Placebo Response is Driven by UCS Revaluation: Evidence, Neurophysiological Consequences and a Quantitative Model
Authors:
Luca Puviani,
Sidita Rama
Abstract:
Despite growing scientific interest in the placebo effect and increasing understanding of neurobiological mechanisms, theoretical modeling of the placebo response remains poorly developed. The most extensively accepted theories are expectation and conditioning, involving both conscious and unconscious information processing. However, it is not completely understood how these mechanisms can shape t…
▽ More
Despite growing scientific interest in the placebo effect and increasing understanding of neurobiological mechanisms, theoretical modeling of the placebo response remains poorly developed. The most extensively accepted theories are expectation and conditioning, involving both conscious and unconscious information processing. However, it is not completely understood how these mechanisms can shape the placebo response. We focus here on neural processes which can account for key properties of the response to substance intake. It is shown that placebo response can be conceptualized as a reaction of a distributed neural system within the central nervous system. Such a reaction represents an integrated component of the response to open substance administration (or to substance intake) and is updated through "unconditioned stimulus (UCS) revaluation" learning. The analysis leads to a theorem, which proves the existence of two distinct quantities coded within the brain, these are the expected or prediction outcome and the reactive response. We show that the reactive response is updated automatically by implicit revaluation lerning, while the expected outcome can also be modulated through conscious information processing. Conceptualizing the response to substance intake in terms of UCS revaluation learning leads to the theoretical formulation of a potential neuropharmacological treatment for increasing unlimitedly the effectiveness of a given drug.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
Prediction Errors Drive UCS Revaluation and not Classical Conditioning: Evidence and Neurophysiological Consequences
Authors:
Luca Puviani,
Sidita Rama,
Giorgio Vitetta
Abstract:
Nowadays, the experimental study of emotional learning is commonly based on classical conditioning paradigms and models, which have been thoroughly investigated in the last century. On the contrary, limited attention has been paid to the revaluation of an unconditioned stimulus (UCS), which, as experimentally observed by various researchers in the last four decades, occurs out of classical conditi…
▽ More
Nowadays, the experimental study of emotional learning is commonly based on classical conditioning paradigms and models, which have been thoroughly investigated in the last century. On the contrary, limited attention has been paid to the revaluation of an unconditioned stimulus (UCS), which, as experimentally observed by various researchers in the last four decades, occurs out of classical conditioning. For this reason, no analytical or quantitative theory has been developed for this phenomenon and its dynamics. Unluckily, models based on classical conditioning are unable to explain or predict important psychophysiological phenomena, such as the failure of the extinction of emotional responses in certain circumstances. In this manuscript an analytical representation of UCS revaluation learning is developed; this allows us to identify the conditions determining the "inextinguishability" (or resistant-to-extinction) property of emotional responses and reactions (such as those observed in evaluative conditioning, in the nonreinforcement presentation of a conditioned inhibitor, in post-traumatic stress disorders and in panic attacks). Furthermore, an analysis of the causal relation existing between classical conditioning and UCS revaluation is provided. Starting from this result, a theory of implicit emotional learning and a novel interpretation of classical conditioning are derived. Moreover, we discuss how the proposed theory can lead to the development of new methodologies for the detection and the treatment of undesired or pathological emotional responses, and can inspire animal models for resistant-to-extinction responses and reactions.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
