Faculty survey on upper-division thermal physics content coverage
Authors:
Katherine D. Rainey,
Bethany R. Wilcox
Abstract:
Thermal physics is a core course requirement for most physics degrees and encompasses both thermodynamics and statistical mechanics content. However, the primary content foci of thermal physics courses vary across universities. This variation can make creation of materials or assessment tools for thermal physics difficult. To determine the scope and content variability of thermal physics courses a…
▽ More
Thermal physics is a core course requirement for most physics degrees and encompasses both thermodynamics and statistical mechanics content. However, the primary content foci of thermal physics courses vary across universities. This variation can make creation of materials or assessment tools for thermal physics difficult. To determine the scope and content variability of thermal physics courses across institutions, we distributed a survey to over 140 institutions to determine content priorities from faculty and instructors who have taught upper-division thermodynamics and/or statistical mechanics. We present results from the survey, which highlight key similarities and differences in thermal physics content coverage across institutions. Though we see variations in content coverage, we found 9 key topical areas covered by all respondents in their upper-division thermal physics courses. We discuss implications of these findings for the development of instructional tools and assessments that are useful to the widest range of institutions and physics instructors.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
Characterizing Inter-Layer Functional Map**s of Deep Learning Models
Authors:
Donald Waagen,
Katie Rainey,
Jamie Gantert,
David Gray,
Megan King,
M. Shane Thompson,
Jonathan Barton,
Will Waldron,
Samantha Livingston,
Don Hulsey
Abstract:
Deep learning architectures have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance for object classification and have become ubiquitous in commercial products. These methods are often applied without understanding (a) the difficulty of a classification task given the input data, and (b) how a specific deep learning architecture transforms that data. To answer (a) and (b), we illustrate the utility of a mu…
▽ More
Deep learning architectures have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance for object classification and have become ubiquitous in commercial products. These methods are often applied without understanding (a) the difficulty of a classification task given the input data, and (b) how a specific deep learning architecture transforms that data. To answer (a) and (b), we illustrate the utility of a multivariate nonparametric estimator of class separation, the Henze-Penrose (HP) statistic, in the original as well as layer-induced representations. Given an $N$-class problem, our contribution defines the $C(N,2)$ combinations of HP statistics as a sample from a distribution of class-pair separations. This allows us to characterize the distributional change to class separation induced at each layer of the model. Fisher permutation tests are used to detect statistically significant changes within a model. By comparing the HP statistic distributions between layers, one can statistically characterize: layer adaptation during training, the contribution of each layer to the classification task, and the presence or absence of consistency between training and validation data. This is demonstrated for a simple deep neural network using CIFAR10 with random-labels, CIFAR10, and MNIST datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2019; v1 submitted 9 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
