-
Fusion of laser diffraction and chord length distribution data for estimation of particle size distribution using multi-objective optimisation
Authors:
Okpeafoh S. Agimelen,
Carla Ferreira,
Bilal Ahmed,
Javier Cardona,
Yi-chieh Chen,
Alastair J. Florence,
Ivan Andonovic,
Jan Sefcik,
Anthony J. Mulholland
Abstract:
The in situ measurement of the particle size distribution (PSD) of a suspension of particles presents huge challenges. Various effects from the process could introduce noise to the data from which the PSD is estimated. This in turn could lead to the occurrence of artificial peaks in the estimated PSD. Limitations in the models used in the PSD estimation could also lead to the occurrence of these a…
▽ More
The in situ measurement of the particle size distribution (PSD) of a suspension of particles presents huge challenges. Various effects from the process could introduce noise to the data from which the PSD is estimated. This in turn could lead to the occurrence of artificial peaks in the estimated PSD. Limitations in the models used in the PSD estimation could also lead to the occurrence of these artificial peaks. This could pose a significant challenge to in situ monitoring of particulate processes, as there will be no independent estimate of the PSD to allow a discrimination of the artificial peaks to be carried out.
Here, we present an algorithm which is capable of discriminating between artificial and true peaks in PSD estimates based on fusion of multiple data streams. In this case, chord length distribution and laser diffraction data have been used. The data fusion is done by means of multi-objective optimisation using the weighted sum approach. The algorithm is applied to two different particle suspensions. The estimated PSDs from the algorithm are compared with offline estimates of PSD from the Malvern Mastersizer and Morphologi G3. The results show that the algorithm is capable of eliminating an artificial peak in a PSD estimate when this artificial peak is sufficiently displaced from the true peak. However, when the artificial peak is too close to the true peak, it is only suppressed but not completely eliminated.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Monitoring crystal breakage in wet milling processes using inline imaging and chord length distribution measurements
Authors:
Okpeafoh S. Agimelen,
Vaclav Svoboda,
Bilal Ahmed,
Javier Cardona,
Jerzy Dziewierz,
Cameron J. Brown,
Thomas McGlone,
Alison Cleary,
Christos Tachtatzis,
Craig Michie,
Alastair J. Florence,
Ivan Andonovic,
Anthony J. Mulholland,
Jan Sefcik
Abstract:
The success of the various secondary operations involved in the production of particulate products depends on the production of particles with a desired size and shape from a previous primary operation such as crystallisation. This is because these properties of size and shape affect the behaviour of the particles in the secondary processes. The size and the shape of the particles are very sensiti…
▽ More
The success of the various secondary operations involved in the production of particulate products depends on the production of particles with a desired size and shape from a previous primary operation such as crystallisation. This is because these properties of size and shape affect the behaviour of the particles in the secondary processes. The size and the shape of the particles are very sensitive to the conditions of the crystallisation processes, and so control of these processes is essential. This control requires the development of software tools that can effectively and efficiently process the sensor data captured in situ. However, these tools have various strengths and limitations depending on the process conditions and the nature of the particles.
In this work, we employ wet milling of crystalline particles as a case study of a process which produces effects typical to crystallisation processes. We study some of the strengths and limitations of our previously introduced tools for estimating the particle size distribution (PSD) and the aspect ratio from chord length distribution (CLD) and imaging data. We find situations where the CLD tool works better than the imaging tool and vice versa. However, in general both tools complement each other, and can therefore be employed in a suitable multi-objective optimisation approach to estimate PSD and aspect ratio.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Modelling of artefacts in estimations of particle size of needle-like particles from laser diffraction measurements
Authors:
Okpeafoh S. Agimelen,
Anthony J. Mulholland,
Jan Sefcik
Abstract:
Manufacturing of particulate products across many industries relies on accurate measurements of particle size distributions in dispersions or powders. Laser diffraction (or small angle light scattering) is commonly used, usually off-line, for particle size measurements. The estimation of particle sizes by this method requires the solution of an inverse problem using a suitable scattering model tha…
▽ More
Manufacturing of particulate products across many industries relies on accurate measurements of particle size distributions in dispersions or powders. Laser diffraction (or small angle light scattering) is commonly used, usually off-line, for particle size measurements. The estimation of particle sizes by this method requires the solution of an inverse problem using a suitable scattering model that takes into account size, shape and optical properties of the particles. However, laser diffraction instruments are usually accompanied by software that employs a default scattering model for spherical particles, which is then used to solve the inverse problem even though a significant number of particulate products occur in strongly non-spherical shapes such as needles. In this work, we demonstrate that using the spherical model for the estimation of sizes of needle-like particles can lead to the appearance of artefacts in the form of multimodal populations of particles with size modes much smaller than those actually present in the sample. This effect can result in a significant under-estimation of the mean particle size and in false modes in estimated particles size distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2016; v1 submitted 9 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Integration of in situ Imaging and Chord Length Distribution Measurements for Estimation of Particle Size and Shape
Authors:
Okpeafoh S. Agimelen,
Anna Jawor-Baczynska,
John McGinty,
Christos Tachtatzis,
Jerzy Dziewierz,
Ian Haley,
Jan Sefcik,
Anthony J. Mulholland
Abstract:
Efficient processing of particulate products across various manufacturing steps requires that particles possess desired attributes such as size and shape. Controlling the particle production process to obtain required attributes will be greatly facilitated using robust algorithms providing the size and shape information of the particles from in situ measurements. However, obtaining particle size a…
▽ More
Efficient processing of particulate products across various manufacturing steps requires that particles possess desired attributes such as size and shape. Controlling the particle production process to obtain required attributes will be greatly facilitated using robust algorithms providing the size and shape information of the particles from in situ measurements. However, obtaining particle size and shape information in situ during manufacturing has been a big challenge. This is because the problem of estimating particle size and shape (aspect ratio) from signals provided by in-line measuring tools is often ill posed, and therefore it calls for appropriate constraints to be imposed on the problem. One way to constrain uncertainty in estimation of particle size and shape from in-line measurements is to combine data from different measurements such as chord length distribution (CLD) and imaging. This paper presents two different methods for combining imaging and CLD data obtained with in-line tools in order to get reliable estimates of particle size distribution and aspect ratio, where the imaging data is used to constrain the search space for an aspect ratio from the CLD data.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2016; v1 submitted 13 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Estimation of Particle Size Distribution and Aspect Ratio of Non-Spherical Particles From Chord Length Distribution
Authors:
Okpeafoh S. Agimelen,
Peter Hamilton,
Ian Haley,
Alison Nordon,
Massimiliano Vasile,
Jan Sefcik,
Anthony J. Mulholland
Abstract:
Information about size and shape of particles produced in various manufacturing processes is very important for process and product development because design of downstream processes as well as final product properties strongly depend on these geometrical particle attributes. However, recovery of particle size and shape information in situ during crystallisation processes has been a major challeng…
▽ More
Information about size and shape of particles produced in various manufacturing processes is very important for process and product development because design of downstream processes as well as final product properties strongly depend on these geometrical particle attributes. However, recovery of particle size and shape information in situ during crystallisation processes has been a major challenge. The focused beam reflectance measurement (FBRM) provides the chord length distribution (CLD) of a population of particles in a suspension flowing close to the sensor window. Recovery of size and shape information from the CLD requires a model relating particle size and shape to its CLD as well as solving the corresponding inverse problem.
This paper presents a comprehensive algorithm which produces estimates of particle size distribution and particle aspect ratio from measured CLD data. While the algorithm searches for a global best solution to the inverse problem without requiring further a priori information on the range of particle sizes present in the population or aspect ratio of particles, suitable regularisation techniques based on relevant additional information can be implemented as required to obtain physically reasonable size distributions. We used the algorithm to analyse CLD data for samples of needle-like crystalline particles of various lengths using two previously published CLD models for ellipsoids and for thin cylinders to estimate particle size distribution and shape. We found that the thin cylinder model yielded significantly better agreement with experimental data, while estimated particle size distributions and aspect ratios were in good agreement with those obtained from imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2014; v1 submitted 19 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
