-
Interior Controls on the Habitability of Rocky Planets
Authors:
Cedric Gillmann,
Kaustubh Hakim,
Diogo Lourenco,
Sascha P. Quanz,
Paolo A. Sossi
Abstract:
No matter how fascinating and exotic other terrestrial planets are revealed to be, nothing generates more excitement than announcements regarding their habitability. From the observation of Mars to present-day efforts toward Venus and the characterization of exoplanets, the search for life, or at least environments that could accommodate life, has been a major drive for space exploration. So far,…
▽ More
No matter how fascinating and exotic other terrestrial planets are revealed to be, nothing generates more excitement than announcements regarding their habitability. From the observation of Mars to present-day efforts toward Venus and the characterization of exoplanets, the search for life, or at least environments that could accommodate life, has been a major drive for space exploration. So far, we have found no other unquestionably habitable world besides Earth. The conditions of the habitability of terrestrial planets have proved elusive, as surface conditions depend on the complex interplay of many processes throughout the evolution of a planet. Here, we review how the interior of a rocky planet can drive the evolution of surface conditions and the atmosphere. Instead of listing criteria assumed to be critical for life, we discuss how the bulk-silicate planet can affect the onset, continuation and cessation of habitability. We then consider how it can be observed and current efforts towards this end.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Solubility of water in peridotite liquids and the prevalence of steam atmospheres on rocky planets
Authors:
Paolo A. Sossi,
Peter M. E. Tollan,
James Badro,
Dan J. Bower
Abstract:
Atmospheres are products of time-integrated mass exchange between the surface of a planet and its interior. On Earth and other planetary bodies, magma oceans likely marked significant atmosphere-forming events, during which both steam- and carbon-rich atmospheres may have been generated. However, the nature of Earth's early atmosphere, and those around other rocky planets, remains unclear for lack…
▽ More
Atmospheres are products of time-integrated mass exchange between the surface of a planet and its interior. On Earth and other planetary bodies, magma oceans likely marked significant atmosphere-forming events, during which both steam- and carbon-rich atmospheres may have been generated. However, the nature of Earth's early atmosphere, and those around other rocky planets, remains unclear for lack of constraints on the solubility of water in liquids of appropriate composition. Here we determine water solubility in 14 peridotite liquids, representative of Earth's mantle, synthesised in a laser-heated aerodynamic levitation furnace. We explore oxygen fugacities (fO$_2$) between -1.9 and +6.0 log units relative to the iron-wüstite buffer at constant temperature (2173$\pm$50 K) and total pressure (1 bar). The resulting fH$_2$O ranged from 0 to 0.027 bar and fH$_2$ from 0 to 0.064 bar. Total H$_2$O contents were determined by transmission FTIR spectroscopy from the absorption band at 3550cm$^{-1}$ and applying the Beer-Lambert law. The mole fraction of water in the liquid is $\propto$ (fH$_2$O)$^{0.5}$, attesting to its dissolution as OH. The data are fit by a solubility coefficient of 524$\pm$16 ppmw/bar$^{0.5}$, for a molar absorption coefficient, $ε_{3550}$, of 6.3$\pm$0.3 m$^2$/mol in basaltic glasses or 647$\pm$25 ppmw/bar$^{0.5}$, with $ε_{3550}$ = 5.1$\pm$0.3m$^2$/mol for peridotitic glasses. These solubility constants are 10-25 % lower than those for basaltic liquids at 1623 K and 1 bar. Higher temperature lowers water solubility, offsetting the greater depolymerisation of peridotite melts that would otherwise increase H$_2$O solubility relative to basaltic liquids. Because the solubility of water remains high relative to that of CO$_2$, steam atmospheres are rare, although they may form under oxidising conditions on telluric bodies, provided high H/C ratios prevail.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
VapoRock: Thermodynamics of vaporized silicate melts for modeling volcanic outgassing and magma ocean atmospheres
Authors:
Aaron S. Wolf,
Noah Jäggi,
Paolo A. Sossi,
Dan J. Bower
Abstract:
Silicate vapors play a key role in planetary evolution, especially dominating early stages of rocky planet formation through outgassed magma ocean atmospheres. Our open-source thermodynamic modeling software "VapoRock" combines the MELTS liquid model (Ghiorso et al., 1995) with gas-species properties from multiple thermochemistry tables (e.g., Chase et al., 1998). VapoRock calculates the partial p…
▽ More
Silicate vapors play a key role in planetary evolution, especially dominating early stages of rocky planet formation through outgassed magma ocean atmospheres. Our open-source thermodynamic modeling software "VapoRock" combines the MELTS liquid model (Ghiorso et al., 1995) with gas-species properties from multiple thermochemistry tables (e.g., Chase et al., 1998). VapoRock calculates the partial pressures of 34 gaseous species in equilibrium with magmatic liquid in the system Si-Mg-Fe-Al-Ca-Na-K-Ti-Cr-O at desired temperatures and oxygen fugacities (fO2, or partial pressure of O2). Comparison with experiments shows that pressures and melt-oxide activities (which vary over many orders of magnitude) are reproduced to within a factor of ~3, consistent with measurement uncertainties. We also benchmark the model against a wide selection of igneous rock compositions including bulk silicate Earth, predicting elemental vapor abundances that are comparable (Na, Ca, & Al) or more realistic (K, Si, Mg, Fe, & Ti) than those of the closed-source MAGMA code (with maximum deviations by factors of 10-300 for K & Si). Vapor abundances depend critically on the activities of liquid components. The MELTS model underpinning VapoRock was calibrated and extensively tested on natural igneous liquids. In contrast, MAGMA's liquid model assumes ideal mixtures of a limited set of chemically simplified pseudo-species, which only roughly approximates the non-ideal compositional interactions typical of many-component natural silicate melts. Finally, we explore how relative abundances of SiO and SiO2 provide a spectroscopically measurable proxy for oxygen fugacity in devolatilized exoplanetary atmospheres, potentially constraining fO2 in outgassed exoplanetary mantles.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2022; v1 submitted 19 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Stochastic accretion of the Earth
Authors:
Paolo A. Sossi,
Ingo L. Stotz,
Seth A. Jacobson,
Alessandro Morbidelli,
Hugh St. C. O'Neill
Abstract:
Earth is depleted in volatile elements relative to chondritic meteorites, its possible building blocks. The extent of this depletion increases with decreasing condensation temperature, and is approximated by a cumulative normal distribution, unlike that in any chondrite. However, moderately volatile elements, occupying the mid-range of the distribution, have chondritic isotope ratios, contrary to…
▽ More
Earth is depleted in volatile elements relative to chondritic meteorites, its possible building blocks. The extent of this depletion increases with decreasing condensation temperature, and is approximated by a cumulative normal distribution, unlike that in any chondrite. However, moderately volatile elements, occupying the mid-range of the distribution, have chondritic isotope ratios, contrary to that expected from loss by partial vaporisation/condensation. Here we reconcile these observations by showing, using N-body simulations, that Earth accreted stochastically from many precursor bodies whose variable compositions reflect the temperatures at which they formed. Impact-induced atmospheric loss was efficient only when the proto-Earth was small, and elements that accreted thereafter retain near-chondritic isotope ratios. Earth's composition is reproduced when initial temperatures of planetesimal- to embryo-sized bodies are set by disk accretion rates of (1.08 $\pm$ 0.17) $\times$ 10$^{-7}$ solar masses/yr, although they may be perturbed by $^{26}$Al heating on bodies formed at different times. The model implies a heliocentric gradient in composition and rapid planetesimal formation within $\sim$ 1 Myr, in accord with radiometric volatile depletion ages of Earth.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
A model Earth-sized planet in the habitable zone of $α$ Centauri A/B
Authors:
Haiyang S. Wang,
Charles H. Lineweaver,
Sascha P. Quanz,
Stephen J. Mojzsis,
Trevor R. Ireland,
Paolo A. Sossi,
Fabian Seidler,
Thierry Morel
Abstract:
The bulk chemical composition and interior structure of rocky exoplanets are of fundamental importance to understanding their long-term evolution and potential habitability. Observations of the chemical compositions of the solar system rocky bodies and of other planetary systems have increasingly shown a concordant picture that the chemical composition of rocky planets reflects that of their host…
▽ More
The bulk chemical composition and interior structure of rocky exoplanets are of fundamental importance to understanding their long-term evolution and potential habitability. Observations of the chemical compositions of the solar system rocky bodies and of other planetary systems have increasingly shown a concordant picture that the chemical composition of rocky planets reflects that of their host stars for refractory elements, whereas this expression breaks down for volatiles. This behavior is explained by devolatilization during planetary formation and early evolution. Here, we apply a devolatilization model calibrated with solar system bodies to the chemical composition of our nearest Sun-like stars -- $α$ Centauri A and B -- to estimate the bulk composition of any habitable-zone rocky planet in this binary system ("$α$-Cen-Earth"). Through further modeling of likely planetary interiors and early atmospheres, we find that compared to Earth, such a planet is expected to have (i) a reduced (primitive) mantle that is similarly dominated by silicates albeit enriched in carbon-bearing species (graphite/diamond); (ii) a slightly larger iron core, with a core mass fraction of $38.4_{-5.1}^{+4.7}$ wt% (cf. Earth's 32.5 $\pm$ 0.3 wt%); (iii) an equivalent water-storage capacity; and (iv) a CO$_2$-CH$_4$-H$_2$O-dominated early atmosphere that resembles that of Archean Earth. Further taking into account its $\sim$ 25% lower intrinsic radiogenic heating from long-lived radionuclides, an ancient $α$-Cen-Earth ($\sim$ 1.5-2.5 Gyr older than Earth) is expected to have less efficient mantle convection and planetary resurfacing, with a potentially prolonged history of stagnant-lid regimes.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 24 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Evolution of Mercury's Earliest Atmosphere
Authors:
Noah Jäggi,
Diana Gamborino,
Dan J. Bower,
Paolo A. Sossi,
Aaron S. Wolf,
Apurva V. Oza,
Audrey Vorburger,
André Galli,
Peter Wurz
Abstract:
MESSENGER observations suggest a magma ocean formed on proto-Mercury, during which evaporation of metals and outgassing of C- and H-bearing volatiles produced an early atmosphere. Atmospheric escape subsequently occurred by plasma heating, photoevaporation, Jeans escape, and photoionization. To quantify atmospheric loss, we combine constraints on the lifetime of surficial melt, melt composition, a…
▽ More
MESSENGER observations suggest a magma ocean formed on proto-Mercury, during which evaporation of metals and outgassing of C- and H-bearing volatiles produced an early atmosphere. Atmospheric escape subsequently occurred by plasma heating, photoevaporation, Jeans escape, and photoionization. To quantify atmospheric loss, we combine constraints on the lifetime of surficial melt, melt composition, and atmospheric composition. Consideration of two initial Mercury sizes and four magma ocean compositions determine the atmospheric speciation at a given surface temperature. A coupled interior-atmosphere model determines the cooling rate and therefore the lifetime of surficial melt. Combining the melt lifetime and escape flux calculations provide estimates for the total mass loss from early Mercury. Loss rates by Jeans escape are negligible. Plasma heating and photoionization are limited by homopause diffusion rates of $\sim10^{6}$ kg/s. Loss by photoevaporation depends on the timing of Mercury formation and assumed heating efficiency and ranges from $\sim10^{6.6}$ to $\sim10^{9.6}$ kg/s. The material for photoevaporation is sourced from below the homopause and is therefore energy-limited rather than diffusion-limited. The timescale for efficient interior-atmosphere chemical exchange is less than ten thousand years. Therefore, escape processes only account for an equivalent loss of less than 2.3 km of crust ($0.3\%$ of Mercury's mass). Accordingly, $\leq0.02\%$ of the total mass of H$_2$O and Na is lost. Therefore, cumulative loss cannot significantly modify Mercury's bulk mantle composition during the magma ocean stage. Mercury's high core:mantle ratio and volatile-rich surface may instead reflect chemical variations in its building blocks resulting from its solar-proximal accretion environment.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Retention of water in terrestrial magma oceans and carbon-rich early atmospheres
Authors:
Dan J. Bower,
Kaustubh Hakim,
Paolo A. Sossi,
Patrick Sanan
Abstract:
Massive steam and CO$_2$ atmospheres have been proposed for magma ocean outgassing of Earth and terrestrial planets. Yet formation of such atmospheres depends on volatile exchange with the molten interior, governed by volatile solubilities and redox reactions. We determine the evolution of magma ocean--atmosphere systems for a range of oxygen fugacities, C/H ratios and hydrogen budgets that includ…
▽ More
Massive steam and CO$_2$ atmospheres have been proposed for magma ocean outgassing of Earth and terrestrial planets. Yet formation of such atmospheres depends on volatile exchange with the molten interior, governed by volatile solubilities and redox reactions. We determine the evolution of magma ocean--atmosphere systems for a range of oxygen fugacities, C/H ratios and hydrogen budgets that include redox reactions for hydrogen (H$_2$--H$_2$O), carbon (CO--CO$_2$), methane (CH$_4$), and solubility laws for H$_2$O and CO$_2$. We find that small initial budgets of hydrogen, high C/H ratios, and oxidizing conditions, suppress outgassing of hydrogen until the late stage of magma ocean crystallization. Hence early atmospheres in equilibrium with magma oceans are dominantly carbon-rich, and specifically CO-rich except at the most oxidizing conditions. The high solubility of H$_2$O limits its outgassing to melt fractions below $\sim$30\%, the fraction at which the mantle transitions from vigorous to sluggish convection with melt percolation. Sluggish melt percolation could enable a surface lid to form, trap** water in the interior and thereby maintaining a carbon-rich atmosphere (equilibrium crystallization). Alternatively, efficient crystal settling could maintain a molten surface, promoting a transition to a water-rich atmosphere (fractional crystallization). However, additional processes, including melt trap** and H dissolution in crystallizing minerals, further conspire to limit the extent of H outgassing, even for fractional crystallization. Hence, much of the water delivered to planets during their accretion can be safely harbored in their interiors during the magma ocean stage, particularly at oxidizing conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2022; v1 submitted 15 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Tidal pull of the Earth strips the proto-Moon of its volatiles
Authors:
S. Charnoz,
P. A. Sossi,
Y-N Lee,
J. Siebert,
R. Hyodo,
L. Allibert,
F. C. Pignatale,
M. Landeau,
A. V. Oza,
F. Moynier
Abstract:
Prevailing models for the formation of the Moon invoke a giant impact between a planetary embryo and the proto-Earth \citep{Canup_2004, Cuk_Stewart_2012}. Despite similarities in the isotopic and chemical abundances of refractory elements compared to Earth's mantle, the Moon is depleted in volatiles \citep{Wolf_Anders_1980}. Current models favour devolatilisation via incomplete condensation of the…
▽ More
Prevailing models for the formation of the Moon invoke a giant impact between a planetary embryo and the proto-Earth \citep{Canup_2004, Cuk_Stewart_2012}. Despite similarities in the isotopic and chemical abundances of refractory elements compared to Earth's mantle, the Moon is depleted in volatiles \citep{Wolf_Anders_1980}. Current models favour devolatilisation via incomplete condensation of the proto-Moon in an Earth-Moon debris-disk \citep{Charnoz_Michaut_2015,Canup_2015,Lock_2018}. However the physics of this protolunar disk is poorly understood and thermal escape of gas is inhibited by the Earth's strong gravitational field \citep{Nakajima_Stevenson_2014}. Here we investigate a simple process, wherein the Earth's tidal pull promotes intense hydrodynamic escape from the liquid surface of a molten proto-Moon assembling at 3-6 Earth radii. Such tidally-driven atmospheric escape persisting for less than 1 Kyr at temperatures $\sim 1600-1700$ K reproduces the measured lunar depletion in K and Na.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Thermodynamics of Element Volatility and its Application to Planetary Processes
Authors:
Paolo A. Sossi,
Bruce Fegley Jr
Abstract:
Despite its importance in geological sciences, our understanding of interactions between gas and condensed phases (comprising solids and liquids) remains clouded by the fact that, often, only indirect evidence remains for their occurrence. This arises from the tendency for the vapour phase to escape from the condensed phase with which it interacts, owing to its much lower density and thus greater…
▽ More
Despite its importance in geological sciences, our understanding of interactions between gas and condensed phases (comprising solids and liquids) remains clouded by the fact that, often, only indirect evidence remains for their occurrence. This arises from the tendency for the vapour phase to escape from the condensed phase with which it interacts, owing to its much lower density and thus greater volume. For a gas that is sufficiently tenuous that interactions do not occur between its constituent molecules, this relationship is quantified in the ideal gas law (Clapeyron 1834): $PV=nRT$ (1) where $P$ is the total pressure exerted by the gas, $V$ its volume, $n$ is the number of moles, $R$ the gas constant 8.3145 $Jmol^{-1}K^{-1}$, Horstmann, 1873) and $T$ the absolute temperature. One mole of an ideal gas at 273.15 $K$ and $10^5$ $Pa$ (standard temperature and pressure for gases) has a molar volume of 22,711 $cm^3/mol$, $10^3$ x greater than typical silicate liquids or minerals. As a result, vaporisation processes in nature are often informed by chemical and textural evidence remaining in the condensed phase.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Volatile loss following cooling and accretion of the Moon revealed by chromium isotopes
Authors:
Paolo A. Sossi,
Frédéric Moynier,
Kirsten van Zuilen
Abstract:
Terrestrial and lunar rocks share chemical and isotopic similarities in refractory elements, suggestive of a common precursor. By contrast, the marked depletion of volatile elements in lunar rocks together with their enrichment in heavy isotopes compared to Earth s mantle suggests that the Moon underwent evaporative loss of volatiles. However, whether equilibrium prevailed during evaporation, and,…
▽ More
Terrestrial and lunar rocks share chemical and isotopic similarities in refractory elements, suggestive of a common precursor. By contrast, the marked depletion of volatile elements in lunar rocks together with their enrichment in heavy isotopes compared to Earth s mantle suggests that the Moon underwent evaporative loss of volatiles. However, whether equilibrium prevailed during evaporation, and, if so, at what conditions (temperature, pressure and oxygen fugacity) remain unconstrained. Chromium may shed light on this question, as it has several thermodynamically-stable, oxidised gas species that can distinguish between kinetic and equilibrium regimes. Here, we present high-precision Cr isotope measurements in terrestrial and lunar rocks that reveal an enrichment in the lighter isotopes of Cr in the Moon compared to Earths mantle by 100 +/- 40 ppm per atomic mass unit. This observation is consistent with Cr partitioning into an oxygen-rich vapour phase in equilibrium with the proto-Moon, thereby stabilising the CrO2 species that is isotopically heavy compared to CrO in a lunar melt. Temperatures of 1600 to 1800 K and oxygen fugacities near the Fayalite-Magnetite-Quartz buffer are required to explain the elemental and isotopic difference of Cr between Earth s mantle and the Moon. These temperatures are far lower than modelled in the aftermath of a giant impact, implying that volatile loss did not occur contemporaneously with impact but following cooling and accretion of the Moon.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Early Solar System irradiation quantified by linked vanadium and beryllium isotope variations in meteorites
Authors:
Paolo A. Sossi,
Frederic Moynier,
Marc Chaussidon,
Johan Villeneuve,
Chizu Kato,
Matthieu Gounelle
Abstract:
X-ray emission in young stellar objects (YSOs) is orders of magnitude more intense than in main sequence stars1,2, suggestive of cosmic ray irradiation of surrounding accretion disks. Protoplanetary disk irradiation has been detected around YSOs by HERSCHEL3. In our solar system, short-lived 10Be (half-life = 1.39 My4), which cannot be produced by stellar nucleosynthesis, was discovered in the old…
▽ More
X-ray emission in young stellar objects (YSOs) is orders of magnitude more intense than in main sequence stars1,2, suggestive of cosmic ray irradiation of surrounding accretion disks. Protoplanetary disk irradiation has been detected around YSOs by HERSCHEL3. In our solar system, short-lived 10Be (half-life = 1.39 My4), which cannot be produced by stellar nucleosynthesis, was discovered in the oldest solar system solids, the calcium-aluminium-rich inclusions (CAIs)5. The high 10Be abundance, as well as detection of other irradiation tracers6,7, suggest 10Be likely originates from cosmic ray irradiation caused by solar flares8. Nevertheless, the nature of these flares (gradual or impulsive), the target (gas or dust), and the duration and location of irradiation remain unknown. Here we use the vanadium isotopic composition, together with initial 10Be abundance to quantify irradiation conditions in the early Solar System9. For the initial 10Be abundances recorded in CAIs, 50V excesses of a few per mil relative to chondrites have been predicted10,11. We report 50V excesses in CAIs up to 4.4 per mil that co-vary with 10Be abundance. Their co-variation dictates that excess 50V and 10Be were synthesised through irradiation of refractory dust. Modelling of the production rate of 50V and 10Be demonstrates that the dust was exposed to solar cosmic rays produced by gradual flares for less than 300 years at about 0.1 au from the protoSun.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
