-
An Augmented Reality Application and User Study for Understanding and Learning Spatial Transformation Matrices
Authors:
Zohreh Shaghaghian,
Heather Burte,
Dezhen Song,
Wei Yan
Abstract:
Understanding spatial transformations and their mathematical representations are essential in computer-aided design, robotics, etc. This research has developed and tested an Augmented Reality (AR) application (BRICKxAR/T) to enhance students' learning of spatial transformation matrices. BRICKxAR/T leverages AR features, including information augmentation, physical-virtual object interplay, and emb…
▽ More
Understanding spatial transformations and their mathematical representations are essential in computer-aided design, robotics, etc. This research has developed and tested an Augmented Reality (AR) application (BRICKxAR/T) to enhance students' learning of spatial transformation matrices. BRICKxAR/T leverages AR features, including information augmentation, physical-virtual object interplay, and embodied learning, to create a novel and effective visualization experience for learning. BRICKxAR T has been evaluated as a learning intervention using LEGO models as example physical and virtual manipulatives in a user study to assess students' learning gains. The study compared AR (N=29) vs. non-AR (N=30) learning workshops with pre- and post-tests on Purdue Visualization of Rotations Test and math questions. Students' math scores significantly improved after participating in both workshops with the AR workshop tending to show greater improvements. The post-workshop survey showed students were inclined to think BRICKxAR/T an interesting and useful application, and they spent more time learning in AR than non-AR.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
BIMxAR: BIM-Empowered Augmented Reality for Learning Architectural Representations
Authors:
Ziad Ashour,
Zohreh Shaghaghian,
Wei Yan
Abstract:
Literature review shows limited research investigating the utilization of Augmented Reality (AR) to improve learning and understanding architectural representations, specifically section views. In this study, we present an AR system prototype (BIMxAR), its new and accurate building-scale registration method, and its novel visualization features that facilitate the comprehension of building constru…
▽ More
Literature review shows limited research investigating the utilization of Augmented Reality (AR) to improve learning and understanding architectural representations, specifically section views. In this study, we present an AR system prototype (BIMxAR), its new and accurate building-scale registration method, and its novel visualization features that facilitate the comprehension of building construction systems, materials configuration, and 3D section views of complex structures through the integration of AR, Building Information Modeling (BIM), and physical buildings. A pilot user study found improvements after students studied building section views in a physical building with AR, though not statistically significant, in terms of scores of the Santa Barbara Solids Test (SBST) and the Architectural Representations Test (ART). When incorporating time as a performance factor, the ART timed scores show a significant improvement in the posttest session. BIMxAR has the potential to enhance the students spatial abilities, particularly in understanding buildings and complex section views.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2022; v1 submitted 7 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Studying Buildings Outlines to Assess and Predict Energy Performance in Buildings: A Probabilistic Approach
Authors:
Zohreh Shaghaghian,
Fatemeh Shahsavari,
Elham Delzendeh
Abstract:
Building performance is commonly calculated during the last phases of design, where most design specifications get fixed and are unlikely to be majorly modified based on design programs. Predictive models could play a significant role in informing architects and designers of the impact of their design decisions on energy consumption in buildings during early design stages. A building outline is a…
▽ More
Building performance is commonly calculated during the last phases of design, where most design specifications get fixed and are unlikely to be majorly modified based on design programs. Predictive models could play a significant role in informing architects and designers of the impact of their design decisions on energy consumption in buildings during early design stages. A building outline is a significant predictor of the final energy consumption and is conceptually determined by architects in the early design phases. This paper evaluates the impact of a building's outline on energy consumption using synthetic data to achieve appropriate predictive models in estimating a building's energy consumption. Four office outlines are selected in this study, including square, T, U, and L shapes. Besides the shape parameter, other building features commonly used in literature (i.e., Window to Wall Ratio (WWR), external wall material properties, glazing U value, windows' shading depth, and building orientation) are utilized in generating data distribution with a probabilistic approach. The results show that buildings with square shapes, in general, are more energy-efficient compared to buildings with T, U, and L shapes of the same volume. Also, T, U, and L shape samples show very similar behavior in terms of energy consumption. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) is applied to assess the variables' correlations on data distribution; the results show that wall material specifications explain about 40% of data variation. Finally, we applied polynomial regression models with different degrees of complexity to predict the synthesized building models' energy consumptions based on their outlines. The results show that degree 2 polynomial models, fitting the data over 98% R squared (coefficient of determination), could be used to predict new samples with high accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2021; v1 submitted 16 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Learning Geometric Transformations for Parametric Design: An Augmented Reality (AR)-Powered Approach
Authors:
Zohreh Shaghaghian,
Heather Burte,
Dezhen Song,
Wei Yan
Abstract:
Despite the remarkable development of parametric modeling methods for architectural design, a significant problem still exists, which is the lack of knowledge and skill regarding the professional implementation of parametric design in architectural modeling. Considering the numerous advantages of digital/parametric modeling in rapid prototy** and simulation most instructors encourage students to…
▽ More
Despite the remarkable development of parametric modeling methods for architectural design, a significant problem still exists, which is the lack of knowledge and skill regarding the professional implementation of parametric design in architectural modeling. Considering the numerous advantages of digital/parametric modeling in rapid prototy** and simulation most instructors encourage students to use digital modeling even from the early stages of design; however, an appropriate context to learn the basics of digital design thinking is rarely provided in architectural pedagogy. This paper presents an educational tool, specifically an Augmented Reality (AR) intervention, to help students understand the fundamental concepts of para-metric modeling before diving into complex parametric modeling platforms. The goal of the AR intervention is to illustrate geometric transformation and the associated math functions so that students learn the mathematical logic behind the algorithmic thinking of parametric modeling. We have developed BRICKxAR_T, an educational AR prototype, that intends to help students learn geometric transformations in an immersive spatial AR environment. A LEGO set is used within the AR intervention as a physical manipulative to support physical interaction and im-prove spatial skill through body gesture.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
A Machine-learning Framework for Acoustic Design Assessment in Early Design Stages
Authors:
Reyhane Abarghooie,
Zahra Sadat Zomorodian,
Mohammad Tahsildoost,
Zohreh Shaghaghian
Abstract:
In time-cost scale model studies, predicting acoustic performance by using simulation methods is a commonly used method that is preferred. In this field, building acoustic simulation tools are complicated by several challenges, including the high cost of acoustic tools, the need for acoustic expertise, and the time-consuming process of acoustic simulation. The goal of this project is to introduce…
▽ More
In time-cost scale model studies, predicting acoustic performance by using simulation methods is a commonly used method that is preferred. In this field, building acoustic simulation tools are complicated by several challenges, including the high cost of acoustic tools, the need for acoustic expertise, and the time-consuming process of acoustic simulation. The goal of this project is to introduce a simple model with a short calculation time to estimate the room acoustic condition in the early design stages of the building. This paper presents a working prototype for a new method of machine learning (ML) to approximate a series of typical room acoustic parameters using only geometric data as input characteristics. A novel dataset consisting of acoustical simulations of a single room with 2916 different configurations are used to train and test the proposed model. In the stimulation process, features that include room dimensions, window size, material absorption coefficient, furniture, and shading type have been analysed by using Pachyderm acoustic software. The mentioned dataset is used as the input of seven machine-learning models based on fully connected Deep Neural Networks (DNN). The average error of ML models is between 1% to 3%, and the average error of the new predicted samples after the validation process is between 2% to 12%.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
A machine-learning framework for daylight and visual comfort assessment in early design stages
Authors:
Hanieh Nourkojouri,
Zahra Sadat Zomorodian,
Mohammad Tahsildoost,
Zohreh Shaghaghian
Abstract:
This research is mainly focused on the assessment of machine learning algorithms in the prediction of daylight and visual comfort metrics in the early design stages. A dataset was primarily developed from 2880 simulations derived from Honeybee for Grasshopper. The simulations were done for a shoebox space with a one side window. The alternatives emerged from different physical features, including…
▽ More
This research is mainly focused on the assessment of machine learning algorithms in the prediction of daylight and visual comfort metrics in the early design stages. A dataset was primarily developed from 2880 simulations derived from Honeybee for Grasshopper. The simulations were done for a shoebox space with a one side window. The alternatives emerged from different physical features, including room dimensions, interior surfaces reflectance, window dimensions and orientations, number of windows, and shading states. 5 metrics were used for daylight evaluations, including UDI, sDA, mDA, ASE, and sVD. Quality Views were analyzed for the same shoebox spaces via a grasshopper-based algorithm, developed from the LEED v4 evaluation framework for Quality Views. The dataset was further analyzed with an Artificial Neural Network algorithm written in Python. The accuracy of the predictions was estimated at 97% on average. The developed model could be used in early design stages analyses without the need for time-consuming simulations in previously used platforms and programs.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Application of Classification and Feature Selection in Building Energy Simulations
Authors:
Fatemeh Shahsavari,
Zohreh Shaghaghian
Abstract:
Building energy performance is one of the key features in performance-based building design decision making. Building envelope materials can play a key role in improving building energy performance. The thermal properties of building materials determine the level of heat transfer through building envelope, thus the annual thermal energy performance of the building. This research applies the Linear…
▽ More
Building energy performance is one of the key features in performance-based building design decision making. Building envelope materials can play a key role in improving building energy performance. The thermal properties of building materials determine the level of heat transfer through building envelope, thus the annual thermal energy performance of the building. This research applies the Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) method to study the effects of materials' thermal properties on building thermal loads. Two approaches are adopted for feature selection including the Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and the Exhaustive Feature Selection (EFS). A hypothetical design scenario is developed with six material alternatives for an office building in Los Angeles, California. The best design alternative is selected based on the LDA results and the key input parameters are determined based on the PCA and EFS methods. The PCA results confirm that among all thermal properties of the materials, the four parameters including thermal conductivity, density, specific heat capacity, and thickness are the most critical features, in terms of building thermal behavior and thermal energy consumption. This result matches quite well with the assumptions of most of the building energy simulation tools.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Towards Learning Geometric Transformations through Play: An AR-powered approach
Authors:
Zohreh Shaghaghian,
Wei Yan,
Dezhen Song
Abstract:
Despite the excessive developments of architectural parametric platforms, parametric design is often interpreted as an architectural style rather than a computational method. Also, the problem is still a lack of knowledge and skill about the technical application of parametric design in architectural modelling. Students often dive into utilizing complex digital modelling without having a competent…
▽ More
Despite the excessive developments of architectural parametric platforms, parametric design is often interpreted as an architectural style rather than a computational method. Also, the problem is still a lack of knowledge and skill about the technical application of parametric design in architectural modelling. Students often dive into utilizing complex digital modelling without having a competent pedagogical context to learn algorithmic thinking and the corresponding logic behind digital and parametric modelling. The insufficient skills and superficial knowledge often result in utilizing the modelling software through trial and error, not taking full advantage of what it has to offer. Geometric transformations as the fundamental functions of parametric modelling is explored in this study to anchor learning essential components in parametric modelling. Students need to understand the differences between variables, parameters, functions and their relations. Fologram, an Augmented Reality tool, is utilized in this study to learn geometric transformation and its components in an intuitive way. A LEGO set is used as an editable physical model to improve spatial skill through hand movement beside an instant feedback in the physical environment.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Application of Deep Learning in Generating Desired Design Options: Experiments Using Synthetic Training Dataset
Authors:
Zohreh Shaghaghian,
Wei Yan
Abstract:
Most design methods contain a forward framework, asking for primary specifications of a building to generate an output or assess its performance. However, architects urge for specific objectives though uncertain of the proper design parameters. Deep Learning (DL) algorithms provide an intelligent workflow in which the system can learn from sequential training experiments. This study applies a meth…
▽ More
Most design methods contain a forward framework, asking for primary specifications of a building to generate an output or assess its performance. However, architects urge for specific objectives though uncertain of the proper design parameters. Deep Learning (DL) algorithms provide an intelligent workflow in which the system can learn from sequential training experiments. This study applies a method using DL algorithms towards generating demanded design options. In this study, an object recognition problem is investigated to initially predict the label of unseen sample images based on training dataset consisting of different types of synthetic 2D shapes; later, a generative DL algorithm is applied to be trained and generate new shapes for given labels. In the next step, the algorithm is trained to generate a window/wall pattern for desired light/shadow performance based on the spatial daylight autonomy (sDA) metrics. The experiments show promising results both in predicting unseen sample shapes and generating new design options.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2021; v1 submitted 27 December, 2019;
originally announced January 2020.
