Showing 1–29 of 29 results for author: Shachnai, H

Approximations and Hardness of Packing Partially Ordered Items

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Guy Kortsarz, Joseph Naor, Baruch Schieber, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: Motivated by applications in production planning and storage allocation in hierarchical databases, we initiate the study of covering partially ordered items (CPO). Given a capacity $k \in \mathbb{Z}^+$, and a directed graph $G=(V,E)$ where each vertex has a size in $\{0,1, \ldots,k\}$, we seek a collection of subsets of vertices $S_1, \ldots, S_m$ that cover all the vertices, such that for any… ▽ More Motivated by applications in production planning and storage allocation in hierarchical databases, we initiate the study of covering partially ordered items (CPO). Given a capacity $k \in \mathbb{Z}^+$, and a directed graph $G=(V,E)$ where each vertex has a size in $\{0,1, \ldots,k\}$, we seek a collection of subsets of vertices $S_1, \ldots, S_m$ that cover all the vertices, such that for any $1 \leq j \leq m$, the total size of vertices in $S_j$ is bounded by $k$, and there are no edges from $V \setminus S_j$ to $S_j$. The objective is to minimize the number of subsets $m$. CPO is closely related to the rule caching problem (RCP) that is of wide interest in the networking area. The input for RCP is a directed graph $G=(V,E)$, a profit function $p:V \rightarrow \mathbb{Z}_{0}^+$, and $k \in \mathbb{Z}^+$. The output is a subset $S \subseteq V$ of maximum profit such that $|S| \leq k$ and there are no edges from $V \setminus S$ to $S$. Our main result is a $2$-approximation algorithm for CPO on out-trees, complemented by an asymptotic $1.5$-hardness of approximation result. We also give a two-way reduction between RCP and the densest $k$-subhypergraph problem, surprisingly showing that the problems are equivalent w.r.t. polynomial-time approximation within any factor $ρ\geq 1$. This implies that RCP cannot be approximated within factor $|V|^{1-\eps}$ for any fixed $\eps>0$, under standard complexity assumptions. Prior to this work, RCP was just known to be strongly NP-hard. We further show that there is no EPTAS for the special case of RCP where the profits are uniform, assuming Gap-ETH. Since this variant admits a PTAS, we essentially resolve the complexity status of this problem. △ Less

Submitted 3 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

An EPTAS for Cardinality Constrained Multiple Knapsack via Iterative Randomized Rounding

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: In [Math. Oper. Res., 2011], Fleischer et al. introduced a powerful technique for solving the generic class of separable assignment problems (SAP), in which a set of items of given values and weights needs to be packed into a set of bins subject to separable assignment constraints, so as to maximize the total value. The approach of Fleischer at al. relies on solving a configuration LP and sampling… ▽ More In [Math. Oper. Res., 2011], Fleischer et al. introduced a powerful technique for solving the generic class of separable assignment problems (SAP), in which a set of items of given values and weights needs to be packed into a set of bins subject to separable assignment constraints, so as to maximize the total value. The approach of Fleischer at al. relies on solving a configuration LP and sampling a configuration for each bin independently based on the LP solution. While there is a SAP variant for which this approach yields the best possible approximation ratio, for various special cases, there are discrepancies between the approximation ratios obtained using the above approach and the state-of-the-art approximations. This raises the following natural question: Can we do better by iteratively solving the configuration LP and sampling a few bins at a time? To assess the potential gain from iterative randomized rounding, we consider as a case study one interesting SAP variant, namely, Uniform Cardinality Constrained Multiple Knapsack, for which we answer this question affirmatively. The input is a set of items, each has a value and a weight, and a set of uniform capacity bins. The goal is to assign a subset of the items of maximum total value to the bins such that $(i)$ the capacity of any bin is not exceeded, and $(ii)$ the number of items assigned to each bin satisfies a given cardinality constraint. While the technique of Fleischer et al. yields a $\left(1-\frac{1}{e}\right)$-approximation for the problem, we show that iterative randomized rounding leads to an efficient polynomial time approximation scheme (EPTAS), thus essentially resolving the complexity status of the problem. Our analysis of iterative randomized rounding can be useful for solving other SAP variants. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2024; v1 submitted 24 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Tight Bounds for Budgeted Maximum Weight Independent Set in Bipartite and Perfect Graphs

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We consider the classic budgeted maximum weight independent set (BMWIS) problem. The input is a graph $G = (V,E)$, a weight function $w:V \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, a cost function $c:V \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, and a budget $B \in \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$. The goal is to find an independent set $S \subseteq V$ in $G$ such that $\sum_{v \in S} c(v) \leq B$, which maximizes the total wei… ▽ More We consider the classic budgeted maximum weight independent set (BMWIS) problem. The input is a graph $G = (V,E)$, a weight function $w:V \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, a cost function $c:V \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, and a budget $B \in \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$. The goal is to find an independent set $S \subseteq V$ in $G$ such that $\sum_{v \in S} c(v) \leq B$, which maximizes the total weight $\sum_{v \in S} w(v)$. Since the problem on general graphs cannot be approximated within ratio $|V|^{1-\varepsilon}$ for any $\varepsilon>0$, BMWIS has attracted significant attention on graph families for which a maximum weight independent set can be computed in polynomial time. Two notable such graph families are bipartite and perfect graphs. BMWIS is known to be NP-hard on both of these graph families; however, the best possible approximation guarantees for these graphs are wide open. In this paper, we give a tight $2$-approximation for BMWIS on perfect graphs and bipartite graphs. In particular, we give We a $(2-\varepsilon)$ lower bound for BMWIS on bipartite graphs, already for the special case where the budget is replaced by a cardinality constraint, based on the Small Set Expansion Hypothesis (SSEH). For the upper bound, we design a $2$-approximation for BMWIS on perfect graphs using a Lagrangian relaxation based technique. Finally, we obtain a tight lower bound for the capacitated maximum weight independent set (CMWIS) problem, the special case of BMWIS where $w(v) = c(v)~\forall v \in V$. We show that CMWIS on bipartite and perfect graphs is unlikely to admit an efficient polynomial-time approximation scheme (EPTAS). Thus, the existing PTAS for CMWIS is essentially the best we can expect. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Lower Bounds for Matroid Optimization Problems with a Linear Constraint

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study a family of matroid optimization problems with a linear constraint (MOL). In these problems, we seek a subset of elements which optimizes (i.e., maximizes or minimizes) a linear objective function subject to (i) a matroid independent set, or a matroid basis constraint, (ii) additional linear constraint. A notable member in this family is budgeted matroid independent set (BM), which can be… ▽ More We study a family of matroid optimization problems with a linear constraint (MOL). In these problems, we seek a subset of elements which optimizes (i.e., maximizes or minimizes) a linear objective function subject to (i) a matroid independent set, or a matroid basis constraint, (ii) additional linear constraint. A notable member in this family is budgeted matroid independent set (BM), which can be viewed as classic $0/1$-knapsack with a matroid constraint. While special cases of BM, such as knapsack with cardinality constraint and multiple-choice knapsack, admit a fully polynomial-time approximation scheme (Fully PTAS), the best known result for BM on a general matroid is an Efficient PTAS. Prior to this work, the existence of a Fully PTAS for BM, and more generally, for any problem in the family of MOL problems, has been open. In this paper, we answer this question negatively by showing that none of the (non-trivial) problems in this family admits a Fully PTAS. This resolves the complexity status of several well studied problems. Our main result is obtained by showing first that exact weight matroid basis (EMB) does not admit a pseudo-polynomial time algorithm. This distinguishes EMB from the special cases of $k$-subset sum and EMB on a linear matroid, which are solvable in pseudo-polynomial time. We then obtain unconditional hardness results for the family of MOL problems in the oracle model (even if randomization is allowed), and show that the same results hold when the matroids are encoded as part of the input, assuming $P \neq NP$. For the hardness proof of EMB, we introduce the $Π$-matroid family. This intricate subclass of matroids, which exploits the interaction between a weight function and the matroid constraint, may find use in tackling other matroid optimization problems. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2024; v1 submitted 15 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Budgeted Matroid Maximization: a Parameterized Viewpoint

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study budgeted variants of well known maximization problems with multiple matroid constraints. Given an $\ell$-matchoid $\cm$ on a ground set $E$, a profit function $p:E \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, a cost function $c:E \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, and a budget $B \in \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, the goal is to find in the $\ell$-matchoid a feasible set $S$ of maximum profit $p(S)$ subject t… ▽ More We study budgeted variants of well known maximization problems with multiple matroid constraints. Given an $\ell$-matchoid $\cm$ on a ground set $E$, a profit function $p:E \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, a cost function $c:E \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, and a budget $B \in \mathbb{R}_{\geq 0}$, the goal is to find in the $\ell$-matchoid a feasible set $S$ of maximum profit $p(S)$ subject to the budget constraint, i.e., $c(S) \leq B$. The {\em budgeted $\ell$-matchoid} (BM) problem includes as special cases budgeted $\ell$-dimensional matching and budgeted $\ell$-matroid intersection. A strong motivation for studying BM from parameterized viewpoint comes from the APX-hardness of unbudgeted $\ell$-dimensional matching (i.e., $B = \infty$) already for $\ell = 3$. Nevertheless, while there are known FPT algorithms for the unbudgeted variants of the above problems, the {\em budgeted} variants are studied here for the first time through the lens of parameterized complexity. We show that BM parametrized by solution size is $W[1]$-hard, already with a degenerate single matroid constraint. Thus, an exact parameterized algorithm is unlikely to exist, motivating the study of {\em FPT-approximation schemes} (FPAS). Our main result is an FPAS for BM (implying an FPAS for $\ell$-dimensional matching and budgeted $\ell$-matroid intersection), relying on the notion of representative set $-$ a small cardinality subset of elements which preserves the optimum up to a small factor. We also give a lower bound on the minimum possible size of a representative set which can be computed in polynomial time. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Improved Approximation for Two-dimensional Vector Multiple Knapsack

Authors: Tomer Cohen, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study the uniform $2$-dimensional vector multiple knapsack (2VMK) problem, a natural variant of multiple knapsack arising in real-world applications such as virtual machine placement. The input for 2VMK is a set of items, each associated with a $2$-dimensional weight vector and a positive profit, along with $m$ $2$-dimensional bins of uniform (unit) capacity in each dimension. The goal is to fi… ▽ More We study the uniform $2$-dimensional vector multiple knapsack (2VMK) problem, a natural variant of multiple knapsack arising in real-world applications such as virtual machine placement. The input for 2VMK is a set of items, each associated with a $2$-dimensional weight vector and a positive profit, along with $m$ $2$-dimensional bins of uniform (unit) capacity in each dimension. The goal is to find an assignment of a subset of the items to the bins, such that the total weight of items assigned to a single bin is at most one in each dimension, and the total profit is maximized. Our main result is a $(1- \frac{\ln 2}{2} - \varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm for 2VMK, for every fixed $\varepsilon > 0$, thus improving the best known ratio of $(1 - \frac{1}{e}-\varepsilon)$ which follows as a special case from a result of [Fleischer at al., MOR 2011]. Our algorithm relies on an adaptation of the Round$\&$Approx framework of [Bansal et al., SICOMP 2010], originally designed for set covering problems, to maximization problems. The algorithm uses randomized rounding of a configuration-LP solution to assign items to $\approx m\cdot \ln 2 \approx 0.693\cdot m$ of the bins, followed by a reduction to the ($1$-dimensional) Multiple Knapsack problem for assigning items to the remaining bins. △ Less

Submitted 5 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

An FPTAS for Budgeted Laminar Matroid Independent Set

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study the budgeted laminar matroid independent set problem. The input is a ground set, where each element has a cost and a non-negative profit, along with a laminar matroid over the elements and a budget. The goal is to select a maximum profit independent set of the matroid whose total cost is bounded by the budget. Several well known special cases, where we have, e.g., no matroid constraint (t… ▽ More We study the budgeted laminar matroid independent set problem. The input is a ground set, where each element has a cost and a non-negative profit, along with a laminar matroid over the elements and a budget. The goal is to select a maximum profit independent set of the matroid whose total cost is bounded by the budget. Several well known special cases, where we have, e.g., no matroid constraint (the classic knapsack problem) or a uniform matroid constraint (knapsack with a cardinality constraint), admit a fully polynomial-time approximation scheme (FPTAS). In contrast, the budgeted matroid independent set (BMI) problem with a general matroid has an efficient polynomial-time approximation scheme (EPTAS) but does not admit an FPTAS. This implies an EPTAS for our problem, which is the best known result prior to this work. We present an FPTAS for budgeted laminar matroid independent set, improving the previous EPTAS for this matroid family and generalizing the FPTAS known for knapsack with a cardinality constraint and multiple-choice knapsack. Our scheme is based on a simple dynamic program which utilizes the tree-like structure of laminar matroids. △ Less

Submitted 27 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Approximating Bin Packing with Conflict Graphs via Maximization Techniques

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We give a comprehensive study of bin packing with conflicts (BPC). The input is a set $I$ of items, sizes $s:I \rightarrow [0,1]$, and a conflict graph $G = (I,E)$. The goal is to find a partition of $I$ into a minimum number of independent sets, each of total size at most $1$. Being a generalization of the notoriously hard graph coloring problem, BPC has been studied mostly on polynomially colora… ▽ More We give a comprehensive study of bin packing with conflicts (BPC). The input is a set $I$ of items, sizes $s:I \rightarrow [0,1]$, and a conflict graph $G = (I,E)$. The goal is to find a partition of $I$ into a minimum number of independent sets, each of total size at most $1$. Being a generalization of the notoriously hard graph coloring problem, BPC has been studied mostly on polynomially colorable conflict graphs. An intriguing open question is whether BPC on such graphs admits the same best known approximation guarantees as classic bin packing. We answer this question negatively, by showing that (in contrast to bin packing) there is no asymptotic polynomial-time approximation scheme (APTAS) for BPC already on seemingly easy graph classes, such as bipartite and split graphs. We complement this result with improved approximation guarantees for BPC on several prominent graph classes. Most notably, we derive an asymptotic $1.391$-approximation for bipartite graphs, a $2.445$-approximation for perfect graphs, and a $\left(1+\frac{2}{e}\right)$-approximation for split graphs. To this end, we introduce a generic framework relying on a novel interpretation of BPC allowing us to solve the problem via maximization techniques. Our framework may find use in tackling BPC on other graph classes arising in applications. △ Less

Submitted 21 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Finding Possible and Necessary Winners in Spatial Voting with Partial Information

Authors: Aviram Imber, Jonas Israel, Markus Brill, Hadas Shachnai, Benny Kimelfeld

Abstract: We consider spatial voting where candidates are located in the Euclidean $d$-dimensional space and each voter ranks candidates based on their distance from the voter's ideal point. We explore the case where information about the location of voters' ideal points is incomplete: for each dimension, we are given an interval of possible values. We study the computational complexity of computing the pos… ▽ More We consider spatial voting where candidates are located in the Euclidean $d$-dimensional space and each voter ranks candidates based on their distance from the voter's ideal point. We explore the case where information about the location of voters' ideal points is incomplete: for each dimension, we are given an interval of possible values. We study the computational complexity of computing the possible and necessary winners for positional scoring rules. Our results show that we retain tractable cases of the classic model where voters have partial-order preferences. Moreover, we show that there are positional scoring rules under which the possible-winner problem is intractable for partial orders, but tractable in the one-dimension spatial setting (while intractable in higher fixed number of dimensions). △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

An EPTAS for Budgeted Matching and Budgeted Matroid Intersection

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study the budgeted versions of the well known matching and matroid intersection problems. While both problems admit a polynomial-time approximation scheme (PTAS) [Berger et al. (Math. Programming, 2011), Chekuri, Vondrak and Zenklusen (SODA 2011)], it has been an intriguing open question whether these problems admit a fully PTAS (FPTAS), or even an efficient PTAS (EPTAS). In this paper we ans… ▽ More We study the budgeted versions of the well known matching and matroid intersection problems. While both problems admit a polynomial-time approximation scheme (PTAS) [Berger et al. (Math. Programming, 2011), Chekuri, Vondrak and Zenklusen (SODA 2011)], it has been an intriguing open question whether these problems admit a fully PTAS (FPTAS), or even an efficient PTAS (EPTAS). In this paper we answer the second part of this question affirmatively, by presenting an EPTAS for budgeted matching and budgeted matroid intersection. A main component of our scheme is a novel construction of representative sets for desired solutions, whose cardinality depends only on $\varepsilon$, the accuracy parameter. Thus, enumerating over solutions within a representative set leads to an EPTAS. This crucially distinguishes our algorithms from previous approaches, which rely on exhaustive enumeration over the solution set. Our ideas for constructing representative sets may find use in tackling other budgeted optimization problems, and are thus of independent interest. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Bin Packing with Partition Matroid can be Approximated within $o(OPT)$ Bins

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We consider the Bin Packing problem with a partition matroid constraint. The input is a set of items of sizes in $(0,1]$, and a partition matroid over the items. The goal is to pack all items in a minimum number of unit-size bins, such that each bin forms an independent set in the matroid. The problem is a generalization of both Group Bin Packing and Bin Packing with Cardinality Constraints. Bin P… ▽ More We consider the Bin Packing problem with a partition matroid constraint. The input is a set of items of sizes in $(0,1]$, and a partition matroid over the items. The goal is to pack all items in a minimum number of unit-size bins, such that each bin forms an independent set in the matroid. The problem is a generalization of both Group Bin Packing and Bin Packing with Cardinality Constraints. Bin Packing with Partition Matroid naturally arises in resource allocation to ensure fault tolerance and security, as well as in harvesting computing capacity. Our main result is a polynomial-time algorithm that packs the items in $OPT + o(OPT)$ bins, where OPT is the minimum number of bins required for packing the given instance. This matches the best known result for the classic Bin Packing problem up to the function hidden by o(OPT). As special cases, our result improves upon the existing APTAS for Group Bin Packing and generalizes the AFTPAS for Bin Packing with Cardinality Constraints. Our approach is based on rounding a solution for a configuration-LP formulation of the problem. The rounding takes a novel point of view of prototypes in which items are interpreted as placeholders for other items and applies fractional grou** to modify a fractional solution (prototype) into one having nice integrality properties. △ Less

Submitted 14 May, 2023; v1 submitted 2 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

An EPTAS for Budgeted Matroid Independent Set

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We consider the budgeted matroid independent set problem. The input is a ground set, where each element has a cost and a non-negative profit, along with a matroid over the elements and a budget. The goal is to select a subset of elements which maximizes the total profit subject to the matroid and budget constraints. Several well known special cases, where we have, e.g., a uniform matroid and a bud… ▽ More We consider the budgeted matroid independent set problem. The input is a ground set, where each element has a cost and a non-negative profit, along with a matroid over the elements and a budget. The goal is to select a subset of elements which maximizes the total profit subject to the matroid and budget constraints. Several well known special cases, where we have, e.g., a uniform matroid and a budget, or no matroid constraint (i.e., the classic knapsack problem), admit a fully polynomial-time approximation scheme (FPTAS). In contrast, already a slight generalization to the multi-budgeted matroid independent set problem has a PTAS but does not admit an efficient polynomial-time approximation scheme (EPTAS). This implies a PTAS for our problem, which is the best known result prior to this work. Our main contribution is an EPTAS for the budgeted matroid independent set problem. A key idea of the scheme is to find a representative set for the instance, whose cardinality depends solely on $1/\varepsilon$, where $\varepsilon > 0$ is the accuracy parameter of the scheme. The representative set is identified via matroid basis minimization, which can be solved by a simple greedy algorithm. Our scheme enumerates over subsets of the representative set and extends each subset using a linear program. The notion of representative sets may be useful in solving other variants of the budgeted matroid independent set problem. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Improved Approximations for Vector Bin Packing via Iterative Randomized Rounding

Authors: Ariel Kulik, Matthias Mnich, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study the $d$-dimensional Vector Bin Packing ($d$VBP) problem, a generalization of Bin Packing with central applications in resource allocation and scheduling. In $d$VBP, we are given a set of items, each of which is characterized by a $d$-dimensional volume vector; the objective is to partition the items into a minimum number of subsets (bins), such that the total volume of items in each subse… ▽ More We study the $d$-dimensional Vector Bin Packing ($d$VBP) problem, a generalization of Bin Packing with central applications in resource allocation and scheduling. In $d$VBP, we are given a set of items, each of which is characterized by a $d$-dimensional volume vector; the objective is to partition the items into a minimum number of subsets (bins), such that the total volume of items in each subset is at most $1$ in each dimension. Our main result is an asymptotic approximation algorithm for $d$VBP that yields a ratio of $(1+\ln d-χ(d) +\varepsilon)$ for all $d \in \mathbb{N}$ and any $\varepsilon > 0$; here, $χ(d)$ is some strictly positive function. This improves upon the best known asymptotic ratio of $ \left(1+ \ln d +\varepsilon\right)$ due to Bansal, Caprara and Sviridenko (SICOMP 2010) for any $d >3$. By slightly modifying our algorithm to include an initial matching phase and applying a tighter analysis we obtain an asymptotic approximation ratio of $\left(\frac{4}{3}+\varepsilon\right)$ for the special case of $d=2$, thus substantially improving the previous best ratio of $\left(\frac{3}{2}+\varepsilon\right)$ due to Bansal, Elias and Khan (SODA 2016). Our algorithm iteratively solves a configuration LP relaxation for the residual instance (from previous iterations) and samples a small number of configurations based on the solution for the configuration LP. While iterative rounding was already used by Karmarkar and Karp (FOCS 1982) to establish their celebrated result for classic (one-dimensional) Bin Packing, iterative randomized rounding is used here for the first time in the context of (Vector) Bin Packing. Our results show that iterative randomized rounding is a powerful tool for approximating $d$VBP, leading to simple algorithms with improved approximation guarantees. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2023; v1 submitted 25 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

A Refined Analysis of Submodular Greedy

Authors: Ariel Kulik, Roy Schwartz, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: Many algorithms for maximizing a monotone submodular function subject to a knapsack constraint rely on the natural greedy heuristic. We present a novel refined analysis of this greedy heuristic which enables us to: $(1)$ reduce the enumeration in the tight $(1-e^{-1})$-approximation of [Sviridenko 04] from subsets of size three to two; $(2)$ present an improved upper bound of $0.42945$ for the cla… ▽ More Many algorithms for maximizing a monotone submodular function subject to a knapsack constraint rely on the natural greedy heuristic. We present a novel refined analysis of this greedy heuristic which enables us to: $(1)$ reduce the enumeration in the tight $(1-e^{-1})$-approximation of [Sviridenko 04] from subsets of size three to two; $(2)$ present an improved upper bound of $0.42945$ for the classic algorithm which returns the better between a single element and the output of the greedy heuristic. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2021; v1 submitted 25 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

An APTAS for Bin Packing with Clique-graph Conflicts

Authors: Ilan Doron-Arad, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study the following variant of the classic {\em bin packing} problem. Given a set of items of various sizes, partitioned into groups, find a packing of the items in a minimum number of identical (unit-size) bins, such that no two items of the same group are assigned to the same bin. This problem, known as {\em bin packing with clique-graph conflicts}, has natural applications in storing file re… ▽ More We study the following variant of the classic {\em bin packing} problem. Given a set of items of various sizes, partitioned into groups, find a packing of the items in a minimum number of identical (unit-size) bins, such that no two items of the same group are assigned to the same bin. This problem, known as {\em bin packing with clique-graph conflicts}, has natural applications in storing file replicas, security in cloud computing and signal distribution. Our main result is an {\em asymptotic polynomial time approximation scheme (APTAS)} for the problem, improving upon the best known ratio of $2$. %In particular, for any instance $I$ and a fixed $\eps \in (0,1)$, the items are packed in at most $(1+\eps)OPT(I) +1$ bins, where $OPT(I)$ is the minimum number of bins required for packing the instance. As a key tool, we apply a novel {\em Shift \& Swap} technique which generalizes the classic linear shifting technique to scenarios allowing conflicts between items. The major challenge of packing {\em small} items using only a small number of extra bins is tackled through an intricate combination of enumeration and a greedy-based approach that utilizes the rounded solution of a {\em linear program}. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2021; v1 submitted 9 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Modular and Submodular Optimization with Multiple Knapsack Constraints via Fractional Grou**

Authors: Yaron Fairstein, Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: A multiple knapsack constraint over a set of items is defined by a set of bins of arbitrary capacities, and a weight for each of the items. An assignment for the constraint is an allocation of subsets of items to the bins which adheres to bin capacities. In this paper we present a unified algorithm that yields efficient approximations for a wide class of submodular and modular optimization problem… ▽ More A multiple knapsack constraint over a set of items is defined by a set of bins of arbitrary capacities, and a weight for each of the items. An assignment for the constraint is an allocation of subsets of items to the bins which adheres to bin capacities. In this paper we present a unified algorithm that yields efficient approximations for a wide class of submodular and modular optimization problems involving multiple knapsack constraints. One notable example is a polynomial time approximation scheme for Multiple-Choice Multiple Knapsack, improving upon the best known ratio of $2$. Another example is Non-monotone Submodular Multiple Knapsack, for which we obtain a $(0.385-\varepsilon)$-approximation, matching the best known ratio for a single knapsack constraint. The robustness of our algorithm is achieved by applying a novel fractional variant of the classical linear grou** technique, which is of independent interest. △ Less

Submitted 28 June, 2021; v1 submitted 20 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

An Almost Optimal Approximation Algorithm for Monotone Submodular Multiple Knapsack

Authors: Yaron Fairstein, Ariel Kulik, Joseph, Naor, Danny Raz, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study the problem of maximizing a monotone submodular function subject to a Multiple Knapsack constraint. The input is a set $I$ of items, each has a non-negative weight, and a set of bins of arbitrary capacities. Also, we are given a submodular, monotone and non-negative function $f$ over subsets of the items. The objective is to find a packing of a subset of items $A \subseteq I$ in the bins… ▽ More We study the problem of maximizing a monotone submodular function subject to a Multiple Knapsack constraint. The input is a set $I$ of items, each has a non-negative weight, and a set of bins of arbitrary capacities. Also, we are given a submodular, monotone and non-negative function $f$ over subsets of the items. The objective is to find a packing of a subset of items $A \subseteq I$ in the bins such that $f(A)$ is maximized. Our main result is an almost optimal polynomial time $(1-e^{-1}-\varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm for the problem, for any $\varepsilon>0$. The algorithm relies on a structuring technique which converts a general multiple knapsack constraint to a constraint in which the bins are partitioned into groups of exponentially increasing cardinalities, each consisting of bins of uniform capacity. We derive the result by combining structuring with a refined analysis of techniques for submodular optimization subject to knapsack constraints. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2021; v1 submitted 25 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Analysis of Two-variable Recurrence Relations with Application to Parameterized Approximations

Authors: Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: In this paper we introduce randomized branching as a tool for parameterized approximation and develop the mathematical machinery for its analysis. Our algorithms improve the best known running times of parameterized approximation algorithms for Vertex Cover and $3$-Hitting Set for a wide range of approximation ratios. One notable example is a simple parameterized random $1.5$-approximation algorit… ▽ More In this paper we introduce randomized branching as a tool for parameterized approximation and develop the mathematical machinery for its analysis. Our algorithms improve the best known running times of parameterized approximation algorithms for Vertex Cover and $3$-Hitting Set for a wide range of approximation ratios. One notable example is a simple parameterized random $1.5$-approximation algorithm for Vertex Cover, whose running time of $O^*(1.01657^k)$ substantially improves the best known runnning time of $O^*(1.0883^k)$ [Brankovic and Fernau, 2013]. For $3$-Hitting Set we present a parameterized random $2$-approximation algorithm with running time of $O^*(1.0659^k)$, improving the best known $O^*(1.29^k)$ algorithm of [Brankovic and Fernau, 2012]. The running times of our algorithms are derived from an asymptotic analysis of a wide class of two-variable recurrence relations of the form: $$p(b,k) = \min_{1\leq j \leq N} \sum_{i=1}^{r_j} \barγ_i^j \cdot p(b-\bar{b}^j_i, k-\bar{k}_i^j),$$ where $\bar{b}^j$ and $\bar{k}^j$ are vectors of natural numbers, and $\barγ^j$ is a probability distribution over $r_j$ elements, for $1\leq j \leq N$. Our main theorem asserts that for any $α>0$, $$\lim_{k \rightarrow \infty } \frac{1}{k} \log p(αk,k) = -\max_{1\leq j \leq N} M_j,$$ where $M_j$ depends only on $α$, $\barγ^j$, $\bar{b}^j$ and $\bar{k}^j$, and can be efficiently calculated by solving a simple numerical optimization problem. To this end, we show an equivalence between the recurrence and a stochastic process. We analyze this process using the Method of Types, by introducing an adaptation of Sanov's theorem to our setting. We believe our novel analysis of recurrence relations which is of independent interest is a main contribution of this paper. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2020; v1 submitted 6 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Generalized Assignment via Submodular Optimization with Reserved Capacity

Authors: Ariel Kulik, Kanthi Sarpatwar, Baruch Schieber, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We study a variant of the \emph{generalized assignment problem} ({\sf GAP}) with group constraints. An instance of {\sf Group GAP} is a set $I$ of items, partitioned into $L$ groups, and a set of $m$ uniform (unit-sized) bins. Each item $i \in I$ has a size $s_i >0$, and a profit $p_{i,j} \geq 0$ if packed in bin $j$. A group of items is \emph{satisfied} if all of its items are packed. The goal is… ▽ More We study a variant of the \emph{generalized assignment problem} ({\sf GAP}) with group constraints. An instance of {\sf Group GAP} is a set $I$ of items, partitioned into $L$ groups, and a set of $m$ uniform (unit-sized) bins. Each item $i \in I$ has a size $s_i >0$, and a profit $p_{i,j} \geq 0$ if packed in bin $j$. A group of items is \emph{satisfied} if all of its items are packed. The goal is to find a feasible packing of a subset of the items in the bins such that the total profit from satisfied groups is maximized. We point to central applications of {\sf Group GAP} in Video-on-Demand services, mobile Device-to-Device network caching and base station cooperation in 5G networks. Our main result is a $\frac{1}{6}$-approximation algorithm for {\sf Group GAP} instances where the total size of each group is at most $\frac{m}{2}$. At the heart of our algorithm lies an interesting derivation of a submodular function from the classic LP formulation of {\sf GAP}, which facilitates the construction of a high profit solution utilizing at most half the total bin capacity, while the other half is \emph{reserved} for later use. In particular, we give an algorithm for submodular maximization subject to a knapsack constraint, which finds a solution of profit at least $\frac{1}{3}$ of the optimum, using at most half the knapsack capacity, under mild restrictions on element sizes. Our novel approach of submodular optimization subject to a knapsack \emph{with reserved capacity} constraint may find applications in solving other group assignment problems. △ Less

Submitted 16 September, 2019; v1 submitted 3 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: Preliminary version to appear in European Symposium on Algorithms 2019

ACM Class: F.2.2; G.2.1

The Preemptive Resource Allocation Problem

Authors: Kanthi Sarpatwar, Baruch Schieber, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We revisit a classical scheduling model to incorporate modern trends in data center networks and cloud services. Addressing some key challenges in the allocation of shared resources to user requests (jobs) in such settings, we consider the following variants of the classic {\em resource allocation problem} (\textsf{RAP}). The input to our problems is a set $J$ of jobs and a set $M$ of homogeneous… ▽ More We revisit a classical scheduling model to incorporate modern trends in data center networks and cloud services. Addressing some key challenges in the allocation of shared resources to user requests (jobs) in such settings, we consider the following variants of the classic {\em resource allocation problem} (\textsf{RAP}). The input to our problems is a set $J$ of jobs and a set $M$ of homogeneous hosts, each has an available amount of some resource. A job is associated with a release time, a due date, a weight, and a given length, as well as its resource requirement. A \emph{feasible} schedule is an allocation of the resource to a subset of the jobs, satisfying the job release times/due dates as well as the resource constraints. A crucial distinction between classic {\textsf{RAP}} and our problems is that we allow preemption and migration of jobs, motivated by virtualization techniques. We consider two natural objectives: {\em throughput maximization} (\textsf{MaxT}), which seeks a maximum weight subset of the jobs that can be feasibly scheduled on the hosts in $M$, and {\em resource minimization} (\textsf{MinR}), that is finding the minimum number of (homogeneous) hosts needed to feasibly schedule all jobs. Both problems are known to be NP-hard. We first present a $Ω(1)$-approximation algorithm for \textsf{MaxT} instances where time-windows form a laminar family of intervals. We then extend the algorithm to handle instances with arbitrary time-windows, assuming there is sufficient slack for each job to be completed. For \textsf{MinR} we study a more general setting with $d$ resources and derive an $O(\log d)$-approximation for any fixed $d \geq 1$, under the assumption that time-windows are not too small. This assumption can be removed leading to a slightly worse ratio of $O(\log d\log^* T)$, where $T$ is the maximum due date of any job. △ Less

Submitted 18 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 20 pages

MSC Class: 68W25 ACM Class: F.2.2; G.1.6

Fast Distributed Approximation for Max-Cut

Authors: Keren Censor-Hillel, Rina Levy, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: Finding a maximum cut is a fundamental task in many computational settings. Surprisingly, it has been insufficiently studied in the classic distributed settings, where vertices communicate by synchronously sending messages to their neighbors according to the underlying graph, known as the $\mathcal{LOCAL}$ or $\mathcal{CONGEST}$ models. We amend this by obtaining almost optimal algorithms for Max-… ▽ More Finding a maximum cut is a fundamental task in many computational settings. Surprisingly, it has been insufficiently studied in the classic distributed settings, where vertices communicate by synchronously sending messages to their neighbors according to the underlying graph, known as the $\mathcal{LOCAL}$ or $\mathcal{CONGEST}$ models. We amend this by obtaining almost optimal algorithms for Max-Cut on a wide class of graphs in these models. In particular, for any $ε> 0$, we develop randomized approximation algorithms achieving a ratio of $(1-ε)$ to the optimum for Max-Cut on bipartite graphs in the $\mathcal{CONGEST}$ model, and on general graphs in the $\mathcal{LOCAL}$ model. We further present efficient deterministic algorithms, including a $1/3$-approximation for Max-Dicut in our models, thus improving the best known (randomized) ratio of $1/4$. Our algorithms make non-trivial use of the greedy approach of Buchbinder et al. (SIAM Journal on Computing, 2015) for maximizing an unconstrained (non-monotone) submodular function, which may be of independent interest. △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Constrained Submodular Maximization via Greedy Local Search

Authors: Kanthi K. Sarpatwar, Baruch Schieber, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We present a simple combinatorial $\frac{1 -e^{-2}}{2}$-approximation algorithm for maximizing a monotone submodular function subject to a knapsack and a matroid constraint. This classic problem is known to be hard to approximate within factor better than $1 - 1/e$. We show that the algorithm can be extended to yield a ratio of $\frac{1 - e^{-(k+1)}}{k+1}$ for the problem with a single knapsack… ▽ More We present a simple combinatorial $\frac{1 -e^{-2}}{2}$-approximation algorithm for maximizing a monotone submodular function subject to a knapsack and a matroid constraint. This classic problem is known to be hard to approximate within factor better than $1 - 1/e$. We show that the algorithm can be extended to yield a ratio of $\frac{1 - e^{-(k+1)}}{k+1}$ for the problem with a single knapsack and the intersection of $k$ matroid constraints, for any fixed $k > 1$. Our algorithms, which combine the greedy algorithm of [Khuller, Moss and Naor, 1999] and [Sviridenko, 2004] with local search, show the power of this natural framework in submodular maximization with combined constraints. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2018; v1 submitted 17 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: Title changed from "Interleaved Algorithms for Constrained Submodular Function Maximization"

ACM Class: F.2.2; G.1.6

Flexible Resource Allocation for Clouds and All-Optical Networks

Authors: Dmitriy Katz, Baruch Schieber, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: Motivated by the cloud computing paradigm, and by key optimization problems in all-optical networks, we study two variants of the classic job interval scheduling problem, where a reusable resource is allocated to competing job intervals in a flexible manner. Each job, $J_i$, requires the use of up to $r_{max}(i)$ units of the resource, with a profit of $p_i \geq 1$ accrued for each allocated unit.… ▽ More Motivated by the cloud computing paradigm, and by key optimization problems in all-optical networks, we study two variants of the classic job interval scheduling problem, where a reusable resource is allocated to competing job intervals in a flexible manner. Each job, $J_i$, requires the use of up to $r_{max}(i)$ units of the resource, with a profit of $p_i \geq 1$ accrued for each allocated unit. The goal is to feasibly schedule a subset of the jobs so as to maximize the total profit. The resource can be allocated either in contiguous or non-contiguous blocks. These problems can be viewed as flexible variants of the well known storage allocation and bandwidth allocation problems. We show that the contiguous version is strongly NP-hard, already for instances where all jobs have the same profit and the same maximum resource requirement. For such instances, we derive the best possible positive result, namely, a polynomial time approximation scheme. We further show that the contiguous variant admits a $(\frac{5}{4} + \varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm, for any fixed $\varepsilon > 0$, on instances whose job intervals form a proper interval graph. At the heart of the algorithm lies a non-standard parameterization of the approximation ratio itself, which is of independent interest. For the non-contiguous case, we uncover an interesting relation to the paging problem that leads to a simple $O(n \log n)$ algorithm for uniform profit instances of n jobs. The algorithm is easy to implement and is thus practical. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

On Lagrangian Relaxation and Reoptimization Problems

Authors: Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai, Gal Tamir

Abstract: We prove a general result demonstrating the power of Lagrangian relaxation in solving constrained maximization problems with arbitrary objective functions. This yields a unified approach for solving a wide class of {\em subset selection} problems with linear constraints. Given a problem in this class and some small $\eps \in (0,1)$, we show that if there exists an $r$-approximation algorithm for t… ▽ More We prove a general result demonstrating the power of Lagrangian relaxation in solving constrained maximization problems with arbitrary objective functions. This yields a unified approach for solving a wide class of {\em subset selection} problems with linear constraints. Given a problem in this class and some small $\eps \in (0,1)$, we show that if there exists an $r$-approximation algorithm for the Lagrangian relaxation of the problem, for some $r \in (0,1)$, then our technique achieves a ratio of $\frac{r}{r+1} -\! \eps$ to the optimal, and this ratio is tight. The number of calls to the $r$-approximation algorithm, used by our algorithms, is {\em linear} in the input size and in $\log (1 / \eps)$ for inputs with cardinality constraint, and polynomial in the input size and in $\log (1 / \eps)$ for inputs with arbitrary linear constraint. Using the technique we obtain (re)approximation algorithms for natural (reoptimization) variants of classic subset selection problems, including real-time scheduling, the {\em maximum generalized assignment problem (GAP)} and maximum weight independent set. △ Less

Submitted 21 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

A Multivariate Framework for Weighted FPT Algorithms

Authors: Hadas Shachnai, Meirav Zehavi

Abstract: We introduce a novel multivariate approach for solving weighted parameterized problems. In our model, given an instance of size $n$ of a minimization (maximization) problem, and a parameter $W \geq 1$, we seek a solution of weight at most (or at least) $W$. We use our general framework to obtain efficient algorithms for such fundamental graph problems as Vertex Cover, 3-Hitting Set, Edge Dominatin… ▽ More We introduce a novel multivariate approach for solving weighted parameterized problems. In our model, given an instance of size $n$ of a minimization (maximization) problem, and a parameter $W \geq 1$, we seek a solution of weight at most (or at least) $W$. We use our general framework to obtain efficient algorithms for such fundamental graph problems as Vertex Cover, 3-Hitting Set, Edge Dominating Set and Max Internal Out-Branching. The best known algorithms for these problems admit running times of the form $c^W n^{O(1)}$, for some constant $c>1$. We improve these running times to $c^s n^{O(1)}$, where $s\leq W$ is the minimum size of a solution of weight at most (at least) $W$. If no such solution exists, $s=\min\{W,m\}$, where $m$ is the maximum size of a solution. Clearly, $s$ can be substantially smaller than $W$. In particular, the running times of our algorithms are (almost) the same as the best known $O^*$ running times for the unweighted variants. Thus, we solve the weighted versions of * Vertex Cover in $1.381^s n^{O(1)}$ time and $n^{O(1)}$ space. * 3-Hitting Set in $2.168^s n^{O(1)}$ time and $n^{O(1)}$ space. * Edge Dominating Set in $2.315^s n^{O(1)}$ time and $n^{O(1)}$ space. * Max Internal Out-Branching in $6.855^s n^{O(1)}$ time and space. We further show that Weighted Vertex Cover and Weighted Edge Dominating Set admit fast algorithms whose running times are of the form $c^t n^{O(1)}$, where $t \leq s$ is the minimum size of a solution. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2015; v1 submitted 8 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Tighter Bounds for Makespan Minimization on Unrelated Machines

Authors: Dor Arad, Yael Mordechai, Hadas Shachnai

Abstract: We consider the problem of scheduling $n$ jobs to minimize the makespan on $m$ unrelated machines, where job $j$ requires time $p_{ij}$ if processed on machine $i$. A classic algorithm of Lenstra et al. yields the best known approximation ratio of $2$ for the problem. Improving this bound has been a prominent open problem for over two decades. In this paper we obtain a tighter bound for a wide sub… ▽ More We consider the problem of scheduling $n$ jobs to minimize the makespan on $m$ unrelated machines, where job $j$ requires time $p_{ij}$ if processed on machine $i$. A classic algorithm of Lenstra et al. yields the best known approximation ratio of $2$ for the problem. Improving this bound has been a prominent open problem for over two decades. In this paper we obtain a tighter bound for a wide subclass of instances which can be identified efficiently. Specifically, we define the feasibility factor of a given instance as the minimum fraction of machines on which each job can be processed. We show that there is a polynomial-time algorithm that, given values $L$ and $T$, and an instance having a sufficiently large feasibility factor $h \in (0,1]$, either proves that no schedule of mean machine completion time $L$ and makespan $T$ exists, or else finds a schedule of makespan at most $T + L/h < 2T$. For the restricted version of the problem, where for each job $j$ and machine $i$, $p_{ij} \in \{p_j, \infty\}$, we show that a simpler algorithm yields a better bound, thus improving for highly feasible instances the best known ratio of $33/17 + ε$, for any fixed $ε>0$, due to Svensson. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2014; v1 submitted 11 May, 2014; originally announced May 2014.

Comments: 12 pages, 2 figures. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1011.1168 by other authors

Parameterized Algorithms for Graph Partitioning Problems

Authors: Hadas Shachnai, Meirav Zehavi

Abstract: We study a broad class of graph partitioning problems, where each problem is specified by a graph $G=(V,E)$, and parameters $k$ and $p$. We seek a subset $U\subseteq V$ of size $k$, such that $α_1m_1 + α_2m_2$ is at most (or at least) $p$, where $α_1,α_2\in\mathbb{R}$ are constants defining the problem, and $m_1, m_2$ are the cardinalities of the edge sets having both endpoints, and exactly one en… ▽ More We study a broad class of graph partitioning problems, where each problem is specified by a graph $G=(V,E)$, and parameters $k$ and $p$. We seek a subset $U\subseteq V$ of size $k$, such that $α_1m_1 + α_2m_2$ is at most (or at least) $p$, where $α_1,α_2\in\mathbb{R}$ are constants defining the problem, and $m_1, m_2$ are the cardinalities of the edge sets having both endpoints, and exactly one endpoint, in $U$, respectively. This class of fixed cardinality graph partitioning problems (FGPP) encompasses Max $(k,n-k)$-Cut, Min $k$-Vertex Cover, $k$-Densest Subgraph, and $k$-Sparsest Subgraph. Our main result is an $O^*(4^{k+o(k)}Δ^k)$ algorithm for any problem in this class, where $Δ\geq 1$ is the maximum degree in the input graph. This resolves an open question posed by Bonnet et al. [IPEC 2013]. We obtain faster algorithms for certain subclasses of FGPPs, parameterized by $p$, or by $(k+p)$. In particular, we give an $O^*(4^{p+o(p)})$ time algorithm for Max $(k,n-k)$-Cut, thus improving significantly the best known $O^*(p^p)$ time algorithm. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Representative Families: A Unified Tradeoff-Based Approach

Authors: Hadas Shachnai, Meirav Zehavi

Abstract: Let $M=(E,{\cal I})$ be a matroid, and let $\cal S$ be a family of subsets of size $p$ of $E$. A subfamily $\widehat{\cal S}\subseteq{\cal S}$ represents ${\cal S}$ if for every pair of sets $X\in{\cal S}$ and $Y\subseteq E\setminus X$ such that $X\cup Y\in{\cal I}$, there is a set $\widehat{X}\in\widehat{\cal S}$ disjoint from $Y$ such that $\widehat{X}\cup Y\in{\cal I}$. Fomin et al. (Proc. ACM-… ▽ More Let $M=(E,{\cal I})$ be a matroid, and let $\cal S$ be a family of subsets of size $p$ of $E$. A subfamily $\widehat{\cal S}\subseteq{\cal S}$ represents ${\cal S}$ if for every pair of sets $X\in{\cal S}$ and $Y\subseteq E\setminus X$ such that $X\cup Y\in{\cal I}$, there is a set $\widehat{X}\in\widehat{\cal S}$ disjoint from $Y$ such that $\widehat{X}\cup Y\in{\cal I}$. Fomin et al. (Proc. ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms, 2014) introduced a powerful technique for fast computation of representative families for uniform matroids. In this paper, we show that this technique leads to a unified approach for substantially improving the running times of parameterized algorithms for some classic problems. This includes, among others, $k$-Partial Cover, $k$-Internal Out-Branching, and Long Directed Cycle. Our approach exploits an interesting tradeoff between running time and the size of the representative families. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2014; v1 submitted 14 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Approximations for Monotone and Non-monotone Submodular Maximization with Knapsack Constraints

Authors: Ariel Kulik, Hadas Shachnai, Tami Tamir

Abstract: Submodular maximization generalizes many fundamental problems in discrete optimization, including Max-Cut in directed/undirected graphs, maximum coverage, maximum facility location and marketing over social networks. In this paper we consider the problem of maximizing any submodular function subject to $d$ knapsack constraints, where $d$ is a fixed constant. We establish a strong relation betwee… ▽ More Submodular maximization generalizes many fundamental problems in discrete optimization, including Max-Cut in directed/undirected graphs, maximum coverage, maximum facility location and marketing over social networks. In this paper we consider the problem of maximizing any submodular function subject to $d$ knapsack constraints, where $d$ is a fixed constant. We establish a strong relation between the discrete problem and its continuous relaxation, obtained through {\em extension by expectation} of the submodular function. Formally, we show that, for any non-negative submodular function, an $α$-approximation algorithm for the continuous relaxation implies a randomized $(α- \eps)$-approximation algorithm for the discrete problem. We use this relation to improve the best known approximation ratio for the problem to $1/4- \eps$, for any $\eps > 0$, and to obtain a nearly optimal $(1-e^{-1}-\eps)-$approximation ratio for the monotone case, for any $\eps>0$. We further show that the probabilistic domain defined by a continuous solution can be reduced to yield a polynomial size domain, given an oracle for the extension by expectation. This leads to a deterministic version of our technique. △ Less

Submitted 14 January, 2011; originally announced January 2011.

Comments: A preliminary version of this paper appeared in the Proceedings of the 20th Annual ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms, New York, January 2009