-
Electrodynamics of highly spin-polarized tunnel Josephson junctions
Authors:
H. G. Ahmad,
R. Caruso,
A. Pal,
G. Rotoli,
G. P. Pepe,
M. G. Blamire,
F. Tafuri,
D. Massarotti
Abstract:
The continuous development of superconducting electronics is encouraging several studies on hybrid Josephson junctions (JJs) based on superconductor/ferromagnet/superconductor (SFS) heterostructures, as either spintronic devices or switchable elements in quantum and classical circuits. Recent experimental evidence of macroscopic quantum tunneling and of an incomplete 0-pi transition in tunnel-ferr…
▽ More
The continuous development of superconducting electronics is encouraging several studies on hybrid Josephson junctions (JJs) based on superconductor/ferromagnet/superconductor (SFS) heterostructures, as either spintronic devices or switchable elements in quantum and classical circuits. Recent experimental evidence of macroscopic quantum tunneling and of an incomplete 0-pi transition in tunnel-ferromagnetic spin-filter JJs could enhance the capabilities of SFS JJs also as active elements. Here, we provide a self-consistent electrodynamic characterization of NbN/GdN/NbN spin-filter JJs as a function of the barrier thickness, disentangling the high-frequency dissipation effects due to the environment from the intrinsic low-frequency dissipation processes. The fitting of the IV characteristics at 4.2K and at 300mK by using the Tunnel Junction Microscopic model allows us to determine the subgap resistance Rsg, the quality factor Q and the junction capacitance C. These results provide the scaling behavior of the electrodynamic parameters as a function of the barrier thickness, which represents a fundamental step for the feasibility of tunnel ferromagnetic JJs as active elements in classical and quantum circuits, and are of general interest for tunnel junctions other than conventional SIS JJs.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Electrodynamics of Josephson junctions containing strong ferromagnets
Authors:
D. Massarotti,
N. Banerjee,
R. Caruso,
G. Rotoli,
M. G. Blamire,
F. Tafuri
Abstract:
Triplet supercurrents in multilayer ferromagnetic Josephson junctions with misaligned magnetization can penetrate thicker ferromagnetic barriers compared to the singlet component. Although the static properties of these junctions have been extensively studied, the dynamic characteristics remain largely unexplored. Here we report a comprehensive electrodynamic characterization of multilayer ferroma…
▽ More
Triplet supercurrents in multilayer ferromagnetic Josephson junctions with misaligned magnetization can penetrate thicker ferromagnetic barriers compared to the singlet component. Although the static properties of these junctions have been extensively studied, the dynamic characteristics remain largely unexplored. Here we report a comprehensive electrodynamic characterization of multilayer ferromagnetic Josephson junctions composed of Co and Ho. By measuring the temperature-dependent current-voltage characteristics and the switching current distributions down to 0.3 K, we show that phase dynamics of junctions with triplet supercurrents exhibits long (in terms of proximity) junction behavior and moderately damped dynamics with renormalized capacitance and resistance. This unconventional behavior possibly provides a different way to dynamically detect triplets. Our results show new theoretical models are required to fully understand the phase dynamics of triplet Josephson junctions for applications in superconducting spintronics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Breakdown of the escape dynamics in Josephson junctions
Authors:
D. Massarotti,
D. Stornaiuolo,
P. Lucignano,
L. Galletti,
D. Born,
G. Rotoli,
F. Lombardi,
L. Longobardi,
A. Tagliacozzo,
F. Tafuri
Abstract:
We have identified anomalous behavior of the escape rate out of the zero-voltage state in Josephson junctions with a high critical current density Jc. For this study we have employed YBa2Cu3O7-x grain boundary junctions, which span a wide range of Jc and have appropriate electrodynamical parameters. Such high Jc junctions, when hysteretic, do not switch from the superconducting to the normal state…
▽ More
We have identified anomalous behavior of the escape rate out of the zero-voltage state in Josephson junctions with a high critical current density Jc. For this study we have employed YBa2Cu3O7-x grain boundary junctions, which span a wide range of Jc and have appropriate electrodynamical parameters. Such high Jc junctions, when hysteretic, do not switch from the superconducting to the normal state following the expected stochastic Josephson distribution, despite having standard Josephson properties such as a Fraunhofer magnetic field pattern. The switching current distributions (SCDs) are consistent with nonequilibrium dynamics taking place on a local rather than a global scale. This means that macroscopic quantum phenomena seem to be practically unattainable for high Jc junctions. We argue that SCDs are an accurate means to measure nonequilibrium effects. This transition from global to local dynamics is of relevance for all kinds of weak links, including the emergent family of nanohybrid Josephson junctions. Therefore caution should be applied in the use of such junctions in, for instance, the search for Majorana fermions.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Macroscopic quantum tunneling in spin filter ferromagnetic Josephson junctions
Authors:
D. Massarotti,
A. Pal,
G. Rotoli,
L. Longobardi,
M. G. Blamire,
F. Tafuri
Abstract:
The interfacial coupling of two materials with different ordered phases, such as a superconductor (S) and a ferromagnet (F) is driving new fundamental physics and innovative applications. For example, the creation of spin-filter Josephson junctions and the demonstration of triplet supercurrents have suggested the potential of a dissipationless version of spintronics based on unconventional superco…
▽ More
The interfacial coupling of two materials with different ordered phases, such as a superconductor (S) and a ferromagnet (F) is driving new fundamental physics and innovative applications. For example, the creation of spin-filter Josephson junctions and the demonstration of triplet supercurrents have suggested the potential of a dissipationless version of spintronics based on unconventional superconductivity. Here we demonstrate evidence for active quantum applications of S-F-S junctions, through the observation of macroscopic quantum tunneling in Josephson junctions with GdN ferromagnetic insulator barriers. We prove a clear transition from thermal to quantum regime at a crossover temperature of about 100 mK at zero magnetic field in junctions which demonstrate a clear signature of unconventional superconductivity. Following previous demonstration of passive S-F-S phase shifters in a phase qubit, our result paves the way to the active use of spin filter Josephson systems in quantum hybrid circuits.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Resolving the effects of frequency dependent dam** and quantum phase diffusion in YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_{7-x}$ Josephson junctions
Authors:
D. Stornaiuolo,
G. Rotoli,
D. Massarotti,
F. Carillo,
L. Longobardi,
F. Beltram,
F. Tafuri
Abstract:
We report on the study of the phase dynamics of high critical temperature superconductor Josephson junctions. We realized YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_{7-x}$ (YBCO) grain boundary (GB) biepitaxial junctions in the submicron scale, using low loss substrates, and analyzed their dissipation by comparing the transport measurements with Monte Carlo simulations. The behavior of the junctions can be fitted using a mo…
▽ More
We report on the study of the phase dynamics of high critical temperature superconductor Josephson junctions. We realized YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_{7-x}$ (YBCO) grain boundary (GB) biepitaxial junctions in the submicron scale, using low loss substrates, and analyzed their dissipation by comparing the transport measurements with Monte Carlo simulations. The behavior of the junctions can be fitted using a model based on two quality factors, which results in a frequency dependent dam**. Moreover, our devices can be designed to have Josephson energy of the order of the Coulomb energy. In this unusual energy range, phase delocalization strongly influences the device's dynamics, promoting the transition to a quantum phase diffusion regime. We study the signatures of such a transition by combining the outcomes of Monte Carlo simulations with the analysis of the device's parameters, the critical current and the temperature behavior of the low voltage resistance $R_0$.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Direct transition from quantum escape to phase diffusion regime in YBaCuO biepitaxial Josephson Junctions
Authors:
Luigi Longobardi,
Davide Massarotti,
Daniela Stornaiuolo,
Luca Galletti,
Giacomo Rotoli,
Floriana Lombardi,
Francesco Tafuri
Abstract:
Dissipation encodes interaction of a quantum system with the environment and regulates the activation regimes of a Brownian particle. We have engineered grain boundary biepitaxial YBaCuO junctions to drive a direct transition from quantum activated running state to phase diffusion regime. The cross-over to the quantum regime is tuned by the magnetic field and dissipation is encoded in a fully cons…
▽ More
Dissipation encodes interaction of a quantum system with the environment and regulates the activation regimes of a Brownian particle. We have engineered grain boundary biepitaxial YBaCuO junctions to drive a direct transition from quantum activated running state to phase diffusion regime. The cross-over to the quantum regime is tuned by the magnetic field and dissipation is encoded in a fully consistent set of junction parameters. To unravel phase dynamics in moderately damped systems is of general interest for advances in the comprehension of retrap** phenomena and in view of quantum hybrid technology.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Quantum crossover in moderately damped epitaxial NbN/MgO/NbN junctions with low critical current density
Authors:
Luigi Longobardi,
Davide Massarotti,
Giacomo Rotoli,
Daniela Stornaiuolo,
Gianpaolo Papari,
Akira Kawakami,
Giovanni Piero Pepe,
Antonio Barone,
Francesco Tafuri
Abstract:
High quality epitaxial NbN/MgO/NbN Josephson junctions have been realized with MgO barriers up to a thickness of d=1 nm. The junction properties coherently scale with the size of barrier, and low critical current densities down to 3 A/cm$^2$ have been achieved for larger barriers. In this limit, junctions exhibit macroscopic quantum phenomena for temperatures lower than 90 mK. Measurements and jun…
▽ More
High quality epitaxial NbN/MgO/NbN Josephson junctions have been realized with MgO barriers up to a thickness of d=1 nm. The junction properties coherently scale with the size of barrier, and low critical current densities down to 3 A/cm$^2$ have been achieved for larger barriers. In this limit, junctions exhibit macroscopic quantum phenomena for temperatures lower than 90 mK. Measurements and junction parameters support the notion of a possible use of these devices for multiphoton quantum experiments, taking advantage of the fast non equilibrium electron-phonon relaxation times of NbN.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Thermal hop** and retrap** of a Brownian particle in the tilted periodic potential of a NbN/MgO/NbN Josephson junction
Authors:
Luigi Longobardi,
Davide Massarotti,
Giacomo Rotoli,
Daniela Stornaiuolo,
Gianpaolo Papari,
Akira Kawakami,
Giovanni Piero Pepe,
Antonio Barone,
Francesco Tafuri
Abstract:
We report on the occurrence of multiple hop** and retrap** of a Brownian particle in a tilted washboard potential. The escape dynamic has been studied experimentally by measuring the switching current distributions as a function of temperature in a moderately damped NbN/MgO/NbN Josephson junction. At low temperatures the second moment of the distribution increases in agreement with calculation…
▽ More
We report on the occurrence of multiple hop** and retrap** of a Brownian particle in a tilted washboard potential. The escape dynamic has been studied experimentally by measuring the switching current distributions as a function of temperature in a moderately damped NbN/MgO/NbN Josephson junction. At low temperatures the second moment of the distribution increases in agreement with calculations based on Kramers thermal activation regime. After a turn-over temperature T*, the shape of the distributions starts changing and width decreases with temperature. We analyze the data through fit of the switching probability and Monte Carlo simulations and we find a good agreement with a model based on a multiple retrap** process.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
The influence of the curvature dependence of the surface tension on the geometry of electrically charged menisci
Authors:
Ramiro dell'Erba,
Francesco dell'Isola,
Giacomo Rotoli
Abstract:
We evaluate how the curvature dependence of surface tension affects the shape of electrically charged interfaces between a perfectly conducting fluid and its vapour. We consider two cases: i) spherical droplets in equilibrium with their vapour; ii) menisci pending in a capillary tube in presence of a conducting plate at given electric potential drop. Tolman-like dependence of surface tension on cu…
▽ More
We evaluate how the curvature dependence of surface tension affects the shape of electrically charged interfaces between a perfectly conducting fluid and its vapour. We consider two cases: i) spherical droplets in equilibrium with their vapour; ii) menisci pending in a capillary tube in presence of a conducting plate at given electric potential drop. Tolman-like dependence of surface tension on curvature becomes important when the "nucleation radius" is comparable with the interface curvature radius. In case i) we prove existence of the equilibrium minimal radius and estimate its dependence on the electric field and Tolmanlike curvature effects. In case ii) the menisci are subject to the gravitational force, surface tension and electrostatic fields We determine the unknown surface of the menisci to which the potential is assigned using an iterative numerical method and show that Tolman-like corrections imply: 1) a variation of the height (up to 10% in some cases) of the tip of the menisci; 2) a decrease of the maximum electrical potential applicable to the menisci before their breakdown amounting to 40V over 800V in the considered cases. We conjecture that these effects could be used in new experiments based on electric measurements to determine the dependence of the equilibrium surface tension on curvature
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling and the "cosmic" Josephson effect
Authors:
A. Barone,
M. Gasperini,
G. Rotoli
Abstract:
We discuss the possible influence of a cosmic magnetic field on the macroscopic quantum tunneling process associated, in a cosmological context, to the decay of the "false vacuum." We find a close analogy with the effects of an external magnetic field applied to a Josephson junction in the context of low-temperature/high-temperature superconducting devices.
We discuss the possible influence of a cosmic magnetic field on the macroscopic quantum tunneling process associated, in a cosmological context, to the decay of the "false vacuum." We find a close analogy with the effects of an external magnetic field applied to a Josephson junction in the context of low-temperature/high-temperature superconducting devices.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2010; v1 submitted 11 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Nucleation of spherical shell-like interfaces by second gradient theory: numerical simulations
Authors:
Francesco Dell'Isola,
Henri Gouin,
Giacomo Rotoli
Abstract:
The theory of second gradient fluids (which are able to exert shear stresses also in equilibrium conditions) allows us: (i) to describe both the thermodynamical and the mechanical behavior of systems in which an interface is present; (ii) to express the surface tension and the radius of microscopic bubbles in terms of a functional of the chemical potential; (iii) to predict the existence of a (m…
▽ More
The theory of second gradient fluids (which are able to exert shear stresses also in equilibrium conditions) allows us: (i) to describe both the thermodynamical and the mechanical behavior of systems in which an interface is present; (ii) to express the surface tension and the radius of microscopic bubbles in terms of a functional of the chemical potential; (iii) to predict the existence of a (minimal) nucleation radius for bubbles. Moreover, the above theory supplies a 3D-continuum model which is endowed with sufficient structure to allow the construction of a 2D-shell-like continuum representing a consistent approximate 2D-model for the interface between phases. In this paper we use numerical simulations in the framework of second gradient theory to obtain explicit relationships for the surface quantities typical of 2D-models. In particular, for some of the most general two-parameter equations of state, it is possible to obtain the curves describing the relationship between the surface tension, the thickness, the surface mass density and the radius of the spherical interfaces between fluid phases of the same substance. These results allow us to predict the (minimal) nucleation radii for this class of equations of state.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
On wireless connection between Josephson qubits
Authors:
Sergei Sergeenkov,
Giacomo Rotoli
Abstract:
By attributing a circulating Josephson current induced diamagnetic moment to a SQUID-type three-level qubit, a wireless connection between such qubits is proposed based only on dipole-dipole interaction between their moments. The estimates of the model parameters suggest quite an optimistic possibility to experimentally realize the suggested coupling scheme.
By attributing a circulating Josephson current induced diamagnetic moment to a SQUID-type three-level qubit, a wireless connection between such qubits is proposed based only on dipole-dipole interaction between their moments. The estimates of the model parameters suggest quite an optimistic possibility to experimentally realize the suggested coupling scheme.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Thermal expansion of Josephson junctions as an elastic response to an effective stress field
Authors:
S. Sergeenkov,
G. Rotoli,
G. Filatrella,
F. M. Araujo-Moreira
Abstract:
By introducing a concept of thermal expansion (TE) of a Josephson junction as an elastic response to an effective stress field, we study (both analytically and numerically) the temperature and magnetic field dependence of TE coefficient $α$ in a single small junction and in a square array. In particular, we found that in addition to {\it field} oscillations due to Fraunhofer-like dependence of t…
▽ More
By introducing a concept of thermal expansion (TE) of a Josephson junction as an elastic response to an effective stress field, we study (both analytically and numerically) the temperature and magnetic field dependence of TE coefficient $α$ in a single small junction and in a square array. In particular, we found that in addition to {\it field} oscillations due to Fraunhofer-like dependence of the critical current, $α$ of a small single junction also exhibits strong flux driven {\it temperature} oscillations near $T_C$. We also numerically simulated stress induced response of a closed loop with finite self-inductance (a prototype of an array) and found that $α$ of a $5\times 5$ array may still exhibit temperature oscillations provided the applied magnetic field is strong enough to compensate for the screening induced effects.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
Observation of a New Fluxon Resonant Mechanism in Annular Josephson Tunnel Structures
Authors:
C. Nappi,
M. P. Lisitskiy,
G. Rotoli,
R. Cristiano,
A. Barone
Abstract:
A novel dynamical state has been observed in the dynamics of a perdurbed sine-Gordon system. This resonant state, has been experimentally observed as a singularity in the dc current voltage characteristic of an annular Josephson tunnel junction, excited in the presence of a magnetic field. With this respect, it can be assimilated to self-resonances known as Fiske steps. Differently from these, h…
▽ More
A novel dynamical state has been observed in the dynamics of a perdurbed sine-Gordon system. This resonant state, has been experimentally observed as a singularity in the dc current voltage characteristic of an annular Josephson tunnel junction, excited in the presence of a magnetic field. With this respect, it can be assimilated to self-resonances known as Fiske steps. Differently from these, however, we demonstrate, on the basis of numerical simulations, that its detailed dynamics involves rotating fluxon pairs, a mechanism associated, so far, to self-resonances known as zero-field steps.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
Coherent response of a low T_c Josephson junction to an ultrafast laser pulse
Authors:
P. Lucignano,
G. Rotoli,
E. Santamato,
A. Tagliacozzo
Abstract:
By irradiating with a single ultrafast laser pulse a superconducting electrode of a Josephson junction it is possible to drive the quasiparticles (qp's) distribution strongly out of equilibrium. The behavior of the Josephson device can, thus, be modified on a fast time scale, shorter than the qp's relaxation time. This could be very useful, in that it allows fast control of Josephson charge qubi…
▽ More
By irradiating with a single ultrafast laser pulse a superconducting electrode of a Josephson junction it is possible to drive the quasiparticles (qp's) distribution strongly out of equilibrium. The behavior of the Josephson device can, thus, be modified on a fast time scale, shorter than the qp's relaxation time. This could be very useful, in that it allows fast control of Josephson charge qubits and, in general, of all Josephson devices. If the energy released to the top layer contact $S1$ of the junction is of the order of $\sim μJ$, the coherence is not degradated, because the perturbation is very fast. Within the framework of the quasiclassical Keldysh Green's function theory, we find that the order parameter of $S1$ decreases. We study the perturbed dynamics of the junction, when the current bias is close to the critical current, by integrating numerically its classical equation of motion. The optical ultrafast pulse can produce switchings of the junction from the Josephson state to the voltage state. The switches can be controlled by tuning the laser light intensity and the pulse duration of the Josephson junction.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2004;
originally announced May 2004.
-
Induced paramagnetic states by localized $π$-loops in grain boundaries
Authors:
Giacomo Rotoli
Abstract:
Recent experiments on high-temperature superconductors show paramagnetic behavior localized at grain boundaries (GB). This paramagnetism can be attributed to the presence unconventional d-wave induced $π$-junctions. By modeling the GB as an array of $π$ and conventional Josephson junction we determine the conditions of the occurrence of the paramagnetic behavior.
Recent experiments on high-temperature superconductors show paramagnetic behavior localized at grain boundaries (GB). This paramagnetism can be attributed to the presence unconventional d-wave induced $π$-junctions. By modeling the GB as an array of $π$ and conventional Josephson junction we determine the conditions of the occurrence of the paramagnetic behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2003;
originally announced March 2003.
-
Paramagnetic and diamagnetic states in two-dimensional Josephson-junction arrays
Authors:
Cinzia De Leo,
Giacomo Rotoli
Abstract:
Many experiments on high-temperature superconductors have shown paramagnetic behavior when the sample is field cooled. The paramagnetism was first attributed to a d-wave order parameter creating pi-junctions in the samples. However, the same effect was later discovered in traditional low-temperature superconductors and conventional Josephson-junction arrays which are s-wave. By simulating both c…
▽ More
Many experiments on high-temperature superconductors have shown paramagnetic behavior when the sample is field cooled. The paramagnetism was first attributed to a d-wave order parameter creating pi-junctions in the samples. However, the same effect was later discovered in traditional low-temperature superconductors and conventional Josephson-junction arrays which are s-wave. By simulating both conventional and mixed pi/conventional Josephson-junction arrays we determine that differences exist which may be sufficient to clearly identify the presence (or absence) of pi-junctions. In particular the pi-junctions cause a symmetry breaking providing a measurable signature of their presence in sample.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2002;
originally announced May 2002.
-
Pulse-induced switches in a Josephson tunnel stacked device
Authors:
G. P. Pepe,
G. Peluso,
M. Valentino,
A. Barone,
L. Parlato,
E. Esposito,
C. Granata,
M. Russo,
C. De Leo,
G. Rotoli
Abstract:
Pulse activated transitions from the metastable to the running state and viceversa have been observed in a stacked double tunnel Nb-based Josephson system. Experimental results are compared with numerical simulations based on the Sine-Gordon model of the stacked junctions by injecting pulses with variable amplitude in one of the junctions of the stack, and observing the voltage response of the o…
▽ More
Pulse activated transitions from the metastable to the running state and viceversa have been observed in a stacked double tunnel Nb-based Josephson system. Experimental results are compared with numerical simulations based on the Sine-Gordon model of the stacked junctions by injecting pulses with variable amplitude in one of the junctions of the stack, and observing the voltage response of the other junction. Both experimental and numerical results show the possibility to induce both direct and back-switching transitions from the metastable to the running state simply by changing the amplitude of the electronic pulses injected across the stack device.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2001;
originally announced May 2001.
-
Mutual Inductance Route to Paramagnetic Meissner Effect in 2D Josephson Junction Arrays
Authors:
Cinzia De Leo,
Giacomo Rotoli,
Paola Barbara,
A. P. Nielsen,
C. J. Lobb
Abstract:
We simulate two-dimensional Josephson junction arrays, including full mutual- inductance effects, as they are cooled below the transition temperature in a magnetic field. We show numerical simulations of the array magnetization as a function of position, as detected by a scanning SQUID which is placed at a fixed height above the array. The calculated magnetization images show striking agreement…
▽ More
We simulate two-dimensional Josephson junction arrays, including full mutual- inductance effects, as they are cooled below the transition temperature in a magnetic field. We show numerical simulations of the array magnetization as a function of position, as detected by a scanning SQUID which is placed at a fixed height above the array. The calculated magnetization images show striking agreement with the experimental images obtained by A. Nielsen et al. The average array magnetization is found to be paramagnetic for many values of the applied field, confirming that paramagnetism can arise from magnetic screening in multiply-connected superconductors without the presence of d-wave superconductivity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2001;
originally announced March 2001.
-
Screening current effects in Josephson junction arrays
Authors:
A. Petraglia,
G. Filatrella,
G. Rotoli
Abstract:
The purpose of this work is to compare the dynamics of arrays of Josephson junctions in presence of magnetic field in two different frameworks: the so called XY frustrated model with no self inductance and an approach that takes into account the screening currents (considering self inductances only). We show that while for a range of parameters the simpler model is sufficiently accurate, in a re…
▽ More
The purpose of this work is to compare the dynamics of arrays of Josephson junctions in presence of magnetic field in two different frameworks: the so called XY frustrated model with no self inductance and an approach that takes into account the screening currents (considering self inductances only). We show that while for a range of parameters the simpler model is sufficiently accurate, in a region of the parameter space solutions arise that are not contained in the XY model equations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 1995;
originally announced July 1995.
