Showing 1–50 of 53 results for author: Price, R H

Binary Black Hole Coalescence Phenomenology from Numerical Relativity

Authors: Richard H. Price, Ritesh Bachhar, Gaurav Khanna

Abstract: The major source of ground-based gravitational wave detectors, the inspiral and merger of comparable mass binary black holes (BBH), consists of a slow quasicircular inspiral, a merger to form a single remnant hole, and the quasinormal ringing of that remnant. The first and last of these epochs are amenable to well developed and familiar approximations: Newtonian or post-Newtonian for the first, an… ▽ More The major source of ground-based gravitational wave detectors, the inspiral and merger of comparable mass binary black holes (BBH), consists of a slow quasicircular inspiral, a merger to form a single remnant hole, and the quasinormal ringing of that remnant. The first and last of these epochs are amenable to well developed and familiar approximations: Newtonian or post-Newtonian for the first, and BH perturbation methods for the last. Ironically, the middle epoch, the merger, generates most of the GW emission, yet has been accessible so far only to numerical relativity. Here we add the close-limit approximation for the phenomenology of the merger. With the completed set of methods (Newtonian/post-Newtonian; close limit; BH perturbation theory) we show that not only can we understand the results of BBH coalescence, but - with reasonable accuracy - we can {\it predict} the resulting radiation and remnant. △ Less

Submitted 25 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, 12 figures, 2 tables

Black Hole Ringing, Quasinormal Modes, and Light Rings

Authors: Gaurav Khanna, Richard H. Price

Abstract: Modelling of gravitational waves from binary black hole inspiral has played an important role in the recent observations of such signals. The late-stage ringdown phase of the gravitational waveform is often associated with the null particle orbit ("light ring") of the black hole spacetime. With simple models we show that this link between the light ring and spacetime ringing is based more on the h… ▽ More Modelling of gravitational waves from binary black hole inspiral has played an important role in the recent observations of such signals. The late-stage ringdown phase of the gravitational waveform is often associated with the null particle orbit ("light ring") of the black hole spacetime. With simple models we show that this link between the light ring and spacetime ringing is based more on the history of specific models than on an actual constraining relationship. We also show, in particular, that a better understanding of the dissociation of the two may be relevant to the astrophysically interesting case of rotating (Kerr) black holes. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2017; v1 submitted 31 August, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 6 pages, 7 figures; to appear in PRD (rapid comm.)

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 95, 081501 (2017)

Arrival Times of Gravitational Radiation Peaks for Binary Inspiral

Authors: Richard H Price, Gaurav Khanna

Abstract: Modeling of gravitational waves (GWs) from binary black hole inspiral brings together early post-Newtonian waveforms and late quasinormal ringing waveforms. Attempts to bridge the two limits without recourse to numerical relativity involve predicting the time of the peak GW amplitude. This prediction will require solving the question of why the peak of the "source," i.e., the peak of the binary an… ▽ More Modeling of gravitational waves (GWs) from binary black hole inspiral brings together early post-Newtonian waveforms and late quasinormal ringing waveforms. Attempts to bridge the two limits without recourse to numerical relativity involve predicting the time of the peak GW amplitude. This prediction will require solving the question of why the peak of the "source," i.e., the peak of the binary angular velocity, does not correspond to the peak of the GW amplitude. We show here that this offset can be understood as due to the existence two distinct components of the radiation: the "direct" radiation analogous to that in flat spacetime, and "scattered" radiation associated with curved spacetime. The time dependence of these two components, and of their relative phases determines the location of the peak amplitude. We use a highly simplified model to clarify the twocomponent nature of the source, then demonstrate that the explanation is valid also for an extreme mass ratio binary inspiral. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2016; v1 submitted 14 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: 12 pages, 10 figures; revised version: figures clarified, typos corrected

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 94, 104026 (2016)

Black hole binary inspiral: Analysis of the plunge

Authors: Richard H. Price, Sourabh Nampalliwar, Gaurav Khanna

Abstract: Binary black hole coalescence has its peak of gravitational wave generation during the "plunge," the transition from quasicircular early motion to late quasinormal ringing. Although advances in numerical relativity have provided plunge waveforms, there is still no intuitive or phenomenological understanding of plungecomparable to that of the early and late stages. Here we make progress in developi… ▽ More Binary black hole coalescence has its peak of gravitational wave generation during the "plunge," the transition from quasicircular early motion to late quasinormal ringing. Although advances in numerical relativity have provided plunge waveforms, there is still no intuitive or phenomenological understanding of plungecomparable to that of the early and late stages. Here we make progress in develo** such understanding by focusing on the excitation of quasinormal ringing (QNR) during the plunge. We rely on insights of the linear mathematics of the particle perturbation model for the extreme mass limit. Our analysis, based on the Fourier domain Green function, and a simple initial model, point to the crucial role played by the kinematics near the "light ring" (the circular photon orbit) in determining the excitation of QNR. That insight is then shown to successfully explain Schwarzschild QNR found with evolution codes. Lastly, a phenomenological explanation is given for the underlying importance of the light ring. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2016; v1 submitted 19 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: Minor changes from the previous version have been made in this final version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 93, 044060 (2016)

Black hole binary inspiral and trajectory dominance

Authors: Richard H. Price, Gaurav Khanna, Scott A. Hughes

Abstract: Gravitational waves emitted during the inspiral, plunge and merger of a black hole binary carry linear momentum. This results in an astrophysically important recoil to the final merged black hole, a ``kick'' that can eject it from the nucleus of a galaxy. In a previous paper we showed that the puzzling partial cancellation of an early kick by a late antikick, and the dependence of the cancellation… ▽ More Gravitational waves emitted during the inspiral, plunge and merger of a black hole binary carry linear momentum. This results in an astrophysically important recoil to the final merged black hole, a ``kick'' that can eject it from the nucleus of a galaxy. In a previous paper we showed that the puzzling partial cancellation of an early kick by a late antikick, and the dependence of the cancellation on black hole spin, can be understood from the phenomenology of the linear momentum waveforms. Here we connect that phenomenology to its underlying cause, the spin-dependence of the inspiral trajectories. This insight suggests that the details of plunge can be understood more broadly with a focus on inspiral trajectories. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: 15 pages, 12 figures

Comparison of electromagnetic and gravitational radiation; what we can learn about each from the other

Authors: Richard H. Price, John W. Belcher, David A. Nichols

Abstract: We compare the nature of electromagnetic fields and of gravitational fields in linearized general relativity. We carry out this comparison both mathematically and visually. In particular the "lines of force" visualizations of electromagnetism are contrasted with the recently introduced tendex/vortex eigenline technique for visualizing gravitational fields. Specific solutions, visualizations, and c… ▽ More We compare the nature of electromagnetic fields and of gravitational fields in linearized general relativity. We carry out this comparison both mathematically and visually. In particular the "lines of force" visualizations of electromagnetism are contrasted with the recently introduced tendex/vortex eigenline technique for visualizing gravitational fields. Specific solutions, visualizations, and comparisons are given for an oscillating point quadrupole source. Among the similarities illustrated are the quasistatic nature of the near fields, the transverse 1/r nature of the far fields, and the interesting intermediate field structures connecting these two limiting forms. Among the differences illustrated are the meaning of field line motion, and of the flow of energy. △ Less

Submitted 19 December, 2012; originally announced December 2012.

Comments: 22 pages, 7 figures

Detection of pulsar beams deflected by the black hole in Sgr A*: effects of black hole spin

Authors: Sourabh Nampalliwar, Richard H. Price, Teviet Creighton, Fredrick A. Jenet

Abstract: Some Galactic models predict a significant population of radio pulsars close to the our galactic center. Beams from these pulsars could get strongly deflected by the supermassive black hole (SMBH) believed to reside at the galactic center and reach the Earth. Earlier work assuming a Schwarzschild SMBH gave marginal chances of observing this exotic phenomenon with current telescopes and good chance… ▽ More Some Galactic models predict a significant population of radio pulsars close to the our galactic center. Beams from these pulsars could get strongly deflected by the supermassive black hole (SMBH) believed to reside at the galactic center and reach the Earth. Earlier work assuming a Schwarzschild SMBH gave marginal chances of observing this exotic phenomenon with current telescopes and good chances with future telescopes. Here we calculate the odds of observability for a rotating SMBH. We find that the estimates of observation are not affected by the SMBH spin, but a pulsar timing analysis of deflected pulses might be able to provide an estimate of the spin of the central black hole. △ Less

Submitted 20 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: 15 pages aastex, 8 Figs

The Creation and Propagation of Radiation: Fields Inside and Outside of Sources

Authors: Stanislaw Olbert, John W. Belcher, Richard H. Price

Abstract: We present a new algorithm for computing the electromagnetic fields of currents inside and outside of finite current sources, for arbitrary time variations in the currents. Unexpectedly, we find that our solutions for these fields are free of the concepts of differential calculus, in that our solutions only involve the currents and their time integrals, and do not involve the time derivatives of t… ▽ More We present a new algorithm for computing the electromagnetic fields of currents inside and outside of finite current sources, for arbitrary time variations in the currents. Unexpectedly, we find that our solutions for these fields are free of the concepts of differential calculus, in that our solutions only involve the currents and their time integrals, and do not involve the time derivatives of the currents. As examples, we give the solutions for two configurations of current: a planar solenoid and a rotating spherical shell carrying a uniform charge density. For slow time variations in the currents, we show that our general solutions reduce to the standard expressions for the fields in classic magnetic dipole radiation. In the limit of extremely fast turn-on of the currents, we show that for our general solutions the amount of energy radiated is exactly equal to the magnetic energy stored in the static fields a long time after current creation. We give three associated problem statements which can be used in courses at the undergraduate level, and one problem statement suitable for courses at the graduate level. These problems are of physical interest because: (1) they show that current systems of finite extent can radiate even during time intervals when the currents are constant; (2) they explicitly display transit time delays across a source associated with its finite dimensions; and (3) they allow students to see directly the origin of the reaction forces for time-varying systems △ Less

Submitted 19 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: 25 pages, 5 figures

Sparse spectral-tau method for the three-dimensional helically reduced wave equation on two-center domains

Authors: Stephen R. Lau, Richard H. Price

Abstract: We describe a multidomain spectral-tau method for solving the three-dimensional helically reduced wave equation on the type of two-center domain that arises when modeling compact binary objects in astrophysical applications. A global two-center domain may arise as the union of Cartesian blocks, cylindrical shells, and inner and outer spherical shells. For each such subdomain, our key objective is… ▽ More We describe a multidomain spectral-tau method for solving the three-dimensional helically reduced wave equation on the type of two-center domain that arises when modeling compact binary objects in astrophysical applications. A global two-center domain may arise as the union of Cartesian blocks, cylindrical shells, and inner and outer spherical shells. For each such subdomain, our key objective is to realize certain (differential and multiplication) physical-space operators as matrices acting on the corresponding set of modal coefficients. We achieve sparse banded realizations through the integration "preconditioning" of Coutsias, Hagstrom, Hesthaven, and Torres. Since ours is the first three-dimensional multidomain implementation of the technique, we focus on the issue of convergence for the global solver, here the alternating Schwarz method accelerated by GMRES. Our methods may prove relevant for numerical solution of other mixed-type or elliptic problems, and in particular for the generation of initial data in general relativity. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2011; originally announced June 2011.

Comments: 37 pages, 3 figures, 12 tables

MSC Class: 65M70; 35M10; 83C35; 35L05

Systematics of black hole binary inspiral kicks and the slowness approximation

Authors: Richard H. Price, Gaurav Khanna, Scott A. Hughes

Abstract: During the inspiral and merger of black holes, the interaction of gravitational wave multipoles carries linear momentum away, thereby providing an astrophysically important recoil, or "kick" to the system and to the final black hole remnant. It has been found that linear momentum during the last stage (quasinormal ringing) of the collapse tends to provide an "antikick" that in some cases cancels a… ▽ More During the inspiral and merger of black holes, the interaction of gravitational wave multipoles carries linear momentum away, thereby providing an astrophysically important recoil, or "kick" to the system and to the final black hole remnant. It has been found that linear momentum during the last stage (quasinormal ringing) of the collapse tends to provide an "antikick" that in some cases cancels almost all the kick from the earlier (quasicircular inspiral) emission. We show here that this cancellation is not due to peculiarities of gravitational waves, black holes, or interacting multipoles, but simply to the fact that the rotating flux of momentum changes its intensity slowly. We show furthermore that an understanding of the systematics of the emission allows good estimates of the net kick for numerical simulations started at fairly late times, and is useful for understanding qualitatively what kinds of systems provide large and small net kicks. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 15 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D83:124002,2011

Observability of pulsar beam bending by the Sgr~A* black hole

Authors: Kevin Stovall, Teviet Creighton, Richard H. Price, Fredrick A. Jenet

Abstract: According to some models, there may be a significant population of radio pulsars in the Galactic center. In principle, a beam from one of these pulsars could pass close to the supermassive black hole (SMBH) at the center, be deflected, and be detected by Earth telescopes. Such a configuration would be an unprecedented probe of the properties of spacetime in the moderate- to strong-field regime of… ▽ More According to some models, there may be a significant population of radio pulsars in the Galactic center. In principle, a beam from one of these pulsars could pass close to the supermassive black hole (SMBH) at the center, be deflected, and be detected by Earth telescopes. Such a configuration would be an unprecedented probe of the properties of spacetime in the moderate- to strong-field regime of the SMBH. We present here background on the problem, and approximations for the probability of detection of such beams. We conclude that detection is marginally probable with current telescopes, but that telescopes that will be operating in the near future, with an appropriate multiyear observational program, will have a good chance of detecting a beam deflected by the SMBH. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2011; originally announced February 2011.

Comments: 18 pages, 16 figures

Detecting massive gravitons using pulsar timing arrays

Authors: Kejia Lee, Fredrick A. Jenet, Richard H. Price, Norbert Wex, Michael Kramer

Abstract: Massive gravitons are features of some alternatives to general relativity. This has motivated experiments and observations that, so far, have been consistent with the zero mass graviton of general relativity, but further tests will be valuable. A basis for new tests may be the high sensitivity gravitational wave experiments that are now being performed, and the higher sensitivity experiments tha… ▽ More Massive gravitons are features of some alternatives to general relativity. This has motivated experiments and observations that, so far, have been consistent with the zero mass graviton of general relativity, but further tests will be valuable. A basis for new tests may be the high sensitivity gravitational wave experiments that are now being performed, and the higher sensitivity experiments that are being planned. In these experiments it should be feasible to detect low levels of dispersion due to nonzero graviton mass. One of the most promising techniques for such a detection may be the pulsar timing program that is sensitive to nano-Hertz gravitational waves. Here we present some details of such a detection scheme. The pulsar timing response to a gravitational wave background with the massive graviton is calculated, and the algorithm to detect the massive graviton is presented. We conclude that, with 90% probability, massles gravitons can be distinguished from gravitons heavier than $3\times 10^{-22}$ eV (Compton wave length $λ_{\rm g}=4.1 \times 10^{12}$ km), if biweekly observation of 60 pulsars are performed for 5 years with pulsar RMS timing accuracy of 100 ns. If 60 pulsars are observed for 10 years with the same accuracy, the detectable graviton mass is reduced to $5\times 10^{-23}$ eV ($λ_{\rm g}=2.5 \times 10^{13}$ km); for 5-year observations of 100 or 300 pulsars, the sensitivity is respectively $2.5\times 10^{-22}$ ($λ_{\rm g}=5.0\times 10^{12}$ km) and $10^{-22}$ eV ($λ_{\rm g}=1.2\times 10^{13}$ km). Finally, a 10-year observation of 300 pulsars with 100 ns timing accuracy would probe graviton masses down to $3\times 10^{-23}$ eV ($λ_{\rm g}=4.1\times 10^{13}$ km). △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2010; v1 submitted 15 August, 2010; originally announced August 2010.

Comments: 13 pages, 5 figures, Accepted by ApJ

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.722:1589-1597,2010

NP Stokes fields for radio astronomy

Authors: Ezra T. Newman, Richard H. Price

Abstract: The spin weighted spherical harmonic (SWSH) description of angular functions typically is associated with the Newman-Penrose (NP) null tetrad formalism. Recently the SWSH description, but not the NP formalism, has been used in the study of the polarization anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background. Here we relate this application of SWSHs to a description of electromagnetic radiation and polar… ▽ More The spin weighted spherical harmonic (SWSH) description of angular functions typically is associated with the Newman-Penrose (NP) null tetrad formalism. Recently the SWSH description, but not the NP formalism, has been used in the study of the polarization anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background. Here we relate this application of SWSHs to a description of electromagnetic radiation and polarization in the NP formalism. In particular we introduce NP Stokes fields that are the NP equivalent of the Stokes parameters. In addition to giving a more coherent foundation for the recent cosmological SWSH application, the NP formalism aids in the computation of the Lorentz transformation properties of polarization. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2010; originally announced July 2010.

Comments: 11 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D82:083516,2010

Strong field effects on pulsar arrival times: general orientations

Authors: Y. Wang, T. Creighton, R. H. Price, F. A. Jenet

Abstract: A pulsar beam passing close to a black hole can provide a probe of very strong gravitational fields even if the pulsar itself is not in a strong field region. In the case that the spin of the hole can be ignored, we have previously shown that all strong field effects on the beam can be understood in terms of two "universal" functions, $F(φ_{\rm in})$ and $T(φ_{\rm in})$ of the angle of beam emis… ▽ More A pulsar beam passing close to a black hole can provide a probe of very strong gravitational fields even if the pulsar itself is not in a strong field region. In the case that the spin of the hole can be ignored, we have previously shown that all strong field effects on the beam can be understood in terms of two "universal" functions, $F(φ_{\rm in})$ and $T(φ_{\rm in})$ of the angle of beam emission $φ_{\rm in}$; these functions are universal in that they depend only on a single parameter, the pulsar/black hole distance from which the beam is emitted. Here we apply this formalism to general pulsar-hole-observer geometries, with arbitrary alignment of the pulsar spin axis and arbitrary pulsar beam direction and angular width. We show that the analysis of the observational problem has two distinct elements: (i) the computation of the location and trajectory of an observer-dependent "keyhole" direction of emission in which a signal can be received by the observer; (ii) the determination of an annulus that represents the set of directions containing beam energy. Examples of each are given along with an example of a specific observational scenario. △ Less

Submitted 14 September, 2009; originally announced September 2009.

Comments: Submitted to the Astrophysical Journal

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.705:1252-1259,2009

Iteration Stability for Simple Newtonian Stellar Systems

Authors: Richard H. Price, Charalampos Markakis, John L. Friedman

Abstract: For an equation of state in which pressure is a function only of density, the analysis of Newtonian stellar structure is simple in principle if the system is axisymmetric, or consists of a corotating binary. It is then required only to solve two equations: one stating that the "injection energy", $κ$, a potential, is constant throughout the stellar fluid, and the other being the integral over th… ▽ More For an equation of state in which pressure is a function only of density, the analysis of Newtonian stellar structure is simple in principle if the system is axisymmetric, or consists of a corotating binary. It is then required only to solve two equations: one stating that the "injection energy", $κ$, a potential, is constant throughout the stellar fluid, and the other being the integral over the stellar fluid to give the gravitational potential. An iterative solution of these equations generally diverges if $κ$ is held fixed, but converges with other choices. We investigate the mathematical reason for this convergence/divergence by starting the iteration from an approximation that is perturbatively different from the actual solution. A cycle of iteration is then treated as a linear "updating" operator, and the properties of the linear operator, especially its spectrum, determine the convergence properties. For simplicity, we confine ourselves to spherically symmetric models in which we analyze updating operators both in the finite dimensional space corresponding to a finite difference representation of the problem, and in the continuum, and we find that the fixed-$κ$ operator is self-adjoint and generally has an eigenvalue greater than unity; in the particularly important case of a polytropic equation of state with index greater than unity, we prove that there must be such an eigenvalue. For fixed central density, on the other hand, we find that the updating operator has only a single eigenvector, with zero eigenvalue, and is nilpotent in finite dimension, thereby giving a convergent solution. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2009; originally announced March 2009.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: J.Math.Phys.50:073505,2009

The periodic standing-wave approximation: computations in full general relativity

Authors: Napoleon Hernandez, Richard H. Price

Abstract: The periodic standing wave method studies circular orbits of compact objects coupled to helically symmetric standing wave gravitational fields. From this solution an approximation is extracted for the strong field, slowly inspiralling motion of binary black holes and binary neutron stars. Previous work on this project has developed a method using a few multipoles of specially adapted coordinates… ▽ More The periodic standing wave method studies circular orbits of compact objects coupled to helically symmetric standing wave gravitational fields. From this solution an approximation is extracted for the strong field, slowly inspiralling motion of binary black holes and binary neutron stars. Previous work on this project has developed a method using a few multipoles of specially adapted coordinates well suited both to the radiation and the source regions. This method had previously been applied to linear and nonlinear scalar field models, to linearized gravity, and to a post-Minkowski approximation. Here we present the culmination of this approach: the application of the method in full general relativity. The fundamental equations had previously been developed and the challenge presented by this step is primarily a computational one which was approached with an innovative technique. The numerical results of these computations are compared with the corresponding results from linearized and post-Minkowksi computations. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2008; originally announced December 2008.

Comments: 14 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D79:064008,2009

Pulsar timing and spacetime curvature

Authors: Teviet Creighton, Fredrick A. Jenet, Richard H. Price

Abstract: We analyze the effect of weak field gravitational waves on the timing of pulsars, with particular attention to gauge invariance, that is, to the effects that are independent of the choice of coordinates. We find: (i) the Doppler shift cannot be separated into gauge invariant gravitational wave and kinetic contributions; (ii) a gauge invariant separation can be made for the time derivative of the… ▽ More We analyze the effect of weak field gravitational waves on the timing of pulsars, with particular attention to gauge invariance, that is, to the effects that are independent of the choice of coordinates. We find: (i) the Doppler shift cannot be separated into gauge invariant gravitational wave and kinetic contributions; (ii) a gauge invariant separation can be made for the time derivative of the Doppler shift in which the gravitational wave contribution is directly related to the Riemann tensor, and the kinetic contribution is that for special relativity; (iii) the gauge dependent effects in the Doppler shift play no role in the program of gravitational wave detection via pulsar timing. The direct connection shown between pulsar timing and the Riemann tensor of the gravitational waves will be of importance in discussions of gravitational waves from alternative (non-Einsteinian) theories of gravitation. △ Less

Submitted 20 December, 2008; originally announced December 2008.

Comments: 10 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.693:1113-1117,2009

Strong field effects on pulsar arrival times: circular orbits and equatorial beams

Authors: Yan Wang, Frederick A. Jenet, Teviet Creighton, Richard H. Price

Abstract: If a pulsar orbits a supermassive black hole, the timing of pulses that pass close to the hole will show a variety of strong field effects. To compute the intensity and timing of pulses that have passed close to a nonrotating black hole we introduce here a simple formalism based on two "universal functions," one for the bending of photon trajectories and the other for the photon travel time on t… ▽ More If a pulsar orbits a supermassive black hole, the timing of pulses that pass close to the hole will show a variety of strong field effects. To compute the intensity and timing of pulses that have passed close to a nonrotating black hole we introduce here a simple formalism based on two "universal functions," one for the bending of photon trajectories and the other for the photon travel time on these trajectories. We apply this simple formalism to the case of a pulsar in circular orbit that beams its pulses into the orbital plane. In addition to the "primary" pulses that reach the receiver by a more-or-less direct path, we find that there are secondary and higher order pulses. These are usually much dimmer than the primary pulses, but they can be of comparable or even greater intensity if they are emitted when pulsar is on the side of the hole furthest from the receiver. We show that there is a phase relationship of the primary and secondary pulses that is a probe of the strongly curved spacetime geometry. Analogs of these phenomena are expected in more general configurations, in which a pulsar in orbit around a hole emits pulses that are not confined to the orbital plane. △ Less

Submitted 12 December, 2008; originally announced December 2008.

Comments: 17 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.697:237-246,2009

Late time tails in the Kerr spacetime

Authors: Reinaldo J. Gleiser, Richard H. Price, Jorge Pullin

Abstract: Outside a black hole, perturbation fields die off in time as $1/t^n$. For spherical holes $n=2\ell+3$ where $\ell$ is the multipole index. In the nonspherical Kerr spacetime there is no coordinate-independent meaning of "multipole," and a common sense viewpoint is to set $\ell$ to the lowest radiatiable index, although theoretical studies have led to very different claims. Numerical results, to da… ▽ More Outside a black hole, perturbation fields die off in time as $1/t^n$. For spherical holes $n=2\ell+3$ where $\ell$ is the multipole index. In the nonspherical Kerr spacetime there is no coordinate-independent meaning of "multipole," and a common sense viewpoint is to set $\ell$ to the lowest radiatiable index, although theoretical studies have led to very different claims. Numerical results, to date, have been controversial. Here we show that expansion for small Kerr spin parameter $a$ leads to very definite numerical results confirming previous theoretical analyses. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2013; v1 submitted 22 October, 2007; originally announced October 2007.

Comments: 4 pages, 1 figure. In previous version an important modification of the radial variable was omitted

Journal ref: Class.Quant.Grav.25:072001,2008

The periodic standing-wave approximation: post-Minkowski computation

Authors: Christopher Beetle, Benjamin Bromley, Napoleón Hernández, Richard H. Price

Abstract: The periodic standing wave method studies circular orbits of compact objects coupled to helically symmetric standing wave gravitational fields. From this solution an approximation is extracted for the strong field, slowly inspiralling motion of black holes and binary stars. Previous work on this model has dealt with nonlinear scalar models, and with linearized general relativity. Here we present… ▽ More The periodic standing wave method studies circular orbits of compact objects coupled to helically symmetric standing wave gravitational fields. From this solution an approximation is extracted for the strong field, slowly inspiralling motion of black holes and binary stars. Previous work on this model has dealt with nonlinear scalar models, and with linearized general relativity. Here we present the results of the method for the post-Minkowski (PM) approximation to general relativity, the first step beyond linearized gravity. We compute the PM approximation in two ways: first, via the standard approach of computing linearized gravitational fields and constructing from them quadratic driving sources for second-order fields, and second, by solving the second-order equations as an ``exact'' nonlinear system. The results of these computations have two distinct applications: (i) The computational infrastructure for the ``exact'' PM solution will be directly applicable to full general relativity. (ii) The results will allow us to begin supplying initial data to collaborators running general relativistic evolution codes. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2007; originally announced August 2007.

Comments: 19 pages, 3 figures, 1 table, RevTeX

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D76:084016,2007

Multidomain Spectral Method for the Helically Reduced Wave Equation

Authors: Stephen R. Lau, Richard H. Price

Abstract: We consider the 2+1 and 3+1 scalar wave equations reduced via a helical Killing field, respectively referred to as the 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional helically reduced wave equation (HRWE). The HRWE serves as the fundamental model for the mixed-type PDE arising in the periodic standing wave (PSW) approximation to binary inspiral. We present a method for solving the equation based on domain deco… ▽ More We consider the 2+1 and 3+1 scalar wave equations reduced via a helical Killing field, respectively referred to as the 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional helically reduced wave equation (HRWE). The HRWE serves as the fundamental model for the mixed-type PDE arising in the periodic standing wave (PSW) approximation to binary inspiral. We present a method for solving the equation based on domain decomposition and spectral approximation. Beyond describing such a numerical method for solving strictly linear HRWE, we also present results for a nonlinear scalar model of binary inspiral. The PSW approximation has already been theoretically and numerically studied in the context of the post-Minkowskian gravitational field, with numerical simulations carried out via the "eigenspectral method." Despite its name, the eigenspectral technique does feature a finite-difference component, and is lower-order accurate. We intend to apply the numerical method described here to the theoretically well-developed post-Minkowski PSW formalism with the twin goals of spectral accuracy and the coordinate flexibility afforded by global spectral interpolation. △ Less

Submitted 19 November, 2007; v1 submitted 8 February, 2007; originally announced February 2007.

Comments: 57 pages, 11 figures, uses elsart.cls. Final version includes revisions based on referee reports and has two extra figures

Journal ref: J.Comput.Phys.227:1126-1161,2007

The periodic standing-wave approximation: eigenspectral computations for linear gravity and nonlinear toy models

Authors: Christopher Beetle, Benjamin Bromley, Richard H. Price

Abstract: The periodic standing wave approach to binary inspiral assumes rigid rotation of gravitational fields and hence helically symmetric solutions. To exploit the symmetry, numerical computations must solve for ``helical scalars,'' fields that are functions only of corotating coordinates, the labels on the helical Killing trajectories. Here we present the formalism for describing linearized general r… ▽ More The periodic standing wave approach to binary inspiral assumes rigid rotation of gravitational fields and hence helically symmetric solutions. To exploit the symmetry, numerical computations must solve for ``helical scalars,'' fields that are functions only of corotating coordinates, the labels on the helical Killing trajectories. Here we present the formalism for describing linearized general relativity in terms of helical scalars and we present solutions to the mixed partial differential equations of the linearized gravity problem (and to a toy nonlinear problem) using the adapted coordinates and numerical techniques previously developed for scalar periodic standing wave computations. We argue that the formalism developed may suffice for periodic standing wave computations for post-Minkowskian computations and for full general relativity. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2006; originally announced February 2006.

Comments: 21 pages, 10 figures, RevTeX

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D74 (2006) 024013

In an expanding universe, what doesn't expand?

Authors: Richard H. Price, Joseph D. Romano

Abstract: The expansion of the universe is often viewed as a uniform stretching of space that would affect compact objects, atoms and stars, as well as the separation of galaxies. One usually hears that bound systems do not take part in the general expansion, but a much more subtle question is whether bound systems expand partially. In this paper, a very definitive answer is given for a very simple system:… ▽ More The expansion of the universe is often viewed as a uniform stretching of space that would affect compact objects, atoms and stars, as well as the separation of galaxies. One usually hears that bound systems do not take part in the general expansion, but a much more subtle question is whether bound systems expand partially. In this paper, a very definitive answer is given for a very simple system: a classical "atom" bound by electrical attraction. With a mathemical description appropriate for undergraduate physics majors, we show that this bound system either completely follows the cosmological expansion, or -- after initial transients -- completely ignores it. This "all or nothing" behavior can be understood with techniques of junior-level mechanics. Lastly, the simple description is shown to be a justifiable approximation of the relativistically correct formulation of the problem. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2012; v1 submitted 12 August, 2005; originally announced August 2005.

Comments: 8 pages, 9 eps figures

The intermediate problem for binary black hole inspiral and the periodic standing wave approximation

Authors: Benjamin Bromley, Robert Owen, Richard H. Price

Abstract: In calculations of the inspiral of binary black holes an intermediate approximation is needed that can bridge the post-Newtonian methods of the early inspiral and the numerical relativity computations of the final plunge. We describe here the periodic standing wave approximation: A numerical solution is found to the problem of a periodic rotating binary with helically symmetric standing wave fie… ▽ More In calculations of the inspiral of binary black holes an intermediate approximation is needed that can bridge the post-Newtonian methods of the early inspiral and the numerical relativity computations of the final plunge. We describe here the periodic standing wave approximation: A numerical solution is found to the problem of a periodic rotating binary with helically symmetric standing wave fields, and from this solution an approximation is extracted for the physically relevant problem of inspiral with outgoing waves. The approximation underlying this approach has been recently confirmed with innovative numerical methods applied to nonlinear model problems. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2005; originally announced February 2005.

Comments: 4 pages, 5 figures

The periodic standing-wave approximation: nonlinear scalar fields, adapted coordinates, and the eigenspectral method

Authors: Benjamin Bromley, Robert Owen, Richard H. Price

Abstract: The periodic standing wave (PSW) method for the binary inspiral of black holes and neutron stars computes exact numerical solutions for periodic standing wave spacetimes and then extracts approximate solutions of the physical problem, with outgoing waves. The method requires solution of a boundary value problem with a mixed (hyperbolic and elliptic) character. We present here a new numerical m… ▽ More The periodic standing wave (PSW) method for the binary inspiral of black holes and neutron stars computes exact numerical solutions for periodic standing wave spacetimes and then extracts approximate solutions of the physical problem, with outgoing waves. The method requires solution of a boundary value problem with a mixed (hyperbolic and elliptic) character. We present here a new numerical method for such problems, based on three innovations: (i) a coordinate system adapted to the geometry of the problem, (ii) an expansion in multipole moments of these coordinates and a filtering out of higher moments, and (iii) the replacement of the continuum multipole moments with their analogs for a discrete grid. We illustrate the efficiency and accuracy of this method with nonlinear scalar model problems. Finally, we take advantage of the ability of this method to handle highly nonlinear models to demonstrate that the outgoing approximations extracted from the standing wave solutions are highly accurate even in the presence of strong nonlinearities. △ Less

Submitted 9 February, 2005; originally announced February 2005.

Comments: RevTex, 32 pages, 13 figures, 6 tables

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D71 (2005) 104017

Projectiles, pendula, and special relativity

Authors: Richard H. Price

Abstract: The kind of flat-earth gravity used in introductory physics appears in an accelerated reference system in special relativity. From this viewpoint, we work out the special relativistic description of a ballistic projectile and a simple pendulum, two examples of simple motion driven by earth-surface gravity. The analysis uses only the basic mathematical tools of special relativity typical of a fir… ▽ More The kind of flat-earth gravity used in introductory physics appears in an accelerated reference system in special relativity. From this viewpoint, we work out the special relativistic description of a ballistic projectile and a simple pendulum, two examples of simple motion driven by earth-surface gravity. The analysis uses only the basic mathematical tools of special relativity typical of a first-year university course. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2005; originally announced January 2005.

Comments: 9 pages, 5 figures; to appear in American Journal of Physics

Journal ref: Am.J.Phys. 73 (2005) 433-438

Late time tails from momentarily stationary, compact initial data in Schwarzschild spacetimes

Authors: Richard H. Price, Lior M. Burko

Abstract: An L-pole perturbation in Schwarzschild spacetime generally falls off at late times t as t^{-2L-3}. It has recently been pointed out by Karkowski, Swierczynski and Malec, that for initial data that is of compact support, and is initially momentarily static, the late-time behavior is different, going as t^{-2L-4}. By considering the Laplace transforms of the fields, we show here why the momentari… ▽ More An L-pole perturbation in Schwarzschild spacetime generally falls off at late times t as t^{-2L-3}. It has recently been pointed out by Karkowski, Swierczynski and Malec, that for initial data that is of compact support, and is initially momentarily static, the late-time behavior is different, going as t^{-2L-4}. By considering the Laplace transforms of the fields, we show here why the momentarily stationary case is exceptional. We also explain, using a time-domain description, the special features of the time development in this exceptional case. △ Less

Submitted 23 August, 2004; originally announced August 2004.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D70 (2004) 084039

Normal forces in stationary spacetimes

Authors: Richard H. Price

Abstract: For geodesic motion of a particle in a stationary spacetime the $U_0$ component of particle 4-velocity is constant and is considered to be a conserved mechanical energy. We show that this concept of a conserved mechanical energy can be extended to particles that move under the influence of a ``normal force,'' a force that, in the stationary frame, is orthogonal to the motion of the particle. We… ▽ More For geodesic motion of a particle in a stationary spacetime the $U_0$ component of particle 4-velocity is constant and is considered to be a conserved mechanical energy. We show that this concept of a conserved mechanical energy can be extended to particles that move under the influence of a ``normal force,'' a force that, in the stationary frame, is orthogonal to the motion of the particle. We illustrate the potential usefulness of the concept with a simple example. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2004; originally announced January 2004.

Comments: 2 pages, no figs, RevTex, submitted to GRG

Journal ref: Gen.Rel.Grav.36:2171-2173,2004

Radiation tails and boundary conditions for black hole evolutions

Authors: Elspeth W. Allen, Elizabeth Buckmiller, Lior M. Burko, Richard H. Price

Abstract: In numerical computations of Einstein's equations for black hole spacetimes, it will be necessary to use approximate boundary conditions at a finite distance from the holes. We point out here that ``tails,'' the inverse power-law decrease of late-time fields, cannot be expected for such computations. We present computational demonstrations and discussions of features of late-time behavior in an… ▽ More In numerical computations of Einstein's equations for black hole spacetimes, it will be necessary to use approximate boundary conditions at a finite distance from the holes. We point out here that ``tails,'' the inverse power-law decrease of late-time fields, cannot be expected for such computations. We present computational demonstrations and discussions of features of late-time behavior in an evolution with a boundary condition. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2004; originally announced January 2004.

Comments: submitted to Phys. Rev. D

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D70 (2004) 044038

Radiation content of Conformally flat initial data

Authors: C. O. Lousto, R. H. Price

Abstract: We study the radiation of energy and linear momentum emitted to infinity by the headon collision of binary black holes, starting from rest at a finite initial separation, in the extreme mass ratio limit. For these configurations we identify the radiation produced by the initially conformally flat choice of the three geometry. This identification suggests that the radiated energy and momentum of… ▽ More We study the radiation of energy and linear momentum emitted to infinity by the headon collision of binary black holes, starting from rest at a finite initial separation, in the extreme mass ratio limit. For these configurations we identify the radiation produced by the initially conformally flat choice of the three geometry. This identification suggests that the radiated energy and momentum of headon collisions will not be dominated by the details of the initial data for evolution of holes from initial proper separations $L_0\geq7M$. For non-headon orbits, where the amount of radiation is orders of magnitude larger, the conformally flat initial data may provide a relative even better approximation. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2004; originally announced January 2004.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures

Report number: UTBRG-2004-001

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D69 (2004) 087503

Ballistic trajectory: parabola, ellipse, or what?

Authors: Lior M. Burko, Richard H. Price

Abstract: Mechanics texts tell us that a particle in a bound orbit under gravitational central force moves on an ellipse, while introductory physics texts approximate the earth as flat, and tell us that the particle moves in a parabola. The uniform-gravity, flat-earth parabola is clearly meant to be an approximation to a small segment of the true central-force/ellipse orbit. To look more deeply into this… ▽ More Mechanics texts tell us that a particle in a bound orbit under gravitational central force moves on an ellipse, while introductory physics texts approximate the earth as flat, and tell us that the particle moves in a parabola. The uniform-gravity, flat-earth parabola is clearly meant to be an approximation to a small segment of the true central-force/ellipse orbit. To look more deeply into this connection we convert earth-centered polar coordinates to ``flat-earth coordinates'' by treating radial lines as vertical, and by treating lines of constant radial distance as horizontal. With the exact trajectory and dynamics in this system, we consider such questions as whether gravity is purely vertical in this picture, and whether the central force nature of gravity is important only when the height or range of a ballistic trajectory is comparable to the earth radius. Somewhat surprisingly, the answers to both questions is ``no,'' and therein lie some interesting lessons. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2004; v1 submitted 11 October, 2003; originally announced October 2003.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Am. J. Phys. 73, 516-520 (2005)

The Periodic Standing-Wave Approximation: Overview and Three Dimensional Scalar Models

Authors: Zeferino Andrade, Christopher Beetle, Alexey Blinov, Benjamin Bromley, Lior M. Burko, Maria Cranor, Robert Owen, Richard H. Price

Abstract: The periodic standing-wave method for binary inspiral computes the exact numerical solution for periodic binary motion with standing gravitational waves, and uses it as an approximation to slow binary inspiral with outgoing waves. Important features of this method presented here are: (i) the mathematical nature of the ``mixed'' partial differential equations to be solved, (ii) the meaning of sta… ▽ More The periodic standing-wave method for binary inspiral computes the exact numerical solution for periodic binary motion with standing gravitational waves, and uses it as an approximation to slow binary inspiral with outgoing waves. Important features of this method presented here are: (i) the mathematical nature of the ``mixed'' partial differential equations to be solved, (ii) the meaning of standing waves in the method, (iii) computational difficulties, and (iv) the ``effective linearity'' that ultimately justifies the approximation. The method is applied to three dimensional nonlinear scalar model problems, and the numerical results are used to demonstrate extraction of the outgoing solution from the standing-wave solution, and the role of effective linearity. △ Less

Submitted 8 May, 2004; v1 submitted 30 September, 2003; originally announced October 2003.

Comments: 13 pages RevTeX, 5 figures. New version. A revised form of the nonlinearity produces better results

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D70 (2004) 064001

Radiation-balanced simulations for binary inspiral

Authors: John T Whelan, Christopher Beetle, Walter Landry, Richard H Price

Abstract: The late stage of the inspiral of two black holes may have important non-Newtonian effects that are unrelated to radiation reaction. To understand these effects we approximate a slowly inspiralling binary by a stationary solution to Einstein's equations in which the holes orbit eternally. Radiation reaction is nullified by specifying a boundary condition at infinity containing equal amounts of i… ▽ More The late stage of the inspiral of two black holes may have important non-Newtonian effects that are unrelated to radiation reaction. To understand these effects we approximate a slowly inspiralling binary by a stationary solution to Einstein's equations in which the holes orbit eternally. Radiation reaction is nullified by specifying a boundary condition at infinity containing equal amounts of ingoing and outgoing radiation. The computational problem is then converted from an evolution problem with initial data to a boundary value problem. In addition to providing an approximate inspiral waveform via extraction of the outgoing modes, our approximation can give alternative initial data for numerical relativity evolution. We report results on simplified models and on progress in building 3D numerical solutions. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2001; originally announced October 2001.

Comments: 7 pages, uses IOP class files, submitted to the proceedings of the 4th Amaldi meeting (which will be published in Classical and Quantum Gravity)

Journal ref: Class.Quant.Grav. 19 (2002) 1285-1290

Tidal interaction in binary black hole inspiral

Authors: Richard H. Price, John T. Whelan

Abstract: In rotating viscous fluid stars, tidal torque leads to an exchange of spin and orbital angular momentum. The horizon of a black hole has an effective viscosity that is large compared to that of stellar fluids, and an effective tidal torque may lead to important effects in the strong field interaction at the endpoint of the inspiral of two rapidly rotating holes. In the most interesting case both… ▽ More In rotating viscous fluid stars, tidal torque leads to an exchange of spin and orbital angular momentum. The horizon of a black hole has an effective viscosity that is large compared to that of stellar fluids, and an effective tidal torque may lead to important effects in the strong field interaction at the endpoint of the inspiral of two rapidly rotating holes. In the most interesting case both holes are maximally rotating and all angular momenta (orbital and spins) are aligned. We point out here that in such a case (i) the transfer of angular momentum may have an important effect in modifying the gravitational wave ``chirp'' at the endpoint of inspiral. (ii) The tidal transfer of spin energy to orbital energy may increase the amount of energy being radiated. (iii) Tidal transfer in such systems may provide a mechanism for shedding excess angular momentum. We argue that numerical relativity, the only tool for determining the importance of tidal torque, should be more specifically focused on binary configurations with aligned, large, angular momenta. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2001; originally announced July 2001.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett. 87 (2001) 231101

Shell sources as a probe of relativistic effects in neutron star models

Authors: Zeferino Andrade, Richard H. Price

Abstract: A perturbing shell is introduced as a device for studying the excitation of fluid motions in relativistic stellar models. We show that this approach allows a reasonably clean separation of radiation from the shell and from fluid motions in the star, and provides broad flexibility in the location and timescale of perturbations driving the fluid motions. With this model we compare the relativistic… ▽ More A perturbing shell is introduced as a device for studying the excitation of fluid motions in relativistic stellar models. We show that this approach allows a reasonably clean separation of radiation from the shell and from fluid motions in the star, and provides broad flexibility in the location and timescale of perturbations driving the fluid motions. With this model we compare the relativistic and Newtonian results for the generation of even parity gravitational waves from constant density models. Our results suggest that relativistic effects will not be important in computations of the gravitational emission except possibly in the case of excitation of the neutron star on very short time scales. △ Less

Submitted 24 April, 2000; v1 submitted 22 February, 2000; originally announced February 2000.

Comments: 16 pages LaTeX with 6 eps figures; submitted to Phys. Rev. D

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D62 (2000) 044032

Nonexistence of conformally flat slices of the Kerr spacetime

Authors: Alcides Garat, Richard H. Price

Abstract: Initial data for black hole collisions are commonly generated using the Bowen-York approach based on conformally flat 3-geometries. The standard (constant Boyer-Lindquist time) spatial slices of the Kerr spacetime are not conformally flat, so that use of the Bowen-York approach is limited in dealing with rotating holes. We investigate here whether there exist foliations of the Kerr spacetime tha… ▽ More Initial data for black hole collisions are commonly generated using the Bowen-York approach based on conformally flat 3-geometries. The standard (constant Boyer-Lindquist time) spatial slices of the Kerr spacetime are not conformally flat, so that use of the Bowen-York approach is limited in dealing with rotating holes. We investigate here whether there exist foliations of the Kerr spacetime that are conformally flat. We limit our considerations to foliations that are axisymmetric and that smoothly reduce in the Schwarzschild limit to slices of constant Schwarzschild time. With these restrictions, we show that no conformally flat slices can exist. △ Less

Submitted 2 February, 2000; originally announced February 2000.

Comments: 5 LaTeX pages; no figures; to be submitted to Phys. Rev. D

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D61 (2000) 124011

Gauge invariant formalism for second order perturbations of Schwarzschild spacetimes

Authors: A. Garat, R. H. Price

Abstract: The ``close limit,'' a method based on perturbations of Schwarzschild spacetime, has proved to be a very useful tool for finding approximate solutions to models of black hole collisions. Calculations carried out with second order perturbation theory have been shown to give the limits of applicability of the method without the need for comparison with numerical relativity results. Those second or… ▽ More The ``close limit,'' a method based on perturbations of Schwarzschild spacetime, has proved to be a very useful tool for finding approximate solutions to models of black hole collisions. Calculations carried out with second order perturbation theory have been shown to give the limits of applicability of the method without the need for comparison with numerical relativity results. Those second order calculations have been carried out in a fixed coordinate gauge, a method that entails conceptual and computational difficulties. Here we demonstrate a gauge invariant approach to such calculations. For a specific set of models (requiring head on collisions and quadrupole dominance of both the first and second order perturbations), we give a self contained gauge invariant formalism. Specifically, we give (i) wave equations and sources for first and second order gauge invariant wave functions; (ii) the prescription for finding Cauchy data for those equations from initial values of the first and second fundamental forms on an initial hypersurface; (iii) the formula for computing the gravitational wave power from the evolved first and second order wave functions. △ Less

Submitted 1 September, 1999; originally announced September 1999.

Comments: 18 pages, no figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D61 (2000) 044006

Excitation of the odd-parity quasi-normal modes of compact objects

Authors: Zeferino Andrade, Richard H. Price

Abstract: The gravitational radiation generated by a particle in a close unbounded orbit around a neutron star is computed as a means to study the importance of the $w$ modes of the neutron star. For simplicity, attention is restricted to odd parity (``axial'') modes which do not couple to the neutron star's fluid modes. We find that for realistic neutron star models, particles in unbounded orbits only we… ▽ More The gravitational radiation generated by a particle in a close unbounded orbit around a neutron star is computed as a means to study the importance of the $w$ modes of the neutron star. For simplicity, attention is restricted to odd parity (``axial'') modes which do not couple to the neutron star's fluid modes. We find that for realistic neutron star models, particles in unbounded orbits only weakly excite the $w$ modes; we conjecture that this is also the case for astrophysically interesting sources of neutron star perturbations. We also find that for cases in which there is significant excitation of quadrupole $w$ modes, there is comparable excitation of higher multipole modes. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 1999; v1 submitted 20 February, 1999; originally announced February 1999.

Comments: 18 pages, 21 figures, submitted to Phys. Rev. D

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D60 (1999) 104037

Formation of a rotating hole from a close limit head-on collision

Authors: W. Krivan, R. H. Price

Abstract: Realistic black hole collisions result in a rapidly rotating Kerr hole, but simulations to date have focused on nonrotating final holes. Using a new solution of the Einstein initial value equations we present here waveforms and radiation for an axisymmetric Kerr-hole-forming collision starting from small initial separation (the ``close limit'' approximation) of two identical rotating holes. Seve… ▽ More Realistic black hole collisions result in a rapidly rotating Kerr hole, but simulations to date have focused on nonrotating final holes. Using a new solution of the Einstein initial value equations we present here waveforms and radiation for an axisymmetric Kerr-hole-forming collision starting from small initial separation (the ``close limit'' approximation) of two identical rotating holes. Several new features are present in the results: (i) In the limit of small separation, the waveform is linear (not quadratic) in the separation. (ii) The waveforms show damped oscillations mixing quasinormal ringing of different multipoles. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 1998; originally announced October 1998.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures, submitted to PRL

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett.82:1358-1361,1999

Quantifying excitations of quasinormal mode systems

Authors: Hans-Peter Nollert, Richard H. Price

Abstract: Computations of the strong field generation of gravitational waves by black hole processes produce waveforms that are dominated by quasinormal (QN) ringing, a damped oscillation characteristic of the black hole. We describe here the mathematical problem of quantifying the QN content of the waveforms generated. This is done in several steps: (i) We develop the mathematics of QN systems that are c… ▽ More Computations of the strong field generation of gravitational waves by black hole processes produce waveforms that are dominated by quasinormal (QN) ringing, a damped oscillation characteristic of the black hole. We describe here the mathematical problem of quantifying the QN content of the waveforms generated. This is done in several steps: (i) We develop the mathematics of QN systems that are complete (in a sense to be defined) and show that there is a quantity, the ``excitation coefficient,'' that appears to have the properties needed to quantify QN content. (ii) We show that incomplete systems can (at least sometimes) be converted to physically equivalent complete systems. Most notably, we give a rigorous proof of completeness for a specific modified model problem. (iii) We evaluate the excitation coefficient for the model problem, and demonstrate that the excitation coefficient is of limited utility. We finish by discussing the general question of quantification of QN excitations, and offer a few speculations about unavoidable differences between normal mode and QN systems. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 1998; originally announced October 1998.

Comments: 27 pages, 14 figures. To be published in: J. Math. Phys. (1999)

Journal ref: J.Math.Phys. 40 (1999) 980-1010

Initial data for superposed rotating black holes

Authors: W. Krivan, R. H. Price

Abstract: The standard approach to initial data for both analytic and numerical computations of black hole collisions has been to use conformally-flat initial geometry. Among other advantages, this choice allows the simple superposition of holes with arbitrary mass, location and spin. The conformally flat restriction, however, is inappropriate to the study of Kerr holes, for which the standard constant-ti… ▽ More The standard approach to initial data for both analytic and numerical computations of black hole collisions has been to use conformally-flat initial geometry. Among other advantages, this choice allows the simple superposition of holes with arbitrary mass, location and spin. The conformally flat restriction, however, is inappropriate to the study of Kerr holes, for which the standard constant-time slice is not conformally flat. Here we point out that for axisymmetric arrangements of rotating holes, a nonconformally flat form of the 3-geometry can be chosen which allows fairly simple superposition of Kerr holes with arbitrary mass and spin. We present initial data solutions representing locally Kerr holes at large separation, and representing rotating holes close enough so that outside a common horizon the spacetime geometry is a perturbation of a single Kerr hole. △ Less

Submitted 3 June, 1998; originally announced June 1998.

Comments: 14 pages, 5 figures, submitted to Phys. Rev. D

Kerr-like initial data for the collision of two locally Kerr holes

Authors: William Krivan, Richard H. Price

Abstract: A technical flaw was found in this paper, and it has been withdrawn. It is intended that a modified version will be submitted soon. A technical flaw was found in this paper, and it has been withdrawn. It is intended that a modified version will be submitted soon. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 1998; v1 submitted 23 April, 1998; originally announced April 1998.

Comments: 4 pages, latex, 2 figures, submitted to Phys. Rev. Letters

Improved initial data for black hole collisions

Authors: Carlos O. Lousto, Richard H. Price

Abstract: Numerical relativity codes now being developed will evolve initial data representing colliding black holes at a relatively late stage in the collision. The choice of initial data used for code development has been made on the basis of mathematical definitiveness and usefulness for computational implementation. By using the ``particle limit'' (the limit of an extreme ratio of masses of colliding… ▽ More Numerical relativity codes now being developed will evolve initial data representing colliding black holes at a relatively late stage in the collision. The choice of initial data used for code development has been made on the basis of mathematical definitiveness and usefulness for computational implementation. By using the ``particle limit'' (the limit of an extreme ratio of masses of colliding holes) we recently showed that the standard choice is not a good representation of astrophysically generated initial data. Here we show that, for the particle limit, there is a very simple alternative choice that appears to give excellent results. That choice, ``convective'' initial data is, roughly speaking, equivalent to the start of a time sequence of parameterized solutions of the Hamiltonian constraint; for a particle in circular orbit, it is the initial data of the steady state solution on any hypersurface. The implementation of related schemes for equal mass holes is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 1997; originally announced August 1997.

Comments: 10 pages, REVTEX, 14 PS figs

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D57 (1998) 1073-1083

Understanding initial data for black hole collisions

Authors: Carlos O. Lousto, Richard H. Price

Abstract: Numerical relativity, applied to collisions of black holes, starts with initial data for black holes already in each other's strong field. The initial hypersurface data typically used for computation is based on mathematical simplifying prescriptions, such as conformal flatness of the 3-geometry and longitudinality of the extrinsic curvature. In the case of head on collisions of equal mass holes… ▽ More Numerical relativity, applied to collisions of black holes, starts with initial data for black holes already in each other's strong field. The initial hypersurface data typically used for computation is based on mathematical simplifying prescriptions, such as conformal flatness of the 3-geometry and longitudinality of the extrinsic curvature. In the case of head on collisions of equal mass holes, there is evidence that such prescriptions work reasonably well, but it is not clear why, or whether this success is more generally valid. Here we study these questions by considering the ``particle limit'' for head on collisions of nonspinning holes. Einstein's equations are linearized in the mass of the small hole, and described by a single gauge invariant spacetime function psi, for each multipole. The resulting equations have been solved by numerical evolution for collisions starting from various initial separations, and the evolution is studied on a sequence of hypersurfaces. In particular, we extract hypersurface data, that is psi and its time derivative, on surfaces of constant background Schwarzschild time. These evolved data can then be compared with ``prescribed'' data, evolved data can be replaced by prescribed data on any hypersurface, and evolved further forward in time, a gauge invariant measure of deviation from conformal flatness can be evaluated, etc. The main findings of this study are: (i) For holes of unequal mass the use of prescribed data on late hypersurfaces is not successful. (ii) The failure is likely due to the inability of the prescribed data to represent the near field of the smaller hole. (iii) The discrepancy in the extrinsic curvature is more important than in the 3-geometry. (iv) The use of the more general conformally flat longitudinal data does not notably improve this picture. △ Less

Submitted 26 May, 1997; originally announced May 1997.

Comments: 20 pages, REVTEX, 26 PS figures included

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D56 (1997) 6439-6457

Head-on collisions of black holes: the particle limit

Authors: Carlos O. Lousto, Richard H. Price

Abstract: We compute gravitational radiation waveforms, spectra and energies for a point particle of mass $m_0$ falling from rest at radius $r_0$ into a Schwarzschild hole of mass $M$. This radiation is found to lowest order in $(m_0/M)$ with the use of a Laplace transform. In contrast with numerical relativity results for head-on collisions of equal-mass holes, the radiated energy is found not to be a mo… ▽ More We compute gravitational radiation waveforms, spectra and energies for a point particle of mass $m_0$ falling from rest at radius $r_0$ into a Schwarzschild hole of mass $M$. This radiation is found to lowest order in $(m_0/M)$ with the use of a Laplace transform. In contrast with numerical relativity results for head-on collisions of equal-mass holes, the radiated energy is found not to be a monotonically increasing function of initial separation; there is a local radiated-energy maximum at $r_0\approx4.5M$. The present results, along with results for infall from infinity, provide a complete catalog of waveforms and spectra for particle infall. We give a representative sample from that catalog and an interesting observation: Unlike the simple spectra for other head-on collisions (either of particle and hole, or of equal mass holes) the spectra for $\infty>r_0>\sim5M$ show a series of evenly spaced bumps. A simple explanation is given for this. Lastly, our energy vs. $r_0$ results are compared with approximation methods used elsewhere, for small and for large initial separation. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 1996; originally announced September 1996.

Comments: 15 pages, REVTeX, 25 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D55 (1997) 2124-2138

Analytic approximations to the spacetime of a critical gravitational collapse

Authors: Richard H. Price, Jorge Pullin

Abstract: We present analytic expressions that approximate the behavior of the spacetime of a collapsing spherically symmetric scalar field in the critical regime first discovered by Choptuik. We find that the critical region of spacetime can usefully be divided into a ``quiescent'' region and an ``oscillatory'' region, and a moving ``transition edge'' that separates the two regions. We find that in each… ▽ More We present analytic expressions that approximate the behavior of the spacetime of a collapsing spherically symmetric scalar field in the critical regime first discovered by Choptuik. We find that the critical region of spacetime can usefully be divided into a ``quiescent'' region and an ``oscillatory'' region, and a moving ``transition edge'' that separates the two regions. We find that in each region the critical solution can be well approximated by a flat spacetime scalar field solution. A qualitative nonlinear matching of the solutions across the edge yields the right order of magnitude for the oscillations of the discretely self-similar critical solution found by Choptuik. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 1996; originally announced January 1996.

Comments: 12 pages, Revtex, 9 figures included with epsf

Report number: CGPG-96/1-1

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D54:3792-3799,1996

Black hole collisions from Brill-Lindquist initial data: predictions of perturbation theory

Authors: A. M. Abrahams, R. H. Price

Abstract: The Misner initial value solution for two momentarily stationary black holes has been the focus of much numerical study. We report here analytic results for an astrophysically similar initial solution, that of Brill and Lindquist (BL). Results are given from perturbation theory for initially close holes and are compared with available numerical results. A comparison is made of the radiation gene… ▽ More The Misner initial value solution for two momentarily stationary black holes has been the focus of much numerical study. We report here analytic results for an astrophysically similar initial solution, that of Brill and Lindquist (BL). Results are given from perturbation theory for initially close holes and are compared with available numerical results. A comparison is made of the radiation generated from the BL and the Misner initial values, and the physical meaning is discussed. △ Less

Submitted 9 September, 1995; originally announced September 1995.

Comments: 11 pages, revtex3.0, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D53 (1996) 1972-1976

Applying black hole perturbation theory to numerically generated spacetimes

Authors: A. M. Abrahams, R. H. Price

Abstract: Nonspherical perturbation theory has been necessary to understand the meaning of radiation in spacetimes generated through fully nonlinear numerical relativity. Recently, perturbation techniques have been found to be successful for the time evolution of initial data found by nonlinear methods. Anticipating that such an approach will prove useful in a variety of problems, we give here both the pr… ▽ More Nonspherical perturbation theory has been necessary to understand the meaning of radiation in spacetimes generated through fully nonlinear numerical relativity. Recently, perturbation techniques have been found to be successful for the time evolution of initial data found by nonlinear methods. Anticipating that such an approach will prove useful in a variety of problems, we give here both the practical steps, and a discussion of the underlying theory, for taking numerically generated data on an initial hypersurface as initial value data and extracting data that can be considered to be nonspherical perturbations. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 1995; originally announced August 1995.

Comments: 14 pages, revtex3.0, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D53 (1996) 1963-1971

Head-on collision of two black holes: comparison of different approaches

Authors: Peter Anninos, Richard H. Price, Jorge Pullin, Ed Seidel, Wai-Mo Suen

Abstract: A benchmark problem for numerical relativity has been the head-on collision of two black holes starting from the ``Misner initial data,'' a closed form momentarily stationary solution to the constraint equations with an adjustable closeness parameter $μ_0$. We show here how an eclectic mixture of approximation methods can provide both an efficient means of determining the time development of the… ▽ More A benchmark problem for numerical relativity has been the head-on collision of two black holes starting from the ``Misner initial data,'' a closed form momentarily stationary solution to the constraint equations with an adjustable closeness parameter $μ_0$. We show here how an eclectic mixture of approximation methods can provide both an efficient means of determining the time development of the initial data and a good understanding of the physics of the problem. When the Misner data is chosen to correspond to holes initially very close together, a common horizon surrounds both holes and the geometry exterior to the horizon can be treated as a non-spherical perturbation of a single Schwarzschild hole. When the holes are initially well separated the problem can be treated with a different approximation scheme, ``the particle-membrane method.'' For all initial separations, numerical relativity is in principle applicable, but is costly and of uncertain accuracy. We present here a comparison of the different approaches. We compare waveforms, for $\ell=2$ and $\ell=4$ radiation, for different values of $μ_0$, from the three different approaches to the problem. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 1995; originally announced May 1995.

Comments: 21 Pages, RevTeX, 25 figures included with epsf, Postscript file available at http://jean-luc.ncsa.uiuc.edu/Papers/price94b/price94b.html

Report number: CGPG-95/3-6

Journal ref: Phys.Rev. D52 (1995) 4462-4480

Embedding initial data for black hole collisions

Authors: Joseph D. Romano, Richard H. Price

Abstract: We discuss isometric embedding diagrams for the visualization of initial data for the problem of the head-on collision of two black holes. The problem of constructing the embedding diagrams is explicitly presented for the best studied initial data, the Misner geometry. We present a partial solution of the embedding diagrams and discuss issues related to completing the solution. We discuss isometric embedding diagrams for the visualization of initial data for the problem of the head-on collision of two black holes. The problem of constructing the embedding diagrams is explicitly presented for the best studied initial data, the Misner geometry. We present a partial solution of the embedding diagrams and discuss issues related to completing the solution. △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 1994; originally announced September 1994.

Comments: (27pp text, 11 figures)

Journal ref: Class.Quant.Grav.12:875-894,1995