Comparative Evaluation of Bipartite, Node-Link, and Matrix-Based Network Representations
Authors:
Moataz Abdelaal,
Nathan D. Schiele,
Katrin Angerbauer,
Kuno Kurzhals,
Michael Sedlmair,
Daniel Weiskopf
Abstract:
This work investigates and compares the performance of node-link diagrams, adjacency matrices, and bipartite layouts for visualizing networks. In a crowd-sourced user study (n = 150), we measure the task accuracy and completion time of the three representations for different network classes and properties. In contrast to the literature, which covers mostly topology-based tasks (e.g., path finding)…
▽ More
This work investigates and compares the performance of node-link diagrams, adjacency matrices, and bipartite layouts for visualizing networks. In a crowd-sourced user study (n = 150), we measure the task accuracy and completion time of the three representations for different network classes and properties. In contrast to the literature, which covers mostly topology-based tasks (e.g., path finding) in small datasets, we mainly focus on overview tasks for large and directed networks. We consider three overview tasks on networks with 500 nodes: (T1) network class identification, (T2) cluster detection, and (T3) network density estimation, and two detailed tasks: (T4) node in-degree vs. out-degree and (T5) representation map**, on networks with 50 and 20 nodes, respectively. Our results show that bipartite layouts are beneficial for revealing the overall network structure, while adjacency matrices are most reliable across the different tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
A Novel Approach for Attack Tree to Attack Graph Transformation: Extended Version
Authors:
Nathan Daniel Schiele,
Olga Gadyatskaya
Abstract:
Attack trees and attack graphs are both common graphical threat models used by organizations to better understand possible cybersecurity threats. These models have been primarily seen as separate entities, to be used and researched in entirely different contexts, but recently there has emerged a new interest in combining the strengths of these models and in transforming models from one notation in…
▽ More
Attack trees and attack graphs are both common graphical threat models used by organizations to better understand possible cybersecurity threats. These models have been primarily seen as separate entities, to be used and researched in entirely different contexts, but recently there has emerged a new interest in combining the strengths of these models and in transforming models from one notation into the other. The existing works in this area focus on transforming attack graphs into attack trees. In this paper, we propose an approach to transform attack trees into attack graphs based on the fundamental understanding of how actions are represented in both structures. From this, we hope to enable more versatility in both structures.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
