-
Symmetry of the coupling between surface acoustic waves and spin waves in synthetic antiferromagnets
Authors:
R. Lopes Seeger,
L. La Spina,
V. Laude,
F. Millo,
A. Bartasyte,
S. Margueron,
A. Solignac,
G. de Loubens,
L. Thevenard,
C. Gourdon,
C. Chappert,
T. Devolder
Abstract:
Synthetic antiferromagnets host spin waves that are highly tunable. It is of practical interest to analyze the symmetry of their coupling to surface acoustic waves with the design of hybrid devices in view. For this we calculate the layer-resolved susceptibility tensor of a synthetic antiferromagnet, the effective magneto-elastic and magneto-rotation fields associated to a travelling elastic wave,…
▽ More
Synthetic antiferromagnets host spin waves that are highly tunable. It is of practical interest to analyze the symmetry of their coupling to surface acoustic waves with the design of hybrid devices in view. For this we calculate the layer-resolved susceptibility tensor of a synthetic antiferromagnet, the effective magneto-elastic and magneto-rotation fields associated to a travelling elastic wave, and the power irreversibly transferred by the elastic wave to the magnetic layers. We consider Rayleigh-type surface acoustic waves: (a) that travel in an elastically isotropic, non-piezoelectric substrate, or (b) that propagate along the X direction at the surface of a Z-cut LiNbO$_3$ substrate, or (c) that are guided in a thin Z-cut LiNbO$_3$ film grown on a sapphire substrate. In particular, we show that the complementary angular dependencies of the acoustic and optical spin wave modes in synthetic antiferromagnets makes it possible to excite spin waves for any relative orientation of magnetization and acoustic wavevector. In addition, we discuss the symmetries of the driving fields and of the energy transferred to the magnetic degree of freedom. We evidence new interaction channels coupling the magnetization eigenmodes when elastic anisotropy and piezoelectricity of the substrate are considered.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2024; v1 submitted 4 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Unidirectionality of spin waves in Synthetic Antiferromagnets
Authors:
F. Millo,
J. -P. Adam,
C. Chappert,
J. -V. Kim,
A. Mouhoub,
A. Solignac,
T. Devolder
Abstract:
We study the frequency non-reciprocity of the spin waves in symmetric CoFeB/Ru/CoFeB synthetic antiferromagnets stacks set in the scissors state by in-plane applied fields. Using a combination of Brillouin Light Scattering and propagating spin wave spectroscopy experiments, we show that the acoustical spin waves in synthetic antiferromagnets possess a unique feature if their wavevector is parallel…
▽ More
We study the frequency non-reciprocity of the spin waves in symmetric CoFeB/Ru/CoFeB synthetic antiferromagnets stacks set in the scissors state by in-plane applied fields. Using a combination of Brillouin Light Scattering and propagating spin wave spectroscopy experiments, we show that the acoustical spin waves in synthetic antiferromagnets possess a unique feature if their wavevector is parallel to the applied field: the frequency non-reciprocity due to layer-to-layer dipolar interactions can be so large that the acoustical spin waves transfer energy in a unidirectional manner for a wide and bipolar interval of wavevectors. Analytical modeling and full micromagnetic calculations are conducted to account for the dispersion relations of the optical and acoustical spin waves for arbitrary field orientations. Our formalism provides a simple and direct method to understand and design devices harnessing unidirectional propagation of spin waves in synthetic antiferromagnets.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2023; v1 submitted 8 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Inducing or suppressing the anisotropy in multilayers based on CoFeB
Authors:
R. L. Seeger,
F. Millo,
A. Mouhoub,
G. de Loubens,
A. Solignac,
T. Devolder
Abstract:
Controlling the uniaxial magnetic anisotropy is of practical interest to a wide variety of applications. We study Co$_{40}$Fe$_{40}$B$_{20}$ single films grown on various crystalline orientations of LiNbO$_3$ substrates and on oxidized silicon. We identify the annealing conditions that are appropriate to induce or suppress uniaxial anisotropy. Anisotropy fields can be increased by annealing up to…
▽ More
Controlling the uniaxial magnetic anisotropy is of practical interest to a wide variety of applications. We study Co$_{40}$Fe$_{40}$B$_{20}$ single films grown on various crystalline orientations of LiNbO$_3$ substrates and on oxidized silicon. We identify the annealing conditions that are appropriate to induce or suppress uniaxial anisotropy. Anisotropy fields can be increased by annealing up to 11 mT when using substrates with anisotropic surfaces. They can be decreased to below 1 mT when using isotropic surfaces. In the first case, the observed increase of the anisotropy originates from the biaxial strain in the film caused by the anisotropic thermal contraction of the substrate when back at room temperature after strain relaxation during annealing. In the second case, anisotropy is progressively removed by applying successive orthogonal fields that are assumed to progressively suppress any chemical ordering within the magnetic film. The method can be applied to CoFeB/Ru/CoFeB synthetic antiferromagnets but the tuning of the anisotropy comes with a decrease of the interlayer exchange coupling and a drastic change of the exchange stiffness.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Exchange energies in CoFeB/Ru/CoFeB Synthetic Antiferromagnets
Authors:
A. Mouhoub,
F. Millo,
C. Chappert,
J. -V. Kim,
J. Létang,
A. Solignac,
T. Devolder
Abstract:
The interlayer exchange coupling confers specific properties to Synthetic Antiferromagnets that make them suitable for several applications of spintronics. The efficient use of this magnetic configuration requires an in-depth understanding of the magnetic properties and their correlation with the material structure. Here we establish a reliable procedure to quantify the interlayer exchange couplin…
▽ More
The interlayer exchange coupling confers specific properties to Synthetic Antiferromagnets that make them suitable for several applications of spintronics. The efficient use of this magnetic configuration requires an in-depth understanding of the magnetic properties and their correlation with the material structure. Here we establish a reliable procedure to quantify the interlayer exchange coupling and the intralayer exchange stiffness in synthetic antiferromagnets; we apply it to the ultrasmooth and amorphous Co$_{40}$Fe$_{40}$B$_{20}$ (5-40 nm)/Ru/ Co$_{40}$Fe$_{40}$B$_{20}$ material platform. The complex interplay between the two exchange interactions results in a gradient of the magnetization orientation across the thickness of the stack which alters the hysteresis and the spin wave eigenmodes of the stack in a non trivial way. We measured the field-dependence of the frequencies of the first four spin waves confined within the thickness of the stack. We modeled these frequencies and the corresponding thickness profiles of these spin waves using micromagnetic simulations. The comparison with the experimental results allows to deduce the magnetic parameters that best account for the sample behavior. The exchange stiffness is established to be 16 $\pm$ 2 pJ/m, independently of the Co$_{40}$Fe$_{40}$B$_{20}$ thickness. The interlayer exchange coupling starts from -1.7 mJ/m$^2$ for the thinnest layers and it can be maintained above -1.3 mJ/m$^2$ for CoFeB layers as thick as 40 nm. The comparison of our method with earlier characterizations using the sole saturation fields argues for a need to revisit the tabulated values of interlayer exchange coupling in thick synthetic antiferromagnets.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Measuring a population of spin waves from the electrical noise of an inductively coupled antenna
Authors:
T. Devolder,
S. -M. Ngom,
A. Mouhoub,
J. Létang,
J. -V. Kim,
P. Crozat,
J. -P. Adam,
A. Solignac,
C. Chappert
Abstract:
We study how a population of spin waves can be characterized from the analysis of the electrical microwave noise delivered by an inductive antenna placed in its vicinity. The measurements are conducted on a synthetic antiferromagnetic thin stripe covered by a micron-sized antenna that feeds a spectrum analyser after amplification. The antenna noise contains two contributions. The population of inc…
▽ More
We study how a population of spin waves can be characterized from the analysis of the electrical microwave noise delivered by an inductive antenna placed in its vicinity. The measurements are conducted on a synthetic antiferromagnetic thin stripe covered by a micron-sized antenna that feeds a spectrum analyser after amplification. The antenna noise contains two contributions. The population of incoherent spin waves generates a fluctuating field that is sensed by the antenna: this is the "magnon noise". The antenna noise also contains the contribution of the electronic fluctuations: the Johnson-Nyquist noise. The latter depends on all impedances within the measurement circuit, which includes the antenna self-inductance. As a result, the electronic noise contains information about the magnetic susceptibility of the stripe, though it does not inform on the absolute amplitude of the magnetic fluctuations. For micrometer-sized systems at thermal equilibrium, the electronic noise dominates and the pure magnon noise cannot be determined. If in contrast the spinwave bath is not at thermal equilibrium with the measurement circuit, and if the spin wave population can be changed then one could measure a mode-resolved effective magnon temperature provided specific precautions are implemented.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2022; v1 submitted 4 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Spin charge conversion in Rashba split ferromagnetic interfaces
Authors:
Olivier Rousseau,
Cosimo Gorini,
Fatima Ibrahim,
Jean-Yves Chauleau,
Aurélie Solignac,
Ali Hallal,
Sebastian Tölle,
Mair Chshiev,
Michel Viret
Abstract:
We show here theoretically and experimentally that a Rashba-split electron state inside a ferromagnet can efficiently convert a dynamical spin accumulation into an electrical voltage. The effect is understood to stem from the Rashba splitting but with a symmetry linked to the magnetization direction. It is experimentally measured by spin pum** in a CoFeB/MgO structure where it is found to be as…
▽ More
We show here theoretically and experimentally that a Rashba-split electron state inside a ferromagnet can efficiently convert a dynamical spin accumulation into an electrical voltage. The effect is understood to stem from the Rashba splitting but with a symmetry linked to the magnetization direction. It is experimentally measured by spin pum** in a CoFeB/MgO structure where it is found to be as efficient as the inverse spin Hall effect at play when Pt replaces MgO, with the extra advantage of not affecting the dam** in the ferromagnet.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Constant TMR magnetic field sensor detectivity with bias voltage
Authors:
E. Monteblanco,
A. Solignac,
C. Chopin,
J. Moulin,
P. Belliot,
N. Belin,
P. Campiglio,
C. Fermon,
M. Pannetier-Lecoeur
Abstract:
In this letter, we present a study of optimized TMR magnetic field sensors as a function of voltage bias. The 1/f low-frequency noise is quantified by the Hooge-like parameter α which allows to compare the low-frequency behavior of various TMR sensors. The sensitivity as well as the detectivity of the sensor are characterized in the parallel state and at 0 mT. We observe that the sensitivity shows…
▽ More
In this letter, we present a study of optimized TMR magnetic field sensors as a function of voltage bias. The 1/f low-frequency noise is quantified by the Hooge-like parameter α which allows to compare the low-frequency behavior of various TMR sensors. The sensitivity as well as the detectivity of the sensor are characterized in the parallel state and at 0 mT. We observe that the sensitivity shows a strong voltage dependence and the noise presents an unexpected decrease, not anticipated by the Hooge's law. Moreover, surprisingly, an almost stable detectivity (140-200 nT/sqrt(Hz) at 10 Hz and 15-20 nT/sqrt(Hz) at 1 kHz) as a function of the bias voltage is observed, tending to highlight that the variation of sensitivity and noise are correlated. Even if the I-V curves are strongly non-linear and reflect the different symmetries of the conduction bands channels, the variations in sensitivity and noise seems to depend mainly on the distortion of the MgO barrier due to bias voltage. With a simple model where the normal noise and sensitivity of the TMR sensors are modified by an element having no noise and a parabolic conductance with voltage, we describe the behavior of noise and sensitivity from mV to V.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Normalization and electronic circuit correction for magnetic tunnel junction sensor performances comparison
Authors:
E. Monteblanco,
A. Solignac,
C. Chopin,
J. Moulin,
P. Belliot,
N. Belin,
P. Campiglio,
C. Fermon,
M. Pannetier-Lecoeur
Abstract:
In this manuscript we propose a theoretical model where the magneto-resistive elements are modelled as fluctuating resistances to correct the output voltage noise of tunnel magnetic junction (MTJ) from standard electronic circuits. This model is validated on single elements, partial and full Wheatstone bridge circuits, giving rise to a correction factor affecting the output noise voltage as well a…
▽ More
In this manuscript we propose a theoretical model where the magneto-resistive elements are modelled as fluctuating resistances to correct the output voltage noise of tunnel magnetic junction (MTJ) from standard electronic circuits. This model is validated on single elements, partial and full Wheatstone bridge circuits, giving rise to a correction factor affecting the output noise voltage as well as sensitivity values. Combining the correction factor and a normalization by the number of MTJs pillars and the pillar surface, we show that the performances extracted by this method allow universal comparison between any results from literature.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2021; v1 submitted 21 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Spin-torque Dynamics for Noise Reduction in Vortex-based Sensors
Authors:
Mafalda Jotta Garcia,
Julien Moulin,
Steffen Wittrock,
Sumito Tsunegi,
Kay Yakushiji,
Akio Fukushima,
Hitoshi Kubota,
Shinji Yuasa,
Ursula Ebels,
Myriam Pannetier-Lecoeur,
Claude Fermon,
Romain Lebrun,
Paolo Bortolotti,
Aurélie Solignac,
Vincent Cros
Abstract:
Performance of magnetoresistive sensors is today mainly limited by their 1/f low-frequency noise. Here, we study this noise component in vortex-based TMR sensors. We compare the noise level in different magnetization configurations of the device, i.e vortex state or uniform parallel or antiparallel states. We find that the vortex state is at least an order of magnitude noisier than the uniform sta…
▽ More
Performance of magnetoresistive sensors is today mainly limited by their 1/f low-frequency noise. Here, we study this noise component in vortex-based TMR sensors. We compare the noise level in different magnetization configurations of the device, i.e vortex state or uniform parallel or antiparallel states. We find that the vortex state is at least an order of magnitude noisier than the uniform states. Nevertheless, by activating the spin-transfer induced dynamics of the vortex configuration, we observe a reduction of the 1/f noise, close to the values measured in the AP state, as the vortex core has a lower probability of pinning into defect sites. Additionally, by driving the dynamics of the vortex core by a non-resonant rf field or current we demonstrate that the 1/f noise can be further decreased. The ability to reduce the 1/f low-frequency noise in vortex-based devices by leveraging their spin-transfer dynamics thus enhances their applicability in the magnetic sensors' landscape.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Multi-GMR sensors controlled by additive dipolar coupling
Authors:
J. Torrejon,
A. Solignac,
C. Chopin,
J. Moulin,
A. Doll,
E. Paul,
C. Fermon,
M. Pannetier-Lecoeur
Abstract:
Vertical packaging of multiple Giant Magnetoresistance (multi-GMR) stacks is a very interesting noise reduction strategy for local magnetic sensor measurements, which has not been reported experimentally so far. Here, we have fabricated multi-GMR sensors (up to 12 repetitions) kee** good GMR ratio, linearity and low roughness. From magnetotransport measurements, two different resistance response…
▽ More
Vertical packaging of multiple Giant Magnetoresistance (multi-GMR) stacks is a very interesting noise reduction strategy for local magnetic sensor measurements, which has not been reported experimentally so far. Here, we have fabricated multi-GMR sensors (up to 12 repetitions) kee** good GMR ratio, linearity and low roughness. From magnetotransport measurements, two different resistance responses have been observed with a crossover around 5 GMR repetitions: step-like (N<5) and linear (N>5) behavior, respectively. With the help of micromagnetic simulations, we have analyzed in detail the two main magnetic mechanisms: the Neel coupling distribution induced by the roughness propagation and the additive dipolar coupling between the N free layers. Furthermore we have correlated the dipolar coupling mechanism, controlled by the number of GMRs (N) and lateral dimensions (width), to the sensor performance (sensitivity, noise and detectivity) in good agreement with analytical theory. The noise roughly decreases in multi-GMRs as 1/\sqrt{N} in both regimes (low frequency 1/f and thermal noise). The sensitivity is even stronger reduced, scaling as 1/N, in the strong dipolar regime (narrow devices) while converges to a constant value in the weak dipolar regime (wide devices). Very interestingly, they are more robust against undesirable RTN noise than single GMRs at high voltages and the linearity can be extended towards much larger magnetic field range without dealing with the size and the reduction of GMR ratio. Finally, we have identified the optimal conditions for which multi-GMRs exhibit lower magnetic field detectivity than single GMRs: wide devices operating in the thermal regime where much higher voltage can be applied without generating remarkable magnetic noise.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Traceably Calibrated Scanning Hall Probe Microscopy at Room Temperature
Authors:
Manuela Gerken,
Aurélie Solignac,
Davood Momeni Pakdehi,
Alessandra Manzin,
Thomas Weimann,
Klaus Pierz,
Sibylle Sievers,
Hans Werner Schumacher
Abstract:
Fabrication, characterization and comparison of gold and graphene micro- and nano-size Hall sensors for room temperature scanning magnetic field microscopy applications is presented. The Hall sensors with active areas from 5 $μ$m down to 50 nm were fabricated by electron-beam lithography. The calibration of the Hall sensors in an external magnetic field revealed a sensitivity of 3.2 mV/(AT) $\pm$…
▽ More
Fabrication, characterization and comparison of gold and graphene micro- and nano-size Hall sensors for room temperature scanning magnetic field microscopy applications is presented. The Hall sensors with active areas from 5 $μ$m down to 50 nm were fabricated by electron-beam lithography. The calibration of the Hall sensors in an external magnetic field revealed a sensitivity of 3.2 mV/(AT) $\pm$ 0.3 % for gold and 1615 V/(AT) $\pm$ 0.5 % for graphene at room temperature. The gold sensors were fabricated on silicon nitride cantilever chips suitable for integration into commercial scanning probe microscopes, allowing scanning Hall microscopy (SHM) under ambient conditions and controlled sensor-sample distance. The height dependent stray field distribution of a magnetic scale was characterized using a 5 $μ$m gold Hall sensor. The uncertainty of the entire Hall sensor based scanning and data acquisition process was analyzed allowing traceably calibrated SHM measurements. The measurement results show good agreement with numerical simulations within the uncertainty budget.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2020; v1 submitted 28 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Optimizing magnetoresistive sensor signal-to-noise via pinning field tuning
Authors:
J. Moulin,
A. Doll,
E. Paul,
M. Pannetier-Lecoeur,
C. Fermon,
N. Sergeeva-Chollet,
A. Solignac
Abstract:
The presence of magnetic noise in magnetoresistive-based magnetic sensors degrades their detection limit at low frequencies. In this paper, different ways of stabilizing the magnetic sensing layer to suppress magnetic noise are investigated by applying a pinning field, either by an external field, internally in the stack or by shape anisotropy. We show that these three methods are equivalent, coul…
▽ More
The presence of magnetic noise in magnetoresistive-based magnetic sensors degrades their detection limit at low frequencies. In this paper, different ways of stabilizing the magnetic sensing layer to suppress magnetic noise are investigated by applying a pinning field, either by an external field, internally in the stack or by shape anisotropy. We show that these three methods are equivalent, could be combined and that there is a competition between noise suppression and sensitivity reduction, which results in an optimum total pinning field, for which the detection limit of the sensor is improved up to a factor of ten.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Field-free magnetization reversal by spin-Hall effect and exchange bias
Authors:
Arno van den Brink,
Guus Vermijs,
Aurélie Solignac,
Jungwoo Koo,
Jurgen T. Kohlhepp,
Henk J. M. Swagten,
Bert Koopmans
Abstract:
Magnetic random-access memory (MRAM) driven by spin-transfer torque (STT) is a major contender for future memory applications. The energy dissipation involved in writing remains problematic, even with the advent of more efficient perpendicular magnetic anisotropy (PMA) devices. A promising alternative switching mechanism employs spin-orbit torques and the spin-Hall effect (SHE) in particular, but…
▽ More
Magnetic random-access memory (MRAM) driven by spin-transfer torque (STT) is a major contender for future memory applications. The energy dissipation involved in writing remains problematic, even with the advent of more efficient perpendicular magnetic anisotropy (PMA) devices. A promising alternative switching mechanism employs spin-orbit torques and the spin-Hall effect (SHE) in particular, but additional symmetry breaking is required to achieve deterministic switching in PMA devices. Currently used methods rely on in-plane magnetic fields or anisotropy gradients, which are not suitable for practical applications. Here, we interface the magnetic layer with an anti-ferromagnetic material. An in-plane exchange bias (EB) is created, and shown to enable field-free SHE-driven magnetization reversal of a perpendicularly magnetized Pt/Co/IrMn structure. Aside from the potential technological implications, our experiment provides additional insight into the local spin structure at the ferromagnetic/anti-ferromagnetic interface.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2015; v1 submitted 29 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Thickness dependence of the interfacial Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction in inversion symmetry broken systems
Authors:
Jaehun Cho,
Nam-Hui Kim,
Sukmock Lee,
June-Seo Kim,
Reinoud Lavrijsen,
Aurelie Solignac,
Yuxiang Yin,
Dong-Soo Han,
Niels J. J. van Hoof,
Henk J. M. Swagten,
Bert Koopmans,
Chun-Yeol You
Abstract:
In magnetic multilayer systems, a large spin-orbit coupling at the interface between heavy metals and ferromagnets can lead to intriguing phenomena such as the perpendicular magnetic anisotropy, the spin Hall effect, the Rashba effect, and especially the interfacial Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya (IDM) interaction. This interfacial nature of IDM interaction has been recently revisited because of its scient…
▽ More
In magnetic multilayer systems, a large spin-orbit coupling at the interface between heavy metals and ferromagnets can lead to intriguing phenomena such as the perpendicular magnetic anisotropy, the spin Hall effect, the Rashba effect, and especially the interfacial Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya (IDM) interaction. This interfacial nature of IDM interaction has been recently revisited because of its scientific and technological potential. Here, we demonstrate an experimental technique to straightforwardly observe the IDM interaction, namely Brillouin light scattering. The non-reciprocal spin wave dispersions, systematically measured by Brillouin light scattering, allow not only the determination of the IDM energy densities beyond the regime of perpendicular magnetization but also the revelation of the inverse proportionality with the thickness of the magnetic layer, which is a clear signature of the interfacial nature. All together, our experimental and theoretical approaches involving double time Green,s function methods open up possibilities for exploring magnetic hybrid structures for engineering the IDM interaction.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2015; v1 submitted 22 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
