Supporting Bayesian modelling workflows with iterative filtering for multiverse analysis
Authors:
Anna Elisabeth Riha,
Nikolas Siccha,
Antti Oulasvirta,
Aki Vehtari
Abstract:
When building statistical models for Bayesian data analysis tasks, required and optional iterative adjustments and different modelling choices can give rise to numerous candidate models. In particular, checks and evaluations throughout the modelling process can motivate changes to an existing model or the consideration of alternative models to ultimately obtain models of sufficient quality for the…
▽ More
When building statistical models for Bayesian data analysis tasks, required and optional iterative adjustments and different modelling choices can give rise to numerous candidate models. In particular, checks and evaluations throughout the modelling process can motivate changes to an existing model or the consideration of alternative models to ultimately obtain models of sufficient quality for the problem at hand. Additionally, failing to consider alternative models can lead to overconfidence in the predictive or inferential ability of a chosen model. The search for suitable models requires modellers to work with multiple models without jeopardising the validity of their results. Multiverse analysis offers a framework for transparent creation of multiple models at once based on different sensible modelling choices, but the number of candidate models arising in the combination of iterations and possible modelling choices can become overwhelming in practice. Motivated by these challenges, this work proposes iterative filtering for multiverse analysis to support efficient and consistent assessment of multiple models and meaningful filtering towards fewer models of higher quality across different modelling contexts. Given that causal constraints have been taken into account, we show how multiverse analysis can be combined with recommendations from established Bayesian modelling workflows to identify promising candidate models by assessing predictive abilities and, if needed, tending to computational issues. We illustrate our suggested approach in different realistic modelling scenarios using real data examples.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
An importance sampling approach for reliable and efficient inference in Bayesian ordinary differential equation models
Authors:
Juho Timonen,
Nikolas Siccha,
Ben Bales,
Harri Lähdesmäki,
Aki Vehtari
Abstract:
Statistical models can involve implicitly defined quantities, such as solutions to nonlinear ordinary differential equations (ODEs), that unavoidably need to be numerically approximated in order to evaluate the model. The approximation error inherently biases statistical inference results, but the amount of this bias is generally unknown and often ignored in Bayesian parameter inference. We propos…
▽ More
Statistical models can involve implicitly defined quantities, such as solutions to nonlinear ordinary differential equations (ODEs), that unavoidably need to be numerically approximated in order to evaluate the model. The approximation error inherently biases statistical inference results, but the amount of this bias is generally unknown and often ignored in Bayesian parameter inference. We propose a computationally efficient method for verifying the reliability of posterior inference for such models, when the inference is performed using Markov chain Monte Carlo methods. We validate the efficiency and reliability of our workflow in experiments using simulated and real data, and different ODE solvers. We highlight problems that arise with commonly used adaptive ODE solvers, and propose robust and effective alternatives which, accompanied by our workflow, can now be taken into use without losing reliability of the inferences.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.