-
"Phase Transitions" in small systems: why standard threshold definitions fail for nanolasers
Authors:
G. L. Lippi,
T. Wang,
G. P. Puccioni
Abstract:
Since the development of micro- and nanolasers, the question of laser threshold has been subject to debate. Different definitions have been used to try and establish its occurrence, often encountering major obstacles. We examine a set of common physical definitions which we apply to measurements taken in a micro-VCSEL. Their predictions not only clearly disagree, pointing to different pump values…
▽ More
Since the development of micro- and nanolasers, the question of laser threshold has been subject to debate. Different definitions have been used to try and establish its occurrence, often encountering major obstacles. We examine a set of common physical definitions which we apply to measurements taken in a micro-VCSEL. Their predictions not only clearly disagree, pointing to different pump values at which the laser should cross threshold, but they also correspond to autocorrelation values which demonstrate very low field coherence. A topological analysis of the rate equations, with average spontaneous emission added to the lasing mode, clearly identifies the contradictions and explains the origin of the discrepancies. Additional considerations help understanding the failure of the approach and highlight the path towards a unique and general definition of threshold in all lasers, irrespective of their sizes. A critical scrutiny of the assumptions made in the rate equations with spontaneous emission illustrates their strength and weaknesses and better defines the bounds within which their predictions hold. We remark in the conclusions how the main results of this paper could hold for other small systems.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Second-order correlation function supported optical sensing for particle detection
Authors:
T. Wang,
C. Jiang,
J. Zou,
H. Zhou,
X. Lin,
H. Chen,
G. P. Puccioni,
G. Wang,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
We propose a new sensing method based on the measurement of the second-order autocorrelation of the output of micro- and nanolasers with intensity feedback. The sensing function is implemented through the feedback-induced threshold shift, whose photon statistics is controlled by the feedback level in a characteristic way for different laser sizes. The specific response offers performances which ca…
▽ More
We propose a new sensing method based on the measurement of the second-order autocorrelation of the output of micro- and nanolasers with intensity feedback. The sensing function is implemented through the feedback-induced threshold shift, whose photon statistics is controlled by the feedback level in a characteristic way for different laser sizes. The specific response offers performances which can be adapted to different kinds of sensors. We propose the implementation of two schemes capable of providing a quantitative sensing signal and covering a broad range of feedback levels: one is utilizing the evolution of g$^{(2)}$(0), the other one is the ratio between central and side peaks in g$^{(2)}(τ)$. Laser-threshold-based sensing could, thanks to its potential sensitivity, gain relevance in biomolecular diagnostics and security monitoring.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Methodological investigation into the noise influence on nanolasers' large signal modulation
Authors:
T. Wang,
J. L. Zou,
G. P. Puccioni,
W. S. Zhao,
X. Lin,
H. S. Chen,
G. F. Wang,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
Nanolasers are considered ideal candidates for communications and data processing at chip-level thanks to their extremely reduced footprint, low thermal load and potentially outstanding modulation bandwidth, which in some case has been numerically estimated to exceed hundreds of GHz. The few experimental implementations reported to date, however, have so-far fallen very short of such predictions,…
▽ More
Nanolasers are considered ideal candidates for communications and data processing at chip-level thanks to their extremely reduced footprint, low thermal load and potentially outstanding modulation bandwidth, which in some case has been numerically estimated to exceed hundreds of GHz. The few experimental implementations reported to date, however, have so-far fallen very short of such predictions, whether because of technical difficulties or of overoptimistic numerical results. We propose a methodology to study the physical characteristics which determine the system's robustness and apply it to a general model, using numerical simulations of large-signal modulation. Changing the DC pump values and modulation frequencies, we further investigate the influence of intrinsic noise, considering, in addition, the role of cavity losses. Our results confirm that significant modulation bandwidths can be achieved, at the expense of large pump values, while the often targeted low bias operation is strongly noise- and bandwidth-limited. This fundamental investigation suggests that technological efforts should be oriented towards enabling large pump rates in nanolasers, whose performance promises to surpass microdevices in the same range of photon flux and input energy.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Photon statistics and dynamics of nanolasers subject to intensity feedback
Authors:
T. Wang,
Z. L. Deng,
J. C. Sun,
X. H. Wang,
G. P. Puccioni,
G. F. Wang,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
Using a fully stochastic numerical scheme, we investigate the behaviour of a nanolaser in the low-coherence regime at the transition between spontaneous emission and lasing under the influence of intensity feedback. Studying the input-output curves as well as the second order correlations for different feedback fractions, we obtain an insight on the role played by the fraction of photons reinjecte…
▽ More
Using a fully stochastic numerical scheme, we investigate the behaviour of a nanolaser in the low-coherence regime at the transition between spontaneous emission and lasing under the influence of intensity feedback. Studying the input-output curves as well as the second order correlations for different feedback fractions, we obtain an insight on the role played by the fraction of photons reinjected into the cavity. The interpretation of the observation is strengthened through the comparison with the temporal traces of the emitted photons and with the radiofrequency power spectra. The results give insight into the physics of nanolasers as well as validate the use of the second order autocorrelation as a sufficient tool for the interpretation of the dynamics. This confirmation offers a solid basis for the reliance on autocorrelations in experiments studying the effects of feedback in nanodevices.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2019; v1 submitted 5 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Dynamics of a micro-VCSEL operated in the threshold region under low-level optical feedback
Authors:
Tao Wang,
Xianghu Wang,
Zhilei Deng,
Jiacheng Sun,
Gian Piero Puccioni,
Gaofeng Wang,
Gian Luca Lippi
Abstract:
Semiconductor lasers are notoriously sensitive to optical feedback, and their dynamics and coherence can be significantly modified through optical reinjection. We concentrate on the dynamical properties of a very small (i.e., microscale) Vertical Cavity Surface Emitting Laser (VCSEL) operated in the low coherence region between the emission of (partially) coherent pulses and ending below the accep…
▽ More
Semiconductor lasers are notoriously sensitive to optical feedback, and their dynamics and coherence can be significantly modified through optical reinjection. We concentrate on the dynamical properties of a very small (i.e., microscale) Vertical Cavity Surface Emitting Laser (VCSEL) operated in the low coherence region between the emission of (partially) coherent pulses and ending below the accepted macroscopic lasing threshold, with the double objective of: 1. studying the feedback influence in a regime of very low energy consumption; 2. using the micro-VCSEL as a surrogate for nanolasers, where measurements can only be based on photon statistics. The experimental investigation is based on time traces and radiofrequency spectra (common for macroscale devices) and correlation functions (required at the nanoscale). Comparison of these results confirms the ability of correlation functions to satisfactorily characterize the action of feedback on the laser dynamics. Numerical predictions obtained from a previously developed, fully stochastic modeling technique provide very close agreement with the experimental observations, thus supporting the possible extension of our observations to the nanoscale.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Photon bursts at lasing onset and modeling issues in micro-VCSELs
Authors:
T. Wang,
G. P. Puccioni,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
Spontaneous photon bursts are observed in the output collected from a mesoscale semiconductor-based laser near the lasing threshold. Their appearence is compared to predictions obtained from Laser Rate Equations and from a Stochastic Laser Simulator. While the latter is capable of predicting the observed large photon bursts, the photon numbers computed by the former produces a noisy trace well bel…
▽ More
Spontaneous photon bursts are observed in the output collected from a mesoscale semiconductor-based laser near the lasing threshold. Their appearence is compared to predictions obtained from Laser Rate Equations and from a Stochastic Laser Simulator. While the latter is capable of predicting the observed large photon bursts, the photon numbers computed by the former produces a noisy trace well below the experimentally detectable limit. We explain the discrepancy between the two approaches on the basis of an incorrect accounting of the onset of stimulated emission by the Rate Equations, which instead are capable of complementing the physical description through topological considerations.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2019; v1 submitted 21 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Analytical vs. Numerical Langevin Description of Noise in Small Lasers
Authors:
G. L. Lippi,
J. Mørk,
G. P. Puccioni
Abstract:
We compare the analytical and numerical predictions of noise in nano- and microcavity lasers obtained from a rate equation model with stochastic Langevin noise. Strong discrepancies are found between the two approaches and these are critically analyzed and explained on the basis of general considerations and through the comparison to the numerical predictions of a Stochastic Laser Simulator. While…
▽ More
We compare the analytical and numerical predictions of noise in nano- and microcavity lasers obtained from a rate equation model with stochastic Langevin noise. Strong discrepancies are found between the two approaches and these are critically analyzed and explained on the basis of general considerations and through the comparison to the numerical predictions of a Stochastic Laser Simulator. While the analytical calculations give reliable redictions, the numerical results are entirely incorrect thus unsuitable for predicting the dynamics and statistical properties of small lasers.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Exploration of Micro-VCSEL Ultra-low Biasing Scheme for Pulse Generation
Authors:
Tao Wang,
Gaofeng Wang,
Gian Piero Puccioni,
Gian Luca Lippi
Abstract:
The generation of optical pulses at ultra low bias level, thus low energy cost, is explored in a commercial microcavity semiconductor laser in view of testing the principle of energy efficient information encoding in potential integrated schemes. Sequences of regular, highly nonlinear pulses with acceptable amplitude stability are obtained from a commercial device as potential sources of bits wher…
▽ More
The generation of optical pulses at ultra low bias level, thus low energy cost, is explored in a commercial microcavity semiconductor laser in view of testing the principle of energy efficient information encoding in potential integrated schemes. Sequences of regular, highly nonlinear pulses with acceptable amplitude stability are obtained from a commercial device as potential sources of bits where the information is added by post-treatment (pulse removal). A discussion on the energy expenditure per bit is offered, together with the optimal frequency for pulse generation, which is found to lie slightly below the above-threshold value declared by the manufacturer.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2018; v1 submitted 12 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Onset of lasing in small devices: the identification of the first threshold
Authors:
Tao Wang,
Gian Piero Puccioni,
Gian Luca Lippi
Abstract:
We present a simple and flexible technique for identifying the onset of coherent emission in lasers, from the mesoscale to the nanoscale, which makes use of photon counting and a small amplitude modulation added to the pump. The optimal modulation frequency is obtained from the radiofrequency power spectrum of the unperturbed laser emission. The identification of the lasing onset rests on the appe…
▽ More
We present a simple and flexible technique for identifying the onset of coherent emission in lasers, from the mesoscale to the nanoscale, which makes use of photon counting and a small amplitude modulation added to the pump. The optimal modulation frequency is obtained from the radiofrequency power spectrum of the unperturbed laser emission. The identification of the lasing onset rests on the appearence of a resonance in the response of the zero-order autocorrelation function ($g^{(2)}(0)$) plotted as a function of the pump rate. The intrinsic simplicity of this technique and its use of photon counting make it an excellent tool for certifying the onset of laser emission in nanoscale sources.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Superthermal light emission and nontrivial photon statistics in small lasers
Authors:
T. Wang,
D. Aktas,
O. Alibart,
É. Picholle,
G. P. Puccioni,
S. Tanzilli,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
Photon statistical measurements on a semiconductor microlaser, obtained using single-photon counting techniques, show that a newly discovered spontaneous pulsed emission regime possesses superthermal statistical properties. The observed spike dynamics, typical of small-scale devices, is at the origin of an unexpected discordance between the probability density function and its representation in te…
▽ More
Photon statistical measurements on a semiconductor microlaser, obtained using single-photon counting techniques, show that a newly discovered spontaneous pulsed emission regime possesses superthermal statistical properties. The observed spike dynamics, typical of small-scale devices, is at the origin of an unexpected discordance between the probability density function and its representation in terms of the first moments, a discordance so far unnoticed in all devices. The impact of this new dynamics is potentially large, since coincidence techniques are presently the sole capable of characterizing light emitted by nanolasers.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020; v1 submitted 5 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Dynamics at Threshold in Mesoscale Class-B Lasers
Authors:
T. Wang,
H. Vergnet,
G. P. Puccioni,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
The threshold properties of very small lasers (down to the nanoscale) are a topic of active research in light of continuous progress in nanofabrication. With the help of a simple rate equation model we analyze the intrinsic, macroscopic dynamics of threshold crossing for Class B lasers. We use the deterministic aspects of the basic rate equations to extract some fundamental time constants from an…
▽ More
The threshold properties of very small lasers (down to the nanoscale) are a topic of active research in light of continuous progress in nanofabrication. With the help of a simple rate equation model we analyze the intrinsic, macroscopic dynamics of threshold crossing for Class B lasers. We use the deterministic aspects of the basic rate equations to extract some fundamental time constants from an approximate analysis of laser dynamics in the threshold region. Approximate solutions for the population inversion and for the field intensity, up to the point where the latter reaches macroscopic levels, are found and discussed. The resulting timescales characterize the laser's ability to respond to perturbations (external modulation or intrinsic fluctuations in the lasing transition region). Numerical verifications test the accuracy of these solutions and confirm their validity. The predictions are used to interpret experimental results obtained in mesoscale lasers and to speculated about their extension to nanolasers.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2017; v1 submitted 3 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Some fundamental considerations on the dynamics of class B laser threshold crossing
Authors:
G. P. Puccioni,
T. Wang,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
With the help of a simple rate equation model, we analyze the intrinsic dynamics of threshold crossing for Class B lasers. A thorough discussion of the characteristics and the limitations of this very commonly employed model, which provides excellent qualitative predictions on the laser behaviour, is offered. Approximate solutions for the population inversion and for the field intensity, up to the…
▽ More
With the help of a simple rate equation model, we analyze the intrinsic dynamics of threshold crossing for Class B lasers. A thorough discussion of the characteristics and the limitations of this very commonly employed model, which provides excellent qualitative predictions on the laser behaviour, is offered. Approximate solutions for the population inversion and for the field intensity, up to the point where the latter reaches macroscopic levels, are found and discussed, together with the associated characteristic times. Numerical verifications test the accuracy of these solutions and confirm their validity. A discussion of the implications on threshold dynamics is presented, together with the motivation for focussing on this -- nowadays most common -- class of lasers.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Stochastic Simulator for modeling the transition to lasing
Authors:
G. P. Puccioni,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
A Stochastic Simulator (SS) is proposed, based on a semiclassical description of the radiation-matter interaction, to obtain an efficient description of the lasing transition for devices ranging from the nanolaser to the traditional "macroscopic" laser. Steady-state predictions obtained with the SS agree both with more traditional laser modeling and with the description of phase transitions in sma…
▽ More
A Stochastic Simulator (SS) is proposed, based on a semiclassical description of the radiation-matter interaction, to obtain an efficient description of the lasing transition for devices ranging from the nanolaser to the traditional "macroscopic" laser. Steady-state predictions obtained with the SS agree both with more traditional laser modeling and with the description of phase transitions in small-sized systems, and provide additional information on fluctuations. Dynamical information can easily be obtained, with good computing time efficiency, which convincingly highlights the role of fluctuations at threshold.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2015; v1 submitted 5 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Fast dynamics and spectral properties of a multilongitudinal-mode semiconductor laser: evolution of an ensemble of driven, globally coupled nonlinear modes
Authors:
G. P. Puccioni,
G. L. Lippi
Abstract:
We analyze the fast transient dynamics of a multi-longitudinal mode semiconductor laser on the basis of a model with intensity coupling. The dynamics, coupled to the constraints of the system and the below-threshold initial conditions, imposes a faster growth of the side modes in the initial stages of the transient, thereby leading the laser through a sequence of states where the modal intensity d…
▽ More
We analyze the fast transient dynamics of a multi-longitudinal mode semiconductor laser on the basis of a model with intensity coupling. The dynamics, coupled to the constraints of the system and the below-threshold initial conditions, imposes a faster growth of the side modes in the initial stages of the transient, thereby leading the laser through a sequence of states where the modal intensity distribution dramatically differs from the asymptotic one. A detailed analysis of the below-threshold, deterministic dynamical evolution allows us to explain the modal dynamics in the strongly coupled regime where the total intensity peak and relaxation oscillations take place, thus providing an explanation for the modal dynamics observed in the slow, hidden evolution towards the asymptotic state (cf. Phys. Rev. A 85, 043823 (2012)). The dynamics of this system can be interpreted as the transient response of a driven, globally coupled ensemble of nonlinear modes evolving towards an equilibrium state. Since the qualitative dynamics do not depend on the details of the interaction but only on the structure of the coupling, our results hold for a whole class of globally, bilinearly coupled oscillators.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
