pull back in almost all characteristics
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Let $X$ and $Y$ be schemes of finite type over $\mathrm{Spec}\ \mathbb{Z}$ and let $α: Y \to X$ be a finite map. We show the following holds for all sufficiently large primes $p$: If $φ$ and $ψ$ are any splittings on $X \times \mathrm{Spec}\ F_p$ and $Y \times \mathrm{Spec}\ F_p$, such that the restriction of $α$ is compatible with $φ$ and $ψ$, and $V$ is any compatibly split subvariety of…
▽ More
Let $X$ and $Y$ be schemes of finite type over $\mathrm{Spec}\ \mathbb{Z}$ and let $α: Y \to X$ be a finite map. We show the following holds for all sufficiently large primes $p$: If $φ$ and $ψ$ are any splittings on $X \times \mathrm{Spec}\ F_p$ and $Y \times \mathrm{Spec}\ F_p$, such that the restriction of $α$ is compatible with $φ$ and $ψ$, and $V$ is any compatibly split subvariety of $(X \times \mathrm{Spec}\ F_p, φ)$, then the reduction $α^{-1}(V)^{\mathrm{red}}$ is a compatibly split subvariety of $(Y \times \mathrm{Spec}\ F_p, ψ)$. This is meant as a tool to aid in listing the compatibly split subvarieties of various classically split varieties.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Some sums over irreducible polynomials
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
We prove a number of conjectures due to Dinesh Thakur concerning sums of the form $\sum_P h(P)$ where the sum is over monic irreducible polynomials $P$ in $\mathbb{F}_q[T]$, the function $h$ is a rational function and the sum is considered in the $T^{-1}$-adic topology. As an example of our results, in $\mathbb{F}_2[T]$, the sum $\sum_P \tfrac{1}{P^k - 1}$ always converges to a rational function,…
▽ More
We prove a number of conjectures due to Dinesh Thakur concerning sums of the form $\sum_P h(P)$ where the sum is over monic irreducible polynomials $P$ in $\mathbb{F}_q[T]$, the function $h$ is a rational function and the sum is considered in the $T^{-1}$-adic topology. As an example of our results, in $\mathbb{F}_2[T]$, the sum $\sum_P \tfrac{1}{P^k - 1}$ always converges to a rational function, and is $0$ for $k=1$.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
The Growth Rate of Tri-Colored Sum-Free Sets
Authors:
Robert Kleinberg,
Will Sawin,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
Let $G$ be an abelian group. A tri-colored sum-free set in $G^n$ is a collection of triples $({\bf a}_i, {\bf b}_i, {\bf c}_i)$ in $G^n$ such that ${\bf a}_i+{\bf b}_j+{\bf c}_k=0$ if and only if $i=j=k$. Fix a prime $q$ and let $C_q$ be the cyclic group of order $q$. Let $θ= \min_{ρ>0} (1+ρ+\cdots + ρ^{q-1}) ρ^{-(q-1)/3}$. Blasiak, Church, Cohn, Grochow, Naslund, Sawin, and Umans (building on pre…
▽ More
Let $G$ be an abelian group. A tri-colored sum-free set in $G^n$ is a collection of triples $({\bf a}_i, {\bf b}_i, {\bf c}_i)$ in $G^n$ such that ${\bf a}_i+{\bf b}_j+{\bf c}_k=0$ if and only if $i=j=k$. Fix a prime $q$ and let $C_q$ be the cyclic group of order $q$. Let $θ= \min_{ρ>0} (1+ρ+\cdots + ρ^{q-1}) ρ^{-(q-1)/3}$. Blasiak, Church, Cohn, Grochow, Naslund, Sawin, and Umans (building on previous work of Croot, Lev and Pach, and of Ellenberg and Gijswijt) showed that a tri-colored sum-free set in $C_q^n$ has size at most $3 θ^n$. Between this paper and a paper of Pebody, we will show that, for any $δ> 0$, and $n$ sufficiently large, there are tri-colored sum-free sets in $C_q^n$ of size $(θ-δ)^n$. Our construction also works when $q$ is not prime.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2018; v1 submitted 30 June, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
The twist for positroid varieties
Authors:
Greg Muller,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
The purpose of this note is to connect two maps related to certain graphs embedded in the disc. The first is Postnikov's boundary measurement map, which combines partition functions of matchings in the graph into a map from an algebraic torus to an open positroid variety in a Grassmannian. The second is a rational map from the open positroid variety to an algebraic torus, given by certain Plücker…
▽ More
The purpose of this note is to connect two maps related to certain graphs embedded in the disc. The first is Postnikov's boundary measurement map, which combines partition functions of matchings in the graph into a map from an algebraic torus to an open positroid variety in a Grassmannian. The second is a rational map from the open positroid variety to an algebraic torus, given by certain Plücker coordinates which are expected to be a cluster in a cluster structure.
This paper clarifies the relationship between these two maps, which has been ambiguous since they were introduced by Postnikov in 2001. The missing ingredient supplied by this paper is a twist automorphism of the open positroid variety, which takes the target of the boundary measurement map to the domain of the (conjectural) cluster. Among other applications, this provides an inverse to the boundary measurement map, as well as Laurent formulas for twists of Plücker coordinates.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Cohomology of cluster varieties. I. Locally acyclic case
Authors:
Thomas Lam,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
We initiate a systematic study of the cohomology of cluster varieties. We introduce the Louise property for cluster algebras that holds for all acyclic cluster algebras, and for most cluster algebras arising from marked surfaces. For cluster varieties satisfying the Louise property and of full rank, we show that the cohomology satisfies the curious Lefschetz property of Hausel and Rodriguez-Villeg…
▽ More
We initiate a systematic study of the cohomology of cluster varieties. We introduce the Louise property for cluster algebras that holds for all acyclic cluster algebras, and for most cluster algebras arising from marked surfaces. For cluster varieties satisfying the Louise property and of full rank, we show that the cohomology satisfies the curious Lefschetz property of Hausel and Rodriguez-Villegas, and that the mixed Hodge structure is split over the rationals. We give a complete description of the highest weight part of the mixed Hodge structure of these cluster varieties, and develop the notion of a standard differential form on a cluster variety. We show that the point counts of these cluster varieties over finite fields can be expressed in terms of Dirichlet characters. Under an additional integrality hypothesis, the point counts are shown to be polynomials in the order of the finite field.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2021; v1 submitted 22 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Variations on a theme of Kasteleyn, with application to the totally nonnegative Grassmannian
Authors:
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
We provide a short proof of a classical result of Kasteleyn, and prove several variants thereof. One of these results has become key in the parametrization of positroid varieties, and thus deserves the short direct proof which we provide.
We provide a short proof of a classical result of Kasteleyn, and prove several variants thereof. One of these results has become key in the parametrization of positroid varieties, and thus deserves the short direct proof which we provide.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
A Cambrian framework for the oriented cycle
Authors:
Nathan Reading,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
This paper completes the project of constructing combinatorial models (called frameworks) for the exchange graph and g-vector fan associated to any exchange matrix B whose Cartan companion is of finite or affine type, using the combinatorics and geometry of Coxeter-sortable elements and Cambrian lattices/fans. Specifically, we construct a framework in the unique non-acyclic affine case, the cyclic…
▽ More
This paper completes the project of constructing combinatorial models (called frameworks) for the exchange graph and g-vector fan associated to any exchange matrix B whose Cartan companion is of finite or affine type, using the combinatorics and geometry of Coxeter-sortable elements and Cambrian lattices/fans. Specifically, we construct a framework in the unique non-acyclic affine case, the cyclically oriented n-cycle. In the acyclic affine case, a framework was constructed by combining a copy of the Cambrian fan for B with an antipodal copy of the Cambrian fan for -B. In this paper, we extend this "doubled Cambrian fan" construction to the oriented n-cycle, using a more general notion of sortable elements for quivers with cycles.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Computing Hermitian determinantal representations of hyperbolic curves
Authors:
Daniel Plaumann,
Rainer Sinn,
David E. Speyer,
Cynthia Vinzant
Abstract:
Every real hyperbolic form in three variables can be realized as the determinant of a linear net of Hermitian matrices containing a positive definite matrix. Such representations are an algebraic certificate for the hyperbolicity of the polynomial and their existence has been proved in several different ways. However, the resulting algorithms for computing determinantal representations are computa…
▽ More
Every real hyperbolic form in three variables can be realized as the determinant of a linear net of Hermitian matrices containing a positive definite matrix. Such representations are an algebraic certificate for the hyperbolicity of the polynomial and their existence has been proved in several different ways. However, the resulting algorithms for computing determinantal representations are computationally intensive. In this note, we present an algorithm that reduces a large part of the problem to linear algebra and discuss its numerical implementation.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Cambrian frameworks for cluster algebras of affine type
Authors:
Nathan Reading,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
We give a combinatorial model for the exchange graph and g-vector fan associated to any acyclic exchange matrix B of affine type. More specifically, we construct a reflection framework for B in the sense of [N. Reading and D. E. Speyer, "Combinatorial frameworks for cluster algebras"] and establish good properties of this framework. The framework (and in particular the g-vector fan) is constructed…
▽ More
We give a combinatorial model for the exchange graph and g-vector fan associated to any acyclic exchange matrix B of affine type. More specifically, we construct a reflection framework for B in the sense of [N. Reading and D. E. Speyer, "Combinatorial frameworks for cluster algebras"] and establish good properties of this framework. The framework (and in particular the g-vector fan) is constructed by combining a copy of the Cambrian fan for B with an antipodal copy of the Cambrian fan for -B.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2017; v1 submitted 1 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Grassmannians for scattering amplitudes in 4d $\mathcal{N}=4$ SYM and 3d ABJM
Authors:
Henriette Elvang,
Yu-tin Huang,
Cynthia Keeler,
Thomas Lam,
Timothy M. Olson,
Samuel B. Roland,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
Scattering amplitudes in 4d $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang-Mills theory (SYM) can be described by Grassmannian contour integrals whose form depends on whether the external data is encoded in momentum space, twistor space, or momentum twistor space. After a pedagogical review, we present a new, streamlined proof of the equivalence of the three integral formulations. A similar strategy allows us to deri…
▽ More
Scattering amplitudes in 4d $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang-Mills theory (SYM) can be described by Grassmannian contour integrals whose form depends on whether the external data is encoded in momentum space, twistor space, or momentum twistor space. After a pedagogical review, we present a new, streamlined proof of the equivalence of the three integral formulations. A similar strategy allows us to derive a new Grassmannian integral for 3d $\mathcal{N}=6$ ABJM theory amplitudes in momentum twistor space: it is a contour integral in an orthogonal Grassmannian with the novel property that the internal metric depends on the external data. The result can be viewed as a central step towards develo** an amplituhedron formulation for ABJM amplitudes. Various properties of Grassmannian integrals are examined, including boundary properties, pole structure, and a homological interpretation of the global residue theorems for $\mathcal{N}=4$ SYM.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Links in the complex of weakly separated collections
Authors:
SuHo Oh,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Plabic graphs are interesting combinatorial objects used to study the totally nonnegative Grassmannian. Faces of plabic graphs are labeled by $k$-element sets of positive integers, and a collection of such $k$-element sets are the face labels of a plabic graph if that collection forms a maximal weakly separated collection. There are moves that one can apply to plabic graphs, and thus to maximal we…
▽ More
Plabic graphs are interesting combinatorial objects used to study the totally nonnegative Grassmannian. Faces of plabic graphs are labeled by $k$-element sets of positive integers, and a collection of such $k$-element sets are the face labels of a plabic graph if that collection forms a maximal weakly separated collection. There are moves that one can apply to plabic graphs, and thus to maximal weakly separated collections, analogous to mutations of seeds in cluster algebras. In this short note, we show that if two maximal weakly separated collections can be mutated from one to another, then one can do so while freezing the face labels they have in common.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Cluster Algebras of Grassmannians are Locally Acyclic
Authors:
Greg Muller,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
Considered as commutative algebras, cluster algebras can be very unpleasant objects. However, the first author introduced a condition known as "local acyclicity" which implies that cluster algebras behave reasonably. One of the earliest and most fundamental examples of a cluster algebra is the homogenous coordinate ring of the Grassmannian. We show that the Grassmannian is locally acyclic. Morally…
▽ More
Considered as commutative algebras, cluster algebras can be very unpleasant objects. However, the first author introduced a condition known as "local acyclicity" which implies that cluster algebras behave reasonably. One of the earliest and most fundamental examples of a cluster algebra is the homogenous coordinate ring of the Grassmannian. We show that the Grassmannian is locally acyclic. Morally, we are in fact showing the stronger result that all positroid varieties are locally acyclic. However, it has not been shown that all positroid varieties have cluster structure, so what we actually prove is that certain cluster varieties associated to Postnikov's alternating strand diagrams are locally acylic. Moreover, we actually establish a slightly stronger property than local acyclicity, which we term the Louise property, that is designed to facilitate proofs involving the Mayer-Vietores sequence.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2015; v1 submitted 20 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
An Infinitely Generated Upper Cluster Algebra
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
We show that upper cluster algebras need not be finitely generated, answering a question of Berenstein, Fomin and Zelevinsky. Our counter-example is a cluster algebra with B-matrix $\begin{pmatrix} 0 & 3 & -3 \\ -3 & 0 & 3 \\ 3 & -3 & 0 \end{pmatrix}$ and coefficients obeying a genericity condition.
We show that upper cluster algebras need not be finitely generated, answering a question of Berenstein, Fomin and Zelevinsky. Our counter-example is a cluster algebra with B-matrix $\begin{pmatrix} 0 & 3 & -3 \\ -3 & 0 & 3 \\ 3 & -3 & 0 \end{pmatrix}$ and coefficients obeying a genericity condition.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Schubert problems with respect to osculating flags of stable rational curves
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Given a point z in P^1, let F(z) be the osculating flag to the rational normal curve at point z. The study of Schubert problems with respect to such flags F(z_1), F(z_2), ..., F(z_r) has been studied both classically and recently, especially when the points z_i are real. Since the rational normal curve has an action of PGL_2, it is natural to consider the points (z_1, ..., z_r) as living in the mo…
▽ More
Given a point z in P^1, let F(z) be the osculating flag to the rational normal curve at point z. The study of Schubert problems with respect to such flags F(z_1), F(z_2), ..., F(z_r) has been studied both classically and recently, especially when the points z_i are real. Since the rational normal curve has an action of PGL_2, it is natural to consider the points (z_1, ..., z_r) as living in the moduli space of r distinct point in P^1 -- the famous M_{0,r}. One can then ask to extend the results on Schubert intersections to the compactification \bar{M}_{0,r}.
The first part of this paper achieves this goal. We construct a flat, Cohen-Macaulay family over \bar{M}_{0,r}, whose fibers over M_{0,r} are isomorphic to G(d,n) and, given partitions lambda_1, ..., lambda_r, we construct a flat Cohen-Macualay family over \bar{M}_{0,r} whose fiber over (z_1, ..., z_r) in M_{0,r} is the intersection of the Schubert varieties indexed by lambda_i with respect to the osculating flags F(z_i).
In the second part of the paper, we investigate the topology of the real points of our family, in the case that sum |lambda_i| = dim G(d,n). We show that our family is a finite covering space of \bar{M}_{0,r}, and give an explicit CW decomposition of this cover whose faces are indexed by objects from the theory of Young tableaux.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2012;
originally announced September 2012.
-
Combinatorial frameworks for cluster algebras
Authors:
Nathan Reading,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
We develop a general approach to finding combinatorial models for cluster algebras. The approach is to construct a labeled graph called a framework. When a framework is constructed with certain properties, the result is a model incorporating information about exchange matrices, principal coefficients, g-vectors, and g-vector fans. The idea behind frameworks arises from Cambrian combinatorics and s…
▽ More
We develop a general approach to finding combinatorial models for cluster algebras. The approach is to construct a labeled graph called a framework. When a framework is constructed with certain properties, the result is a model incorporating information about exchange matrices, principal coefficients, g-vectors, and g-vector fans. The idea behind frameworks arises from Cambrian combinatorics and sortable elements, and in this paper, we use sortable elements to construct a framework for any cluster algebra with an acyclic initial exchange matrix. This Cambrian framework yields a model of the entire exchange graph when the cluster algebra is of finite type. Outside of finite type, the Cambrian framework models only part of the exchange graph. In a forthcoming paper, we extend the Cambrian construction to produce a complete framework for a cluster algebra whose associated Cartan matrix is of affine type.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2014; v1 submitted 10 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Weak Separation and Plabic Graphs
Authors:
Suho Oh,
Alex Postnikov,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Leclerc and Zelevinsky described quasicommuting families of quantum minors in terms of a certain combinatorial condition, called weak separation. They conjectured that all maximal by inclusion weakly separated collections of minors have the same cardinality, and that they can be related to each other by a sequence of mutations.
On the other hand, Postnikov studied total positivity on the Grassma…
▽ More
Leclerc and Zelevinsky described quasicommuting families of quantum minors in terms of a certain combinatorial condition, called weak separation. They conjectured that all maximal by inclusion weakly separated collections of minors have the same cardinality, and that they can be related to each other by a sequence of mutations.
On the other hand, Postnikov studied total positivity on the Grassmannian. He described a stratification of the totally nonnegative Grassmannian into positroid strata, and constructed their parametrization using plabic graphs.
In this paper we link the study of weak separation to plabeic graphs. We extend the notion of weak separation to positroids. We generalize the conjectures of Leclerc and Zelevinsky, and related ones of Scott, and prove them. We show that the maximal weakly separated collections in a positroid are in bijective correspondence with the plabic graphs. This correspondence allows us to use the combinatorial techniques of positroids and plabic graphs to prove the (generalized) purity and mutation connectedness conjectures.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
Projections of Richardson Varieties
Authors:
Allen Knutson,
Thomas Lam,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
While the projections of Schubert varieties in a full generalized flag manifold G/B to a partial flag manifold $G/P$ are again Schubert varieties, the projections of Richardson varieties (intersections of Schubert varieties with opposite Schubert varieties) are not always Richardson varieties. The stratification of G/P by projections of Richardson varieties arises in the theory of total positivity…
▽ More
While the projections of Schubert varieties in a full generalized flag manifold G/B to a partial flag manifold $G/P$ are again Schubert varieties, the projections of Richardson varieties (intersections of Schubert varieties with opposite Schubert varieties) are not always Richardson varieties. The stratification of G/P by projections of Richardson varieties arises in the theory of total positivity and also from Poisson and noncommutative geometry.
In this paper we show that many of the geometric properties of Richardson varieties hold more generally for projected Richardson varieties; they are normal, Cohen-Macaulay, have rational singularities, and are compatibly Frobenius split with respect to the standard splitting. Indeed, we show that the projected Richardson varieties are the only compatibly split subvarieties, providing an example of the recent theorem [Schwede, Kumar-Mehta] that a Frobenius split scheme has only finitely many compatibly split subvarieties. (The G/B case was treated by [Hague], whose proof we simplify somewhat.)
One combinatorial analogue of a Richardson variety is the order complex of the corresponding Bruhat interval in W; this complex is known to be an EL-shellable ball [Bjorner-Wachs '82]. We prove that the projection of such a complex into the order complex of the Bruhat order on W/W_P is again a shellable ball. This requires extensive analysis of "P-Bruhat order", a generalization of the k-Bruhat order of [Bergeron-Sottile '98]. In the case that G/P is minuscule (e.g. a Grassmannian), we show that its Grobner degeneration takes each projected Richardson variety to the Stanley-Reisner scheme of its corresponding ball.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2011; v1 submitted 23 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
K-classes of matroids and equivariant localization
Authors:
Alex Fink,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
To every matroid, we associate a class in the K-theory of the Grassmannian. We study this class using the method of equivariant localization. In particular, we provide a geometric interpretation of the Tutte polynomial. We also extend results of the second author concerning the behavior of such classes under direct sum, series and parallel connection and two-sum; these results were previously only…
▽ More
To every matroid, we associate a class in the K-theory of the Grassmannian. We study this class using the method of equivariant localization. In particular, we provide a geometric interpretation of the Tutte polynomial. We also extend results of the second author concerning the behavior of such classes under direct sum, series and parallel connection and two-sum; these results were previously only established for realizable matroids, and their earlier proofs were more difficult.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2010; v1 submitted 14 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
-
Loo** of the numbers game and the alcoved hypercube
Authors:
Qëndrim R. Gashi,
Travis Schedler,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
We study in detail the so-called loo** case of Mozes's game of numbers, which concerns the (finite) orbits in the reflection representation of affine Weyl groups situated on the boundary of the Tits cone. We give a simple proof that all configurations in the orbit are obtainable from each other by playing the numbers game, and give a strategy for going from one configuration to another. The st…
▽ More
We study in detail the so-called loo** case of Mozes's game of numbers, which concerns the (finite) orbits in the reflection representation of affine Weyl groups situated on the boundary of the Tits cone. We give a simple proof that all configurations in the orbit are obtainable from each other by playing the numbers game, and give a strategy for going from one configuration to another. The strategy gives rise to a partition of the finite Weyl group into finitely many graded posets, one for each extending vertex of the associated extended Dynkin diagram. These are selfdual and mutually isomorphic, and dual to the triangulation of the unit hypercube by reflecting hyperplanes, studied by many authors. Unlike the weak and Bruhat orders, the top degree is cubic in the number of vertices of the graph. We explicitly compute the Hilbert polynomial of the poset.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Sortable Elements for Quivers with Cycles
Authors:
Nathan Reading,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Each Coxeter element c of a Coxeter group W defines a subset of W called the c-sortable elements. The choice of a Coxeter element of W is equivalent to the choice of an acyclic orientation of the Coxeter diagram of W. In this paper, we define a more general notion of Omega-sortable elements, where Omega is an arbitrary orientation of the diagram, and show that the key properties of c-sortable elem…
▽ More
Each Coxeter element c of a Coxeter group W defines a subset of W called the c-sortable elements. The choice of a Coxeter element of W is equivalent to the choice of an acyclic orientation of the Coxeter diagram of W. In this paper, we define a more general notion of Omega-sortable elements, where Omega is an arbitrary orientation of the diagram, and show that the key properties of c-sortable elements carry over to the Omega-sortable elements. The proofs of these properties rely on reduction to the acyclic case, but the reductions are nontrivial; in particular, the proofs rely on a subtle combinatorial property of the weak order, as it relates to orientations of the Coxeter diagram. The c-sortable elements are closely tied to the combinatorics of cluster algebras with an acyclic seed; the ultimate motivation behind this paper is to extend this connection beyond the acyclic case.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2011; v1 submitted 16 July, 2009;
originally announced July 2009.
-
Positroid varieties I: juggling and geometry
Authors:
Allen Knutson,
Thomas Lam,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
While the intersection of the Grassmannian Bruhat decompositions for all coordinate flags is an intractable mess, the intersection of only the {\em cyclic shifts} of one Bruhat decomposition turns out to have many of the good properties of the Bruhat and Richardson decompositions. This decomposition coincides with the projection of the Richardson stratification of the flag manifold, studied by L…
▽ More
While the intersection of the Grassmannian Bruhat decompositions for all coordinate flags is an intractable mess, the intersection of only the {\em cyclic shifts} of one Bruhat decomposition turns out to have many of the good properties of the Bruhat and Richardson decompositions. This decomposition coincides with the projection of the Richardson stratification of the flag manifold, studied by Lusztig, Rietsch, and Brown-Goodearl-Yakimov. However, its cyclic-invariance is hidden in this description. Postnikov gave many cyclic-invariant ways to index the strata, and we give a new one, by a subset of the affine Weyl group we call {\em bounded juggling patterns}. We adopt his terminology and call the strata {\em positroid varieties.} We show that positroid varieties are normal and Cohen-Macaulay, and are defined as schemes by the vanishing of Plucker coordinates. We compute their T-equivariant Hilbert series, and show that their associated cohomology classes are represented by affine Stanley functions. This latter fact lets us connect Postnikov's and Buch-Kresch-Tamvakis' approaches to quantum Schubert calculus. Our principal tools are the Frobenius splitting results for Richardson varieties as developed by Brion, Lakshmibai, and Littelmann, and the Hodge-Grobner degeneration of the Grassmannian. We show that each positroid variety degenerates to the projective Stanley-Reisner scheme of a shellable ball.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
A non-crossing standard monomial theory
Authors:
T. Kyle Petersen,
Pavlo Pylyavskyy,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
The second author has introduced non-crossing tableaux, objects whose non-nesting analogues are semi-standard Young tableaux. We relate non-crossing tableaux to Gelfand-Tsetlin patterns and develop the non-crossing analogue of standard monomial theory. Leclerc and Zelevinsky's weakly separated sets are special cases of non-crossing tableaux, and we suggest that non-crossing tableaux may help ill…
▽ More
The second author has introduced non-crossing tableaux, objects whose non-nesting analogues are semi-standard Young tableaux. We relate non-crossing tableaux to Gelfand-Tsetlin patterns and develop the non-crossing analogue of standard monomial theory. Leclerc and Zelevinsky's weakly separated sets are special cases of non-crossing tableaux, and we suggest that non-crossing tableaux may help illuminate the theory of weakly separated sets.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
Sortable elements in infinite Coxeter groups
Authors:
Nathan Reading,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
In a series of previous papers, we studied sortable elements in finite Coxeter groups, and the related Cambrian fans. We applied sortable elements and Cambrian fans to the study of cluster algebras of finite type and the noncrossing partitions associated to Artin groups of finite type. In this paper, as the first step towards expanding these applications beyond finite type, we study sortable ele…
▽ More
In a series of previous papers, we studied sortable elements in finite Coxeter groups, and the related Cambrian fans. We applied sortable elements and Cambrian fans to the study of cluster algebras of finite type and the noncrossing partitions associated to Artin groups of finite type. In this paper, as the first step towards expanding these applications beyond finite type, we study sortable elements in a general Coxeter group W. We supply uniform arguments which transform all previous finite-type proofs into uniform proofs (rather than type by type proofs), generalize many of the finite-type results and prove new and more refined results. The key tools in our proofs include a skew-symmetric form related to (a generalization of) the Euler form of quiver theory and the projection \pidown^c map** each element of W to the unique maximal c-sortable element below it in the weak order. The fibers of \pidown^c essentially define the c-Cambrian fan. The most fundamental results are, first, a precise statement of how sortable elements transform under (BGP) reflection functors and second, a precise description of the fibers of \pidown^c. These fundamental results and others lead to further results on the lattice theory and geometry of Cambrian (semi)lattices and Cambrian fans.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2010; v1 submitted 18 March, 2008;
originally announced March 2008.
-
Uniformizing Tropical Curves I: Genus Zero and One
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
In tropical geometry, given a curve in a toric variety, one defines a corresponding graph embedded in Euclidean space. We study the problem of reversing this process for curves of genus zero and one. Our methods focus on describing curves by parameterizations, not by their defining equations; we give parameterizations by rational functions in the genus zero case and by non-archimedean elliptic f…
▽ More
In tropical geometry, given a curve in a toric variety, one defines a corresponding graph embedded in Euclidean space. We study the problem of reversing this process for curves of genus zero and one. Our methods focus on describing curves by parameterizations, not by their defining equations; we give parameterizations by rational functions in the genus zero case and by non-archimedean elliptic functions in the genus one case. For genus zero curves, those graphs which can be lifted can be characterized in a completely combinatorial manner. For genus one curves, show that certain conditions identified by Mikhalkin are sufficient and we also identify a new necessary condition.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Powers of Coxeter elements in infinite groups are reduced
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Let W be an infinite irreducible Coxeter group with (s_1, ..., s_n) the simple generators. We give a simple proof that the word s_1 s_2 ... s_n s_1 s_2 >... s_n ... s_1 s_2 ... s_n is reduced for any number of repetitions of s_1 s_2 >... s_n. This result was proved for simply-laced, crystallographic groups by Kleiner and Pelley using methods from the theory of quiver representations. Our proof o…
▽ More
Let W be an infinite irreducible Coxeter group with (s_1, ..., s_n) the simple generators. We give a simple proof that the word s_1 s_2 ... s_n s_1 s_2 >... s_n ... s_1 s_2 ... s_n is reduced for any number of repetitions of s_1 s_2 >... s_n. This result was proved for simply-laced, crystallographic groups by Kleiner and Pelley using methods from the theory of quiver representations. Our proof only using basic facts about Coxeter groups and the geometry of root systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
The Multidimensional Cube Recurrence
Authors:
Andre Henriques,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
We introduce a recurrence which we term the multidimensional cube recurrence, generalizing the octahedron recurrence studied by Propp, Fomin and Zelevinsky, Speyer, and Fock and Goncharov and the three-dimensional cube recurrence studied by Fomin and Zelevinsky, and Carroll and Speyer. The states of this recurrence are indexed by tilings of a polygon with rhombi, and the variables in the recurre…
▽ More
We introduce a recurrence which we term the multidimensional cube recurrence, generalizing the octahedron recurrence studied by Propp, Fomin and Zelevinsky, Speyer, and Fock and Goncharov and the three-dimensional cube recurrence studied by Fomin and Zelevinsky, and Carroll and Speyer. The states of this recurrence are indexed by tilings of a polygon with rhombi, and the variables in the recurrence are indexed by vertices of these tilings. We travel from one state of the recurrence to another by performing elementary flips. We show that the values of the recurrence are independent of the order in which we perform the flips; this proof involves nontrivial combinatorial results about rhombus tilings which may be of independent interest. We then show that the multidimensional cube recurrence exhibits the Laurent phenomenon -- any variable is given by a Laurent polynomial in the other variables. We recognize a special case of the multidimensional cube recurrence as giving explicit equations for the isotropic Grassmannians IG(n-1,2n). Finally, we describe a tropical version of the multidimensional cube recurrence and show that, like the tropical octahedron recurrence, it propagates certain linear inequalities.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2009; v1 submitted 20 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
-
Cambrian fans
Authors:
Nathan Reading,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
For a finite Coxeter group W and a Coxeter element c of W, the c-Cambrian fan is a coarsening of the fan defined by the reflecting hyperplanes of W. Its maximal cones are naturally indexed by the c-sortable elements of W. The main result of this paper is that the known bijection cl_c between c-sortable elements and c-clusters induces a combinatorial isomorphism of fans. In particular, the c-Camb…
▽ More
For a finite Coxeter group W and a Coxeter element c of W, the c-Cambrian fan is a coarsening of the fan defined by the reflecting hyperplanes of W. Its maximal cones are naturally indexed by the c-sortable elements of W. The main result of this paper is that the known bijection cl_c between c-sortable elements and c-clusters induces a combinatorial isomorphism of fans. In particular, the c-Cambrian fan is combinatorially isomorphic to the normal fan of the generalized associahedron for W. The rays of the c-Cambrian fan are generated by certain vectors in the W-orbit of the fundamental weights, while the rays of the c-cluster fan are generated by certain roots. For particular ("bipartite") choices of c, we show that the c-Cambrian fan is linearly isomorphic to the c-cluster fan. We characterize, in terms of the combinatorics of clusters, the partial order induced, via the map cl_c, on c-clusters by the c-Cambrian lattice. We give a simple bijection from c-clusters to c-noncrossing partitions that respects the refined (Narayana) enumeration. We relate the Cambrian fan to well known objects in the theory of cluster algebras, providing a geometric context for g-vectors and quasi-Cartan companions.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2008; v1 submitted 8 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
A matroid invariant via the K-theory of the Grassmannian
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Let G(d,n) denote the Grassmannian of d-planes in C^n and let T be the torus (C^*)^n/diag(C^*) which acts on G(d,n). Let x be a point of G(d,n) and let \bar{Tx} be the closure of the T-orbit through x. Then the class of the structure sheaf of \bar{Tx} in the K-theory of G(d,n) depends only on which Plücker coordinates of x are nonzero -- combinatorial data known as the matroid of x. In this pape…
▽ More
Let G(d,n) denote the Grassmannian of d-planes in C^n and let T be the torus (C^*)^n/diag(C^*) which acts on G(d,n). Let x be a point of G(d,n) and let \bar{Tx} be the closure of the T-orbit through x. Then the class of the structure sheaf of \bar{Tx} in the K-theory of G(d,n) depends only on which Plücker coordinates of x are nonzero -- combinatorial data known as the matroid of x. In this paper, we will define a certain map of additive groups from the K-theory of G(d,n) to Z[t]. Letting g_x(t) denote the image of (-1)^{n-dim Tx} [ O_{\bar{Tx}}], g_x behaves nicely under the standard constructions of matroid theory. Specifically, g_{x_1 \oplus x_2}(t)=g_{x_1}(t) g_{x_2}(t), g_{x_1 +_2 x_2}(t)=g_{x_1}(t) g_{x_2}(t)/t, g_x(t) = g_{x^{\perp}}(t) and g_x is unaltered by series and parallel extensions. Furthermore, the coefficients of g_x are nonnegative. The existence of this map implies bounds on (essentially equivalently) the complexity of Kapranov's Lie complexes, Hacking, Keel and Tevelev's very stable pairs and the author's tropical linear spaces when they are realizable in characteristic zero. Namely, in characteristic zero, a Lie complex or the underlying d-1 dimensional scheme of a very stable pair can have at most (n-i-1)! / (d-i)!(n-d-i)!(i-1)! strata of dimensions n-i and d-i respectively and a tropical linear space realizable in characteristic zero can have at most this many i-dimensional bounded faces.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2006;
originally announced March 2006.
-
A Kleiman-Bertini Theorem for sheaf tensor products
Authors:
Ezra Miller,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Fix a variety X with a transitive (left) action by an algebraic group G. Let E and F be coherent sheaves on X. We prove that, for elements g in a dense open subset of G, the sheaf Tor_i^X(E, g F) vanishes for all i > 0. When E and F are structure sheaves of smooth subschemes of X in characteristic zero, this follows from the Kleiman-Bertini theorem; our result has no smoothness hypotheses on the…
▽ More
Fix a variety X with a transitive (left) action by an algebraic group G. Let E and F be coherent sheaves on X. We prove that, for elements g in a dense open subset of G, the sheaf Tor_i^X(E, g F) vanishes for all i > 0. When E and F are structure sheaves of smooth subschemes of X in characteristic zero, this follows from the Kleiman-Bertini theorem; our result has no smoothness hypotheses on the supports of E or F, or hypotheses on the characteristic of the ground field.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2007; v1 submitted 9 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
-
Cyclically Orientable Graphs
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
Barot, Geiss and Zelevinsky define a notion of a ``cyclically orientable graph'' and use it to devise a test for whether a cluster algebra is of finite type. Barot, Geiss and Zelivinsky's work leaves open the question of giving an efficient characterization of cyclically orientable graphs. In this paper, we give a simple recursive description of cyclically orientable graphs, and use this to give…
▽ More
Barot, Geiss and Zelevinsky define a notion of a ``cyclically orientable graph'' and use it to devise a test for whether a cluster algebra is of finite type. Barot, Geiss and Zelivinsky's work leaves open the question of giving an efficient characterization of cyclically orientable graphs. In this paper, we give a simple recursive description of cyclically orientable graphs, and use this to give an O(n) algorithm to test whether a graph on $n$ vertices is cyclically orientable. Shortly after writing this paper, I learned that most of its results had been obtained independently by Gurvich; I am placing this paper on the arXiv to spread knowledge of these results.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2005;
originally announced November 2005.
-
Tropical Linear Spaces
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
We define tropical analogues of the notions of linear space and Plucker coordinate and study their combinatorics. We introduce tropical analogues of intersection and dualization and define a tropical linear space built by repeated dualization and transverse intersection to be constructible. Our main result that all constructible tropical linear spaces have the same f-vector and are ``series-para…
▽ More
We define tropical analogues of the notions of linear space and Plucker coordinate and study their combinatorics. We introduce tropical analogues of intersection and dualization and define a tropical linear space built by repeated dualization and transverse intersection to be constructible. Our main result that all constructible tropical linear spaces have the same f-vector and are ``series-parallel''. We conjecture that this f-vector is maximal for all tropical linear spaces with equality precisely for the series-parallel tropical linear spaces. We present many partial results towards this conjecture.
In addition we relate tropical linear spaces to linear spaces defined over power series fields and give many examples and counter-examples illustrating aspects of this relationship. We describe a family of particularly nice series-parallel linear spaces, which we term tree spaces, that realize the conjectured maximal f-vector and are constructed in a manner similar to the cyclic polytopes.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2004;
originally announced October 2004.
-
A Broken Circuit Ring
Authors:
Nicholas J. Proudfoot,
David E. Speyer
Abstract:
Given a matroid M represented by a linear subspace L in n-space (equivalently by an arrangement of n hyperplanes in L), we define a graded ring R(L) which degenerates to the Stanley-Reisner ring of the broken circuit complex for any choice of ordering of the ground set. In particular, R(L) is Cohen-Macaulay, and may be used to compute the h-vector of the broken circuit complex of M. We give a ge…
▽ More
Given a matroid M represented by a linear subspace L in n-space (equivalently by an arrangement of n hyperplanes in L), we define a graded ring R(L) which degenerates to the Stanley-Reisner ring of the broken circuit complex for any choice of ordering of the ground set. In particular, R(L) is Cohen-Macaulay, and may be used to compute the h-vector of the broken circuit complex of M. We give a geometric interpretation of Spec R(L), as well as a stratification indexed by the flats of M.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2006; v1 submitted 5 October, 2004;
originally announced October 2004.
-
The Cube Recurrence
Authors:
Gabriel D. Carroll,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
We construct a combinatorial model that is described by the cube recurrence, a nonlinear recurrence relation introduced by Propp, which generates families of Laurent polynomials indexed by points in $\mathbb{Z}^3$. In the process, we prove several conjectures of Propp and of Fomin and Zelevinsky, and we obtain a combinatorial interpretation for the terms of Gale-Robinson sequences. We also indic…
▽ More
We construct a combinatorial model that is described by the cube recurrence, a nonlinear recurrence relation introduced by Propp, which generates families of Laurent polynomials indexed by points in $\mathbb{Z}^3$. In the process, we prove several conjectures of Propp and of Fomin and Zelevinsky, and we obtain a combinatorial interpretation for the terms of Gale-Robinson sequences. We also indicate how the model might be used to obtain some interesting results about perfect matchings of certain bipartite planar graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2004;
originally announced March 2004.
-
Perfect Matchings and the Octahedron Recurrence
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
We study a recurrence defined on a three dimensional lattice and prove that its values are Laurent polynomials in the initial conditions with all coefficients equal to one. This recurrence was studied by Propp and by Fomin and Zelivinsky. Fomin and Zelivinsky were able to prove Laurentness and conjectured that the coefficients were 1. Our proof establishes a bijection between the terms of the La…
▽ More
We study a recurrence defined on a three dimensional lattice and prove that its values are Laurent polynomials in the initial conditions with all coefficients equal to one. This recurrence was studied by Propp and by Fomin and Zelivinsky. Fomin and Zelivinsky were able to prove Laurentness and conjectured that the coefficients were 1. Our proof establishes a bijection between the terms of the Laurent polynomial and the perfect matchings of certain graphs, generalizing the theory of Aztec diamonds. In particular, this shows that the coefficients of this polynomial, and polynomials obtained by specializing its variables, are positive, a conjecture of Fomin and Zelevinsky.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2004; v1 submitted 27 February, 2004;
originally announced February 2004.
-
Horn's Problem, Vinnikov Curves and the Hive Cone
Authors:
David E Speyer
Abstract:
A Vinnikov curve is a projective plane curve which can be written in the form det(xX+yY+zZ)=0 for X, Y and Z positive definite Hermitian n by n matrices. Given three n-tuples of positive real numbers, alpha, beta and gamma, there exist A, B and C in GL_n \CC with singular values alpha, beta and gamma and ABC=1 if and only if there is a Vinnikov curve passing through the 3n points (-1: alpha_i^2:…
▽ More
A Vinnikov curve is a projective plane curve which can be written in the form det(xX+yY+zZ)=0 for X, Y and Z positive definite Hermitian n by n matrices. Given three n-tuples of positive real numbers, alpha, beta and gamma, there exist A, B and C in GL_n \CC with singular values alpha, beta and gamma and ABC=1 if and only if there is a Vinnikov curve passing through the 3n points (-1: alpha_i^2:0), (0:-1:beta_i^2) and (gamma_i^2:0:-1). Knutson and Tao proved that another equivalent condition for such A, B and C to exist is that there is a hive (defined within) whose boundary is (log alpha, log beta, log gamma). The logarithms of the coefficients of F approximately form such a hive; this leads to a new proof of Knutson and Tao's result. This paper uses no representation theory and essentially no symplectic geometry. In their place, it uses Viro's patchworking method and a topological description of Vinnikov curves.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
-
Reconstructing Trees from Subtree Weights
Authors:
Lior Pachter,
David E Speyer
Abstract:
The tree-metric theorem provides a necessary and sufficient condition for a dissimilarity matrix to be a tree metric, and has served as the foundation for numerous distance-based reconstruction methods in phylogenetics. Our main result is an extension of the tree-metric theorem to more general dissimilarity maps. In particular, we show that a tree with n leaves is reconstructible from the weight…
▽ More
The tree-metric theorem provides a necessary and sufficient condition for a dissimilarity matrix to be a tree metric, and has served as the foundation for numerous distance-based reconstruction methods in phylogenetics. Our main result is an extension of the tree-metric theorem to more general dissimilarity maps. In particular, we show that a tree with n leaves is reconstructible from the weights of the m-leaf subtrees provided that n \geq 2m-1.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
