-
Position Paper: Technical Research and Talent is Needed for Effective AI Governance
Authors:
Anka Reuel,
Lisa Soder,
Ben Bucknall,
Trond Arne Undheim
Abstract:
In light of recent advancements in AI capabilities and the increasingly widespread integration of AI systems into society, governments worldwide are actively seeking to mitigate the potential harms and risks associated with these technologies through regulation and other governance tools. However, there exist significant gaps between governance aspirations and the current state of the technical to…
▽ More
In light of recent advancements in AI capabilities and the increasingly widespread integration of AI systems into society, governments worldwide are actively seeking to mitigate the potential harms and risks associated with these technologies through regulation and other governance tools. However, there exist significant gaps between governance aspirations and the current state of the technical tooling necessary for their realisation. In this position paper, we survey policy documents published by public-sector institutions in the EU, US, and China to highlight specific areas of disconnect between the technical requirements necessary for enacting proposed policy actions, and the current technical state of the art. Our analysis motivates a call for tighter integration of the AI/ML research community within AI governance in order to i) catalyse technical research aimed at bridging the gap between current and supposed technical underpinnings of regulatory action, as well as ii) increase the level of technical expertise within governing institutions so as to inform and guide effective governance of AI.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Towards Publicly Accountable Frontier LLMs: Building an External Scrutiny Ecosystem under the ASPIRE Framework
Authors:
Markus Anderljung,
Everett Thornton Smith,
Joe O'Brien,
Lisa Soder,
Benjamin Bucknall,
Emma Bluemke,
Jonas Schuett,
Robert Trager,
Lacey Strahm,
Rumman Chowdhury
Abstract:
With the increasing integration of frontier large language models (LLMs) into society and the economy, decisions related to their training, deployment, and use have far-reaching implications. These decisions should not be left solely in the hands of frontier LLM developers. LLM users, civil society and policymakers need trustworthy sources of information to steer such decisions for the better. Inv…
▽ More
With the increasing integration of frontier large language models (LLMs) into society and the economy, decisions related to their training, deployment, and use have far-reaching implications. These decisions should not be left solely in the hands of frontier LLM developers. LLM users, civil society and policymakers need trustworthy sources of information to steer such decisions for the better. Involving outside actors in the evaluation of these systems - what we term 'external scrutiny' - via red-teaming, auditing, and external researcher access, offers a solution. Though there are encouraging signs of increasing external scrutiny of frontier LLMs, its success is not assured. In this paper, we survey six requirements for effective external scrutiny of frontier AI systems and organize them under the ASPIRE framework: Access, Searching attitude, Proportionality to the risks, Independence, Resources, and Expertise. We then illustrate how external scrutiny might function throughout the AI lifecycle and offer recommendations to policymakers.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Probabilistic Multi-product Trading in Sequential Intraday and Frequency-Regulation Markets
Authors:
Saeed Nordin,
Abolfazl Khodadadi,
Priyanka Shinde,
Evelin Blom,
Mohammad Reza Hesamzadeh,
Lennart Söder
Abstract:
With the increasing integration of power plants into the frequency-regulation markets, the importance of optimal trading has grown substantially. This paper conducts an in-depth analysis of their optimal trading behavior in sequential day-ahead, intraday, and frequency-regulation markets. We introduce a probabilistic multi-product optimization model, derived through a series of transformation tech…
▽ More
With the increasing integration of power plants into the frequency-regulation markets, the importance of optimal trading has grown substantially. This paper conducts an in-depth analysis of their optimal trading behavior in sequential day-ahead, intraday, and frequency-regulation markets. We introduce a probabilistic multi-product optimization model, derived through a series of transformation techniques. Additionally, we present two reformulations that re-frame the problem as a mixed-integer linear programming problem with uncertain parameters. Various aspects of the model are thoroughly examined to observe the optimal multi-product trading behavior of hydro power plant assets, along with numerous case studies. Leveraging historical data from Nordic electricity markets, we construct realistic scenarios for the uncertain parameters. Furthermore, we then proposed an algorithm based on the No-U-Turn sampler to provide probability distribution functions of cleared prices in frequency-regulation and day-ahead markets. These distribution functions offer valuable statistical insights into temporal price risks for informed multi-product optimal-trading decisions.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Estimating the Future Need of Balancing Power Based on Long-Term Power System Market Simulations
Authors:
Henrik Nordström,
Lennart Söder,
Robert Eriksson
Abstract:
With increasing penetration of variable renewable energy sources (vRES) and a higher rate of electrification in the society, there will be future challenges in maintaining a continuous balance between electricity supply and demand. To investigate the possibility of different technologies to provide balancing services, to dimension future balancing services and design technical requirements for fut…
▽ More
With increasing penetration of variable renewable energy sources (vRES) and a higher rate of electrification in the society, there will be future challenges in maintaining a continuous balance between electricity supply and demand. To investigate the possibility of different technologies to provide balancing services, to dimension future balancing services and design technical requirements for future balancing services, the future need of balancing power must first be known. Future power systems are often analysed by performing simulations capturing the energy produced, consumed or transmitted for different power system components with resolution of one trading period (TP), here called TP energy simulations. However, these simulations do not fully capture the continuous intra-TP power balance that must be kept at every time instance. In this paper, we propose a model to perform high-resolution intra-TP simulations to estimate the need of balancing power based on TP energy simulations. The model is applied to the Swedish system operator (SO) Svenska kraftnät's TP energy simulations of a scenario with high vRES penetration and a highly electrified society in year 2045. The results show that a considerable need of balancing power will occur frequently, where faster ram** of components tend to increase the need of balancing power while assuming that the transmission reliability margin (TRM) is used to net imbalances clearly decreases the need of balancing power.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
A bottom-up quantification of flexibility potential from the thermal energy storage in electric space heating
Authors:
Lars Herre,
Behrouz Nourozi,
Mohammad Reza Hesamzadeh,
Qian Wang,
Lennart Söder
Abstract:
Non-generating resources such as thermostatically controlled loads (TCLs) can arbitrage energy prices and provide balancing reserves when aggregated due to their thermal energy storage capacity. Based on a performed survey of Swedish single- and two-family dwellings with electric heating, this paper quantifies the potential of TCLs to provide reserves to the power system in Sweden. To this end, dw…
▽ More
Non-generating resources such as thermostatically controlled loads (TCLs) can arbitrage energy prices and provide balancing reserves when aggregated due to their thermal energy storage capacity. Based on a performed survey of Swedish single- and two-family dwellings with electric heating, this paper quantifies the potential of TCLs to provide reserves to the power system in Sweden. To this end, dwellings with heat pumps and direct electric heaters are modeled as thermal energy storage equivalents that can be included in a linear two-stage problem formulation. We approach the operational flexibility of the TCLs by modeling a risk-averse aggregator that controls decentralized TCLs and aims to maximize its own profit. The results show a potential of 2 GW/0.1Hz averaged over a year, and up to 6.4 GW/0.1Hz peak capacity. Based on a sensitivity analysis we derive policy implications regarding market timing and activation signal.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
