-
Local search and trajectory metaheuristics for the flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequencing flexibility and position-based learning effect
Authors:
Kennedy A. G. Araújo,
Ernesto G. Birgin,
Débora P. Ronconi
Abstract:
The flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequencing flexibility and position-based learning effect is considered in the present work. In [K. A. G. Araujo, E. G. Birgin, and D. P. Ronconi, Technical Report MCDO02022024, 2024], models, constructive heuristics, and benchmark instances for the same problem were introduced. In the present work, we are concerned with the development of effective an…
▽ More
The flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequencing flexibility and position-based learning effect is considered in the present work. In [K. A. G. Araujo, E. G. Birgin, and D. P. Ronconi, Technical Report MCDO02022024, 2024], models, constructive heuristics, and benchmark instances for the same problem were introduced. In the present work, we are concerned with the development of effective and efficient methods for its resolution. For this purpose, a local search method and four trajectory metaheuristics are considered. In the local search, we show that the classical strategy of only reallocating operations that are part of the critical path can miss better quality neighbors, as opposed to what happens in the case where there is no learning effect. Consequently, we analyze an alternative type of neighborhood reduction that eliminates only neighbors that are not better than the current solution. In addition, we also suggest a neighborhood cut and experimentally verify that this significantly reduces the neighborhood size, bringing efficiency, with minimal loss in effectiveness. Extensive numerical experiments with the local search and the metaheuristics are carried on. The experiments show that tabu search, built on the reduced neighborhood, when applied to large-sized instances, stands out in relation to other the other three metaheuristics, namely, iterated local search, greedy randomized adaptive search procedure, and simulating annealing. Experiments with classical instances without sequencing flexibility show that the introduced methods also stand out in relation to methods from the literature. All the methods introduced, as well as the instances and solutions found, are freely available. As a whole, we build a test suite that can be used in future work.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Models, constructive heuristics, and benchmark instances for the flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequencing flexibility and position-based learning effect
Authors:
Kennedy A. G. Araújo,
Ernesto G. Birgin,
Débora P. Ronconi
Abstract:
This paper addresses the flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequencing flexibility and position-based learning effect. In this variant of the flexible job shop scheduling problem, precedence constraints of the operations constituting a job are given by an arbitrary directed acyclic graph, in opposition to the classical case in which a total order is imposed. Additionally, it is assumed that…
▽ More
This paper addresses the flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequencing flexibility and position-based learning effect. In this variant of the flexible job shop scheduling problem, precedence constraints of the operations constituting a job are given by an arbitrary directed acyclic graph, in opposition to the classical case in which a total order is imposed. Additionally, it is assumed that the processing time of an operation in a machine is subject to a learning process such that the larger the position of the operation in the machine, the faster the operation is processed. Mixed integer programming and constraint programming models are presented and compared in the present work. In addition, constructive heuristics are introduced to provide an initial solution to the models' solvers. Sets of benchmark instances are also introduced. The problem considered corresponds to modern problems of great relevance in the printing industry. The models and instances presented are intended to support the development of new heuristic and metaheuristics methods for this problem.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
A forward-looking matheuristic approach for the multi-period two-dimensional non-guillotine cutting stock problem with usable leftovers
Authors:
E. G. Birgin,
O. C Romão,
D. P. Ronconi
Abstract:
In [E. G. Birgin, O. C. Romão, and D. P. Ronconi, The multi-period two-dimensional non-guillotine cutting stock problem with usable leftovers, International Transactions in Operational Research 27(3), 1392-1418, 2020] the multi-period two-dimensional non-guillotine cutting stock problem with usable leftovers was introduced. At each decision instant, the problem consists in determining a cutting pa…
▽ More
In [E. G. Birgin, O. C. Romão, and D. P. Ronconi, The multi-period two-dimensional non-guillotine cutting stock problem with usable leftovers, International Transactions in Operational Research 27(3), 1392-1418, 2020] the multi-period two-dimensional non-guillotine cutting stock problem with usable leftovers was introduced. At each decision instant, the problem consists in determining a cutting pattern for a set of ordered items using a set of objects that can be purchased or can be leftovers of previous periods; the goal being the minimization of the overall cost of the objects up to the considered time horizon. Among solutions with minimum cost, a solution that maximizes the value of the leftovers at the end of the considered horizon is sought. A forward-looking matheuristic approach that applies to this problem is introduced in the present work. At each decision instant, the objects and the cutting pattern that will be used is determined, taking into account the impact of this decision in future states of the system. More specifically, for each potentially used object, an attempt is made to estimate the utilization rate of its leftovers and thereby determine whether the object should be used or not. The approach's performance is compared to the performance of a myopic technique. Numerical experiments show the efficacy of the proposed approach.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2022; v1 submitted 25 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Relax-and-fix heuristics applied to a real-world lot-sizing and scheduling problem in the personal care consumer goods industry
Authors:
K. A. G. Araujo,
E. G. Birgin,
M. S. Kawamura,
D. P. Ronconi
Abstract:
This paper addresses an integrated lot-sizing and scheduling problem in the industry of consumer goods for personal care, a very competitive market in which the good customer service level and the cost management show up in the competition for the clients. In this research, a complex operational environment composed of unrelated parallel machines with limited production capacity and sequence-depen…
▽ More
This paper addresses an integrated lot-sizing and scheduling problem in the industry of consumer goods for personal care, a very competitive market in which the good customer service level and the cost management show up in the competition for the clients. In this research, a complex operational environment composed of unrelated parallel machines with limited production capacity and sequence-dependent setup times and costs is studied. There is also a limited finished-goods storage capacity, a characteristic not found in the literature. Backordering is allowed but it is extremely undesirable. The problem is described through a mixed integer linear programming formulation. Since the problem is NP-hard, relax-and-fix heuristics with hybrid partitioning strategies are investigated. Computational experiments with randomly generated and also with real-world instances are presented. The results show the efficacy and efficiency of the proposed approaches. Compared to current solutions used by the company, the best proposed strategies yield results with substantially lower costs, primarily from the reduction in inventory levels and better allocation of production batches on the machines.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Mixed Integer Linear Programming and Constraint Programming Models for the Online Printing Shop Scheduling Problem
Authors:
Willian T. Lunardi,
Ernesto G. Birgin,
Philippe Laborie,
Débora P. Ronconi,
Holger Voos
Abstract:
In this work, the online printing shop scheduling problem is considered. This challenging real problem, that appears in the nowadays printing industry, can be seen as a flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequence flexibility in which precedence constraints among operations of a job are given by an arbitrary directed acyclic graph. In addition, several complicating particularities such as pe…
▽ More
In this work, the online printing shop scheduling problem is considered. This challenging real problem, that appears in the nowadays printing industry, can be seen as a flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequence flexibility in which precedence constraints among operations of a job are given by an arbitrary directed acyclic graph. In addition, several complicating particularities such as periods of unavailability of the machines, resumable operations, sequence-dependent setup times, partial overlap** among operations with precedence constraints, release times, and fixed operations are also present in the addressed problem. In the present work, mixed integer linear programming and constraint programming models for the minimization of the makespan are presented. Modeling the problem is twofold. On the one hand, the problem is precisely defined. On the other hand, the capabilities and limitations of a commercial software for solving the models are analyzed. Extensive numerical experiments with small-, medium-, and large-sized instances are presented. Numerical experiments show that the commercial solver is able to optimally solve only a fraction of the small-sized instances when considering the mixed integer linear programming model; while all small-sized and a fraction of the medium-sized instances are optimally solved when considering the constraint programming formulation of the problem. Moreover, the commercial solver is able to deliver feasible solutions for the large-sized instances that are of the size of the instances that appear in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2022; v1 submitted 22 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Metaheuristics for the Online Printing Shop Scheduling Problem
Authors:
Willian T. Lunardi,
Ernesto G. Birgin,
Débora P. Ronconi,
Holger Voos
Abstract:
In this work, the online printing shop scheduling problem introduced in (Lunardi et al., Mixed Integer Linear Programming and Constraint Programming Models for the Online Printing Shop Scheduling Problem, Computers & Operations Research, to appear) is considered. This challenging real scheduling problem, that emerged in the nowadays printing industry, corresponds to a flexible job shop scheduling…
▽ More
In this work, the online printing shop scheduling problem introduced in (Lunardi et al., Mixed Integer Linear Programming and Constraint Programming Models for the Online Printing Shop Scheduling Problem, Computers & Operations Research, to appear) is considered. This challenging real scheduling problem, that emerged in the nowadays printing industry, corresponds to a flexible job shop scheduling problem with sequencing flexibility; and it presents several complicating specificities such as resumable operations, periods of unavailability of the machines, sequence-dependent setup times, partial overlap** between operations with precedence constraints, and fixed operations, among others. A local search strategy and metaheuristic approaches for the problem are proposed and evaluated. Based on a common representation scheme, trajectory and populational metaheuristics are considered. Extensive numerical experiments with large-sized instances show that the proposed methods are suitable for solving practical instances of the problem; and that they outperform a half-heuristic-half-exact off-the-shelf solver by a large extent. Numerical experiments with classical instances of the flexible job shop scheduling problem show that the introduced methods are also competitive when applied to this particular case.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2022; v1 submitted 22 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A MILP model for an extended version of the Flexible Job Shop Problem
Authors:
Ernesto G. Birgin,
Paulo Feofiloff,
Cristina G. Fernandes,
Everton L. de Melo,
Marcio T. I. Oshiro,
Débora P. Ronconi
Abstract:
A MILP model for an extended version of the Flexible Job Shop Scheduling problem is proposed. The extension allows the precedences between operations of a job to be given by an arbitrary directed acyclic graph rather than a linear order. The goal is the minimization of the makespan. Theoretical and practical advantages of the proposed model are discussed. Numerical experiments show the performance…
▽ More
A MILP model for an extended version of the Flexible Job Shop Scheduling problem is proposed. The extension allows the precedences between operations of a job to be given by an arbitrary directed acyclic graph rather than a linear order. The goal is the minimization of the makespan. Theoretical and practical advantages of the proposed model are discussed. Numerical experiments show the performance of a commercial exact solver when applied to the proposed model. The new model is also compared with a simple extension of the model described by Özgüven, Özbakir, and Yavuz (Mathematical models for job-shop scheduling problems with routing and process plan flexibility, Applied Mathematical Modelling, 34:1539--1548, 2010), using instances from the literature and instances inspired by real data from the printing industry.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
