-
Control of friction: shortcuts and optimization for the rate- and state-variable equation
Authors:
Andrea Plati,
Alberto Petri,
Marco Baldovin
Abstract:
Frictional forces are a key ingredient of any physical description of the macroscopic world, as they account for the phenomena causing transformation of mechanical energy into heat. They are ubiquitous in nature, and a wide range of practical applications involve the manipulation of physical systems where friction plays a crucial role. In this paper, we apply control theory to dynamics governed by…
▽ More
Frictional forces are a key ingredient of any physical description of the macroscopic world, as they account for the phenomena causing transformation of mechanical energy into heat. They are ubiquitous in nature, and a wide range of practical applications involve the manipulation of physical systems where friction plays a crucial role. In this paper, we apply control theory to dynamics governed by the paradigmatic rate- and state-variable law for solid-on-solid friction. Several control problems are considered for the case of a slider dragged on a surface by an elastic spring. By using swift state-to-state protocols, we show how to drive the system between two arbitrary stationary states characterized by different constant sliding velocities in a given time. Remarkably, this task proves to be feasible even when specific constraints are imposed on the dynamics, such as preventing the instantaneous sliding velocity or the frictional force from exceeding a prescribed bound. The derived driving protocols also allow to avoid a stick-slip instability, which instead occurs when velocity is suddenly switched. By exploiting variational methods, we also address the functional minimization problem of finding the optimal protocol that connects two steady states in a specified time, while minimizing the work done by the friction. We find that the optimal strategy can change qualitatively depending on the time imposed for the duration of the process. Our results mark a significant step forward in establishing a theoretical framework for control problems in the presence of friction and naturally pave the way for future experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Enhancing (quasi-)long-range order in a two-dimensional driven crystal
Authors:
R. Maire,
A. Plati
Abstract:
It has been recently shown that 2D systems can exhibit crystalline phases with long-range translational order showcasing a striking violation of the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner (HMW) theorem which is valid at equilibrium. This is made possible by athermal driving mechanisms that inject energy into the system without exciting long wavelength modes of the density field. However, as thermal fluctuations…
▽ More
It has been recently shown that 2D systems can exhibit crystalline phases with long-range translational order showcasing a striking violation of the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner (HMW) theorem which is valid at equilibrium. This is made possible by athermal driving mechanisms that inject energy into the system without exciting long wavelength modes of the density field. However, as thermal fluctuations are superimposed on the non-equilibrium driving, long-range translational order is inevitably lost. In this paper, we discuss the possibility of exploiting non-equilibrium effects to suppress arbitrarily large density fluctuations even when a global thermal bath is coupled to the system. We introduce a model of a harmonic crystal driven both by a global thermal bath and by a momentum conserving noise, where the typical observables related to density fluctuations and long-range translational order can be analytically derived and put in relation. This model allows us to rationalize the violation of the HMW theorem observed in previous studies through the prediction of large-wavelength phonons which thermalize at a vanishing effective temperature when the global bath is switched off. The conceptual framework introduced through this theory is then applied to numerical simulations of a hard-disk solid in contact with a thermal bath and driven out-of-equilibrium by active collisions. Our numerical analysis demonstrates how varying driving and dissipative parameters can lead to an arbitrary enhancement of the quasi-long-range order in the system regardless of the applied global noise amplitude. Finally, we outline a possible experimental procedure to apply our results to a realistic granular system.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Interplay between an absorbing phase transition and synchronization in a driven granular system
Authors:
R. Maire,
A. Plati,
M. Stockinger,
E. Trizac,
F. Smallenburg,
G. Foffi
Abstract:
Absorbing phase transitions (APTs) are widespread in non-equilibrium systems, spanning condensed matter, epidemics, earthquakes, ecology, and chemical reactions. APTs feature an absorbing state in which the system becomes entrapped, along with a transition, either continuous or discontinuous, to an active state. Understanding which physical mechanisms determine the order of these transitions repre…
▽ More
Absorbing phase transitions (APTs) are widespread in non-equilibrium systems, spanning condensed matter, epidemics, earthquakes, ecology, and chemical reactions. APTs feature an absorbing state in which the system becomes entrapped, along with a transition, either continuous or discontinuous, to an active state. Understanding which physical mechanisms determine the order of these transitions represents a challenging open problem in non-equilibrium statistical mechanics. Here, by numerical simulations and mean-field analysis, we show that a quasi-2d vibrofluidized granular system exhibits a novel form of APT. The absorbing phase is observed in the horizontal dynamics below a critical packing fraction, and can be continuous or discontinuous based on the emergent degree of synchronization in the vertical motion. Our results provide a direct representation of a feasible experimental scenario, showcasing a surprising interplay between dynamic phase transition and synchronization.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Shear profile in a dense packing of large grains
Authors:
Alessio Quaresima,
Andrea Plati,
Andrea Gnoli,
Alberto Petri
Abstract:
We investigate the shear of a dense bed of refracting supermillimetric grains confined within a transparent horizontal annular cell with a rotating top. The local time correlation functions of interferometric images allow to characterize the shear profile close to the wall, with a spatial resolution well below the grain diameter. For increasing shear, we observe a transition in the system response…
▽ More
We investigate the shear of a dense bed of refracting supermillimetric grains confined within a transparent horizontal annular cell with a rotating top. The local time correlation functions of interferometric images allow to characterize the shear profile close to the wall, with a spatial resolution well below the grain diameter. For increasing shear, we observe a transition in the system response and the manifestations of anisotropies in the force chains. The employed technique is of easy implementation and is especially suitable for the study of stationary processes.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Thermodynamic uncertainty relations in the presence of non-linear friction and memory
Authors:
A. Plati,
A. Puglisi,
A. Sarracino
Abstract:
A new Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation (TUR) is derived for systems described by linearly coupled Langevin equations in the presence of non-linear frictional forces. In our scheme, the main variable represents the velocity of a particle, while the other coupled variables describe memory effects which may arise from strongly correlated degrees of freedom with several time-scales and, in general,…
▽ More
A new Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation (TUR) is derived for systems described by linearly coupled Langevin equations in the presence of non-linear frictional forces. In our scheme, the main variable represents the velocity of a particle, while the other coupled variables describe memory effects which may arise from strongly correlated degrees of freedom with several time-scales and, in general, are associated with thermal baths at different temperatures. The new TUR gives a lower bound for the mean-squared displacement of the position of the particle, including its asymptotic diffusion coefficient. This bound, in several examples worked out here, appears to be a good analytical estimate of the real diffusion coefficient. The new TUR can be also applied in the absence of any external force (with or without thermal equilibrium between the baths), a case which usually goes beyond the scope of original TURs. We show applications to non-linear frictional models with memory, such as the Coulomb and the Prantdtl-Tomlinson models, usually representative of friction at the nano-scale and within atomic-force microscopy experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Quasi-crystalline order in vibrated granular matter
Authors:
Andrea Plati,
Raphael Maire,
Etienne Fayen,
Francois Boulogne,
Frederic Restagno,
Frank Smallenburg,
Giuseppe Foffi
Abstract:
Quasi-crystals are aperiodic structures that present crystallographic properties which are not compatible with that of a single unit cell. Their revolutionary discovery in a metallic alloy, less than three decades ago, has required a full reconsideration of what we defined as a crystal structure. Surprisingly, quasi-crystalline structures have been discovered also at much larger length scales in d…
▽ More
Quasi-crystals are aperiodic structures that present crystallographic properties which are not compatible with that of a single unit cell. Their revolutionary discovery in a metallic alloy, less than three decades ago, has required a full reconsideration of what we defined as a crystal structure. Surprisingly, quasi-crystalline structures have been discovered also at much larger length scales in different microscopic systems for which the size of elementary building blocks ranges between the nanometric to the micrometric scale. Here, we report the first experimental observation of spontaneous quasi-crystal self-assembly at the millimetric scale. This result is obtained in a fully athermal system of macroscopic spherical grains vibrated on a substrate. Starting from a liquid-like disordered phase, the grains begin to locally arrange into three types of squared and triangular tiles that eventually align, forming 8-fold symmetric quasi-crystal that has been predicted in simulation but not yet observed experimentally in non-atomic systems. These results are not only the proof of a novel route to spontaneously assemble quasi-crystals but are of fundamental interest for the connection between equilibrium and non-equilibrium statistical physics.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Thermodynamic bounds for diffusion in non-equilibrium systems with multiple timescales
Authors:
Andrea Plati,
Andrea Puglisi,
Alessandro Sarracino
Abstract:
We derive a Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation bounding the mean squared displacement of a Gaussian process with memory, driven out of equilibrium by unbalanced thermal baths and/or by external forces. Our bound is tighter with respect to previous results and also holds at finite time. We apply our findings to experimental and numerical data for a many-body interacting granular fluid, characterize…
▽ More
We derive a Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation bounding the mean squared displacement of a Gaussian process with memory, driven out of equilibrium by unbalanced thermal baths and/or by external forces. Our bound is tighter with respect to previous results and also holds at finite time. We apply our findings to experimental and numerical data for a many-body interacting granular fluid, characterized by regimes of anomalous diffusion. In some cases, our relation can distinguish between equilibrium and non-equilibrium behavior, a non-trivial inference task, particularly for Gaussian processes.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2023; v1 submitted 17 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Collective drifts in vibrated granular packings: the interplay of friction and structure
Authors:
Andrea Plati,
Andrea Puglisi
Abstract:
We simulate vertically shaken dense granular packings with horizontal periodic boundary conditions. A coordinated translating motion of the whole medium emerges when the horizontal symmetry is broken by disorder or defects in the packing and the shaking is weak enough to conserve the structure. We argue that such a drift originates in the interplay between structural symmetry breaking and friction…
▽ More
We simulate vertically shaken dense granular packings with horizontal periodic boundary conditions. A coordinated translating motion of the whole medium emerges when the horizontal symmetry is broken by disorder or defects in the packing and the shaking is weak enough to conserve the structure. We argue that such a drift originates in the interplay between structural symmetry breaking and frictional forces transmitted by the vibrating plate. A non-linear ratchet model with stick-slips reproduces many faces of the phenomenon. The collective motion discussed here underlies phenomena observed recently with vibrofluidized granular materials, such as persistent rotations and anomalous diffusion.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2022; v1 submitted 15 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Long range correlations and slow time scales in a boundary driven granular model
Authors:
Andrea Plati,
Andrea Puglisi
Abstract:
We consider a velocity field with linear viscous interactions defined on a one dimensional lattice. Brownian baths with different parameters can be coupled to the boundary sites and to the bulk sites, determining different kinds of non-equilibrium steady states or free-cooling dynamics. Analytical results for spatial and temporal correlations are provided by analytical diagonalisation of the syste…
▽ More
We consider a velocity field with linear viscous interactions defined on a one dimensional lattice. Brownian baths with different parameters can be coupled to the boundary sites and to the bulk sites, determining different kinds of non-equilibrium steady states or free-cooling dynamics. Analytical results for spatial and temporal correlations are provided by analytical diagonalisation of the system's equations in the infinite size limit. We demonstrate that spatial correlations are scale-free and time-scales become exceedingly long when the system is driven only at the boundaries. On the contrary, in the case a bath is coupled to the bulk sites too, an exponential correlation decay is found with a finite characteristic length. This is also true in the free cooling regime, but in this case the correlation length grows diffusively in time. We discuss the crucial role of boundary driving for long-range correlations and slow time-scales, proposing an analogy between this simplified dynamical model and dense vibro-fluidized granular materials. Several generalizations and connections with the statistical physics of active matter are also suggested.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2021; v1 submitted 23 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Getting hotter by heating less: How driven granular materials dissipate energy in excess
Authors:
A. Plati,
L. de Arcangelis,
A. Gnoli,
E. Lippiello,
A. Puglisi,
A. Sarracino
Abstract:
We investigate how the kinetic energy acquired by a dense granular system driven by an external vibration depends on the input energy. Our focus is on the dependence of the granular behavior on two main parameters: frequency and vibration amplitude. We find that there exists an optimal forcing frequency, at which the system reaches the maximal kinetic energy: if the input energy is increased beyon…
▽ More
We investigate how the kinetic energy acquired by a dense granular system driven by an external vibration depends on the input energy. Our focus is on the dependence of the granular behavior on two main parameters: frequency and vibration amplitude. We find that there exists an optimal forcing frequency, at which the system reaches the maximal kinetic energy: if the input energy is increased beyond such a threshold, the system dissipates more and more energy and recovers a colder and more viscous state. Quite surprisingly, the nonmonotonic behavior is found for vibration amplitudes which are sufficiently small to keep the system always in contact with the driving oscillating plate. Studying dissipative properties of the system, we unveil a striking difference between this nonmonotonic behavior and a standard resonance mechanism. This feature is also observed at the microscopic scale of the single-grain dynamics and can be interpreted as an instance of negative specific heat. An analytically solvable model based on a generalized forced-damped oscillator well reproduces the observed phenomenology, illustrating the role of the competing effects of forcing and dissipation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Slow time scales in a dense vibrofluidized granular material
Authors:
Andrea Plati,
Andrea Puglisi
Abstract:
Modeling collective motion in non-conservative systems, such as granular materials, is difficult since a general microscopic-to-macroscopic approach is not available: there is no Hamiltonian, no known stationary densities in phase space, not a known small set of relevant variables. Phenomenological coarse-grained models are a good alternative, provided that one has identified a few slow observable…
▽ More
Modeling collective motion in non-conservative systems, such as granular materials, is difficult since a general microscopic-to-macroscopic approach is not available: there is no Hamiltonian, no known stationary densities in phase space, not a known small set of relevant variables. Phenomenological coarse-grained models are a good alternative, provided that one has identified a few slow observables and collected a sufficient amount of data for their dynamics. Here we study the case of a vibrofluidized dense granular material. The experimental study of a tracer, dispersed into the media, showed the evidence of many time scales: fast ballistic, intermediate caged, slow superdiffusive, very slow diffusive. A numerical investigation has demonstrated that tracer's superdiffusion is related to slow rotating drifts of the granular medium. Here we offer a deeper insight into the slow scales of the granular medium, and propose a new phenomenological model for such a "secular" dynamics. Based upon the model for the granular medium, we also introduce a model for the tracer (fast and slow) dynamics, which consists in a stochastic system of equations for three coupled variables, and is therefore more refined and successful than previous models.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2020; v1 submitted 19 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Dynamical collective memory in fluidized granular materials
Authors:
A. Plati,
A. Baldassarri,
A. Gnoli,
G. Gradenigo,
A. Puglisi
Abstract:
Recent experiments with rotational diffusion of a probe in a vibrated granular media revealed a rich scenario, ranging from the dilute gas to the dense liquid with cage effects and an unexpected superdiffusive behavior at large times. Here we setup a simulation that reproduces quantitatively the experimental observations and allows us to investigate the properties of the host granular medium, a ta…
▽ More
Recent experiments with rotational diffusion of a probe in a vibrated granular media revealed a rich scenario, ranging from the dilute gas to the dense liquid with cage effects and an unexpected superdiffusive behavior at large times. Here we setup a simulation that reproduces quantitatively the experimental observations and allows us to investigate the properties of the host granular medium, a task not feasible in the experiment. We discover a persistent collective rotational mode which emerges at high density and low granular temperature: a macroscopic fraction of the medium slowly rotates, randomly switching direction after very long times. Such a rotational mode of the host medium is the origin of probe's superdiffusion. Collective motion is accompanied by a kind of dynamical heterogeneity at intermediate times (in the cage stage) followed by a strong reduction of fluctuations at late times, when superdiffusion sets in.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
