-
On the investigation of properties of superfluid $^4$He turbulence using a hot-wire signal
Authors:
P. Diribarne,
M. Bon-Mardion,
A. Girard,
J. -P. Moro,
B. Rousset,
F. Chilla,
J. Salort,
A. Braslau,
F. Daviaud,
B. Dubrulle,
B. Gallet,
I. Moukharski,
E. -W. Saw,
C. Baudet,
M. Gibert,
P. -E. Roche,
E. Rusaouen,
A. Golov,
V. L'vov,
S. Nazarenko
Abstract:
We report hot-wire measurements performed in two very different, co- and counter-rotating flows, in normal and superfluid helium at 1.6 K, 2 K, and 2.3 K. As recently reported, the power spectrum of the hot-wire signal in superfluid flows exhibits a significant bump at high frequency (Diribarne et al. [1]). We confirm that the bump frequency does not depend significantly on the temperature and fur…
▽ More
We report hot-wire measurements performed in two very different, co- and counter-rotating flows, in normal and superfluid helium at 1.6 K, 2 K, and 2.3 K. As recently reported, the power spectrum of the hot-wire signal in superfluid flows exhibits a significant bump at high frequency (Diribarne et al. [1]). We confirm that the bump frequency does not depend significantly on the temperature and further extend the previous analysis of the velocity dependence of the bump, over more than one decade of velocity. The main result is that the bump frequency depends on the turbulence intensity of the flow, and that using the turbulent Reynolds number rather than the velocity as a control parameter collapses results from both co- and counter-rotating flows. The vortex shedding model previously proposed, in its current form, does not account for this observation. This suggests that the physical origin of the bump is related to the small scale turbulence properties of the flow. We finally propose some qualitative physical mechanism by which the smallest structures of the flow, at intervortex distance, could affect the heat flux of the hot-wire.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2021; v1 submitted 31 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Pair dispersion in inhomogeneous turbulent thermal convection
Authors:
Olivier Liot,
David-Martin-Calle,
Amélie Gay,
Julien Salort,
Francesca Chillà,
Mickaël Bourgoin
Abstract:
Due to large scale flow inhomogeneities and the effects of temperature, turbulence small-scale structure in thermal convection is still an active field of investigation, especially considering sophisticated Lagrangian statistics. Here we experimentally study Lagrangian pair dispersion (one of the canonical problems of Lagrangian turbulence) in a Rayleigh-Bénard convection cell. A sufficiently high…
▽ More
Due to large scale flow inhomogeneities and the effects of temperature, turbulence small-scale structure in thermal convection is still an active field of investigation, especially considering sophisticated Lagrangian statistics. Here we experimentally study Lagrangian pair dispersion (one of the canonical problems of Lagrangian turbulence) in a Rayleigh-Bénard convection cell. A sufficiently high temperature difference is imposed on a horizontal layer of fluid to observe a turbulent flow. We perform Lagrangian tracking of sub-millimetric particles on a large measurement volume including part of the Large Scale Circulation (LSC) revealing some large inhomogeneities. Our study brings to light several new insights regarding our understanding of turbulent thermal convection: (i) by decomposing particle Lagrangian dynamics into the LSC contribution and the turbulent fluctuations, we highlight the relative impact of both contributions on pair dispersion; (ii) using the same decomposition, we estimate the Eulerian second-order velocity structure functions from pair statistics and show that after removing the LSC contribution, the remaining statistics recover usual homogeneous and isotropic behaviours which are governed by a local energy dissipation rate to be distinguished from the global dissipation rate classically used to characterise turbulence in thermal convection; and (iii) we revisit the super-diffusive Richardson-Obukhov regime of particle dispersion and propose a refined estimate of the Richardson constant.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2019; v1 submitted 26 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Structure, dynamics and reconnection of vortices in a nonlocal model of superfluids
Authors:
Jason Reneuve,
Julien Salort,
Laurent Chevillard
Abstract:
We study the reconnection of vortices in a quantum fluid with a roton minimum, by numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii (GP) equations. A non-local interaction potential is introduced to mimic the experimental dispersion relation of superfluid $^4\mathrm{He}$. We begin by choosing a functional shape of the interaction potential that allows to reproduce in an approximative way the so-called roto…
▽ More
We study the reconnection of vortices in a quantum fluid with a roton minimum, by numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii (GP) equations. A non-local interaction potential is introduced to mimic the experimental dispersion relation of superfluid $^4\mathrm{He}$. We begin by choosing a functional shape of the interaction potential that allows to reproduce in an approximative way the so-called roton minimum observed in experiments, without leading to spurious local crystallization events. We then follow and track the phenomenon of reconnection starting from a set of two perpendicular vortices. A precise and quantitative study of various quantities characterizing the evolution of this phenomenon is proposed: this includes the evolution of statistics of several hydrodynamical quantities of interest, and the geometrical description of a observed helical wave packet that propagates along the vortex cores. Those geometrical properties are systematically compared to the predictions of the Local Induction Approximation (LIA), showing similarities and differences. The introduction of the roton minimum in the model does not change the macroscopic properties of the reconnection event but the microscopic structure of the vortices differs. Structures are generated at the roton scale and helical waves are evidenced along the vortices. However, contrary to what is expected in classical viscous or inviscid incompressible flows, the numerical simulations do not evidence the generation of structures at smaller or larger scales than the typical atomic size.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2018; v1 submitted 16 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Thermal boundary layers in turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection with rough surfaces
Authors:
Ronald du Puits,
Alice Loesch,
Julien Salort,
Francesca Chillà
Abstract:
We present highly resolved measurements of the near-wall temperature field in thermally driven convection at a rough surface. Our measurements have been undertaken in a very large experimental facility called the "Barrel of Ilmenau". They provide a unique insight into the local transport process at the interface between a hot solid surface and a surrounding fluid. In order to probe the near-wall t…
▽ More
We present highly resolved measurements of the near-wall temperature field in thermally driven convection at a rough surface. Our measurements have been undertaken in a very large experimental facility called the "Barrel of Ilmenau". They provide a unique insight into the local transport process at the interface between a hot solid surface and a surrounding fluid. In order to probe the near-wall temperature field, we used a tiny micro-thermistor of 130 $μ$m in diameter and 330 $μ$m in length with a response time $τ_{70}$ of less than 150 ms. This sensor is forty times smaller than the thickness of the boundary layer, and it permits a resolution better than the typical Kolmogorov micro-scales that appear in our experiment. We demonstrate that the heat flux enhancement generally observed at rough surfaces, basically results from an increase of the local heat transfer coefficient at the top of the roughness elements. We also shed light on the detailed mechanism of the transition in the scaling of the global heat transfer relation $Nu\sim Ra^γ$ that has been observed beyond a critical Ra number $Ra_c$. In turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection with rough surfaces, it already appears at $Ra_c\approx 10^{10}$ [Tisserand et al.{\em Phys. Fluids \/} 23, 015105(2011)] while, for smooth plates, it has been predicted at $Ra_c\approx 10^{14}$ [[Grossmann \& Lohse {\em Phys. Rev. Lett.\/} {\bf 86}, 3316(2001)]. We found this transition at rough surfaces to be attributed to an earlier laminar-turbulent transition of the boundary layer at the top of the roughness elements as well as to a modification of the temperature field in between the obstacles.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2018; v1 submitted 17 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Intermittency of quantum turbulence with superfluid fractions from 0% to 96%
Authors:
Eléonore Rusaouen,
Benoît Chabaud,
Julien Salort,
Philippe-E Roche
Abstract:
The intermittency of turbulent superfluid helium is explored systematically in a steady wake flow from 1.28 K up to T>2.18K using a local anemometer. This temperature range spans relative densities of superfluid from 96% down to 0%, allowing to test numerical predictions of enhancement or depletion of intermittency at intermediate superfluid fractions. Using the so-called extended self-similarity…
▽ More
The intermittency of turbulent superfluid helium is explored systematically in a steady wake flow from 1.28 K up to T>2.18K using a local anemometer. This temperature range spans relative densities of superfluid from 96% down to 0%, allowing to test numerical predictions of enhancement or depletion of intermittency at intermediate superfluid fractions. Using the so-called extended self-similarity method, scaling exponents of structure functions have been calculated. No evidence of temperature dependence is found on these scaling exponents in the upper part of the inertial cascade, where turbulence is well developed and fully resolved by the probe. This result supports the picture of a profound analogy between classical and quantum turbulence in their inertial range, including the violation of self-similarities associated with inertial-range intermittency.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Velocity fluctuations and boundary layer structure in a rough Rayleigh-B{é}nard cell filled with water
Authors:
Olivier Liot,
Quentin Ehlinger,
Elonore Rusaouën,
Thibaut Coudarchet,
Julien Salort,
Francesca Chillà
Abstract:
We report Particle Image Velocimetry of the Large Scale Circulation and the viscous boundary layer in turbulent thermal convection. We use two parallelepipedic Rayleigh-B{é}nard cells with a top smooth plate. The first one has a rough bottom plate and the second one has a smooth one so we compare the rough-smooth and the smooth-smooth configurations. The dimensions of the cell allow to consider a…
▽ More
We report Particle Image Velocimetry of the Large Scale Circulation and the viscous boundary layer in turbulent thermal convection. We use two parallelepipedic Rayleigh-B{é}nard cells with a top smooth plate. The first one has a rough bottom plate and the second one has a smooth one so we compare the rough-smooth and the smooth-smooth configurations. The dimensions of the cell allow to consider a bi-dimensional mean flow. Lots of previous heat flux measurements have shown a Nusselt--Rayleigh regime transition corresponding to an increase of the heat flux in presence of roughness which is higher than the surface increase. Our velocity measurements show that if the mean velocity field is not clearly affected by the roughness, the velocity fluctuations rise dramatically. It is accompanied by a change of the longitudinal velocity structure functions scaling. Moreover, we show that the boundary layer becomes turbulent close to roughness, as it was observed recently in the air [Liot et al., JFM, vol. 786, pp. 275-293]. Finally we discuss the link between the change of the boundary layer structure and the ones observed on the Large Scale Circulation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2018; v1 submitted 3 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Simultaneous temperature and velocity Lagrangian measurements in turbulent thermal convection
Authors:
O. Liot,
F. Seychelles,
F. Zonta,
S. Chibbaro,
T. Coudarchet,
Y. Gasteuil,
J. -F. Pinton,
J. Salort,
F. Chillà
Abstract:
We report joint Lagrangian velocity and temperature measurements in turbulent thermal convection. Measurements are performed using an improved version (extended autonomy) of the neutrally-buoyant instrumented particle that was used by to performed experiments in a parallelepipedic Rayleigh-Benard cell. The temperature signal is obtained from a RFtransmitter. Simultaneously, we determine particle's…
▽ More
We report joint Lagrangian velocity and temperature measurements in turbulent thermal convection. Measurements are performed using an improved version (extended autonomy) of the neutrally-buoyant instrumented particle that was used by to performed experiments in a parallelepipedic Rayleigh-Benard cell. The temperature signal is obtained from a RFtransmitter. Simultaneously, we determine particle's position and velocity with one camera, which grants access to the Lagrangian heat flux. Due to the extended autonomy of the present particle, we obtain well converged temperature and velocity statistics, as well as pseudo-eulerian maps of velocity and heat flux. Present experimental results have also been compared with the results obtained by a corresponding campaign of Direct Numerical Simulations and Lagrangian Tracking of massless tracers. The comparison between experimental and numerical results show the accuracy and reliability of our experimental measurements. Finally, the analysis of lagrangian velocity and temperature frequency spectra is shown and discussed. In particular, we observe that temperature spectra exhibit an anomalous f^2.5 frequency scaling, likely representing the ubiquitous passive and active scalar behavior of temperature
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Probing quantum and classical turbulence analogy through global bifurcations in a von Kármán liquid Helium experiment
Authors:
B Saint-Michel,
E Herbert,
J Salort,
C Baudet,
M Bon Mardion,
P Bonnay,
M Bourgoin,
B Castaing,
L Chevillard,
F Daviaud,
P Diribarne,
B Dubrulle,
Y Gagne,
M Gibert,
A Girard,
B Hébral,
Th Lehner,
B Rousset
Abstract:
We report measurements of the dissipation in the Superfluid Helium high REynold number von Karman flow (SHREK) experiment for different forcing conditions, through a regime of global hysteretic bifurcation. Our macroscopical measurements indicate no noticeable difference between the classical fluid and the superfluid regimes, thereby providing evidence of the same dissipative anomaly and response…
▽ More
We report measurements of the dissipation in the Superfluid Helium high REynold number von Karman flow (SHREK) experiment for different forcing conditions, through a regime of global hysteretic bifurcation. Our macroscopical measurements indicate no noticeable difference between the classical fluid and the superfluid regimes, thereby providing evidence of the same dissipative anomaly and response to asymmetry in fluid and superfluid regime. %In the latter case, A detailed study of the variations of the hysteretic cycle with Reynolds number supports the idea that (i) the stability of the bifurcated states of classical turbulence in this closed flow is partly governed by the dissipative scales and (ii) the normal and the superfluid component at these temperatures (1.6K) are locked down to the dissipative length scale.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2014; v1 submitted 28 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Energy cascade and the four-fifths law in superfluid turbulence
Authors:
Julien Salort,
Benoît Chabaud,
Emmanuel Lévêque,
Philippe-E. Roche
Abstract:
The 4/5-law of turbulence, which characterizes the energy cascade from large to small-sized eddies at high Reynolds numbers in classical fluids, is verified experimentally in a superfluid 4He wind tunnel, operated down to 1.56 K and up to R_lambda ~ 1640. The result is corroborated by high-resolution simulations of Landau-Tisza's two-fluid model down to 1.15 K, corresponding to a residual normal f…
▽ More
The 4/5-law of turbulence, which characterizes the energy cascade from large to small-sized eddies at high Reynolds numbers in classical fluids, is verified experimentally in a superfluid 4He wind tunnel, operated down to 1.56 K and up to R_lambda ~ 1640. The result is corroborated by high-resolution simulations of Landau-Tisza's two-fluid model down to 1.15 K, corresponding to a residual normal fluid concentration below 3 % but with a lower Reynolds number of order R_lambda ~ 100. Although the Kármán-Howarth equation (including a viscous term) is not valid \emph{a priori} in a superfluid, it is found that it provides an empirical description of the deviation from the ideal 4/5-law at small scales and allows us to identify an effective viscosity for the superfluid, whose value matches the kinematic viscosity of the normal fluid regardless of its concentration.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
On the triggering of the Ultimate Regime of convection
Authors:
Philippe-E. Roche,
Frédéric Gauthier,
Robert Kaiser,
Julien Salort
Abstract:
Rayleigh-Bénard cells are one of the simplest systems to explore the laws of natural convection in the highly turbulent limit. However, at very high Rayleigh numbers (Ra > 1E12) and for Prandtl numbers of order one, experiments fall into two categories: some evidence a steep enhancement of the heat transfer while others do not. The origin of this apparent disagreement is presently unexplained. Thi…
▽ More
Rayleigh-Bénard cells are one of the simplest systems to explore the laws of natural convection in the highly turbulent limit. However, at very high Rayleigh numbers (Ra > 1E12) and for Prandtl numbers of order one, experiments fall into two categories: some evidence a steep enhancement of the heat transfer while others do not. The origin of this apparent disagreement is presently unexplained. This puzzling situation motivated a systematic study of the triggering of the regime with an enhanced heat transfer, originally named the "Ultimate Regime" of convection. High accuracy heat transfer measurements have been conducted in convection cells with various aspect ratios and different specificities, such as altered boundary conditions or obstacles inserted in the flow. The two control parameters, the Rayleigh and Prandtl numbers have been varied independently to disentangle their relative influence. Among other results, it is found that i) most experiments reaching very high $Ra$ are not in disagreement if small differences in Prandtl numbers are taken into account, ii) the transition is not directly triggered by the large scale circulation present in the cell, iii) the sidewall of the cell have a significant influence on the transition. The characteristics of this Ultimate regime are summarized and compared with R. Kraichnan prediction for the asymptotic regime of convection.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Turbulent velocity spectra in superfluid flows
Authors:
J. Salort,
C. Baudet,
B. Castaing,
B. Chabaud,
F. Daviaud,
T. Didelot,
P. Diribarne,
B. Dubrulle,
Y. Gagne,
F. Gauthier,
A. Girard,
B. Hébral,
B. Rousset,
P. Thibault,
P. -E. Roche
Abstract:
We present velocity spectra measured in three cryogenic liquid 4He steady flows: grid and wake flows in a pressurized wind tunnel capable of achieving mean velocities up to 5 m/s at temperatures above and below the superfluid transition, down to 1.7 K, and a "chunk" turbulence flow at 1.55 K, capable of sustaining mean superfluid velocities up to 1.3 m/s. Depending on the flows, the stagnation pre…
▽ More
We present velocity spectra measured in three cryogenic liquid 4He steady flows: grid and wake flows in a pressurized wind tunnel capable of achieving mean velocities up to 5 m/s at temperatures above and below the superfluid transition, down to 1.7 K, and a "chunk" turbulence flow at 1.55 K, capable of sustaining mean superfluid velocities up to 1.3 m/s. Depending on the flows, the stagnation pressure probes used for anemometry are resolving from one to two decades of the inertial regime of the turbulent cascade. We do not find any evidence that the second order statistics of turbulence below the superfluid transition differ from the ones of classical turbulence, above the transition.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Mesoscale Equipartition of kinetic energy in Quantum Turbulence
Authors:
Julien Salort,
Philippe-E. Roche,
Emmanuel Lévêque
Abstract:
The turbulence of superfluid helium is investigated numerically at finite temperature. Direct numerical simulations are performed with a "truncated HVBK" model, which combines the continuous description of the Hall-Vinen-Bekeravich-Khalatnikov equations with the additional constraint that this continuous description cannot extend beyond a quantum length scale associated with the mean spacing betwe…
▽ More
The turbulence of superfluid helium is investigated numerically at finite temperature. Direct numerical simulations are performed with a "truncated HVBK" model, which combines the continuous description of the Hall-Vinen-Bekeravich-Khalatnikov equations with the additional constraint that this continuous description cannot extend beyond a quantum length scale associated with the mean spacing between individual superfluid vortices. A good agreement is found with experimental measurements of the vortex density. Besides, by varying the turbulence intensity only, it is observed that the inter-vortex spacing varies with the Reynolds number as $Re^{-3/4}$, like the viscous length scale in classical turbulence. In the high temperature limit, Kolmogorov's inertial cascade is recovered, as expected from previous numerical and experimental studies. As the temperature decreases, the inertial cascade remains present at large scales while, at small scales, the system evolves towards a statistical equipartition of kinetic energy among spectral modes, with a characteristic $k^2$ velocity spectrum. The accumulation of superfluid excitations on a range of mesoscales enables the superfluid to keep dissipating kinetic energy through mutual friction with the residual normal fluid, although the later becomes rare at low temperature. It is found that most of the superfluid vorticity can concentrate on these mesoscales at low temperature, while it is concentrated in the inertial range at higher temperature. This observation should have consequences on the interpretation of decaying turbulence experiments, which are often based on vortex line density measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Temperature fluctuations in the Ultimate Regime of Convection
Authors:
Frédéric Gauthier,
Julien Salort,
Olivier Bourgeois,
Jean-Luc Garden,
Ronald Du Puits,
Andre Thess,
Philippe-Emmanuel P. -E. Roche
Abstract:
A new regime of turbulent convection has been reported nearly one decade ago, based on global heat transfer measurements at very high Rayleigh numbers. We examine the signature of this "Ultimate Regime" from within the flow itself. A systematic study of probe-size corrections shows that the earlier temperature measurements within the flow were altered by an excessive size of thermometer, but not…
▽ More
A new regime of turbulent convection has been reported nearly one decade ago, based on global heat transfer measurements at very high Rayleigh numbers. We examine the signature of this "Ultimate Regime" from within the flow itself. A systematic study of probe-size corrections shows that the earlier temperature measurements within the flow were altered by an excessive size of thermometer, but not according to a theoretical model proposed in the literature. Using a probe one order of magnitude smaller than the one used previously, we find evidence that the transition to the Ultimate Regime is indeed accompanied with a clear change in the statistics of temperature fluctuations in the flow.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
