Showing 1–13 of 13 results for author: Puntel, D

Impact of a $MoS_2$ monolayer on the nanoscale thermoelastic response of silicon heterostructures

Authors: Davide Soranzio, Denny Puntel, Manuel Tuniz, Paulina E. Majchrzak, Alessandra Milloch, Nicholas M. Olsen, Wibke Bronsch, Bjarke S. Jessen, Danny Fainozzi, Jacopo S. Pelli Cresi, Dario De Angelis, Laura Foglia, Riccardo Mincigrucci, Xiaoyang Zhu, Cory R. Dean, Søren Ulstrup, Francesco Banfi, Claudio Giannetti, Fulvio Parmigiani, Filippo Bencivenga, Federico Cilento

Abstract: Understanding the thermoelastic response of a nanostructure is crucial for the choice of materials and interfaces in electronic devices with improved and tailored transport properties, at the length scales of the present technology. Here we show how the deposition of a $MoS_2$ monolayer can strongly modify the nanoscale thermoelastic dynamics of silicon substrates close to their interface. We achi… ▽ More Understanding the thermoelastic response of a nanostructure is crucial for the choice of materials and interfaces in electronic devices with improved and tailored transport properties, at the length scales of the present technology. Here we show how the deposition of a $MoS_2$ monolayer can strongly modify the nanoscale thermoelastic dynamics of silicon substrates close to their interface. We achieve this result by creating a transient grating with extreme ultraviolet light, using ultrashort free-electron laser pulses, whose $\approx$84 nm period is comparable to the size of elements typically used in nanodevices, such as electric contacts and nanowires. The thermoelastic response, featured by coherent acoustic waves and an incoherent relaxation, is tangibly modified by the presence of monolayer $MoS_2$. Namely, we observed a major reduction of the amplitude of the surface mode, which is almost suppressed, while the longitudinal mode is basically unperturbed, aside from a faster decay of the acoustic modulations. We interpret this behavior as a selective modification of the surface elasticity and we discuss the conditions to observe such effect, which might be of immediate relevance for the design of Si-based nanoscale devices. △ Less

Submitted 29 March, 2024; v1 submitted 28 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 27 pages, 15 figures

Ultrafast Band Structure Dynamics in Bulk 1$T$-VSe$_2$

Authors: Wibke Bronsch, Manuel Tuniz, Denny Puntel, Alessandro Giammarino, Fulvio Parmigiani, Yang-hao Chan, Federico Cilento

Abstract: Complex materials encompassing different phases of matter can display new photoinduced metastable states differing from those attainable under equilibrium conditions. These states can be realized when energy is injected in the material following a non-equilibrium pathway, unbalancing the unperturbed energy landscape of the material. Guided by the fact that photoemission experiments allow for detai… ▽ More Complex materials encompassing different phases of matter can display new photoinduced metastable states differing from those attainable under equilibrium conditions. These states can be realized when energy is injected in the material following a non-equilibrium pathway, unbalancing the unperturbed energy landscape of the material. Guided by the fact that photoemission experiments allow for detailed insights in the electronic band structure of ordered systems, here we study bulk 1T-VSe$_2$ in its metallic and charge-density-wave phase by time- and angle-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy. After near-infrared optical excitation, the system shows a net increase of the density of states in the energy range of the valence bands, in the vicinity of the Fermi level, lasting for several picoseconds. We discuss possible origins as band shifts or correlation effects on the basis of a band structure analysis. Our results uncover the possibility of altering the electronic band structure of bulk 1T-VSe$_2$ for low excitation fluences, contributing to the understanding of light-induced electronic states. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2024; v1 submitted 6 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Unveiling the physics of the spin-orbit coupling at the surface of a model topological insulator: from theory to experiments

Authors: Denny Puntel, Simone Peli, Wibke Bronsch, Federico Cilento, Hubert Ebert, Jürgen Braun, Fulvio Parmigiani

Abstract: Spin-orbit interaction affects the band structure of topological insulators beyond the opening of an inverted gap in the bulk bands, and the understanding of its effects on the surface states is of primary importance to access the underlying physics of these exotic states. Here, we propose an $\textit{ab initio}$ approach benchmarked by pump-probe angle-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy data to… ▽ More Spin-orbit interaction affects the band structure of topological insulators beyond the opening of an inverted gap in the bulk bands, and the understanding of its effects on the surface states is of primary importance to access the underlying physics of these exotic states. Here, we propose an $\textit{ab initio}$ approach benchmarked by pump-probe angle-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy data to model the effect of spin-orbit coupling on the surface states of a topological insulator. The critical novelty of our approach lies in the possibility of accounting for a partial transfer of the spin-orbit coupling to the surface states, mediated by the hybridization with the surface resonance states. In topological insulators, the fraction of transferred spin-orbit coupling influences the strength of the hexagonal war** of the surface states, which we use as a telltale of the capability of our model to reproduce the experimental dispersion. The comparison between calculations and measurements, of both the unoccupied and part of the occupied Dirac cone, indicates that the fraction of spin-orbit coupling transferred to the surface states by hybridization with the resonance states is between 70% and 85% of its full atomic value. This offers a valuable insight to improve the modeling of surface state properties in topological insulators for both scientific purposes and technological applications. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Nanoscale transient polarization gratings

Authors: Laura Foglia, Björn Wehinger, Giovanni Perosa, Riccardo Mincigrucci, Enrico Allaria, Francesco Armillotta, Alexander Brynes, Riccardo Cucini, Dario De Angelis, Giovanni De Ninno, W. Dieter Engel, Danny Fainozzi, Luca Giannessi, Nupur N. Khatu, Simone Laterza, Ettore Paltanin, Jacopo Stefano Pelli-Cresi, Giuseppe Penco, Denny Puntel, Primož Rebernik Ribič, Filippo Sottocorona, Mauro Trovò, Clemens von Korff Schmising, Kelvin Yao, Claudio Masciovecchio , et al. (2 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We present the generation of transient polarization gratings at the nanoscale, achieved using a tailored accelerator configuration of the FERMI free electron laser. We demonstrate the capabilities of such a transient polarization grating by comparing its induced dynamics with the ones triggered by a more conventional intensity grating on a thin film ferrimagnetic alloy. While the signal of the int… ▽ More We present the generation of transient polarization gratings at the nanoscale, achieved using a tailored accelerator configuration of the FERMI free electron laser. We demonstrate the capabilities of such a transient polarization grating by comparing its induced dynamics with the ones triggered by a more conventional intensity grating on a thin film ferrimagnetic alloy. While the signal of the intensity grating is dominated by the thermoelastic response of the system, such a contribution is suppressed in the case of the polarization grating. This exposes helicity-dependent magnetization dynamics that have so-far remained hidden under the large thermally driven response. We anticipate nanoscale transient polarization gratings to become useful for the study of any physical, chemical and biological systems possessing chiral symmetry. △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Out-of-equilibrium charge redistribution in a copper-oxide based superconductor by time-resolved X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy

Authors: Denny Puntel, Dmytro Kutnyakhov, Lukas Wenthaus, Markus Scholz, Nils O. Wind, Michael Heber, Günter Brenner, Genda Gu, Robert J. Cava, Wibke Bronsch, Federico Cilento, Fulvio Parmigiani, Federico Pressacco

Abstract: Charge-transfer excitations are of paramount importance for understanding the electronic structure of copper-oxide based high-temperature superconductors. In this study, we investigate the response of a Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{\mathrm{8}+ δ}$ crystal to the charge redistribution induced by an infrared ultrashort pulse. Element-selective time-resolved core-level photoelectron spectroscopy with a hi… ▽ More Charge-transfer excitations are of paramount importance for understanding the electronic structure of copper-oxide based high-temperature superconductors. In this study, we investigate the response of a Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{\mathrm{8}+ δ}$ crystal to the charge redistribution induced by an infrared ultrashort pulse. Element-selective time-resolved core-level photoelectron spectroscopy with a high energy resolution allows disentangling the dynamics of oxygen ions with different coordination and bonds thanks to their different chemical shifts. Our experiment shows that the O\,$1s$ component arising from the Cu-O planes is significantly perturbed by the infrared light pulse. Conversely, the apical oxygen, also coordinated with Sr ions in the Sr-O planes, remains unaffected. This result highlights the peculiar behavior of the electronic structure of the Cu-O planes. It also unlocks the way to study the out-of-equilibrium electronic structure of copper-oxide-based high-temperature superconductors by identifying the O\,$1s$ core-level emission originating from the oxygen ions in the Cu-O planes. This ability could be critical to gain information about the strongly-correlated electron ultrafast dynamical mechanisms in the Cu-O plane in the normal and superconducting phases. △ Less

Submitted 22 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Photoinduced dynamics of flat bands in the kagome metal CoSn

Authors: Denny Puntel, Wibke Bronsch, Manuel Tuniz, Mingu Kang, Paul M. Neves, Shiang Fang, Efthimios Kaxiras, Joseph G. Checkelsky, Riccardo Comin, Fulvio Parmigiani, Federico Cilento

Abstract: CoSn is a prototypical kagome compound showing lattice-born flat bands with suppressed bandwidth over large parts of the Brillouin zone. Here, by means of time- and angle-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy, we provide direct evidence of the response to photoexcitation of the flat bands, that underlie information about localization in real space. In particular, we detect a sudden shift and broaden… ▽ More CoSn is a prototypical kagome compound showing lattice-born flat bands with suppressed bandwidth over large parts of the Brillouin zone. Here, by means of time- and angle-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy, we provide direct evidence of the response to photoexcitation of the flat bands, that underlie information about localization in real space. In particular, we detect a sudden shift and broadening of the flat bands, while after one picosecond only a broadening survives. We ascribe both these effects to an ultrafast disruption of electron localization, which renormalizes the effective electron-electron interaction and affects the flat band dispersion. Since both variations are in the order of a few meV, our measurements suggest that the flat bands are resilient to near-infrared photoexcitation. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Ultrafast all-optical manipulation of the charge-density-wave in VTe$_{2}$

Authors: Manuel Tuniz, Davide Soranzio, Davide Bidoggia, Denny Puntel, Wibke Bronsch, Steven L. Johnson, Maria Peressi, Fulvio Parmigiani, Federico Cilento

Abstract: The charge-density wave (CDW) phase in the layered transition-metal dichalcogenide VTe$_{2}$ is strongly coupled to the band inversion involving vanadium and tellurium orbitals. In particular, this coupling leads to a selective disappearance of the Dirac-type states that characterize the normal phase, when the CDW phase sets in. Here, by means of broadband time-resolved optical spectroscopy (TR-OS… ▽ More The charge-density wave (CDW) phase in the layered transition-metal dichalcogenide VTe$_{2}$ is strongly coupled to the band inversion involving vanadium and tellurium orbitals. In particular, this coupling leads to a selective disappearance of the Dirac-type states that characterize the normal phase, when the CDW phase sets in. Here, by means of broadband time-resolved optical spectroscopy (TR-OS), we investigate the ultrafast reflectivity changes caused by collective and single particle excitations in the CDW ground state of VTe$_{2}$. Remarkably, our measurements show the presence of two collective (amplitude) modes of the CDW ground state. By applying a double-pulse excitation scheme, we show the possibility to manipulate these modes, demonstrating a more efficient way to control and perturb the CDW phase in VTe$_{2}$. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 5, 043276 - 21 December 2023

Dynamics and Resilience of the Charge Density Wave in a bilayer kagome metal

Authors: Manuel Tuniz, Armando Consiglio, Denny Puntel, Chiara Bigi, Stefan Enzner, Ganesh Pokharel, Pasquale Orgiani, Wibke Bronsch, Fulvio Parmigiani, Vincent Polewczyk, Phil D. C. King, Justin W. Wells, Ilija Zeljkovic, Pietro Carrara, Giorgio Rossi, Jun Fujii, Ivana Vobornik, Stephen D. Wilson, Ronny Thomale, Tim Wehling, Giorgio Sangiovanni, Giancarlo Panaccione, Federico Cilento, Domenico Di Sante, Federico Mazzola

Abstract: Long-range electronic order descending from a metallic parent state constitutes a rich playground to study the intricate interplay of structural and electronic degrees of freedom. With dispersive and correlation features as multifold as topological Dirac-like itinerant states, van-Hove singularities, correlated flat bands, and magnetic transitions at low temperature, kagome metals are located in t… ▽ More Long-range electronic order descending from a metallic parent state constitutes a rich playground to study the intricate interplay of structural and electronic degrees of freedom. With dispersive and correlation features as multifold as topological Dirac-like itinerant states, van-Hove singularities, correlated flat bands, and magnetic transitions at low temperature, kagome metals are located in the most interesting regime where both phonon and electronically mediated couplings are significant. Several of these systems undergo a charge density wave (CDW) transition, and the van-Hove singularities, which are intrinsic to the kagome tiling, have been conjectured to play a key role in mediating such an instability. However, to date, the origin and the main driving force behind this charge order is elusive. Here, we use the topological bilayer kagome metal ScV6Sn6 as a platform to investigate this puzzling problem, since it features both kagome-derived nested Fermi surface and van-Hove singularities near the Fermi level, and a CDW phase that affects the susceptibility, the neutron scattering, and the specific heat, similarly to the siblings AV3Sb5 (A = K, Rb, Cs) and FeGe. We report on our findings from high-resolution angle-resolved photoemission, density functional theory, and time-resolved optical spectroscopy to unveil the dynamics of its CDW phase. We identify the structural degrees of freedom to play a fundamental role in the stabilization of charge order. Along with a comprehensive analysis of the subdominant impact from electronic correlations, we find ScV6Sn6 to feature an instance of charge density wave order that predominantly originates from phonons. As we shed light on the emergent phonon profile in the low-temperature ordered regime, our findings pave the way for a deeper understanding of ordering phenomena in all CDW kagome metals. △ Less

Submitted 21 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

External screening and lifetime of exciton population in single-layer ReSe$_2$ probed by time- and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy

Authors: Klara Volckaert, Byoung Ki Choi, Hyuk ** Kim, Deepnarayan Biswas, Denny Puntel, Simone Peli, Fulvio Parmigiani, Federico Cilento, Young Jun Chang, Søren Ulstrup

Abstract: The semiconductor ReSe$_2$ is characterized by a strongly anisotropic optical absorption and is therefore promising as an optically active component in two-dimensional heterostructures. However, the underlying femtosecond dynamics of photoinduced excitations in such materials has not been sufficiently explored. Here, we apply an infrared optical excitation to single-layer ReSe$_2$ grown on a bilay… ▽ More The semiconductor ReSe$_2$ is characterized by a strongly anisotropic optical absorption and is therefore promising as an optically active component in two-dimensional heterostructures. However, the underlying femtosecond dynamics of photoinduced excitations in such materials has not been sufficiently explored. Here, we apply an infrared optical excitation to single-layer ReSe$_2$ grown on a bilayer graphene substrate and monitor the temporal evolution of the excited state signal using time- and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy. We measure an optical gap of $(1.53 \pm 0.02)$ eV, consistent with resonant excitation of the lowest exciton state. The exciton distribution is tunable via the linear polarization of the pump pulse and exhibits a biexponential decay with time constants given by $τ_1 = (110 \pm 10)$ fs and $τ_2 = (650 \pm 70)$ fs, facilitated by recombination via an in-gap state that is pinned at the Fermi level. By extracting the momentum-resolved exciton distribution we estimate its real-space radial extent to be greater than 17.1 Å, implying significant exciton delocalization due to screening from the bilayer graphene substrate. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Materials 7, L041001 (2023)

Van der Waals engineering of ultrafast carrier dynamics in magnetic heterostructures

Authors: Paulina Majchrzak, Klara Volckaert, Deepnarayan Biswas, Denny Puntel, Wibke Bronsch, Federico Cilento, Xing-Chen Pan, Yong P. Chen, Søren Ulstrup

Abstract: Heterostructures composed of the intrinsic magnetic topological insulator MnBi$_2$Te$_4$ and its non-magnetic counterpart Bi$_2$Te$_3$ host distinct surface band structures depending on the stacking order and exposed termination, allowing fine control of their magnetic, electronic and optical properties. Here, we probe the ultrafast dynamical response of MnBi$_2$Te$_4$ and MnBi$_4$Te$_7$ following… ▽ More Heterostructures composed of the intrinsic magnetic topological insulator MnBi$_2$Te$_4$ and its non-magnetic counterpart Bi$_2$Te$_3$ host distinct surface band structures depending on the stacking order and exposed termination, allowing fine control of their magnetic, electronic and optical properties. Here, we probe the ultrafast dynamical response of MnBi$_2$Te$_4$ and MnBi$_4$Te$_7$ following near-infrared optical excitation using time- and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy. We gain access to the out-of-equilibrium surface electronic structure of both MnBi$_2$Te$_4$ and Bi$_2$Te$_3$ surface terminations of MnBi$_4$Te$_7$, revealing an instantaneous occupation of states that are resonant with the optical excitation in the Bi$_2$Te$_3$ layer followed by carrier extraction into the adjacent MnBi$_2$Te$_4$ layers with a laser fluence-tunable delay of up to 350 fs. The ensuing thermal relaxation processes are driven by in-plane phonon scattering with significantly slower relaxation times in the magnetic MnBi$_2$Te$_4$ septuple layers. The competition of interlayer charge transfer and intralayer phonon scattering establishes MnBi$_2$Te$_4$-based compounds as a platform for controlling ultrafast charge transfer processes in combination with magnetism and topology in van der Waals heterostructures. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 17 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: A substantially revised version is published in Nano Letters (2023)

Ultrafast dynamics in (TaSe$_4$)$_2$I triggered by valence and core-level excitation

Authors: Wibke Bronsch, Manuel Tuniz, Giuseppe Crupi, Michela De Col, Denny Puntel, Davide Soranzio, Alessandro Giammarino, Michele Perlangeli, Helmuth Berger, Dario De Angelis, Danny Fainozzi, Ettore Paltanin, Stefano Pelli Cresi, Gabor Kurdi, Laura Foglia, Riccardo Mincigrucci, Fulvio Parmigiani, Filippo Bencivenga, Federico Cilento

Abstract: In this work, we study the out-of-equilibrium dynamics of the paradigmatic quasi-one-dimensional material (TaSe$_4$)$_2$I, that exhibits a transition into an incommensurate CDW phase when cooled just below room temperature, namely at T$_{\rm{CDW}} $= 263 K. We make use of both optical laser and free-electron laser (FEL) based time-resolved spectroscopies in order to study the effect of a selective… ▽ More In this work, we study the out-of-equilibrium dynamics of the paradigmatic quasi-one-dimensional material (TaSe$_4$)$_2$I, that exhibits a transition into an incommensurate CDW phase when cooled just below room temperature, namely at T$_{\rm{CDW}} $= 263 K. We make use of both optical laser and free-electron laser (FEL) based time-resolved spectroscopies in order to study the effect of a selective excitation on the normal-state and on the CDW phases, by probing the near-infrared/visible optical properties both along and perpendicularly to the direction of the CDW, where the system is metallic and insulating, respectively. Excitation of the core-levels by ultrashort X-ray FEL pulses at 47 eV and 119 eV induces reflectivity transients resembling those recorded when only exciting the valence band of the compound - by near-infrared pulses at 1.55 eV - in the case of the insulating sub-system. Conversely, the metallic sub-system displays a relaxation dynamics which depends on the energy of photo-excitation. Moreover, excitation of the CDW amplitude mode is recorded only for excitation at low-photon-energy. This fact suggests that the coupling of light to ordered states of matter can predominantly be achieved when directly injecting delocalized carriers in the valence band, rather than localized excitations in the core levels. On a complementary side, table-top experiments allow us to prove the quasi-unidirectional nature of the CDW phase in (TaSe$_4$)$_2$I, whose fingerprints are detected along its $c$-axis only. Our results provide new insights on the symmetry of the ordered phase of (TaSe$_4$)$_2$I perturbed by a selective excitation, and suggest a novel approach based on complementary table-top and FEL spectroscopies for the study of complex materials. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 24 pages, 7 figures

Polarization-resolved broadband time-resolved optical spectroscopy for complex materials: application to the case of MoTe$_2$ polytypes

Authors: Michele Perlangeli, Simone Peli, Davide Soranzio, Denny Puntel, Fulvio Parmigiani, Federico Cilento

Abstract: Time-resolved optical spectroscopy (TR-OS) has emerged as a fundamental spectroscopic tool for probing complex materials, to both investigate ground-state-related properties and trigger phase transitions among different states with peculiar electronic and lattice structures. We describe a versatile approach to perform polarization-resolved TR-OS measurements, by combining broadband detection with… ▽ More Time-resolved optical spectroscopy (TR-OS) has emerged as a fundamental spectroscopic tool for probing complex materials, to both investigate ground-state-related properties and trigger phase transitions among different states with peculiar electronic and lattice structures. We describe a versatile approach to perform polarization-resolved TR-OS measurements, by combining broadband detection with the capability to simultaneously probe two orthogonal polarization states. This method allows us to probe, with femtoseconds resolution, the frequency-resolved reflectivity or transmittivity variations along two mutually orthogonal directions, matching the principal axis of the crystal structure of the material under scrutiny. We report on the results obtained by acquiring the polarization-dependent transient reflectivity of two polytypes of the MoTe$_2$ compound, with 2H and 1T' crystal structures. We reveal marked anisotropies in the time-resolved reflectivity signal of 1T'-MoTe$_2$, which are connected to the crystal structure of the compound. Polarization- and time- resolved spectroscopic measurements can thus provide information about the nature and dynamics of both the electronic and crystal lattice subsystems, advancing the comprehension of their inter-dependence, in particular in the case of photoinduced phase transitions; in addition, they provide a broadband measurement of transient polarization rotations. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Journal ref: Optics Express 28, 8819 (2020)

High repetition rate Time-Resolved VUV ARPES at 10.8 eV photon energy

Authors: Simone Peli, Denny Puntel, Damir Kopic, Benjamin Sockol, Fulvio Parmigiani, Federico Cilento

Abstract: The quest for map** the femtosecond dynamics of the electronic band structure of complex materials via Time- and Angle-Resolved Photoelectron Spectroscopy (TR-ARPES) over their full First Brillouin Zone is pushing the development of schemes to efficiently generate ultrashort photon pulses in the VUV-range of photon energies. At present, the critical aspect is to combine a high photon energy with… ▽ More The quest for map** the femtosecond dynamics of the electronic band structure of complex materials via Time- and Angle-Resolved Photoelectron Spectroscopy (TR-ARPES) over their full First Brillouin Zone is pushing the development of schemes to efficiently generate ultrashort photon pulses in the VUV-range of photon energies. At present, the critical aspect is to combine a high photon energy with high photoemission count rates and a small pulse-bandwidth, necessary to achieve high energy resolution in ARPES, while preserving a good time resolution and mitigating space-charge effects. Here we describe a novel approach to produce light pulses at 10.8 eV, combining high repetition rate operation (1-4 MHz), high energy resolution ($\sim26$ meV) and space-charge free operation, with a time-resolution of $\sim$700 fs. These results have been achieved by generating the 9th harmonic of a Yb fiber laser, through a phase-matched process of third harmonic generation in Xenon of the laser third harmonic. The full up-conversion process is driven by a seed pulse energy as low as 10 $μ$J, hence is easily scalable to multi-MHz operation. This source opens the way to TR-ARPES experiments for the investigation of the electron dynamics over the full first Brillouin zone of most complex materials, with unprecedented energy and momentum resolutions and high count rates. The performances of our setup are tested in a number of experiments on WTe$_2$ and Bi$_2$Se$_3$, of which we measure the electronic band structure in energy, two-dimensional momentum and time. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Comments: 11 pages, 8 figures