-
A sub-Saturn Mass-Radius Desert for Planets with Equilibrium Temperature Less than 600 K
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
The sample of exoplanets from the NASA Exoplanet Archive with equilibrium temperature less than 600 K and with low uncertainty for both mass and radius measurements is found to have a desert in the mass-radius distribution consistent with predictions from the core-accretion scenario. This sub-Saturn mass-radius desert is almost completely barren of any planets with both a mass greater than 20 Eart…
▽ More
The sample of exoplanets from the NASA Exoplanet Archive with equilibrium temperature less than 600 K and with low uncertainty for both mass and radius measurements is found to have a desert in the mass-radius distribution consistent with predictions from the core-accretion scenario. This sub-Saturn mass-radius desert is almost completely barren of any planets with both a mass greater than 20 Earth masses and a radius in the range 4.0 to 7.5 Earth radii for the sample of planets with equilibrium temperature less than 600 K. In contrast, the sample of planets with equilibrium temperature greater than 630 K includes a large fraction of planets with mass-radius values that fall into the less than 600 K sub-Saturn mass-radius desert. The difference between the two populations may result from differences in migration history in the core-accretion scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2023; v1 submitted 11 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
A Catalog of Exoplanets with Equilibrium Temperature less than 600 K
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
The NASA Exoplanet Archive was searched for planets with an equilibrium temperature below 600 K, mass uncertainty less than 27 percent, and radius uncertainty less than 8 percent. This search produced 93 planets with mass from 0.3 to 1680 ME; and 101 planets if the Solar System planets are included. The characteristics of the sample in this catalog are: (1) 94 percent of the Terrestrial planets ha…
▽ More
The NASA Exoplanet Archive was searched for planets with an equilibrium temperature below 600 K, mass uncertainty less than 27 percent, and radius uncertainty less than 8 percent. This search produced 93 planets with mass from 0.3 to 1680 ME; and 101 planets if the Solar System planets are included. The characteristics of the sample in this catalog are: (1) 94 percent of the Terrestrial planets have mass less than 2.9 ME and radius less than 1.4 RE, (3) The sample has a small drop in population consistent with the previously identified radius gap from 1.5 to 2.0 RE, (4) Planets in the radius range 1.50 to 2.25 RE are consistent with either a gas-rich Terrestrial composition or a rock-ice Terrestrial composition with a supercritical hydrosphere and water mass fraction less than 20 percent, (5) A super-Neptune radius desert is observed for the radius range 4.5 to 7.5 RE, (6) Saturn composition planets have masses from 15 to 170 ME and radii from 7.9 to 10.1 RE, (7) A nearly barren sub-Saturn mass-radius desert is found in the sample as indicated by a lack of planets with mass exceeding 20 ME and radii in the range 4.0 to 7.5 RE, (8) Most Jupiter composition planets have radii between 10.9 and 12.4 RE and mass exceeding 200 ME, (9) With few exceptions, planet radius can be used as a proxy for planet composition classification into Terrestrial, gas-rich Terrestrial or supercritical hydrosphere Terrestrial, Rock-Ice Giant, and Gas Giant composition classes for this sample of Teq less than 600 K planets. The characteristics of this sample are consistent with several predictions of the core accretion model including the predicted values for the critical core mass for gas accretion and runaway accretion, the pebble isolation mass, and the Saturn mass desert.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
On the Need for a Classification System for Consistent Characterization of the Composition of Planetary Bodies
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
A classification system is presented for characterizing the composition of planetary bodies. From mass-radius and mass-density relationships, planets may be broadly grouped into five composition classes identified as: Gas Giant, Rock-Ice Giant, gas-rich Terrestrial, Rock Terrestrial, and Rock-Ice Terrestrial based upon the mass fractions of H-He gas, rock, and ice. For each of these broad composit…
▽ More
A classification system is presented for characterizing the composition of planetary bodies. From mass-radius and mass-density relationships, planets may be broadly grouped into five composition classes identified as: Gas Giant, Rock-Ice Giant, gas-rich Terrestrial, Rock Terrestrial, and Rock-Ice Terrestrial based upon the mass fractions of H-He gas, rock, and ice. For each of these broad composition classes, specific bulk composition classes are defined and characterized with Solar System analog names. The classification system allows for both general and detailed characterization of exoplanets based upon planetary mass-radius-composition models and provides rationale for distinguishing gas-rich super-Earths from mini-Neptunes.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2022; v1 submitted 6 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
The Ks-band Tully-Fisher Relation - A Determination of the Hubble Parameter from 218 ScI Galaxies and 16 Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
The value of the Hubble Parameter (H0) is determined using the morphologically type dependent Ks-band Tully-Fisher Relation (K-TFR). The slope and zero point are determined using 36 calibrator galaxies with ScI morphology. Calibration distances are adopted from direct Cepheid distances, and group or companion distances derived with the Surface Brightness Fluctuation Method or Type Ia Supernova.…
▽ More
The value of the Hubble Parameter (H0) is determined using the morphologically type dependent Ks-band Tully-Fisher Relation (K-TFR). The slope and zero point are determined using 36 calibrator galaxies with ScI morphology. Calibration distances are adopted from direct Cepheid distances, and group or companion distances derived with the Surface Brightness Fluctuation Method or Type Ia Supernova. Distances are determined to 16 galaxy clusters and 218 ScI galaxies with minimum distances of 40.0 Mpc. From the 16 galaxy clusters a weighted mean Hubble Parameter of H0=84.2 +/-6 km s-1 Mpc-1 is found. From the 218 ScI galaxies a Hubble Parameter of H0=83.4 +/-8 km s-1 Mpc-1 is found. When the zero point of the K-TFR is corrected to account for recent results that find a Large Magellanic Cloud distance modulus of 18.39 +/-0.05 a Hubble Parameter of 88.0 +/-6 km s-1 Mpc-1 is found. A comparison with the results of the Hubble Key Project (Freedman et al 2001) is made and discrepancies between the K-TFR distances and the HKP I-TFR distances are discussed. Implications for Lamda-CDM cosmology are considered with H0=84 km s-1 Mpc-1. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2009; v1 submitted 6 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
A Catalogue of M51 type Galaxy Associations
Authors:
Ari Jokimaki,
Harley "Skip" Orr,
David G. Russell
Abstract:
A catalog of 232 apparently interacting galaxy pairs of the M51 class is presented. Catalog members were identified from visual inspection of mult-band images in the IRSA archive. The major findings in the compilation of this catalog are (1) A surprisingly low number of the main galaxies in M51 systems are early type spirals and barred spirals. (2) Over 70% of the main galaxies in M51 systems ar…
▽ More
A catalog of 232 apparently interacting galaxy pairs of the M51 class is presented. Catalog members were identified from visual inspection of mult-band images in the IRSA archive. The major findings in the compilation of this catalog are (1) A surprisingly low number of the main galaxies in M51 systems are early type spirals and barred spirals. (2) Over 70% of the main galaxies in M51 systems are 2-armed spirals. (3) Some systems that were classified as M51 types in previous studies are not M51 types as defined in this catalog. There were a number of systems previously classified as M51 systems for which the companion is identified as an HII region within the main galaxy or a foreground star within the Milky Way. (4) It was found that only 18% of the M51 type companions have redshift measurements in the literature. There is a significant need for spectroscopic study of the companions in order to improve the value of the catalog as a sample for studying the effects of M51 type interaction on galaxy dynamics, morphology, and star formation. Further spectroscopy will also help constrain the statistics of possible chance projections between foreground and background galaxies in this catalog. The catalog also contains over 430 additional systems which are classified as "possible M51" systems. The reasons for classifying certain systems as possible M51 systems are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
-
Further Evidence for Intrinsic Redshifts in Normal Spiral Galaxies
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
Evidence from galaxy absolute magnitudes, linear diameters, and HyperLeda images is presented which strongly supports the interpretation that some normal spiral galaxies can contain large non-cosmological (intrinsic) redshifts in excess of 5000 km s-1.
Evidence from galaxy absolute magnitudes, linear diameters, and HyperLeda images is presented which strongly supports the interpretation that some normal spiral galaxies can contain large non-cosmological (intrinsic) redshifts in excess of 5000 km s-1.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Intrinsic Redshifts and the Tully-Fisher Distance Scale
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
The Tully-Fisher relationship (TFR) has been shown to have a relatively small observed scatter of ~ +/-0.35 mag implying an intrinsic scatter < +/-0.30 mag. However, when the TFR is calibrated from distances derived from the Hubble relation for field galaxies scatter is consistently found to be +/-0.64 to +/-0.84 mag. This significantly larger scatter requires that intrinsic TFR scatter is actua…
▽ More
The Tully-Fisher relationship (TFR) has been shown to have a relatively small observed scatter of ~ +/-0.35 mag implying an intrinsic scatter < +/-0.30 mag. However, when the TFR is calibrated from distances derived from the Hubble relation for field galaxies scatter is consistently found to be +/-0.64 to +/-0.84 mag. This significantly larger scatter requires that intrinsic TFR scatter is actually much larger than +/-0.30 mag, that field galaxies have an intrinsic TFR scatter much larger than cluster spirals, or that field galaxies have a velocity dispersion relative to the Hubble flow in excess of 1000 km s-1. Each of these potential explanations faces difficulties contradicted by available data and the results of previous studies. An alternative explanation is that the measured redshifts of galaxies are composed of a cosmological redshift component predicted from the value of the Hubble Constant and a superimposed intrinsic redshift component previously identified in other studies. This intrinsic redshift component may exceed 5000 km s-1 in individual galaxies. In this alternative scenario a possible value for the Hubble Constant is 55-60 km s-1 Mpc-1.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Evidence for Intrinsic Redshifts in Normal Spiral Galaxies
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
The Tully-Fisher Relationship (TFR) is utilized to identify anomalous redshifts in normal spiral galaxies. Three redshift anomalies are identified in this analysis: (1) Several clusters of galaxies are examined in which late type spirals have significant excess redshifts relative to early type spirals in the same clusters, (2) Galaxies of morphology similar to ScI galaxies are found to have a sy…
▽ More
The Tully-Fisher Relationship (TFR) is utilized to identify anomalous redshifts in normal spiral galaxies. Three redshift anomalies are identified in this analysis: (1) Several clusters of galaxies are examined in which late type spirals have significant excess redshifts relative to early type spirals in the same clusters, (2) Galaxies of morphology similar to ScI galaxies are found to have a systematic excess redshift relative to the redshifts expected if the Hubble Constant is 72 km s-1 Mpc-1, (3) individual galaxies, pairs, and groups are identified which strongly deviate from the predictions of a smooth Hubble flow. These redshift deviations are significantly larger than can be explained by peculiar motions and TFR errors. It is concluded that the redshift anomalies identified in this analysis are consistent with previous claims for large non-cosmological (intrinsic) redshifts.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2004; v1 submitted 19 August, 2004;
originally announced August 2004.
-
Discrete Components in the Radial Velocities of ScI Galaxies
Authors:
M. B. Bell,
S. P. Comeau,
D. G. Russell
Abstract:
We examine the V_{CMB} velocities and Tully-Fisher distances of 83 ScI galaxies and find that their velocities contain the same discrete velocity components identified previously by Tifft. After removing the discrete velocity components, the scatter remaining on the Hubble plot is in good agreement with the Tully-Fisher distance uncertainties. Although there is, as yet, no physical explanation f…
▽ More
We examine the V_{CMB} velocities and Tully-Fisher distances of 83 ScI galaxies and find that their velocities contain the same discrete velocity components identified previously by Tifft. After removing the discrete velocity components, the scatter remaining on the Hubble plot is in good agreement with the Tully-Fisher distance uncertainties. Although there is, as yet, no physical explanation for these discrete components, the fact that they appear to be identical to those found previously by Tifft suggests that their reality needs to be taken seriously.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
Morphological Type Dependence in the Tully-Fisher Relationship
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
The Tully-Fisher relationship is subject to morphological type dependence such that galaxies of morphology similar to ScI galaxies and Seyfert galaxies are more luminous at a given rotational velocity than galaxies of other morphological classification. This effect is most prevalent in the B-band. It is shown that the type effect is not simply an artifact of the calibrator sample, but is also pr…
▽ More
The Tully-Fisher relationship is subject to morphological type dependence such that galaxies of morphology similar to ScI galaxies and Seyfert galaxies are more luminous at a given rotational velocity than galaxies of other morphological classification. This effect is most prevalent in the B-band. It is shown that the type effect is not simply an artifact of the calibrator sample, but is also present in cluster samples. The type effect is corrected by creating type dependent Tully-Fisher relations for ScI group galaxies and Sb/ScIII group galaxies. It is shown that with single calibrations, the distances to ScI group galaxies are systematically underestimated while the distances to Sb/ScIII group galaxies are systematically overestimated. Tully-Fisher slope and scatter is also considered in the context of Type Dependent Tully-Fisher relations. It is concluded that the use of type dependent Tully-Fisher relations provide significant improvement in the distances to individual galaxies and refined distances to clusters of galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2004;
originally announced February 2004.
-
Discrete Components in the Radial Velocities of 83 ScI Galaxies: Examining the Accuracy of Tully-Fisher Distances
Authors:
M. B. Bell,
S. P. Comeau,
D. G. Russell
Abstract:
Our previous analyses of the redshifts and distances of galaxies included 55 spiral galaxies and 36 Type Ia Supernovae galaxies in three separate groups. All groups showed evidence that their radial velocities contain the same discrete velocity components that are predicted from the early work of Tifft. Here we examine another new source sample containing 83 ScI galaxies. When B-band distances a…
▽ More
Our previous analyses of the redshifts and distances of galaxies included 55 spiral galaxies and 36 Type Ia Supernovae galaxies in three separate groups. All groups showed evidence that their radial velocities contain the same discrete velocity components that are predicted from the early work of Tifft. Here we examine another new source sample containing 83 ScI galaxies. When B-band distances are used, we find clear evidence that the discrete velocities defined by Tifft's most common velocity period are present in the radial velocities of these galaxies. Assuming this is true, we are then able to use the visibility, or ease of detection, of the discrete components as an indication of the distance accuracy of the galaxies, comparing B- and I-band distances, galaxy inclination ranges, and galaxy rotation velocity ranges. We find (a), that, contrary to expectation, B-band distances for these sources are considerably more accurate than I-band, (b), that the distance accuracy varies with galaxy inclination, as expected, with the most consistent distances obtained for inclinations between 48 and 65 degrees, and (c), that distances are probably more accurate for small rotation velocities. With these results for the 83 ScI galaxies, discrete velocity components have now been detected in all 174 galaxies examined.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2003;
originally announced December 2003.
-
Intrinsic Redshifts in Normal Spiral Galaxies
Authors:
David G. Russell
Abstract:
The Tully-Fisher (TF) relation calibrated in both the B-band and the I-band indicates that (1) the redshift distribution of Virgo Cluster spirals has a morphological dependence that is inconsistent with a peculiar velocity interpretation. (2) Galaxies of morphology similar to ScI galaxies have a systematic excess redshift component relative to the redshift expected from a Hubble Constant of 72 k…
▽ More
The Tully-Fisher (TF) relation calibrated in both the B-band and the I-band indicates that (1) the redshift distribution of Virgo Cluster spirals has a morphological dependence that is inconsistent with a peculiar velocity interpretation. (2) Galaxies of morphology similar to ScI galaxies have a systematic excess redshift component relative to the redshift expected from a Hubble Constant of 72 km s-1 Mpc-1. (3) Pairs and groups of galaxies exist for which the TF relation provides excellent agreement among individual members, but for which the group redshift deviates strongly from the predictions of the Hubble Relation. It is again found that morphology plays a role as these galaxies are all of Hubble types Sbc and Sc. The overall results of this study indicate that normal Sbc and Sc galaxies have a systematic excess redshift component relative to the predictions of the standard Hubble relation assuming a Hubble Constant of 72 km s-1 Mpc-1. The excess redshifts identified in this analysis are consistent with the expectations of previous claims for non-cosmological (intrinsic) redshifts.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
