-
Optimal design of experiments in the context of machine-learning inter-atomic potentials: improving the efficiency and transferability of kernel based methods
Authors:
Bartosz Barzdajn,
Christopher P. Race
Abstract:
Data-driven, machine learning (ML) models of atomistic interactions are often based on flexible and non-physical functions that can relate nuanced aspects of atomic arrangements into predictions of energies and forces. As a result, these potentials are as good as the training data (usually results of so-called ab initio simulations) and we need to make sure that we have enough information for a mo…
▽ More
Data-driven, machine learning (ML) models of atomistic interactions are often based on flexible and non-physical functions that can relate nuanced aspects of atomic arrangements into predictions of energies and forces. As a result, these potentials are as good as the training data (usually results of so-called ab initio simulations) and we need to make sure that we have enough information for a model to become sufficiently accurate, reliable and transferable. The main challenge stems from the fact that descriptors of chemical environments are often sparse high-dimensional objects without a well-defined continuous metric. Therefore, it is rather unlikely that any ad hoc method of choosing training examples will be indiscriminate, and it will be easy to fall into the trap of confirmation bias, where the same narrow and biased sampling is used to generate train- and test- sets. We will demonstrate that classical concepts of statistical planning of experiments and optimal design can help to mitigate such problems at a relatively low computational cost. The key feature of the method we will investigate is that they allow us to assess the informativeness of data (how much we can improve the model by adding/swap** a training example) and verify if the training is feasible with the current set before obtaining any reference energies and forces -- a so-called off-line approach. In other words, we are focusing on an approach that is easy to implement and doesn't require sophisticated frameworks that involve automated access to high-performance computational (HPC).
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Molecular dynamics simulations of neutron induced collision cascades in Zr - statistical modelling of irradiation damage and potential applications
Authors:
Bartosz Barzdajn,
Christopher P Race
Abstract:
Understanding the nature of irradiation damage often requires a multi-scale and multi-physics approach, i.e. it requires a significant amount of information from experiments, simulations and phenomenological models. This paper focuses on the initial stages of irradiation damage, namely neutron-induced displacement cascades in zirconium, as nuclear-grade zirconium alloys are widely used in fuel ass…
▽ More
Understanding the nature of irradiation damage often requires a multi-scale and multi-physics approach, i.e. it requires a significant amount of information from experiments, simulations and phenomenological models. This paper focuses on the initial stages of irradiation damage, namely neutron-induced displacement cascades in zirconium, as nuclear-grade zirconium alloys are widely used in fuel assemblies. We provide results of large-scale molecular dynamics (MD) simulations based on existing inter-atomic potentials and the two-temperature model to include the effect of electron-phonon coupling. Our data can be used directly in higher scale methods. Furthermore, we analysed summary statistics associated with defect production, such as the number of defects produced, their distribution and the size of clusters. As a result, we have developed a generative model of collision cascades. The model is hierarchical, as well as stochastic, i.e. it includes the variance of the considered features. This development had three main objectives: to establish a sufficient descriptor of a cascade, to develop an interpolator of data obtained from high-fidelity simulations, and to demonstrate that the statistical model of the data can generate representative distributions of primary irradiation defects. The results can be used to generate synthetic inputs for longer length- and time-scale models, as well as to build fast approximations relating dose, damage and irradiation conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Exploring descriptors for titanium microstructure via digital fingerprints from variational autoencoders
Authors:
Michael D. White,
Gowtham Nimmal Haribabu,
Jeyapriya Thimukonda Jegadeesan,
Bikramjit Basu,
Philip J. Withers,
Chris P. Race
Abstract:
Microstructure is key to controlling and understanding the properties of metallic materials, but traditional approaches to describing microstructure capture only a small number of features. To enable data-centric approaches to materials discovery, allow efficient storage of microstructural data and assist in quality control in metals processing, we require more complete descriptors of microstructu…
▽ More
Microstructure is key to controlling and understanding the properties of metallic materials, but traditional approaches to describing microstructure capture only a small number of features. To enable data-centric approaches to materials discovery, allow efficient storage of microstructural data and assist in quality control in metals processing, we require more complete descriptors of microstructure. The concept of microstructural fingerprinting, using machine learning (ML) to develop quantitative, low-dimensional descriptors of microstructures, has recently attracted significant attention. However, it is difficult to interpret conclusions drawn by ML algorithms, which are commonly referred to as "black boxes".
Here we explore variational autoencoders (VAEs), which can be trained to produce microstructural fingerprints in a continuous latent space. VAEs enable the reconstruction of images from fingerprints, allowing us to explore how key features of microstructure are encoded. We develop a VAE architecture based on ResNet18 and train it on Ti-6Al-4V optical micrographs as an example of an industrially important alloy where microstructural control is critical to performance. The latent space is explored in several ways, including by supplying interpolated and randomly perturbed fingerprints to the trained decoder and via dimensionality reduction to explore the distribution of microstructural features within the latent space of fingerprints. We show that the VAE fingerprints exhibit smooth, interpolable behaviour with stability to local perturbations, supporting their suitability as general purpose descriptors for microstructure. We also show that key properties of the microstructures are strongly correlated with position in the latent space, supporting the use of VAE fingerprints for quantitative exploration of process-structure-property relationships.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Interaction of monoclinic ZrO$_2$ grain boundaries with oxygen vacancies, Sn and Nb -- implications for the corrosion of Zr alloy fuel cladding
Authors:
Maria S. Yankova,
Christopher P. Race
Abstract:
We used density-functional-theory simulations to examine the structural and electronic properties of the $Σ180°(100)[001] $ grain boundary in monoclinic ZrO$_2$, which is a very low-energy (0.06Jm$^{-2}$) twin boundary present in experimental oxide texture maps, with suggested special properties. This equilibrium structure was compared with a metastable structure (with a boundary energy of 0.32Jm…
▽ More
We used density-functional-theory simulations to examine the structural and electronic properties of the $Σ180°(100)[001] $ grain boundary in monoclinic ZrO$_2$, which is a very low-energy (0.06Jm$^{-2}$) twin boundary present in experimental oxide texture maps, with suggested special properties. This equilibrium structure was compared with a metastable structure (with a boundary energy of 0.32Jm$^{-2}$), which was considered to be representative of a more general oxide boundary. The interaction of oxygen vacancies, substitutional Sn and Nb defects (substituting host Zr sites) with both structures - and their effect on the boundary properties - were examined. We found that the equilibrium structure energetically favours V$_\textrm{O}^{2+}$ and Nb$_\textrm{Zr}^{2-}$, whereas the metastable structure favours V$_\textrm{O}^{2+}$ and Sn$_\textrm{Zr}^{2-}$. Tin was further found to bind strongly with oxygen vacancies in both structures, and introduce gap states in the band gap of their electronic structure. Sn$_\textrm{Zr}^{2-}$ was, however, found to increase the segregation preference of V$_\textrm{O}^{2+}$ for the metastable structure, which might contribute to increased oxygen and electron transport down this interface, and therefore other more general boundaries, compared to the equilibrium structure of the studied monoclinic twin boundary.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Digital Fingerprinting of Microstructures
Authors:
Michael D. White,
Alexander Tarakanov,
Christopher P. Race,
Philip J. Withers,
Kody J. H. Law
Abstract:
Finding efficient means of fingerprinting microstructural information is a critical step towards harnessing data-centric machine learning approaches. A statistical framework is systematically developed for compressed characterisation of a population of images, which includes some classical computer vision methods as special cases. The focus is on materials microstructure. The ultimate purpose is t…
▽ More
Finding efficient means of fingerprinting microstructural information is a critical step towards harnessing data-centric machine learning approaches. A statistical framework is systematically developed for compressed characterisation of a population of images, which includes some classical computer vision methods as special cases. The focus is on materials microstructure. The ultimate purpose is to rapidly fingerprint sample images in the context of various high-throughput design/make/test scenarios. This includes, but is not limited to, quantification of the disparity between microstructures for quality control, classifying microstructures, predicting materials properties from image data and identifying potential processing routes to engineer new materials with specific properties. Here, we consider microstructure classification and utilise the resulting features over a range of related machine learning tasks, namely supervised, semi-supervised, and unsupervised learning.
The approach is applied to two distinct datasets to illustrate various aspects and some recommendations are made based on the findings. In particular, methods that leverage transfer learning with convolutional neural networks (CNNs), pretrained on the ImageNet dataset, are generally shown to outperform other methods. Additionally, dimensionality reduction of these CNN-based fingerprints is shown to have negligible impact on classification accuracy for the supervised learning approaches considered. In situations where there is a large dataset with only a handful of images labelled, graph-based label propagation to unlabelled data is shown to be favourable over discarding unlabelled data and performing supervised learning. In particular, label propagation by Poisson learning is shown to be highly effective at low label rates.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2024; v1 submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Validating x-ray line-profile defect analysis using atomistic models of deformed material
Authors:
C P Race,
T Ungar,
G Ribarik
Abstract:
The population of dislocation defects in a crystalline material strongly influences its properties, so the ability to analyse this population in experimental samples is of great utility. As a complement to direct counting in the transmission electron microscope, quantitative analysis of x-ray diffraction line profiles is an important tool. This is an indirect approach to quantification and so requ…
▽ More
The population of dislocation defects in a crystalline material strongly influences its properties, so the ability to analyse this population in experimental samples is of great utility. As a complement to direct counting in the transmission electron microscope, quantitative analysis of x-ray diffraction line profiles is an important tool. This is an indirect approach to quantification and so requires careful validation of the physical models that underly the inferential process. Here we undertake to directly evaluate the ability of line profile analysis to quantify aspects of the dislocation and stacking fault populations by exploiting atomistic models of deformed copper single crystals. We directly analyse these models to determine exact details of the defect content (our "ground truth"). We then generate theoretical line profiles for the models and analyse them using the same procedures used in experimental analysis. This leads to inferred measures of the defect content which we are able to compare with the exact data. We show that line profile analysis is able to provide sound predictions of both dislocation density and stacking fault fraction across two orders of magnitude. We further show how the outer cut-off radius in the mean-square strain of a dislocation distribution invoked by Warren and Averbach corresponds to the cell size in an artificially constructed restrictedly-random distribution of dislocations according to the model of Wilkens. Overall, our results lend important new support to the use of line profile analysis for the quantification of line and planar defects in crystalline materials.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2022; v1 submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Validation of x-ray line-profile analysis of extended defects in deformed crystals
Authors:
C P Race,
T Ungar,
G Ribarik
Abstract:
Quantitative measurements of extended defects in crystalline materials are important in understanding material behaviour. X-ray line profile analysis provides a complement to direct counting in the electron microscope, but is an indirect method and requires validation. Previous studies have focused on comparing x-ray analysis to electron microscopy results. Instead, we use simulated defective mate…
▽ More
Quantitative measurements of extended defects in crystalline materials are important in understanding material behaviour. X-ray line profile analysis provides a complement to direct counting in the electron microscope, but is an indirect method and requires validation. Previous studies have focused on comparing x-ray analysis to electron microscopy results. Instead, we use simulated defective material with known defect content and apply line profile analysis to calculated diffraction profiles to directly show that line profile analysis can reliably quantify dislocations and stacking faults.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Oleylamine aging of PtNi nanoparticles giving enhanced functionality for the oxygen reduction reaction
Authors:
Gerard M Leteba,
Yi-Chi Wang,
Thomas J A Slater,
Rongsheng Cai,
Conor Byrne,
Christopher P Race,
David R G Mitchell,
Pieter B J Levecque,
Neil P Young,
Alex Walton,
Angus I Kirkland,
Sarah J Haigh,
Candace I Lang
Abstract:
We report a rapid solution-phase strategy to synthesize alloyed PtNi nanoparticles which demonstrate outstanding functionality for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). This one-pot co-reduction colloidal synthesis results in a monodisperse population of single-crystal nanoparticles of rhombic dodecahedral morphology, with Pt enriched edges and compositions close to Pt1Ni2. We use nanoscale 3D comp…
▽ More
We report a rapid solution-phase strategy to synthesize alloyed PtNi nanoparticles which demonstrate outstanding functionality for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). This one-pot co-reduction colloidal synthesis results in a monodisperse population of single-crystal nanoparticles of rhombic dodecahedral morphology, with Pt enriched edges and compositions close to Pt1Ni2. We use nanoscale 3D compositional analysis to reveal for the first time that oleylamine (OAm)-aging of the rhombic dodecahedral Pt1Ni2 particles results in Ni leaching from surface facets, producing aged particles with concave faceting, an exceptionally high surface area and a composition of Pt2Ni1. We show that the modified atomic nanostructures catalytically outperform the original PtNi rhombic dodecahedral particles by more than 2-fold and also yield improved cycling durability. Their functionality for the ORR far exceeds commercially available Pt/C nanoparticle electrocatalysts, both in terms of mass-specific activities (up to a 25-fold increase) and intrinsic area-specific activities (up to a 27-fold increase).
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Development of data-driven spd tight-binding models of Fe -- parameterisation based on QSGW and DFT calculations including information about higher-order elastic constants
Authors:
Bartosz Barzdajn,
Alexander M Garrett,
Thomas M Whiting,
Christopher P Race
Abstract:
Quantum-mechanical (QM) simulations, thanks to their predictive power, can provide significant insights into the nature and dynamics of defects such as vacancies, dislocations and grain boundaries. These considerations are essential in the context of the development of reliable, inexpensive and environmentally friendly alloys. However, despite significant progress in computer performance, QM simul…
▽ More
Quantum-mechanical (QM) simulations, thanks to their predictive power, can provide significant insights into the nature and dynamics of defects such as vacancies, dislocations and grain boundaries. These considerations are essential in the context of the development of reliable, inexpensive and environmentally friendly alloys. However, despite significant progress in computer performance, QM simulations of defects are still extremely time-consuming with ab-initio/non-parametric methods. The two-centre Slater-Koster (SK) tight-binding (TB) models can achieve significant computational efficiency and provide an interpretable picture of the electronic structure. In some cases, this makes TB a compelling alternative to models based on abstraction of the electronic structure, such as the embedded atom model. The biggest challenge in the implementation of the SK method is the estimation of the optimal and transferable parameters that are used to construct the Hamiltonian matrix. In this paper, we will present results of the development of a data-driven framework, following the classical approach of adjusting parameters in order to recreate properties that can be measured or estimated using ab-initio or non-parametric methods. Distinct features include incorporation of data from QSGW (quasi-particle self-consistent GW approximation) calculations, as well as consideration of higher-order elastic constants. Furthermore, we provide a description of the optimisation procedure, omitted in many publications, including the design stage. We also apply modern optimisation techniques that allow us to minimise constraints on the parameter space. In summary, this paper introduces some methodological improvements to the semi-empirical approach while addressing associated challenges and advantages.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
A First Principles Study of Zirconium Grain Boundaries
Authors:
Adam J Plowman,
Christopher P Race
Abstract:
We present the results of first-principles calculations of selected structural and thermodynamic properties of a set of grain boundaries (GBs) in zirconium, spanning a range of misorientation angles and boundary planes. We performed plane-wave density functional theory calculations on low-sigma grain boundaries - five symmetric tilt GBs (STGBs) and three twist GBs; all with misorientation axes abo…
▽ More
We present the results of first-principles calculations of selected structural and thermodynamic properties of a set of grain boundaries (GBs) in zirconium, spanning a range of misorientation angles and boundary planes. We performed plane-wave density functional theory calculations on low-sigma grain boundaries - five symmetric tilt GBs (STGBs) and three twist GBs; all with misorientation axes about [0001] and in optimised microscopic configurations - to gain insight into the associated atomistic structures. From studying the interface energetics, we found that higher GB excess volumes tended to be associated with higher GB energies. Furthermore, we examined how the interplanar spacing, volume per atom, and local atomic coordination at the GB deviated from equivalent quantities in bulk. We also defined a grain boundary width according to a threshold value of volume per atom, allowing us to rank the GBs by their relative thickness. We found the twist GBs to exhibit similar energetic and structural properties, whereas the STGBs demonstrated more variation. Our comprehensive analysis demonstrates how all five dimensions of GB space are crucial in determining properties such as the work of ideal separation and the length scale over which atoms are perturbed by the presence of the GB. So that our results can be useful for further investigations, we have published our data to a public repository (Zenodo). This data includes the optimised and initial structures, in addition to the computed interface energetics and structural properties.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
An Atomistic Modelling Study of the Properties of Dislocation Loops in Zirconium
Authors:
Rory Hulse,
Christopher P Race
Abstract:
Neutron irradiation progressively changes the properties of zirconium alloys: they harden and their average c/a lattice parameter ratio decreases with fluence. The bombardment by neutrons produces point defects, which evolve into dislocation loops that contribute to a non-uniform growth phenomenon called irradiation-induced growth (IIG). To gain insights into these dislocation loops in Zr we studi…
▽ More
Neutron irradiation progressively changes the properties of zirconium alloys: they harden and their average c/a lattice parameter ratio decreases with fluence. The bombardment by neutrons produces point defects, which evolve into dislocation loops that contribute to a non-uniform growth phenomenon called irradiation-induced growth (IIG). To gain insights into these dislocation loops in Zr we studied them using atomistic simulation. We constructed and relaxed dislocation loops of various types. We find that the energies of <a>-loops on different habit planes are similar, but our results indicate that they are most likely to form on the 1st prismatic plane and then reduce their energy by rotating onto the 2nd prismatic plane. By simulating loops of different aspect ratios, we find that, based on energetics alone, the shape of <a>-loops does not depend on character, and that these loops become increasingly elliptical as their size increases. Additionally, we find that interstitial <c/2+p>-loops and vacancy <c>-loops are both energetically feasible and so the possibility of these should be considered in future work. Our findings offer important insights into loop formation and evolution, which are difficult to probe experimentally.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.