-
Temperature-invariant heat conductivity from compensating crystalline and glassy transport: from the Steinbach meteorite to furnace bricks
Authors:
Michele Simoncelli,
Daniele Fournier,
Massimiliano Marangolo,
Etienne Balan,
Keevin Béneut,
Benoit Baptiste,
Béatrice Doisneau,
Nicola Marzari,
Francesco Mauri
Abstract:
The thermal conductivities of crystals and glasses vary strongly and with opposite trends upon heating, decreasing in crystals and increasing in glasses. Here, we show--both with first-principles predictions based on the Wigner transport equation and with thermoreflectance experiments--that the dominant transport mechanisms of crystals (particle-like propagation) and glasses (wave-like tunnelling)…
▽ More
The thermal conductivities of crystals and glasses vary strongly and with opposite trends upon heating, decreasing in crystals and increasing in glasses. Here, we show--both with first-principles predictions based on the Wigner transport equation and with thermoreflectance experiments--that the dominant transport mechanisms of crystals (particle-like propagation) and glasses (wave-like tunnelling) can coexist and compensate in materials with crystalline bond order and nearly glassy bond geometry. We demonstrate that ideal compensation emerges in a sample of silica in the form of tridymite, carved from a meteorite found in Steinbach (Germany) in 1724, and yields a "propagation-tunneling-invariant" (PTI) conductivity that is independent from temperature and intermediate between the opposite trends of $α$-quartz crystal and silica glass. We show how such PTI conductivity occurs in the quantum regime below the Debye temperature, and can largely persist at high temperatures in a geometrically amorphous tridymite phase found in refractory bricks fired for years in furnaces for steel smelting. Last, we discuss implications to heat transfer in solids exposed to extreme temperature variations, ranging from planetary cooling to heating protocols to reduce the carbon footprint of industrial furnaces.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
First-principles characterization of thermal conductivity in LaPO4-based alloys
Authors:
Anees Pazhedath,
Lorenzo Bastonero,
Nicola Marzari,
Michele Simoncelli
Abstract:
Alloys based on lanthanum phosphate (LaPO$_{4}$) are often employed as thermal barrier coatings, due to their low thermal conductivity and structural stability over a wide temperature range. To enhance the thermal-insulation performance of these alloys, it is essential to comprehensively understand the fundamental physics governing their heat conduction. Here, we employ the Wigner formulation of t…
▽ More
Alloys based on lanthanum phosphate (LaPO$_{4}$) are often employed as thermal barrier coatings, due to their low thermal conductivity and structural stability over a wide temperature range. To enhance the thermal-insulation performance of these alloys, it is essential to comprehensively understand the fundamental physics governing their heat conduction. Here, we employ the Wigner formulation of thermal transport in conjunction with first-principles calculations to elucidate how the interplay between anharmonicity and compositional disorder determines the thermal properties of La$_{1{-}x}$Gd$_{x}$PO$_{4}$ alloys, and discuss the fundamental physics underlying the emergence and coexistence of particle-like and wave-like heat-transport mechanisms. We also show how the Wigner transport equation describes correctly the thermodynamic limit of a compositionally disordered crystal, while the Boltzmann transport equation does not. Our predictions for microscopic vibrational properties (temperature-dependent Raman spectrum) and for macroscopic thermal conductivity are validated against experiments. Finally, we leverage these findings to devise strategies to optimize the performance of thermal barrier coatings.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2024; v1 submitted 19 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Viscous heat backflow and temperature resonances in extreme thermal conductors
Authors:
Jan Dragašević,
Michele Simoncelli
Abstract:
We demonstrate that non-diffusive, fluid-like heat transport, such as heat backflowing from cooler to warmer regions, can be induced, controlled, and amplified in extreme thermal conductors such as graphite and hexagonal boron nitride. We employ the viscous heat equations, i.e. the thermal counterpart of the Navier-Stokes equations in the laminar regime, to show with first-principles quantitative…
▽ More
We demonstrate that non-diffusive, fluid-like heat transport, such as heat backflowing from cooler to warmer regions, can be induced, controlled, and amplified in extreme thermal conductors such as graphite and hexagonal boron nitride. We employ the viscous heat equations, i.e. the thermal counterpart of the Navier-Stokes equations in the laminar regime, to show with first-principles quantitative accuracy that a finite thermal viscosity yields steady-state heat vortices, and governs the magnitude of transient temperature waves. Finally, we devise strategies that exploit devices' boundaries and resonance to amplify and control heat hydrodynamics, paving the way for novel experiments and applications in next-generation electronic and phononic technologies.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024; v1 submitted 22 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Vibrational and thermal properties of amorphous alumina from first principles
Authors:
Angela F. Harper,
Kamil Iwanowski,
William C. Witt,
Mike C. Payne,
Michele Simoncelli
Abstract:
Amorphous alumina is employed ubiquitously as a high-dielectric-constant material in electronics, and its thermal-transport properties are of key relevance for heat management in electronic chips and devices. Experiments show that the thermal conductivity of alumina depends significantly on the synthesis process, indicating the need for a theoretical study to elucidate the atomistic origin of thes…
▽ More
Amorphous alumina is employed ubiquitously as a high-dielectric-constant material in electronics, and its thermal-transport properties are of key relevance for heat management in electronic chips and devices. Experiments show that the thermal conductivity of alumina depends significantly on the synthesis process, indicating the need for a theoretical study to elucidate the atomistic origin of these variations. Here we employ first-principles simulations to characterize the atomistic structure, vibrational properties, and thermal conductivity of alumina at densities ranging from 2.28 g/cm3 to 3.49 g/cm3. Moreover, using an interatomic potential trained on first-principles data, we investigate how system size affects predictions of the thermal conductivity, showing that simulations containing 120 atoms can already reproduce the bulk limit of the conductivity. Finally, relying on the recently developed Wigner formulation of thermal transport, we shed light on the interplay between atomistic topological disorder and anharmonicity in the context of heat conduction, showing that the former dominates over the latter in determining the conductivity of alumina.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2023; v1 submitted 15 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Crossover from Boltzmann to Wigner thermal transport in thermoelectric skutterudites
Authors:
Enrico Di Lucente,
Michele Simoncelli,
Nicola Marzari
Abstract:
Skutterudites are crystals with a cage-like structure that can be augmented with filler atoms ("rattlers"), usually leading to a reduction in thermal conductivity that can be exploited for thermoelectric applications. Here, we leverage the recently introduced Wigner formulation of thermal transport to elucidate the microscopic physics underlying heat conduction in skutterudites, showing that fille…
▽ More
Skutterudites are crystals with a cage-like structure that can be augmented with filler atoms ("rattlers"), usually leading to a reduction in thermal conductivity that can be exploited for thermoelectric applications. Here, we leverage the recently introduced Wigner formulation of thermal transport to elucidate the microscopic physics underlying heat conduction in skutterudites, showing that filler atoms can drive a crossover from the Boltzmann to the Wigner regimes of thermal transport, i.e., from particle-like conduction to wave-like tunnelling. At temperatures where the thermoelectric efficiency of skutterudites is largest, wave-like tunneling can become comparable to particle-like propagation. We define a Boltzmann deviation descriptor able to differentiate the two regimes and relate the competition between the two mechanisms to the materials' chemistry, providing a design strategy to select rattlers and identify optimal compositions for thermoelectric applications.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2023; v1 submitted 13 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Thermal conductivity of glasses above the plateau: first-principles theory and applications
Authors:
Michele Simoncelli,
Francesco Mauri,
Nicola Marzari
Abstract:
Predicting the thermal conductivity of glasses from first principles has hitherto been a prohibitively complex problem. In fact, past works have highlighted challenges in achieving computational convergence with respect to length and/or time scales using either the established Allen-Feldman or Green-Kubo formulations, endorsing the concept that atomistic models containing thousands of atoms -- thu…
▽ More
Predicting the thermal conductivity of glasses from first principles has hitherto been a prohibitively complex problem. In fact, past works have highlighted challenges in achieving computational convergence with respect to length and/or time scales using either the established Allen-Feldman or Green-Kubo formulations, endorsing the concept that atomistic models containing thousands of atoms -- thus beyond the capabilities of first-principles calculations -- are needed to describe the thermal conductivity of glasses. In addition, these established formulations either neglect anharmonicity (Allen-Feldman) or miss the Bose-Einstein statistics of atomic vibrations (Green Kubo), thus leaving open the question on the relevance of these effects. Here, we present a first-principles formulation to address the thermal conductivity of glasses above the plateau, which can account comprehensively for the effects of structural disorder, anharmonicity, and quantum Bose-Einstein statistics. The protocol combines the Wigner formulation of thermal transport with convergence-acceleration techniques, and is validated in vitreous silica using both first-principles calculations and a quantum-accurate machine-learned interatomic potential. We show that models of vitreous silica containing less than 200 atoms can already reproduce the thermal conductivity in the macroscopic limit and that anharmonicity negligibly affects heat transport in vitreous silica. We discuss the microscopic quantities that determine the trend of the conductivity at high temperature, highlighting the agreement of the calculations with experiments in the temperature range above the plateau where radiative effects remain negligible (50<T <450 K).
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Many-body Green's function approach to lattice thermal transport
Authors:
Giovanni Caldarelli,
Michele Simoncelli,
Nicola Marzari,
Francesco Mauri,
Lara Benfatto
Abstract:
Recent progress in understanding thermal transport in complex crystals has highlighted the prominent role of heat conduction mediated by interband tunneling processes, which emerge between overlap** phonon bands (i.e. with energy differences smaller than their broadenings). These processes have recently been described in different ways, relying on the Wigner or Green-Kubo formalism, leading to a…
▽ More
Recent progress in understanding thermal transport in complex crystals has highlighted the prominent role of heat conduction mediated by interband tunneling processes, which emerge between overlap** phonon bands (i.e. with energy differences smaller than their broadenings). These processes have recently been described in different ways, relying on the Wigner or Green-Kubo formalism, leading to apparently different results which question the definition of the heat-current operator. Here, we implement a full quantum approach based on the Kubo formula, elucidating analogies and differences with the recently introduced Wigner or Green-Kubo formulations, and extending the description of thermal transport to the overdamped regime of atomic vibrations, where the phonon quasiparticle picture breaks down. We rely on first-principles calculations on complex crystals with ultralow conductivity to compare numerically the thermal conductivity obtained within the aforementioned approaches, showing that at least in the quasiparticle regime the differences are negligible for practical applications.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2022; v1 submitted 4 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Wigner formulation of thermal transport in solids
Authors:
Michele Simoncelli,
Nicola Marzari,
Francesco Mauri
Abstract:
Two different heat-transport mechanisms are discussed in solids: in crystals, heat carriers propagate and scatter particle-like as described by Peierls' formulation of the Boltzmann transport equation for phonon wavepackets. In glasses, instead, carriers behave wave-like, diffusing via a Zener-like tunneling between quasi-degenerate vibrational eigenstates, as described by the Allen-Feldman equati…
▽ More
Two different heat-transport mechanisms are discussed in solids: in crystals, heat carriers propagate and scatter particle-like as described by Peierls' formulation of the Boltzmann transport equation for phonon wavepackets. In glasses, instead, carriers behave wave-like, diffusing via a Zener-like tunneling between quasi-degenerate vibrational eigenstates, as described by the Allen-Feldman equation. Recently, it has been shown that these two conduction mechanisms emerge from a Wigner transport equation, which unifies and extends the Peierls-Boltzmann and Allen-Feldman formulations, allowing to describe also complex crystals where particle-like and wave-like conduction mechanisms coexist. Here, we discuss the theoretical foundations of such transport equation as is derived from the Wigner phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics, elucidating how the interplay between disorder, anharmonicity, and the quantum Bose-Einstein statistics of atomic vibrations determines thermal conductivity. This Wigner formulation argues for a preferential phase convention for the dynamical matrix in the reciprocal Bloch representation and related off-diagonal velocity operator's elements; such convention is the only one yielding a conductivity which is invariant with respect to the non-unique choice of the crystal's unit cell and is size-consistent. We rationalize the conditions determining the crossover from particle-like to wave-like heat conduction, showing that phonons below the Ioffe-Regel limit (i.e. with a mean free path shorter than the interatomic spacing) contribute to heat transport due to their wave-like capability to interfere and tunnel. Finally, we show that the present approach overcomes the failures of the Peierls-Boltzmann formulation for materials with ultralow or glass-like thermal conductivity.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2022; v1 submitted 13 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Generalization of Fourier's law into viscous heat equations
Authors:
Michele Simoncelli,
Nicola Marzari,
Andrea Cepellotti
Abstract:
Heat conduction in dielectric crystals originates from the propagation of atomic vibrations, whose microscopic dynamics is well described by the linearized phonon Boltzmann transport equation. Recently, it was shown that thermal conductivity can be resolved exactly and in a closed form as a sum over relaxons, $\mathit{i.e.}$ collective phonon excitations that are the eigenvectors of Boltzmann equa…
▽ More
Heat conduction in dielectric crystals originates from the propagation of atomic vibrations, whose microscopic dynamics is well described by the linearized phonon Boltzmann transport equation. Recently, it was shown that thermal conductivity can be resolved exactly and in a closed form as a sum over relaxons, $\mathit{i.e.}$ collective phonon excitations that are the eigenvectors of Boltzmann equation's scattering matrix [Cepellotti and Marzari, PRX $\mathbf{6}$ (2016)]. Relaxons have a well-defined parity, and only odd relaxons contribute to the thermal conductivity. Here, we show that the complementary set of even relaxons determines another quantity --- the thermal viscosity --- that enters into the description of heat transport, and is especially relevant in the hydrodynamic regime, where dissipation of crystal momentum by Umklapp scattering phases out. We also show how the thermal conductivity and viscosity parametrize two novel viscous heat equations --- two coupled equations for the temperature and drift-velocity fields --- which represent the thermal counterpart of the Navier-Stokes equations of hydrodynamics in the linear, laminar regime. These viscous heat equations are derived from a coarse-graining of the linearized Boltzmann transport equation for phonons, and encompass both limits of Fourier's law and of second sound, taking place, respectively, in the regimes of strong or weak momentum dissipation. Last, we introduce the Fourier deviation number as a descriptor that captures the deviations from Fourier's law due to hydrodynamic effects. We showcase these findings in a test case of a complex-shaped device made of graphite, obtaining a remarkable agreement with the very recent experimental demonstration of hydrodynamic transport in this material. The present findings also suggest that hydrodynamic behavior can appear at room temperature in micrometer-sized diamond crystals.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2019; v1 submitted 24 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Unified theory of thermal transport in crystals and disordered solids
Authors:
Michele Simoncelli,
Nicola Marzari,
Francesco Mauri
Abstract:
Crystals and glasses exhibit fundamentally different heat conduction mechanisms: the periodicity of crystals allows for the excitation of propagating vibrational waves that carry heat, as first discussed by Peierls; in glasses, the lack of periodicity breaks Peierls' picture and heat is mainly carried by the coupling of vibrational modes, often described by a harmonic theory introduced by Allen an…
▽ More
Crystals and glasses exhibit fundamentally different heat conduction mechanisms: the periodicity of crystals allows for the excitation of propagating vibrational waves that carry heat, as first discussed by Peierls; in glasses, the lack of periodicity breaks Peierls' picture and heat is mainly carried by the coupling of vibrational modes, often described by a harmonic theory introduced by Allen and Feldman. Anharmonicity or disorder are thus the limiting factors for thermal conductivity in crystals or glasses; hitherto, no transport equation has been able to account for both. Here, we derive such equation, resulting in a thermal conductivity that reduces to the Peierls and Allen-Feldman limits, respectively, in anharmonic-and-ordered or harmonic-and-disordered solids, while also covering the intermediate regimes where both effects are relevant. This approach also solves the long-standing problem of accurately predicting the thermal properties of crystals with ultralow or glass-like thermal conductivity, as we show with an application to a thermoelectric material representative of this class.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
