-
The Wetting of H$_2$O by CO$_2$
Authors:
Samuel G. H. Brookes,
Venkat Kapil,
Christoph Schran,
Angelos Michaelides
Abstract:
Biphasic interfaces are complex but fascinating regimes that display a number of properties distinct from those of the bulk. The CO$_2$-H$_2$O interface, in particular, has been the subject of a number of studies on account of its importance for the carbon life cycle as well as carbon capture and sequestration schemes. Despite this attention, there remain a number of open questions on the nature o…
▽ More
Biphasic interfaces are complex but fascinating regimes that display a number of properties distinct from those of the bulk. The CO$_2$-H$_2$O interface, in particular, has been the subject of a number of studies on account of its importance for the carbon life cycle as well as carbon capture and sequestration schemes. Despite this attention, there remain a number of open questions on the nature of the CO$_2$-H$_2$O interface, particularly concerning the interfacial tension and phase behavior of CO$_2$ at the interface. In this paper, we seek to address these ambiguities using ab initio-quality simulations. Harnessing the benefits of machine-learned potentials and enhanced statistical sampling methods, we present an ab initio-level description of the CO$_2$-H$_2$O interface. Interfacial tensions are predicted from 1-500 bar and found to be in close agreement with experiment at the pressures for which experimental data is available. Structural analyses indicate the build-up of an adsorbed, saturated CO$_2$ film forming at low pressure (20 bar) with properties similar to those of the bulk liquid, but preferential perpendicular alignment with respect to the interface. CO$_2$ monolayer build-up coincides with a reduced structuring of water molecules close to the interface. This study highlights the predictive nature of machine-learned potentials for complex macroscopic properties of biphasic interfaces, and the mechanistic insight obtained into carbon dioxide aggregation at the water interface is of high relevance for geoscience, climate research, and materials science.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
A foundation model for atomistic materials chemistry
Authors:
Ilyes Batatia,
Philipp Benner,
Yuan Chiang,
Alin M. Elena,
Dávid P. Kovács,
Janosh Riebesell,
Xavier R. Advincula,
Mark Asta,
Matthew Avaylon,
William J. Baldwin,
Fabian Berger,
Noam Bernstein,
Arghya Bhowmik,
Samuel M. Blau,
Vlad Cărare,
James P. Darby,
Sandip De,
Flaviano Della Pia,
Volker L. Deringer,
Rokas Elijošius,
Zakariya El-Machachi,
Fabio Falcioni,
Edvin Fako,
Andrea C. Ferrari,
Annalena Genreith-Schriever
, et al. (51 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Machine-learned force fields have transformed the atomistic modelling of materials by enabling simulations of ab initio quality on unprecedented time and length scales. However, they are currently limited by: (i) the significant computational and human effort that must go into development and validation of potentials for each particular system of interest; and (ii) a general lack of transferabilit…
▽ More
Machine-learned force fields have transformed the atomistic modelling of materials by enabling simulations of ab initio quality on unprecedented time and length scales. However, they are currently limited by: (i) the significant computational and human effort that must go into development and validation of potentials for each particular system of interest; and (ii) a general lack of transferability from one chemical system to the next. Here, using the state-of-the-art MACE architecture we introduce a single general-purpose ML model, trained on a public database of 150k inorganic crystals, that is capable of running stable molecular dynamics on molecules and materials. We demonstrate the power of the MACE-MP-0 model - and its qualitative and at times quantitative accuracy - on a diverse set problems in the physical sciences, including the properties of solids, liquids, gases, chemical reactions, interfaces and even the dynamics of a small protein. The model can be applied out of the box and as a starting or "foundation model" for any atomistic system of interest and is thus a step towards democratising the revolution of ML force fields by lowering the barriers to entry.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024; v1 submitted 29 December, 2023;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen bonding in nanoconfined ice
Authors:
Pavan Ravindra,
Xavier R. Advincula,
Christoph Schran,
Angelos Michaelides,
Venkat Kapil
Abstract:
The Bernal-Fowler ice rules stipulate that each water molecule in an ice crystal should form four hydrogen bonds. However, in extreme or constrained conditions, the arrangement of water molecules deviates from conventional ice rules, resulting in properties significantly different from bulk water. In this study, we employ machine learning-driven first-principles simulations to identify a new stabi…
▽ More
The Bernal-Fowler ice rules stipulate that each water molecule in an ice crystal should form four hydrogen bonds. However, in extreme or constrained conditions, the arrangement of water molecules deviates from conventional ice rules, resulting in properties significantly different from bulk water. In this study, we employ machine learning-driven first-principles simulations to identify a new stabilization mechanism in nanoconfined ice phases beyond conventional ice rules. Instead of forming four hydrogen bonds, nanoconfined crystalline ice can form a quasi-one-dimensional hydrogen-bonded structure that exhibits only two hydrogen bonds per water molecule. These structures consist of strongly hydrogen-bonded linear chains of water molecules that zig-zag along one dimension, stabilized by van der Waals interactions that stack these chains along the other dimension. The unusual interplay of hydrogen bonding and van der Waals interactions in nanoconfined ice results in atypical proton behavior such as potential ferroelectric behavior, low dielectric response, and long-range proton dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2024; v1 submitted 3 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
To Pair or not to Pair? Machine-Learned Explicitly-Correlated Electronic Structure for NaCl in Water
Authors:
Niamh O'Neill,
Benjamin X. Shi,
Kara Fong,
Angelos Michaelides,
Christoph Schran
Abstract:
The extent of ion pairing in solution is an important phenomenon to rationalise transport and thermodynamic properties of electrolytes. A fundamental measure of this pairing is the potential of mean force (PMF) between solvated ions. The relative stabilities of the paired and solvent shared states in the PMF and the barrier between them are highly sensitive to the underlying potential energy surfa…
▽ More
The extent of ion pairing in solution is an important phenomenon to rationalise transport and thermodynamic properties of electrolytes. A fundamental measure of this pairing is the potential of mean force (PMF) between solvated ions. The relative stabilities of the paired and solvent shared states in the PMF and the barrier between them are highly sensitive to the underlying potential energy surface. However direct application of accurate electronic structure methods is challenging, since long simulations are required. We develop wavefunction based machine learning potentials with the Random Phase Approximation (RPA) and second order Moller-Plesset (MP2) perturbation theory for the prototypical system of Na and Cl ions in water. We show both methods in agreement, predicting the paired and solvent shared states to have similar energies (within 0.2 kcal/mol). We also provide the same benchmarks for different DFT functionals as well as insight into the PMF based on simple analyses of the interactions in the system.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2024; v1 submitted 2 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Understanding the anomalously low dielectric constant of confined water: an ab initio study
Authors:
Thomas Dufils,
Christoph Schran,
Ji Chen,
Andre K. Geim,
Laura Fumagalli,
Angelos Michaelides
Abstract:
Recent experiments have shown that the out-of-plane dielectric constant of water confined in nanoslits of graphite and hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) is vanishingly small. Despite extensive effort based mainly on classical force-field molecular dynamics (FFMD) approaches, the origin of this phenomenon is under debate. Here we used ab initio molecular dynamics simulations (AIMD) and AIMD-trained mac…
▽ More
Recent experiments have shown that the out-of-plane dielectric constant of water confined in nanoslits of graphite and hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) is vanishingly small. Despite extensive effort based mainly on classical force-field molecular dynamics (FFMD) approaches, the origin of this phenomenon is under debate. Here we used ab initio molecular dynamics simulations (AIMD) and AIMD-trained machine learning potentials to explore the structure and electronic properties of water confined inside graphene and hBN slits. We found that the reduced dielectric constant arises mainly from the anti-parallel alignment of the water dipoles in the perpendicular direction to the surface in the first two water layers near the solid interface. Although the water molecules retain liquid-like mobility, the interfacial layers exhibit a net ferroelectric ordering and constrained hydrogen-bonding orientations which lead to much reduced polarization fluctuations in the out-of-plane direction at room temperature. Importantly, we show that this effect is independent of the distance between the two confining surfaces of the slit, and it originates in the spontaneous polarization of interfacial water. Our calculations also show no significant variations in the structure and polarization of water near graphene and hBN, despite their different electronic structures. These results are important as they offer new insight into a property of water that plays a critical role in the long-range interactions between surfaces, the electric double-layer formation, ion solvation and transport, as well as biomolecular functioning.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Crumbling Crystals: On the Dissolution Mechanism of NaCl in Water
Authors:
Niamh O'Neill,
Christoph Schran,
Stephen J. Cox,
Angelos Michaelides
Abstract:
Life on Earth depends upon the dissolution of ionic salts in water, particularly NaCl. However, an atomistic scale understanding of the process remains elusive. Simulations lend themselves conveniently to studying dissolution since they provide the spatio-temporal resolution that can be difficult to obtain experimentally. Nevertheless, the complexity of various inter- and intra-molecular interacti…
▽ More
Life on Earth depends upon the dissolution of ionic salts in water, particularly NaCl. However, an atomistic scale understanding of the process remains elusive. Simulations lend themselves conveniently to studying dissolution since they provide the spatio-temporal resolution that can be difficult to obtain experimentally. Nevertheless, the complexity of various inter- and intra-molecular interactions require careful treatment and long time scale simulations, both of which are typically hindered by computational expense. Here, we use advances in machine learning potential methodology to resolve for the first time at an ab initio level of theory the dissolution mechanism of NaCl in water. The picture that emerges is that of a steady ion-wise unwrap** of the crystal preceding its rapid disintegration, reminiscent of crumbling. The onset of crumbling can be explained by a strong increase in the ratio of the surface to volume of the crystal. Overall, dissolution is comprised of a series of highly dynamical microscopic sub-processes, resulting in an inherently stochastic mechanism. These atomistic level insights now pave the way for a general understanding of dissolution mechanisms in other crystals, and the methodology is primed for more complex systems of recent interest such as water/salt interfaces under flow and salt crystals under confinement.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
State-resolved infrared spectrum of the protonated water dimer: Revisiting the characteristic proton transfer doublet peak
Authors:
Henrik R. Larsson,
Markus Schröder,
Richard Beckmann,
Fabien Brieuc,
Christoph Schran,
Dominik Marx,
Oriol Vendrell
Abstract:
The infrared (IR) spectra of protonated water clusters encode precise information on the dynamics and structure of the hydrated proton. However, the strong anharmonic coupling and quantum effects of these elusive species remain puzzling up to the present day. Here, we report unequivocal evidence that the interplay between the proton transfer and the water wagging motions in the protonated water di…
▽ More
The infrared (IR) spectra of protonated water clusters encode precise information on the dynamics and structure of the hydrated proton. However, the strong anharmonic coupling and quantum effects of these elusive species remain puzzling up to the present day. Here, we report unequivocal evidence that the interplay between the proton transfer and the water wagging motions in the protonated water dimer (Zundel ion) giving rise to the characteristic doublet peak is both more complex and more sensitive to subtle energetic changes than previously thought. In particular, hitherto overlooked low-intensity satellite peaks in the experimental spectrum are now unveiled and mechanistically assigned. Our findings rely on the comparison of IR spectra obtained using two highly accurate potential energy surfaces in conjunction with highly accurate state-resolved quantum simulations. We demonstrate that these high-accuracy simulations are important for providing definite assignments of the complex IR signals of fluxional molecules.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2022; v1 submitted 23 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Neural Network Interaction Potentials for para-Hydrogen with Flexible Molecules
Authors:
Laura Durán Caballero,
Christoph Schran,
Fabien Brieuc,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
The study of molecular impurities in $para$-hydrogen ($p$H$\rm_2$) clusters is key to push forward our understanding of intra- and intermolecular interactions including their impact on the superfluid response of this bosonic quantum solvent. This includes tagging with one or very few $p$H$\rm_2$, the microsolvation regime, and matrix isolation. However, the fundamental coupling between the bosonic…
▽ More
The study of molecular impurities in $para$-hydrogen ($p$H$\rm_2$) clusters is key to push forward our understanding of intra- and intermolecular interactions including their impact on the superfluid response of this bosonic quantum solvent. This includes tagging with one or very few $p$H$\rm_2$, the microsolvation regime, and matrix isolation. However, the fundamental coupling between the bosonic $p$H$\rm_2$ environment and the (ro-)vibrational motion of molecular impurities remains poorly understood. Quantum simulations can in provide the necessary atomistic insight, but very accurate descriptions of the involved interactions are required. Here, we present a data-driven approach for the generation of $impurity\cdots p$H$\rm_2$ interaction potentials based on machine learning techniques which retain the full flexibility of the impurity. We employ the well-established adiabatic hindered rotor (AHR) averaging technique to include the impact of the nuclear spin statistics on the symmetry-allowed rotational quantum numbers of $p$H$\rm_2$. Embedding this averaging procedure within the high-dimensional neural network potential (NNP) framework enables the generation of highly-accurate AHR-averaged NNPs at coupled cluster accuracy, namely CCSD(T$^*$)-F12a/aVTZcp in an automated manner. We apply this methodology to the water and protonated water molecules, as representative cases for quasi-rigid and highly-flexible molecules respectively, and obtain AHR-averaged NNPs that reliably describe the H$\rm _2$O$\cdots p$H$\rm_2$ and H$\rm _3$O$^+\cdots p$H$\rm_2$ interactions. Using path integral simulations we show for the hydronium cation that umbrella-like tunneling inversion has a strong impact on the first and second $p$H$\rm_2$ microsolvation shells. The data-driven nature of our protocol opens the door to the study of bosonic $p$H$\rm_2$ quantum solvation for a wide range of embedded impurities.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2022; v1 submitted 16 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Tracking single atoms in a liquid environment
Authors:
Nicholas Clark,
Daniel J. Kelly,
Mingwei Zhou,
Yi-Chao Zou,
Chang Woo Myung,
David G. Hopkinson,
Christoph Schran,
Angelos Michaelides,
Roman Gorbachev,
Sarah J. Haigh
Abstract:
The chemical behaviour of single metal atoms largely depends on the local coordination environment, including interactions with the substrate and with the surrounding gas or liquid. However, the key instrumentation for studying such systems at the atomic scale generally requires high vacuum conditions, limiting the degree to which the aforementioned environmental parameters can be investigated. He…
▽ More
The chemical behaviour of single metal atoms largely depends on the local coordination environment, including interactions with the substrate and with the surrounding gas or liquid. However, the key instrumentation for studying such systems at the atomic scale generally requires high vacuum conditions, limiting the degree to which the aforementioned environmental parameters can be investigated. Here we develop a new platform for transmission electron microscopy investigation of single metal atoms in liquids and study the dynamic behaviour of individual platinum atoms on the surface of a single layer MoS2 crystal in water. To achieve the record single atom resolution, we introduce a double liquid cell based on a 2D material heterostructure, which allows us to submerge an atomically thin membrane with liquid on both sides while maintaining the total specimen thickness of only ~ 70 nm. By comparison with an identical specimen imaged under high vacuum conditions, we reveal drastic differences in the single atom resting sites and atomic hop** behaviour, demonstrating that in situ imaging conditions are essential to gain complete understanding of the chemical activity of individual atoms. These findings pave the way for in situ liquid imaging of chemical processes with single atom precision.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2022; v1 submitted 9 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Water flow in single-wall nanotubes: Oxygen makes it slip, hydrogen makes it stick
Authors:
Fabian L Thiemann,
Christoph Schran,
Patrick Rowe,
Erich A Müller,
Angelos Michaelides
Abstract:
Experimental measurements have reported ultra-fast and radius-dependent water transport in carbon nanotubes which are absent in boron nitride nanotubes. Despite considerable effort, the origin of this contrasting (and fascinating) behaviour is not understood. Here, with the aid of machine learning-based molecular dynamics simulations that deliver first-principles accuracy, we investigate water tra…
▽ More
Experimental measurements have reported ultra-fast and radius-dependent water transport in carbon nanotubes which are absent in boron nitride nanotubes. Despite considerable effort, the origin of this contrasting (and fascinating) behaviour is not understood. Here, with the aid of machine learning-based molecular dynamics simulations that deliver first-principles accuracy, we investigate water transport in single-wall carbon and boron nitride nanotubes. Our simulations reveal a large, radius-dependent hydrodynamic slippage on both materials with water experiencing indeed a $\approx 5$ times lower friction on carbon surfaces compared to boron nitride. Analysis of the diffusion mechanisms across the two materials reveals that the fast water transport on carbon is governed by facile oxygen motion, whereas the higher friction on boron nitride arises from specific hydrogen-nitrogen interactions. This work not only delivers a clear reference of unprecedented accuracy for water flow in single-wall nanotubes, but also provides detailed mechanistic insight into its radius and material dependence for future technological application.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Infrared spectra at coupled cluster accuracy from neural network representations
Authors:
Richard Beckmann,
Fabien Brieuc,
Christoph Schran,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
Infrared spectroscopy is key to elucidate molecular structures, monitor reactions and observe conformational changes, while providing information on both structural and dynamical properties. This makes the accurate prediction of infrared spectra based on first-principle theories a highly desirable pursuit. Molecular dynamics simulations have proven to be a particularly powerful approach for this t…
▽ More
Infrared spectroscopy is key to elucidate molecular structures, monitor reactions and observe conformational changes, while providing information on both structural and dynamical properties. This makes the accurate prediction of infrared spectra based on first-principle theories a highly desirable pursuit. Molecular dynamics simulations have proven to be a particularly powerful approach for this task, albeit requiring the computation of energies, forces and dipole moments for a large number of molecular configurations as a function of time. This explains why highly accurate first principles methods, such as coupled cluster theory, have so far been inapplicable for the prediction of fully anharmonic vibrational spectra of large systems at finite temperatures. Here, we push cutting-edge machine learning techniques forward by using neural network representations of energies, forces and in particular dipoles to predict such infrared spectra fully at "gold standard" coupled cluster accuracy as demonstrated for protonated water clusters as large as the protonated water hexamer, in its extended Zundel configuration. Furthermore, we show that this methodology can be used beyond the scope of the data considered during the development of the neural network models, allowing for the computation of finite-temperature infrared spectra of large systems inaccessible to explicit coupled cluster calculations. This substantially expands the hitherto existing limits of accuracy, speed and system size for theoretical spectroscopy and opens up a multitude of avenues for the prediction of vibrational spectra and the understanding of complex intra- and intermolecular couplings.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2022; v1 submitted 1 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
The first-principles phase diagram of monolayer nanoconfined water
Authors:
Venkat Kapil,
Christoph Schran,
Andrea Zen,
Ji Chen,
Chris J. Pickard,
Angelos Michaelides
Abstract:
Water in nanoscale cavities is ubiquitous and of central importance to everyday phenomena in geology and biology. However, the properties of nanoscale water can be remarkably different from bulk, as shown e.g., by the anomalously low dielectric constant of water in nanochannels [1], near frictionless water flow [2], or the possible existence of a square ice phase [3]. Such properties suggest that…
▽ More
Water in nanoscale cavities is ubiquitous and of central importance to everyday phenomena in geology and biology. However, the properties of nanoscale water can be remarkably different from bulk, as shown e.g., by the anomalously low dielectric constant of water in nanochannels [1], near frictionless water flow [2], or the possible existence of a square ice phase [3]. Such properties suggest that nanoconfined water could be engineered for technological applications in nanouidics [4], electrolyte materials [5], and water desalination [6]. Unfortunately, challenges in experimentally characterising water on the nanoscale and the high cost of first-principles simulations have prevented the molecular level understanding required to control the behavior of water. Here we combine a range of computational approaches to enable a first-principles level investigation of a single layer of water within a graphene-like channel. We find that monolayer water exhibits surprisingly rich and diverse phase behavior that is highly sensitive to temperature and the van der Waals pressure acting within the nanochannel. In addition to multiple molecular phases with melting temperatures varying non-monotonically by over 400 degrees with pressure, we predict a hexatic phase, which is an intermediate between a solid and a liquid, and a superionic phase with a high electrical conductivity exceeding that of battery materials. Notably, this suggests that nanoconfinement could be a promising route towards superionic behavior at easily accessible conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2022; v1 submitted 27 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Machine learning potentials for complex aqueous systems made simple
Authors:
Christoph Schran,
Fabian L. Thiemann,
Patrick Rowe,
Erich A. Müller,
Ondrej Marsalek,
Angelos Michaelides
Abstract:
Simulation techniques based on accurate and efficient representations of potential energy surfaces are urgently needed for the understanding of complex aqueous systems such as solid-liquid interfaces. Here, we present a machine learning framework that enables the efficient development and validation of models for complex aqueous systems. Instead of trying to deliver a globally-optimal machine lear…
▽ More
Simulation techniques based on accurate and efficient representations of potential energy surfaces are urgently needed for the understanding of complex aqueous systems such as solid-liquid interfaces. Here, we present a machine learning framework that enables the efficient development and validation of models for complex aqueous systems. Instead of trying to deliver a globally-optimal machine learning potential, we propose to develop models applicable to specific thermodynamic state points in a simple and user-friendly process. After an initial ab initio simulation, a machine learning potential is constructed with minimum human effort through a data-driven active learning protocol. Such models can afterwards be applied in exhaustive simulations to provide reliable answers for the scientific question at hand. We showcase this methodology on a diverse set of aqueous systems with increasing degrees of complexity. The systems chosen here comprise bulk water with different ions in solution, water on a titanium dioxide surface, as well as water confined in nanotubes and between molybdenum disulfide sheets. Highlighting the accuracy of our approach with respect to the underlying ab initio reference, the resulting models are evaluated in detail with an automated validation protocol that includes structural and dynamical properties and the precision of the force prediction of the models. Finally, we demonstrate the capabilities of our approach for the description of water on the rutile titanium dioxide (110) surface to analyze the structure and mobility of water on this surface. Such machine learning models provide a straightforward and uncomplicated but accurate extension of simulation time and length scales for complex systems.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2021; v1 submitted 31 May, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Correlated Particle Motion and THz Spectral Response of Supercritical Water
Authors:
Maciej Śmiechowsk,
Christoph Schran,
Harald Forbert,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
Molecular dynamics simulations of supercritical water reveal distinctly different distance-dependent modulations of dipolar response and correlations in particle motion compared to ambient conditions. The strongly perturbed H-bond network of water at supercritical conditions allows for considerable translational and rotational freedom of individual molecules. These changes give rise to substantial…
▽ More
Molecular dynamics simulations of supercritical water reveal distinctly different distance-dependent modulations of dipolar response and correlations in particle motion compared to ambient conditions. The strongly perturbed H-bond network of water at supercritical conditions allows for considerable translational and rotational freedom of individual molecules. These changes give rise to substantially different infrared spectra and vibrational density of states at THz frequencies for densities above and below the Widom line that separates percolating liquid-like and clustered gas-like supercritical water.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Force-induced Catastrophes on Energy Landscapes: Mechanochemical Manipulation of Downhill and Uphill Bifurcations Explains Ring-opening Selectivity of Cyclopropanes
Authors:
Miriam Wollenhaupt,
Christoph Schran,
Martin Krupička,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
The mechanochemistry of ring-opening reactions of cyclopropane derivatives turns out to be unexpectedly rich and puzzling. After showing that a rare so-called uphill bifurcation in the case of trans-gem-difluorocyclopropane turns into a downhill bifurcation upon substitution of fluorine by chlorine, bromine and iodine in the thermal activation limit, the dichloro derivative is studied systematical…
▽ More
The mechanochemistry of ring-opening reactions of cyclopropane derivatives turns out to be unexpectedly rich and puzzling. After showing that a rare so-called uphill bifurcation in the case of trans-gem-difluorocyclopropane turns into a downhill bifurcation upon substitution of fluorine by chlorine, bromine and iodine in the thermal activation limit, the dichloro derivative is studied systematically in the realm of mechanochemical activation. Detailed exploration of the force-transformed potential energy surface of trans-gem-dichlorocyclopropane in terms of Dijkstra path analysis unveils a hitherto unknown topological catastrophe where the global shape of the energy landscape is fundamentally changed. From thermal activation up to moderately large forces, it is an uphill bifurcation that decides about dis-versus conrotatory ring-opening followed by separate transition states along both pathways. Above a critical force, the two distinct transition states merge to yield a single transition state such that the decision about the dis-versus conrotatory ring-opening process is taken at a newly established downhill bifurcation. The discovery of a force-induced qualitative change of the topology of a reaction network vastly transcends the previous understanding of the ring-opening reaction of this species. It would be astonishing to not discover a wealth of such catastrophes for mechanochemically activated reactions which will greatly extend the known opportunities to manipulate chemical reaction networks.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
High-dimensional neural network potentials for solvation: The case of protonated water clusters in helium
Authors:
Christoph Schran,
Felix Uhl,
Jörg Behler,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
The design of accurate helium-solute interaction potentials for the simulation of chemically complex molecules solvated in superfluid helium has long been a cumbersome task due to the rather weak but strongly anisotropic nature of the interactions. We show that this challenge can be met by using a combination of an effective pair potential for the He-He interactions and a flexible high-dimensional…
▽ More
The design of accurate helium-solute interaction potentials for the simulation of chemically complex molecules solvated in superfluid helium has long been a cumbersome task due to the rather weak but strongly anisotropic nature of the interactions. We show that this challenge can be met by using a combination of an effective pair potential for the He-He interactions and a flexible high-dimensional neural network potential (NNP) for describing the complex interaction between helium and the solute in a pairwise additive manner. This approach yields an excellent agreement with a mean absolute deviation as small as 0.04 kJ/mol for the interaction energy between helium and both, hydronium and Zundel cations compared to CCSD(T) reference calculations with an energetically converged basis set. The construction and improvement of the potential can be performed in a highly automated way, which opens the door for applications to a variety of reactive molecules to study the effect of solvation on the solute as well as the solute-induced structuring of the solvent. Furthermore, we show that this NNP approach yields very convincing agreement with the CCSD(T) reference for properties like many-body spatial and radial distribution functions. This holds for the microsolvation of the protonated water monomer and dimer by a few helium atoms up to their solvation in bulk helium as obtained from path integral simulations at about 1 K.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Converged Colored Noise Path Integral Molecular Dynamics Study of the Zundel Cation down to Ultra-low Temperatures at Coupled Cluster Accuracy
Authors:
Christoph Schran,
Fabien Brieuc,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
For a long time, performing converged path integral simulations at ultra-low, but finite temperatures of a few Kelvin has been a nearly impossible task. However, recent developments in advanced colored noise thermostatting schemes for path integral simulations, namely the Path Integral Generalized Langevin Equation Thermostat (PIGLET) and the Path Integral Quantum Thermal Bath (PIQTB), have been a…
▽ More
For a long time, performing converged path integral simulations at ultra-low, but finite temperatures of a few Kelvin has been a nearly impossible task. However, recent developments in advanced colored noise thermostatting schemes for path integral simulations, namely the Path Integral Generalized Langevin Equation Thermostat (PIGLET) and the Path Integral Quantum Thermal Bath (PIQTB), have been able to greatly reduce the computational cost of these simulations, thus making the ultra-low temperature regime accessible in practice. In this work, we investigate the influence of these two thermostatting schemes on the description of hydrogen-bonded systems at temperatures down to a few Kelvin as encountered, for example, in helium nanodroplet isolation or tagging photodissociation spectroscopy experiments. For this purpose, we analyze the prototypical hydrogen bond in the Zundel cation (H$_5$O$_{2}^{+}$) as a function of both, oxygen-oxygen distance and temperature in order to elucidate how the anisotropic quantum delocalization and, thus, the shape of the shared proton adapts depending on the donor-acceptor distance. The underlying electronic structure of the Zundel cation is described in terms of Behler's Neural Network Potentials of essentially converged Coupled Cluster accuracy, CCSD(T*)-F12a/AVTZ. In addition, the performances of the PIQTB and PIGLET methods for energetic, structural, and quantum delocalization properties are assessed and directly compared. Overall, our results emphasize the validity and practical usefulness of these two modern thermostatting approaches for path integral simulations of hydrogen-bonded systems even at ultra-low temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Manifestations of Local Supersolidity of $^{4}$He around a Charged Molecular Impurity
Authors:
Fabien Brieuc,
Christoph Schran,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
A frozen, solid helium core, dubbed snowball, is typically observed around cations in liquid helium. Here we discover, using path integral simulations, that around a cationic molecular impurity, protonated methane, the $^4$He atoms are indeed strongly localized akin to snowballs but still participate in vivid bosonic exchange induced by the ro-vibrational motion of the impurity. Such combination o…
▽ More
A frozen, solid helium core, dubbed snowball, is typically observed around cations in liquid helium. Here we discover, using path integral simulations, that around a cationic molecular impurity, protonated methane, the $^4$He atoms are indeed strongly localized akin to snowballs but still participate in vivid bosonic exchange induced by the ro-vibrational motion of the impurity. Such combination of solid-like order with pronounced superfluid response in the first helium shell indicates that manifestations of local supersolid behavior of $^4$He can be induced -- and probed experimentally -- by charged molecules.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2023; v1 submitted 16 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Transferability of machine learning potentials: Protonated water neural network potential applied to the protonated water hexamer
Authors:
Christoph Schran,
Fabien Brieuc,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
A previously published neural network potential for the description of protonated water clusters up to the protonated water tetramer, H$^+$(H$_2$O)$_4$, at essentially converged coupled cluster accuracy (J. Chem. Theory Comput. 16, 88 (2020)) is applied to the protonated water hexamer, H$^+$(H$_2$O)$_6$ -- a system that the neural network has never seen before. Although being in the extrapolation…
▽ More
A previously published neural network potential for the description of protonated water clusters up to the protonated water tetramer, H$^+$(H$_2$O)$_4$, at essentially converged coupled cluster accuracy (J. Chem. Theory Comput. 16, 88 (2020)) is applied to the protonated water hexamer, H$^+$(H$_2$O)$_6$ -- a system that the neural network has never seen before. Although being in the extrapolation regime, it is shown that the potential not only allows for quantum simulations from ultra-low temperatures $\sim$ 1 K up to 300 K, but that it is able to describe the new system very accurately compared to explicit coupled cluster calculations. This transferability of the model is rationalized by the similarity of the atomic environments encountered for the larger cluster compared to the environments in the training set of the model. Compared to the interpolation regime the quality of the model is reduced by roughly one order of magnitude, but most of the difference to the coupled cluster reference comes from global shifts of the potential energy surface, while local energy fluctuations are well recovered. These results suggest that the application of neural network potentials in extrapolation regimes can provide useful results and might be more general than usually thought.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2021; v1 submitted 28 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Deciphering High-order Structural Correlations within Fluxional Molecules from Classical and Quantum Configurational Entropy
Authors:
Rafal Topolnicki,
Fabien Brieuc,
Christoph Schran,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
We employ the k-th nearest-neighbor estimator of configurational entropy in order to decode within a parameter-free numerical approach the complex high-order structural correlations in fluxional molecules going beyond the usual linear, bivariate correlations. This generic entropy-based scheme for determining many-body correlations is applied to the complex configurational ensemble of protonated ac…
▽ More
We employ the k-th nearest-neighbor estimator of configurational entropy in order to decode within a parameter-free numerical approach the complex high-order structural correlations in fluxional molecules going beyond the usual linear, bivariate correlations. This generic entropy-based scheme for determining many-body correlations is applied to the complex configurational ensemble of protonated acetylene, a prototype for fluxional molecules featuring large-amplitude motion. After revealing the importance of high-order correlations beyond the simple two-coordinate picture for this molecule, we analyze in detail the evolution of the relevant correlations with temperature as well as the impact of nuclear quantum effects down to the ultra-low temperature regime of 1 K. We find that quantum delocalization and zero-point vibrations significantly reduce all correlations in protonated acetylene in the deep quantum regime. At intermediate temperatures of approximately 100 to 800 K, a quantum-to-classical cross-over regime is found where classical mechanics starts to correctly describe trends in the correlations whereas it even qualitatively fails below 100 K. Finally, a classical description of the nuclei provides correlations that are in quantitative agreement with the quantum ones only at temperatures exceeding 1000 K. This data-intensive analysis has been made possible due to recent developments of machine learning techniques based on neural network potentials in full dimensionality that allow us to exhaustively sample both, the classical and quantum ensemble of protonated acetylene at essentially converged coupled cluster accuracy. The presented non-parametric analysis of correlations is expected to complement and guide the analysis of experimental measurements, in particular multi-dimensional vibrational spectroscopy, by revealing the complex coupling between various degrees of freedom.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Committee neural network potentials control generalization errors and enable active learning
Authors:
Christoph Schran,
Krystof Brezina,
Ondrej Marsalek
Abstract:
It is well known in the field of machine learning that committee models improve accuracy, provide generalization error estimates, and enable active learning strategies. In this work, we adapt these concepts to interatomic potentials based on artificial neural networks. Instead of a single model, multiple models that share the same atomic environment descriptors yield an average that outperforms it…
▽ More
It is well known in the field of machine learning that committee models improve accuracy, provide generalization error estimates, and enable active learning strategies. In this work, we adapt these concepts to interatomic potentials based on artificial neural networks. Instead of a single model, multiple models that share the same atomic environment descriptors yield an average that outperforms its individual members as well as a measure of the generalization error in the form of the committee disagreement. We not only use this disagreement to identify the most relevant configurations to build up the model's training set in an active learning procedure, but also monitor and bias it during simulations to control the generalization error. This facilitates the adaptive development of committee neural network potentials and their training sets, while kee** the number of ab initio calculations to a minimum. To illustrate the benefits of this methodology, we apply it to the development of a committee model for water in the condensed phase. Starting from a single reference ab initio simulation, we use active learning to expand into new state points and to describe the quantum nature of the nuclei. The final model, trained on 814 reference calculations, yields excellent results under a range of conditions, from liquid water at ambient and elevated temperatures and pressures to different phases of ice, and the air-water interface - all including nuclear quantum effects. This approach to committee models will enable the systematic development of robust machine learning models for a broad range of systems.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2020; v1 submitted 2 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Quantum Nature of the Hydrogen Bond from Ambient Conditions down to Ultra-low Temperatures
Authors:
Christoph Schran,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
Many experimental techniques such as tagging photodissociation and helium nanodroplet isolation spectroscopy operate at very low temperatures in order to investigate hydrogen bonding. To elucidate the differences between such ultra-cold and usual ambient conditions, different hydrogen bonded systems are studied systematically from 300 K down to about 1 K using path integral simulations that explic…
▽ More
Many experimental techniques such as tagging photodissociation and helium nanodroplet isolation spectroscopy operate at very low temperatures in order to investigate hydrogen bonding. To elucidate the differences between such ultra-cold and usual ambient conditions, different hydrogen bonded systems are studied systematically from 300 K down to about 1 K using path integral simulations that explicitly consider both, the quantum nature of the nuclei and thermal fluctuations. For that purpose, finite sized water clusters, specifically the water dimer and hexamer, protonated water clusters including the Zundel and Eigen complexes, as well as hexagonal ice as a condensed phase representative are compared directly as a function of temperature. While weaker hydrogen bonds, as present in the neutral systems, show distinct structural differences between ambient conditions and the ultra-cold regime, the stronger hydrogen bonds of the protonated water clusters are less perturbed by temperature compared to their quantum ground state. In all studied systems, the quantum delocalization of the nuclei is found to vary drastically with temperature. Interestingly, upon reaching temperatures of about 1 K, the spatial quantum delocalization of the heavy oxygens approaches that of the protons for relatively weak spatial constraints, and even significantly exceeds the latter in case of the centered hydrogen bond in the Zundel complex. These findings are relevant for comparisons between experiments on hydrogen bonding carried out at ultra-cold versus ambient conditions as well as to understand quantum delocalization phenomena of nuclei by seamlessly extending our insights into noncovalent interactions down to ultra-low temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2019; v1 submitted 30 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Automated Fitting of Neural Network Potentials at Coupled Cluster Accuracy: Protonated Water Clusters as Testing Ground
Authors:
Christoph Schran,
Jörg Behler,
Dominik Marx
Abstract:
Highly accurate potential energy surfaces are of key interest for the detailed understanding and predictive modeling of chemical systems. In recent years, several new types of force fields, which are based on machine learning algorithms and fitted to ab initio reference calculations, have been introduced to meet this requirement. Here we show how high-dimensional neural network potentials can be e…
▽ More
Highly accurate potential energy surfaces are of key interest for the detailed understanding and predictive modeling of chemical systems. In recent years, several new types of force fields, which are based on machine learning algorithms and fitted to ab initio reference calculations, have been introduced to meet this requirement. Here we show how high-dimensional neural network potentials can be employed to automatically generate the potential energy surface of finite sized clusters at coupled cluster accuracy, namely CCSD(T*)-F12a/aug-cc-pVTZ. The developed automated procedure utilizes the established intrinsic properties of the model such that the configurations for the training set are selected in an unbiased and efficient way to minimize the computational effort of expensive reference calculations. These ideas are applied to protonated water clusters from the hydronium cation, H$_3$O$^+$, up to the tetramer, H$_9$O$_{4}^{+}$, and lead to a single potential energy surface that describes all these systems at essentially converged coupled cluster accuracy with a fitting error of 0.06 kJ/mol per atom. The fit is validated in detail for all clusters up to the tetramer and yields reliable results not only for stationary points, but also for reaction pathways, intermediate configurations, as well as different sampling techniques. Per design the NNPs constructed in this fashion can handle very different conditions including the quantum nature of the nuclei and enhanced sampling techniques covering very low as well as high temperatures. This enables fast and exhaustive exploration of the targeted protonated water clusters with essentially converged interactions. In addition, the automated process will allow one to tackle finite systems much beyond the present case.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2019; v1 submitted 23 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Unravelling the influence of quantum proton delocalization on electronic charge transfer through the hydrogen bond
Authors:
Christoph Schran,
Ondrej Marsalek,
Thomas E. Markland
Abstract:
Upon hydrogen bond formation, electronic charge density is transferred between the donor and acceptor, impacting processes ranging from hydration to spectroscopy. Here we use ab initio path integral simulations to elucidate the role of nuclear quantum effects in determining the charge transfer in a range of hydrogen bonded species in the gas and liquid phase. We show that the quantization of the n…
▽ More
Upon hydrogen bond formation, electronic charge density is transferred between the donor and acceptor, impacting processes ranging from hydration to spectroscopy. Here we use ab initio path integral simulations to elucidate the role of nuclear quantum effects in determining the charge transfer in a range of hydrogen bonded species in the gas and liquid phase. We show that the quantization of the nuclei gives rise to large changes in the magnitude of the charge transfer as well as its temperature dependence. We then explain how a single geometric parameter determines the charge transfer through the hydrogen bond. These results thus demonstrate that nuclear quantum effects are vital for the accurate description of charge transfer and offer a physically transparent way to understand how hydrogen bonding gives rise to it.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2018; v1 submitted 17 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.