-
Producing treatment hierarchies in network meta-analysis using probabilistic models and treatment-choice criteria
Authors:
Theodoros Evrenoglou,
Adriani Nikolakopoulou,
Guido Schwarzer,
Gerta Rücker,
Anna Chaimani
Abstract:
A key output of network meta-analysis (NMA) is the relative ranking of the treatments; nevertheless, it has attracted a lot of criticism. This is mainly due to the fact that ranking is an influential output and prone to over-interpretations even when relative effects imply small differences between treatments. To date, common ranking methods rely on metrics that lack a straightforward interpretati…
▽ More
A key output of network meta-analysis (NMA) is the relative ranking of the treatments; nevertheless, it has attracted a lot of criticism. This is mainly due to the fact that ranking is an influential output and prone to over-interpretations even when relative effects imply small differences between treatments. To date, common ranking methods rely on metrics that lack a straightforward interpretation, while it is still unclear how to measure their uncertainty. We introduce a novel framework for estimating treatment hierarchies in NMA. At first, we formulate a mathematical expression that defines a treatment choice criterion (TCC) based on clinically important values. This TCC is applied to the study treatment effects to generate paired data indicating treatment preferences or ties. Then, we synthesize the paired data across studies using an extension of the so-called "Bradley-Terry" model. We assign to each treatment a latent variable interpreted as the treatment "ability" and we estimate the ability parameters within a regression model. Higher ability estimates correspond to higher positions in the final ranking. We further extend our model to adjust for covariates that may affect treatment selection. We illustrate the proposed approach and compare it with alternatives in two datasets: a network comparing 18 antidepressants for major depression and a network comparing 6 antihypertensives for the incidence of diabetes. Our approach provides a robust and interpretable treatment hierarchy which accounts for clinically important values and is presented alongside with uncertainty measures. Overall, the proposed framework offers a novel approach for ranking in NMA based on concrete criteria and preserves from over-interpretation of unimportant differences between treatments.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Shortest path or random walks? A framework for path weights in network meta-analysis
Authors:
Gerta Rücker,
Theodoros Papakonstantinou,
Adriani Nikolakopoulou,
Guido Schwarzer,
Tobias Galla,
Annabel L. Davies
Abstract:
Quantifying the contributions, or weights, of comparisons or single studies to the estimates in a network meta-analysis (NMA) is an active area of research. We extend this to the contributions of paths to NMA estimates. We present a general framework, based on the path-design matrix, that describes the problem of finding path contributions as a linear equation. The resulting solutions may have neg…
▽ More
Quantifying the contributions, or weights, of comparisons or single studies to the estimates in a network meta-analysis (NMA) is an active area of research. We extend this to the contributions of paths to NMA estimates. We present a general framework, based on the path-design matrix, that describes the problem of finding path contributions as a linear equation. The resulting solutions may have negative coefficients. We show that two known approaches, called shortestpath and randomwalk, are special solutions of this equation, and both meet an optimization criterion, as they minimize the sum of absolute path contributions. In general, there is an infinite space of solutions, which can be identified using the generalized inverse (Moore-Penrose pseudoinverse). We consider two further special approaches. For complex networks we find that shortestpath is superior with respect to run time and variability, compared to the other approaches, and is thus recommended in practice. The path-weights framework also has the potential to answer more general research questions in network meta-analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Model selection for component network meta-analysis in connected and disconnected networks: a simulation study
Authors:
Maria Petropoulou,
Gerta Rücker,
Stephanie Weibel,
Peter Kranke,
Guido Schwarzer
Abstract:
Network meta-analysis (NMA) is widely used in evidence synthesis to estimate the effects of several competing interventions for a given clinical condition. One of the challenges is that it is not possible in disconnected networks. Component network meta-analysis (CNMA) allows technically 'reconnecting' a disconnected network with multicomponent interventions. The additive CNMA model assumes that t…
▽ More
Network meta-analysis (NMA) is widely used in evidence synthesis to estimate the effects of several competing interventions for a given clinical condition. One of the challenges is that it is not possible in disconnected networks. Component network meta-analysis (CNMA) allows technically 'reconnecting' a disconnected network with multicomponent interventions. The additive CNMA model assumes that the effect of any multicomponent intervention is the additive sum of its components. This assumption can be relaxed by adding interaction component terms, which improves the goodness of fit but decreases the network connectivity. Model selection aims at finding the model with a reasonable balance between the goodness of fit and connectivity (selected CNMA model). We aim to introduce a forward model selection strategy for CNMA models and to investigate the performance of CNMA models for connected and disconnected networks. We applied the methods to a real Cochrane review dataset and simulated data with additive, mildly, or strongly violated intervention effects. We started with connected networks, and we artificially constructed disconnected networks. We compared the results of the additive and the selected CNMAs from each connected and disconnected network with the NMA using the mean squared error and coverage probability. CNMA models provide good performance for connected networks and can be an alternative to standard NMA if additivity holds. On the contrary, model selection does not perform well for disconnected networks, and we recommend conducting separate analyses of subnetworks.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
The influence of infant-directed speech on 12-month-olds' intersensory perception of fluent speech
Authors:
Claudia Kubicek,
Judit Gervain,
Anne Hillairet De Boisferon,
Olivier Pascalis,
Hélène Lœvenbruck,
Gudrun Schwarzer
Abstract:
The present study examined whether infant-directed (ID) speech facilitates intersensory matching of audio--visual fluent speech in 12-month-old infants. German-learning infantsâ audio--visual matching ability of German and French fluent speech was assessed by using a variant of the intermodal matching procedure, with auditory and visual speech information presented sequentially. In Experiment 1,…
▽ More
The present study examined whether infant-directed (ID) speech facilitates intersensory matching of audio--visual fluent speech in 12-month-old infants. German-learning infantsâ audio--visual matching ability of German and French fluent speech was assessed by using a variant of the intermodal matching procedure, with auditory and visual speech information presented sequentially. In Experiment 1, the sentences were spoken in an adult-directed (AD) manner. Results showed that 12-month-old infants did not exhibit a matching performance for the native, nor for the non-native language. However, Experiment 2 revealed that when ID speech stimuli were used, infants did perceive the relation between auditory and visual speech attributes, but only in response to their native language. Thus, the findings suggest that ID speech might have an influence on the intersensory perception of fluent speech and shed further light on multisensory perceptual narrowing.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
