-
From Young Massive Clusters to Old Globular Clusters: Density Profile Evolution and IMBH Formation
Authors:
Kuldeep Sharma,
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
The surface brightness profiles of globular clusters are conventionally described with the well-known King profile. However, observations of young massive clusters (YMCs) in the local Universe suggest that they are better fit by simple models with flat central cores and simple power-law densities in their outer regions (such as the Elson-Fall-Freeman, or EFF, profile). Depending on their initial c…
▽ More
The surface brightness profiles of globular clusters are conventionally described with the well-known King profile. However, observations of young massive clusters (YMCs) in the local Universe suggest that they are better fit by simple models with flat central cores and simple power-law densities in their outer regions (such as the Elson-Fall-Freeman, or EFF, profile). Depending on their initial central density, these YMCs may also facilitate large numbers of stellar collisions, potentially creating very massive stars that will directly collapse to intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs). Using Monte Carlo $N$-body models of YMCs, we show that EFF-profile clusters transform to Wilson or King profiles through natural dynamical evolution, but that their final $W_0$ parameters do not strongly correlate to their initial concentrations. The most centrally-dense YMCs can produce runaway stellar mergers as massive as $4000\,M_{\odot}$ (the largest resolved mass in our simulations) which can collapse to produce IMBHs of similar masses. In doing so, these runaway collisions also deplete the clusters of their primordial massive stars, reducing the number of stellar-mass BHs by as much as $\sim$ 40\%. This depletion will accelerate the core collapse of clusters, suggesting that the process of IMBH formation itself may produce the high densities observed in some core-collapsed clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Stellar Black Holes and Compact Stellar Remnants
Authors:
Guglielmo Costa,
Martyna Chruślińska,
Jakub Klencki,
Floor S. Broekgaarden,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Tana D. Joseph,
Sara Saracino
Abstract:
The recent observations of gravitational waves (GWs) by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaboration (LVK) have provided a new opportunity for studying our Universe. By detecting several merging events of black holes (BHs), LVK has spurred the astronomical community to improve theoretical models of single, binary, and multiple star evolution in order to better understand the formation of binary black hole (…
▽ More
The recent observations of gravitational waves (GWs) by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaboration (LVK) have provided a new opportunity for studying our Universe. By detecting several merging events of black holes (BHs), LVK has spurred the astronomical community to improve theoretical models of single, binary, and multiple star evolution in order to better understand the formation of binary black hole (BBH) systems and interpret their observed properties. The final BBH system configuration before the merger depends on several processes, including those related to the evolution of the inner stellar structure and those due to the interaction with the companion and the environment (such as in stellar clusters). This chapter provides a summary of the formation scenarios of stellar BHs in single, binary, and multiple systems. We review all the important physical processes that affect the formation of BHs and discuss the methodologies used to detect these elusive objects and constrain their properties.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Great Balls of FIRE III: Modeling Black Hole Mergers from Massive Star Clusters in Simulations of Galaxies
Authors:
Tristan Bruel,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Astrid Lamberts,
Michael Y. Grudic,
Zachary Hafen,
Robert Feldmann
Abstract:
After the nearly hundred gravitational-wave detections reported by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Collaboration, the question of the cosmological origin of merging binary black holes (BBHs) remains open. The two main formation channels generally considered are from isolated field binaries or via dynamical assembly in dense star clusters. Here, we focus on understanding the dynamical formation of merging BBH…
▽ More
After the nearly hundred gravitational-wave detections reported by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Collaboration, the question of the cosmological origin of merging binary black holes (BBHs) remains open. The two main formation channels generally considered are from isolated field binaries or via dynamical assembly in dense star clusters. Here, we focus on understanding the dynamical formation of merging BBHs within massive clusters in galaxies of different masses. To this end, we apply a new framework to consistently model the formation and evolution of massive star clusters in zoom-in cosmological simulations of galaxies. Each simulation, taken from the FIRE project, provides a realistic star formation environment with a unique star formation history and hosts realistic giant molecular clouds that constitute the birthplace of star clusters. Combined with the code for star cluster evolution CMC, we are able to produce populations of dynamically formed merging BBHs across cosmic time in different environments. As the most massive star clusters preferentially form in dense massive clouds of gas, we find that, despite their low metallicities favourable to the creation of black holes, low-mass galaxies contain few massive clusters and therefore have a limited contribution to the global production of dynamically formed merging BBHs. Furthermore, we find that massive clusters can host hierarchical BBH mergers with clear identifiable physical properties. Looking at the evolution of the BBH merger rate in different galaxies, we find strong correlations between BBH mergers and the most extreme episodes of star formation. Finally, we discuss the implications for future LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA gravitational wave observations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Young Star Clusters Dominate the Production of Detached Black Hole-Star Binaries
Authors:
Ugo Niccolò Di Carlo,
Poojan Agrawal,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Katelyn Breivik
Abstract:
The recent discovery of two detached black hole-star (BH-star) binaries from Gaia's third data release has sparkled interest in understanding the formation mechanisms of these systems. We investigate the formation of these systems by dynamical processes in young open star clusters (SCs) and via isolated binary (IB) evolution, using a combination of direct $N$-body models and population synthesis s…
▽ More
The recent discovery of two detached black hole-star (BH-star) binaries from Gaia's third data release has sparkled interest in understanding the formation mechanisms of these systems. We investigate the formation of these systems by dynamical processes in young open star clusters (SCs) and via isolated binary (IB) evolution, using a combination of direct $N$-body models and population synthesis simulations. By comparing dynamical and isolated systems created using the same model of binary stellar evolution, we find that dynamical formation in SCs is nearly 40 times as efficient per unit of star formation at producing BH-star binaries compared to IB evolution. We expand this analysis to the full Milky Way (MW) using a FIRE-2 hydrodynamical simulation of a MW-mass galaxy. Even assuming that only $10\%$ of star formation produces SCs with masses $> 1000\,\mathrm{M_{\odot}}$, we find that the MW contains $\sim 2 \times 10^5$ BH-star systems, with approximately 4 out of every 5 systems being formed dynamically. Many of these dynamically-formed systems have larger orbital periods, eccentricities, and black hole masses than their isolated counterparts. For binaries older than 100 Myr, we show that any detectable system with $e\gtrsim0.5$ or $M_{\rm BH}\gtrsim 10\,\mathrm{M_{\odot}}$ can only be formed through dynamical processes. Our MW model predicts between 61 and 210 such detections from the complete DR4 Gaia catalog, with the majority of systems being dynamically formed in massive and metal-rich SCs. Finally, we compare our populations to the recently discovered Gaia BH1 and Gaia BH2, and conclude that the dynamical scenario is the most favorable formation pathway for both systems.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Modelling stellar evolution in mass-transferring binaries and gravitational-wave progenitors with METISSE
Authors:
Poojan Agrawal,
Jarrod Hurley,
Simon Stevenson,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Dorottya Szecsi,
Alex Kemp
Abstract:
Massive binaries are vital sources of various transient processes, including gravitational-wave mergers. However, large uncertainties in the evolution of massive stars, both physical and numerical, present a major challenge to the understanding of their binary evolution. In this paper, we upgrade our interpolation-based stellar evolution code METISSE to include the effects of mass changes, such as…
▽ More
Massive binaries are vital sources of various transient processes, including gravitational-wave mergers. However, large uncertainties in the evolution of massive stars, both physical and numerical, present a major challenge to the understanding of their binary evolution. In this paper, we upgrade our interpolation-based stellar evolution code METISSE to include the effects of mass changes, such as binary mass transfer or wind-driven mass loss, not already included within the input stellar tracks. METISSE's implementation of mass loss (applied to tracks without mass loss) shows excellent agreement with the SSE fitting formulae and with detailed MESA tracks, except in cases where the mass transfer is too rapid for the star to maintain equilibrium. We use this updated version of METISSE within the binary population synthesis code BSE to demonstrate the impact of varying stellar evolution parameters, particularly core overshooting, on the evolution of a massive (25M$_\odot$ and 15M$_\odot$) binary system with an orbital period of 1800 days. Depending on the input tracks, we find that the binary system can form a binary black hole or a black hole-neutron star system, with primary(secondary) remnant masses ranging between 4.47(1.36)M$_\odot$ and 12.30(10.89)M$_\odot$, and orbital periods ranging from 6 days to the binary becoming unbound. Extending this analysis to a population of isolated binaries uniformly distributed in mass and orbital period, we show that the input stellar models play an important role in determining which regions of the binary parameter space can produce compact binary mergers, paving the way for predictions for current and future gravitational-wave observatories.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2023; v1 submitted 17 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Constraints on the Cosmological Coupling of Black Holes from the Globular Cluster NGC 3201
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
Globular clusters are among the oldest stellar populations in the Milky Way; consequently, they also host some of the oldest known stellar-mass black holes, providing insight into black hole formation and evolution in the early ($z\gtrsim 2$) Universe. Recent observations of supermassive black holes in elliptical galaxies have been invoked to suggest the possibility of a cosmological coupling betw…
▽ More
Globular clusters are among the oldest stellar populations in the Milky Way; consequently, they also host some of the oldest known stellar-mass black holes, providing insight into black hole formation and evolution in the early ($z\gtrsim 2$) Universe. Recent observations of supermassive black holes in elliptical galaxies have been invoked to suggest the possibility of a cosmological coupling between astrophysical black holes and the surrounding expanding Universe, offering a mechanism for black holes to grow over cosmic time, and potentially explaining the origin of dark energy. In this paper, I show that the mass functions of the two radial velocity black hole candidates in NGC 3201 place strong constraints on the cosmologically-coupled growth of black holes. In particular, the amount of coupling required to explain the origin of dark energy would either require both NGC 3201 black holes to be nearly face on (a configuration with probability of at most $10^{-4}$) or one of the BHs would need to have formed with a mass below that of the most massive neutron stars ($2.2M_{\odot}$). This emphasizes that these and other detached black hole-star binaries can serve not only as laboratories for compact object and binary astrophysics, but as constraints on the long-term evolution of astrophysical black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2023; v1 submitted 23 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Runaway and Hypervelocity Stars from Compact Object Encounters in Globular Clusters
Authors:
Tomás Cabrera,
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
The dense environments in the cores of globular clusters (GCs) facilitate many strong dynamical encounters among stellar objects. These encounters have been shown capable of ejecting stars from the host GC, whereupon they become runaway stars, or hypervelocity stars if unbound to the galactic potential. We study high speed stellar ejecta originating from GCs by using Monte Carlo N-body models, in…
▽ More
The dense environments in the cores of globular clusters (GCs) facilitate many strong dynamical encounters among stellar objects. These encounters have been shown capable of ejecting stars from the host GC, whereupon they become runaway stars, or hypervelocity stars if unbound to the galactic potential. We study high speed stellar ejecta originating from GCs by using Monte Carlo N-body models, in particular focusing on binary-single encounters involving compact objects. We pair our model-discriminated populations with observational catalogs of Milky Way GCs to compose a present-day galactic population of stellar ejecta. We find that these kinds of encounters can accelerate stars to velocities in excess of 2000 km/s, to speeds beyond the previously predicted limits for ejecta from star-only encounters and in the same regime of galactic center ejections. However, the same ejections can only account for 1.5-20% of the total population of stellar runaways, and only 0.0001-1% of hypervelocity stars, with similar relative rates found for runaway white dwarfs. We also provide credible regions for ejecta from 149 Milky Way GCs, which we hope will be useful as supplementary evidence when pairing runaway stars with origin GCs.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2024; v1 submitted 6 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Evolution of Massive Black Hole Binaries in Collisionally Relaxed Nuclear Star Clusters -- Impact of Mass Segregation
Authors:
Diptajyoti Mukherjee,
Qirong Zhu,
Go Ogiya,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Hy Trac
Abstract:
Massive Black Hole (MBH) binaries are considered to be one of the most important sources of Gravitational Waves (GW) that can be detected by GW detectors like LISA. However, there are a lot of uncertainties in the dynamics of MBH binaries in the stages leading up to the GW-emission phase. It has been recently suggested that Nuclear Star Clusters (NSCs) could provide a viable route to overcome the…
▽ More
Massive Black Hole (MBH) binaries are considered to be one of the most important sources of Gravitational Waves (GW) that can be detected by GW detectors like LISA. However, there are a lot of uncertainties in the dynamics of MBH binaries in the stages leading up to the GW-emission phase. It has been recently suggested that Nuclear Star Clusters (NSCs) could provide a viable route to overcome the final parsec problem for MBH binaries at the center of galaxies. NSCs are collisional systems where the dynamics would be altered by the presence of a mass spectrum. In this study, we use a suite of high-resolution $N$-body simulations with over 1 million particles to understand how collisional relaxation under the presence of a mass spectrum of NSC particles affects the dynamics of the MBH binary under the merger of two NSCs. We consider MBH binaries with different mass ratios and additional non-relaxed models. We find that mass-segregation driven by collisional relaxation can lead to accelerated hardening in lower mass ratio binaries but has the opposite effect in higher mass ratio binaries. Crucially, the relaxed models also demonstrate much lower eccentricities at binary formation and negligible growth during hardening stages leading to longer merger timescales. The results are robust and highlight the importance of collisional relaxation on changing the dynamics of the binary. Our models are state-of-the-art, use zero softening, and high enough particle numbers to model NSCs realistically.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2022; v1 submitted 24 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Great Balls of FIRE II: The evolution and destruction of star clusters across cosmic time in a Milky Way-mass galaxy
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Zachary Hafen,
Michael Y. Grudić,
Astrid Lamberts,
Kuldeep Sharma,
Claude-André Faucher-Giguère,
Andrew Wetzel
Abstract:
The current generation of galaxy simulations can resolve individual giant molecular clouds, the progenitors of dense star clusters. But the evolutionary fate of these young massive clusters, and whether they can become the old globular clusters (GCs) observed in many galaxies, is determined by a complex interplay of internal dynamical processes and external galactic effects. We present the first s…
▽ More
The current generation of galaxy simulations can resolve individual giant molecular clouds, the progenitors of dense star clusters. But the evolutionary fate of these young massive clusters, and whether they can become the old globular clusters (GCs) observed in many galaxies, is determined by a complex interplay of internal dynamical processes and external galactic effects. We present the first star-by-star $N$-body models of massive ($N\sim10^5-10^7$) star clusters formed in a FIRE-2 MHD simulation of a Milky Way-mass galaxy, with the relevant initial conditions and tidal forces extracted from the cosmological simulation. We select 895 ($\sim 30\%$) of the YMCs with $ > 6\times10^4M_{\odot}$ from Grudić et al.~2022 and integrate them to $z=0$ using the Cluster Monte Carlo Code, \texttt{CMC}. This procedure predicts a MW-like system with 148 GCs, predominantly formed during the early, bursty mode of star formation. Our GCs are younger, less massive, and more core-collapsed than clusters in the Milky Way or M31. This results from the assembly history and age-metallicity relationship of the host galaxy: younger clusters are preferentially born in stronger tidal fields and initially retain fewer stellar-mass black holes, causing them to lose mass faster and reach core collapse sooner than older GCs. Our results suggest that the masses and core/half-light radii of GCs are shaped not only by internal dynamical processes, but also by the specific evolutionary history of their host galaxies. These results emphasize that $N$-body studies with realistic stellar physics are crucial to understanding the evolution and present-day properties of GC systems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2023; v1 submitted 30 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Great Balls of FIRE I: The formation of star clusters across cosmic time in a Milky Way-mass galaxy
Authors:
Michael Y. Grudić,
Zachary Hafen,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Dávid Guszejnov,
Astrid Lamberts,
Andrew Wetzel,
Michael Boylan-Kolchin,
Claude-André Faucher-Giguère
Abstract:
The properties of young star clusters formed within a galaxy are thought to vary in different interstellar medium (ISM) conditions, but the details of this map** from galactic to cluster scales are poorly understood due to the large dynamic range involved in galaxy and star cluster formation. We introduce a new method for modeling cluster formation in galaxy simulations: map** giant molecular…
▽ More
The properties of young star clusters formed within a galaxy are thought to vary in different interstellar medium (ISM) conditions, but the details of this map** from galactic to cluster scales are poorly understood due to the large dynamic range involved in galaxy and star cluster formation. We introduce a new method for modeling cluster formation in galaxy simulations: map** giant molecular clouds (GMCs) formed self-consistently in a FIRE-2 MHD galaxy simulation onto a cluster population according to a GMC-scale cluster formation model calibrated to higher-resolution simulations, obtaining detailed properties of the galaxy's star clusters in mass, metallicity, space, and time. We find $\sim 10\%$ of all stars formed in the galaxy originate in gravitationally-bound clusters overall, and this fraction increases in regions with elevated $Σ_{\rm gas}$ and $Σ_{\rm SFR}$, because such regions host denser GMCs with higher star formation efficiency. These quantities vary systematically over the history of the galaxy, driving variations in cluster formation. The mass function of bound clusters varies -- no single Schechter-like or power-law distribution applies at all times. In the most extreme episodes, clusters as massive as $7\times 10^6 M_\odot$ form in massive, dense clouds with high star formation efficiency. The initial mass-radius relation of young star clusters is consistent with an environmentally-dependent 3D density that increases with $Σ_{\rm gas}$ and $Σ_{\rm SFR}$. The model does not reproduce the age and metallicity statistics of old ($>11\rm Gyr$) globular clusters found in the Milky Way, possibly because it forms stars more slowly at $z>3$.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2022; v1 submitted 10 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Compact Object Modeling in the Globular Cluster 47 Tucanae
Authors:
Claire S. Ye,
Kyle Kremer,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Nicholas Z. Rui,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
The globular cluster 47~Tucanae (47~Tuc) is one of the most massive star clusters in the Milky Way and is exceptionally rich in exotic stellar populations. For several decades it has been a favorite target of observers, and yet it is computationally very challenging to model because of its large number of stars ($N\gtrsim 10^6$) and high density. Here we present detailed and self-consistent 47~Tuc…
▽ More
The globular cluster 47~Tucanae (47~Tuc) is one of the most massive star clusters in the Milky Way and is exceptionally rich in exotic stellar populations. For several decades it has been a favorite target of observers, and yet it is computationally very challenging to model because of its large number of stars ($N\gtrsim 10^6$) and high density. Here we present detailed and self-consistent 47~Tuc models computed with the \texttt{Cluster Monte Carlo} code (\texttt{CMC}). The models include all relevant dynamical interactions coupled to stellar and binary evolution, and reproduce various observations, including the surface brightness and velocity dispersion profiles, pulsar accelerations, and numbers of compact objects. We show that the present properties of 47~Tuc are best reproduced by adopting an initial stellar mass function that is both bottom-heavy and top-light relative to standard assumptions \citep[as in, e.g.,][]{Kroupa2001}, and an initial Elson profile \citep{Elson1987} that is overfilling the cluster's tidal radius. We include new prescriptions in \texttt{CMC} for the formation of binaries through giant star collisions and tidal captures, and we show that these mechanisms play a crucial role in the formation of neutron star binaries and millisecond pulsars in 47~Tuc; our best-fit model contains $\sim 50$ millisecond pulsars, $70\%$ of which are formed through giant collisions and tidal captures. Our models also suggest that 47~Tuc presently contains up to $\sim 200$ stellar-mass black holes, $\sim 5$ binary black holes, $\sim 15$ low-mass X-ray binaries, and $\sim 300$ cataclysmic variables.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2022; v1 submitted 11 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Modeling Dense Star Clusters in the Milky Way and Beyond with the Cluster Monte Carlo Code
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Scott C. Coughlin,
Pau Amaro Seoane,
Katelyn Breivik,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Fulya Kıroğlu,
Kyle Kremer,
Nicholas Z. Rui,
Claire S. Ye,
Michael Zevin,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
We describe the public release of the Cluster Monte Carlo Code (CMC) a parallel, star-by-star $N$-body code for modeling dense star clusters. CMC treats collisional stellar dynamics using Hénon's method, where the cumulative effect of many two-body encounters is statistically reproduced as a single effective encounter between nearest-neighbor particles on a relaxation timescale. The star-by-star a…
▽ More
We describe the public release of the Cluster Monte Carlo Code (CMC) a parallel, star-by-star $N$-body code for modeling dense star clusters. CMC treats collisional stellar dynamics using Hénon's method, where the cumulative effect of many two-body encounters is statistically reproduced as a single effective encounter between nearest-neighbor particles on a relaxation timescale. The star-by-star approach allows for the inclusion of additional physics, including strong gravitational three- and four-body encounters, two-body tidal and gravitational-wave captures, mass loss in arbitrary galactic tidal fields, and stellar evolution for both single and binary stars. The public release of CMC is pinned directly to the COSMIC population synthesis code, allowing dynamical star cluster simulations and population synthesis studies to be performed using identical assumptions about the stellar physics and initial conditions. As a demonstration, we present two examples of star cluster modeling: first, we perform the largest ($N = 10^8$) star-by-star $N$-body simulation of a Plummer sphere evolving to core collapse, reproducing the expected self-similar density profile over more than 15 orders of magnitude; second, we generate realistic models for typical globular clusters, and we show that their dynamical evolution can produce significant numbers of black hole mergers with masses greater than those produced from isolated binary evolution (such as GW190521, a recently reported merger with component masses in the pulsational pair-instability mass gap).
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2021; v1 submitted 4 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
On the Mass Ratio Distribution of Black Hole Mergers in Triple Systems
Authors:
Miguel A. S. Martinez,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Giacomo Fragione
Abstract:
Observations have shown that the majority of massive stars, progenitors of black holes (BHs), have on average more than one stellar companion. In triple systems, wide inner binaries can be driven to a merger by the third body due to long-term secular interactions, most notably by the eccentric Lidov-Kozai effect. In this study, we explore the properties of BH mergers in triple systems and compare…
▽ More
Observations have shown that the majority of massive stars, progenitors of black holes (BHs), have on average more than one stellar companion. In triple systems, wide inner binaries can be driven to a merger by the third body due to long-term secular interactions, most notably by the eccentric Lidov-Kozai effect. In this study, we explore the properties of BH mergers in triple systems and compare their population properties to those of binaries produced in isolation and assembled in dense star clusters. Using the same stellar physics and identical assumptions for the initial populations of binaries and triples, we show that stellar triples yield a significantly flatter mass ratio distribution from $q=1$ down to $q\sim0.3$ than either binary stars or dense stellar clusters, similar to the population properties inferred from the most recent catalog of gravitational-wave events, though we do not claim that all the observed events can be accounted for with triples. While hierarchical mergers in clusters can also produce asymmetric mass ratios, the unique spins of such mergers can be used to distinguished them from those produced from stellar triples. All three channels occupy distinct regions in total mass-mass ratio space, which may allow them to be disentangled as more BH mergers are detected by LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2022; v1 submitted 4 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
White Dwarf Subsystems in Core-Collapsed Globular Clusters
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Nicholas Z. Rui,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Frederic A. Rasio,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Claire S. Ye
Abstract:
Numerical and observational evidence suggests that massive white dwarfs dominate the innermost regions of core-collapsed globular clusters by both number and total mass. Using NGC 6397 as a test case, we constrain the features of white dwarf populations in core-collapsed clusters, both at present day and throughout their lifetimes. The dynamics of these white dwarf subsystems have a number of astr…
▽ More
Numerical and observational evidence suggests that massive white dwarfs dominate the innermost regions of core-collapsed globular clusters by both number and total mass. Using NGC 6397 as a test case, we constrain the features of white dwarf populations in core-collapsed clusters, both at present day and throughout their lifetimes. The dynamics of these white dwarf subsystems have a number of astrophysical implications. We demonstrate that the collapse of globular cluster cores is ultimately halted by the dynamical burning of white dwarf binaries. We predict core-collapsed clusters in the local universe yield a white dwarf merger rate of $\mathcal{O}(10\rm{)\,Gpc}^{-3}\,\rm{yr}^{-1}$, roughly $0.1-1\%$ of the observed Type Ia supernova rate. We show that prior to merger, inspiraling white dwarf binaries will be observable as gravitational wave sources at milli- and decihertz frequencies. Over $90\%$ of these mergers have a total mass greater than the Chandrasekhar limit. If the merger/collision remnants are not destroyed completely in an explosive transient, we argue the remnants may be observed in core-collapsed clusters as either young neutron stars/pulsars/magnetars (in the event of accretion-induced collapse) or as young massive white dwarfs offset from the standard white dwarf cooling sequence. Finally, we show collisions between white dwarfs and main sequence stars, which may be detectable as bright transients, occur at a rate of $\mathcal{O}(100\rm{)\,Gpc}^{-3}\,\rm{yr}^{-1}$ in the local universe. We find that these collisions lead to depletion of blue straggler stars and main sequence star binaries in the centers of core-collapsed clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2021; v1 submitted 23 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
No Black Holes in NGC 6397
Authors:
Nicholas Z. Rui,
Newlin Weatherford,
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Frederic A. Rasio,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Claire S. Ye
Abstract:
Recently, \citet{vitral2021does} detected a central concentration of dark objects in the core-collapsed globular cluster NGC 6397, which could be interpreted as a subcluster of stellar-mass black holes. However, it is well established theoretically that any significant number of black holes in the cluster would provide strong dynamical heating and is fundamentally inconsistent with this cluster's…
▽ More
Recently, \citet{vitral2021does} detected a central concentration of dark objects in the core-collapsed globular cluster NGC 6397, which could be interpreted as a subcluster of stellar-mass black holes. However, it is well established theoretically that any significant number of black holes in the cluster would provide strong dynamical heating and is fundamentally inconsistent with this cluster's core-collapsed profile. Claims of intermediate-mass black holes in core-collapsed clusters should similarly be treated with suspicion, for reasons that have been understood theoretically for many decades. Instead, the central dark population in NGC 6397 is exactly accounted for by a compact subsystem of white dwarfs, as we demonstrate here by inspection of a previously published model that provides a good fit to this cluster. These central subclusters of heavy white dwarfs are in fact a generic feature of core-collapsed clusters, while central black hole subclusters are present in all {\em non\/}-collapsed clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Matching Globular Cluster Models to Observations
Authors:
Nicholas Z. Rui,
Kyle Kremer,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Frederic A. Rasio,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Claire S. Ye
Abstract:
As ancient, gravitationally bound stellar populations, globular clusters are abundant, vibrant laboratories characterized by high frequencies of dynamical interactions coupled to complex stellar evolution. Using surface brightness and velocity dispersion profiles from the literature, we fit $59$ Milky Way globular clusters to dynamical models from the \texttt{CMC Cluster Catalog}. Without doing an…
▽ More
As ancient, gravitationally bound stellar populations, globular clusters are abundant, vibrant laboratories characterized by high frequencies of dynamical interactions coupled to complex stellar evolution. Using surface brightness and velocity dispersion profiles from the literature, we fit $59$ Milky Way globular clusters to dynamical models from the \texttt{CMC Cluster Catalog}. Without doing any interpolation, and without any directed effort to fit any particular cluster, $26$ globular clusters are well-matched by at least one of our models. We discuss in particular the core-collapsed clusters NGC 6293, NGC 6397, NGC 6681, and NGC 6624, and the non-core-collapsed clusters NGC 288, NGC 4372, and NGC 5897. As NGC 6624 lacks well-fitting snapshots on the main \texttt{CMC Cluster Catalog}, we run six additional models in order to refine the fit. We calculate metrics for mass segregation, explore the production of compact object sources such as millisecond pulsars, cataclysmic variables, low-mass X-ray binaries, and stellar-mass black holes, finding reasonable agreement with observations. Additionally, closely mimicking observational cuts, we extract the binary fraction from our models, finding good agreement except in the dense core regions of core-collapsed clusters. Accompanying this paper are a number of \textsf{python} methods for examining the publicly accessible \texttt{CMC Cluster Catalog}, as well as any other models generated using \texttt{CMC}.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
The Observed Rate of Binary Black Hole Mergers can be Entirely Explained by Globular Clusters
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Abraham Loeb,
Frederic A. Rasio,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Claire S. Ye
Abstract:
Since the first signal in 2015, the gravitational-wave detections of merging binary black holes (BBHs) by the LIGO and Virgo collaborations (LVC) have completely transformed our understanding of the lives and deaths of compact object binaries, and have motivated an enormous amount of theoretical work on the astrophysical origin of these objects. We show that the phenomenological fit to the redshif…
▽ More
Since the first signal in 2015, the gravitational-wave detections of merging binary black holes (BBHs) by the LIGO and Virgo collaborations (LVC) have completely transformed our understanding of the lives and deaths of compact object binaries, and have motivated an enormous amount of theoretical work on the astrophysical origin of these objects. We show that the phenomenological fit to the redshift-dependent merger rate of BBHs from Abbott et al. (2020) is consistent with a purely dynamical origin for these objects, and that the current merger rate of BBHs from the LVC could be explained entirely with globular clusters alone. While this does not prove that globular clusters are the dominant formation channel, we emphasize that many formation scenarios could contribute a significant fraction of the current LVC rate, and that any analysis that assumes a single (or dominant) mechanism for producing BBH mergers is implicitly using a specious astrophysical prior.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2021; v1 submitted 20 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Black Hole Mergers from Star Clusters with Top-Heavy Initial Mass Functions
Authors:
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Giacomo Fragione,
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Claire S. Ye,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Recent observations of globular clusters (GCs) provide evidence that the stellar initial mass function (IMF) may not be universal, suggesting specifically that the IMF grows increasingly top-heavy with decreasing metallicity and increasing gas density. Non-canonical IMFs can greatly affect the evolution of GCs, mainly because the high end determines how many black holes (BHs) form. Here we compute…
▽ More
Recent observations of globular clusters (GCs) provide evidence that the stellar initial mass function (IMF) may not be universal, suggesting specifically that the IMF grows increasingly top-heavy with decreasing metallicity and increasing gas density. Non-canonical IMFs can greatly affect the evolution of GCs, mainly because the high end determines how many black holes (BHs) form. Here we compute a new set of GC models, varying the IMF within observational uncertainties. We find that GCs with top-heavy IMFs lose most of their mass within a few Gyr through stellar winds and tidal strip**. Heating of the cluster through BH mass segregation greatly enhances this process. We show that, as they approach complete dissolution, GCs with top-heavy IMFs can evolve into 'dark clusters' consisting of mostly BHs by mass. In addition to producing more BHs, GCs with top-heavy IMFs also produce many more binary BH (BBH) mergers. Even though these clusters are short-lived, mergers of ejected BBHs continue at a rate comparable to, or greater than, what is found for long-lived GCs with canonical IMFs. Therefore these clusters, although they are no longer visible today, could still contribute significantly to the local BBH merger rate detectable by LIGO/Virgo, especially for sources with higher component masses well into the BH mass gap. We also report that one of our GC models with a top-heavy IMF produces dozens of intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs) with masses $M>100\,{\rm M_\odot}$, including one with $M>500\,{\rm M_\odot}$. Ultimately, additional gravitational wave observations will provide strong constraints on the stellar IMF in old GCs and the formation of IMBHs at high redshift.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Intermediate-mass Black Holes from High Massive-star Binary Fractions in Young Star Clusters
Authors:
Elena González,
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Claire S. Ye,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Black holes formed in dense star clusters, where dynamical interactions are frequent, may have fundamentally different properties than those formed through isolated stellar evolution. Theoretical models for single star evolution predict a gap in the black hole mass spectrum from roughly $40-120\,M_{\odot}$ caused by (pulsational) pair-instability supernovae. Motivated by the recent LIGO/Virgo even…
▽ More
Black holes formed in dense star clusters, where dynamical interactions are frequent, may have fundamentally different properties than those formed through isolated stellar evolution. Theoretical models for single star evolution predict a gap in the black hole mass spectrum from roughly $40-120\,M_{\odot}$ caused by (pulsational) pair-instability supernovae. Motivated by the recent LIGO/Virgo event GW190521, we investigate whether black holes with masses within or in excess of this "upper-mass gap" can be formed dynamically in young star clusters through strong interactions of massive stars in binaries. We perform a set of $N$-body simulations using the CMC cluster-dynamics code to study the effects of the high-mass binary fraction on the formation and collision histories of the most massive stars and their remnants. We find that typical young star clusters with low metallicities and high binary fractions in massive stars can form several black holes in the upper-mass gap and often form at least one intermediate-mass black hole. These results provide strong evidence that dynamical interactions in young star clusters naturally lead to the formation of more massive black hole remnants.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2021; v1 submitted 18 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Probing multiple populations of compact binaries with third-generation gravitational-wave detectors
Authors:
Ken K. Y. Ng,
Salvatore Vitale,
Will M. Farr,
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
Third-generation (3G) gravitational-wave (GW) detectors will be able to observe binary-black-hole mergers (BBHs) up to redshift of $\sim 30$. This gives unprecedented access to the formation and evolution of BBHs throughout cosmic history. In this paper we consider three sub-populations of BBHs originating from the different evolutionary channels: isolated formation in galactic fields, dynamical f…
▽ More
Third-generation (3G) gravitational-wave (GW) detectors will be able to observe binary-black-hole mergers (BBHs) up to redshift of $\sim 30$. This gives unprecedented access to the formation and evolution of BBHs throughout cosmic history. In this paper we consider three sub-populations of BBHs originating from the different evolutionary channels: isolated formation in galactic fields, dynamical formation in globular clusters and mergers of black holes formed from Population III (Pop III) stars at very high redshift. Using input from populations synthesis analyses, we created two months of simulated data of a network of 3G detectors made of two Cosmic Explorers and an Einstein Telescope, consisting of $\sim16000$ field and cluster BBHs as well as $\sim400$ Pop III BBHs. First, we show how one can use non-parametric models to infer the existence and characteristic of a primary and secondary peak in the merger rate distribution. In particular, the location and the height of the secondary peak around $z\approx 12$, arising from the merger of Pop III remnants, can be constrained at $\mathcal{O}(10\%)$ level. Then we perform a modeled analysis, using phenomenological templates for the merger rates of the three sub-population, and extract the branching ratios and the characteristic parameters of the merger rate densities of the individual formation channels. With this modeled method, the uncertainty on the measurement of the fraction of Pop III BBHs can be improved to $\lesssim 10\%$, while the ratio between field and cluster BBHs can be measured with an uncertainty of $\sim 50\%$.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2021; v1 submitted 17 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Dynamical Formation Scenarios for GW190521 and Prospects for Decihertz Gravitational-Wave Astronomy with GW190521-Like Binaries
Authors:
A. Miguel Holgado,
Alexis Ortega,
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
The gravitational-wave (GW) detection of GW190521 has provided new insights on the mass distribution of black holes and new constraints for astrophysical formation channels. With independent claims of GW190521 having significant pre-merger eccentricity, we investigate what this implies for GW190521-like binaries that form dynamically. The Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) will also be sens…
▽ More
The gravitational-wave (GW) detection of GW190521 has provided new insights on the mass distribution of black holes and new constraints for astrophysical formation channels. With independent claims of GW190521 having significant pre-merger eccentricity, we investigate what this implies for GW190521-like binaries that form dynamically. The Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) will also be sensitive to GW190521-like binaries if they are circular from an isolated formation channel. We show, however, that GW190521-like binaries that form dynamically may skip the LISA band entirely. To this end, we simulate GW190521 analogues that dynamically form via post-Newtonian binary-single scattering. From these scattering experiments, we find that GW190521-like binaries may enter the LIGO-Virgo band with significant eccentricity as suggested by recent studies, though well below an eccentricity of $e_{\rm 10Hz} \lesssim 0.7$. Eccentric GW190521-like binaries further motivate the astrophysical science case for a decihertz GW observatory, such as the kilometer-scale version of the Midband Atomic Gravitational-wave Interferometric Sensor (MAGIS). Pre-merger observations of GW190521-like binaries with such a decihertz GW detector would be able to constrain the eccentricity of GW190521-like binaries to greater precision than with just LIGO-Virgo alone. These eccentricity constraints would also provide additional insights into the possible environments that GW190521-like binaries form in.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2021; v1 submitted 16 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Fast Multipole Methods for $N$-body Simulations of Collisional Star Systems
Authors:
Diptajyoti Mukherjee,
Qirong Zhu,
Hy Trac,
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
Direct $N$-body simulations of star clusters are accurate but expensive, largely due to the numerous $\mathcal{O} (N^2)$ pairwise force calculations. To solve the post-million-body problem, it will be necessary to use approximate force solvers, such as tree codes. In this work, we adapt a tree-based, optimized Fast Multipole Method (FMM) to the collisional $N$-body problem. The use of a rotation-a…
▽ More
Direct $N$-body simulations of star clusters are accurate but expensive, largely due to the numerous $\mathcal{O} (N^2)$ pairwise force calculations. To solve the post-million-body problem, it will be necessary to use approximate force solvers, such as tree codes. In this work, we adapt a tree-based, optimized Fast Multipole Method (FMM) to the collisional $N$-body problem. The use of a rotation-accelerated translation operator and an error-controlled cell opening criterion leads to a code that can be tuned to arbitrary accuracy. We demonstrate that our code, Taichi, can be as accurate as direct summation when $N> 10^4$. This opens up the possibility of performing large-$N$, star-by-star simulations of massive stellar clusters, and would permit large parameter space studies that would require years with the current generation of direct summation codes. Using a series of tests and idealized models, we show that Taichi can accurately model collisional effects, such as dynamical friction and the core-collapse time of idealized clusters, producing results in strong agreement with benchmarks from other collisional codes such as NBODY6++GPU or PeTar. Parallelized using OpenMP and AVX, Taichi is demonstrated to be more efficient than other CPU-based direct $N$-body codes for simulating large systems. With future improvements to the handling of close encounters and binary evolution, we clearly demonstrate the potential of an optimized FMM for the modeling of collisional stellar systems, opening the door to accurate simulations of massive globular clusters, super star clusters, and even galactic nuclei.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2021; v1 submitted 3 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
One Channel to Rule Them All? Constraining the Origins of Binary Black Holes using Multiple Formation Pathways
Authors:
Michael Zevin,
Simone S. Bavera,
Christopher P. L. Berry,
Vicky Kalogera,
Tassos Fragos,
Pablo Marchant,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Fabio Antonini,
Daniel E. Holz,
Chris Pankow
Abstract:
The second LIGO-Virgo catalog of gravitational wave transients has more than quadrupled the observational sample of binary black holes. We analyze this catalog using a suite of five state-of-the-art binary black hole population models covering a range of isolated and dynamical formation channels and infer branching fractions between channels as well as constraints on uncertain physical processes t…
▽ More
The second LIGO-Virgo catalog of gravitational wave transients has more than quadrupled the observational sample of binary black holes. We analyze this catalog using a suite of five state-of-the-art binary black hole population models covering a range of isolated and dynamical formation channels and infer branching fractions between channels as well as constraints on uncertain physical processes that impact the observational properties of mergers. Given our set of formation models, we find significant differences between the branching fractions of the underlying and detectable populations, and that the diversity of detections suggests that multiple formation channels are at play. A mixture of channels is strongly preferred over any single channel dominating the detected population: an individual channel does not contribute to more than $\simeq 70\%$ of the observational sample of binary black holes. We calculate the preference between the natal spin assumptions and common envelope efficiencies in our models, favoring natal spins of isolated black holes of $\lesssim 0.1$, and marginally preferring common envelope efficiencies of $\gtrsim 2.0$ while strongly disfavoring highly inefficient common envelopes. We show that it is essential to consider multiple channels when interpreting gravitational wave catalogs, as inference on branching fractions and physical prescriptions becomes biased when contributing formation scenarios are not considered or incorrect physical prescriptions are assumed. Although our quantitative results can be affected by uncertain assumptions in model predictions, our methodology is capable of including models with updated theoretical considerations and additional formation channels.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2021; v1 submitted 19 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Black Hole Mergers from Hierarchical Triples in Dense Star Clusters
Authors:
Miguel A. S. Martinez,
Giacomo Fragione,
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Johan Samsing,
Claire S. Ye,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Michael Zevin,
Smadar Naoz,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Hierarchical triples are expected to be produced by the frequent binary-mediated interactions in the cores of globular clusters. In some of these triples, the tertiary companion can drive the inner binary to merger following large eccentricity oscillations, as a result of the eccentric Kozai-Lidov mechanism. In this paper, we study the dynamics and merger rates of black hole (BH) hierarchical trip…
▽ More
Hierarchical triples are expected to be produced by the frequent binary-mediated interactions in the cores of globular clusters. In some of these triples, the tertiary companion can drive the inner binary to merger following large eccentricity oscillations, as a result of the eccentric Kozai-Lidov mechanism. In this paper, we study the dynamics and merger rates of black hole (BH) hierarchical triples, formed via binary--binary encounters in the CMC Cluster Catalog, a suite of cluster simulations with present-day properties representative of the Milky Way's globular clusters. We compare the properties of the mergers from triples to the other merger channels in dense star clusters, and show that triple systems do not produce significant differences in terms of mass and effective spin distribution. However, they represent an important pathway for forming eccentric mergers, which could be detected by LIGO--Virgo/KAGRA (LVK), and future missions such as LISA and DECIGO. We derive a conservative lower limit for the merger rate from this channel of $0.35$ Gpc$^{-3}$yr$^{-1}$ in the local Universe and up to $\sim9\%$ of these events may have a detectable eccentricity at LVK design sensitivity. Additionally, we find that triple systems could play an important role in retaining second-generation BHs, which can later merge again in the core of the host cluster.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2020; v1 submitted 17 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Demographics of triple systems in dense star clusters
Authors:
Giacomo Fragione,
Miguel A. S. Martinez,
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Claire S. Ye,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Smadar Naoz,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Depending on the stellar type, more than $\sim 50$\% and $\sim 15\%$ of stars in the field have at least one and two stellar companions, respectively. Hierarchical systems can be assembled dynamically in dense star clusters, as a result of few-body encounters among stars and/or compact remnants in the cluster core. In this paper, we present the demographics of stellar and compact-object triples fo…
▽ More
Depending on the stellar type, more than $\sim 50$\% and $\sim 15\%$ of stars in the field have at least one and two stellar companions, respectively. Hierarchical systems can be assembled dynamically in dense star clusters, as a result of few-body encounters among stars and/or compact remnants in the cluster core. In this paper, we present the demographics of stellar and compact-object triples formed via binary--binary encounters in the \texttt{CMC Cluster Catalog}, a suite of cluster simulations with present-day properties representative of the globular clusters (GCs) observed in the Milky Way. We show how the initial properties of the host cluster set the typical orbital parameters and formation times of the formed triples. We find that a cluster typically assembles hundreds of triples with at least one black hole (BH) in the inner binary, while only clusters with sufficiently small virial radii are efficient in producing triples with no BHs, as a result of the BH-burning process. We show that a typical GC is expected to host tens of triples with at least one luminous component at present day. We discuss how the Lidov-Kozai mechanism can drive the inner binary of the formed triples to high eccentricities, whenever it takes place before the triple is dynamically reprocessed by encountering another cluster member. Some of these systems can reach sufficiently large eccentricities to form a variety of transients and sources, such as blue stragglers, X-ray binaries, Type Ia Supernovae, Thorne-Zytkow objects, and LIGO/Virgo sources.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Populating the upper black hole mass gap through stellar collisions in young star clusters
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Mario Spera,
Devin Becker,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Ugo N. Di Carlo,
Giacomo Fragione,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Claire S. Ye,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Theoretical modeling of massive stars predicts a gap in the black hole (BH) mass function above $\sim 40-50\,M_{\odot}$ for BHs formed through single star evolution, arising from (pulsational) pair-instability supernovae. However, in dense star clusters, dynamical channels may exist that allow construction of BHs with masses in excess of those allowed from single star evolution. The detection of B…
▽ More
Theoretical modeling of massive stars predicts a gap in the black hole (BH) mass function above $\sim 40-50\,M_{\odot}$ for BHs formed through single star evolution, arising from (pulsational) pair-instability supernovae. However, in dense star clusters, dynamical channels may exist that allow construction of BHs with masses in excess of those allowed from single star evolution. The detection of BHs in this so-called "upper-mass gap" would provide strong evidence for the dynamical processing of BHs prior to their eventual merger. Here, we explore in detail the formation of BHs with masses within or above the pair-instability gap through collisions of young massive stars in dense star clusters. We run a suite of 68 independent cluster simulations, exploring a variety of physical assumptions pertaining to growth through stellar collisions, including primordial cluster mass segregation and the efficiency of envelope strip** during collisions. We find that as many as $\sim20\%$ of all BH progenitors undergo one or more collisions prior to stellar collapse and up to $\sim1\%$ of all BHs reside within or above the pair-instability gap through the effects of these collisions. We show that these BHs readily go on to merge with other BHs in the cluster, creating a population of massive BH mergers at a rate that may compete with the "multiple-generation" merger channel described in other analyses. This has clear relevance for the formation of very massive BH binaries as recently detected by LIGO/Virgo in GW190521. Finally, we describe how stellar collisions in clusters may provide a unique pathway to pair-instability supernovae and briefly discuss the expected rate of these events and other electromagnetic transients.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2020; v1 submitted 18 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
GW190412 as a Third-Generation Black Hole Merger from a Super Star Cluster
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Kyle Kremer,
Michael Y. Grudić,
Zachary Hafen,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Astrid Lamberts,
Miguel A. S. Martinez,
Frederic A. Rasio,
Newlin Weatherford,
Claire S. Ye
Abstract:
We explore the possibility that GW190412, a binary black hole merger with a non-equal-mass ratio and significantly spinning primary, was formed through repeated black hole mergers in a dense super star cluster. Using a combination of semi-analytic prescriptions for the remnant spin and recoil kick of black hole mergers, we show that the mass ratio and spin of GW190412 are consistent with a binary…
▽ More
We explore the possibility that GW190412, a binary black hole merger with a non-equal-mass ratio and significantly spinning primary, was formed through repeated black hole mergers in a dense super star cluster. Using a combination of semi-analytic prescriptions for the remnant spin and recoil kick of black hole mergers, we show that the mass ratio and spin of GW190412 are consistent with a binary black hole whose primary component has undergone two successive mergers from a population of $\sim 10M_{\odot}$ black holes in a high-metallicity environment. We then explore the production of GW190412-like analogs in the CMC Cluster Catalog, a grid of 148 $N$-body star cluster models, as well as a new model, behemoth, with nearly $10^7$ particles and initial conditions taken from a cosmological MHD simulation of galaxy formation. We show that the production of binaries with GW190412-like masses and spins is dominated by massive super star clusters with high metallicities and large central escape speeds. While many are observed in the local universe, our results suggest that a careful treatment of these massive clusters, many of which may have been disrupted before the present day, is necessary to characterize the production of unique gravitational-wave events produced through dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2020; v1 submitted 8 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Relativistic three-body effects in hierarchical triples
Authors:
Halston Lim,
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
The hierarchical three-body problem has many applications in relativistic astrophysics, and can play an important role in the formation of the binary black hole mergers detected by LIGO/Virgo. However, many studies have only included relativistic corrections responsible for the precession of pericenter of the inner and outer binaries, neglecting relativistic interactions between the three bodies.…
▽ More
The hierarchical three-body problem has many applications in relativistic astrophysics, and can play an important role in the formation of the binary black hole mergers detected by LIGO/Virgo. However, many studies have only included relativistic corrections responsible for the precession of pericenter of the inner and outer binaries, neglecting relativistic interactions between the three bodies. We revisit this problem and develop a fully consistent derivation of the secular three-body problem to first post-Newtonian order. We start with the Einstein-Infeld-Hoffman equations for a three-body system and expand the accelerations as a power series in the ratio of the semi-major axes of the inner ($a_1$) and outer ($a_2$) binary. We then perform a post-Keplerian, two-parameter expansion of the single-orbit-averaged Lagrange planetary equations in $δ= v^2/c^2$ and $ε= a_1/a_2$ using the method of multiple scales. Using this method, we derive previously-indentified secular effects at $δε^{5/2}$ order that arise directly from the equations of motion. We also calculate new secular effects through $δε^4$ order that can lead to eccentricity growth over many Lidov-Kozai cycles when the tertiary is much more massive than the inner binary. In such cases, inclusion of these effects can substantially alter the evolution of three-body systems as compared to an analysis in which they are neglected. Careful analysis of post-Newtonian three-body effects will be important to understand the formation and properties of coalescing binaries that form via three-body dynamical processes.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2020; v1 submitted 10 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
COSMIC Variance in Binary Population Synthesis
Authors:
Katelyn Breivik,
Scott Coughlin,
Michael Zevin,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Kyle Kremer,
Claire S. Ye,
Jeff J. Andrews,
Michael Kurkowski,
Matthew C. Digman,
Shane L. Larson,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
The formation and evolution of binary stars is a critical component of several fields in astronomy. The most numerous sources for gravitational wave observatories are inspiraling and/or merging compact binaries, while binary stars are present in nearly every electromagnetic survey regardless of the target population. Simulations of large binary populations serve to both predict and inform observat…
▽ More
The formation and evolution of binary stars is a critical component of several fields in astronomy. The most numerous sources for gravitational wave observatories are inspiraling and/or merging compact binaries, while binary stars are present in nearly every electromagnetic survey regardless of the target population. Simulations of large binary populations serve to both predict and inform observations of electromagnetic and gravitational wave sources. Binary population synthesis is a tool that balances physical modeling with simulation speed to produce large binary populations on timescales of days. We present a community-developed binary population synthesis suite: COSMIC which is designed to simulate compact-object binary populations and their progenitors. As a proof of concept, we simulate the Galactic population of compact binaries and their gravitational wave signal observable by the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). We find that $\sim10^8$ compact binaries reside in the Milky Way today, while $\sim10^4$ of them may be resolvable by LISA.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020; v1 submitted 3 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Modeling Dense Star Clusters in the Milky Way and Beyond with the $\texttt{CMC}$ Cluster Catalog
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Claire S. Ye,
Nicholas Z. Rui,
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Mario Spera,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
We present a set of 148 independent $N$-body simulations of globular clusters (GCs) computed using the code $\texttt{CMC}$ ($\texttt{Cluster Monte Carlo}$). At an age of $\sim10-13\,$Gyr, the resulting models cover nearly the full range of cluster properties exhibited by the Milky Way GCs, including total mass, core and half-light radii, metallicity, and galactocentric distance. We use our models…
▽ More
We present a set of 148 independent $N$-body simulations of globular clusters (GCs) computed using the code $\texttt{CMC}$ ($\texttt{Cluster Monte Carlo}$). At an age of $\sim10-13\,$Gyr, the resulting models cover nearly the full range of cluster properties exhibited by the Milky Way GCs, including total mass, core and half-light radii, metallicity, and galactocentric distance. We use our models to investigate the role that stellar-mass black holes play in the process of core collapse. Furthermore, we study how dynamical interactions affect the formation and evolution of several important types of sources in GCs, including low-mass X-ray binaries, millisecond pulsars, blue stragglers, cataclysmic variables, Type Ia supernovae, calcium-rich transients, and merging compact binaries. While our focus here is on old, low-metallicity GCs, our $\texttt{CMC}$ simulations follow the evolution of clusters over a Hubble time, and they include a wide range of metallicities (up to solar), so that our results can also be used to study younger and higher-metallicity star clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2020; v1 submitted 31 October, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
On the Rate of Neutron Star Binary Mergers from Globular Clusters
Authors:
Claire S. Ye,
Wen-fai Fong,
Kyle Kremer,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Giacomo Fragione,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
The first detection of gravitational waves from a neutron star - neutron star (NS-NS) merger, GW170817, and the increasing number of observations of short gamma-ray bursts (SGRBs) have greatly motivated studies of the origins of NS-NS and neutron star - black hole (NS-BH) binaries. We calculate the merger rates of NS-NS and NS-BH binaries from globular clusters (GCs) using realistic GC simulations…
▽ More
The first detection of gravitational waves from a neutron star - neutron star (NS-NS) merger, GW170817, and the increasing number of observations of short gamma-ray bursts (SGRBs) have greatly motivated studies of the origins of NS-NS and neutron star - black hole (NS-BH) binaries. We calculate the merger rates of NS-NS and NS-BH binaries from globular clusters (GCs) using realistic GC simulations with the \texttt{CMC} cluster catalog. We use a large sample of models with a range of initial numbers of stars, metallicities, virial radii and galactocentric distances, representative of the present-day Milky Way GCs, to quantify the inspiral times and volumetric merger rates as a function of redshift, both inside and ejected from clusters. We find that over the complete lifetime of most GCs, stellar BHs dominate the cluster cores and prevent the mass segregation of NSs, thereby reducing the dynamical interaction rates of NSs so that at most a few NS binary mergers are ever produced. We estimate the merger rate in the local universe to be $\sim\rm{0.02\,Gpc^{-3}\,yr^{-1}}$ for both NS-NS and NS-BH binaries, or a total of $\sim 0.04$~Gpc$^{-3}$~yr$^{-1}$ for both populations. These rates are about 5 orders of magnitude below the current empirical merger rate from LIGO/Virgo. We conclude that dynamical interactions in GCs do not play a significant role in enhancing the NS-NS and NS-BH merger rates.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2019; v1 submitted 23 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
The Role of "Black Hole Burning" in the Evolution of Dense Star Clusters
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Claire S. Ye,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
As self-gravitating systems, dense star clusters exhibit a natural diffusion of energy from their innermost to outermost regions, which leads to a slow and steady contraction of the core until it ultimately collapses under gravity. However, in spite of the natural tendency toward so-called "core collapse," the globular clusters (GCs) in the Milky Way exhibit a well-observed bimodal distribution in…
▽ More
As self-gravitating systems, dense star clusters exhibit a natural diffusion of energy from their innermost to outermost regions, which leads to a slow and steady contraction of the core until it ultimately collapses under gravity. However, in spite of the natural tendency toward so-called "core collapse," the globular clusters (GCs) in the Milky Way exhibit a well-observed bimodal distribution in core radii separating the core-collapsed and non-core-collapsed clusters. This suggests an internal energy source is at work, delaying the onset of core collapse in many clusters. Primordial binary stars have been thought for a long time to provide this energy source, but recent analyses have cast doubt upon the corresponding "binary-burning" mechanism as a viable explanation. Over the past decade, a large amount of both observational and theoretical work has suggested that many stellar-mass black holes (BHs) are retained in typical clusters today and that they play a dynamically-significant role in these clusters throughout their entire lifetimes. Here we review our latest understanding of the formation and evolution of BH populations in GCs and demonstrate that, through their dynamical interaction with their host cluster, BHs can naturally explain the distinction between core-collapsed and non-core-collapsed clusters through a process we call "black hole burning."
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Single-single gravitational-wave captures in globular clusters: Eccentric deci-Hertz sources observable by DECIGO and Tian-Qin
Authors:
Johan Samsing,
Daniel J. D'Orazio,
Kyle Kremer,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Abbas Askar
Abstract:
We study the formation rate of binary black hole mergers formed through gravitational-wave emission between unbound, single black holes in globular clusters. While the formation of these binaries in very dense systems such as galactic nuclei has been well studied, we show here that this process can operate in lower-density stellar systems as well, forming binaries at a rate similar to other propos…
▽ More
We study the formation rate of binary black hole mergers formed through gravitational-wave emission between unbound, single black holes in globular clusters. While the formation of these binaries in very dense systems such as galactic nuclei has been well studied, we show here that this process can operate in lower-density stellar systems as well, forming binaries at a rate similar to other proposed pathways for creating eccentric mergers. Recent advances in post-Newtonian cluster dynamics indicate that a large fraction of dynamically-assembled binary black holes merge inside their host clusters during weak and strong binary-single and binary-binary interactions, and that these systems may retain measurable eccentricities as they travel through the LIGO and LISA sensitivity bands. Using an analytic approach to modeling binary black holes from globular clusters, we show that the formation of merging binaries from previously unbound black holes can operate at a similar rate to mergers forming during strong binary encounters, and that these binaries inhabit a unique region of the gravitational-wave frequency space which can be identified by proposed deci-Hertz space-based detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2020; v1 submitted 25 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Black Holes: The Next Generation -- Repeated Mergers in Dense Star Clusters and their Gravitational-Wave Properties
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Michael Zevin,
Pau Amaro-Seoane,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Kyle Kremer,
Frederic A. Rasio,
Claire S. Ye
Abstract:
When two black holes merge in a dense star cluster, they form a new black hole with a well-defined mass and spin. If that "second-generation" black hole remains in the cluster, it will continue to participate in dynamical encounters, form binaries, and potentially merge again. Using a grid of 96 dynamical models of dense star clusters and a cosmological model of cluster formation, we explore the p…
▽ More
When two black holes merge in a dense star cluster, they form a new black hole with a well-defined mass and spin. If that "second-generation" black hole remains in the cluster, it will continue to participate in dynamical encounters, form binaries, and potentially merge again. Using a grid of 96 dynamical models of dense star clusters and a cosmological model of cluster formation, we explore the production of binary black hole mergers where at least one component of the binary was forged in a previous merger. We create four hypothetical universes where every black hole born in the collapse of a massive star has a dimensionless Kerr spin parameter, $χ_{\rm birth}$, of 0.0, 0.1, 0.2, or 0.5. We show that if all stellar-born black holes are non-spinning ($χ_{\rm birth} = 0.0$), then more than 10% of merging binary black holes from clusters have components formed from previous mergers, accounting for more than 20% of the mergers from globular clusters detectable by LIGO/Virgo. Furthermore, nearly 7% of detectable mergers would have a component with a mass $\gtrsim 55M_{\odot}$, placing them clearly in the mass "gap" region where black holes cannot form from isolated collapsing stars due to the pulsational-pair instability mechanism. On the other hand, if black holes are born spinning, then the contribution from these second-generation mergers decreases, making up as little as 1% of all detections from globular clusters when $χ_{\rm birth} = 0.5$. We make quantitative predictions for the detected masses, mass ratios, and spin properties of first- and second-generation mergers from dense star clusters, and show how these distributions are highly sensitive to the birth spins of black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2019; v1 submitted 24 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Tidal Disruptions of Stars by Black Hole Remnants in Dense Star Clusters
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Wenbin Lu,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Mitchell Lachat,
Frederic Rasio
Abstract:
In a dense stellar environment, such as the core of a globular cluster (GC), dynamical interactions with black holes (BHs) are expected to lead to a variety of astrophysical transients. Here we explore tidal disruption events (TDEs) of stars by stellar-mass BHs through collisions and close encounters. Using state-of-the-art $N$-body simulations, we show that these TDEs occur at significant rates t…
▽ More
In a dense stellar environment, such as the core of a globular cluster (GC), dynamical interactions with black holes (BHs) are expected to lead to a variety of astrophysical transients. Here we explore tidal disruption events (TDEs) of stars by stellar-mass BHs through collisions and close encounters. Using state-of-the-art $N$-body simulations, we show that these TDEs occur at significant rates throughout the evolution of typical GCs and we study how their relative rates relate to cluster parameters such mass and size. By incorporating a realistic cosmological model of GC formation, we predict a BH - main-sequence-star TDE rate of approximately $3\,\rm{Gpc}^{-3}\,\rm{yr}^{-1}$ in the local universe ($z<0.1$) and a cosmological rate that peaks at roughly $25\,\rm{Gpc}^{-3}\,\rm{yr}^{-1}$ for redshift 3. Furthermore, we show that the ejected mass associated with these TDEs could produce optical transients of luminosity $\sim 10^{41} - 10^{44}\rm\,erg\,s^{-1}$ with timescales of about a day to a month. These should be readily detectable by optical transient surveys such as the Zwicky Transient Facility. Finally, we comment briefly on BH - giant encounters and discuss how these events may contribute to the formation of BH - white-dwarf binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2019; v1 submitted 12 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Gravity and Light: Combining Gravitational Wave and Electromagnetic Observations in the 2020s
Authors:
R. J. Foley,
K. D. Alexander,
I. Andreoni,
I. Arcavi,
K. Auchettl,
J. Barnes,
G. Baym,
E. C. Bellm,
A. M. Beloborodov,
N. Blagorodnova,
J. P. Blakeslee,
P. R. Brady,
M. Branchesi,
J. S. Brown,
N. Butler,
M. Cantiello,
R. Chornock,
D. O. Cook,
J. Cooke,
D. L. Coppejans,
A. Corsi,
S. M. Couch,
M. W. Coughlin,
D. A. Coulter,
P. S. Cowperthwaite
, et al. (88 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
As of today, we have directly detected exactly one source in both gravitational waves (GWs) and electromagnetic (EM) radiation, the binary neutron star merger GW170817, its associated gamma-ray burst GRB170817A, and the subsequent kilonova SSS17a/AT 2017gfo. Within ten years, we will detect hundreds of events, including new classes of events such as neutron-star-black-hole mergers, core-collapse s…
▽ More
As of today, we have directly detected exactly one source in both gravitational waves (GWs) and electromagnetic (EM) radiation, the binary neutron star merger GW170817, its associated gamma-ray burst GRB170817A, and the subsequent kilonova SSS17a/AT 2017gfo. Within ten years, we will detect hundreds of events, including new classes of events such as neutron-star-black-hole mergers, core-collapse supernovae, and almost certainly something completely unexpected. As we build this sample, we will explore exotic astrophysical topics ranging from nucleosynthesis, stellar evolution, general relativity, high-energy astrophysics, nuclear matter, to cosmology. The discovery potential is extraordinary, and investments in this area will yield major scientific breakthroughs. Here we outline some of the most exciting scientific questions that can be answered by combining GW and EM observations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
The Fate of Binaries in the Galactic Center: The Mundane and the Exotic
Authors:
Alexander P. Stephan,
Smadar Naoz,
Andrea M. Ghez,
Mark R. Morris,
Anna Ciurlo,
Tuan Do,
Katelyn Breivik,
Scott Coughlin,
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
The Galactic Center (GC) is dominated by the gravity of a super-massive black hole (SMBH), Sagittarius A$^*$, and is suspected to contain a sizable population of binary stars. Such binaries form hierarchical triples with the SMBH, undergoing Eccentric Kozai-Lidov (EKL) evolution, which can lead to high eccentricity excitations for the binary companions' mutual orbit. This effect can lead to stella…
▽ More
The Galactic Center (GC) is dominated by the gravity of a super-massive black hole (SMBH), Sagittarius A$^*$, and is suspected to contain a sizable population of binary stars. Such binaries form hierarchical triples with the SMBH, undergoing Eccentric Kozai-Lidov (EKL) evolution, which can lead to high eccentricity excitations for the binary companions' mutual orbit. This effect can lead to stellar collisions or Roche-lobe crossings, as well as orbital shrinking due to tidal dissipation. In this work we investigate the dynamical and stellar evolution of such binary systems, especially with regards to the binaries' post-main-sequence evolution. We find that the majority of binaries (~75%) is eventually separated into single stars, while the remaining binaries (~25%) undergo phases of common-envelope evolution and/or stellar mergers. These objects can produce a number of different exotic outcomes, including rejuvenated stars, G2-like infrared-excess objects, stripped giant stars, Type Ia supernovae (SNe), cataclysmic variables (CVs), symbiotic binaries (SBs), or compact object binaries. We estimate that, within a sphere of 250 Mpc radius, about 7.5 to 15 Type Ia SNe per year should occur in galactic nuclei due to this mechanism, potentially detectable by ZTF and ASAS-SN. Likewise we estimate that, within a sphere of 1 Gpc$^3$ volume, about 10 to 20 compact object binaries form per year that could become gravitational wave sources. Based on results of EKL-driven compact object binary mergers in galactic nuclei by Hoang at al. (2018), this compact object binary formation rate translates to about 15 to 30 events per year detectable by Advanced LIGO.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2019; v1 submitted 28 February, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Millisecond Pulsars and Black Holes in Globular Clusters
Authors:
Claire S. Ye,
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Over a hundred millisecond radio pulsars (MSPs) have been observed in globular clusters (GCs), motivating theoretical studies of the formation and evolution of these sources through stellar evolution coupled to stellar dynamics. Here we study MSPs in GCs using realistic $N$-body simulations with our Cluster Monte Carlo code. We show that neutron stars (NSs) formed in electron-capture supernovae (i…
▽ More
Over a hundred millisecond radio pulsars (MSPs) have been observed in globular clusters (GCs), motivating theoretical studies of the formation and evolution of these sources through stellar evolution coupled to stellar dynamics. Here we study MSPs in GCs using realistic $N$-body simulations with our Cluster Monte Carlo code. We show that neutron stars (NSs) formed in electron-capture supernovae (including both accretion-induced and merger-induced collapse of white dwarfs) can be spun up through mass transfer to form MSPs. Both NS formation and spin-up through accretion are greatly enhanced through dynamical interaction processes. We find that our models for average GCs at the present day with masses $\approx 2 \times 10^5\,M_\odot$ can produce up to $10-20$ MSPs, while a very massive GC model with mass $\approx 10^6\,M_\odot$ can produce close to $100$. We show that the number of MSPs is anti-correlated with the total number of stellar-mass black holes (BHs) retained in the host cluster. The radial distributions are also affected: MSPs are more concentrated towards the center in a host cluster with a smaller number of retained BHs. As a result, the number of MSPs in a GC could be used to place constraints on its BH population. Some intrinsic properties of MSP systems in our models (such as the magnetic fields and spin periods) are in good overall agreement with observations, while others (such as the distribution of binary companion types) less so, and we discuss the possible reasons for such discrepancies. Interestingly, our models also demonstrate the possibility of dynamically forming NS--NS and NS--BH binaries in GCs, although the predicted numbers are very small.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2019; v1 submitted 15 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Post-Newtonian Dynamics in Dense Star Clusters: Binary Black Holes in the LISA Band
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Pau Amaro-Seoane,
Katelyn Breivik,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Michael L. Katz,
Shane L. Larson,
Frederic A. Rasio,
Johan Samsing,
Claire S. Ye,
Michael Zevin
Abstract:
The dynamical processing of black holes in the dense cores of globular clusters (GCs), makes them efficient factories for producing binary black holes (BBHs). Here we explore the population of BBHs that form dynamically in GCs and may be observable at mHz frequencies or higher with LISA. We use our Monte Carlo stellar dynamics code, which includes gravitational radiation reaction effects for all B…
▽ More
The dynamical processing of black holes in the dense cores of globular clusters (GCs), makes them efficient factories for producing binary black holes (BBHs). Here we explore the population of BBHs that form dynamically in GCs and may be observable at mHz frequencies or higher with LISA. We use our Monte Carlo stellar dynamics code, which includes gravitational radiation reaction effects for all BH encounters. By creating a representative local universe of GCs, we show that up to dozens of these systems may be resolvable by LISA with signal-to-noise ratios of at least 5. Approximately one third of these binaries will have measurable eccentricities ($e > 10^{-3}$) in the LISA band and a small number ($\lesssim 5$) may evolve from the LISA band to the LIGO band during the LISA mission.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2019; v1 submitted 28 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Post-Newtonian Dynamics in Dense Star Clusters: Formation, Masses, and Merger Rates of Highly-Eccentric Black Hole Binaries
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Pau Amaro-Seoane,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Kyle Kremer,
Frederic A. Rasio,
Johan Samsing,
Claire S. Ye,
Michael Zevin
Abstract:
Using state-of-the-art dynamical simulations of globular clusters, including radiation reaction during black hole encounters and a cosmological model of star cluster formation, we create a realistic population of dynamically-formed binary black hole mergers across cosmic space and time. We show that in the local universe, 10% of these binaries form as the result of gravitational-wave emission betw…
▽ More
Using state-of-the-art dynamical simulations of globular clusters, including radiation reaction during black hole encounters and a cosmological model of star cluster formation, we create a realistic population of dynamically-formed binary black hole mergers across cosmic space and time. We show that in the local universe, 10% of these binaries form as the result of gravitational-wave emission between unbound black holes during chaotic resonant encounters, with roughly half of those events having eccentricities detectable by current ground-based gravitational-wave detectors. The mergers that occur inside clusters typically have lower masses than binaries that were ejected from the cluster many Gyrs ago. Gravitational-wave captures from globular clusters contribute 1-2 Gpc^-3 yr^-1 to the binary merger rate in the local universe, increasing to ~10 Gpc^-3 yr^-1 at z~3. Finally, we discuss some of the technical difficulties associated with post-Newtonian scattering encounters, and how care must be taken when measuring the binary parameters during a dynamical capture.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2018; v1 submitted 12 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Redshift Evolution of the Black Hole Merger Rate from Globular Clusters
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Abraham Loeb
Abstract:
As the sensitivity of current and future gravitational-wave detectors improves, it will become possible to measure the evolution of the binary black hole merger rate with redshift. Here, we combine detailed fits to state-of-the-art dynamical models of binary black hole formation in dense star clusters with a cosmological model of cluster formation across cosmic time. We find a typical merger rate…
▽ More
As the sensitivity of current and future gravitational-wave detectors improves, it will become possible to measure the evolution of the binary black hole merger rate with redshift. Here, we combine detailed fits to state-of-the-art dynamical models of binary black hole formation in dense star clusters with a cosmological model of cluster formation across cosmic time. We find a typical merger rate of 14 $\rm{Gpc}^{-3} \rm{yr}^{-1}$ in the local universe, with a reasonable range of 4-18 $\rm{Gpc}^{-3} \rm{yr}^{-1}$, depending on the rate of cluster disruption and the cluster initial mass function. This rate increases by a factor of 6 to redshift $z=2.7$ before declining at higher redshifts. We compare the merger rate from binaries produced in clusters to similar estimates from isolated binaries and triples in galactic fields, and discuss various ways that these different formation channels could add up to the current merger rate observed by LIGO/Virgo.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2018; v1 submitted 4 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
How initial size governs core collapse in globular clusters
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Claire S. Ye,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Globular clusters (GCs) in the Milky Way exhibit a well-observed bimodal distribution in core radii separating the so-called "core-collapsed" and "non-core-collapsed" clusters. Here, we use our Hénon-type Monte Carlo code, CMC, to explore initial cluster parameters that map into this bimodality. Remarkably, we find that by varying the initial size of clusters (specified in our initial conditions i…
▽ More
Globular clusters (GCs) in the Milky Way exhibit a well-observed bimodal distribution in core radii separating the so-called "core-collapsed" and "non-core-collapsed" clusters. Here, we use our Hénon-type Monte Carlo code, CMC, to explore initial cluster parameters that map into this bimodality. Remarkably, we find that by varying the initial size of clusters (specified in our initial conditions in terms of the initial virial radius, $r_v$) within a relatively narrow range consistent with the measured radii of young star clusters in the local universe ($r_v \approx 0.5-5$ pc), our models reproduce the variety of present-day cluster properties. Furthermore, we show that stellar-mass black holes (BHs) play an intimate role in this map** from initial conditions to the present-day structural features of GCs. We identify "best-fit" models for three GCs with known observed BH candidates, NGC 3201, M22, and M10, and show that these clusters harbor populations of $\sim 50-100$ stellar-mass BHs at present. As an alternative case, we also compare our models to the core-collapsed cluster NGC 6752 and show that this cluster likely contains few BHs at present. Additionally, we explore the formation of BH binaries in GCs and demonstrate that these systems form naturally in our models in both detached and mass-transferring configurations with a variety of companion stellar types, including low-mass main sequence stars, white dwarfs, and sub-subgiants.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2018; v1 submitted 7 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Measuring the star formation rate with gravitational waves from binary black holes
Authors:
Salvatore Vitale,
Will M. Farr,
Ken Ng,
Carl L. Rodriguez
Abstract:
A measurement of the history of cosmic star formation is central to understand the origin and evolution of galaxies. The measurement is extremely challenging using electromagnetic radiation: significant modeling is required to convert luminosity to mass, and to properly account for dust attenuation, for example. Here we show how detections of gravitational waves from inspiraling binary black holes…
▽ More
A measurement of the history of cosmic star formation is central to understand the origin and evolution of galaxies. The measurement is extremely challenging using electromagnetic radiation: significant modeling is required to convert luminosity to mass, and to properly account for dust attenuation, for example. Here we show how detections of gravitational waves from inspiraling binary black holes made by proposed third-generation detectors can be used to measure the star formation rate (SFR) of massive stars with high precision up to redshifts of ~10. Depending on the time-delay model, the predicted detection rates ranges from ~2310 to ~56,740 per month with the current measurement of local merger rate density. With 30,000 detections, parameters describing the volumetric SFR can be constrained at the few percent level, and the volumetric merger rate can be directly measured to 3% at z ~ 2. Given a parameterized SFR, the characteristic delay time between binary formation and merger can be measured to ~60%.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2021; v1 submitted 1 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
A Triple Origin for the Heavy and Low-Spin Binary Black Holes Detected by LIGO/Virgo
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Fabio Antonini
Abstract:
We explore the masses, merger rates, eccentricities, and spins for field binary black holes driven to merger by a third companion through the Lidov-Kozai mechanism. Using a population synthesis approach, we model the creation of stellar-mass black hole triples across a range of different initial conditions and stellar metallicities. We find that the production of triple-mediated mergers is enhance…
▽ More
We explore the masses, merger rates, eccentricities, and spins for field binary black holes driven to merger by a third companion through the Lidov-Kozai mechanism. Using a population synthesis approach, we model the creation of stellar-mass black hole triples across a range of different initial conditions and stellar metallicities. We find that the production of triple-mediated mergers is enhanced at low metallicities by a factor of ~100 due to the lower black hole natal kicks and reduced stellar mass loss. These triples naturally yield heavy binary black holes with near-zero effective spins, consistent with most of the mergers observed to date. This process produces a merger rate of between 2 and 25 Gpc^-3 yr^-1 in the local universe, suggesting that the Lidov-Kozai mechanism can potentially explain all of the low-spin, heavy black hole mergers observed by Advanced LIGO/Virgo. Finally, we show that triples admit a unique eccentricity and spin distribution that will allow this model to be tested in the near future.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2018; v1 submitted 21 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
How black holes shape globular clusters: Modeling NGC 3201
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Claire S. Ye,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Numerical simulations have shown that black holes (BHs) can strongly influence the evolution and present-day observational properties of globular clusters (GCs). Using a Monte Carlo code, we construct GC models that match the Milky Way (MW) cluster NGC 3201, the first cluster in which a stellar-mass BH was identified through radial-velocity measurements. We predict that NGC 3201 contains…
▽ More
Numerical simulations have shown that black holes (BHs) can strongly influence the evolution and present-day observational properties of globular clusters (GCs). Using a Monte Carlo code, we construct GC models that match the Milky Way (MW) cluster NGC 3201, the first cluster in which a stellar-mass BH was identified through radial-velocity measurements. We predict that NGC 3201 contains $\gtrsim 200$ stellar-mass BHs. Furthermore, we explore the dynamical formation of main sequence-BH binaries and demonstrate that systems similar to the observed BH binary in NGC 3201 are produced naturally. Additionally, our models predict the existence of bright blue-straggler-BH binaries unique to core-collapsed clusters, which otherwise retain few BHs.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
LISA sources in Milky Way globular clusters
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Katelyn Breivik,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Shane L. Larson,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
We explore the formation of double-compact-object binaries in Milky Way (MW) globular clusters (GCs) that may be detectable by the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). We use a set of 137 fully evolved GC models that, overall, effectively match the properties of the observed GCs in the MW. We estimate that, in total, the MW GCs contain $\sim21$ sources that will be detectable by LISA. These…
▽ More
We explore the formation of double-compact-object binaries in Milky Way (MW) globular clusters (GCs) that may be detectable by the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). We use a set of 137 fully evolved GC models that, overall, effectively match the properties of the observed GCs in the MW. We estimate that, in total, the MW GCs contain $\sim21$ sources that will be detectable by LISA. These detectable sources contain all combinations of black hole (BH), neutron star, and white dwarf components. We predict $\sim7$ of these sources will be BH-BH binaries. Furthermore, we show that some of these BH-BH binaries can have signal-to-noise ratios large enough to be detectable at the distance of the Andromeda galaxy or even the Virgo cluster.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2018; v1 submitted 15 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Low-mass X-ray binaries ejected from globular clusters
Authors:
Kyle Kremer,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
We explore the population of mass-transferring binaries ejected from globular clusters (GCs) with both black hole (BH) and neutron star (NS) accretors. We use a set of 137 fully evolved globular cluster models which span a large range in cluster properties and, overall, match very well the properties of old GCs observed in the Milky Way. We identify all binaries ejected from our set of models that…
▽ More
We explore the population of mass-transferring binaries ejected from globular clusters (GCs) with both black hole (BH) and neutron star (NS) accretors. We use a set of 137 fully evolved globular cluster models which span a large range in cluster properties and, overall, match very well the properties of old GCs observed in the Milky Way. We identify all binaries ejected from our set of models that eventually undergo mass-transfer. These binaries are ejected from their host clusters over a wide range of ejection times and include white dwarf, giant, and main sequence donors. We calculate the orbits of these ejected systems in the Galactic potential to determine their present-day positions in the Galaxy and compare to the distribution of observed low-mass X-ray binaries (XRBs) in the Milky Way. We estimate $\sim 300$ mass-transferring NS binaries and $\sim 180$ mass-transferring BH binaries may currently be present in the Milky Way that originated from within GCs. Of these, we estimate, based on mass-transfer rates and duty cycles at the present time, at most a few would be observable as BH--XRBs and NS--XRBs at the present day. Based on our results, XRBs that originated from GCs are unlikely to contribute significantly to the total population of low-mass XRBs in the Galactic field.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Post-Newtonian Dynamics in Dense Star Clusters: Highly-Eccentric, Highly-Spinning, and Repeated Binary Black Hole Mergers
Authors:
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Pau Amaro-Seoane,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
We present models of realistic globular clusters with post-Newtonian dynamics for black holes. By modeling the relativistic accelerations and gravitational-wave emission in isolated binaries and during three- and four-body encounters, we find that nearly half of all binary black hole mergers occur inside the cluster, with about 10% of those mergers entering the LIGO/Virgo band with eccentricities…
▽ More
We present models of realistic globular clusters with post-Newtonian dynamics for black holes. By modeling the relativistic accelerations and gravitational-wave emission in isolated binaries and during three- and four-body encounters, we find that nearly half of all binary black hole mergers occur inside the cluster, with about 10% of those mergers entering the LIGO/Virgo band with eccentricities greater than 0.1. In-cluster mergers lead to the birth of a second generation of black holes with larger masses and high spins, which, depending on the black hole natal spins, can sometimes be retained in the cluster and merge again. As a result, globular clusters can produce merging binaries with detectable spins regardless of the birth spins of black holes formed from massive stars. These second-generation black holes would also populate any upper mass gap created by pair-instability supernovae.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2018; v1 submitted 13 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Predicting Stellar-Mass Black Hole Populations in Globular Clusters
Authors:
Newlin C. Weatherford,
Sourav Chatterjee,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Frederic A. Rasio
Abstract:
Recent discoveries of black hole (BH) candidates in Galactic and extragalactic globular clusters (GCs) have ignited interest in understanding how BHs dynamically evolve in a GC and the number of BHs ($N_{\rm{BH}}$) that may still be retained by today's GCs. Numerical models show that even if stellar-mass BHs are retained in today's GCs, they are typically in configurations that are not directly de…
▽ More
Recent discoveries of black hole (BH) candidates in Galactic and extragalactic globular clusters (GCs) have ignited interest in understanding how BHs dynamically evolve in a GC and the number of BHs ($N_{\rm{BH}}$) that may still be retained by today's GCs. Numerical models show that even if stellar-mass BHs are retained in today's GCs, they are typically in configurations that are not directly detectable. We show that a suitably defined measure of mass segregation ($Δ$) between, e.g., giants and low-mass main-sequence stars, can be an effective probe to indirectly estimate $N_{\rm{BH}}$ in a GC aided by calibrations from numerical models. Using numerical models including all relevant physics we first show that $N_{\rm{BH}}$ is strongly anticorrelated with $Δ$ between giant stars and low-mass main-sequence stars. We apply the distributions of $Δ$ vs $N_{\rm{BH}}$ obtained from models to three Milky Way GCs to predict the $N_{\rm{BH}}$ retained by them at present. We calculate $Δ$ using the publicly available ACS survey data for 47 Tuc, M 10, and M 22, all with identified stellar-mass BH candidates. Using these measured $Δ$ and distributions of $Δ$ vs $N_{\rm{BH}}$ from models as calibration we predict distributions for $N_{\rm{BH}}$ expected to be retained in these GCs. For 47 Tuc, M 10, and M 22 our predicted distributions peak at $N_{\rm{BH}}\approx20$, $24$, and $50$, whereas, within the $2σ$ confidence level, $N_{\rm{BH}}$ can be up to $\sim150$, $50$, and $200$, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2018; v1 submitted 11 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Precessional dynamics of black hole triples: binary mergers with near-zero effective spin
Authors:
Fabio Antonini,
Carl L. Rodriguez,
Cristobal Petrovich,
Caitlin L. Fischer
Abstract:
The binary black hole mergers detected by Advanced LIGO/Virgo have shown no evidence of large black hole spins. However, because LIGO/Virgo best measures the effective combination of the two spins along the orbital angular momentum ($χ_{\rm eff}$), it is difficult to distinguish between binaries with slowly-spinning black holes and binaries with spins lying in the orbital plane. Here, we study the…
▽ More
The binary black hole mergers detected by Advanced LIGO/Virgo have shown no evidence of large black hole spins. However, because LIGO/Virgo best measures the effective combination of the two spins along the orbital angular momentum ($χ_{\rm eff}$), it is difficult to distinguish between binaries with slowly-spinning black holes and binaries with spins lying in the orbital plane. Here, we study the spin dynamics for binaries with a distant black hole companion. For spins initially aligned with the orbital angular momentum of the binary, we find that $χ_{\rm eff}$ "freezes" near zero as the orbit decays through the emission of gravitational waves. Through a population study, we show that this process predominantly leads to merging black hole binaries with near-zero $χ_{\rm eff}$. We conclude that if the detected black hole binaries were formed in triples, then this would explain their low $χ_{\rm eff}$ without the need to invoke near-zero spins or initially large spin-orbit angles.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2018; v1 submitted 19 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.