-
Charge transport in doped conjugated polymers for organic thermoelectrics
Authors:
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Emmy Järsvall,
Jian Liu,
Davide Beretta,
Simone Fabiano,
Mario Caironi,
Martijn Kemerink,
Christian Müller
Abstract:
Research on conjugated polymers for thermoelectric applications has made tremendous progress in recent years, which is accompanied by surging interest in molecular do** as a means to achieve the high electrical conductivities that are required. A detailed understanding of the complex relationship between the do** process, the structural as well as energetic properties of the polymer films, and…
▽ More
Research on conjugated polymers for thermoelectric applications has made tremendous progress in recent years, which is accompanied by surging interest in molecular do** as a means to achieve the high electrical conductivities that are required. A detailed understanding of the complex relationship between the do** process, the structural as well as energetic properties of the polymer films, and the resulting thermoelectric behavior is slowly emerging. This review summarizes recent developments and strategies that permit enhancing the electrical conductivity of p- and n-type conjugated polymers via molecular do**. The impact of the chemical design of both the polymer and the dopant, the processing conditions, and the resulting nanostructure on the do** efficiency and stability of the doped state are discussed. Attention is paid to the interdependence of the electrical and thermal transport characteristics of semiconductor host-dopant systems and the Seebeck coefficient. Strategies that permit to improve the thermoelectric performance, such as an uniaxial alignment of the polymer backbone in both bulk and thin film geometries, manipulation of the dielectric constant of the polymer, and the variation of the dopant size, are explored. A combination of theory and experiment is predicted to yield new chemical design principles and processing schemes that will ultimately give rise to the next generation of organic thermoelectric materials.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Experimentally Validated Hop**-Transport Model for Energetically Disordered Organic Semiconductors
Authors:
Tanvi Upreti,
Yuming Wang,
Huotian Zhang,
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Feng Gao,
Martijn Kemerink
Abstract:
Charge transport in disordered organic semiconductors occurs by hop** of charge carriers between localized sites that are randomly distributed in a strongly energy dependent density of states. Extracting disorder and hop** parameters from experimental data like temperature dependent current-voltage characteristics typically relies on parametrized mobility functionals that are integrated in a d…
▽ More
Charge transport in disordered organic semiconductors occurs by hop** of charge carriers between localized sites that are randomly distributed in a strongly energy dependent density of states. Extracting disorder and hop** parameters from experimental data like temperature dependent current-voltage characteristics typically relies on parametrized mobility functionals that are integrated in a drift-diffusion solver. Surprisingly, the functional based on the extended Gaussian disorder model (eGDM) has been extremely successful at this, despite it being based on the assumption of nearest neighbor hop** (nnH) on a regular lattice. We here propose a variable range hop** (VRH) model that has been integrated in a freeware drift-diffusion solver. The mobility model has been calibrated using kinetic Monte Carlo calculations and shows good agreement with the Monte Carlo calculations over the experimentally relevant part of the parameter space. The model is applied to temperature-dependent space charge limited current (SCLC) measurements of different systems. In contrast to the eGDM, the VRH model provides a consistent description of both p-type and n-type devices. We find a critical ratio of aNN/$α$ (mean inter-site distance / localization radius) of ~3 below which hop** to non-nearest neighbors becomes important around room temperature and the eGDM cannot be used for parameter extraction. Typical (Gaussian) disorder values in the range 45-120 meV are found, without any clear correlation with photovoltaic performance when the same active layer is used in an organic solar cell.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
High thermoelectric power factor of poly(3-hexylthiophene) through in-plane alignment and do** with a molybdenum dithiolene complex
Authors:
Viktoriia Untilova,
Jonna Hynynen,
Anna I. Hofmann,
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Yadong Zhang,
Stephen Barlow,
Martijn Kemerink,
Seth R. Marder,
Laure Biniek,
Christian Müller,
Martin Brinkmann
Abstract:
Here we report a record thermoelectric power factor of up to 160 $μ$ W m-1 K-2 for the conjugated polymer poly(3-hexylthiophene) (P3HT). This result is achieved through the combination of high-temperature rubbing of thin films together with the use of a large molybdenum dithiolene p-dopant with a high electron affinity. Comparison of the UV-vis-NIR spectra of the chemically doped samples to electr…
▽ More
Here we report a record thermoelectric power factor of up to 160 $μ$ W m-1 K-2 for the conjugated polymer poly(3-hexylthiophene) (P3HT). This result is achieved through the combination of high-temperature rubbing of thin films together with the use of a large molybdenum dithiolene p-dopant with a high electron affinity. Comparison of the UV-vis-NIR spectra of the chemically doped samples to electrochemically oxidized material reveals an oxidation level of 10%, i.e. one polaron for every 10 repeat units. The high power factor arises due to an increase in the charge-carrier mobility and hence electrical conductivity along the rubbing direction. We conclude that P3HT, with its facile synthesis and outstanding processability, should not be ruled out as a potential thermoelectric material.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Rubbing and Drawing: Generic Ways to Improve the Thermoelectric Power Factor of Organic Semiconductors?
Authors:
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Vishnu Vijayakumar,
Huiyan Zeng,
Pablo Durand,
Nicolas Leclerc,
Martin Brinkmann,
Martijn Kemerink
Abstract:
Highly oriented polymer films can show considerable anisotropy in the thermoelectric properties leading to power factors beyond those predicted by the widely obeyed power law linking the thermopower $S$ and the electrical conductivity $σ$ as $S\proptoσ^{-1/4}$. This has led to encouraging practical results with respect to the electrical conductivity, notwithstanding that the conditions necessary t…
▽ More
Highly oriented polymer films can show considerable anisotropy in the thermoelectric properties leading to power factors beyond those predicted by the widely obeyed power law linking the thermopower $S$ and the electrical conductivity $σ$ as $S\proptoσ^{-1/4}$. This has led to encouraging practical results with respect to the electrical conductivity, notwithstanding that the conditions necessary to enhance $σ$ and $S$ simultaneously are less clear. Here, kinetic Monte Carlo simulations are used to study the impact of structural anisotropy on the thermoelectric properties of disordered organic semiconductors. We find that stretching is a suitable strategy to improve the conductivity along the direction of strain, while the effect on the power factor depends on the morphology the polymer crystallizes. In general, crystalline polymers show a simultaneous increase in $σ$ and $S$ which is not the case for amorphous polymers. Moreover, we show that the trends resulting from simulations based on variable-range hop** are in good agreement with experiments and can describe the different functional dependencies in the $S$ versus $σ$ behaviour of different directions.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Non-Wiedemann-Franz Behavior of the Thermal Conductivity of Organic Semiconductors
Authors:
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Martijn Kemerink
Abstract:
Organic semiconductors have attracted increasing interest as thermoelectric converters in recent years due to their intrinsically low thermal conductivity compared to inorganic materials. This boom has led to encouraging practical results, in which the thermal conductivity has predominantly been treated as an empirical number. However, in an optimized thermoelectric material, the electronic compon…
▽ More
Organic semiconductors have attracted increasing interest as thermoelectric converters in recent years due to their intrinsically low thermal conductivity compared to inorganic materials. This boom has led to encouraging practical results, in which the thermal conductivity has predominantly been treated as an empirical number. However, in an optimized thermoelectric material, the electronic component can dominate the thermal conductivity in which case the figure of merit $ZT$ becomes a function of thermopower and Lorentz factor only. Hence design of effective organic thermoelectric materials requires understanding the Lorenz number. Here, analytical modeling and kinetic Monte Carlo simulations are combined to study the effect of energetic disorder and length scales on the correlation of electrical and thermal conductivity in organic semiconductor thermoelectrics. We show that a Lorenz factor up to a factor $\sim 5$ below the Sommerfeld value can be obtained for weakly disordered systems, in contrast with what has been observed for materials with band transport. Although the electronic contribution dominates the thermal conductivity within the application-relevant parameter space, reaching ZT>1 would require to minimize both the energetic disorder but also the lattice thermal conductivity to values below $κ_\text{lat}<0.2$W/mK.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
How to Reduce Charge Recombination in Organic Solar Cells: There Are Still Lessons to Learn from P3HT:PCBM
Authors:
Sebastian Wilken,
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Staffan Dahlström,
Mathias Nyman,
Jürgen Parisi,
Ronald Österbacka
Abstract:
Suppressing charge recombination is key for organic solar cells to become commercial reality. However, there is still no conclusive picture of how recombination losses are influenced by the complex nanoscale morphology. Here, new insight is provided by revisiting the P3HT:PCBM blend, which is still one of the best performers regarding reduced recombination. By changing small details in the anneali…
▽ More
Suppressing charge recombination is key for organic solar cells to become commercial reality. However, there is still no conclusive picture of how recombination losses are influenced by the complex nanoscale morphology. Here, new insight is provided by revisiting the P3HT:PCBM blend, which is still one of the best performers regarding reduced recombination. By changing small details in the annealing procedure, two model morphologies were prepared that vary in phase separation, molecular order and phase purity, as revealed by electron tomography and optical spectroscopy. Both systems behave very similarly with respect to charge generation and transport, but differ significantly in bimolecular recombination. Only the system containing P3HT aggregates of high crystalline quality and purity is found to achieve exceptionally low recombination rates. The high-quality aggregates support charge delocalization, which assists the re-dissociation of interfacial charge-transfer states formed upon the encounter of free carriers. For devices with the optimized morphology, an exceptional long hole diffusion length is found, which allows them to work as Shockley-type solar cells even in thick junctions of 300 nm. In contrast, the encounter rate and the size of the phase-separated domains appears to be less important.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2021; v1 submitted 18 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Watching Space Charge Build up in an Organic Solar Cell
Authors:
Sebastian Wilken,
Oskar J. Sandberg,
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Ronald Österbacka
Abstract:
Space charge effects can significantly degrade charge collection in organic photovoltaics (OPVs), especially in thick-film devices. The two main causes of space charge are do** and imbalanced transport. Although these are completely different phenomena, they lead to the same voltage dependence of the photocurrent, making them difficult to distinguish. In this work, a method is introduced how the…
▽ More
Space charge effects can significantly degrade charge collection in organic photovoltaics (OPVs), especially in thick-film devices. The two main causes of space charge are do** and imbalanced transport. Although these are completely different phenomena, they lead to the same voltage dependence of the photocurrent, making them difficult to distinguish. In this work, a method is introduced how the build-up of space charge due to imbalanced transport can be monitored in a real operating organic solar cell. The method is based on the reconstruction of quantum efficiency spectra and requires only optical input parameters that are straightforward to measure. This makes it suitable for the screening of new OPV materials. Furthermore, numerical and analytical means are derived to predict the impact of imbalanced transport on the charge collection. It is shown that when charge recombination is sufficiently reduced, balanced transport is not a necessary condition for efficient thick-film OPVs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2020; v1 submitted 3 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Impact of a do**-induced space-charge region on the collection of photo-generated charge carriers in thin-film solar cells based on low-mobility semiconductors
Authors:
Oskar J. Sandberg,
Staffan Dahlström,
Mathias Nyman,
Sebastian Wilken,
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Ronald Österbacka
Abstract:
Unintentional do** of the active layer is a source for lowered device performance in organic solar cells. The effect of do** is to induce a space-charge region within the active layer, generally resulting in increased recombination losses. In this work, the impact of a do**-induced space-charge region on the current-voltage characteristics of low-mobility solar cell devices has been clarifie…
▽ More
Unintentional do** of the active layer is a source for lowered device performance in organic solar cells. The effect of do** is to induce a space-charge region within the active layer, generally resulting in increased recombination losses. In this work, the impact of a do**-induced space-charge region on the current-voltage characteristics of low-mobility solar cell devices has been clarified by means of analytical derivations and numerical device simulations. It is found that, in case of a doped active layer, the collection efficiency of photo-generated charge carriers is independent of the light intensity and exhibits a distinct voltage dependence, resulting in an apparent electric-field dependence of the photocurrent. Furthermore, an analytical expression describing the behavior of the photocurrent is derived. The validity of the analytical model is verified by numerical drift-diffusion simulations and demonstrated experimentally on solution-processed organic solar cells. Based on the theoretical results, conditions of how to overcome charge collection losses caused by do** are discussed. Furthermore, the presented analytical framework provides tools to distinguish between different mechanisms leading to voltage dependent photocurrents.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2019; v1 submitted 21 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Investigation of the Spatially Dependent Charge Collection Probability in CuInS$_2$/ZnO Colloidal Nanocrystal Solar Cells
Authors:
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Sebastian Wilken,
Jürgen Parisi,
Holger Borchert
Abstract:
Solar cells with a heterojunction between colloidal CuInS$_2$ and ZnO nanocrystals are an innovative concept in solution-processed photovoltaics, but the conversion efficiency cannot compete yet with devices employing lead chalcogenide quantum dots. Here, we present a detailed study on the charge collection in CuInS$_2$/ZnO solar cells. An inverted device architecture was utilized, in which the Zn…
▽ More
Solar cells with a heterojunction between colloidal CuInS$_2$ and ZnO nanocrystals are an innovative concept in solution-processed photovoltaics, but the conversion efficiency cannot compete yet with devices employing lead chalcogenide quantum dots. Here, we present a detailed study on the charge collection in CuInS$_2$/ZnO solar cells. An inverted device architecture was utilized, in which the ZnO played an additional role as optical spacer layer. Variations of the ZnO thickness were exploited to create different charge generation profiles within the light-harvesting CuInS$_2$ layer, which strongly affected both the external and internal quantum efficiency. By the reconstruction of these experimental findings with the help of a purely optical model, we were able to draw conclusions on the spatial dependency of the charge collection probability. We provide evidence that only carriers generated within a narrow zone of circa 40 nm near the CuInS$_2$/ZnO interface contribute to the external photocurrent. The remaining part of the absorber can be considered as "dead zone" for charge collection, which reasonably explains the limited device performance and indicates a direction for future research. From the methodical point of view, the optical modeling approach developed in the present work has the advantage that no electrical input parameters are required and is believed to be easily transferable to other material systems.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Effect of Imbalanced Charge Transport on the Interplay of Surface and Bulk Recombination in Organic Solar Cells
Authors:
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Sebastian Wilken,
Oskar J. Sandberg,
Ronald Österbacka,
Manuela Schiek
Abstract:
Surface recombination has a major impact on the open-circuit voltage ($V_\text{oc}$) of organic photovoltaics. Here, we study how this loss mechanism is influenced by imbalanced charge transport in the photoactive layer. As a model system, we use organic solar cells with a two orders of magnitude higher electron than hole mobility. We find that small variations in the work function of the anode ha…
▽ More
Surface recombination has a major impact on the open-circuit voltage ($V_\text{oc}$) of organic photovoltaics. Here, we study how this loss mechanism is influenced by imbalanced charge transport in the photoactive layer. As a model system, we use organic solar cells with a two orders of magnitude higher electron than hole mobility. We find that small variations in the work function of the anode have a strong effect on the light intensity dependence of $V_\text{oc}$. Transient measurements and drift-diffusion simulations reveal that this is due to a change in the surface recombination rather than the bulk recombination. We use our numerical model to generalize these findings and determine under which circumstances the effect of contacts is stronger or weaker compared to the idealized case of balanced charge transport. Finally, we derive analytical expressions for $V_\text{oc}$ in the case that a pile-up of space charge is present due to highly imbalanced mobilities.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Semitransparent Polymer-Based Solar Cells with Aluminum-Doped Zinc Oxide Electrodes
Authors:
Sebastian Wilken,
Verena Wilkens,
Dorothea Scheunemann,
Regina-Elisabeth Nowak,
Karsten von Maydell,
Jürgen Parisi,
Holger Borchert
Abstract:
With the usage of two transparent electrodes, organic solar cells are semitransparent and may be combined to parallel-connected multi-junction devices or used for innovative applications like power-generating windows. A challenging issue is the optimization of the electrodes, in order to combine high transparency with adequate electric properties. In the present work, we study the potential of spu…
▽ More
With the usage of two transparent electrodes, organic solar cells are semitransparent and may be combined to parallel-connected multi-junction devices or used for innovative applications like power-generating windows. A challenging issue is the optimization of the electrodes, in order to combine high transparency with adequate electric properties. In the present work, we study the potential of sputter-deposited aluminum-doped zinc oxide (AZO) as an alternative to the widely used but relatively expensive indium tin oxide (ITO) as cathode material in semitransparent polymer-fullerene solar cells. Concerning the anode, we utilized an insulator/metal/insulator structure based on ultra-thin Au films embedded between two evaporated MoO$_3$ layers, with the outer MoO$_3$ film (cap** layer) serving as a light coupling layer. The performance of the ITO-free semitransparent solar cells is systematically studied as dependent on the thickness of the cap** layer and the active layer, as well as the illumination direction. These variations are found to have strong impact on the obtained photocurrent. We performed optical simulations of the electric field distribution within the devices to analyze the origin of the current variations and provide deep insight in the device physics. With the conventional absorber materials studied herein, optimized ITO-free and semitransparent devices reached 2.0% power conversion efficiency and a maximum optical transmission of 60%, with the device concept being potentially transferable to other absorber materials.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
