-
Understanding magnetic hyperthermia performance within the "Brezovich criterion": beyond the uniaxial anisotropy description
Authors:
Daniel Faílde,
Víctor Ocampo-Zalvide,
David Serantes,
Òscar Iglesias
Abstract:
Careful determination of the heating performance of magnetic nanoparticles under AC fields is critical for magnetic hyperthermia applications. However, most interpretations of experimental data are based on the uniaxial anisotropy approximation, which in first instance can be correlated with particle aspect ratio. This is to say, the intrinsic magnetocrystalline anisotropy is discarded, under the…
▽ More
Careful determination of the heating performance of magnetic nanoparticles under AC fields is critical for magnetic hyperthermia applications. However, most interpretations of experimental data are based on the uniaxial anisotropy approximation, which in first instance can be correlated with particle aspect ratio. This is to say, the intrinsic magnetocrystalline anisotropy is discarded, under the assumption that the shape contribution dominates. We show in this work that such premise, generally valid for large field amplitudes, does not hold for describing hyperthermia experiments carried out under small field values. Specifically, given its relevance for \textit{in vivo} applications, we focus our analysis on the so-called "Brezovich criterion", $H\cdot{f}=4.85\times{10^8}A/m\cdot{s}$. By means of a computational model, we show that the intrinsic magnetocrystalline anisotropy plays a critical role in defining the heat output, determining also the role of shape and aspect ratio of the particles on the SLP. Our results indicate that even small deviations from spherical shape have an important impact in optimizing the heating performance. The influence of interparticle interactions on the dissipated heat is also evaluated. Our results call therefore for an improvement in the theoretical models used to interpret magnetic hyperthermia performance.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2024; v1 submitted 31 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
A device-independent approach to evaluate the heating performance during magnetic hyperthermia experiments: peak analysis and zigzag protocol
Authors:
Sergiu Ruta,
Yilian Fernández-Afonso,
Samuel E. Rannala,
M. Puerto Morales,
Sabino Veintemillas-Verdaguer,
Carlton Jones,
Lucía Gutiérre,
Roy W Chantrell,
David Serantes
Abstract:
Accurate knowledge of the heating performance of magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) under AC fields is critical for the development of hyperthermia-mediated applications. Usually reported in terms of the specific loss power (SLP) obtained from the temperature variation ($Δ{T}$) vs. time (t) curve, such estimate is subjected to a huge uncertainty. Thus, very different SLP values are reported for the sam…
▽ More
Accurate knowledge of the heating performance of magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) under AC fields is critical for the development of hyperthermia-mediated applications. Usually reported in terms of the specific loss power (SLP) obtained from the temperature variation ($Δ{T}$) vs. time (t) curve, such estimate is subjected to a huge uncertainty. Thus, very different SLP values are reported for the same particles when measured on different equipment/laboratories. This lack of control clearly hampers the further development of MNP-mediated heat-triggered technologies. Here we report a device-independent approach to calculate the SLP value of a suspension of MNPs: the SLP is obtained from the analysis of the peak at the field on/off switch of the $Δ{T}(t)$ curve. The measurement procedure, which itself constitutes a change of paradigm within the field, is based on fundamental physics considerations: specifically to guarantee the applicability of Newton's law of cooling, as i) it corresponds to the ideal scenario in which the temperature profiles of the system during heating and cooling are the same; and ii) it diminishes the role of coexistence of various heat dissipation channels. Such an approach is supported by theoretical and computational calculations to increase the reliability and reproducibility of SLP determination. This is experimentally confirmed, demonstrating a reduction in SLP variation across 3 different devices located in 3 different laboratories. Furthermore, the application of this peak analysis method (PAM) to a rapid succession of field on/off switches that result in a zigzag-like $Δ{T}(t)$, which we term the zigzag protocol, allows evaluating possible variations of the SLP values with time or temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Nanoparticle size threshold for magnetic agglomeration and associated hyperthermia performance
Authors:
D. Serantes,
D. Baldomir
Abstract:
The likelihood of magnetic nanoparticles to agglomerate is usually estimated through the ratio between magnetic dipole-dipole and thermal energies, thus neglecting the fact that, depending on the magnitude of the magnetic anisotropy constant ($K$), the particle moment may fluctuate internally and thus undermine the agglomeration process. Based on the comparison between the involved timescales, we…
▽ More
The likelihood of magnetic nanoparticles to agglomerate is usually estimated through the ratio between magnetic dipole-dipole and thermal energies, thus neglecting the fact that, depending on the magnitude of the magnetic anisotropy constant ($K$), the particle moment may fluctuate internally and thus undermine the agglomeration process. Based on the comparison between the involved timescales, we study in this work how the threshold size for magnetic agglomeration ($d_{aggl}$) varies depending on the $K$ value. Our results suggest that small variations in $K$ -due to e.g. shape contribution-, might shift $d_{aggl}$ by a few nm. A comparison with the usual \textit{superparamagnetism} estimation is provided, as well as with the energy competition approach. In addition, based on the key role of the anisotropy in the hyperthermia performance, we also analyse the associated heating capability, as non-agglomerated particles would be of high interest for the application.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2021; v1 submitted 18 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Controlling magnetisation's reversal mechanism and hyperthermia efficiency in core/shell magnetic nanoparticles by tuning the interphase coupling
Authors:
K. Simeonidis,
C. Martinez-Boubeta,
D. Serantes,
S. Ruta,
O. Chubykalo-Fesenko,
R. Chantrell,
J. Oró-Solé,
Ll. Balcells,
A. S. Kamzin,
R. A. Nazipov,
A. Makridis,
M. Angelakeris
Abstract:
Magnetic particle hyperthermia, in which colloidal nanostructures are exposed to an alternating magnetic field, is a promising approach to cancer therapy. Unfortunately, the clinical efficacy of hyperthermia has not yet been optimized. Consequently, routes to improve magnetic particle hyperthermia such as designing hybrid structures comprised from different phase materials are actively pursued. He…
▽ More
Magnetic particle hyperthermia, in which colloidal nanostructures are exposed to an alternating magnetic field, is a promising approach to cancer therapy. Unfortunately, the clinical efficacy of hyperthermia has not yet been optimized. Consequently, routes to improve magnetic particle hyperthermia such as designing hybrid structures comprised from different phase materials are actively pursued. Here we demonstrate enhanced hyperthermia efficiency in relative large spherical Fe/Fe-oxide core/shell nanoparticles through the manipulation of interactions between the core and shell phases. Experimental results on exemplary samples with diameters in the range 30-80 nm indicated a direct correlation of hysteresis losses to the observed temperature elevation rate with a maximum efficiency of around 0.9 kW/g. The absolute particle size, the core/shell ratio, and the interposition of a thin wüstite interlayer, are shown to have powerful effects on the specific absorption rate. By comparing our measurements to micromagnetic calculations we have unveiled topologically non-trivial magnetisation reversal modes under which interparticle interactions become negligible, aggregates formation is minimized, and the energy that is converted into heat is increased. This information has been overlooked till date and is in stark contrast to the existing knowledge on homogeneous particles.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Effective macrospin model for $Co_{x}Fe_{3-x}O_{4}$ nanoparticles: decreasing the anisotropy by Co-do**?
Authors:
David Serantes,
Daniel Faílde,
Daniel Baldomir,
Beatriz Pelaz,
Pablo del Pino,
Roy W. Chantrell
Abstract:
$Co$-do** of $Fe_{3}O_{4}$ magnetic nanoparticles is an effective way to tailor their magnetic properties. When considering the two extreme cases of the $Co_{x}Fe_{3-x}O_{4}$ series, i.e. the $x=0$ and $x=1$ values, one finds that the system evolves from a negative cubic-anisotropy energy constant, $K_{C}^{-}<0$, to a positive one, $K_{C}^{+}>0$. Thus, what happens for intermediate $x…
▽ More
$Co$-do** of $Fe_{3}O_{4}$ magnetic nanoparticles is an effective way to tailor their magnetic properties. When considering the two extreme cases of the $Co_{x}Fe_{3-x}O_{4}$ series, i.e. the $x=0$ and $x=1$ values, one finds that the system evolves from a negative cubic-anisotropy energy constant, $K_{C}^{-}<0$, to a positive one, $K_{C}^{+}>0$. Thus, what happens for intermediate $x$-compositions? In this work we present a very simple phenomenological model for the anisotropy, under the \textit{macrospin} approximation, in which the resultant anisotropy is just directly proportional to the amount of $Co$. First, we perform a detailed analysis on a rather ideal system in which the extreme values have the same magnitude (i.e. $|K_{C}^{-}|=|K_{C}^{+}|$) and then we focus on the real $Co_{x}Fe_{3-x}O_{4}$ system, for which $|K_{C}^{+}|\sim 18|K_{C}^{-}|$. Remarkably, the approach reproduces rather well the experimental values of the heating performance of $Co_{x}Fe_{3-x}O_{4}$ nanoparticles, suggesting that our simple approach may in fact be a good representation of the real situation. This gives rise to an intriguing related possibility arises: a $Co$-do** composition should exist for which the effective anisotropy tends to zero, estimated here as 0.05.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Micromagnetic evaluation of the dissipated heat in cylindrical magnetic nanowires
Authors:
J. A. Fernandez-Roldan,
D. Serantes,
R. P. Del Real,
M. Vazquez,
O. Chubykalo-Fesenko
Abstract:
Magnetic nanowires (NW) are promising candidates for heat generation under AC-field application due to their large shape anisotropy. They may be used for catalysis, hyperthermia or water purification treatments. In the present work we theoretically evaluate the heat dissipated by a single magnetic nanowire, originated from the domain wall dynamics under the action of an AC-field. We compare the Pe…
▽ More
Magnetic nanowires (NW) are promising candidates for heat generation under AC-field application due to their large shape anisotropy. They may be used for catalysis, hyperthermia or water purification treatments. In the present work we theoretically evaluate the heat dissipated by a single magnetic nanowire, originated from the domain wall dynamics under the action of an AC-field. We compare the Permalloy NWs (which demagnetize via the transverse wall propagation) with the Co fcc NWs whose reversal mode is via a vortex domain wall. The average hysteresis loop areas -which are proportional to the Specific Absorption Rate (SAR)- as a function of the field frequency have a pronounced maximum in the range 200MHz-1GHz. This maximum frequency is smaller in Permalloy than in Co and depends on the nanowire length. A simple model related to the nucleation and propagation time and domain wall velocity (higher for the vortex than for the transverse domain wall) is proposed to explain the non-monotonic SAR dependence on the frequency.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Anisotropic magnetic nanoparticles for biomedicine: bridging frequency separated AC-field controlled domains of actuation
Authors:
David Serantes,
Roy Chantrell,
Helena Gavilán,
María del Puerto Morales,
Oksana Chubykalo-Fesenko,
Daniel Baldomir,
Akira Satoh
Abstract:
Magnetic nanoparticles constitute potential nanomedicine tools based on the possibility to obtain different responses triggered by safe remote stimulus. However, such richness can be detrimental if the different performances are not accurately differentiated (and controlled). An example of this is the reorientation of magnetic nanoparticles under the influence of AC fields, which can be exploited…
▽ More
Magnetic nanoparticles constitute potential nanomedicine tools based on the possibility to obtain different responses triggered by safe remote stimulus. However, such richness can be detrimental if the different performances are not accurately differentiated (and controlled). An example of this is the reorientation of magnetic nanoparticles under the influence of AC fields, which can be exploited for either magneto-mechanical actuation (MMA) at low frequencies (tens of Hz); or heat release at large ones (MHz range). While it is clear that Brownian rotation is responsible for MMA, its heating role in the high-frequency regime is not clear. In this work we aim to shed light on this issue, which needs to be well understood for applications in magnetic fluid hyperthermia (MFH) or heat triggered drug release. Using a Brownian dynamics (BD) simulation technique, we have theoretically investigated the contribution of Brownian reversal in disk-shape particles (to enhance the viscous interaction with the environment) over a wide range of frequencies. Our results predict essentially negligible hysteresis losses both in the high- and low-frequency domains, with completely different implications: highly efficient MMA, but negligible MFH performance. Importantly, complementary micromagnetic simulations indicate that the large magnetic torque assumption of the BD simulations is supported by hexagonal-shape disks, up to field amplitudes of the order of 100 Oe. Larger fields would lead to Néel reversal which, noteworthy, predicts significant heating performance. The possibility of switching between the MMA and MFH response by changing the amplitude of the AC field, together with their distinct optimal conditions (large magnetic torque for MMF; large heating for MFH), points to such hexagonal nanodisks as promising nanomedicine agents with double mechanical and heating functionalities.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Why do magnetic nanoparticles form messy clumps? Taking into account the bridging or sticking of ligands in simulations
Authors:
N. R. Anderson,
D. R. Louie,
D. Serantes,
K. L. Livesey
Abstract:
Experiments on magnetic nanoparticles in a viscous medium have shown that agglomerates form that display complex shapes. However, most theoretical results predict more simple, ordered shapes, such as single-particle width chains. To account for this discrepancy we have created a theoretical model that phenomenologically includes the bridging or "stickiness" between ligands on nearby nanoparticles.…
▽ More
Experiments on magnetic nanoparticles in a viscous medium have shown that agglomerates form that display complex shapes. However, most theoretical results predict more simple, ordered shapes, such as single-particle width chains. To account for this discrepancy we have created a theoretical model that phenomenologically includes the bridging or "stickiness" between ligands on nearby nanoparticles. This interaction is accounted for through a unitless stickiness parameter c that can be varied between 0 (no bridging between ligands) and 1 (irreversible bridging or sticking together on impact). An analytic estimate for the value of c is provided based on a comparison between the time for a particle to diffuse to an agglomerate compared to the time for it to reorient into the local magnetic field direction. Numerical Langevin simulations are performed using ferromagnetic, 50 nm and 25 nm diameter magnetite nanoparticles with various ligand coating lengths in hexane in order to support the analytic estimate. The simulations produce agglomerates that are qualitatively and quantitatively similar to experimental results.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2017; v1 submitted 24 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Quantum Landau-Lifshitz-Bloch equation and its comparison with the classical case
Authors:
P. Nieves,
D. Serantes,
U. Atxitia,
O. Chubykalo-Fesenko
Abstract:
The detailed derivation of the quantum Landau-Lifshitz-Bloch (qLLB) equation for simple spin-flip scattering mechanisms based on spin-phonon and spin-electron interactions is presented and the approximations are discussed. The qLLB equation is written in the form, suitable for comparison with its classical counterpart. The temperature dependence of the macroscopic relaxation rates is discussed for…
▽ More
The detailed derivation of the quantum Landau-Lifshitz-Bloch (qLLB) equation for simple spin-flip scattering mechanisms based on spin-phonon and spin-electron interactions is presented and the approximations are discussed. The qLLB equation is written in the form, suitable for comparison with its classical counterpart. The temperature dependence of the macroscopic relaxation rates is discussed for both mechanisms. It is demonstrated that the magnetization dynamics is slower in the quantum case than in the classical one.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2015; v1 submitted 28 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Learning from Nature to Improve the Heat Generation of Iron-Oxide Nanoparticles for Magnetic Hyperthermia Applications
Authors:
Carlos Martinez-Boubeta,
Konstantinos Simeonidis,
Antonios Makridis,
Makis Angelakeris,
Oscar Iglesias,
Pablo Guardia,
Andreu Cabot,
Lluis Yedra,
Sonia Estrade,
Francesca Peiro,
Zineb Saghi,
Paul A. Midgley,
Ivan Conde-Leboran,
David Serantes,
Daniel Baldomir
Abstract:
The performance of magnetic nanoparticles is intimately entwined with their structure, mean size and magnetic anisotropy. Besides, ensembles offer a unique way of engineering the magnetic response by modifying the strength of the dipolar interactions between particles. Here we report on an experimental and theoretical analysis of magnetic hyperthermia, a rapidly develo** technique in medical res…
▽ More
The performance of magnetic nanoparticles is intimately entwined with their structure, mean size and magnetic anisotropy. Besides, ensembles offer a unique way of engineering the magnetic response by modifying the strength of the dipolar interactions between particles. Here we report on an experimental and theoretical analysis of magnetic hyperthermia, a rapidly develo** technique in medical research and oncology. Experimentally, we demonstrate that single-domain cubic iron oxide particles resembling bacterial magnetosomes have superior magnetic heating efficiency compared to spherical particles of similar sizes. Monte Carlo simulations at the atomic level corroborate the larger anisotropy of the cubic particles in comparison with the spherical ones, thus evidencing the beneficial role of surface anisotropy in the improved heating power. Moreover we establish a quantitative link between the particle assembling, the interactions and the heating properties. This knowledge opens new perspectives for improved hyperthermia, an alternative to conventional cancer therapies.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Superparamagnetism and Monte Carlo simulations
Authors:
David Serantes,
Daniel Baldomir
Abstract:
We revise the basic concepts beneath the idea of \textit{superparamagnetism} and the suitability of Monte Carlo (MC) simulations to study superparamagnetic (SPM) properties. Starting with the description of the characteristic features of the single-domain SPM entities, their general magnetic-field and temperature-dependent magnetic properties are discussed. Then, the use of a MC technique for stud…
▽ More
We revise the basic concepts beneath the idea of \textit{superparamagnetism} and the suitability of Monte Carlo (MC) simulations to study superparamagnetic (SPM) properties. Starting with the description of the characteristic features of the single-domain SPM entities, their general magnetic-field and temperature-dependent magnetic properties are discussed. Then, the use of a MC technique for studying SPM properties is presented, starting with a general approach to MC methods and introducing the Metropolis algorithm as an adequate tool for reproducing SPM features. Special attention is paid to the role played by the \textit{computational time} MC steps on the simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Scaling the effect of the dipolar interactions on the ZFC/FC curves of random nanoparticle assemblies
Authors:
David Serantes,
Manuel Pereiro,
Roy Chantrell,
Daniel Baldomir
Abstract:
Zero Field Cooling (ZFC) and Field Cooling (FC) protocols are commonly used to investigate the properties of magnetic nanoparticle systems. For non-interacting conditions the particle properties are fairly well correlated with the shape of the ZFC/FC curves. However, that is not the case when significant dipolar interparticle interactions (DII) are present, what frequently occurs in experimental s…
▽ More
Zero Field Cooling (ZFC) and Field Cooling (FC) protocols are commonly used to investigate the properties of magnetic nanoparticle systems. For non-interacting conditions the particle properties are fairly well correlated with the shape of the ZFC/FC curves. However, that is not the case when significant dipolar interparticle interactions (DII) are present, what frequently occurs in experimental samples (e.g. aggregates in biological systems; or the dried powder often used for the ZFC/FC measurements). The purpose of this work is to show how the influence of the DII on the ZFC/FC curves, computed by the volume sample concentration c, can be described in a general way if scaled by the dimensionless parameter c_0 = 2K/M_S^2; where K and M_S are the anisotropy and saturation magnetization constants of the particles, respectively. This scaling parameter, which is straightforwardly derived from the energy equation governing the system, has an analogous meaning to the normalization of the external magnetic field H by the anisotropy field of the particles, H_A = 2K/M_S. We use a Monte Carlo technique to show how apparently different T_B vs. c curves of various particles types (where T_B is the blocking temperature), follow the same trend if scaling c/c_0.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2018; v1 submitted 17 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Nonmonotonic Evolution of the Blocking Temperature in Dispersions of Superparamagnetic Nanoparticles
Authors:
D. Serantes,
D. Baldomir,
M. Pereiro,
C. E. Hoppe,
F. Rivadulla,
J. Rivas
Abstract:
We use a Monte Carlo approach to simulate the influence of the dipolar interaction on assemblies of monodisperse superparamagnetic $γ-Fe_{2}O_{3}$ nanoparticles. We have identified a critical concentration c*, that marks the transition between two different regimes in the evolution of the blocking temperature ($T_{B}$) with interparticle interactions. At low concentrations (c < c*) magnetic partic…
▽ More
We use a Monte Carlo approach to simulate the influence of the dipolar interaction on assemblies of monodisperse superparamagnetic $γ-Fe_{2}O_{3}$ nanoparticles. We have identified a critical concentration c*, that marks the transition between two different regimes in the evolution of the blocking temperature ($T_{B}$) with interparticle interactions. At low concentrations (c < c*) magnetic particles behave as an ideal non-interacting system with a constant $T_{B}$. At concentrations c > c* the dipolar energy enhances the anisotropic energy barrier and $T_{B}$ increases with increasing c, so that a larger temperature is required to reach the superparamagnetic state. The fitting of our results with classical particle models and experiments supports the existence of two differentiated regimes. Our data could help to understand apparently contradictory results from the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
