-
Calibration of the mixing-length parameter $α$ for the MLT and FST models by matching with CO$^5$BOLD models
Authors:
T. Sonoi,
H. -G. Ludwig,
M. -A. Dupret,
J. Montalbán,
R. Samadi,
K. Belkacem,
E. Caffau,
M. -J. Goupil
Abstract:
The CoRoT and Kepler missions provided a wealth of high-quality data for solar-like oscillations. To make the best of such data for seismic inferences, we need theoretical models with precise near-surface structure, which has significant influence on solar-like oscillation frequencies. The mixing-length parameter, $α$, is a key factor for the near-surface structure. In the convection formulations…
▽ More
The CoRoT and Kepler missions provided a wealth of high-quality data for solar-like oscillations. To make the best of such data for seismic inferences, we need theoretical models with precise near-surface structure, which has significant influence on solar-like oscillation frequencies. The mixing-length parameter, $α$, is a key factor for the near-surface structure. In the convection formulations used in evolution codes, the $α$ is a free parameter that needs to be properly specified. We calibrated $α$ values by matching entropy profiles of 1D envelope models with those of 3D CO$^5$BOLD models. For such calibration, previous works concentrated on the classical mixing-length theory (MLT). Here we also analyzed the full spectrum turbulence (FST) models. For the atmosphere part in the 1D models, we use the Eddington grey $T(τ)$ relation and the one with the solar-calibrated Hopf-like function. For both the MLT and FST models with a mixing length $l=αH_p$, calibrated $α$ values increase with increasing $g$ or decreasing $T_{\rm eff}$. For the FST models, we also calibrated values of $α^*$ defined as $l=r_{\rm top}-r+α^*H_{p,{\rm top}}$. $α^*$ is found to increase with $T_{\rm eff}$ and $g$. As for the correspondence to the 3D models, the solar Hopf-like function gives a photospheric-minimum entropy closer to a 3D model than the Eddington $T(τ)$. The structure below the photosphere depends on the convection model. However, not a single convection model gives the best correspondence since the averaged 3D quantities are not necessarily related via an EOS. Although the FST models with $l=r_{\rm top}-r+α^*H_{p,{\rm top}}$ are found to give the frequencies closest to the solar observed ones, a more appropriate treatment of the top part of the 1D convective envelope is necessary.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Influence of metallicity on the near-surface effect on oscillation frequencies
Authors:
L. Manchon,
K. Belkacem,
R. Samadi,
T. Sonoi,
J. P. C. Marques,
H. -G. Ludwig,
E. Caffau
Abstract:
The CoRoT and Kepler missions have provided high-quality measurements of the frequency spectra of solar-like pulsators, enabling us to probe stellar interiors with a very high degree of accuracy by comparing the observed and modeled frequencies. However, the frequencies computed with 1D models suffer from systematic errors related to the poor modeling of the uppermost layers of stars. These biases…
▽ More
The CoRoT and Kepler missions have provided high-quality measurements of the frequency spectra of solar-like pulsators, enabling us to probe stellar interiors with a very high degree of accuracy by comparing the observed and modeled frequencies. However, the frequencies computed with 1D models suffer from systematic errors related to the poor modeling of the uppermost layers of stars. These biases are what is commonly named the near surface effect. The dominant effect is related to the turbulent pressure that modifies the hydrostatic equilibrium and thus the frequencies. This has already been investigated using grids of 3D RMHD simulations, which also were used to constrain the parameters of the empirical correction models. However, the effect of metallicity has not been considered so far. We study the impact of metallicity on the surface effect across the HR diagram, and provide a method for accounting for it when using the empirical correction models. We computed a grid of patched 1D stellar models with the stellar evolution code CESTAM in which poorly modeled surface layers have been replaced by averaged stratification computed with the 3D RMHD code CO5BOLD. We found that metallicity has a strong impact on the surface effect: kee** T_eff and log g constant, the frequency residuals can vary by up to a factor two. Therefore, the influence of metallicity cannot be neglected. We found that a correct way of accounting for it is to consider the surface Rosseland mean opacity. It allowed us to give a physically-grounded justification as well as a scaling relation for the frequency differences at nu_max as a function of T_eff, log g and kappa. Finally, we provide prescriptions for the fitting parameters of the correction functions. We show that the impact of metallicity through the Rosseland mean opacity must be taken into account when studying and correcting the surface effect.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2018; v1 submitted 24 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Mean density inversions for red giants and red clump stars
Authors:
Gaël Buldgen,
B. Rendle,
T. Sonoi,
G. R. Davies,
A. Miglio,
S. J. A. J. Salmon,
D. R. Reese,
D. Bossini,
P. Eggenberger,
A. Noels,
R. Scuflaire
Abstract:
Since the CoRoT and Kepler missions, the availability of high quality seismic spectra for red giants has made them the standard clocks and rulers for Galactic Archeology. With the expected excellent data from the TESS and PLATO missions, red giants will again play a key role in Galactic studies and stellar physics, thanks to the precise masses and radii determined by asteroseismology. The determin…
▽ More
Since the CoRoT and Kepler missions, the availability of high quality seismic spectra for red giants has made them the standard clocks and rulers for Galactic Archeology. With the expected excellent data from the TESS and PLATO missions, red giants will again play a key role in Galactic studies and stellar physics, thanks to the precise masses and radii determined by asteroseismology. The determination of these quantities is often based on so-called scaling laws, which have been used extensively for main-sequence stars. We show how the SOLA inversion technique can provide robust determinations of the mean density of red giants within 1 per cent of the real value, using only radial oscillations. Combined with radii determinations from Gaia of around 2 per cent precision, this approach provides robust, less model-dependent masses with an error lower than 10 per cent. It will improve age determinations, hel** to accurately dissect the Galactic structure and history. We present results on artificial data of standard models, models including an extended atmosphere from averaged 3D simulations and non-adiabatic frequency calculations to test surface effects, and on eclipsing binaries. We show that the inversions provide very robust mean density estimates, using at best seismic information. However, we also show that a distinction between red-giant branch and red-clump stars is required to determine a reliable estimate of the mean density. The stability of the inversion enables an implementation in automated pipelines, making it suitable for large samples of stars.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
On the computation of eigenfrequencies for equilibrium models including turbulent pressure
Authors:
T. Sonoi,
K. Belkacem,
M. -A. Dupret,
R. Samadi,
H. -G. Ludwig,
E. Caffau,
B. Mosser
Abstract:
The space-borne missions have provided a wealth of highly accurate data. However, our inability to properly model the upper-most region of solar-like stars prevents us from making the best of these observations. This problem is called "surface effect" and a key ingredient to solve it is turbulent pressure for the computation of both the equilibrium models and the oscillations. While 3D hydrodynami…
▽ More
The space-borne missions have provided a wealth of highly accurate data. However, our inability to properly model the upper-most region of solar-like stars prevents us from making the best of these observations. This problem is called "surface effect" and a key ingredient to solve it is turbulent pressure for the computation of both the equilibrium models and the oscillations. While 3D hydrodynamic simulations help to include properly the turbulent pressure in the equilibrium models, the way this surface effect is included in the computation of stellar oscillations is still subject to uncertainties. We aim at determining how to properly include the effect of turbulent pressure and its Lagrangian perturbation in the adiabatic computation of the oscillations. We also discuss the validity of the gas-gamma model (GGM) and reduced gamma model (RGM) approximations, which have been used to compute adiabatic oscillations of equilibrium models including turbulent pressure. We use a patched model of the Sun with an inner part constructed by a 1D stellar evolution code (CESTAM) and an outer part by the 3D hydrodynamical code (CO$^5$BOLD). Then, the adiabatic oscillations are computed using the ADIPLS code for the GGM and RGM and with the MAD code imposing the adiabatic condition on an existing time-dependent convection (TDC) formalism. We show that the computation of the oscillations using the TDC formalism in the adiabatic limit improves significantly the agreement with the observed frequencies compared to the GGM and RGM. Of the components of the turbulent pressure perturbation, the perturbation of the density and advection term is found to contribute most to the frequency shift. We propose a formalism to evaluate the frequency shift due to the inclusion of the term with the turbulent pressure perturbation in the variational principle in order to extrapolate our result to other stars.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Stellar oscillations. II The non-adiabatic case
Authors:
R. Samadi,
K. Belkacem,
T. Sonoi
Abstract:
A leap forward has been performed due to the space-borne missions, MOST, CoRoT and Kepler. They provided a wealth of observational data, and more precisely oscillation spectra, which have been (and are still) exploited to infer the internal structure of stars. While an adiabatic approach is often sufficient to get information on the stellar equilibrium structures it is not sufficient to get a full…
▽ More
A leap forward has been performed due to the space-borne missions, MOST, CoRoT and Kepler. They provided a wealth of observational data, and more precisely oscillation spectra, which have been (and are still) exploited to infer the internal structure of stars. While an adiabatic approach is often sufficient to get information on the stellar equilibrium structures it is not sufficient to get a full understanding of the physics of the oscillation. Indeed, it does not permit one to answer some fundamental questions about the oscillations, such as: What are the physical mechanisms responsible for the pulsations inside stars? What determines the amplitudes? To what extent the adiabatic approximation is valid? All these questions can only be addressed by considering the energy exchanges between the oscillations and the surrounding medium.
This lecture therefore aims at considering the energetical aspects of stellar pulsations with particular emphasis on the driving and dam** mechanisms. To this end, the full non-adiabatic equations are introduced and thoroughly discussed. Two types of pulsation are distinguished, namely the self-excited oscillations that result from an instability and the solar-like oscillations that result from a balance between driving and dam** by turbulent convection. For each type, the main physical principles are presented and illustrated using recent observations obtained with the ultra-high precision photometry space-borne missions (MOST, CoRoT and Kepler). Finally, we consider in detail the physics of scaling relations, which relates the seismic global indices with the global stellar parameters and gave birth to the development of statistical (or ensemble) asteroseismology. Indeed, several of these relations rely on the same cause: the physics of non-adiabatic oscillations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Surface-effect corrections for solar-like oscillations using 3D hydrodynamical simulations
Authors:
T. Sonoi,
R. Samadi,
K. Belkacem,
H. -G. Ludwig,
E. Caffau,
B. Mosser
Abstract:
The space-borne missions have provided us with a wealth of high-quality observational data that allows for seismic inferences of stellar interiors. This requires the computation of precise and accurate theoretical frequencies, but imperfect modeling of the uppermost stellar layers introduces systematic errors. To overcome this problem, an empirical correction has been introduced by Kjeldsen et al.…
▽ More
The space-borne missions have provided us with a wealth of high-quality observational data that allows for seismic inferences of stellar interiors. This requires the computation of precise and accurate theoretical frequencies, but imperfect modeling of the uppermost stellar layers introduces systematic errors. To overcome this problem, an empirical correction has been introduced by Kjeldsen et al. (2008, ApJ, 683, L175) and is now commonly used for seismic inferences. Nevertheless, we still lack a physical justification allowing for the quantification of the surface-effect corrections. We used a grid of these simulations computed with the CO$^5$BOLD code to model the outer layers of solar-like stars. Upper layers of the corresponding 1D standard models were then replaced by the layers obtained from the horizontally averaged 3D models. The frequency differences between these patched models and the 1D standard models were then calculated using the adiabatic approximation and allowed us to constrain the Kjeldsen et al. power law, as well as a Lorentzian formulation. We find that the surface effects on modal frequencies depend significantly on both the effective temperature and the surface gravity. We further provide the variation in the parameters related to the surface-effect corrections using their power law as well as a Lorentzian formulation. Scaling relations between these parameters and the elevation (related to the Mach number) is also provided. The Lorentzian formulation is shown to be more robust for the whole frequency spectrum, while the power law is not suitable for the frequency shifts in the frequency range above $ν_{\rm max}$.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Angular momentum redistribution by mixed modes in evolved low-mass stars. II. Spin-down of the core of red giants induced by mixed modes
Authors:
K. Belkacem,
J. P. Marques,
M. J. Goupil,
B. Mosser,
T. Sonoi,
R. M. Ouazzani,
M. A. Dupret,
S. Mathis,
M. Grosjean
Abstract:
The detection of mixed modes in subgiants and red giants by the CoRoT and \emph{Kepler} space-borne missions allows us to investigate the internal structure of evolved low-mass stars. In particular, the measurement of the mean core rotation rate as a function of the evolution places stringent constraints on the physical mechanisms responsible for the angular momentum redistribution in stars. It sh…
▽ More
The detection of mixed modes in subgiants and red giants by the CoRoT and \emph{Kepler} space-borne missions allows us to investigate the internal structure of evolved low-mass stars. In particular, the measurement of the mean core rotation rate as a function of the evolution places stringent constraints on the physical mechanisms responsible for the angular momentum redistribution in stars. It showed that the current stellar evolution codes including the modelling of rotation fail to reproduce the observations. An additional physical process that efficiently extracts angular momentum from the core is thus necessary.
Our aim is to assess the ability of mixed modes to do this. To this end, we developed a formalism that provides a modelling of the wave fluxes in both the mean angular momentum and the mean energy equations in a companion paper. In this article, mode amplitudes are modelled based on recent asteroseismic observations, and a quantitative estimate of the angular momentum transfer is obtained. This is performed for a benchmark model of 1.3 $M_{\odot}$ at three evolutionary stages, representative of the evolved pulsating stars observed by CoRoT and Kepler.
We show that mixed modes extract angular momentum from the innermost regions of subgiants and red giants. However, this transport of angular momentum from the core is unlikely to counterbalance the effect of the core contraction in subgiants and early red giants. In contrast, for more evolved red giants, mixed modes are found efficient enough to balance and exceed the effect of the core contraction, in particular in the hydrogen-burning shell. Our results thus indicate that mixed modes are a promising candidate to explain the observed spin-down of the core of evolved red giants, but that an other mechanism is to be invoked for subgiants and early red giants.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Angular momentum redistribution by mixed modes in evolved low-mass stars. I. Theoretical formalism
Authors:
K. Belkacem,
J. P. Marques,
M. J. Goupil,
T. Sonoi,
R. M. Ouazzani,
M. A. Dupret,
S. Mathis,
B. Mosser,
M. Grosjean
Abstract:
Seismic observations by the space-borne mission \emph{Kepler} have shown that the core of red giant stars slows down while evolving, requiring an efficient physical mechanism to extract angular momentum from the inner layers. Current stellar evolution codes fail to reproduce the observed rotation rates by several orders of magnitude, and predict a drastic spin-up of red giant cores instead. New ef…
▽ More
Seismic observations by the space-borne mission \emph{Kepler} have shown that the core of red giant stars slows down while evolving, requiring an efficient physical mechanism to extract angular momentum from the inner layers. Current stellar evolution codes fail to reproduce the observed rotation rates by several orders of magnitude, and predict a drastic spin-up of red giant cores instead. New efficient mechanisms of angular momentum transport are thus required.
In this framework, our aim is to investigate the possibility that mixed modes extract angular momentum from the inner radiative regions of evolved low-mass stars. To this end, we consider the Transformed Eulerian Mean (TEM) formalism, introduced by Andrews \& McIntyre (1978), that allows us to consider the combined effect of both the wave momentum flux in the mean angular momentum equation and the wave heat flux in the mean entropy equation as well as their interplay with the meridional circulation.
In radiative layers of evolved low-mass stars, the quasi-adiabatic approximation, the limit of slow rotation, and the asymptotic regime can be applied for mixed modes and enable us to establish a prescription for the wave fluxes in the mean equations. The formalism is finally applied to a $1.3 M_\odot$ benchmark model, representative of observed CoRoT and \emph{Kepler} oscillating evolved stars.
We show that the influence of the wave heat flux on the mean angular momentum is not negligible and that the overall effect of mixed modes is to extract angular momentum from the innermost region of the star. A quantitative and accurate estimate requires realistic values of mode amplitudes. This is provided in a companion paper.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Stability Analysis of Strange-Modes in Hot Massive Stars with Time-Dependent Convection
Authors:
Takafumi Sonoi,
Hiromoto Shibahashi
Abstract:
We carry out a nonadiabatic analysis of strange-modes in hot massive stars with time-dependent convection (TDC). In envelopes of such stars, convective luminosity is not so dominant as that in envelopes of stars in the redder side of the classical instability strip. Around the Fe opacity bump, however, convection non-negligibly contributes to energy transfer. Indeed, instability of modes excited a…
▽ More
We carry out a nonadiabatic analysis of strange-modes in hot massive stars with time-dependent convection (TDC). In envelopes of such stars, convective luminosity is not so dominant as that in envelopes of stars in the redder side of the classical instability strip. Around the Fe opacity bump, however, convection non-negligibly contributes to energy transfer. Indeed, instability of modes excited at the Fe bump is likely to be suppressed with TDC compared with the case of adopting the frozen-in convection approximation. But we make sure that unstable strange-modes certainly appear in hot massive stars even by taking into account TDC. We also examine properties of the strange-mode instability, which is related to destabilization of strange-modes without adiabatic counterparts. In this type of instability, the phase lag between density and pressure varies from 0 to $180^{\circ}$ in an excitation zone unlike the case of the $κ$-mechanism. In addition, we confirm by comparing models with $Z=0$ and $Z=0.02$ that dominance of radiation pressure is important for this type of instability.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Analysis of strange-mode instability with time-dependent convection in hot massive stars
Authors:
Takafumi Sonoi,
Hiromoto Shibahashi
Abstract:
We carry out nonadiabatic analysis of strange-modes in hot massive stars with time-dependent convection (TDC) for the first time. Although convective luminosity in envelopes of hot massive stars is not as dominative as in stars near the red edge of the classical Cepheid instability strip in the Hertzsprung-Russell (H-R) diagram, we have found that the strange-mode instability can be affected by th…
▽ More
We carry out nonadiabatic analysis of strange-modes in hot massive stars with time-dependent convection (TDC) for the first time. Although convective luminosity in envelopes of hot massive stars is not as dominative as in stars near the red edge of the classical Cepheid instability strip in the Hertzsprung-Russell (H-R) diagram, we have found that the strange-mode instability can be affected by the treatment of convection. However, existence of the instability around and over the Humphreys-Davidson (H-D) limit is independent of the treatment. This implies that the strange-mode instability could be responsible for the lack of observed stars over the H-D limit regardless of uncertainties on convection theories.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Dipole low-order g mode instability of metal-poor low-mass main-sequence stars due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism
Authors:
Takafumi Sonoi,
Hiromoto Shibahashi
Abstract:
We analyzed vibrational stability of metal-poor low-mass main-sequence stars due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism. Since outer convection zones of the metal-poor stars is limited only to the very outer layers, the uncertainty in treatment of convection does not affect the result significantly. We found that the dipole g$_1$- and g$_2$-modes certainly become unstable due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanis…
▽ More
We analyzed vibrational stability of metal-poor low-mass main-sequence stars due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism. Since outer convection zones of the metal-poor stars is limited only to the very outer layers, the uncertainty in treatment of convection does not affect the result significantly. We found that the dipole g$_1$- and g$_2$-modes certainly become unstable due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism for $Z\la 6\times 10^{-4}$. Besides that, we found that as the metallicity decreases the mass range of the $\varepsilon$-mechanism instability extends toward higher mass.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Vibrational Instability of Metal-Poor Low-Mass Main-Sequence Stars
Authors:
Takafumi Sonoi,
Hiromoto Shibahashi
Abstract:
We find that low-degree low-order g-modes become unstable in metal-poor low-mass stars due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism of the pp-chain. Since the outer convection zone of these stars is limited only to the very outer layers, the uncertainty in the treatment of convection does not affect the result significantly. The decrease in metallicity leads to decrease in opacity and hence increase in lumi…
▽ More
We find that low-degree low-order g-modes become unstable in metal-poor low-mass stars due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism of the pp-chain. Since the outer convection zone of these stars is limited only to the very outer layers, the uncertainty in the treatment of convection does not affect the result significantly. The decrease in metallicity leads to decrease in opacity and hence increase in luminosity of a star. This makes the star compact and results in decrease in the density contrast, which is favorable to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism instability. We find also instability for high order g-modes of metal-poor low-mass stars by the convective blocking mechanism. Since the effective temperature and the luminosity of metal-poor stars are significantly higher than those of Pop I stars, the stars showing $γ$ Dor-type pulsation are substantially less massive than in the case of Pop I stars. We demonstrate that those modes are unstable for about $1\,M_\odot$ stars in the metal-poor case.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Fully Nonadiabatic Analysis of Vibrational Instability of Population III Stars due to the $\varepsilon$-Mechanism
Authors:
Takafumi Sonoi,
Hiromoto Shibahashi
Abstract:
A linear nonadiabatic analysis of the vibrational stability of population III main-sequence stars was carried out. It was demonstrated that, in the case of massive stars with $M \gtrsim 5\Mo$, helium burning (triple alpha reaction) starts during the main-sequence stage and produces $^{12}{\rm C}$, leading to the activation of a part of the CNO-cycle. It was found that, despite of that, those stars…
▽ More
A linear nonadiabatic analysis of the vibrational stability of population III main-sequence stars was carried out. It was demonstrated that, in the case of massive stars with $M \gtrsim 5\Mo$, helium burning (triple alpha reaction) starts during the main-sequence stage and produces $^{12}{\rm C}$, leading to the activation of a part of the CNO-cycle. It was found that, despite of that, those stars with $M\lesssim 13\Mo$ become unstable against the dipole g$_1$- and g$_2$-modes due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism, during the early evolutionary phase at which the pp-chain is still the dominant nuclear energy source. The instability due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism occurs against g-modes having a large amplitude in the off-centered $^3$He accumulation shell in the deep interior, and the growth time is much shorter than the evolutionary timescale. This instability is therefore likely to induce mixing in the stellar interior, and have a significant influence on the evolution of these stars.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Vibrational instability of Population III very massive main-sequence stars due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism
Authors:
Takafumi Sonoi,
Hideyuki Umeda
Abstract:
Very massive stars are thought to be formed in the early Universe because of a lack of cooling process by heavy elements, and might have been responsible for the later evolution of the Universe. We had an interest in vibrational stability of their evolution and carried out the linear nonadiabatic analysis of radial and nonradial oscillations for population III very massive main-sequence stars with…
▽ More
Very massive stars are thought to be formed in the early Universe because of a lack of cooling process by heavy elements, and might have been responsible for the later evolution of the Universe. We had an interest in vibrational stability of their evolution and carried out the linear nonadiabatic analysis of radial and nonradial oscillations for population III very massive main-sequence stars with $500-3000M_{\sun}$. We found that only the radial fundamental mode becomes unstable due to the $\varepsilon$-mechanism for these stars. The instability appears just after the CNO cycle is activated and the nuclear energy generation rate becomes large enough to stop the pre--main-sequence contraction, and continues during the early stage of the core hydrogen burning. Besides, we roughly estimated amount of mass loss due to the instability to know its significance.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
