-
Messengers: Breaking Echo Chambers in Collective Opinion Dynamics with Homophily
Authors:
Mohsen Raoufi,
Heiko Hamann,
Pawel Romanczuk
Abstract:
Collective estimation manifests computational intelligence emerging from inter-individual local interactions, e.g., by aggregating opinions from neighbors to estimate a quantity. Use cases of collective estimation may include directed motion in physical space, such that agents, for example, have to collectively explore a distributed feature, and collectively agree on a numerical value. In doing so…
▽ More
Collective estimation manifests computational intelligence emerging from inter-individual local interactions, e.g., by aggregating opinions from neighbors to estimate a quantity. Use cases of collective estimation may include directed motion in physical space, such that agents, for example, have to collectively explore a distributed feature, and collectively agree on a numerical value. In doing so, collectives face several challenges in achieving precise estimations. These challenges exhibit complex behaviors, particularly when the interaction network and opinion of agents evolve simultaneously. We take homophilic networks as an example, where disproportionate interaction with like-minded neighbors leads to the emergence of echo chambers, preventing collective consensus. Our simulation results confirm that, besides a lack of exposure to attitude-challenging opinions, seeking reaffirming information entraps agents in echo chambers. We propose a generic novel approach based on a Dichotomous Markov Process (DMP) where stubborn agents (called Messengers) connect the disconnected clusters by physically transporting their opinions to other clusters to inform and direct the other agents. We show that diverse collective behaviors arise from the DMP and study a continuum between task specialization with no switching (full-time Messengers), generalization with slow task switching (part-time Messengers), and rapid task switching (short-time Messengers) and its impact on system performance. Our results show that stubborn agents can, in various ways, break the echo chambers and promote consensus in collective opinion.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Leveraging Uncertainty in Collective Opinion Dynamics with Heterogeneity
Authors:
Vito Mengers,
Mohsen Raoufi,
Oliver Brock,
Heiko Hamann,
Pawel Romanczuk
Abstract:
Natural and artificial collectives exhibit heterogeneities across different dimensions, contributing to the complexity of their behavior. We investigate the effect of two such heterogeneities on collective opinion dynamics: heterogeneity of the quality of agents' prior information and of centrality in the network, i.e., the number of immediate neighbors. To study these heterogeneities, we not only…
▽ More
Natural and artificial collectives exhibit heterogeneities across different dimensions, contributing to the complexity of their behavior. We investigate the effect of two such heterogeneities on collective opinion dynamics: heterogeneity of the quality of agents' prior information and of centrality in the network, i.e., the number of immediate neighbors. To study these heterogeneities, we not only consider them in our model, proposing a novel network generator with heterogeneous centrality, but also introduce uncertainty as an additional dimension. By quantifying the uncertainty of each agent, we provide a mechanism for agents to adaptively weigh their individual against social information. As uncertainties develop according to the interactions between agents, they capture information on heterogeneities. Therefore, uncertainty is a relevant additional observable in the study of complex collective opinion dynamics that we use to show the bidirectional relationship of heterogeneous centrality and information. Furthermore, we demonstrate that uncertainty-driven adaptive weighting leads to increased accuracy and speed of consensus, especially under heterogeneity, and provide guidelines for avoiding performance-decreasing errors in uncertainty modeling. These opportunities for improved performance and observability suggest the importance of uncertainty both for the study of natural and the design of artificial heterogeneous systems.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Individuality in Swarm Robots with the Case Study of Kilobots: Noise, Bug, or Feature?
Authors:
Mohsen Raoufi,
Pawel Romanczuk,
Heiko Hamann
Abstract:
Inter-individual differences are studied in natural systems, such as fish, bees, and humans, as they contribute to the complexity of both individual and collective behaviors. However, individuality in artificial systems, such as robotic swarms, is undervalued or even overlooked. Agent-specific deviations from the norm in swarm robotics are usually understood as mere noise that can be minimized, fo…
▽ More
Inter-individual differences are studied in natural systems, such as fish, bees, and humans, as they contribute to the complexity of both individual and collective behaviors. However, individuality in artificial systems, such as robotic swarms, is undervalued or even overlooked. Agent-specific deviations from the norm in swarm robotics are usually understood as mere noise that can be minimized, for example, by calibration. We observe that robots have consistent deviations and argue that awareness and knowledge of these can be exploited to serve a task. We measure heterogeneity in robot swarms caused by individual differences in how robots act, sense, and oscillate. Our use case is Kilobots and we provide example behaviors where the performance of robots varies depending on individual differences. We show a non-intuitive example of phototaxis with Kilobots where the non-calibrated Kilobots show better performance than the calibrated supposedly ``ideal" one. We measure the inter-individual variations for heterogeneity in sensing and oscillation, too. We briefly discuss how these variations can enhance the complexity of collective behaviors. We suggest that by recognizing and exploring this new perspective on individuality, and hence diversity, in robotic swarms, we can gain a deeper understanding of these systems and potentially unlock new possibilities for their design and implementation of applications.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Estimation of continuous environments by robot swarms: Correlated networks and decision-making
Authors:
Mohsen Raoufi,
Pawel Romanczuk,
Heiko Hamann
Abstract:
Collective decision-making is an essential capability of large-scale multi-robot systems to establish autonomy on the swarm level. A large portion of literature on collective decision-making in swarm robotics focuses on discrete decisions selecting from a limited number of options. Here we assign a decentralized robot system with the task of exploring an unbounded environment, finding consensus on…
▽ More
Collective decision-making is an essential capability of large-scale multi-robot systems to establish autonomy on the swarm level. A large portion of literature on collective decision-making in swarm robotics focuses on discrete decisions selecting from a limited number of options. Here we assign a decentralized robot system with the task of exploring an unbounded environment, finding consensus on the mean of a measurable environmental feature, and aggregating at areas where that value is measured (e.g., a contour line). A unique quality of this task is a causal loop between the robots' dynamic network topology and their decision-making. For example, the network's mean node degree influences time to convergence while the currently agreed-on mean value influences the swarm's aggregation location, hence, also the network structure as well as the precision error. We propose a control algorithm and study it in real-world robot swarm experiments in different environments. We show that our approach is effective and achieves higher precision than a control experiment. We anticipate applications, for example, in containing pollution with surface vehicles.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2023; v1 submitted 27 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Speed-vs-Accuracy Tradeoff in Collective Estimation: An Adaptive Exploration-Exploitation Case
Authors:
Mohsen Raoufi,
Heiko Hamann,
Pawel Romanczuk
Abstract:
The tradeoff between accuracy and speed is considered fundamental to individual and collective decision-making. In this paper, we focus on collective estimation as an example of collective decision-making. The task is to estimate the average scalar intensity of a desired feature in the environment. The solution we propose consists of exploration and exploitation phases, where the switching time is…
▽ More
The tradeoff between accuracy and speed is considered fundamental to individual and collective decision-making. In this paper, we focus on collective estimation as an example of collective decision-making. The task is to estimate the average scalar intensity of a desired feature in the environment. The solution we propose consists of exploration and exploitation phases, where the switching time is a factor dictating the balance between the two phases. By decomposing the total accuracy into bias and variance, we explain that diversity and social interactions could promote the accuracy of the collective decision. We also show how the exploration-vs-exploitation tradeoff relates to the speed-vs-accuracy tradeoff. One significant finding of our work is that there is an optimal duration for exploration to compromise between speed and accuracy. This duration cannot be determined offline for an unknown environment. Hence, we propose an adaptive, distributed mechanism enabling individual agents to decide in a decentralized manner when to switch. Moreover, the spatial consequence of the exploitation phase is an emergent collective movement, leading to the aggregation of the collective at the iso-contours of the mean intensity of the environmental field in the spatial domain. Examples of potential applications for such a fully distributed collective estimation model are spillage capturing and source localization.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Cooperative Pollution Source Localization and Cleanup with a Bio-inspired Swarm Robot Aggregation
Authors:
Arash S. Amjadi,
Mohsen Raoufi,
Ali E. Turgut,
George Broughton,
Tomáš Krajník,
Farshad Arvin
Abstract:
Using robots for exploration of extreme and hazardous environments has the potential to significantly improve human safety. For example, robotic solutions can be deployed to find the source of a chemical leakage and clean the contaminated area. This paper demonstrates a proof-of-concept bio-inspired exploration method using a swarm robotic system, which is based on a combination of two bio-inspire…
▽ More
Using robots for exploration of extreme and hazardous environments has the potential to significantly improve human safety. For example, robotic solutions can be deployed to find the source of a chemical leakage and clean the contaminated area. This paper demonstrates a proof-of-concept bio-inspired exploration method using a swarm robotic system, which is based on a combination of two bio-inspired behaviours: aggregation, and pheromone tracking. The main idea of the work presented is to follow pheromone trails to find the source of a chemical leakage and then carry out a decontamination task by aggregating at the critical zone. Using experiments conducted by a simulated model of a Mona robot, we evaluate the effects of population size and robot speed on the ability of the swarm in a decontamination task. The results indicate the feasibility of deploying robotic swarms in an exploration and cleaning task in an extreme environment.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Self-organized Collective Motion with a Simulated Real Robot Swarm
Authors:
Mohsen Raoufi,
Ali Emre Turgut,
Farshad Arvin
Abstract:
Collective motion is one of the most fascinating phenomena observed in the nature. In the last decade, it aroused so much attention in physics, control and robotics fields. In particular, many studies have been done in swarm robotics related to collective motion, also called flocking. In most of these studies, robots use orientation and proximity of their neighbors to achieve collective motion. In…
▽ More
Collective motion is one of the most fascinating phenomena observed in the nature. In the last decade, it aroused so much attention in physics, control and robotics fields. In particular, many studies have been done in swarm robotics related to collective motion, also called flocking. In most of these studies, robots use orientation and proximity of their neighbors to achieve collective motion. In such an approach, one of the biggest problems is to measure orientation information using on-board sensors. In most of the studies, this information is either simulated or implemented using communication. In this paper, to the best of our knowledge, we implemented a fully autonomous coordinated motion without alignment using very simple Mona robots. We used an approach based on Active Elastic Sheet (AES) method. We modified the method and added the capability to enable the swarm to move toward a desired direction and rotate about an arbitrary point. The parameters of the modified method are optimized using TCACS optimization algorithm. We tested our approach in different settings using Matlab and Webots.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
