-
Element-specific ultrafast lattice dynamics in monolayer WSe2
Authors:
H. Jung,
S. Dong,
D. Zahn,
T. Vasileiadis,
H. Seiler,
R. Schneider,
S. Michaelis de Vasconcellos,
V. C. A. Taylor,
R. Bratschitsch,
R. Ernstorfer,
Y. W. Windsor
Abstract:
We study monolayer WSe2 using ultrafast electron diffraction. We introduce an approach to quantitatively extract atomic-site-specific information, providing an element-specific view of incoherent atomic vibrations following femtosecond excitation. Via differences between W and Se vibrations, we identify stages in the nonthermal evolution of the lattice. Combined with a calculated phonon dispersion…
▽ More
We study monolayer WSe2 using ultrafast electron diffraction. We introduce an approach to quantitatively extract atomic-site-specific information, providing an element-specific view of incoherent atomic vibrations following femtosecond excitation. Via differences between W and Se vibrations, we identify stages in the nonthermal evolution of the lattice. Combined with a calculated phonon dispersion, this element specificity enables us to identify a long-lasting overpopulation of specific optical phonons, and to interpret the stages as energy transfer processes between specific phonon groups. These results demonstrate the appeal of resolving element-specific vibrational information in the ultrafast time domain.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Observation of multi-directional energy transfer in a hybrid plasmonic-excitonic nanostructure
Authors:
Tommaso Pincelli,
Thomas Vasileiadis,
Shuo Dong,
Samuel Beaulieu,
Maciej Dendzik,
Daniela Zahn,
Sang-Eun Lee,
Hélène Seiler,
Yinpeng Qi,
R. Patrick Xian,
Julian Maklar,
Emerson Coy,
Niclas S. Müller,
Yu Okamura,
Stephanie Reich,
Martin Wolf,
Laurenz Rettig,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
Hybrid plasmonic devices involve a nanostructured metal supporting localized surface plasmons to amplify light-matter interaction, and a non-plasmonic material to functionalize charge excitations. Application-relevant epitaxial heterostructures, however, give rise to ballistic ultrafast dynamics that challenge the conventional semiclassical understanding of unidirectional nanometal-to-substrate en…
▽ More
Hybrid plasmonic devices involve a nanostructured metal supporting localized surface plasmons to amplify light-matter interaction, and a non-plasmonic material to functionalize charge excitations. Application-relevant epitaxial heterostructures, however, give rise to ballistic ultrafast dynamics that challenge the conventional semiclassical understanding of unidirectional nanometal-to-substrate energy transfer. We study epitaxial Au nanoislands on WSe$_2$ with time- and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy and femtosecond electron diffraction: this combination of techniques resolves material, energy and momentum of charge-carriers and phonons excited in the heterostructure. We observe a strong non-linear plasmon-exciton interaction that transfers the energy of sub-bandgap photons very efficiently to the semiconductor, leaving the metal cold until non-radiative exciton recombination heats the nanoparticles on hundreds of femtoseconds timescales. Our results resolve a multi-directional energy exchange on timescales shorter than the electronic thermalization of the nanometal. Electron-phonon coupling and diffusive charge-transfer determine the subsequent energy flow. This complex dynamics opens perspectives for optoelectronic and photocatalytic applications, while providing a constraining experimental testbed for state-of-the-art modelling.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2022; v1 submitted 8 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Direct observation of ultrafast lattice distortions during exciton-polaron formation in lead-halide perovskite nanocrystals
Authors:
Hélène Seiler,
Daniela Zahn,
Victoria C. A. Taylor,
Maryna I. Bodnarchnuk,
Yoav W. Windsor,
Maxsym V. Kovalenko,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
The microscopic origin of slow carrier cooling in lead-halide perovskites remains debated, and has direct implications for applications. Slow carrier cooling has been attributed to either polaron formation or a hot-phonon bottleneck effect at high excited carrier densities (> 10$^{18}$ cm$^{-3}$). These effects cannot be unambiguously disentangled from optical experiments alone. However, they can…
▽ More
The microscopic origin of slow carrier cooling in lead-halide perovskites remains debated, and has direct implications for applications. Slow carrier cooling has been attributed to either polaron formation or a hot-phonon bottleneck effect at high excited carrier densities (> 10$^{18}$ cm$^{-3}$). These effects cannot be unambiguously disentangled from optical experiments alone. However, they can be distinguished by direct observations of ultrafast lattice dynamics, as these effects are expected to create qualitatively distinct fingerprints. To this end, we employ femtosecond electron diffraction and directly measure the sub-picosecond lattice dynamics of weakly confined CsPbBr$_3$ nanocrystals following above-gap photo-excitation. The data reveal a light-induced structural distortion appearing on a time scale varying between 380 fs to 1200 fs depending on the excitation fluence. We attribute these dynamics to the effect of exciton-polarons on the lattice, and the slower dynamics at high fluences to slower hot carrier cooling, which slows down the establishment of the exciton-polaron population. Further analysis and simulations show that the distortion is consistent with motions of the [PbBr$_3$]$^{-}$ octahedral ionic cage, and closest agreement with the data is obtained for Pb-Br bond lengthening. Our work demonstrates how direct studies of lattice dynamics on the sub-picosecond timescale can discriminate between competing scenarios, thereby shedding light on the origin of slow carrier cooling in lead-halide perovskites.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Intrinsic energy flow in laser-excited 3$d$ ferromagnets
Authors:
Daniela Zahn,
Florian Jakobs,
Hélène Seiler,
Tim A. Butcher,
Dieter Engel,
Jan Vorberger,
Unai Atxitia,
Yoav William Windsor,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
Ultrafast magnetization dynamics are governed by energy flow between electronic, magnetic, and lattice degrees of freedom. A quantitative understanding of these dynamics must be based on a model that agrees with experimental results for all three subsystems. However, ultrafast dynamics of the lattice remain largely unexplored experimentally. Here, we combine femtosecond electron diffraction experi…
▽ More
Ultrafast magnetization dynamics are governed by energy flow between electronic, magnetic, and lattice degrees of freedom. A quantitative understanding of these dynamics must be based on a model that agrees with experimental results for all three subsystems. However, ultrafast dynamics of the lattice remain largely unexplored experimentally. Here, we combine femtosecond electron diffraction experiments of the lattice dynamics with energy-conserving atomistic spin dynamics (ASD) simulations and ab-initio calculations to study the intrinsic energy flow in the 3d ferromagnets cobalt (Co) and iron (Fe). The simulations yield a good description of experimental data, in particular an excellent description of our experimental results for the lattice dynamics. We find that the lattice dynamics are influenced significantly by the magnetization dynamics due to the energy cost of demagnetization. Our results highlight the role of the spin system as the dominant heat sink in the first hundreds of femtoseconds. Together with previous findings for nickel [Zahn et al., Phys. Rev. Research 3, 023032 (2021)], our work demonstrates that energy-conserving ASD simulations provide a general and consistent description of the laser-induced dynamics in all three elemental 3d ferromagnets.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022; v1 submitted 1 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Photoinduced ultrafast transition of the local correlated structure in chalcogenide phase-change materials
Authors:
Yingpeng Qi,
Nianke Chen,
Thomas Vasileiadis,
Daniela Zahn,
Helene Seiler,
Xianbin Li,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
Revealing the bonding and time-evolving atomic dynamics in functional materials with complex lattice structures can update the fundamental knowledge on rich physics therein, and also help to manipulate the material properties as desired. As the most prototypical chalcogenide phase change material, Ge2Sb2Te5 has been widely used in optical data storage and non-volatile electric memory due to the fa…
▽ More
Revealing the bonding and time-evolving atomic dynamics in functional materials with complex lattice structures can update the fundamental knowledge on rich physics therein, and also help to manipulate the material properties as desired. As the most prototypical chalcogenide phase change material, Ge2Sb2Te5 has been widely used in optical data storage and non-volatile electric memory due to the fast switching speed and the low energy consumption. However, the basic understanding of the structural dynamics on the atomic scale is still not clear. Using femtosecond electron diffraction, structure factor calculation and TDDFT-MD simulation, we reveal the photoinduced ultrafast transition of the local correlated structure in the averaged rock-salt phase of Ge2Sb2Te5. The randomly oriented Peierls distortion among unit cells in the averaged rock-salt phase of Ge2Sb2Te5 is termed as local correlated structures. The ultrafast suppression of the local Peierls distortions in individual unit cell gives rise to a local structure change from the rhombohedral to the cubic geometry within ~ 0.3 ps. In addition, the impact of the carrier relaxation and the large amount of vacancies to the ultrafast structural response is quantified and discussed. Our work provides new microscopic insights into contributions of the local correlated structure to the transient structural and optical responses in phase change materials. Moreover, we stress the significance of femtosecond electron diffraction in revealing the local correlated structure in the subunit cell and the link between the local correlated structure and physical properties in functional materials with complex microstructures.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2022; v1 submitted 13 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Traversing double-well potential energy surfaces: photoinduced concurrent intralayer and interlayer structural transitions in XTe2 (X=Mo, W)
Authors:
Yingpeng Qi,
Mengxue Guan,
Daniela Zahn,
Thomas Vasileiadis,
Helene Seiler,
Yoav William Windsor,
Hui Zhao,
Sheng Meng,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
Manipulating crystal structure and the corresponding electronic properties in quantum materials provides opportunities for the exploration of exotic physics and practical applications. Here, by ultrafast electron diffraction, structure factor calculation and TDDFT-MD simulations, we report the photoinduced concurrent intralayer and interlayer structural transitions in the Td and 1T' phase of XTe2…
▽ More
Manipulating crystal structure and the corresponding electronic properties in quantum materials provides opportunities for the exploration of exotic physics and practical applications. Here, by ultrafast electron diffraction, structure factor calculation and TDDFT-MD simulations, we report the photoinduced concurrent intralayer and interlayer structural transitions in the Td and 1T' phase of XTe2 (X=Mo, W). Concomitant with the interlayer structural transition by shear displacement, the ultrafast suppression of the intralayer Peierls distortion within 0.3 ps is demonstrated and attributed to Mo-Mo (W-W) bond stretching. We discuss the modification of multiple quantum electronic states associated with the intralayer and interlayer structural transitions, such as the topological band inversion and the higher-order topological state. The twin structure and the stacking fault in XTe2 are identified by the ultrafast structural response. Our work elucidates the pathway of the photoinduced intralayer and interlayer structural transitions in atomic and femtosecond spatiotemporal scale. Moreover, the concurrent intralayer and interlayer structural transitions reveals the traversal of all double-well potential energy surfaces (DWPES) by laser excitation in material system, which may be an intrinsic mechanism in the field of photoexcitation-driven symmetry engineering, beyond the single DWPES transition model and the order-disorder transition model.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2022; v1 submitted 28 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Multi-phonon diffuse scattering in solids from first-principles: Application to layered crystals and 2D materials
Authors:
Marios Zacharias,
Hélène Seiler,
Fabio Caruso,
Daniela Zahn,
Feliciano Giustino,
Pantelis C. Kelires,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
Time-resolved diffuse scattering experiments have gained increasing attention due to their potential to reveal non-equilibrium dynamics of crystal lattice vibrations with full momentum resolution. Although progress has been made in interpreting experimental data on the basis of one-phonon scattering, understanding the role of individual phonons can be sometimes hindered by multi-phonon excitations…
▽ More
Time-resolved diffuse scattering experiments have gained increasing attention due to their potential to reveal non-equilibrium dynamics of crystal lattice vibrations with full momentum resolution. Although progress has been made in interpreting experimental data on the basis of one-phonon scattering, understanding the role of individual phonons can be sometimes hindered by multi-phonon excitations. In Ref. [{\it arXiv:2103.10108}] we have introduced a rigorous approach for the calculation of the all-phonon inelastic scattering intensity of solids from first-principles. In the present work, we describe our implementation in detail and show that multi-phonon interactions are captured efficiently by exploiting translational and time-reversal symmetries of the crystal. We demonstrate its predictive power by calculating the scattering patterns of monolayer molybdenum disulfide (MoS$_2$), bulk MoS$_2$, and black phosphorus (bP), and we obtain excellent agreement with our measurements of thermal electron diffuse scattering. Remarkably, our results show that multi-phonon excitations dominate in bP across multiple Brillouin zones, while in MoS$_2$ they play a less pronounced role. We expand our analysis for each system and examine the effect of individual atomic and interatomic vibrational motion on the diffuse scattering signals. We further demonstrate the high-throughput capability of our approach by reporting all-phonon scattering maps of 2D MoSe2, WSe2, WS2, graphene, and CdI2, rationalizing in each case the effect of multi-phonon processes. As a side point, we show that the special displacement method reproduces the thermally distorted configuration that generates precisely the all-phonon diffuse pattern.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2021; v1 submitted 16 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Efficient first-principles methodology for the calculation of the all-phonon inelastic scattering in solids
Authors:
Marios Zacharias,
Hélène Seiler,
Fabio Caruso,
Daniela Zahn,
Feliciano Giustino,
Pantelis C. Kelires,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
Inelastic scattering experiments are key methods for map** the full dispersion of fundamental excitations of solids in the ground as well as non-equilibrium states. A quantitative analysis of inelastic scattering in terms of phonon excitations requires identifying the role of multi-phonon processes. Here, we develop an efficient first-principles methodology for calculating the all-phonon quantum…
▽ More
Inelastic scattering experiments are key methods for map** the full dispersion of fundamental excitations of solids in the ground as well as non-equilibrium states. A quantitative analysis of inelastic scattering in terms of phonon excitations requires identifying the role of multi-phonon processes. Here, we develop an efficient first-principles methodology for calculating the all-phonon quantum mechanical structure factor of solids. We demonstrate our method by obtaining excellent agreement between measurements and calculations of the diffuse scattering patterns of black phosphorus, showing that multi-phonon processes play a substantial role. The present approach constitutes a step towards the interpretation of static and time-resolved electron, X-ray, and neutron inelastic scattering data.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2021; v1 submitted 18 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Ultrafast lattice dynamics and electron-phonon coupling in platinum extracted with a global fitting approach for time-resolved polycrystalline diffraction data
Authors:
Daniela Zahn,
Hélène Seiler,
Yoav William Windsor,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
Quantitative knowledge of electron-phonon coupling is important for many applications as well as for the fundamental understanding of nonequilibrium relaxation processes. Time-resolved diffraction provides direct access to this knowledge through its sensitivity to laser-induced lattice dynamics. Here, we present an approach for analyzing time-resolved polycrystalline diffraction data. A two-step r…
▽ More
Quantitative knowledge of electron-phonon coupling is important for many applications as well as for the fundamental understanding of nonequilibrium relaxation processes. Time-resolved diffraction provides direct access to this knowledge through its sensitivity to laser-induced lattice dynamics. Here, we present an approach for analyzing time-resolved polycrystalline diffraction data. A two-step routine is used to minimize the number of time-dependent fit parameters. The lattice dynamics are extracted by finding the best fit to the full transient diffraction pattern rather than by analyzing transient changes of individual Debye-Scherrer rings. We apply this approach to platinum, an important component of novel photocatalytic and spintronic applications, for which a large variation of literature values exists for the electron-phonon coupling parameter $G_\mathrm{ep}$. Based on the extracted evolution of the atomic mean squared displacement (MSD) and using a two-temperature model (TTM), we obtain $G_\mathrm{ep}=(3.9\pm0.2)\cdot10^{17}\frac{\mathrm{W}}{\mathrm{m}^3\hspace{1pt}\mathrm{K}}$ (statistical error). We find that at least up to an absorbed energy density of $124\hspace{2pt}\frac{\mathrm{J}}{\mathrm{cm}^3}$, $G_\mathrm{ep}$ is not fluence-dependent. Our results for the lattice dynamics of platinum provide insights into electron-phonon coupling and phonon thermalization and constitute a basis for quantitative descriptions of platinum-based heterostructures in nonequilibrium conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2021; v1 submitted 18 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Nuclear dynamics of singlet exciton fission: a direct observation in pentacene single crystals
Authors:
Hélène Seiler,
Marcin Krynski,
Daniela Zahn,
Sebastian Hammer,
Yoav William Windsor,
Thomas Vasileiadis,
Jens Pflaum,
Ralph Ernstorfer,
Mariana Rossi,
Heinrich Schwoerer
Abstract:
Singlet exciton fission (SEF) is a key process in the development of efficient opto-electronic devices. An aspect that is rarely probed directly, and yet has a tremendous impact on SEF properties, is the nuclear structure and dynamics involved in this process. Here we directly observe the nuclear dynamics accompanying the SEF process in single crystal pentacene using femtosecond electron diffracti…
▽ More
Singlet exciton fission (SEF) is a key process in the development of efficient opto-electronic devices. An aspect that is rarely probed directly, and yet has a tremendous impact on SEF properties, is the nuclear structure and dynamics involved in this process. Here we directly observe the nuclear dynamics accompanying the SEF process in single crystal pentacene using femtosecond electron diffraction. The data reveal coherent atomic motions at 1 THz, incoherent motions, and an anisotropic lattice distortion representing the polaronic character of the triplet excitons. Combining molecular dynamics simulations, time-dependent density functional theory and experimental structure factor analysis, the coherent motions are identified as collective sliding motions of the pentacene molecules along their long axis. Such motions modify the excitonic coupling between adjacent molecules. Our findings reveal that long-range motions play a decisive part in the disintegration of the electronically correlated triplet pairs, and shed light on why SEF occurs on ultrafast timescales.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Exchange-striction driven ultrafast nonthermal lattice dynamics in NiO
Authors:
Y. W. Windsor,
D. Zahn,
R. Kamrla,
J. Feldl,
H. Seiler,
C. -T. Chiang,
M. Ramsteiner,
W. Widdra,
R. Ernstorfer,
L. Rettig
Abstract:
We use femtosecond electron diffraction to study ultrafast lattice dynamics in the highly correlated antiferromagnetic (AF) semiconductor NiO. Using the scattering vector (Q) dependence of Bragg diffraction, we introduce a Q-resolved effective lattice temperature, and identify a nonthermal lattice state with preferential displacement of O compared to Ni ions, which occurs within ~0.3 ps and persis…
▽ More
We use femtosecond electron diffraction to study ultrafast lattice dynamics in the highly correlated antiferromagnetic (AF) semiconductor NiO. Using the scattering vector (Q) dependence of Bragg diffraction, we introduce a Q-resolved effective lattice temperature, and identify a nonthermal lattice state with preferential displacement of O compared to Ni ions, which occurs within ~0.3 ps and persists for 25 ps. We associate this with transient changes to the AF exchange striction-induced lattice distortion, supported by the observation of a transient Q-asymmetry of Friedel pairs. Our observation highlights the role of spin-lattice coupling in routes towards ultrafast control of spin order.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Lattice dynamics and ultrafast energy flow between electrons, spins, and phonons in a 3d ferromagnet
Authors:
Daniela Zahn,
Florian Jakobs,
Yoav William Windsor,
Hélène Seiler,
Thomas Vasileiadis,
Tim A. Butcher,
Yingpeng Qi,
Dieter Engel,
Unai Atxitia,
Jan Vorberger,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
The ultrafast dynamics of magnetic order in a ferromagnet are governed by the interplay between electronic, magnetic and lattice degrees of freedom. In order to obtain a microscopic understanding of ultrafast demagnetization, information on the response of all three subsystems is required. A consistent description of demagnetization and microscopic energy flow, however, is still missing. Here, we…
▽ More
The ultrafast dynamics of magnetic order in a ferromagnet are governed by the interplay between electronic, magnetic and lattice degrees of freedom. In order to obtain a microscopic understanding of ultrafast demagnetization, information on the response of all three subsystems is required. A consistent description of demagnetization and microscopic energy flow, however, is still missing. Here, we combine a femtosecond electron diffraction study of the ultrafast lattice response of nickel to laser excitation with ab initio calculations of the electron-phonon interaction and energy-conserving atomistic spin dynamics simulations. Our model is in agreement with the observed lattice dynamics and previously reported electron and magnetization dynamics. Our approach reveals that the spin system is the dominating heat sink in the initial few hundreds of femtoseconds and implies a transient non-thermal state of the spins. Our results provide a clear picture of the microscopic energy flow between electronic, magnetic and lattice degrees of freedom on ultrafast timescales and constitute a foundation for theoretical descriptions of demagnetization that are consistent with the dynamics of all three subsystems.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2021; v1 submitted 11 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Accessing the anisotropic non-thermal phonon populations in black phosphorus
Authors:
Hélène Seiler,
Daniela Zahn,
Marios Zacharias,
Patrick Hildebrandt,
Thomas Vasileiadis,
Yoav William Windsor,
Yingpeng Qi,
Christian Carbogno,
Claudia Draxl,
Ralph Ernstorfer,
Fabio Caruso
Abstract:
We combine femtosecond electron diffuse scattering experiments and first-principles calculations of the coupled electron-phonon dynamics to provide a detailed momentum-resolved picture of the ultrafast lattice thermalization in a thin film of black phosphorus. The measurements reveal the emergence of highly anisotropic non-thermal phonon populations which persist for several picoseconds following…
▽ More
We combine femtosecond electron diffuse scattering experiments and first-principles calculations of the coupled electron-phonon dynamics to provide a detailed momentum-resolved picture of the ultrafast lattice thermalization in a thin film of black phosphorus. The measurements reveal the emergence of highly anisotropic non-thermal phonon populations which persist for several picoseconds following excitation of the electrons with a light pulse. Combining ultrafast dynamics simulations based on the time-dependent Boltzmann formalism and calculations of the structure factor, we reproduce the experimental data and identify the vibrational modes primarily responsible for the carrier relaxation via electron-phonon coupling and the subsequent lattice thermalization via phonon-phonon scattering. In particular, we attribute the non-equilibrium lattice dynamics of black phosphorus to highly-anisotropic phonon-assisted scattering processes, which are primarily mediated by high-energy optical phonons. Our approach paves the way towards unravelling and controlling microscopic energy-flow pathways in two-dimensional materials and van der Waals heterostructures, and may also be extended to other non-equilibrium phenomena involving coupled electron-phonon dynamics such as superconductivity, phase transitions or polaron physics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2021; v1 submitted 23 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Anisotropic Nonequilibrium Lattice Dynamics of Black Phosphorus
Authors:
Daniela Zahn,
Patrick-Nigel Hildebrandt,
Thomas Vasileiadis,
Yoav William Windsor,
Yingpeng Qi,
Hélène Seiler,
Ralph Ernstorfer
Abstract:
Black phosphorus has recently attracted significant attention for its highly anisotropic properties. A variety of ultrafast optical spectroscopies has been applied to probe the carrier response to photoexcitation, but the complementary lattice response has remained unaddressed. Here we employ femtosecond electron diffraction to explore how the structural anisotropy impacts the lattice dynamics aft…
▽ More
Black phosphorus has recently attracted significant attention for its highly anisotropic properties. A variety of ultrafast optical spectroscopies has been applied to probe the carrier response to photoexcitation, but the complementary lattice response has remained unaddressed. Here we employ femtosecond electron diffraction to explore how the structural anisotropy impacts the lattice dynamics after photoexcitation. We observe two timescales in the lattice response, which we attribute to electron-phonon and phonon-phonon thermalization. Pronounced differences between armchair and zigzag directions are observed, indicating a nonthermal state of the lattice lasting up to ~60 ps. This nonthermal state is characterized by a modified anisotropy of the atomic vibrations compared to equilibrium. Our findings provide insights in both electron-phonon as well as phonon-phonon coupling and bear direct relevance for any application of black phosphorus in nonequilibrium conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2020; v1 submitted 27 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.