-
Spherical Harmonics for the 1D Radiative Transfer Equation II: Thermal Emission
Authors:
Caoimhe M. Rooney,
Natasha E. Batalha,
Mark S. Marley
Abstract:
Approximate methods to estimate solutions to the radiative transfer equation are essential for the understanding of atmospheres of exoplanets and brown dwarfs. The simplest and most popular choice is the "two-stream method" which is often used to produce simple yet effective models for radiative transfer in scattering and absorbing media. Toon et al. (1989) (Toon89) outlined a two-stream method fo…
▽ More
Approximate methods to estimate solutions to the radiative transfer equation are essential for the understanding of atmospheres of exoplanets and brown dwarfs. The simplest and most popular choice is the "two-stream method" which is often used to produce simple yet effective models for radiative transfer in scattering and absorbing media. Toon et al. (1989) (Toon89) outlined a two-stream method for computing reflected light and thermal spectra and was later implemented in the open-source radiative transfer model PICASO. In Part~I of this series, we developed an analytical spherical harmonics method for solving the radiative transfer equation for reflected solar radiation (Rooney et al. 2023), which was implemented in PICASO to increase the accuracy of the code by offering a higher-order approximation. This work is an extension of this spherical harmonics derivation to study thermal emission spectroscopy. We highlight the model differences in the approach for thermal emission and benchmark the 4-term method (SH4) against Toon89 and a high-stream discrete-ordinates method, CDISORT. By comparing the spectra produced by each model we demonstrate that the SH4 method provides a significant increase in accuracy, compared to Toon89, which can be attributed to the increased order of approximation and to the choice of phase function. We also explore the trade-off between computational time and model accuracy. We find that our 4-term method is twice as slow as our 2-term method, but is up to five times more accurate, when compared with CDISORT. Therefore, SH4 provides excellent improvement in model accuracy with minimal sacrifice in numerical expense.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Spherical Harmonics for the 1D Radiative Transfer Equation I: Reflected Light
Authors:
Caoimhe M. Rooney,
Natasha E. Batalha,
Mark S. Marley
Abstract:
A significant challenge in radiative transfer theory for atmospheres of exoplanets and brown dwarfs is the derivation of computationally efficient methods that have adequate fidelity to more precise, numerically demanding solutions. In this work, we extend the capability of the first open-source radiative transfer model for computing the reflected light of exoplanets at any phase geometry, PICASO:…
▽ More
A significant challenge in radiative transfer theory for atmospheres of exoplanets and brown dwarfs is the derivation of computationally efficient methods that have adequate fidelity to more precise, numerically demanding solutions. In this work, we extend the capability of the first open-source radiative transfer model for computing the reflected light of exoplanets at any phase geometry, PICASO: Planetary Intensity Code for Atmospheric Spectroscopy Observations. Until now, PICASO has implemented two-stream approaches to the solving the radiative transfer equation for reflected light, in particular following the derivations of Toon et al. (1989) (Toon89). In order to improve the model accuracy, we have considered higher-order approximations of the phase functions, namely, we have increased the order of approximation from 2 to 4, using spherical harmonics. The spherical harmonics approximation decouples spatial and directional dependencies by expanding the intensity and phase function into a series of spherical harmonics, or Legendre polynomials, allowing for analytical solutions for low-order approximations to optimize computational efficiency. We rigorously derive the spherical harmonics method for reflected light and benchmark the 4-term method (SH4) against Toon89 and two independent and higher-fidelity methods (CDISORT & doubling-method). On average, the SH4 method provides an order of magnitude increase in accuracy, compared to Toon89. Lastly, we implement SH4 within PICASO and observe only modest increase in computational time, compared to two-stream methods (20% increase).
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
A New Sedimentation Model for Greater Cloud Diversity in Giant Exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs
Authors:
Caoimhe M. Rooney,
Natasha E. Batalha,
Peter Gao,
Mark S. Marley
Abstract:
The observed atmospheric spectrum of exoplanets and brown dwarfs depends critically on the presence and distribution of atmospheric condensates. The Ackerman & Marley (2001) methodology for predicting the vertical distribution of condensate particles is widely used to study cloudy atmospheres and has recently been implemented in an open-source python package virga. The model relies upon input para…
▽ More
The observed atmospheric spectrum of exoplanets and brown dwarfs depends critically on the presence and distribution of atmospheric condensates. The Ackerman & Marley (2001) methodology for predicting the vertical distribution of condensate particles is widely used to study cloudy atmospheres and has recently been implemented in an open-source python package virga. The model relies upon input parameter $f_{\text{sed}}$, the sedimentation efficiency, which until now has been held constant. The relative simplicity of this model renders it useful for retrieval studies due to its rapidly attainable solutions. However, comparisons with more complex microphysical models such as CARMA have highlighted inconsistencies between the two approaches, namely that the cloud parameters needed for radiative transfer produced by virga are dissimilar to those produced by CARMA. To address these discrepancies, we have extended the original Ackerman and Marley methodology in virga to allow for non-constant $f_{\text{sed}}$ values, in particular those that vary with altitude. We discuss one such parameterization and compare the cloud mass mixing ratio produced by virga with constant and variable $f_{\text{sed}}$ profiles to that produced by CARMA. We find that the variable $f_{\text{sed}}$ formulation better captures the profile produced by CARMA with heterogeneous nucleation, yet performs comparatively to constant $f_{\text{sed}}$ for homogeneous nucleation. In general, virga has the capacity to handle any $f_{\text{sed}}$ with an explicit anti-derivative, permitting a plethora of alternative cloud profiles that are otherwise unattainable by constant $f_{\text{sed}}$ values. The ensuing flexibility has the potential to better agree with increasingly complex models and observed data.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2021; v1 submitted 12 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
