Showing 1–50 of 194 results for author: Raidal, M

Interpreting DESI 2024 BAO: late-time dynamical dark energy or a local effect?

Authors: Ioannis D. Gialamas, Gert Hütsi, Kristjan Kannike, Antonio Racioppi, Martti Raidal, Martin Vasar, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We perform fits to DESI, CMB and supernova data to understand the physical origin of the DESI hint for dynamical dark energy. We find that the linear parametrization of the equation of state $w$ may guide to misleading interpretations, such as the hint for a phantom Universe, which are not preferred by the data. Instead, physical quintessence models fit the data well. Model-independently, present… ▽ More We perform fits to DESI, CMB and supernova data to understand the physical origin of the DESI hint for dynamical dark energy. We find that the linear parametrization of the equation of state $w$ may guide to misleading interpretations, such as the hint for a phantom Universe, which are not preferred by the data. Instead, physical quintessence models fit the data well. Model-independently, present observations prefer deviations from the constant dark energy, $w=-1$, only at very low redshifts, $z < \mathcal{O}(0.1)$. We find that this result is driven by low-$z$ supernova data. Therefore, either the fundamental properties of our Universe, characterised by the equation of state $w$ and the Hubble parameter $H$, underwent dramatic changes very recently or, alternatively, we do not fully understand the systematics of our local Universe in a radius of about $300\,h^{-1}\rm Mpc$. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 9 pages, 5 figures

Formation of primordial black hole binaries and their merger rates

Authors: Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We review the theory behind the formation of primordial black hole binaries and their merger rates. We consider the binary formation in the early and late Universe, emphasising the former as it gives the dominant contribution of the present primordial black hole merger rate. The binaries formed in the early Universe are highly eccentric and get easily disrupted by interactions with other primordia… ▽ More We review the theory behind the formation of primordial black hole binaries and their merger rates. We consider the binary formation in the early and late Universe, emphasising the former as it gives the dominant contribution of the present primordial black hole merger rate. The binaries formed in the early Universe are highly eccentric and get easily disrupted by interactions with other primordial black holes. We discuss in detail how the suppression of the merger rate arising from such interactions can be estimated and how such interactions lead to the formation of another, much harder, binary population that contributes to the present merger rate if more than 10% of dark matter consists of primordial black holes with a narrow mass distribution. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 32 pages, 8 figures, To appear (with updates) in the book "Primordial Black Holes", ed. Chris Byrnes, Gabriele Franciolini, Tomohiro Harada, Paolo Pani, Misao Sasaki; Springer (2024)

Probing sterile neutrino freeze-in at stronger coupling

Authors: Niko Koivunen, Oleg Lebedev, Martti Raidal

Abstract: The regime of dark matter (DM) freeze-in at stronger coupling interpolates between freeze-in and freeze-out. It relies on Boltzmann-suppressed dark matter production, implying that the Standard Model bath temperature never exceeds the dark matter mass. In this work, we study this regime in the context of sterile neutrino dark matter, which can be sufficiently long-lived for a tiny sterile-active m… ▽ More The regime of dark matter (DM) freeze-in at stronger coupling interpolates between freeze-in and freeze-out. It relies on Boltzmann-suppressed dark matter production, implying that the Standard Model bath temperature never exceeds the dark matter mass. In this work, we study this regime in the context of sterile neutrino dark matter, which can be sufficiently long-lived for a tiny sterile-active mixing. The sterile neutrino is assumed to couple to a real singlet scalar, providing for a thermal production mechanism of the former. We find that DM mass can range from GeV to tens of TeV consistently with all the constraints. The most interesting aspect of the consequent freeze-in phenomenology is that the sterile neutrino dark matter can be probed efficiently by both direct detection experiments and invisible Higgs decay at the LHC. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2024; v1 submitted 22 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures, formulas corrected

Explaining the $B^+\to K^+ ν\barν$ excess via a massless dark photon

Authors: E. Gabrielli, L. Marzola, K. Müürsepp, M. Raidal

Abstract: The Belle II collaboration has recently observed the rare decay $B^+\to K^+ ν\barν$, finding an excess with respect to the Standard Model prediction. We explore the possibility that the data entails long-distance interactions induced by a massless dark photon, $γ_{\scriptscriptstyle{D}}$. This couples at the tree-level to an invisible, dark sector and to the Standard Model via higher-dimensional o… ▽ More The Belle II collaboration has recently observed the rare decay $B^+\to K^+ ν\barν$, finding an excess with respect to the Standard Model prediction. We explore the possibility that the data entails long-distance interactions induced by a massless dark photon, $γ_{\scriptscriptstyle{D}}$. This couples at the tree-level to an invisible, dark sector and to the Standard Model via higher-dimensional operators, such as the chromomagnetic-dipole coupling that we use to explain the excess. As the process $B^+\to K^+ γ_{\scriptscriptstyle{D}}$ is forbidden by angular momentum conservation, the transition mediated by the off-shell dark photon yields a three-body final state comprising a pair of dark fermions that show as a missing energy continuum in the detector, faking the neutrino signature. We show that the Belle II data is explained for perturbative values of the parameters of the model. This scenario predicts new contributions to the neutral $B$ meson decays $B^0\to K^* γ_{\scriptscriptstyle{D}}$, in which the emission of a on-shell dark photon is allowed, yielding a monochromatic missing energy signature. Analogously, an excess due to the emission of a dark photon is predicted for the $B^0_s\to φ+ E_{\rm miss}$ decay that could be scrutinized next at the LHCb experiments. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 17 pages, 3 figures

What is the source of the PTA GW signal?

Authors: John Ellis, Malcolm Fairbairn, Gabriele Franciolini, Gert Hütsi, Antonio Iovino Jr., Marek Lewicki, Martti Raidal, Juan Urrutia, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: The most conservative interpretation of the nHz stochastic gravitational wave background (SGWB) discovered by NANOGrav and other Pulsar Timing Array (PTA) Collaborations is astrophysical, namely that it originates from supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries. However, alternative cosmological models have been proposed, including cosmic strings, phase transitions, domain walls, primordial fluctuati… ▽ More The most conservative interpretation of the nHz stochastic gravitational wave background (SGWB) discovered by NANOGrav and other Pulsar Timing Array (PTA) Collaborations is astrophysical, namely that it originates from supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries. However, alternative cosmological models have been proposed, including cosmic strings, phase transitions, domain walls, primordial fluctuations and "audible" axions. We perform a multi-model analysis (MMA) to compare how well these different hypotheses fit the NANOGrav data, both in isolation and in combination with SMBH binaries, and address the questions: Which interpretations fit the data best, and which are disfavoured? We also discuss experimental signatures that can help discriminate between different sources of the PTA GW signal, including fluctuations in the signal strength between frequency bins, individual sources and how the PTA signal extends to higher frequencies. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2023; v1 submitted 16 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: 15 pages, 17 figures, 1 table

Report number: KCL-PH-TH/2023-43, CERN-TH-2023-153, AION-REPORT/2023-08

Production and decays of 146 GeV flavons into $eμ$ final state at the LHC

Authors: Niko Koivunen, Martti Raidal

Abstract: The CMS experiment at CERN has reported a possible signal for a resonance at 146 GeV decaying into the $eμ$ final state which, presently, is the only experimental hint for lepton flavour violation in any low- and high-energy experiment. The Froggatt-Nielsen mechanism naturally predicts the existence of new scalars, the flavons, with flavour off-diagonal couplings. We study this framework in the co… ▽ More The CMS experiment at CERN has reported a possible signal for a resonance at 146 GeV decaying into the $eμ$ final state which, presently, is the only experimental hint for lepton flavour violation in any low- and high-energy experiment. The Froggatt-Nielsen mechanism naturally predicts the existence of new scalars, the flavons, with flavour off-diagonal couplings. We study this framework in the context of the CMS result and find that the minimal, purely leptophilic model is too restricted to match the claimed signal. Thereafter we show how models with additional flavon couplings to quarks can explain the claimed signal while satisfying all the existing constraints on lepton flavour violation. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 16 pages, 5 figures

Prospects for Future Binary Black Hole GW Studies in Light of PTA Measurements

Authors: John Ellis, Malcolm Fairbairn, Gert Hütsi, Martti Raidal, Juan Urrutia, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: NANOGrav and other Pulsar Timing Arrays (PTAs) have discovered a common-spectrum process in the nHz range that may be due to gravitational waves (GWs): if so, they are likely to have been generated by black hole (BH) binaries with total masses $> 10^9 M_{\odot}$. Using the Extended Press-Schechter formalism to model the galactic halo mass function and a simple relation between the halo and BH mass… ▽ More NANOGrav and other Pulsar Timing Arrays (PTAs) have discovered a common-spectrum process in the nHz range that may be due to gravitational waves (GWs): if so, they are likely to have been generated by black hole (BH) binaries with total masses $> 10^9 M_{\odot}$. Using the Extended Press-Schechter formalism to model the galactic halo mass function and a simple relation between the halo and BH masses suggests that these binaries have redshifts $z = {O}(1)$ and mass ratios $\gtrsim 10$, and that the GW signal at frequencies above ${O}(10)$~nHz may be dominated by relatively few binaries that could be distinguished experimentally and would yield observable circular polarization. Extrapolating the model to higher frequencies indicates that future GW detectors such as LISA and AEDGE could extend the PTA observations to lower BH masses $\in (10^6, 10^9 ) M_{\odot}$ and $\in (10^3, 10^9) M_{\odot}$. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2023; v1 submitted 31 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: Minor updates, accepted for publication in A&A

Report number: KCL-PH-TH/2023-04, CERN-TH-2023-008, AION-REPORT/2023-1

Journal ref: A&A 676, A38 (2023)

Non-supersymmetric SO(10) models with Gauge and Yukawa coupling unification

Authors: Abdelhak Djouadi, Renato Fonseca, Ruiwen Ouyang, Martti Raidal

Abstract: We study a non-supersymmetric SO(10) Grand Unification Theory with a very high energy intermediate symmetry breaking scale in which not only gauge but also Yukawa coupling unification are enforced via suitable threshold corrections and matching conditions. For gauge unification, we focus on a few symmetry breaking patterns with the intermediate gauge groups… ▽ More We study a non-supersymmetric SO(10) Grand Unification Theory with a very high energy intermediate symmetry breaking scale in which not only gauge but also Yukawa coupling unification are enforced via suitable threshold corrections and matching conditions. For gauge unification, we focus on a few symmetry breaking patterns with the intermediate gauge groups ${\rm SU(4)_C \times SU(2)_L \times SU(2)_R}$ (Pati-Salam) and ${\rm SU(3)_C \times SU(2)_L \times SU(2)_R\times U(1)_{B-L}}$ (minimal left-right symmetry) assuming an additional global U(1) Peccei--Quinn symmetry, and having the Standard Model supplemented by a second Higgs doublet field at the electroweak scale. We derive the conditions as well as the approximate analytical solutions for the unification of the gauge coupling constants at the two-loop level and discuss the constraints from proton decay on the resulting high scale. Specializing to the case of the Pati-Salam intermediate breaking pattern, we then impose also the unification of the Yukawa couplings of third generation fermions at the high scale, again at the two-loop level. In the considered context, Yukawa unification implies a relation between the fermion couplings to the 10- and 126-dimensional scalar representations of the SO(10) group. We consider one such possible relation which is obtainable in an ${\rm E_6}$ model where the previous two scalar fields are part of a single multiplet. Taking into account some phenomenological features such as the absence of flavor changing neutral currents at tree-level, we derive constraints on the parameters of the low energy model, in particular on the ratio of the two Higgs doublets vacuum expectation values $\tanβ$. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2023; v1 submitted 21 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: 40 pages, 7 figures, Fig. 7 added compared to v1, comments are welcome

Did JWST observe imprints of axion miniclusters or primordial black holes?

Authors: Gert Hütsi, Martti Raidal, Juan Urrutia, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: The James Webb Space Telescope has detected surprisingly luminous early galaxies that indicate a tension with the $Λ$CDM. Motivated by scenarios including axion miniclusters or primordial black holes, we consider power-law modifications of the matter power spectrum. We show that the tension could be resolved if dark matter consists of $2\times 10^{-18}{\rm eV}$ axions or if a fraction… ▽ More The James Webb Space Telescope has detected surprisingly luminous early galaxies that indicate a tension with the $Λ$CDM. Motivated by scenarios including axion miniclusters or primordial black holes, we consider power-law modifications of the matter power spectrum. We show that the tension could be resolved if dark matter consists of $2\times 10^{-18}{\rm eV}$ axions or if a fraction $f_{\rm PBH} > 0.005$ of dark matter is composed of compact heavy $4\times 10^6 M_\odot (f_{\rm PBH}/0.005)^{-1}$ structures such as primordial black hole clusters. However, in both cases, the star formation efficiency needs to be significantly enhanced. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2023; v1 submitted 4 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: published version with added references

Dark Matter-Induced Multi-Phase Dynamical Symmetry Breaking

Authors: Kristjan Kannike, Niko Koivunen, Aleksei Kubarski, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal, Alessandro Strumia, Venno Vipp

Abstract: We consider the classically scale invariant Higgs-dilaton model of dynamical symmetry breaking extended with an extra scalar field that plays the role of dark matter. The Higgs boson is light near a critical boundary between different symmetry breaking phases, where quantum corrections beyond the usual Gildener-Weinberg approximation become relevant. This implies a tighter connection between dark… ▽ More We consider the classically scale invariant Higgs-dilaton model of dynamical symmetry breaking extended with an extra scalar field that plays the role of dark matter. The Higgs boson is light near a critical boundary between different symmetry breaking phases, where quantum corrections beyond the usual Gildener-Weinberg approximation become relevant. This implies a tighter connection between dark matter and Higgs phenomenology. The model has only three free parameters, yet it allows for the observed relic abundance of dark matter while respecting all constraints. The direct detection cross section mediated by the Higgs boson is determined by the dark matter mass alone and is testable at future experiments. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures; for a webinar presentation of the paper see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTIdhPiI7hk

Multi-phase critical Higgs boson at colliders

Authors: Katri Huitu, Kristjan Kannike, Niko Koivunen, Luca Marzola, Subhadeep Mondal, Martti Raidal

Abstract: The recently proposed multi-phase criticality principle in Coleman-Weinberg models can provide a new explanation for the hierarchy between the electroweak and new physics scales. When applied to the Standard Model, a Higgs boson as light as the pseudo-Goldstone boson of broken scale invariance occurs. The suppressed mixing between the two light fields still carries information about the large scal… ▽ More The recently proposed multi-phase criticality principle in Coleman-Weinberg models can provide a new explanation for the hierarchy between the electroweak and new physics scales. When applied to the Standard Model, a Higgs boson as light as the pseudo-Goldstone boson of broken scale invariance occurs. The suppressed mixing between the two light fields still carries information about the large scale of symmetry breaking, albeit up to logarithmic corrections. In this work we probe this scenario with the present LHC data and assess the impact of future lepton and hadron colliders. Our results show that the multi-phase criticality can easily explain the apparent absence of new physics at the energy scales tested in current experiments. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures

New fermions in the light of the $(g-2)_μ$

Authors: J. C. Criado, A. Djouadi, N. Koivunen, K. Müürsepp, M. Raidal, H. Veermäe

Abstract: The very precise measurement of the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon, recently released by the Muon g-2 experiment at Fermilab, can serve to set stringent constraints on new particles. If the observed 4$σ$ discrepancy from the Standard Model value is indeed real, it will set a tight margin on the scale of the masses and couplings of these particles. Instead, if the discrepancy is simply a res… ▽ More The very precise measurement of the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon, recently released by the Muon g-2 experiment at Fermilab, can serve to set stringent constraints on new particles. If the observed 4$σ$ discrepancy from the Standard Model value is indeed real, it will set a tight margin on the scale of the masses and couplings of these particles. Instead, if the discrepancy is simply a result of additional theoretical and experimental uncertainties to be included, strong constraints can be put on their parameters. In this mini-review, we summarize the impact of the latest muon g-2 measurement on new fermions that are predicted by a wide range of new physics models and with exotic quantum numbers and interactions. We will particularly discuss the case of vector-like leptons, excited leptons, and supersymmetric fermions, as well as spin-3/2 isosinglet fermions, which have been advocated recently. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 figures. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:2104.03231

Primordial black holes from spectator field bubbles

Authors: David Navidad Maeso, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We study the evolution of light spectator fields in an asymmetric polynomial potential. During inflation, stochastic fluctuations displace the spectator field from the global minimum of its potential, populating the false vacuum state and thereby allowing for the formation of false vacuum bubbles. By using a lattice simulation, we show that these bubbles begin to contract once they re-enter the ho… ▽ More We study the evolution of light spectator fields in an asymmetric polynomial potential. During inflation, stochastic fluctuations displace the spectator field from the global minimum of its potential, populating the false vacuum state and thereby allowing for the formation of false vacuum bubbles. By using a lattice simulation, we show that these bubbles begin to contract once they re-enter the horizon and, if sufficiently large, collapse into black holes. This process generally results in the formation of primordial black holes, which, due to the specific shape of their mass function, are constrained to yield at most 1% of the total dark matter abundance. However, the resulting population can source gravitational wave signals observable at the LIGO-Virgo experiments, provide seeds for supermassive black holes or cause a transient matter-dominated phase in the early Universe. △ Less

Submitted 2 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 25 pages, 8 figures

Yukawa coupling unification in non-supersymmetric SO(10) models with an intermediate scale

Authors: Abdelhak Djouadi, Ruiwen Ouyang, Martti Raidal

Abstract: We discuss the possibility of unifying in a simple and economical manner the Yukawa couplings of third generation fermions in a non-supersymmetric SO(10) model with an intermediate symmetry breaking, focusing on two possible patterns with intermediate Pati-Salam and minimal left-right groups. assume a minimal Yukawa sector at high energy, starting with two Higgs bi-doublets at the intermediate sca… ▽ More We discuss the possibility of unifying in a simple and economical manner the Yukawa couplings of third generation fermions in a non-supersymmetric SO(10) model with an intermediate symmetry breaking, focusing on two possible patterns with intermediate Pati-Salam and minimal left-right groups. assume a minimal Yukawa sector at high energy, starting with two Higgs bi-doublets at the intermediate scale which then simply reduce to a two Higgs doublet model at the electroweak scale. We first enforce gauge coupling unification at the two-loop level by including the threshold corrections in the renormalisation group running which are generated by the heavy fields that appear at the intermediate symmetry breaking scale. We then study the running of the Yukawa couplings of the top quark, bottom quark and tau lepton at two-loops in these two breaking schemes, when the appropriate matching conditions are imposed. We find that the unification of the third family Yukawa couplings can be achieved while retaining a viable spectrum, provided that the ratio of the vacuum expectation values of the two Higgs doublet fields is large, $\tanβ\approx 60$. △ Less

Submitted 21 December, 2022; v1 submitted 30 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 14 pages, 3 figures, published version, comments are welcome

An effective field theory of the Delta-resonance

Authors: Juan Carlos Criado, Abdelhak Djouadi, Niko Koivunen, Kristjan Müürsepp, Martti Raidal, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We present an effective field theory of the $Δ$-resonance as an interacting Weinberg's $(3/2,0)\oplus (0,3/2)$ field in the multi-spinor formalism. We derive its interactions with nucleons $N$, pions $π$ and photons $γ$, and compute the $Δ$-resonance cross-sections in pion-nucleon scattering and pion photo-production. The theory contains only the physical spin-3/2 degrees of freedom. Thus, it is i… ▽ More We present an effective field theory of the $Δ$-resonance as an interacting Weinberg's $(3/2,0)\oplus (0,3/2)$ field in the multi-spinor formalism. We derive its interactions with nucleons $N$, pions $π$ and photons $γ$, and compute the $Δ$-resonance cross-sections in pion-nucleon scattering and pion photo-production. The theory contains only the physical spin-3/2 degrees of freedom. Thus, it is intrinsically consistent at the Hamiltonian level and, unlike the commonly used Rarita-Schwinger framework, does not require any additional ad hoc manipulation of couplings or propagators. The symmetries of hadronic physics select a unique operator for each coupling $NπΔ$ and $γπΔ$. The proposed framework can be extended to also describe other higher-spin hadronic resonances. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 2 figures

Reply to "Comment on: Cosmological black holes are not described by the Thakurta metric"

Authors: Gert Hütsi, Tomi Koivisto, Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: In this reply, we address the comment [arXiv:2105.14908] to our recent paper [arXiv:2105.09328], where we argued that the Thakurta metric does not describe cosmological black holes. We clarify that the mass growth of Thakurta black holes is due to an influx of energy (i.e. accretion), which, by definition, is not a feature of geometry. The conclusions of [arXiv:2105.09328] are independent of the i… ▽ More In this reply, we address the comment [arXiv:2105.14908] to our recent paper [arXiv:2105.09328], where we argued that the Thakurta metric does not describe cosmological black holes. We clarify that the mass growth of Thakurta black holes is due to an influx of energy (i.e. accretion), which, by definition, is not a feature of geometry. The conclusions of [arXiv:2105.09328] are independent of the interpretation of this energy flux. We show that the average energy density of primordial Thakurta black holes scales as $a^{-2}$ and requires an unrealistic and fine-tuned energy transfer from a smooth dark matter component to the primordial black hole sector. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 2 pages

Cosmological black holes are not described by the Thakurta metric: LIGO-Virgo bounds on PBHs remain unchanged

Authors: Gert Hütsi, Tomi Koivisto, Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We show that the physical conditions which induce the Thakurta metric, recently studied by Bœhm {\it et al.} in the context of time-dependent black hole masses, correspond to a single accreting black hole in the entire Universe filled with isotropic non-interacting dust. In such a case, the physics of black hole accretion is not local but tied to the properties of the whole Universe. We show that… ▽ More We show that the physical conditions which induce the Thakurta metric, recently studied by Bœhm {\it et al.} in the context of time-dependent black hole masses, correspond to a single accreting black hole in the entire Universe filled with isotropic non-interacting dust. In such a case, the physics of black hole accretion is not local but tied to the properties of the whole Universe. We show that radiation, primordial black holes or particle dark matter cannot produce the specific energy flux required for supporting the mass growth of Thakurta black holes. In particular, this solution does not apply to black hole binaries. We conclude that cosmological black holes and their mass growth cannot be described by the Thakurta metric, and thus existing constraints on the primordial black hole abundance from the LIGO-Virgo and the CMB measurements remain valid. △ Less

Submitted 22 June, 2021; v1 submitted 19 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 figure, discussion extended

A fake doublet solution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment

Authors: Damiano Anselmi, Kristjan Kannike, Carlo Marzo, Luca Marzola, Aurora Melis, Kristjan Müürsepp, Marco Piva, Martti Raidal

Abstract: Extensions to the Standard Model that use strictly off-shell degrees of freedom - the fakeons - allow for new measurable interactions at energy scales usually precluded by the constraints that target the on-shell propagation of new particles. Here we employ the interactions between a new fake scalar doublet and the muon to explain the recent Fermilab measurement of its anomalous magnetic moment. R… ▽ More Extensions to the Standard Model that use strictly off-shell degrees of freedom - the fakeons - allow for new measurable interactions at energy scales usually precluded by the constraints that target the on-shell propagation of new particles. Here we employ the interactions between a new fake scalar doublet and the muon to explain the recent Fermilab measurement of its anomalous magnetic moment. Remarkably, unlike in the case of usual particles, the experimental result can be matched for fakeon masses below the electroweak scale without contradicting the stringent precision data and collider bounds on new light degrees of freedom. Our analysis, therefore, demonstrates that the fakeon approach offers unexpected viable possibilities to model new physics naturally at low scales. △ Less

Submitted 25 August, 2021; v1 submitted 7 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures, PRD version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 104, 035009 (2021)

Confronting spin-3/2 and other new fermions with the muon g-2 measurement

Authors: Juan C. Criado, Abdelhak Djouadi, Niko Koivunen, Kristjan Müürsepp, Martti Raidal, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: The new measurement of the muon's anomalous magnetic moment released by the Muon g-2 experiment at Fermilab sets strong constraints on the properties of many new particles. Using an effective field theory approach to the interactions of higher-spin fields, we evaluate the contribution of an electrically neutral and colour singlet spin-3/2 fermion to $(g-2)_μ$ and derive the corresponding constrain… ▽ More The new measurement of the muon's anomalous magnetic moment released by the Muon g-2 experiment at Fermilab sets strong constraints on the properties of many new particles. Using an effective field theory approach to the interactions of higher-spin fields, we evaluate the contribution of an electrically neutral and colour singlet spin-3/2 fermion to $(g-2)_μ$ and derive the corresponding constraints on its mass and couplings. These constraints are then compared with the ones on spin-1/2 fermions, such as the vector-like leptons that are predicted by various extensions of the Standard Model, the excited leptons which appear in composite models, as well as the charginos and neutralinos of supersymmetric theories. Unlike these new spin-1/2 fermions, the spin-3/2 particles generate only small contributions to the muon anomalous magnetic moment. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2021; v1 submitted 7 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: References updated, typos fixed and comments added; results unchanged

Phenomenology of a Fake Inert Doublet Model

Authors: Damiano Anselmi, Kristjan Kannike, Carlo Marzo, Luca Marzola, Aurora Melis, Kristjan Müürsepp, Marco Piva, Martti Raidal

Abstract: We introduce a new way of modeling the physics beyond the Standard Model by considering fake, strictly off-shell degrees of freedom: the fakeons. To demonstrate the approach and exemplify its reach, we re-analyze the phenomenology of the Inert Doublet Model under the assumption that the second doublet is a fakeon. Remarkably, the fake doublet avoids the most stringent $Z$-pole constraints regardle… ▽ More We introduce a new way of modeling the physics beyond the Standard Model by considering fake, strictly off-shell degrees of freedom: the fakeons. To demonstrate the approach and exemplify its reach, we re-analyze the phenomenology of the Inert Doublet Model under the assumption that the second doublet is a fakeon. Remarkably, the fake doublet avoids the most stringent $Z$-pole constraints regardless of the chosen mass scale, thereby allowing for the presence of new effects well below the electroweak scale. Furthermore, the absence of on-shell propagation prevents fakeons from inducing missing energy signatures in collider experiments. The distinguishing features of the model appear at the loop level, where fakeons modify the Higgs boson $h\toγγ$ decay width and the Higgs trilinear coupling. The running of Standard Model parameters proceeds as in the usual Inert Doublet Model case. Therefore, the fake doublet can also ensure the stability of the Standard Model vacuum. Our work shows that fakeons are a valid alternative to the usual tools of particle physics model building, with the potential to shape a new paradigm, where the significance of the existing experimental constraints towards new physics must necessarily be reconsidered. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2021; v1 submitted 5 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 12 pages, 7 figures, version accepted by JHEP

Higgs-like spectator field as the origin of structure

Authors: Alexandros Karam, Tommi Markkanen, Luca Marzola, Sami Nurmi, Martti Raidal, Arttu Rajantie

Abstract: We show that the observed primordial perturbations can be entirely sourced by a light spectator scalar field with a quartic potential, akin to the Higgs boson, provided that the field is sufficiently displaced from vacuum during inflation. The framework relies on the indirect modulation of reheating, which is implemented without any direct coupling between the spectator field and the inflaton and… ▽ More We show that the observed primordial perturbations can be entirely sourced by a light spectator scalar field with a quartic potential, akin to the Higgs boson, provided that the field is sufficiently displaced from vacuum during inflation. The framework relies on the indirect modulation of reheating, which is implemented without any direct coupling between the spectator field and the inflaton and does not require non-renormalisable interactions. The scenario gives rise to local non-Gaussianity with $f_{\rm NL}\simeq 5$ as the typical signal. As an example model where the indirect modulation mechanism is realised for the Higgs boson, we study the Standard Model extended with right-handed neutrinos. For the Standard Model running we find, however, that the scenario analysed does not seem to produce the observed perturbation. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2021; v1 submitted 3 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: Figures modified, analysis extended, references added, matches published version

Higher-spin particles at high-energy colliders

Authors: Juan Carlos Criado, Abdelhak Djouadi, Niko Koivunen, Martti Raidal, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: Using an effective field theory approach for higher-spin fields, we derive the interactions of colour singlet and electrically neutral particles with a spin higher than unity, concentrating on the spin-3/2, spin-2, spin-5/2 and spin-3 cases. We compute the decay rates and production cross sections in the main channels for spin-3/2 and spin-2 states at both electron-positron and hadron colliders, a… ▽ More Using an effective field theory approach for higher-spin fields, we derive the interactions of colour singlet and electrically neutral particles with a spin higher than unity, concentrating on the spin-3/2, spin-2, spin-5/2 and spin-3 cases. We compute the decay rates and production cross sections in the main channels for spin-3/2 and spin-2 states at both electron-positron and hadron colliders, and identify the most promising novel experimental signatures for discovering such particles at the LHC. The discussion is qualitatively extended to the spin-5/2 and spin-3 cases. Higher-spin particles exhibit a rich phenomenology and have signatures that often resemble the ones of supersymmetric and extra-dimensional theories. To enable further studies of higher-spin particles at collider and beyond, we collect the relevant Feynman rules and other technical details. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2021; v1 submitted 26 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: Published version. 38 pages, 6 figures. Comments welcome

Light Higgs boson from multi-phase criticality in dynamical symmetry breaking

Authors: Kristjan Kannike, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal, Alessandro Strumia

Abstract: The Coleman-Weinberg mechanism can realise different phases of dynamical symmetry breaking. In each phase a combination of scalars, corresponding to the pseudo-Goldstone boson of scale invariance, has a loop-suppressed mass. We show that additional scalars, beyond the pseudo-Goldstone bosons, can become light at critical points in the parameter space where two different phases co-exist. We present… ▽ More The Coleman-Weinberg mechanism can realise different phases of dynamical symmetry breaking. In each phase a combination of scalars, corresponding to the pseudo-Goldstone boson of scale invariance, has a loop-suppressed mass. We show that additional scalars, beyond the pseudo-Goldstone bosons, can become light at critical points in the parameter space where two different phases co-exist. We present a minimal implementation of the mechanism in multi-scalar models, detailing how loop-suppressed masses and mixings can be computed. We discuss realisations of the resulting multi-phase criticality principle and its relevance to the case of the Higgs boson. △ Less

Submitted 19 March, 2021; v1 submitted 1 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 figures, version accepted in PLB

Two populations of LIGO-Virgo black holes

Authors: Gert Hütsi, Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We analyse the LIGO-Virgo data, including the recently released GWTC-2 dataset, to test a hypothesis that the data contains more than one population of black holes. We perform a maximum likelihood analysis including a population of astrophysical black holes with a truncated power-law mass function whose merger rate follows from star formation rate, and a population of primordial black holes for wh… ▽ More We analyse the LIGO-Virgo data, including the recently released GWTC-2 dataset, to test a hypothesis that the data contains more than one population of black holes. We perform a maximum likelihood analysis including a population of astrophysical black holes with a truncated power-law mass function whose merger rate follows from star formation rate, and a population of primordial black holes for which we consider log-normal and critical collapse mass functions. We find that primordial black holes alone are strongly disfavoured by the data, while the best fit is obtained for the template combining astrophysical and primordial merger rates. Alternatively, the data may hint towards two different astrophysical black hole populations. We also update the constraints on primordial black hole abundance from LIGO-Virgo observations finding that in the $2-400M_\odot$ mass range they must comprise less than 0.2% of dark matter. △ Less

Submitted 20 August, 2022; v1 submitted 4 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 28 pages, 8 figures, minor corrections

Journal ref: JCAP 03 (2021) 068

Principle of Multiple Point Criticality in Multi-Scalar Dark Matter Models

Authors: Kristjan Kannike, Niko Koivunen, Martti Raidal

Abstract: The principle of multiple point criticality (PMPC), which allowed the prediction of the Higgs boson mass before its discovery, has so far been applied to radiatively generated vacua. If this principle is fundamental, following from some presently unknown underlying physics, the PMPC must apply to all vacua, including the multiple vacua of multi-scalar models dominated by tree-level terms. We first… ▽ More The principle of multiple point criticality (PMPC), which allowed the prediction of the Higgs boson mass before its discovery, has so far been applied to radiatively generated vacua. If this principle is fundamental, following from some presently unknown underlying physics, the PMPC must apply to all vacua, including the multiple vacua of multi-scalar models dominated by tree-level terms. We first motivate this idea and then exemplify it by applying the PMPC to various realizations of singlet scalar dark matter models. We derive constraints on the dark matter properties from the requirement of degenerate vacua and show that some scalar dark matter models are ruled out by the PMPC, while in others the allowed parameters space is constrained. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2021; v1 submitted 19 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: Published version

Dark matter of any spin -- an effective field theory and applications

Authors: Juan Carlos Criado, Niko Koivunen, Martti Raidal, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We develop an effective field theory of a generic massive particle of any spin and, as an example, apply this to study higher-spin dark matter (DM). Our formalism does not introduce unphysical degrees of freedom, thus avoiding the potential inconsistencies that may appear in other field-theoretical descriptions of higher spin. Being a useful reformulation of the Weinberg's original idea, the propo… ▽ More We develop an effective field theory of a generic massive particle of any spin and, as an example, apply this to study higher-spin dark matter (DM). Our formalism does not introduce unphysical degrees of freedom, thus avoiding the potential inconsistencies that may appear in other field-theoretical descriptions of higher spin. Being a useful reformulation of the Weinberg's original idea, the proposed effective field theory allows for consistent computations of physical observables for general-spin particles, although it does not admit a Lagrangian description. As a specific realization, we explore the phenomenology of a general-spin singlet with $\mathbb{Z}_2$-symmetric Higgs portal couplings, a setup which automatically arises for high spin, and show that higher spin particles with masses above $O(10)\,\mathrm{TeV}$ can be viable thermally-produced DM candidates. Most importantly, if the general-spin DM has purely parity-odd couplings, it naturally avoids all DM direct detection bounds, in which case its mass can lie below the electroweak scale. Our formalism reproduces the existing results for low-spin DM, and allows one to develop consistent higher-spin particle physics phenomenology for high- and low-energy experiments and cosmology. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2020; v1 submitted 5 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: References added. Corrections in formulae involving multispinor contractions. Results qualitatively the same. Matches version published in PRD

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 102, 125031 (2020)

Gravitational dark matter production in Palatini preheating

Authors: Alexandros Karam, Martti Raidal, Eemeli Tomberg

Abstract: We study preheating in plateau inflation in the Palatini formulation of general relativity, in a special case that resembles Higgs inflation. It was previously shown that the oscillating inflaton field returns to the plateau repeatedly in this model, and this leads to tachyonic production of inflaton particles. We show that a minimally coupled spectator scalar field can be produced even more effic… ▽ More We study preheating in plateau inflation in the Palatini formulation of general relativity, in a special case that resembles Higgs inflation. It was previously shown that the oscillating inflaton field returns to the plateau repeatedly in this model, and this leads to tachyonic production of inflaton particles. We show that a minimally coupled spectator scalar field can be produced even more efficiently by a similar mechanism. The mechanism is purely gravitational, and the scalar field mass can be of order $10^{13}$ GeV, larger than the Hubble scale by many orders of magnitude, making this a candidate for superheavy dark matter. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2021; v1 submitted 7 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: Section 4 extended, references added, typos fixed, matches published version

Novel mechanism for CMB modulation in the Standard Model

Authors: Alexandros Karam, Tommi Markkanen, Luca Marzola, Sami Nurmi, Martti Raidal, Arttu Rajantie

Abstract: We demonstrate that light spectator fields can source sizeable CMB anisotropies through modulated reheating even in the absence of direct couplings to the inflaton. The effect arises when the phase space of the inflaton decay is modulated by the spectator which generates masses for the decay products. We call the mechanism \textit{indirect modulation} and show that it can source perturbations even… ▽ More We demonstrate that light spectator fields can source sizeable CMB anisotropies through modulated reheating even in the absence of direct couplings to the inflaton. The effect arises when the phase space of the inflaton decay is modulated by the spectator which generates masses for the decay products. We call the mechanism \textit{indirect modulation} and show that it can source perturbations even four orders of magnitude larger than the observed. Importantly, the indirect mechanism is present in the Standard Model extended with right-handed neutrinos. For a minimally coupled Higgs boson this leads to a novel lower bound on the quartic coupling and constrains the neutrino Yukawas below unity. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2020; v1 submitted 25 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: discussion updated, references added

Dark Matter and the XENON1T electron recoil excess

Authors: Kristjan Kannike, Martti Raidal, Hardi Veermäe, Alessandro Strumia, Daniele Teresi

Abstract: We show that the electron recoil excess around 2 keV claimed by the Xenon collaboration can be fitted by DM or DM-like particles having a fast component with velocity of order $\sim 0.1$. Those particles cannot be part of the cold DM halo of our Galaxy, so we speculate about their possible nature and origin, such as fast moving DM sub-haloes, semi-annihilations of DM and relativistic axions produc… ▽ More We show that the electron recoil excess around 2 keV claimed by the Xenon collaboration can be fitted by DM or DM-like particles having a fast component with velocity of order $\sim 0.1$. Those particles cannot be part of the cold DM halo of our Galaxy, so we speculate about their possible nature and origin, such as fast moving DM sub-haloes, semi-annihilations of DM and relativistic axions produced by a nearby axion star. Feasible new physics scenarios must accommodate exotic DM dynamics and unusual DM properties. △ Less

Submitted 9 November, 2020; v1 submitted 18 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures, published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 102, 095002 (2020)

Implications of Milky Way Substructures for the Nature of Dark Matter

Authors: María Benito, Juan Carlos Criado, Gert Hütsi, Martti Raidal, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We study how the indirect observation of dark matter substructures in the Milky Way, using recent stellar stream studies, translates into constraints for different dark matter models. Particularly, we use the measured number of dark subhalos in the mass range $10^7-10^9\,{\rm M_{\odot}}$ to constrain modifications of the subhalo mass function compared to the cold dark matter scenario. We obtain th… ▽ More We study how the indirect observation of dark matter substructures in the Milky Way, using recent stellar stream studies, translates into constraints for different dark matter models. Particularly, we use the measured number of dark subhalos in the mass range $10^7-10^9\,{\rm M_{\odot}}$ to constrain modifications of the subhalo mass function compared to the cold dark matter scenario. We obtain the lower bounds $m_{\rm WDM} > 3.2\,{\rm keV}$ and $m_{\rm FDM} > 5.2\times 10^{-21}\,{\rm eV}$ on the warm dark matter and fuzzy dark matter particle mass, respectively. When dark matter is coupled to a dark radiation bath, we find that kinetic decoupling must take place at temperatures higher than $T_{\rm kd} > 0.7\,{\rm keV}$. We also discuss future prospects of stellar stream observations. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2020; v1 submitted 29 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: minor errors corrected, accepted for publication in PRD

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 103023 (2020)

Gravitational Wave Signals of Pseudo-Goldstone Dark Matter in the $\mathbb{Z}_{3}$ Complex Singlet Model

Authors: Kristjan Kannike, Kaius Loos, Martti Raidal

Abstract: We study pseudo-Goldstone dark matter in the $\mathbb{Z}_{3}$ complex scalar singlet model. Because the direct detection spin-independent cross section is suppressed, such dark matter is allowed in a large mass range. Unlike in the original model stabilized by a parity, due to the cubic coupling of the singlet the $\mathbb{Z}_{3}$ model can accommodate first-order phase transitions that give rise… ▽ More We study pseudo-Goldstone dark matter in the $\mathbb{Z}_{3}$ complex scalar singlet model. Because the direct detection spin-independent cross section is suppressed, such dark matter is allowed in a large mass range. Unlike in the original model stabilized by a parity, due to the cubic coupling of the singlet the $\mathbb{Z}_{3}$ model can accommodate first-order phase transitions that give rise to a stochastic gravitational wave signal potentially observable in future space-based detectors. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2019; v1 submitted 30 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 9 pages, 2 figures; citations added, Eq. (23) corrected, results unchanged

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 035001 (2020)

Small-scale structure of primordial black hole dark matter and its implications for accretion

Authors: Gert Hütsi, Martti Raidal, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: Primordial black hole (PBH) dark matter (DM) nonlinear small-scale structure formation begins before the epoch of recombination due to large Poisson density fluctuations. Those small-scale effects still survive today, distinguishing physics of PBH DM structure formation from the one involving WIMP DM. We construct an analytic model for the small-scale PBH velocities that reproduces the velocity fl… ▽ More Primordial black hole (PBH) dark matter (DM) nonlinear small-scale structure formation begins before the epoch of recombination due to large Poisson density fluctuations. Those small-scale effects still survive today, distinguishing physics of PBH DM structure formation from the one involving WIMP DM. We construct an analytic model for the small-scale PBH velocities that reproduces the velocity floor seen in numerical simulations, and investigate how these motions impact PBH accretion bounds at different redshifts. We find that the effect is small at the time of recombination, leaving the cosmic microwave background bounds on PBH abundance unchanged. However, already at $z=20$ the PBH internal motion significantly reduces their accretion due to the additional $1/v^6$ suppression, affecting the 21 cm bounds. Today the accretion bounds arising from dwarf galaxies or smaller PBH substructures are all reduced by the PBH velocity floor. We also investigate the feasibility for the PBH clusters to coherently accrete gas leading to a possible enhancement proportional to the cluster's occupation number but find this effect to be insignificant for PBH around $10 M_{\odot}$ or lighter. Those results should be reconsidered if the initial PBH distribution is not Poisson, for example, in the case of large initial PBH clustering. △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 2019; v1 submitted 15 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures, typos corrected, references added, matches version published in PRD

Report number: CERN-TH-2019-112

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 083016 (2019)

Left-Right Supersymmetry as the Origin of Flavor Physics

Authors: Sean Fraser, Emidio Gabrielli, Carlo Marzo, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal

Abstract: We propose a new framework for the observed flavor hierarchy and mixing based on left-right supersymmetry. The model contains the most minimal Higgs sector consisting only of gauge doublets which forbid the standard model Yukawa couplings. New mediator fields then connect the left- and right-chiral fermion sectors and result in effective tree level Yukawa couplings for the third generation charged… ▽ More We propose a new framework for the observed flavor hierarchy and mixing based on left-right supersymmetry. The model contains the most minimal Higgs sector consisting only of gauge doublets which forbid the standard model Yukawa couplings. New mediator fields then connect the left- and right-chiral fermion sectors and result in effective tree level Yukawa couplings for the third generation charged fermions. The remaining fermions, including all neutrinos, acquire effective Yukawa couplings sourced by the supersymmetry breaking sector at loop level. We predict new TeV range scalars, as well as heavier fermions and vector bosons, that can be discovered at the LHC and future colliders. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 21 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 115002 (2019)

Electromagnetic probes of primordial black holes as dark matter

Authors: Y. Ali-Haimoud, S. Clesse, J. Garcia-Bellido, A. Kashlinsky, L. Wyrzykowski, A. Achucarro, L. Amendola, J. Annis, A. Arbey, R. G. Arendt, F. Atrio-Barandela, N. Bellomo, K. Belotsky, J-L. Bernal, S. Bird, V. Bozza, C. Byrnes, S. Calchi Novati, F. Calore, B. J. Carr, J. Chluba, I. Cholis, A. Cieplak, P. Cole, I. Dalianis , et al. (69 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The LIGO discoveries have rekindled suggestions that primordial black holes (BHs) may constitute part to all of the dark matter (DM) in the Universe. Such suggestions came from 1) the observed merger rate of the BHs, 2) their unusual masses, 3) their low/zero spins, and 4) also from the independently uncovered cosmic infrared background (CIB) fluctuations signal of high amplitude and coherence wit… ▽ More The LIGO discoveries have rekindled suggestions that primordial black holes (BHs) may constitute part to all of the dark matter (DM) in the Universe. Such suggestions came from 1) the observed merger rate of the BHs, 2) their unusual masses, 3) their low/zero spins, and 4) also from the independently uncovered cosmic infrared background (CIB) fluctuations signal of high amplitude and coherence with unresolved cosmic X-ray background (CXB). Here we summarize the prospects to resolve this important issue with electromagnetic observations using the instruments and tools expected in the 2020's. These prospects appear promising to make significant, and potentially critical, advances. We demonstrate that in the next decade, new space- and ground-borne electromagnetic instruments, combined with concurrent theoretical efforts, should shed critical light on the long-considered link between primordial BHs and DM. Specifically the new data and methodologies under this program will involve: I) Probing with high precision the spatial spectrum of source-subtracted CIB with Euclid and WFIRST, and its coherence with unresolved cosmic X-ray background using eROSITA and Athena, II) Advanced searches for microlensing of Galactic stars by the intervening Galactic Halo BHs with OGLE, Gaia, LSST and WFIRST, III) Supernovae (SNe) lensing in the upcoming surveys with WFIRST, LSST and also potentially with Euclid and JWST, IV) Advanced theoretical work to understand the details of PBH accretion and evolution and their influence on cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies in light of the next generation CMB experiments, V) Better new samples and theoretical understanding involving stability and properties of ultra faint dwarf galaxies, pulsar timing, and cosmological quasar lensing. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2019; v1 submitted 11 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: Science whitepaper submitted to the Astro2020 Decadal Survey

Dark Matter through the Higgs portal

Authors: Giorgio Arcadi, Abdelhak Djouadi, Martti Raidal

Abstract: We review scenarios in which the particles that account for the Dark Matter (DM) in the Universe interact only through their couplings with the Higgs sector of the theory, the so-called Higgs-portal models. In a first step, we use a general and model-independent approach in which the DM particles are singlets with spin $0,\frac12$ or $1$, and assume a minimal Higgs sector with the presence of only… ▽ More We review scenarios in which the particles that account for the Dark Matter (DM) in the Universe interact only through their couplings with the Higgs sector of the theory, the so-called Higgs-portal models. In a first step, we use a general and model-independent approach in which the DM particles are singlets with spin $0,\frac12$ or $1$, and assume a minimal Higgs sector with the presence of only the Standard Model (SM) Higgs particle observed at the LHC. In a second step, we discuss non-minimal scenarios in which the spin-$\frac12$ DM particle is accompanied by additional lepton partners and consider several possibilities like sequential, singlet-doublet and vector-like leptons. In a third step, we examine the case in which it is the Higgs sector of the theory which is enlarged either by a singlet scalar or pseudoscalar field, an additional two Higgs doublet field or by both; in this case, the matter content is also extended in several ways. Finally, we investigate the case of supersymmetric extensions of the SM with neutralino DM, focusing on the possibility that the latter couples mainly to the neutral Higgs particles of the model which then serve as the main portals for DM phenomenology. In all these scenarios, we summarize and update the present constraints and future prospects from the collider physics perspective, namely from the determination of the SM Higgs properties at the LHC and the search for its invisible decays into DM, and the search for heavier Higgs bosons and the DM companion particles at high-energy colliders. We then compare these results with the constraints and prospects obtained from the cosmological relic abundance as well as from direct and indirect DM searches in astroparticle physics experiments. The complementarity of collider and astroparticle DM searches is investigated in all the considered models. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 260 pages, 105 figures. The review is open to comments and suggestions

Report number: LAPTH-010/19

Common explanation to the $R_{K^{(*)}}$, $R_{D^{(*)}}$ and $ε^\prime/ε$ anomalies in a 3HDM+$ν_R$ and connections to neutrino physics

Authors: Carlo Marzo, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal

Abstract: Scalar theories can account for the current $R_{D^{(*)}}$ measurements through a vector operator $\bar{c}_L γ_μ b_L\,\barτ_L γ^μν_L$ induced at the loop level. Once the vector contribution is considered on top of a subdominant tree-level scalar component, the predicted value of $R_{D^{(*)}}$ falls within the $1σ$ region indicated by the experiments. We explicitly demonstrate this claim in the fram… ▽ More Scalar theories can account for the current $R_{D^{(*)}}$ measurements through a vector operator $\bar{c}_L γ_μ b_L\,\barτ_L γ^μν_L$ induced at the loop level. Once the vector contribution is considered on top of a subdominant tree-level scalar component, the predicted value of $R_{D^{(*)}}$ falls within the $1σ$ region indicated by the experiments. We explicitly demonstrate this claim in the framework of a three Higgs doublet model extended with GeV scale right-handed neutrinos, by matching the anomalous signal for perturbative values of the involved couplings and respecting the bounds from complementary flavour physics measurements. Remarkably, we furthermore show that the proposed framework can be employed to simultaneously explain also the present $R_{K^{(*)}}$ measurement, as well as the deviation in $ε'/ε$ currently being debated in the literature. These results are obtained by considering the contribution of relatively light right-handed neutrinos which are fundamental in mediating the processes behind the anomalous signals. In this way our findings reveal a new possible connection that links the flavour anomalies to the phenomenology of extended Higgs sector and neutrino physics. △ Less

Submitted 24 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: 18 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 100, 055031 (2019)

Phase Transitions and Gravitational Wave Tests of Pseudo-Goldstone Dark Matter in the Softly Broken U(1) Scalar Singlet Model

Authors: Kristjan Kannike, Martti Raidal

Abstract: We study phase transitions in a softly broken $U(1)$ complex singlet scalar model in which the dark matter is the pseudo-scalar part of a singlet whose direct detection coupling to matter is strongly suppressed. Our aim is to find ways to test this model with the stochastic gravitational wave background from the scalar phase transition. We find that the phase transition which induces vacuum expect… ▽ More We study phase transitions in a softly broken $U(1)$ complex singlet scalar model in which the dark matter is the pseudo-scalar part of a singlet whose direct detection coupling to matter is strongly suppressed. Our aim is to find ways to test this model with the stochastic gravitational wave background from the scalar phase transition. We find that the phase transition which induces vacuum expectation values for both the Higgs boson and the singlet - necessary to provide a realistic dark matter candidate - is always of the second order. If the stochastic gravitational wave background characteristic to a first order phase transition will be discovered by interferometers, the soft breaking of $U(1)$ cannot be the explanation to the suppressed dark matter-baryon coupling, providing a conclusive negative test for this class of singlet models. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2019; v1 submitted 10 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 99, 115010 (2019)

Formation and Evolution of Primordial Black Hole Binaries in the Early Universe

Authors: Martti Raidal, Christian Spethmann, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: The abundance of primordial black holes (PBHs) in the mass range $0.1 - 10^3 M_\odot$ can potentially be tested by gravitational wave observations due to the large merger rate of PBH binaries formed in the early universe. To put the estimates of the latter on a firmer footing, we first derive analytical PBH merger rate for general PBH mass functions while imposing a minimal initial comoving distan… ▽ More The abundance of primordial black holes (PBHs) in the mass range $0.1 - 10^3 M_\odot$ can potentially be tested by gravitational wave observations due to the large merger rate of PBH binaries formed in the early universe. To put the estimates of the latter on a firmer footing, we first derive analytical PBH merger rate for general PBH mass functions while imposing a minimal initial comoving distance between the binary and the PBH nearest to it, in order to pick only initial configurations where the binary would not get disrupted. We then study the formation and evolution of PBH binaries before recombination by performing N-body simulations. We find that the analytical estimate based on the tidally perturbed 2-body system strongly overestimates the present merger rate when PBHs comprise all dark matter, as most initial binaries are disrupted by the surrounding PBHs. This is mostly due to the formation of compact N-body systems at matter-radiation equality. However, if PBHs make up a small fraction of the dark matter, $f_{\rm PBH} \lesssim 10\%$, these estimates become more reliable. In that case, the merger rate observed by LIGO imposes the strongest constraint on the PBH abundance in the mass range $2 - 160 M_\odot$. Finally, we argue that, even if most initial PBH binaries are perturbed, the present BH-BH merger rate of binaries formed in the early universe is larger than $\mathcal{O}(10)\,{\rm Gpc}^{-3} {\rm yr}^{-1}\, f_{\rm PBH}^3$ △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2019; v1 submitted 5 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 32pages, 12 figures, typos corrected, references added, figures updated, matches version published in JCAP

Report number: KCL-PH-TH/2018-70, CERN-TH-2018-266

Journal ref: JCAP 1902, 018 (2019)

Towards a viable scalar interpretation of $R_{D^{(*)}}$

Authors: Sean Fraser, Carlo Marzo, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal, Christian Spethmann

Abstract: Recent measurements of semileptonic B-meson decays seemingly imply violations of lepton flavor universality beyond the Standard Model predictions. With three-level explanations based on extended Higgs sectors being strongly challenged by the measurements of the $B_c^-$ lifetime, new theories invoking leptoquark or vector fields appear as the only feasible answer. However, in this work we show that… ▽ More Recent measurements of semileptonic B-meson decays seemingly imply violations of lepton flavor universality beyond the Standard Model predictions. With three-level explanations based on extended Higgs sectors being strongly challenged by the measurements of the $B_c^-$ lifetime, new theories invoking leptoquark or vector fields appear as the only feasible answer. However, in this work we show that simple scalar extensions of the Standard Model still offer a possible solution to the $B$ physics puzzle, owing to sizeable loop-level corrections which mimic the effects of new vector contributions. Considering a simplified model characterised by a charged and a neutral scalar particle, we verify the compatibility of the observed $R_{D^{(*)}}$ signal with the relevant collider bounds. We also study an embedding of the simplified model into a three-Higgs-doublet framework, and investigate its main phenomenological constraints. △ Less

Submitted 27 August, 2018; v1 submitted 21 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 15 pages, 12 figures. v2: References updated, larger captions for most of the plots. Version to appear on PRD

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 98, 035016 (2018)

Constraints on primordial black hole dark matter from Galactic center X-ray observations

Authors: Andi Hektor, Gert Hütsi, Martti Raidal

Abstract: Surprisingly high masses of the black holes inferred from the LIGO & Virgo gravitational wave measurements have lead to speculations that the observed mergers might be due to ${\cal O}(10) M_\odot$ primordial black holes (PBHs). Furthermore, it has been suggested that the whole amount of dark matter (DM) might be in that exotic form. We investigate constraints on the PBH DM using NuSTAR Galactic c… ▽ More Surprisingly high masses of the black holes inferred from the LIGO & Virgo gravitational wave measurements have lead to speculations that the observed mergers might be due to ${\cal O}(10) M_\odot$ primordial black holes (PBHs). Furthermore, it has been suggested that the whole amount of dark matter (DM) might be in that exotic form. We investigate constraints on the PBH DM using NuSTAR Galactic center (GC) X-ray data. We used a robust Monte Carlo approach in conjunction with a radiatively inefficient PBH accretion model with commonly accepted model parameters. Compared to previous studies we allowed for multiple forms of DM density profiles. Most importantly, our study includes treatment of the gas turbulence, which significantly modifies the relative velocity between PBHs and gas. We show that inclusion of the effects of gas turbulence and the uncertainties related to the DM density profile reduces significantly the gas accretion onto PBHs compared to the claimed values in previous papers. It is highly improbable to obtain accreting PBHs brighter than the NuSTAR point source limit using observationally determined gas velocities. As such, one can safely conclude that GC X-ray observations cannot rule out ${\cal O}(10) M_\odot$ PBH DM. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2018; v1 submitted 16 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 8 pages, 5 figures, A&A accepted

Journal ref: A&A 618, A139 (2018)

Dark Matter Effects On Neutron Star Properties

Authors: John Ellis, Gert Hütsi, Kristjan Kannike, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen

Abstract: We study possible effects of a dark matter (DM) core on the maximum mass of a neutron star (NS), on the mass-radius relation and on the NS tidal deformability parameter $Λ$. We show that all these quantities would in general be reduced in the presence of a DM core. In particular, our calculations indicate that the presence of a DM core with a mass fraction $\sim 5\%$ could affect significantly the… ▽ More We study possible effects of a dark matter (DM) core on the maximum mass of a neutron star (NS), on the mass-radius relation and on the NS tidal deformability parameter $Λ$. We show that all these quantities would in general be reduced in the presence of a DM core. In particular, our calculations indicate that the presence of a DM core with a mass fraction $\sim 5\%$ could affect significantly the interpretation of these NS data as constraints on the nuclear equation of state (EOS), potentially excluding some EOS models on the basis of the measured mass of PSR J0348+0432, while allowing other EOS models to become consistent with the LIGO/Virgo upper limit on $Λ$. Specific scenarios for generating such DM cores are explored in an Appendix. △ Less

Submitted 12 June, 2018; v1 submitted 4 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures; minor changes to match the published version

Report number: CERN-TH-2018-072, KCL-PH-TH/2018-13

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 123007 (2018)

Constraining Primordial Black Holes with the EDGES 21-cm Absorption Signal

Authors: Andi Hektor, Gert Hütsi, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: The EDGES experiment has recently measured an anomalous global 21-cm spectrum due to hydrogen absorptions at redshifts of about $z\sim 17$. Model independently, the unusually low temperature of baryons probed by this observable sets strong constraints on any physical process that transfers energy into the baryonic environment at such redshifts. Here we make use of the 21-cm spectrum to derive boun… ▽ More The EDGES experiment has recently measured an anomalous global 21-cm spectrum due to hydrogen absorptions at redshifts of about $z\sim 17$. Model independently, the unusually low temperature of baryons probed by this observable sets strong constraints on any physical process that transfers energy into the baryonic environment at such redshifts. Here we make use of the 21-cm spectrum to derive bounds on the energy injection due to a possible population of ${\cal O}(1-100) M_\odot$ primordial black holes, which induce a wide spectrum of radiation during the accretion of the surrounding gas. After calculating the total radiative intensity of a primordial black hole population, we estimate the amount of heat and ionisations produced in the baryonic gas and compute the resulting thermal history of the Universe with a modified version of RECFAST code. Finally, by imposing that the temperature of the gas at $z\sim 17$ does not exceed the indications of EDGES, we constrain the possible abundance of primordial black holes. Depending on uncertainties related to the accretion model, we find that ${\cal O}(10) M_\odot$ primordial black holes can only contribute to a fraction $f_{\rm PBH}<(1-10^{-3})$ of the total dark matter abundance. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2018; v1 submitted 26 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures, PRD accepted

Report number: CERN-TH-2018-073

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 98, 023503 (2018)

The EDGES 21 cm Anomaly and Properties of Dark Matter

Authors: Sean Fraser, Andi Hektor, Gert Hütsi, Kristjan Kannike, Carlo Marzo, Luca Marzola, Christian Spethmann, Antonio Racioppi, Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: The recently claimed anomaly in the measurement of the 21 cm hydrogen absorption signal by EDGES at $z\sim 17$, if cosmological, requires the existence of new physics. The possible attempts to resolve the anomaly rely on either (i) cooling the hydrogen gas via new dark matter-hydrogen interactions or (ii) modifying the soft photon background beyond the standard CMB one, as possibly suggested also… ▽ More The recently claimed anomaly in the measurement of the 21 cm hydrogen absorption signal by EDGES at $z\sim 17$, if cosmological, requires the existence of new physics. The possible attempts to resolve the anomaly rely on either (i) cooling the hydrogen gas via new dark matter-hydrogen interactions or (ii) modifying the soft photon background beyond the standard CMB one, as possibly suggested also by the ARCADE~2 excess. We argue that solutions belonging to the first class are generally in tension with cosmological dark matter probes once simple dark sector models are considered. Therefore, we propose soft photon emission by light dark matter as a natural solution to the 21 cm anomaly, studying a few realizations of this scenario. We find that the signal singles out a photophilic dark matter candidate characterised by an enhanced collective decay mechanism, such as axion mini-clusters. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 7 pages, 2 figures

Report number: CERN-TH-2018-053

Light Primordial Exotic Compact Objects as All Dark Matter

Authors: Martti Raidal, Sergey Solodukhin, Ville Vaskonen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: The radiation emitted by horizonless exotic compact objects (ECOs), such as wormholes, 2-2-holes, fuzzballs, gravastars, boson stars, collapsed polymers, superspinars etc., is expected to be strongly suppressed when compared to the radiation of black holes. If large primordial curvature fluctuations collapse into such objects instead of black holes, they do not evaporate or evaporate much slower t… ▽ More The radiation emitted by horizonless exotic compact objects (ECOs), such as wormholes, 2-2-holes, fuzzballs, gravastars, boson stars, collapsed polymers, superspinars etc., is expected to be strongly suppressed when compared to the radiation of black holes. If large primordial curvature fluctuations collapse into such objects instead of black holes, they do not evaporate or evaporate much slower than black holes and could thus constitute all of the dark matter with masses below $M < 10^{-16}M_\odot.$ We reevaluate the relevant experimental constraints for light ECOs in this mass range and show that very large new parameter space down to ECO masses $M\sim 10\,{\rm TeV}$ opens up for light primordial dark matter. A new dedicated experimental program is needed to test this mass range of primordial dark matter. △ Less

Submitted 12 June, 2018; v1 submitted 21 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, 2 figures; minor changes to match the published version

Report number: CERN-TH-2018-035

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 123520 (2018)

Wormholes in conformal gravity

Authors: Manuel Hohmann, Christian Pfeifer, Martti Raidal, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We present a new class of solutions for static spherically symmetric wormhole spacetimes in conformal gravity and outline a detailed method for their construction. As an explicit example, we construct a class of traversable and non-traversable wormholes that are locally conformal to Schwarzschild-(anti) de Sitter spacetimes. These wormhole spacetimes are exact vacuum solutions in, but not being li… ▽ More We present a new class of solutions for static spherically symmetric wormhole spacetimes in conformal gravity and outline a detailed method for their construction. As an explicit example, we construct a class of traversable and non-traversable wormholes that are locally conformal to Schwarzschild-(anti) de Sitter spacetimes. These wormhole spacetimes are exact vacuum solutions in, but not being limited to, Weyl gravity and conformal scalar-tensor theories. Importantly, the method implies that every conformal theory of gravity with static spherically symmetric solutions will trivially contain wormholes without the need for exotic matter. Applying those results on gravitational theories that possess conformal symmetry in the ultraviolet regime, the central singularities of black holes can be replaced with wormhole throats. We speculate on possible phenomenological consequences. We also discuss the inclusion of matter fields and give explicit examples of charged wormholes in Weyl gravity and conformal scalar-tensor gravity. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2018; v1 submitted 6 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 24 pages, 3 figures. To appear in JCAP. References updated, examples of charged wormholes added

Report number: CERN-TH-2018-026

Journal ref: JCAP 1810 (2018) no.10, 003

Statistical Analyses of Higgs- and Z-Portal Dark Matter Models

Authors: John Ellis, Andrew Fowlie, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal

Abstract: We perform frequentist and Bayesian statistical analyses of Higgs- and Z-portal models of dark matter particles with spin 0, 1/2 and 1. Our analyses incorporate data from direct detection and indirect detection experiments, as well as LHC searches for monojet and monophoton events, and we also analyze the potential impacts of future direct detection experiments. We find acceptable regions of the p… ▽ More We perform frequentist and Bayesian statistical analyses of Higgs- and Z-portal models of dark matter particles with spin 0, 1/2 and 1. Our analyses incorporate data from direct detection and indirect detection experiments, as well as LHC searches for monojet and monophoton events, and we also analyze the potential impacts of future direct detection experiments. We find acceptable regions of the parameter spaces for Higgs-portal models with real scalar, neutral vector, Majorana or Dirac fermion dark matter particles, and Z-portal models with Majorana or Dirac fermion dark matter particles. In many of these cases, there are interesting prospects for discovering dark matter particles in Higgs or Z decays, as well as dark matter particles weighing $\gtrsim 100$ GeV. Negative results from planned direct detection experiments would still allow acceptable regions for Higgs- and Z-portal models with Majorana or Dirac fermion dark matter particles. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2018; v1 submitted 27 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: 9 figures, 8 tables, 34 pages. v3: closely matches published version

Report number: CoEPP-MN-17-20, KCL-PH-TH-58, CERN-TH-2017-246

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 115014 (2018)

Search for Dark Matter Effects on Gravitational Signals from Neutron Star Mergers

Authors: John Ellis, Andi Hektor, Gert Hütsi, Kristjan Kannike, Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal, Ville Vaskonen

Abstract: Motivated by the recent detection of the gravitational wave signal emitted by a binary neutron star merger, we analyse the possible impact of dark matter on such signals. We show that dark matter cores in merging neutron stars may yield an observable supplementary peak in the gravitational wave power spectral density following the merger, which could be distinguished from the features produced by… ▽ More Motivated by the recent detection of the gravitational wave signal emitted by a binary neutron star merger, we analyse the possible impact of dark matter on such signals. We show that dark matter cores in merging neutron stars may yield an observable supplementary peak in the gravitational wave power spectral density following the merger, which could be distinguished from the features produced by the neutron components. △ Less

Submitted 15 May, 2018; v1 submitted 16 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures; minor changes to match the published version

Report number: CERN-TH-2017-208, KCL-PH-TH/2017-50

Journal ref: Phys. Lett. B781, 607-610 (2018)

Oscillating Spin-2 Dark Matter

Authors: Luca Marzola, Martti Raidal, Federico R. Urban

Abstract: We show that the coherent oscillations of a spin-2 field from bimetric theory can easily account for the observed dark matter abundance. We obtain the equation of motion for the field in a cosmological setting and discuss in detail the phenomenology of the model. The framework is testable in precision measurements of oscillating electric charge in atomic clocks, using atomic spectroscopy and in de… ▽ More We show that the coherent oscillations of a spin-2 field from bimetric theory can easily account for the observed dark matter abundance. We obtain the equation of motion for the field in a cosmological setting and discuss in detail the phenomenology of the model. The framework is testable in precision measurements of oscillating electric charge in atomic clocks, using atomic spectroscopy and in dedicated resonant mass detectors as well as in axion-like-particles experiments, which therefore provide a new window to probe and test gravity itself. We also comment on possible multimetric extensions of the framework that straightforwardly implement the clockwork mechanism for gravity. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 5 pages + references

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 024010 (2018)

Vacuum Stability and Perturbativity of SU(3) Scalars

Authors: Matti Heikinheimo, Kristjan Kannike, Florian Lyonnet, Martti Raidal, Kimmo Tuominen, Hardi Veermäe

Abstract: We calculate the vacuum stability conditions and renormalisation group equations for the extensions of standard model with a higher colour multiplet scalar up to the representation $\mathbf{15'}$ that leaves the strong interaction asymptotically free. In order to find the vacuum stability conditions, we calculate the orbit spaces for the self-couplings of the higher multiplets, which for the repre… ▽ More We calculate the vacuum stability conditions and renormalisation group equations for the extensions of standard model with a higher colour multiplet scalar up to the representation $\mathbf{15'}$ that leaves the strong interaction asymptotically free. In order to find the vacuum stability conditions, we calculate the orbit spaces for the self-couplings of the higher multiplets, which for the representations $\mathbf{15}$ and $\mathbf{15'}$ of $SU(3)_c$ are highly complicated. However, if the scalar potential is linear in orbit space variables, it is sufficient to know the convex hull of the orbit space. In contrast to the self-couplings of other multiplets, we find that the scalar quartic couplings of the representations $\mathbf{3}$ and $\mathbf{8}$ walk rather than run, remaining nearly constant and perturbative over a vast energy range. We describe the conditions for walking couplings using a schematic model. With these technical results at hand we revise earlier results of generation of new scales with large $SU(3)_c$ scalar multiplets. Our results are easily extendable to models of new physics with additional $SU(3)$ or SU($N$) gauge symmetries. △ Less

Submitted 27 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 26 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables

Report number: HIP-2017-19/TH

Collisionless shocks in self-interacting dark matter

Authors: Matti Heikinheimo, Martti Raidal, Christian Spethmann, Hardi Veermae

Abstract: Self-interacting dark matter has been proposed as a solution to small scale problems in cosmological structure formation, and hints of dark matter self scattering have been observed in mergers of galaxy clusters. One of the simplest models for self-interacting dark matter is a particle that is charged under dark electromagnetism, a new gauge interaction analogous to the usual electromagnetic force… ▽ More Self-interacting dark matter has been proposed as a solution to small scale problems in cosmological structure formation, and hints of dark matter self scattering have been observed in mergers of galaxy clusters. One of the simplest models for self-interacting dark matter is a particle that is charged under dark electromagnetism, a new gauge interaction analogous to the usual electromagnetic force, but operating on the dark matter particle instead of the visible particles. In this case, the collisional behaviour of dark matter is primarily due to the formation of collisionless shocks, that should affect the distribution of DM in merging galaxy clusters. We evaluate the time and length scales of shock formation in cluster mergers, and discuss the implications for modelling charged dark matter in cosmological simulations. △ Less

Submitted 12 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 6 pages + references, based on a talk at EPS plasma physics conference, June 26-30, 2017

Report number: HIP-2017-18/TH

Journal ref: Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion 60 014011, 2017